Page 1


ENERGY 2010 Volume 34 – March 2010

Emery County

You know that Joy Mining Machinery is an industry leader. But dig deeper and see what you find. Eight out of ten continuous miners working in U.S. mines today are JOY machines.* Nine out of ten longwall shearers operating in the U.S. are JOY machines.** In the U.S. and around the world, more coal producers use high-performing JOY equipment. Joy has more than 90 years of experience as a global leader in the development, manufacture, distribution and service of underground mining machinery. And the way we lead is by innovation, dating all the way back to 1919.

* Joy database ** Coal Age Magazine U.S. Longwall Census 2008

Joy Mining Machinery, Wellington, 1275 West Ridge Road, Wellington, UT 84542, 435-637-6161

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 3

“We’re serious about



When the trucks or equipment that move your business fail and you are losing money every minute they’re down, you need to call a professional, fair, and reliable team who’s serious about diesel. Whether you’re hauling coal from the mines, water from the rigs, freight from state to state or operating equipment, Landon’s Diesel Service will keep your business running at full speed. 24 Hours a day, 7 days a week. Our Technicians are armed with Caterpillar and Cummins Warranty and Engine Certifications, Years of experience, and all the tools for your job. From scheduled service to engine overhaul, any make or model, we’re the team that will keep your business running smoothly.

Diese Service Diesel 435-613-1221

24 Hour Towing, Roadside 540 SOUTH 300 WEST PRICE, UTAH Assistance and Service (435).613.1221 Serving all of Eastern Utah

4 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

ENERGY 2010 For over three decades the Sun Advocate and Emery County Progress have been bringing Eastern Utah our energy guide each winter or spring. The publication has always been for those in our community who provide jobs in the most dynamic industry in the world, energy. It has been for the companies to bring information to the public, for the miners to spread the news about their profession and for the jobbers to show off their part in the coal and gas industry. Most of all, this special is about our readers, who want to know more about the energy industry, its technology, the issues facing it and what its future is. There are many challenges facing the energy industry today. Times are changing and the sure thing of coal being king seems to be waning as people start to look to alternative sources of power for homes and businesses. But coal still provides around 50 percent of the electricity used in the United States. In Utah, it provides over 80 percent. This publication contains articles about coal, its production and what may be happening with it, as well as information about associated industries

and gas production, which has also become a big part of our community’s network of businesses. There are also some stories concerning alternative energy sources that in some cases are pertinent or will be pertinent to the local area. While being rich in coal, this area also has huge amounts of coal bed methane, natural gas and tar sands, which are just in their infancy when it comes to development. The area also has a lot of renewable energy capacity as well. In some parts of the area, the wind blows as much as it does in many other places where turbines churn out power for grids, suppling thousands of homes. The area also has nearly 300 sunny days a year, which could mean it is a good place to generate solar power as well. But for now, the coal-fired power plants are the backbone of our power generation and that is here to stay for some time. We make no pretension that this publication covers every aspect of energy or energy development that is going on in our area, but we have tried to give a snapshot of what is up and what could go on in the future. We truly appreciate the individuals in our area that agreed to be interviewed for this special and those that contributed to it. Without their help we just couldn’t produce this one of a kind guide every year. This is also the second year our annual Carbon and Emery Energy Guide is housed in a slick cover publication. We are very proud of the way this has turned out and look forward to your comments about it. Richard Shaw, publisher Sun Advocate Emery County Progress


“24 hours a day, 7 days a week”


21 Years of Mass Excavation Experience • Earth Moving • Road Grading • Underground Water & Sewer • Irrigation Installation • Snow Removal • Gas and Oil Well Sites • Emergency and Reserve Ponds • Gas Well Gathering • Building Footings • Site Preparation

• Heavy Equipment Transport • Heavy Equipment Retrieval Systems • Poly Fusion Insurance:

• Workers Compensation • General Liability


• Contractor #100 • Pilot Car • Business License: Utah & Colorado • Certified Blasting

