Shakir Aamer

Page 1

S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE HEADQUARTERS, JOINT TASK FORCE GUANTANAMO U.S. NAVAL STATION, GUANTANAMO BAY, CUBA APO AE 09360

! <%=>?%"*>,6+! .!5@ABCDBE!/::F! ! "("*+456#"!=*+!,@CCGHIBE3!#HJKBI!)KGKBL!)@MKNBEH!,@CCGHI3!;1..!5O!0PLK!4ABHMB3! "JGCJ3!=$!;;.F/!!! ! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! !

JTF-GTMO Detainee Assessment ! 1. (S//NF) Personal Information: ! !

! ! ! !

<6&")U56+,!+BTBEBHSB!5GCBR!!)GVGI!GP>"GIGHJ! 4PJGLBL!GHI!,MEEBHKU%EMB!5GCBR!!)NGWJE!4DI!GP>+GNJC! "MNGCCGI!4GCBE3!4DM!4DIMPPGN3!4DM!<MNGJHG3!)GVGI!GP> "GIGHJ3!"GIGHJ!GP>%GXXJD3!4CYGI!"BWVGE3!"MNGCCGI! ZGNBBI3!'E@TBLL@E3!!"MNGCCGI![GCJI!GP>ZMDGXEJ! 'PGSB!@T!QJEKNR!!"BIJHG3!)GMIJ!4EGDJG!8)49!!! 6GKB!@T!QJEKNR!!/.!6BSBCDBE!.0\\!!!!! ,JKJ]BHLNJ^R!!)GMIJ!4EGDJG!!!!!! &HKBEHCBHK!)BEJGP!5MCDBE!8&)59R!!#)0)4>::/;06'!!

!

! 2. (U//FOUO) Health: 6BKGJHBB!JL!JH!@ABEGPP!_@@I!NBGPKN-!! ! 3. (U) JTF-GTMO Assessment: ! a. (S) Recommendation:!!<%=>?%"*!EBS@CCBHIL!KNJL!IBKGJHBB!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H! #HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69-!!<%=>?%"*!^EBAJ@MLPX!EBS@CCBHIBI!IBKGJHBB!T@E!,@HKJHMBI! 6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!VJKN!KEGHLTBE!PGH_MG_B!@H!.1!)B^KBCDBE!/::\-! ! b. (S//NF) Executive Summary:!!6BKGJHBB!JL!G!CBCDBE!@T!GP>`GJIG!KJBI!K@!KNB!(ME@^BGH! LM^^@EK!HBKV@EW-!!6BKGJHBB!JL!G!SP@LB!GLL@SJGKB!@T!#LGCG!QJH!$GIBH!8#Q$9!GHI!NGL! S@HHBSKJ@HL!K@!LBABEGP!@KNBE!LBHJ@E!BaKEBCJLK!CBCDBEL-!!6BKGJHBB!NGL!KEGABPBI!JHKBEHGKJ@HGPPX! @H!TGPLB!I@SMCBHKL!GHI!JL!GLL@SJGKBI!VJKN!GP>`GJIG!KBEE@EJLK!SBPPL!JH!KNB!#)-!!6BKGJHBB!JL!G! EB^@EKBI!EBSEMJKBE3!TJHGHSJBE3!GHI!TGSJPJKGK@E!VJKN!G!NJLK@EX!@T!^GEKJSJ^GKJH_!JH!YJNGIJLK!S@CDGK-!! !!! CLASSIFIED BY:!"#$%&'$(!)*#+,()!!! REASON:!(-*-!./0123!4)!4"(56(63!)(,%&*5!.-78,9! DECLASSIFY ON:!/:;/..:.!!!

! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 !


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! 6BKGJHBB!EBSBJABI!GIAGHSBI!KBEE@EJLK!KEGJHJH_3!JHIJSGKBI!NJL!VJPPJH_HBLL!K@!DBS@CB!G!CGEKXE3! GHI!LBEABI!GL!G!LMD>S@CCGHIBE!@T!GP>`GJIG!T@ESBL!JH!%@EG!Q@EG-!!<%=>?%"*!IBKBECJHBI! KNJL!IBKGJHBB!K@!DBR ! ! !

4!HIGH!EJLW3!GL!NB!JL!PJWBPX!K@!^@LB!G!KNEBGK!K@!KNB!#)3!JKL!JHKBEBLKL3!GHI!GPPJBL ! 4!HIGH KNEBGK!TE@C!G!IBKBHKJ@H!^BEL^BSKJAB *T!HIGH JHKBPPJ_BHSB!AGPMB

! c. (S//NF) Summary of Changes:!!%NB!T@PP@VJH_!@MKPJHBL!SNGH_BL!K@!IBKGJHBBbL! GLLBLLCBHK!LJHSB!KNB!PGLK!<%=>?%"*!EBS@CCBHIGKJ@H-!!8,NGH_BL!JH!KNJL!GLLBLLCBHK!VJPP!DB! GHH@KGKBI!DX!!!HBaK!K@!KNB!T@@KH@KB-9!! ! ! &HSPMIBI!EB^@EKL!JHIJSGKJH_!IBKGJHBBbL!SP@LB!GLL@SJGKJ@H!VJKN!LBHJ@E!GP>`GJIG!GLL@SJGKB! 4DM!"MLGD!GP>)MEJ!8IBKGJHBI9!GHI!)NGXWN!4DM!GP>OGPJI! ! &HSPMIBI!G!EB^@EK!@T!IBKGJHBBbL!KEGABP!VJKN!LBHJ@E!GP>`GJIG!@^BEGKJAB!OGPJI! "MNGCCGI!)GPJN!QJH!4KKGLN3!GWG!8)JPABE93!&)5!#)0c">:.::.76'!8c">.::.79d!GHI!GP> `GJIG!TGSJPJKGK@E!4DM!QGWE!"MNGCCGI!Q@M_NJKJ3!GWG!84DM!cGLJE!GP><G]GJEJ9!! ! &HSPMIBI!G!EB^@EK!@T!IBKGJHBBbL!SPGJCBI!GDJPJKX!K@!MLB!KNB!CGJP!LXLKBC!K@!KGE_BK!_E@M^L! @T!#)!SJKJ]BHL! ! &HSPMIBI!EB^@EKL!@T!IBKGJHBBL!PBGIBELNJ^!^@LJKJ@H!GHI!GSKJAJKJBL!JH!%@EG!Q@EG! ! &HSPMIBI!GHGPXLJL!T@E!IJLSEB^GHSJBL!JH!IBKGJHBBbL!SG^KMEB!JHT@ECGKJ@H! ! 4. (U) Detainee’s Account of Events: ! The following section is based, unless otherwise indicated, on detainee’s own account. These statements are included without consideration of veracity, accuracy, or reliability. ! a. (S//NF) Prior History:!!6BKGJHBB!L^BHK!BJ_NK!C@HKNL!GK!KNB!e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fMBHKPX!EBKMEHBI!K@!)GMIJ!4EGDJG!GHI!_@K!G!Y@D!GL!G!KEGHLPGK@E!T@E!KNB! #HJKBI!)KGKBL!4ECX-!!4L!G!KEGHLPGK@E3!IBKGJHBB!SPGJCBI!K@!@SSGLJ@HGPPX!KEGABP!K@!)XEJG-!!ONBH! NB!fMJK!NJL!Y@D!GL!G!KEGHLPGK@E3!NB!VBHK!K@!+@CGHJG!VJKN!KNB!JHKBHK!@T!LKGEKJH_!G!LNBB^! JC^@EKGKJ@H!DMLJHBLL-!!&K!VGL!IMEJH_!KNJL!AJLJK!KNGK!IBKGJHBB!DBSGCB!TGCJPJGE!VJKN!

! /!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! NMCGHJKGEJGH!@E_GHJ]GKJ@HL!JHSPMIJH_!KNB!+BAJAGP!@T!&LPGCJS![BEJKG_B!)@SJBKX!8+&[)9!GHI!KNB! &HKBEHGKJ@HGP!&LPGCJS!+BPJBT!*E_GHJ]GKJ@H!8&&+*9- . ! b. (S//NF) Recruitment and Travel:!!=@E!G^^E@aJCGKBPX!LJa!C@HKNL!JH!.0073!IBKGJHBB! V@EWBI!T@E!EBPJBT!@E_GHJ]GKJ@HL!JH!Q@LHJG!LMSN!GL!KNB!+&[)-!!&H!Q@LHJG3!IBKGJHBB!CBK!QGDBE! 4NCBI3!VN@!S@HAJHSBI!NJC!K@!GSKJABPX!^EGSKJSB!&LPGC-/ !!&H!.0013!IBKGJHBB!V@EWBI!T@E!KNB! eMVGJKJ!5?*3!GP>4NXG!GP>%MEGKN3!GHI!KNBH!EBKMEHBI!K@!"BIJHG3!)43!K@!DB_JH!G!C@DJPB!^N@HB! LGPBL!DMLJHBLL!VJKN!NJL!DE@KNBE>JH>PGV- ; !!%NB!DMLJHBLL!EBfMJEBI!IBKGJHBB!K@!KEGABP!K@!%MEWBX! GHI!KNB!5BKNBEPGHIL-!!ONJPB!JH!KNB!5BKNBEPGHIL!@H!G!DMLJHBLL!KEJ^3!IBKGJHBB!AJLJKBI!4NCBI! VN@!VGL!KNBH!PJAJH_!JH!KNB!#HJKBI!eJH_I@C!8#e9-!!4TKBE!KEGABPJH_!K@!KNB!#e3!IBKGJHBB! IBSJIBI!K@!LKGX!GHI!DEJBTPX!PJABI!VJKN!4NCBI-!!6MEJH_!KNJL!KJCB3!IBKGJHBB!CBK!ZGSNGEJGL! "@MLL@MJ!GK!KNB!QEJaK@H!"@LfMB3!GHI!C@ABI!JHK@!"@MLL@MJbL!N@CB-!!6BKGJHBB!PJABI!VJKN! "@MLL@MJ!T@E!G^^E@aJCGKBPX!KBH!IGXL!DBT@EB!C@AJH_!JH!VJKN!"MNGCCGI!<MHGXI3!G!'GWJLKGHJ! NBECJK!JH!KNB!%@@KJH_!"@LfMB!GEBG-!!ONJPB!PJAJH_!VJKN!<MHGXI3!IBKGJHBB!L@PI!JKBCL!GK!4DM! `GKGIGbL!NGPP!GHI!GKKBHIBI!KNB!=@ME!=BGKNBEL!,PMD- 7 !!&H!KNB!LMCCBE!@T!.0023!GLLJLKBI!DX! "@]GTGE!GP>4T_NGHJ3!IBKGJHBB!KEGABPBI!K@!4T_NGHJLKGH!K@!AJLJK!"@G]]GC!QB__!&)5!#)0#e> :::1126'!8#e>1123!KEGHLTBEEBI9-!!QB__!CBK!IBKGJHBB!GK!KNB!gVNJKB!C@LfMB3h!GHI!K@_BKNBE! KNBX!KEGABPBI!K@!KNB!4EGD!_MBLKN@MLB!JH!<GPGPGDGI3!4=3!GHI!KNBH!4DM!4DIGPPGN!GP>)S@KPGHIJbL! EBLJIBHSB!JH!eGDMP3!4=- 1 !!&H!.0003!IBKGJHBB!KEGABPBI!G_GJH!K@!4T_NGHJLKGH!VNBEB!NB!K@PI! ^B@^PB!JH!eGHIGNGE3!4=!GHI!eGDMP!KNGK!NB!VGL!@HB!@T!GP>ZMDGXE!GP>[GJPJbL!^B@^PB- \ !!6BKGJHBB! SPGJCBI!K@!NGAB!CBK!4DM![GTL!GP>"GMEJKGHJ!GHI!LKGXBI!GK!KNB!+BPJ_J@ML!&HLKJKMKB!JH!eGHIGNGE-!! 6BKGJHBB!GPL@!EBLJIBI!JH!@KNBE!LGTB!N@MLBL!JH!eGHIGNGE!GHI!eGDMP- F ! ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! .

