E d i t o r ’ s
Photo courtesy Thomas Brown
With construction next door, the Nasher’s Tending, (Blue) takes an unscheduled hiatus
Before construction muscled its way into the frame, the view from Tending, (Blue) was heavenly.
1 1 / 1 2
2 0 1 1
Art and science – the theme of this edition – converge in the work of James Turrell, particularly in the meticulous design of his bedazzling “skyspaces.” Site specific, they are fine-tuned by the artist to such a degree that changes in external conditions can erode the science and efface the art. Turrell’s skyspaces are, generally speaking, rooms with a large square or round opening in the roof. Commissioned by Ray Nasher to design one for his Nasher Sculpture Center, Turrell called it Tending, (Blue). As with his other skyspaces, the art is not the structure but the optical effect that occurs when observing the sky overhead as programmed lighting inside the space alters the eye’s perception of the celestial view. The illusion is ethereal and difficult to describe. The Nasher’s website offers this: “The sky seems to take on extraordinary colors and, framed by the knife-edge rim of the aperture, appears extremely dense and flat. At sunrise and sunset, when changes in the coloration of the sky are most rapid and pronounced, the experience can be especially mesmerizing.” The city’s arts community was taken by surprise in June when the Nasher abruptly closed its skyspace to the public due to visual encroachment of the construction next door of a 42-story luxury condominium project. As D Magazine arts writer Peter Simek reported on his blog a few weeks later, the arm of a crane was reaching into the frame of view above Tending, (Blue). While the Nasher considers the closing to be temporary and says all parties are working together toward a solution to the problem, specifics have not been released. Concerns about potential intr usion by the future Museum Tower were raised in D Magazine’s October 2009 edition when another writer alerted readers that the condo tower would be visible through the 9 1/2 x 9 1/2foot aperture of the skyspace. To prove his point, Willard Spiegelman had his colleague Tim Rogers tether a big red balloon and let it rise above the future construction site. Sure enough, as the headline of Spiegelman’s piece
N o t e
Overwhelmed stated, the balloon experiment “burst the Nasher’s bubble.” The condo tower was originally designed to be 18-stories tall, according to Spiegelman’s article, which would not have sullied the skyspace’s pristine sightlines to the heavens. But the project ultimately grew another six stories after Los Angeles-based Johnson Fain was commissioned by Museum Tower’s development team. His interest piqued, Spiegelman’s research determined that the structure actually would rise to 560 feet—potentially blocking out the sky entirely from view through the ceiling portal across North Olive Street. If that turned out to be the case, he reported, the Nasher was contractually obligated to close its skyspace “unless or until” the situation was rectified. Asked to comment for this article, a Nasher spokeswoman said earlier iterations of the tower design, including a 24-story version, were deemed to have no affect on the view from the skyspace. However… “When the plan for the building changed to a 42-story structure,” explained Kristin Gibbons, the sculpture center’s associate director of media relations, “we reviewed the new sightlines, determined that the taller structure would impede the view, and contacted the artist for his advice on possible solutions.” Without offering a tentative date for the reopening, Gibbons said, “James Turrell is developing a new design for Tending, (Blue) that will restrict the Museum Tower from the visitor’s field of vision, leaving an unobstructed view of the sky. Further steps will be determined when the artist’s plans are finalized. The development team at Museum Tower have recognized their responsibility in this matter, and are committed to working with the Nasher to realize the artist’s new design.” Meanwhile, construction continues apace on Museum Tower, its opening scheduled for late next year. S t e p h e n
S h a r p e ,
H o n .
t e x a s
T S A
a r c h i t e c t
Built around the theme of “Arts & Science,” the November/December 2011 edition of Texas Architect profiles the Botanical Research Institute...