Fax 435-637-5696 • PO Box 50, Wellington, Utah 84542

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 5

ABOUT THE COVER The cover of this publication was painted by Thomas Williams of Helper. Williams and his partner, David Johnsen, have been creating period paintings about the coal industry for years. This painting was done as a collage, depicting coal town life as it was before the middle of the 20th century. The pair presently own the Boxcar Gallery in Helper, but have been featured at shows and galleries throughout the United States. Williams was born in West Virginia to a coal mining family. He eventually migrated to the mines of Eastern Utah where he worked as a miner for some years, until an injury ended that career. It was during his rehabilitation that Williams and others recognized his artistic ability. Soon he was painting what was nearest and dearest to his heart, the coal mining industry, with its storied past, its challenges and its people. Two years ago, Williams was commissioned to produce art for the new public safety building in Park City, where the mining history along with the ski and tourism industry go hand in hand. He produced a series of paintings that currently hang in the foyer and in other places in the building, bringing that legacy to life for all who visit. Over the years both artists’ period and industrial paintings have brought the story of the blue collar worker to a public that knows little about where the energy used in their homes and businesses comes from. Williams and Johnsen have produced a number of paintings for companies connected to the coal and power generation industry. “We hope to continue to do that, and hope that along with more work for the gas and oil industry as well,” Williams said.

Tom Williams, once a coal miner, now uses his experience to create works of art about the industry.

booth fire protection, inc.

Serving Carbon & EmeryArea for 20 Years!

I n d u s t r i a l Commercial Residential

Restaurant Systems Addressable and Conventional Fire Alarm Systems Specializing in Underground and Surface Mine Systems

781 W. 14600 South Bluffdale, UT 84065 Phone (801) 748-0696


164 South Carbon Ave. Price, Utah 84501 Phone (435) 637-3506 Fax (435) 637-3505

State Licensed and Fully Insured


6 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Directory of Advertisers * Banasky Insurance .................. 12 Badlands .................................. 45 Bill Barrett Corporation ........... 19 BookCliff Sales......................... 31 Booth Fire Protection ................. 5 Brady Mining .................... 48, 49 Bridge Realty/ Brenda Quick.... 66 Bruno Electric/ Bodec Inc......... 18 Bucyrus .................................. 16 Canyon Fuel ............................ 20 Carbon Chiropractic ................ 60 Carbon Co. Commissioners ...... 21 Carbon County Events Center . 66 Castle Country Oil................... 51 Castle Country Orthopaedics ... 17 Castleview Occupational Med .... 6 CEU Museum .......................... 19 CEU Mining ........................... 54 Chute Supply ............................ 7 Cloyd’s Floor Store .................. 63


Consol Energy ......................... 32 Desert Mountain ..................... 46 Dinosaur Tire .......................... 19 Dyno Nobel ............................. 41 Electrical Contractors Inc. ........ 31 Emery Co. Commissioners ...... 29 Emery Telcom.......................... 37 Fairmont Supply ..................... 11 Filter Service and Testing ......... 15 Golden West Industries ............ 24 Guymon’s ............................... 22 Hydraulic Repair...................... 30 Industrial Electric .................... 28 Johansen & Tuttle.................... 63 JBR Environmental .................. 29 Jones & Demille ....................... 36 Joy Mining ............................... 2 Kaman Industries .................... 22 Kenworth Sales .......................... 8 Landon’s Diesel.......................... 3


* Longwall Associates ................ 14 Mac’s Mining ............................ 8 MB Financial ........................... 42 MHS Industrial Maintenance .. 12 Mine Systems .......................... 62 Morgantown ........................... 39 Nelco ....................................... 47 Nielson Construction........ 25, 26, ........................................43 & 68 Now Cap Respiratory .............. 38 Peterson Chemical.................... 18 Phillips Machine ...................... 43 Pierce Oil Company ................. 24 Price City ................................. 27 Price Insurance .......................... 9 Questar ................................... 39 Rocky Mountain Power ........... 58 Savage ..................................... 44 Scamp Excavation ..................... 4 SGS North America, Inc. ......... 59

WORK POINT Occupational Medicine

a service of Castleview Hospital

Our goal is to improve the working relationship between health care providers and the industrial workforce in Carbon and Emery Counties. Services Include: Pre-employment physicals Respiratory Fit tests DOT Physical Audiograms Drug screens DOT and non-DOT Work related injuries Drug alcohol tests Wellness programs/Health Pulmonary Function tests Fairs 590 East 100 North Suite 9 Price Utah 84501 435-637-1697 Emery Medical Center 90 West Main, Castle Dale, Utah 84513 435-381-2305 Hours 8 to 5 Monday through Friday