!:::/;0!;:/!/:>=(Q>/::/3!:::/;0!"=+!:/>4#?>/::/3!4HGPXLK!5@KBR!!6BKGJHBB!JIBHKJTJBI!KNB!+&[)!GL!KNB! &LPGCJS![BEJKG_B!+BAJAGP-!!Q@KN!KNB!+&[)!GHI!KNB!&&+*3!GWG!8[GXi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fMB!GEBG!JL!WH@VH!T@E!JKL!S@HHBSKJ@HL!K@!KNB!#e!DGLBI!GP>`GJIG!@E_GHJ]GKJ@H-!!%NB! =@ME!=BGKNBEL!,PMD!JL!G!NGPP!KNGK!VGL!MLBI!DX!LML^BSKBI!#e!GP>`GJIG!SBPP!PBGIBE3!4DM!`GKGIG3!T@E!CBBKJH_L!GHI!GL!G! C@LfMB-! 1 !4HGPXLK!5@KBR!!4DM!4DIGPPGN!GP>)S@KPGHIJ!T@M_NK!JH!Q@LHJG!GHI!NGL!SP@LB!KJBL!K@!4PJ!"MNGCCGI!4DIMP!4]J]!GP> =GNWEJ3!GWG!8&DH!GP>)NGXWN!GP>$JDJ93!&)5!#)0$c>:::/./6'!8$c>/./93!KNB!^EJCGEX!KEGJHBE!GHI!PBGIBE!@T!eNGPIGH! KEGJHJH_!SGC^-! \ !4HGPXLK!5@KBR!!4P>ZMDGXE!GP>[GJPJ!JL!JIBHKJTJGDPB!VJKN!QGIE!4DI!GP>eGEJC!GP>)MIGXEJ3!G!LBHJ@E!GP>`GJIG!@^BEGKJAB! GHI!_MBLKN@MLB!CGHG_BE!JH!eGHIGNGE3!VN@!TGSJPJKGKBI!LKMIBHKLb!KEGABP!K@!KNB!GP>=GEMf!%EGJHJH_!,GC^-!!! F !:::/;0!;:/!/:>=(Q>/::/3!:::/;0!)&+!/:>"4c>/::/3!&&+!\!:;7!::72!:/3!&&+!\!:;7!:\;;!:/3!%6>;.7U;27;;>:/3! 4HGPXLK!5@KBR!%NB!Q@LHJGH!<JNGI!VGL!MHIBEVGX!IMEJH_!IBKGJHBBbL!LKGX!JH!Q@LHJG-!

! ;!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! c. (S//NF) Training and Activities:!!6MEJH_!@HB!@T!IBKGJHBBbL!AJLJKL!K@!4T_NGHJLKGH3!NB! KEGABPBI!VJKN!"@]GTGE!GP>4T_NGHJ!K@!KNB!eNGPIGH!,GC^!GHI!GKKBHIBI!KEGJHJH_-!!6BKGJHBB!NGI! DEBGWTGLK!VJKN!KNB!SGC^!S@CCGHIBE3!4PJ!"MNGCCGI!4DIMP!4]J]!GP>=GNWEJ3!GWG!8&DH!GP> )NGXWN!GP>$JDJ93!&)5!#)0$c>:::/./6'!8$c>/./93!GHI!K@MEBI!KNB!SGC^!VJKN@MK!S@CCJKKJH_! K@!GKKBHI-!!6BKGJHBB!SPGJCBI!KNGK!NJL!LBS@HI!KEJ^!K@!4T_NGHJLKGH!JH!/:::!VGL!L^BSJTJSGPPX!K@! LBEAB!VJKN!KNB!CMYGNJIBBH!@H!KNB!TE@HK!PJHBL-!!6BKGJHBB!LKGXBI!T@E!@HB!C@HKN!GHI!GPKN@M_N!NB! SGEEJBI!G!VBG^@H3!NB!SPGJCBI!NB!HBABE!TJEBI!JK-!!4TKBE!IBKGJHBB!IB^GEKBI!4T_NGHJLKGH3!NB! EBKMEHBI!K@!KNB!#e!DMK!IBSJIBI!K@!C@AB!DGSW!K@!4T_NGHJLKGH-!!&H!4M_MLK!/::.3!NB!IB^GEKBI! KNB!#e!TE@C![BGKNE@V!GJE^@EK!GHI!KEGABPBI!K@!%BNEGH3!&EGH!8&+93!GHI!KNBH!@H!K@!`MBKKG3! 'GWJLKGH!8'e9-!!4^^E@aJCGKBPX!KVBHKX!K@!KVBHKX>TJAB!IGXL!PGKBE3!NJL!VJTB!GHI!SNJPIEBH!Y@JHBI! NJC!JH!`MBKKG-!!%NBX!KNBH!KEGABPBI!K@!eGDMP3!4=-!!4^^E@aJCGKBPX!2!*SK@DBE!/::.3!IBKGJHBB! C@ABI!NJL!TGCJPX!K@!<GPGPGDGI!DMK!IBSJIBI!K@!S@HKJHMB!K@!KNB!'GWJLKGH!D@EIBE!K@!BAGSMGKB! KNBC!@MK!@T!KNB!S@MHKEX!IMB!K@!LGTBKX!S@HSBEHL-!!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!!&K!JL!MHWH@VH!BaGSKPX!N@V! CGHX!KEJ^L!IBKGJHBB!K@@W!K@!4T_NGHJLKGH-!![B!SPGJCBI!KNGK!NJL!LBS@HI!KEJ^!K@!4T_NGHJLKGH!VGL! JH!/:::3!DMK!NB!GPL@!SPGJCBI!K@!NGAB!DBBH!KNBEB!JH!.002!GHI!.000-!!&K!JL!MHWH@VH!BaGSKPX! VNBH!IBKGJHBB!KEGABPBI!K@!eNGPIGH!@E!VNBH!JH!/:::!NB!KEGABPBI!K@!KNB!TE@HK!PJHBL-92 ! ! 5. (U) Capture Information: ! a. 8)UU5=9!!4TKBE!PBGAJH_!NJL!TGCJPX!GK!KNB!'GWJLKGH!D@EIBE3!IBKGJHBB!LKGKBI!NB!EBKMEHBI!K@! <GPGPGDGI3!@DKGJHBI!GH!4e>7F!GLLGMPK!EJTPB3!GHI!NJI!JH!G!SGAB!JH!KNB!%@EG!Q@EG!GEBG-!!6BKGJHBB! SPGJCBI!4T_NGH!T@ESBL!SG^KMEBI!NJC!JH!<GPGPGDGI!GP@H_!VJKN!eMVGJKJ!HGKJ@HGP3!4DIMP! 4DIMPPGN!GHI!"GNBE!%GEJW3!G!'GPBLKJHJGH3!@H!//!@E!/;!6BSBCDBE!/::.- 0 !!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!! 4DIMP!4DIMPPGN!JL!GLLBLLBI!K@!DB!eMVGJKJ!SJKJ]BH!=MGI!"GNCMI![GLGH!GP>+GDJG3!&)5! #)0e#>:::11.6'!8e#>11.9-!!"GNBE!%GEJW!JL!GLLBLLBI!K@!DB!OBLK!QGHW!SJKJ]BH3!"GNE!+GTGK! GP>`MVGEJ3!&)5!#)0O(>:::1.06'!8O(>1.09!8EB^@EKBIPX!@T!'GPBLKJHJGH!@E!(_X^KJGH! SJKJ]BHLNJ^- .: !!O(>1.0!SPGJCBI!K@!NGAB!DBBH!SG^KMEBI!VJKN!e#>11.!MHIBE!SJESMCLKGHSBL! LJCJPGE!K@!KN@LB!IBLSEJDBI!DX!IBKGJHBB3!DMK!KNBX!IJI!H@K!H@KB!IBKGJHBBbL!^EBLBHSB-!!6BKGJHBB!JL! GLLBLLBI!K@!NGAB!LBEABI!GL!G!TJ_NKBE!JH!%@EG!Q@EG!MHIBE!$c>/./bL!S@CCGHI!MHKJP!@EIBEBI!K@! EBKEBGK-!!#Q$!G^^@JHKBI!$c>/./!GL!S@CCGHIBE!@T!GPP!T@ESBL!JH!%@EG!Q@EG-9 .. !!! ! b. (S) Property Held: !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! 2

