04.21.95

Page 1

t eanc 0 ,

VOL. 39, NO. 116

•

Friday, April 21, 1995

FALL RIVER, MASS.

FALL RIVER DIOCESAN NEWSPAPER FOR SOUTHEAST MASSACHUSETTS CAPE COD & THE ISLANDS Southeastern Massachusetts' Largest Weekly

•

$11 Per Year

Season of Renewal lists' special week

MOVING SPIRITS: Among those who helped shape the sixth annual Ethics Symposium of St. Anne's Hospital, Fall River are, from left, Joseph Wilczek, the hospital's acting president; Dr. Michael Collins, president/ CEO of Caritas Christi Health Care System, Waltham; Sister Joanna Fernandes, OP, chair ofSt. Anne's board of trustees; Francis Gendreau, Ph.D., dean of philosophy at Stonehill College and member of symposium planning and St. Anne's ethics committees; Sister Carol Keehan, DC, president/ CEO of Providence Hospital, Washington, DC; and Father Mark Hession, member of symposium planning and St. Anne's ethics committees. (McGowan photo)

St. Anne's busy day: ethics symposium, open house By Pat McGowan

April 7 was a day for St. Anne's Hospital, Fall River, to manifest its concern for ethical issues facing the health care profession in an age of increasing medical and technical skills but decreasing ability and/ or willingness to pay for those skills. It was also a dlly when St. Anne's manifested its compassion for cancer patients by means of an open house alt its Hudner Oncology Center ~djacent to the hospital building. Ethical Symposium St. Anne's 6th annual Ethics Symposium took place at the Martin Institute of Stonehill College, North Easton, with the theme "Managed Care: Who Manages Whom? - Ethical Issues in the Face of Rationing,," Its planning committee was headed by Diane Santos, RN, of St. Anne's Hospital, and Father Mark R. Hession, vice chair of the hospital's Ethics Committee, introduced the speakers. "Preventing doctors from learning about new medical procedures is a lethal way of curbing patient consumption [of services]," declared Don Feder in criticizing the proposed Clinton health plan. Feder, a columnist and editorial writer for the Boston Herald, is also a lawyer. The Clinton plan is pragmatic, he said, with no regard for the Christian view of the sanctity of each human life, and even though the plan is "decomposing," its attitude lives on, with the idea of containing medical costs by a system of rationing becoming increasingly

appealing to proponents of managed care, defined as health services delivered primarily with an eye to profit. The columnist predicted that improved technology will eventually reduce medical costs but said that the bad effects of present-day cost containment efforts are demonstrated by the fact that many deinstitutionalized mental patients, unable to manage any welfare funds they may be given, end up homeless and roaming the streets. He questioned the concept of "limited rcs()urce~," citing the example of whale oil, once used as a lighti ng fuel. When it became scarce, he said, kerosene was employed. Today electricity provi~es light and the future holds promIse of more extensive use of nuclear power than at present, he pointed out. The same principle of new possibilities emerging exists in the health care field, he said. Feder cited medical malpractice suits as a major cause of escalating health care costs, declaring that he thought most malpractice cases were unjustified.

Hospital President Sister Carol Keehan, a Daughtel' of Charity of St. Vincent de Paul and president of Providence Hospital in a poverty-stricken area of Washington, DC, tackled the problem of whether the Catholic health care mission to reflect the care of God for the sick and the profit motive of managed care companies are compatible. "It is more important to keep the mission vital than the operation viable," she said, "but is it possible to do both?" Noting that managed health care companies have two customers hospitals and their investors -she said their prime consideration is costs. "Most assume quality and reasonable patient satisfaction," she added, whereas for Catholic institutions the means of attaining financial success must meet moral and ethical tests. Sister Keehan said that in such a climate she foresees "hard medical decisions coming" but pointed out that living wills give Christians the opportunity to declare their wishes Turn to Page 13

The diocesanwide Season of II, with ceremonies at a time and Renewal which began last Nov. 20 place to be announced. Father Tagg with a telecast Mass of Christ the Father Tagg will not come as a King and has continued with a variety of spiritual programs offered stranger to members of St. Williat many sites in the diocese will am's parish, Fall River, where he reach a high point the week of preached an enthusiastically received Lenten mission in 1994, one April 24 through 30. During that time Father Joe of many retreats and missions he Tagg III of the diocese of Memphis, has given around the country. Originally a lawyer, he became a Tenn., will conduct a week of renewal, offering an evening of priest in 1988 after many years of reflection from 7 to 9 on the bap- indecision as to his vocation. A tismal call to all to be workers in story in the Anchor for March II, the Lord's vineyard. Parish lay 1994, relates the odyssey that led ministers and all others are invited him to the priesthood: though he originally felt a call in high school. to attend. The program will be offered in he struggled with the decision for each area of the diocese according many years before opting instead for a law degree. After three years to the following schedule: April 24: Mt. Carmel church as a trial lawyer. he had an $80,OOO-a-year practice. hall, New Bedford But in 1974 he again felt called April 25: St. Pius X parish cen-' to the priesthood, entering the tel', So. Yarmouth April 26: Bishop Connolly High seminary in Rome. Only days before his sched uled ordination in School, Fall River 1978. once again beset by doubts, April 27: Bishop Feehan High he passed up his vocation and School, Attleboro April 28: Sacred Heart church returned to his law practice. While doing much pro bono work for the hall, Taunton Priests of each area will meet poor and underprivileged. and occasionally for the diocese, Joe Tagg ~ith Father Tagg from II a.m. to I p.m. on the day listed for their also enjoyed the "good life"-a fashionable residence. sports car area's evening meeting. with phone. a lakeside house in The week will conclude with a Arkansas. Mass at 5 p.m. Sunday, April 30, "I was enjoying life," he recalled. at St. Mary's Cathedral, Fall River, "I never missed the Sugar Bowl, I with Bishop Sean O'Malley as always had tickets to the final four celebrant and Father Tagg as basketball tournaments, and I behomilist. longed to all the right clubs ...So The entire Season of Renewal will be completed on Sunday, June Turn to Page 13

I:Osservalore Romano' Arturo MaTi photo

FATHER JOE TAGG III meets with Pope John Paul II after concelebrating a Mass with him. "It seemed as if everything I had ever done in my life pointed to that moment," the priest commented later.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.