Standard Laboratories.............. 51 Stilson and Sons Construction.. 23 Sun Advocate/ Emery Co. Progress ...50 and 55 Supreme Muffler ..................... 52 Tavaputs Ranch ....................... 26 Tony Basso GM ....................... 53 Tram Electric ........................... 34 Tram Electric ........................... 35 UA Local 140 Pipefitters .......... 27 United Mine Workers of America............................ 57 University of Utah Miners Hospital ...................... 9 University of Utah Mining Department............. 33 Utah Railway .......................... 13 Waste Logistics ........................ 67

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 7

Modern miners jobs good, here to stay By Richard Shaw As jobs go in Utah, coal mining, based on education and training, is one of the highest paid jobs a person can have. In the state as a whole it is a relatively small proportion of people who do that kind of work, but in Carbon and Emery counties the profession makes up a large amount of the workforce. Coal mining affects Sevier County’s workforce strongly as well. While a high income job, it is also a dangerous one. In the last 25 years that has been proven in such mines as Wilberg, Willow Creek and Crandall Canyon, along with many mishaps with fewer casualties in various other mines and mining facilities. Contrary to local popular belief, Utah is not one of the largest

coal producing states, although it does rank 14th in the United States overall. It does, however, produce more coal than it uses and a great deal is shipped outside the Beehive State’s boundaries. The state only internally uses about twothirds of what it produces each year. In 2008, the largest consumers of Utah coal were California, Nevada and Alabama. Most of the coal produced in the state is used for generating electricity – a great deal of that power is generated within the state’s boundaries. Between some hydroelectric power that the state consumes and the coal-burning, Utah has some of the lowest cost consumer power in the country. The coal produced from the three counties includes 47.5 percent (Continued on page 10)

2010 Energy Edition Published by the Sun Advocate and Emery County Progress

Rick Shaw ............................................................. Publisher Kevin Scannell ........................................................... Writer Jenni Fasselin ............................................................... Sales Cherie Murdoch .......................................................... Sales DeAnna Duncan ......................................................... Sales Lynna Tweddell............................................................ Sales Christa Kaminski ......................................................... Sales

Sun Advocate 845 East Main, Price, Utah 435-637-0732 435-637-2716 Fax

The days of coal miners working up against the face of a coal seam by hand are largely gone. Today most operations are very automated.

Quality Service All Year-Round! - Full line of Farm & Ranch Pressurized Irrigation Parts - Industrial & Construction Supply - Drainage Products - Safety Supply

Boyd & Brink would like to thank the Carbon and Emery Counties for their support over the past 16 years. 435-653-2388 Fax 435-653-2728

8 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Carbon and Emery are unique partners Carbon and Emery counties share a common history, although the general focus of the two counties has differed slightly at times during the years. Energy related industries have played a key role in the initial and continued economic development in the local Castle Valley region. The original boundaries established for Emery County encompassed the majority of Castle Valley, including the Carbon area. But in 1894, the Utah Territorial Legislature created Carbon County from a portion of Emery. Over the years the economic focus of Carbon County shifted to coal, the railroad and industrial development. After the split of the two counties, Emery spent many years relying more on agricultural endeavors. Originally Mormon settlements were established along

the Price River in the late 1870s. Routes into the region included offshoots of the Old Spanish Trail and over Soldier Summit. Farming and ranching became early economic activities in the Castle Valley region. Cowboys and outlaws filled several colorful chapters in Carbon County’s history, with the likes of Butch Cassidy and “Gunplay” Maxwell roaming the local area. During the early 1880s, the Denver & Rio Grande Western Railroad decided to establish a transportation route from the Colorado city to the Salt Lake Valley. At this point the Nine Mile Canyon freight road from Price to the Uinta Basin became an important transportation link in Carbon’s chain of development. Built by Buffalo soldiers, the road between Myton and Price became (Continued on page 9)

Parts for Semi Trucks Fleetguard Filters for all your needs.

Repairing & Rebuilding all types of Mining Equipment, and new Steel Fabrication. Underground Diesel Exhaust Systems and Parts. 687-2244 HUNTINGTON, UTAH

Branch Manager Craig Dastrup Parts Brent Hanson & Zeph Tucker Outside Sales Ed Walls

Where a hand shake is still the heart of the deal.