!:::/;0!;:/!/:>=(Q>/::/3!:::/;0!eQ!.2>=(Q>/::/3!:::/;0!)&+!/7><#$>:/3!&&+!\!:;7!:\;;!:/3!%6>;.7U;27;;> :/3!:::/;0!)&+>::1>:.>:.:/! 0 !:::/;0!&5&%&4$!),+((5&5?!:\><45>/::/3!:::/;0!647;/F!:\><45>/::/3!:::/;0!647;/F!/:><45>/::/d! !4HGPXLK!5@KBR!%NBEB!GEB!S@HTPJSKJH_!IGKBL!@T!SG^KMEB!DBKVBBH!KNB!EBTBEBHSBI!I@SMCBHKLd!N@VBABE3!NJL!^EBLBHSB!JH! %@EG!Q@EG!GHI!@KNBE!IBKGJHBB!EB^@EKJH_!JHIJSGKB!//!6BSBCDBE!/::.!JL!KNB!C@LK!PJWBPX!IGKB!@T!SG^KMEB-! .: !&&+!\!:;7!..F/!:;! .. !:::1.0!&5%&4$!),+((5&5?!:.><45>/::/3!:::/;0!)&+!:/><45>/::/3!:::11.!eQ!./>"4c>/::/3!OJKNIEGVGP! TE@C!%@EG!Q@EG!4HGPXLJL3!%6>;.7U.7\:1>:7!

! 7!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! ! ! ;::!'GWJLKGHJ!+M^BBL!8'e+9 ./ ! ! 6BKGJHBB!EB^@EKBI!KNB!T@PP@VJH_!JKBCL3!H@K!NBPI!GK!<%=>?%"*3!VBEB!JH!NJL!^@LLBLLJ@H! GK!KNB!KJCB!@T!SG^KMEB-! ! =GPLB!QBP_JGH!'GLL^@EK! ! "@HBX .; ! " ;:3:::!'e+! " /3:::!)GMIJ!+JXGPL!8)4+9! ! c. (S) Transferred to JTF-GTMO:!!.;!=BDEMGEX!/::/! ! d. (S//NF) Reasons for Transfer to JTF-GTMO:!!%@!^E@AJIB!JHT@ECGKJ@H!@H!KNB! T@PP@VJH_R! ! ! +&[)!5?*! ! eNGPIGH!%EGJHJH_!,GC^! ! 6. (S//NF) Evaluation of Detainee’s Account:!!6BKGJHBB!JL!MHS@@^BEGKJAB!GHI!S@HKJHMBL!K@! VJKNN@PI!JHT@ECGKJ@H!@T!JHKBPPJ_BHSB!AGPMB!GD@MK!NJL!BaKEBCJLK!GSKJAJKJBL!GHI!GLL@SJGKJ@HL-!! 6BKGJHBB!NGL!TGJPBI!K@!TMPPX!GSS@MHK!T@E!NJL!KEGABPL!GHI!NJ_N!PBABP!GLL@SJGKBL!VNJSN!NGAB!DBBH! EB^@EKBI!DX!@KNBE!<%=>?%"*!IBKGJHBBL-!!6BKGJHBB!JL!BaKEBCBPX!B_@KJLKJSGP3!NGL!CGHJ^MPGKBI! IBDEJBTBEL!GHI!_MGEI!LKGTT3!GHI!VJPP!S@HKJHMB!K@!GKKBC^K!K@!I@!L@!K@!LM^^@EK!NJL!^@PJKJSGP!G_BHIG-!! 6BKGJHBB!EBTMLBL!K@!^GEKJSJ^GKB!JH!IJEBSK!fMBLKJ@HJH_3!@TKBH!SJKJH_!JCG_JHGEX3!@E!GLLMCBI! CJLKEBGKCBHK!@T!NJCLBPT3!@E!@KNBEL3!GL!YMLKJTJSGKJ@H!@T!KNJL!EBTMLGP!JH!G!SPGLLJS!BaGC^PB!@T!GP>`GJIG! S@MHKBE!JHKBEE@_GKJ@H!KBSNHJfMBL-! ! 7. (U) Detainee Threat: ! a. (S) Assessment: 6BKGJHBB!JL!GLLBLLBI!K@!DB!G!HIGH!EJLW3!GL!NB!JL!PJWBPX!K@!^@LB!G!KNEBGK! K@!KNB!#)3!JKL!JHKBEBLKL3!GHI!GPPJBL-! ! b. (S//NF) Reasons for Continued Detention: 6BKGJHBB!JL!G!CBCDBE!@T!GP>`GJIG3!VJKN! LJ_HJTJSGHK!KJBL!K@!LBHJ@E!PBABP!BaKEBCJLKL3!K@!JHSPMIB!#Q$-!!6BKGJHBB!NBPI!G!LBHJ@E!PBABP! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! ./

!4HGPXLK!5@KBR!!;::!'e+!JL!BfMJAGPBHK!K@!j1!#)!MLJH_!KNB!S@HABELJ@H!IGKB!@T!.!<GHMGEX!/::/-! !!4HGPXLK!5@KBR!!;:3:::!'e+!JL!BfMJAGPBHK!K@!j1/;!#)!GHI!/3:::!)4+!JL!BfMJAGPBHK!K@!j1;;!#)!MLJH_!KNB! S@HABELJ@H!IGKB!@T!.!<GHMGEX!/::/d!N@VBABE3!KNBEB!GEB!IJLSEB^GHSJBL!JH!EB^@EKJH_!@T!KNB!GC@MHK!@T!C@HBX!IBKGJHBB! ^@LLBLLBI!M^@H!SG^KMEB-!!%NB!;:3:::!'e+!EGKNBE!KNGH!;::3:::!'e+!JL!GLLBLLBI!GL!DBJH_!KNB!S@EEBSK!GC@MHK-!!)BB! :::/;0!647/;F!:\><45>/::/!GHI!:::/;0!&5&%&4$!),+((5&5?!:\><45>/::/!T@E!GIIJKJ@HGP!JHT@ECGKJ@H!@H! KNBLB!JKBCL-! .;

! 1!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! ^@LJKJ@H!GC@H_!KNB!#e!DGLBI!GP>`GJIG!SBPP3!JL!G!EB^@EKBI!TGSJPJKGK@E3!EBSEMJKBE!GHI!TJHGHSJBE! GHI!JL!GLL@SJGKBI!VJKN!GP>`GJIG!SBPPL!JHLJIB!KNB!#)-!!6BKGJHBB!VGL!GH!GLLBLLBI!S@CDGKGHK! LMD>S@CCGHIBE!JH!%@EG!Q@EG!VNBEB!NB!^GEKJSJ^GKBI!JH!N@LKJPJKJBL!G_GJHLK!#)!GHI!,@GPJKJ@H! T@ESBL-!!6BKGJHBB!NGL!PBH_KNX!KJBL!K@!CJPJKGHK!YJNGI!GHI!NGL!EBSBJABI!DGLJS!GHI!GIAGHSBI! KEGJHJH_3!K@!JHSPMIB!Ba^P@LJABL!KEGJHJH_-!!6BKGJHBB!NGL!LN@VH!G!VJPPJH_HBLL!K@!DBS@CB!G! CGEKXE!T@E!NJL!SGMLB-!! ! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!JL!G!CBCDBE!@T!GP>`GJIG3!G!HBKV@EW!TGSJPJKGK@E3!EBSEMJKBE!GHI!G! TJHGHSJBE!VJKN!SP@LB!KJBL!K@!#Q$-! ! 8)UU5=9!!)GMIJ!JHKBPPJ_BHSB!8"GDGNJKN9!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB!PBTK!)GMIJ!4EGDJG!GHI! Y@JHBI!#Q$!JH!4T_NGHJLKGH-!!%NB!"GDGNJKN!JIBHKJTJBI!IBKGJHBB!GL!G!NJ_N!^EJ@EJKX!T@E! KNB!_@ABEHCBHK!@T!)GMIJ!4EGDJG3!GH!JHIJSGKJ@H!@T!NJL!PGV!BHT@ESBCBHK!AGPMB!K@! KNBC- .7 ! ! 8)UU5=9!!?Z>.::.\!JIBHKJTJBI!IBKGJHBB!GL!G!CBCDBE!@T!GP>`GJIG- .1 !!?Z>.::.\! LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB!LM^^PJBI!GP>`GJIG!VJKN!CBH3!Ba^BEKJLB3!BfMJ^CBHK3!GHI!C@HBX- .\ !!?Z> .::.\!TMEKNBE!EB^@EKBI!IBKGJHBB!PJWBPX!LV@EB!bayat!8@GKN!@T!GPPB_JGHSB9!K@!#Q$3! DBSGMLB!IBKGJHBB!HBBIBI!K@!@DKGJH!#Q$bL!^BECJLLJ@H!T@E!GHX!GSKJAJKX-!!6BKGJHBB!N@PIL! #Q$!JH!NJ_N!EB_GEI- .F !! ! 8)UU5=9!!4LLBLLBI!GP>`GJIG!TGSJPJKGK@E3!#e>112!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB!LBEABI!GL!G! EBSEMJKBE!T@E!GP>`GJIG- .2 !!?Z>.::.\!LM^^@EKBI!KNJL!LKGKBCBHK!H@KJH_!KNB!IBKGJHBB!VGL! BaKEBCBPX!GSKJAB!JH!EBSEMJKJH_!X@MH_!CBH- .0 ! ! 8)UU5=9!!)4>70;!LKGKBI!KNGK!IBKGJHBB!VGL!G!L^BSJGP!JHKBE^EBKBE!T@E!#Q$!GHI!KNB! @HPX!^BEL@H!SP@LB!K@!#Q$!VN@!VGL!TPMBHK!JH!(H_PJLN!GHI!4EGDJS- /: ! ! 8)9!!"MNGCCGI!QGLGEIGN3!&)5!#)0c">:::/1/6'!8c">/1/93!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB! VGL!GH!JC^@EKGHK!@TTJSBE!GHI!VGL!G!SP@LB!GLL@SJGKB!@T!#Q$!JH!%@EG!Q@EG- /. !!6BKGJHBB! JHIJSGKBI!NB!VGL!VJKN!#Q$!GTKBE!KNB!#)!D@CDJH_!SGC^GJ_H!JH!4T_NGHJLKGH!DB_GH!JH! *SK@DBE!/::.-!!c">/1/!GPL@!LKGKBI!KNGK!IBKGJHBBbL!TGCJPX!EBSBJABI!G!C@HKNPX!LKJ^BHI! TE@C!#Q$- // !