320 W. 600 So., Price, Utah 84501 Office: (435) 637-3440 (800) 747-2807 Fax: (435) 637-3438

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 9

Carbon and Emery are unique partners: (Continued from page 9) a lifeline for the Uintah Basin from railroad they would never have. The railroads efforts served as an impetus in the discovery of the vast coal lands of Carbon County and provided a foundation for opening the natural resource to production. Therefore coal mining rapidly became the major catalyst for economic development in Carbon County. Companies built and ran coal camps in Carbon County, importing southern and eastern Europeans, as well as Japanese laborers, to work in the mines and on railroad gangs. The town of Helper, which is well known for its involvement in the coal mining industry of years past, got its name from being the station where locomotives were utilized to “help” loaded freight trains climb the canyon grades and reach Solider Summit. Helper became

known as the town of “57 varieties” because of the city’s ethnic diversity. Between the coal mining and the railroad, and the influx of immigrants from all over Europe and some parts of Asia, the area developed a more cosmopolitan atmosphere than most other rural areas of the state of Utah, whose immigrants came largely from northern Europe. Over the years the development of electrical generating facilities has changed the entire area. Large electric plants built in Huntington Canyon and near Castle Dale in the 1970s provided the impetus for huge mines to be developed and the output of coal from those and other mines in Emery County far surpassed the coal output in Carbon County in some of those years. Today coal continues to be a large part of both counties livelihood, yet an uncertain one as the

world of energy changes. Environmental challenges and new forms of energy generation are beginning

to affect the use of coal, but it still is the main fuel used to generate power in the state of Utah.

The stacks at the Huntington Canyon Power plant denote the dual partnership that Carbon and Emery counties have in energy projects and the jobs they provide across county lines.

For all kinds of energy related insurance protection.

Price Insurance Agency Roy Nikas, CIC

Visit us at our new location 76 West Main, Price 637-3351 1-800-464-3351

10 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Modern miners jobs good, here to stay: (Continued from page 7) from Carbon, 23.9 percent from Emery and 28.6 percent from Sevier. However, the largest producing mine is in Sevier County (Sufco) from which that entire percentage is derived. However in the last 100 years, the dual counties of Carbon and Emery have produced the vast majority of coal in the state. Based on statistics from the Utah Department of Workforce Services, from the last quarter of 2008 through the third quarter of 2009 coal mining accounted for 1997 jobs. More than three-quarters of those jobs were in the eastern Utah counties. These jobs impact the two county area dramatically. While in the state overall coal mining makes up less than one half a percent of the jobs eastern Utah between 12 13 percent of the jobs in Carbon and Emery are coal mining positions, and that is only counting direct employment and not ancillary jobs that exist because of the mining activity. Interestingly, over the past de-

cade coal mining jobs have not fluctuated based on other sectors of the economy very much. In fact as the latest recession has set in, coal mining employment has actually increased. That increase may even be larger as the Lila Canyon Mine is expected to open sometime in the next year. Coal mining wages are high compared to many other sectors. In Emery they are 85 percent higher than other industries in the county and in Carbon the rate is 112 percent. The average coal miner in Carbon and Emery counties earns $5,804 per month, based on the year from the last quarter of 2008 through the third quarter of 2009. While all this seems positive, the growth of the number of jobs, while increasing, has not grown as much as the standard employment within the state in the first years of the 21st century. Some say coal mining is on its way out of the realm of occupations, because of the changes that will be

taking place in energy consumption as more and more people turn toward so called renewable sources of power. However, coal still remains the most stable and reliable power source (along

with nuclear and gas buring plants) that exist to provide electric power. It appears these jobs will exist for a very long time, even if that transition does take place.

Coal mining jobs provide jobs for power plant workers, other jobs with good incomes.

SGS serves electricity, coal producers in Castle Valley

A SGS employee analyzes coal samples. SGS also provides inspection, sampling, testing and analytical services to the the mining industry.

SGS Minerals Services has served the coal mining and electrical generation industries in Castle Valley for more than 30 years. SGS, a major international inspection, testing and consulting firm, acquired Commercial Testing & Engineering Company in 1984. CT&E started in the midwestern United States in 1908 and became a leader in formulating comprehensive testing services to the power industry for nearly 100 years. CT&E played a major role in setting the analytical pace in the coalfields east of the Mississippi River, then expanded to establish service concepts for the mines and power generating stations. SGS provides inspection, sampling, testing and analytical services to the mining, generation and energy companies in Carbon and Emery counties.