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! .7

!%6>;.7U/F171>:/! !%6>;.7U;1;;/>:/3!%6>;.7U./F.7>:;3!%6>;.7U//0.7>:13!%6>;.7U7/;::>:/3!%6>;.7U//011>:/! .\ !,&+!;.\U::\1.>:;3!%6>;.7U;2:2:>:/! .F !%6>;.7U/7\0\>:/! .2 !&&+!\!:;7!..10!:;3!:::112!)KGKBCBHK!@T!=GSK!/::;:/.;3!:::112!="7:!:0>"4+>/::;! .0 !%6>;.7U;2:2:>:/! /: !&&+!\!:;7!:;.1!:13!:::70;!)&+!:.><#5>/::1! /. !&&+!\!:;7!..F/!:;3!&&+!\!:;7!.;:;!:;3!:::/1/!)&+!.\><45>:;3!&&+!\!:;7!./2F!:73!:::/;0!"=+!.2><#$>/::/! // !:::/1/!"=+!.\><45>/::;! .1

! \!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! ! 8,UU+($!#)4!456!?,%=9!!)BHJ@E!GP>`GJIG!Ba^P@LJABL!Ba^BEK3!%GEJf!"GNCMI! 4NCGI!GP>)GVGN3!&)5!#)0(?>:::1;16'!8(?>1;193!SPGJCBI!IBKGJHBB!S@HTBLLBI!K@! SG^KMEJH_!5@EKNBEH!4PPJGHSB!T@ESBL!KNGK!NB!VGL!G!CBCDBE!@T!GP>`GJIG- /; ! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!NGL!KEGABPBI!JHKBEHGKJ@HGPPX!@H!CMPKJ^PB!TGPLB!^GLL^@EKL3!G! WH@VH!JHIJSGK@E!@T!GP>`GJIG!KEGABP- /7 !! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!JL!GLLBLLBI!K@!DB!G!WBX!CBCDBE!@T!KNB!#e!DGLBI!GP>`GJIG!HBKV@EW! VJKN!CMPKJ^PB!GLL@SJGKJ@HL!K@!LBHJ@E!GP>`GJIG!CBCDBEL!GHI!@KNBE!@^BEGKJABL-! ! 8,UU+($!#)4!456!?,%=9!!(?>1;1!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB!IBPJABEBI!8S@MEJBEBI9!C@HBX! TE@C!KNB!#e!K@!Q@LHJG!JH!.00\-!!(?>1;1!GIIBI!KNGK!IBKGJHBB!DBP@H_BI!K@!KNB!_E@M^! GLL@SJGKBI!K@!4DM![GC]G!GP>"GLEJ!JH!KNB!#e- /1 ! ! 8,UU+($!#)4!456!?,%=9!!4SS@EIJH_!K@!)4>70;3!IBKGJHBB!DBP@H_BI!K@!GH!GP> `GJIG!SBPP!JH!$@HI@H3!#e!GHI!VGL!GLL@SJGKBI!K@!#Q$- %NB!SBPP!JHSPMIBI!IBKGJHBBd! QJLNBE!4CJH!eNGPJP!GP>+GVJ3!&)5!#)0&Z>:::0:\6'!8&Z>0:\3!KEGHLTBEEBI9d!?NGLLGH! 4DIGPPGN!?NG]J!GP>)NGEDJ3!&)5!#)0)4>:::\2/6'!8)4>\2/9d!GHI!GLLBLLBI!GP>`GJIG! TGSJPJKGK@E!4DIMPPGN!"MNGCCGI!eNGH3!GWG!84DI!GP>$GKJT!GP>%MEWJ93!&)5!#)04=> :::11\6'!84=>11\9. /\ ! " 8,UU+($!#)4!456!?,%=9!!)4>70;!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB!JHT@ECBI!NJC!KNGK!NB! WHBV!"MNGCCGI![GCJI!GP>`GEGHJ3!&)5!#)0,6>:::/\06'!8,6>/\09!GL!cMLMT! GP>,NGIJ3!GHI!SPGJCBI!,6>/\0!VGL!GPL@!GLL@SJGKBI!VJKN!KNB!#e!SBPP- /F !!! " 8)UU5=9!!c">/1/!LKGKBI!NB!NBGEI!KNGK!&Z>0:\!GHI!IBKGJHBB!VBEB!SP@LB!TEJBHIL! GHI!VBEB!D@KN!JHA@PABI!JH!GH!&LPGCJS!C@ABCBHK!PBI!DX!)NGXWN!4DM!#DGXIGN-!! 4TKBE!QEJKJLN!GMKN@EJKJBL!GEEBLKBI!#DGXIGN!T@E!NGAJH_!KJBL!K@!GP>`GJIG3!&Z>0:\! DE@WB!JHK@!NJL!$@HI@H3!#e3!N@CB!GHI!LK@PB!AGPMGDPB!^G^BEL!GPPB_BIPX!PJHWJH_! #DGXIGN!K@!GP>`GJIG-!!c">/1/!GPL@!DBPJBABI!KNGK!&Z>0:\!VGL!JHA@PABI!JH!GP> `GJIG!EBSEMJKJH_!@^BEGKJ@HL!JH!(H_PGHI-!!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!!4DM!#DGXIGN!JL!GLLBLLBI! K@!DB!IBKGJHBBbL!GLL@SJGKB!4DM!`GKGIG- /2 ! ! 8#UU=*#*9!!6BKGJHBB!VGL!G!SP@LB!TEJBHI!@T!QGDBE!4NCBI-!!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!!QGDBE! 4NCBI!JL!GH!GLLBLLBI!CBCDBE!@T!KNB!g%@@KJH_!?E@M^3h!G!#e>DGLBI!,NBSNBH!LM^^@EK! GHI!^E@SMEBCBHK!HBKV@EW-9 /0 ! ! 8)9!!4DIGPPGN!cGNXG!cMLJT!GP>)NJDPJ3!&)5!#)0c">:::/7:6'!8c">/7:93! JIBHKJTJBI!IBKGJHBB!GL!G!^@LLJDPB!WBX!CBCDBE!@T!KNB!#e!GP>`GJIG!HBKV@EW- ;: !!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! /;

!:::1;1!)&+!:0>4'+>/::1! !%6>;.7U./F.7>:;3!%6>;.7U//0.7>:13!"GDGNJKN!+=&!+BL^@HLB!/;>4#?>/::1! /1 !:::1;1!)&+!:0>4'+>/::1! /\ !&&+!\!:;7!:/F:!:1! /F !&&+!\!:;7!:/F:!:1! /2 !:::/1/!="7:!.7>)('>/::73!:::/1/!="7:!:.>)('>/::73!:::/1/!="7:!/;>)('>/::73!:::0:\!="7:!:0>5*k> /::7! /0 !:::/;0!;:/!/:>=(Q>/::/3!)BB!&&+!/:.!.72;!:1!T@E!GIIJKJ@HGP!JHT@ECGKJ@H!@H!4NCGI-! ;: !&&+!/!;7:!\7\7!:/! /7

! F!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! ! !8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!GICJKKBI!TEBfMBHKJH_!KNB!=JHLDMEX!'GEW!"@LfMB!VNBEB!NB!CBK! 4DM![GC]G!GP>"GLEJ3!KNB!(_X^KJGH!SPBEJS!@T!KNB!=JHLDMEX!'GEW!"@LfMB- ;. !!?Z>.::.\! GIIBI!IBKGJHBB!VGL!S@HHBSKBI!K@!KNB!=@ME!=BGKNBEL!,PMD!JH!(H_PGHI- ;/ ! " 8)UU5=9!!5@EKN!$@HI@HbL!=JHLDMEX!'GEW!"@LfMB!NGL!G!NJLK@EX!@T!LBEAJH_!GL!GH! GKKGSW!^PGHHJH_!GHI!^E@^G_GHIG!^E@IMSKJ@H!DGLB!T@E!GP>`GJIG-!!QEJKJLN!GMKN@EJKJBL! S@HLJIBE!KNB!C@LfMB!G!WBX!EBSEMJKCBHK!TGSJPJKX!T@E!5@EKN!4TEJSGH!GHI!@KNBE! BaKEBCJLKL!VJKNJH!KNB!GP>`GJIG!GLL@SJGKBI!C@ABCBHK-;; ! " 8)UU5=9!!)BABEGP!IBKGJHBBL!EB^@EKBI!KNGK!X@MH_!"MLPJCL!VBEB!EBSEMJKBI!TE@C! KNB!=@ME!=BGKNBEbL!"@LfMB!GWG!8QGWBE!)KEBBK!"@LfMB9-!!QGWBE!)KEBBK!JL!KNB!N@CB! @T!EGIJSGP!JCGC3!4DM!`GKGIG-!!6BKGJHBB!GICJKKBI!K@!GLL@SJGKJ@HL!VJKN!D@KN!KNB! C@LfMB!GHI!`GKGIG- ;7 ! " 8)UU5=9!!(_X^KJGH!)NGXWN3!4DM![GC]G!GP>"GLEJ3!VGL!KNB!T@ECBE!JCGC!@T! KNB!=JHLDMEX!'GEW!"@LfMB!JH!$@HI@H-!!4P>"GLEJ3!GWG!"MNGCCGI!GP!"GLEJ3! VGL!G!EGIJSGP!SPBEJS!GHI!4DM!`GKGIGbL!GLL@SJGKB- ;1 !!4P>"GLEJ!PBSKMEBI!GK!KNB! C@LfMB!TE@C!.00F!MHKJP!/::;-!!4P>"GLEJ!BL^@MLBI!NGKEBI!K@VGEI!C@IBEH! OBLKBEH!SJAJPJ]GKJ@H!GHI!<MIGJLC!GHI!BHS@MEG_BI!NJL!T@PP@VBEL!K@!CMEIBE! H@H>"MLPJCL-!!*H!F!<GHMGEX!/::\3!QEJKJLN!S@MEKL!T@MHI!GP>"GLEJ!_MJPKX!@H!..! SNGE_BL!GHI!LBHKBHSBI!NJC!K@!LBABH!XBGEL!JH!^EJL@H- ;\ !!)4>70;!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB! AJLJKBI!GP>"GLEJ!JH!$@HI@H- ;F !!! " 8)UU5=9!!4DM!`GKGIG!VGL!EB_GEIBI!GL!GP>`GJIGbL!gL^JEJKMGP!PJGJL@Hh!JH! (ME@^B3!TGSJPJKGKJH_!EBSEMJKCBHK!@T!X@MH_!"MLPJCL!T@E!YJNGI!KNE@M_N!KNB! =JHLDMEX!'GEW!GHI!QGWBE!)KEBBKU=@ME!=BGKNBEL!"@LfMBL!JH!$@HI@H-;2 !!?Z> .::.\!SGPPBI!4DM!`GKGIG!gKNB!C@LK!LMSSBLLTMP!EBSEMJKBE!JH!(ME@^B-h;0 !!4DM! `GKGIG!VGL!KNB!PBGIBE!@T!KNB!$@HI@H!GP>`GJIG!SBPP3!GHI!)NGXWN3!4DM![GC]G! GP>"GLEJ!VGL!NJL!LBS@HI!JH!S@CCGHI- 7: ! ! 8)UU5=9!!?Z>.::.\!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB!VGL!JH!S@HKGSK!VJKN!GP>`GJIG!CBCDBE!eNGPJP! 6BBW!IMEJH_!IBKGJHBBbL!KJCB!JH!KNB!#e-!!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!!eNGPJP!6BBW!NGL!DBBH! JIBHKJTJBI!GL!G!LML^BSK!JH!KNB!"JPPBHHJMC!'P@K3!GHI!G!^EJHSJ^PB!IEGTKBE!@T!KNB! g(HSXSP@^BIJG!<JNGIh!K@!VNJSN!#e>112!JL!GPL@!PJHWBI-9 7. ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! ;.

!:::/;0!;:/!/\>"4+>/::;3!:::/;0!"=+!.2><#$>/::/! !%6>;.7U.2\;/>:/! ;; !:::/;2!4,&,!&HT@ECGKJ@H!'G^BE!%BEE@EJLK!%NEBGK!4LLBLLCBHK!//>)('>/::7! ;7 !&&+!7!/:.!.1;:!:13!&&+!\!:;7!:;1:!:/D3!6&>/F..>/1>:7!6&4!4LLBLLCBHK! ;1 !&&+!\!:;7!:;.1!:13!&&+!\!:;7!:;1\!:/3!&&+!\!:;7!:;.1!:1! ;\ !,5(>,\=!*HB!'G_BE!.:>=(Q>:\! ;F !:::70;!)&+!/1>4'+>/::1! ;2 !6&>/F..>/1>:7!6&4!4LLBLLCBHK! ;0 !%6>;.7U;1;\:>:/! 7: !&&+!\!:;7!:;.1!:13!&&+!\!:;7!:/F:!:13!&&+!\!:;7!:;:/!:7!!8&KBC!769! 7. !%6>;.7U;71.\>:/! ;/

! 2!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!GICJKKBI!GLL@SJGKJH_!VJKN!S@HAJSKBI!LMJSJIB!KBEE@EJLK!+JSNGEI! +BJI!GHI!VGL!LBBH!VJKN!+BJI!JH!IBKGJHBBbL!G^GEKCBHK!JH!eGDMP- 7/ ! " 8)UU5=9!!+JSNGEI!+BJI!GKKBHIBI!KNB!=JHLDMEX!'GEW!"@LfMB!GHI!VGL!S@HAJSKBI! @T!GKKBC^KJH_!K@!DP@V!M^!GH!4CBEJSGH!4JEPJHBL!TPJ_NK!JH!6BSBCDBE!/::.!VJKN! Ba^P@LJABL!NJIIBH!JH!NJL!LN@BL- 7; !!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!!(?>1;1!IBABP@^BI!KNB!LN@B! D@CD-9 77 ! ! 8#9!!6BKGJHBB!GICJKKBI!DBJH_!G!E@@CCGKB!@T!S@HAJSKBI!GP>`GJIG!LMJSJIB!@^BEGKJAB3! ZGSNGEJGL!"@MLL@MJ- 71 ! " 8#9!"@MLL@MJ!GKKBHIBI!GP>`GJIG!L^@HL@EBI!TPJ_NK!KEGJHJH_!JH!KNB!#)3!GHI! GKKBHIBI!KNB!QEJaK@H!"@LfMB!GHI!KNB!=JHLDMEX!'GEW!"@LfMB- 7\ ! " 8#9!!4DIMP![G__!QGWBE3!KNB!QEJaK@H!"@LfMB!JCGC3!EBCGEWBI!KNGK!QJaK@H! NGL!DBS@CB!^EBX!K@!&LPGCJS!BaKEBCJLKL!LBBWJH_!X@MH_!EBSEMJKL!T@E!YJNGI-!! 6BKGJHBB!GICJKKBI!K@!GKKBHIJH_!KNJL!C@LfMB-7F ! ! 8#UU=*#*9!!6BKGJHBB!GICJKKBI!CBBKJH_!#Q$bL!EBPJ_J@ML!GIAJL@E3!4DM![GTL!GP> "GMEJKGHJG!M^@H!GEEJAGP!JH!eGHIGNGE!JH!/::.- 72 !! ! 8,UU+($!#)4!456!?,%=U+($&6*9!!6BKGJHBB!JIBHKJTJBI!NJL!eGDMP!HBJ_ND@EL!GL! @T!LBHJ@E!GP>`GJIG!GLL@SJGKB!"MLKGTG!5G]GE!)BKCGEJGC3!GWG!84DM!"MLGD!GP>)MEJ3! SG^KMEBI9!GHI!)NGXWN!4DM!GP>OGPJI3!PJWBPX!JIBHKJTJGDPB!VJKN!EGIJSGP!)NGXWN!4DM! OGPJI!GP>=JPJLKJHJ-!!&H!eGDMP3!IBKGJHBB!LKGXBI!GK!KNB!N@CB!@T!Q@LHJGH!YJNGI!ABKBEGH! 4DIMPPGN!GP>)S@KPGHIJ3!GWG!8<GCBL!"S$JHK@SW9-!! 70 ! ! 8)UU5=9!!?Z>.::.\!LKGKBI!NB!LBHK!c">.::.73!GP>`GJIG!TGSJPJKGK@E!4DM!cGLJE!GP> <G]GJEJ3!GHI!4DM!%GXXJD!GP>)GMIJ!8GLLBLLBI!K@!DB!IBKGJHBB9!K@!'GWJLKGH!JH!6BSBCDBE!@T! /::.- 1: !!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!!%NJL!GSKJAJKX!^E@DGDPX!@SSMEEBI!JH!BGEPX!6BSBCDBE3!^EJ@E!K@! IBKGJHBBbL!KEGABP!K@!%@EG!Q@EG-9! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!JL!GLL@SJGKBI!VJKN!$JDXGH!BaKEBCJLKL!@^BEGKJH_!JH!&EBPGHI-! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!JL!PJHWBI!K@!$JDXGH!BaKEBCJLK3![JLNGC!)BJTBPHGLE-!!&EJLN! GMKN@EJKJBL!LBGESNBI!)BJTBPHGLEbL!N@CB!@H!;!)B^KBCDBE!.002!GHI!T@MHI!IBKGJHBB! GP@H_!VJKN!ZMDGXE!GP>[GJPJ-!!)BJTBPHGLE!IBLSEJDBI!IBKGJHBB!GL!G!ABKBEGH!@T!KNB!4T_NGH! OGE!GHI!GH!BaKEBCJLK!GSKJAB!KNE@M_N@MK!(ME@^B-!!6MEJH_!G!LBGESN!@T!G!6MDPJH3!&EBPGHI3!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! 7/

!%6>;.7U.2\;/>:/! !+(,+#&%&5?!=*+!<&[46!(#+*'(3!&&+!\!:;7!..7:!:;3!:::/;0!)&+!:;><45>/::/3!&&+!\!:;7!::;\!:\! 77 !:::1;1!"=+!.;><MH>/::;! 71 !&&+!\!:;7!:;1:>:/D3!&&+!\!:;7!:;1:!:/! 7\ !+(,+#&%&5?!=*+!<&[46!(#+*'(3!&&+!\!:;7!:;1:!:/D3!&&+!\!:;7!:;1:!:/! 7F !+(,+#&%&5?!=*+!<&[46!(#+*'(3!&&+!\!:;7!:;1:!:/D! 72 !!:::/;0!;:/!/:>=(Q>/::/! 70 !!:::/;0!;:/!/:>=(Q>/::/3!&&+!\!:;7!::71!:\! 1: !!%6>;.7U:771;>:;! 7;

! 0!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! G^GEKCBHK!DBP@H_JH_!K@!4KJT!4NCBI3!I@SMCBHKGKJ@H!VGL!EBS@ABEBI!LN@VJH_!KNEBB! LB^GEGKB!^N@HB!HMCDBEL!T@E!IBKGJHBB3!JHIJSGKJH_!GH!GLL@SJGKJ@H!K@!4NCBI- 1. !!! ! 8)UU5=9!!#e>112!SPGJCBI!K@!NGAB!KEGABPBI!K@!&EBPGHI!JH!PGKB>/:::!VJKN!IBKGJHBB3!GK! VNJSN!KJCB!NB!CBK!IBKGJHBBbL!TEJBHI3!4DBENJC!QMLNBE-1/ !!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!4DBENJC! QMLNBE!JL!&DEGNJC!QMJLJE!GWG!8&DEGNJC!i4DI!GP>)GPGC!"MNGCCGI!QMLGXE9-!!&DEGNJC! QMJLJE!JL!GH!&EBPGHI>DGLBI!KBEE@EJLK!TGSJPJKGK@E!VN@!N@PIL!G!PBGIBELNJ^!^@LJKJ@H!JH!KNB! GP>`GJIG!(ME@^BGH!SBPP-!!QMJLJE!VGL!KNB!IJEBSK@E!@T!KNB!&EBPGHI!DEGHSN!@T!KNB!&LPGCJS! +BPJBT!4_BHSX!MHKJP!PGKB>/::/- 1; 9! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!JL!GLLBLLBI!K@!NGAB!^GEKJSJ^GKBI!JH!N@LKJPJKJBL!G_GJHLK!#)!GHI! ,@GPJKJ@H!T@ESBL!JH!%@EG!Q@EG!VNBEB!NB!LBEABI!GL!G!LMD>S@CCGHIBE-! ! 8)UU5=9!!"MPKJ^PB!IBKGJHBBL!NGAB!JIBHKJTJBI!IBKGJHBBbL!HGCB!@E!GPJGL!GL!KNB! S@CCGHIBE!@T!KNB!<MNGXHG!,BHKBE!JH!%@EG!Q@EG- 17 !! ! 8)UU5=9!!c">/1/!LKGKBI!KNGK!IBKGJHBB!VGL!JH!SNGE_B!@T!KNEBB!KEBHSNBL!JH!%@EG! Q@EG3!BGSN!VJKN!KNEBB>K@>KBH!^B@^PB!GLLJ_HBI-!!c">/1/!GPL@!JIBHKJTJBI!IBKGJHBB!GL!G! PBGIBE!GK!KNB!GP>`MEGLNJ!,BHKBE!JH!%@EG!Q@EG- 11 !!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!!%NB!SBHKBEL!JH!%@EG! Q@EG!NGAB!DBBH!EB^@EKBI!GL!SGABL3!DMHWBEL3!GHI!KEBHSNBL!VNJSN!GP>`GJIG!PBI!T@ESBL! @SSM^JBI!IMEJH_!@^BEGKJ@HL!G_GJHLK!#)!GHI!,@GPJKJ@H!T@ESBL!JH!5@ABCDBE!GHI! 6BSBCDBE!/::.-!!6BKGJHBBbL!^EBLBHSB!JH!%@EG!Q@EG!GHI!NJL!EB^@EKBI!^@LJKJ@H!@T! PBGIBELNJ^!GK!G!SBHKBE!LM^^@EKL!KNB!GLLBLLCBHK!KNGK!NB!^GEKJSJ^GKBI!JH!KNB!N@LKJPJKJBL-9! ! 8)UU5=9!![MCMI!6GWNJP![MCMI!)GJI!GP><GIGHJ3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;:6'!8)4>/;:93! VJKHBLLBI!IBKGJHBB!CBBKJH_!VJKN!#Q$!JH!%@EG!Q@EG-1\ ! ! 8,UU+($!#)4!456!?,%=9!!(?>1;1!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB!VGL!JH!%@EG!Q@EG!GHI! @^BEGKBI!G!EGIJ@!KNGK!IBKGJHBB!MLBI!K@!S@CCMHJSGKB!VJKN!@KNBE!TJ_NKJH_!^@LJKJ@HL- 1F !! c">/1/!GIIBI!KNGK!JH!%@EG!Q@EG3!IBKGJHBB!BLKGDPJLNBI!G!^E@_EGC!T@E!MLJH_!IJTTBEBHK! SNGHHBPL!K@!GA@JI!JHKBESB^KJ@H- 12 !!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!!'@LLBLLJ@H!@T!G!EGIJ@!VGL!GH! JHIJSGKJ@H!@T!G!PBGIBELNJ^!^@LJKJ@H-9! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!NGL!PBH_KNX!KJBL!K@!CJPJKGHK!YJNGI!DBX@HI!%@EG!Q@EG!GHI!EBSBJABI! DGLJS!GHI!GIAGHSBI!KEGJHJH_3!K@!JHSPMIB!KNB!MLB!@T!Ba^P@LJABL-! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! 1.

!%6>;.7U;F\72>:;3!4HGPXLK!5@KBR!4!AGEJGHK!@T!)BJTBPHGLE!JL!)GJT!GP>5GLLBE-! !&&+!\!:;7!:.:;!:\3!&&+!\!:;7!..10!:;3!:::112!="7:!:0>"4+>/::;! 1; %6>;.7U.227F>:73!%6>;.7U;0\\.>:.!! 17 !!&&+!/!;7:!\;;7!:/3!:::1..!;:/!/.><MH>/::/3!&&+!\!:;7!.;::!:;3!&&+!\!:;7!.;::!:;3!&&+!\!:;7!::2\!:;3!&&+!\! :;7!.;:;!:;3!%6>;.7>:;;F2>:/3!:::170!)&+!.;>"4c>/::/3!%6>;.7U:;;F2>:/3!&&+!\!:;7!.;:;!:;3!&&+!\!:;7!:/2.! :F3!4HGPXLK!5@KBR!!%NB!V@EI!,BHKBE!JL!MLBI!K@!IBLSEJDB!TJ_NKJH_!^@LJKJ@HL!@E!IBTBHLJAB!SGC^L-!! 11 !&&+!\!:;7!..F/!:;3!&&+!\!:;7!.;:;!:;3!&&+!\!:;7!./2F!:73!:::/1/!)&+!.\><45>/::;3!:::/;0!"=+!.2><#$>/::/3! :::/1/!="7:!.:>=(Q>/::1-!=@E!GIIJKJ@HGP!EB^@EKJH_!@H!KNB!`MEGLNJ!,BHKBE3!LBB!&&+!\!:;7!:1;F!:;3!&&+!/!;7:!\/;\! :/3!&&+!\!:;7!.701!:;3!&&+!/!;7:!\./:!:/3!GHI!&&+!\!:;7!:1\7!:;-!!`MEGLNJ!CGX!DB!PJLKBI!GL!eGEGSNJ!@E!GH@KNBE! AGEJGHK!JH!KNB!EB^@EKL-! 1\ !:::/;:!)&+!/\>4#?>/::\! 1F !:::1;1!)&+!:0>4'+>/::1! 12 !!:::/1/!)&+!//>"4c>/::F! 1/

! .:!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! ! 8)UU5=9!!4SS@EIJH_!K@!LML^BSKBI!GP>`GJIG!CBCDBE3!*CGE!=GEMf3!IBKGJHBB!KEGABPBI! K@!KNB!'NJPJ^^JHBL!GK!KNB!BHI!@T!.00\3!T@E!G^^E@aJCGKBPX!@HB!C@HKN-!!6MEJH_!KNGK!KJCB3! IBKGJHBB!EBSBJABI!KEGJHJH_!@H!DGLJS!Ba^P@LJABL!GHI!@H!D@@DX!KEG^L-!!=GEMf!VGL!GK! ,GC^!4DM!QGWE!VNBH!IBKGJHBB!S@HKGSKBI!NJC- 10 !!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!!6BKGJHBB!NGL!H@K! GSWH@VPBI_BI!GHX!KEGABP!K@!KNB!'NJPJ^^JHBL3!H@E!I@BL!NB!CGWB!GHX!EBTBEBHSBL!K@! WH@VJH_!*CGE!=GEMf-9!!! ! 8)UU5=9!!#e>112!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB!VGL!^GEK!@T!KNB!Q@LHJGH!%NJEI!4ECX!,@E^L3! TJ_NKJH_!G_GJHLK!KNB!)BEDL-!!#e>112!DBPJBABI!IBKGJHBB!VGL!G!CBCDBE!@T!KNB!ZMDGXE! ?E@M^!EMH!DX!4DM!ZMDGXE!GP>[GJPJ-!!#e>112!LKGKBI!KNGK!IBKGJHBB!L^BHK!;:!IGXL! KEGJHJH_!@H!KNB!4e>7F!GHI!E@SWBK!^E@^BPPBI!_EBHGIBL- \: !!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!6BKGJHBBbL! ^GEKJSJ^GKJ@H!JH!Q@LHJG!@SSMEEBI!IMEJH_!.001-9!!! ! 8)UU5=9!!=GNI!#CGE!4DI!GP>"GYJI!GP>#CGEJ!GP>)NGEJT3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/.16'! 8)4>/.193!JIBHKJTJBI!IBKGJHBB!GL!"MNGCCGI![GCBI!GP>ZMDGJEJ!GHI!H@KBI!KNGK!NB!CBK! IBKGJHBB!@H!KNB!TE@HK!PJHBL!JH!4T_NGHJLKGH!JH!/::.-!!)4>/.1!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB!VGL! ^E@TJSJBHK!JH!GEKJPPBEX!GHI!gCG^!KEGSWJH_-h \. !!c">/1/!GIIBI!KNGK!IBKGJHBB!VGL!G! C@EKGE!Ba^BEK- \/ ! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!NGL!Ba^EBLLBI!G!IBLJEB!K@!DBS@CB!G!CGEKXE!GHI!_GAB!JHIJSGKJ@HL!@T! GKKGSWJH_!#)!SJKJ]BHL!M^@H!EBPBGLB-! ! 8)9!!6BKGJHBB!SPGJCBI!KNGK!VNJPB!NB!VGL!G_GJHLK!KNB!GKKGSWL!@T!..!)B^KBCDBE!/::.3! NB!V@MPI!DB!NG^^X!K@!DB!G!CGEKXE!T@E!NJL!EBPJ_J@H- \; !!! ! 8#UU=*#*9!!6BKGJHBB!GPL@!LKGKBI!gKNB!#HJKBI!)KGKBL!V@MPI3!GHI!LN@MPI!TGPP! DBSGMLB!JK!NGL!DBS@CB!GH!MHYMLK!HGKJ@H!GHI!?@I!V@MPI!KGWB!NJL!EBABH_B!@H!KNB!#HJKBI! )KGKBL!T@E!KNB!MHPGVTMP!JC^EJL@HCBHK!@T!JHH@SBHK!"MLPJCL!YMLK!GL!NJCLBPT-h\7 !!! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!LKGKBI!JK!VGL!N@H@EGDPB!KNGK!KNB!JHLME_BHKL!JH!&EGf!VBEB!VJPPJH_! K@!_JAB!KNBJE!PJABL!T@E!VNGK!KNBX!DBPJBABI!VGL!G!H@DPB!SGMLB- \1 ! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!LKGKBI!KNGK!NB!S@MPI!^MK!Ba^P@LJAB!CGKBEJGP!JHLJIB!BHABP@^BL!GHI! LBHI!KNBC!K@!JHIJAJIMGPL!VN@!LNGEBI!KNB!LGCB!PGLK!HGCB-!!6BKGJHBB!CGIB!KNB! S@CCBHK!VNJPB!IJLSMLLJH_!NJL!AJBV!@T!4CBEJSGH!^GEGH@JG!JH!VNJSN!KNBX!Ba^BSKBI!NJC! 8IBKGJHBB9!K@!GKKGSW!_E@M^L!@T!#)!SJKJ]BHL!VJKN!LGCB!PGLK!HGCB!GTKBE!NB!JL!EBPBGLBI-\\ ! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!JL!GLL@SJGKBI!VJKN!KBEE@EJLKL!@^BEGKJH_!JH!KNB!#)!@E!KGE_BKJH_!KNB!#)-! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! 10

!%6>;.7U72/;7>:/d!4HGPXLK!5@KBR!!*CGE!=GE@Mf!JL!^E@DGDPX!JIBHKJTJGDPB!VJKN!IBSBGLBI!GP>`GJIG!CBCDBE3! "MNCMI!4NCGI!"MNGCCGI!GP>+GLNJI3!&)5!#)0e#>::./:\6'!8e#>.:/\9-! \: !&&+!\!:;7!..10!:;3!:::112!)KGKBCBHK!.;>=(Q>/::;3!:::112!="7:!:0>"4+>/::;! \. !:::/.1!)&+!.;>*,%>/::1! \/ !:::/1/!)&+!.\><45>/::;! \; !:::/;0!;:/!.F><#$>/::/! \7 !:::/;0!="7:!/:>=(Q>/::;! \1 !:::/;0!)&+!/0>"4+>/::\! \\ !!&&+!\!:;7!:77/!:F!

! ..!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! ! 8)UU5=9!!)4>70;!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB!KEGABPBI!KVJSB!K@!KNB!#)-!!6MEJH_!KNB!TJELK!KEJ^3! IBKGJHBB!KEGABPBI!K@!5BV!c@EW!K@!AJLJK!GP>`GJIG!SBPPL-!!)B^GEGKB!EB^@EKJH_!LKGKBI! IBKGJHBB!L^BHK!TJAB!XBGEL!JH!KNB!#)-\F !!)4>70;!LKGKBI!NB!@ABENBGEI!e#>/;/!GHI! IBKGJHBB!IJLSMLLJH_!KNB!KJCB!KNBX!VBEB!JH!5BV!c@EW!JH!.002. \2 !!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!! 6BKGJHBB!NGL!H@K!^E@AJIBI!GHX!JHT@ECGKJ@H!EB_GEIJH_!KEGABP!K@!5BV!c@EW3!GHI!)4> 70;!IJI!H@K!^E@AJIB!IGKBL!@T!KEGABP-!!&K!JL!^@LLJDPB!KNGK!IBKGJHBB!NGI!S@HKGSK!VJKN!KNB! #CGE!4DIMP!+GNCGH3!GWG!8KNB!QPJHI!)NGXWN9!GHI!NJL!@^BEGKJABL!JH!5BV!c@EW!,JKX!@E! CBCDBEL!@T!KNB!$GSWGVGHHG!)Ja!SBPP!JH!QMTTGP@3!5c-!!%NB!QPJHI!)NGXWN!VGL! S@HAJSKBI!T@E!SEJCBL!EBPGKBI!K@!KNB!.00;!O@EPI!%EGIB!,BHKBE!D@CDJH_!GHI!.001!^P@KL! G_GJHLK!@KNBE!5BV!c@EW!PGHICGEWL-9! ! 8)UU+($!54%*U+($&6*9!!)4>70;!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB!JHT@ECBI!NJC!KNGK!KNBEB!VGL! GH!GP>`GJIG!SBPP!JH!4EJ]@HG-!!6BKGJHBB!AJLJKBI!KNB!SBPP!JH!4EJ]@HG!JH!PGKB>.000!VJKN! GLLBLLBI!GP>`GJIG!CBCDBE!+JSNGEI!6BGH!QBPCGE3!&)5!#)0#e>:::2.F6'!8#e>2.F3! KEGHLTBEEBI9-\0 ! ! 8)UU5=9!!?Z>.::.\!JIBHKJTJBI!JHIJAJIMGPL!VN@!S@MPI!DB!LMJKBI!T@E!GKKGSWL!G_GJHLK! OBLKBEH!KGE_BKLd!KNB!PJLK!JHSPMIBI!IBKGJHBB-!!?Z>.::.\!LKGKBI!gIBKGJHBB!VGL!JH!KNB!#)! DBT@EB!KNB!YJNGI!JH!Q@LHJG-!!OJKN!NJL!LKE@H_!(H_PJLN!GHI!4CBEJSGH!IJGPBSK3!GHI!NJL! _BHBEGP!G^^BGEGHSB3!NB!S@MPI!BGLJPX!BHKBE!KNB!#)!GL!GH!4EGD!CBESNGHK-!!&T!NB!VBEB! WH@VH!lK@!GMKN@EJKJBLm3!NB!S@MPI!BHKBE!KNE@M_N!KNB!PGHI!TE@C!KNB!5@EKN!8,GHGIG9!@E! )@MKN!8"BaJS@9-!!&!WH@V!NB!JL!VJKN!GP>`GJIG!GHI!P@ABL!K@!V@EW!JHLJIB!KNB!#)-h!! 84HGPXLK!5@KBR!!%NJL!LKGKBCBHK!TE@C!?Z>.::.\!JPPMLKEGKBL!IBKGJHBBbL!^@KBHKJGP!GL!GH! GP>`GJIG!@^BEGKJAB!JH!KNB!#)-!!,@M^PBI!VJKN!IBKGJHBBbL!CBCDBELNJ^!JH!GP>`GJIG3!NJL! IBLJEB!T@E!CGEKXEI@C!GHI!NJL!GLLBLLBI!LWJPPL!JH!EBSEMJKCBHK!GHI!TGSJPJKGKJ@H3!IBKGJHBB! VJPP!^@LB!G!KNEBGK3!JT!EBPBGLBI-9F: !!! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!NGL!S@HKJHMBI!K@!^GEKJSJ^GKB!JH!GSKJAJKJBL!G_GJHLK!KNB!#)-! ! 8)UU5=9!!)4>/;:!LKGKBI!KNB!^EJCGEX!EBGL@H!KNB!<%=>?%"*!IBKGJHBBL!VBHK!@H!KNB! NMH_BE!LKEJWB!VGL!DBSGMLB!IBKGJHBBbL!PGVXBE!K@PI!KNBC!BaGSKPX!VNGK!KNBX!HBBIBI!K@! I@- F. !!4DI!GP>+GNJC!4DIMP!+G]G!<GHW@3!&)5!#)0)c>:::7206'!8)c>72093!LKGKBI!KNB! IBKGJHBB!^GLLBI!JHT@ECGKJ@H!K@!@KNBE!IBKGJHBBL!VN@!SGCB!K@!,GC^!(SN@!T@E![GDBGL! AJLJKL- F/ !!!! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!LKGKBI!KNGK!KNB!IBGKN!@T!G!IBKGJHBB!GK!<%=>?%"*!V@MPI!g@^BH! KNB!BXBL!@T!KNB!V@EPI!GHI!EBLMPK!JH!KNB!SP@LMEB!@T!KNB!DGLB-h F; ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! \F

!&&+!\!:;7!:;.1!:13!"GDGNJKN!+=&!+BL^@HLB!/;>4#?>/::13!%6!;.7U/F171>:/! !&&+!\!:;7!:/F:!:13!)&+!/\>*,%>/::1! \0 !&&+!\!:;7!::/\!:\! F: !%6>;.7U;1;;/>:/! F. !:::/;:!)&+!/2><#$>/::1! F/ !:::720!)&+!;:>"4c>/::\! F; !:::/;0!)&+!//>=(Q>/::\! \2

! ./!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!^@LLBLLBI!VBG^@HL!S@HLJLKJH_!@T!KNEBB!EG]@E!DPGIB!^JBSBL! NJIIBH!JH!NJL!NGDBGL!I@SMCBHK!^@MSN- F7 !! ! 8)UU5=9!!+BTBEEJH_!K@!G!"GX!/::\!JHSJIBHK!JH!,GC^!73!c">/1/!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB! VGL!ABEX!NG^^X!GD@MK!JK- F1 !!+BTBEEJH_!K@!KNB!LGCB!JHSJIBHK3!,6>/\0!LKGKBI!IBKGJHBB! NGI!KNB!HBSBLLGEX!^@VBE!GHI!S@HKE@P!8@ABE!KNB!IBKGJHBBL9!K@!JLLMB!GH!@EIBE!T@E!@KNBE! IBKGJHBBL!K@!GKKBC^K!LMJSJIB- F\ !!! ! 8)UU5=9!!4DI!GP>"GYJI!"MNGCCGI3!&)5!#)0&+>:::1116'!8&+>1113!KEGHLTBEEBI93! LKGKBI!KNGK!IBKGJHBB!EMHL!GPP!KNB!@KNBE!IBKGJHBBL!JH!<%=>?%"*-FF !!&H!"GX!/::\3!&+> 111!GPL@!LKGKBI!IMEJH_!G!S@HABELGKJ@H!VJKN!IBKGJHBB3!GH!MHWH@VH!IBKGJHBB!LKGKBI!gOB! NGAB!G!^PGH!K@!S@HKJHMB!KNB!TJ_NK!L@@H3!VJKNJH!KNB!HBaK!T@ME!K@!TJAB!IGXL-!!(JKNBE!KNBX! WJPP!ML!@E!VB!WJPP!KNBC-n!!%NB!MHWH@VH!IBKGJHBB!JHT@ECBI!IBKGJHBB!KNGK!KNB!^PGH!VGL! T@E!IBKGJHBBL!VJPP!H@K!BGK!T@E!KV@!@E!KNEBB!IGXL!GHI!KNBH!^EBKBHI!K@!^GLL!@MK-!!*HSB!.1> /:!IBKGJHBBL!VBEB!JH!KNB!N@L^JKGP3!LJHSB!KNBEB!GEB!@HPX!LJa!"'L!JH!KNB!N@L^JKGP!GHI!@HB! JH!KNB!_MGEI!K@VBE3!KNB!IBKGJHBBL!S@MPI!@ABE^@VBE!KNBC- F2 ! ! 8)UU5=9!!"@NGCBI@M!*MPI!)PGNJ3!&)5!#)0"+>:::F\:6'!8"+>F\:9!LKGKBI! IBKGJHBB!VGL!S@HLKGHKPX!KEXJH_!K@!EBSEMJK!8@KNBE!IBKGJHBBL9!GHI!T@E!KNBC!K@!_JAB!bayat! K@!IBKGJHBB!GL!KNB!BCJE- F0 ! ! 8)UU5=9!!6BKGJHBB!CGX!NGAB!WH@VPBI_B!@T!KNB!eN@DGE!%@VBE!D@CDJH_L!JH!)GMIJ! 4EGDJG!@H!/1!<MHB!.00\3!JH!VNJSN!.0!#)!LBEAJSB!CBCDBEL!VBEB!WJPPBI-! ! 8)UU5=9!!"GDGNJKN!H@KBI!IBKGJHBB!PBTK!)GMIJ!4EGDJG!gGTKBE!KNB!GEEBLK!@T!KNB! Ba^P@LJABL!_GH_-h 2: !!84HGPXLK!5@KBR!!%NB!Ba^P@LJABL!_GH_!JL!GLLBLLBI!K@!DB!G!EBTBEBHSB! K@!JHIJAJIMGPL!JHA@PABI!JH!KNB!eN@DGE!%@VBE!GKKGSW-9! ! c. (S//NF) Detainee’s Conduct:!!6BKGJHBB!JL!GLLBLLBI!K@!DB!G![&?[!KNEBGK!TE@C!G!IBKBHKJ@H! ^BEL^BSKJAB-!!6BKGJHBBbL!@ABEGPP!DBNGAJ@E!NGL!DBBH!H@H>S@C^PJGHK!GHI!N@LKJPB!K@!KNB!_MGEI! T@ESB!GHI!LKGTT-!!6BKGJHBB!SMEEBHKPX!NGL!.;F!+B^@EKL!@T!6JLSJ^PJHGEX!&HTEGSKJ@H!PJLKBI!JH! 6&")!VJKN!KNB!C@LK!EBSBHK!@SSMEEJH_!@H!0!*SK@DBE!/::F3!VNBH!NB!VGL!EB^@EKBI!K@!NGAB! ABEDGPPX!NGEGLLBI!KNB!_MGEI!T@ESB!VNJPB!DBJH_!C@ABI!TE@C!NJL!SBPP!K@!KNB!LN@VBE-!!6BKGJHBB! NGL!.:!+B^@EKL!@T!6JLSJ^PJHGEX!&HTEGSKJ@H!T@E!GLLGMPK!KNB!PGLK!JHSJIBHK!@SSMEEJH_!@H!/\!4^EJP! /::F3!VNBH!NB!L^GK!@H!GHI!L^PGLNBI!G!_MGEI!VJKN!VGKBE!GTKBE!KNB!_MGEI!K@PI!NJC!K@!LK@^! LPGCCJH_!NJL!I@@E-!!*KNBE!JHSJIBHKL!T@E!VNJSN!IBKGJHBB!NGL!DBBH!IJLSJ^PJHBI!JHSPMIB! MHGMKN@EJ]BI!S@CCMHJSGKJ@HL3!^E@A@WJH_!V@EIL!GHI!_BLKMEBL3!KNEBGK3!JHSJKJH_!IJLKMEDGHSB3! TGJPMEB!K@!T@PP@V!JHLKEMSKJ@HL!GHI!SGC^!EMPBL3!IGCG_B!K@!_@ABEHCBHK!^E@^BEKX3!GHI! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! F7

!:::/;0!)&+!;.>6(,>/::1! !:::/1/!)&+!/1>"4c>/::\! F\ !:::/\0!)&+!.2>"4c>/::\! FF !:::111!)&+!/7>"4c>/::\3!:::111!)&+!/\>"4c>/::\! F2 !:::111!)&+!/\>"4c>/::\! F0 !&&+!\!:;7!.::7!:7! 2: !%6>;.7U/F17:>:/! F1

! .;!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101 ! <%=>?%"*>,6+! )#Q<(,%R!!+BS@CCBHIGKJ@H!T@E!,@HKJHMBI!6BKBHKJ@H!#HIBE!6@6!,@HKE@P!8,69!T@E! ?MGHKGHGC@!6BKGJHBB3!&)5!#)0)4>:::/;06'!8)9!!!! ! ^@LLBLLJ@H!@T!S@HKEGDGHI-!!6BKGJHBB!NGI!G!K@KGP!@T!KNJEKX!+B^@EKL!@T!6JLSJ^PJHGEX!&HTEGSKJ@H!JH! /::\3!GHI!T@EKX>KV@!L@!TGE!JH!/::F-!!4PKN@M_N!H@K!GL!CMSN!@T!G!IJEBSK!^NXLJSGP!KNEBGK!K@!KNB! _MGEI!T@ESB!GL!@KNBE!IBKGJHBBL3!NB!SGH!LMCC@H!LM^^@EK!TE@C!@ABE!@HB!NGPT!@T!,GC^!6BPKGbL! IBKGJHBB!^@^MPGKJ@H-!! ! 8. (U) Detainee Intelligence Value Assessment: ! a. (S) Assessment: 6BKGJHBB!JL!GLLBLLBI!K@!DB!@T HIGH!JHKBPPJ_BHSB!AGPMB-!!6BKGJHBBbL! C@LK!EBSBHK!JHKBEE@_GKJ@H!LBLLJ@H!@SSMEEBI!@H!/\!"GESN!/::F-!! ! b. (S//NF) Placement and Access:!!6BKGJHBB!^@LLJDPX!NGL!JHT@ECGKJ@H!@H!KNB!GP>`GJIG! @E_GHJ]GKJ@H!TE@C!G!NJ_N!PBABP!^BEL^BSKJAB3!JHSPMIJH_!EBSEMJKCBHK3!TGSJPJKGKJ@H3!GHI!WH@VPBI_B! @T!@^BEGKJABL-!!6BKGJHBB!^E@DGDPX!NGL!JHT@ECGKJ@H!@H!5?*L!GHI!&LPGCJS!TMHIGCBHKGPJLK! _E@M^L!JH!KNB!P@SGKJ@HL!NB!NGL!AJLJKBI!GHI!PJABI-! ! c. (S//NF) Intelligence Assessment: 6BKGJHBB!PJWBPX!NGL!JHKBPPJ_BHSB!@T!LJ_HJTJSGHK!AGPMB! H@K!XBK!Ba^P@JKBI-!!&K!JL!fMJKB!^E@DGDPB!NB!NGL!G!_EBGK!IBGP!C@EB!WH@VPBI_B!K@!@TTBE!@T!GP> `GJIG!EBSEMJKJH_!GHI!P@_JLKJSGP!KJBL!KNE@M_N!(ME@^B!K@!KNB!#HJKBI!)KGKBL-!!&H!GIIJKJ@H3!NB!CGX! NGAB!XBK!MHWH@VH!BAJIBHSB!EB_GEIJH_!KBEE@EJLK!LM^^@EK!GSKJAJKJBL!K@!KNB!..!)B^KBCDBE!/::.! GKKGSWL!GHI!KNB!eN@DGE!K@VBEL!D@CDJH_-!!6BKGJHBB!CGX!DB!GC@H_LK!KNB!C@LK!JC^@EKGHK! L@MESBL!NBPI!GK!<%=>?%"*-! ! d. (S//NF) Areas of Potential Exploitation: ! ! 4P>`GJIG!@^BEGKJ@HL!KGE_BKJH_!KNB!#)!GHI!#e! ! 4P>`GJIG!LM^^@EK!@^BEGKJ@HL!JH!KNB!#)3!#e3!'NJPJ^^JHBL3!GHI!4T_NGHJLKGH! ! 4P>`GJIG!PBGIBELNJ^! ! #Q$! ! 4DM![GTL!GP>"GMEJKGHJ! ! ?Z>.::.\! ! c">.::.7! ! #e!HBKV@EW!+BSEMJKCBHK!GHI!@KNBE!BaKEBCJLK!GSKJAJKJBL!JH!#e!C@LfMBL! ! 4DM!`GKGIG! ! 4DM![GC]G! ! +JSNGEI!+BJI! ! ZGSSGEJGL!"@MLL@MJ!! ! eNGPJP!6BBW! ! #e>112! ! =GPLB!6@SMCBHKGKJ@H! ! =JHGHSJH_! ! .7!!! ! S E C R E T / / NOFORN / / 20321101


S E C R E T //NOFORN I I 2O32IIOI JTF-GTMO-CDR SUBJECT: Recommendationfor Continued Detention Under DoD Control (CD) for GuantanamoDetainee,ISN US9SA-000239DP(S) o

Extrernist training o Bosnia o Khaldan Camp o Front line training o Advanced training camps

on 3 Decernber2004, 9. (S) EC Status: Detainee'senemycombatantstatuswas reassessed and he remains an enemv combatant. t

v\ft, /r// <

,

t

/ ./// K ,//\

n

x

/////Au/ZN- tV%,2_>a/////

z-

/.-z\

MARK H. BUZBY /(RearAdmiral, US Navy Commanding

-

Definitions for intelligence terms used in the assessmentcan be found in the Joint Military Intelligence College October 2001 guide Intelligence Warning Terminology.

15 S E C R E T // NOFORN I / 2O32IIOI