The company operates the only full-service environmental laboratory in Castle Valley. The Huntington lab has maintained state NELAC certification for water and A2LA accreditation for coal analysis for many years. Castle Valley’s coal and power companies maintain markets by reducing costs and producing dependable products. SGS Minerals joins the local industries’ efforts by offering technically advanced laboratory services and support. The Carbon-Emery area is home to a hard-working labor force and a business community supplying the state, the nation and countries across the globe with quality products, explained the testing company. SGS plans to continue to provide cost-effective services to local governments and industry.

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 11

Here it’s all about underground mining Underground or deep mining methods account for around 40 percent of total coal production in the United States today. Although the majority of underground mines are less than 1,000 feet deep, several reach depths of about 2,000 feet. U.S. underground coal production facilities essentially fall into three basic categories: • Drift mine. This is a mine that has a horizontal entry to a coalbed seam in a hillside. • Slope mine. Entry to this kind of mine is inclined from the surface to the coalbed. • Shaft mine. This kind of a mine is equipped with elevators, which provides vertical access to a coalbed generally deeper than one reached by a slope mine. Four major processes are commonly used in mining underground coal in the United States: longwall, continuous, conventional and shortwall, with continuous and conventional being room-and-pillar systems. •Longwall mining. Mining via

a longwall has helped revolutionize underground coal production operations in the past 30 years. Long walls now produce about 20 percent of the coal taken out of mines in the United States. In fact, longwall tonnage was slightly higher than continuous mining tonnage for the first time in history in 1994, and the trend has held true since then. A longwall is one giagantic machine that can cover up to 600 feet of a coal seam. The unit basically holds up the ceiling (the overburden) while it mines the coal and then moves and lets the roof fail behind it. The longwall consists of a rotating drum, which is dragged mechanically backand-forth across a wide coal seam. The loosened coal falls onto a long conveyor that removes it from the mine and onto waiting transportation or into large stock piles. Longwalls have continued to advance with technology since their introduction three decades ago. Newer versions of the longwall employ sen(Continued on page 12)


A continuous miner in operation.

Value that continues beyond the sale. Mining Safety Electrical Industrial Rubber General Industrial Pipe, Valves & Fittings Bearings & Power Transmission Material Handling & Processing

MATERIALS MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS Storeroom Management Vending Distribution Programs Vendor Managed Inventory On-Line Ordering Recorded Savings Value Program Warranty Tool Replacement Service

Tools of the trade require more than juice These large receiving tanks hold compressed air that power various tools, instrumentation, valves, and other types of equipment that are used in the daily operation and maintenance of Rocky Mountain Power’s Hunter power plant near Castle Dale.

Elko, NV Delta, CO Gillette, WY Green River, WY Price, UT

Ph: Ph: Ph: Ph: Ph:

775.738.6205 970.874.5011 800.365.4029 866.868.5765 800.332.6934

27 locations throughout the United States

12 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Here it’s all about underground mining: (Continued from page 11) sors to detect how much coal remains in the seam being mined, as well as robotic controls to enhance efficiency. In general, longwalls can increase the average coal recoverability rate to as much as 80 percent, and they have had an important impact in helping to increase underground coal mine productivity. Largely because of longwalls, productivity in underground mines has increased dramatically since their introduction. • Continuous mining. This process still accounts for a significant amount of coal removed from deep mines. The production process utilizes a specialized cutting machine that mechanizes the extraction procedure: the continuous miner. The continuous mining machine tears the coal from a seam in the mine and automatically removes it from the area by conveyor. Remote-controlled continuous miners allow an operator to direct the machine from a distance, increasing safety. Although still utilized in stand-alone production operations,

continuous miners are increasingly employed for main mine entry and longwall panel development. Some underground coal facilities are hybrid operations, utilizing both longwall and continuous mining methods for coal production. When longwalls are not used, underground fossil fuel can be mined by the room-and-pillar system. Mining crews excavate a series of rooms into the coalbed and leave pillars or columns of coal to help support the mine roof. In this type of mining often nearly 40 percent of the coal must be left in the mine to support the roof. Long steel expansion bolts inserted into holes bored into the roof are also used for support. When production reaches the end of a “panel” the direction of operations is usually reversed, with miners recovering as much coal as possible from the pillars as the roof is allowed to systematically collapse. • Conventional mining. The conventional coal production process is one of the oldest methods of mining

the fossil fuel, although the process is not as commonly used today as earlier in the 20th century. Conventional mining consists of a series of operations that begins with cutting the bed so the coal will break easily when blasted with explosives. Once the coal is blasted, the pieces are removed from the working sites. Conventional mining can be a practical and economical method in situations where seams are thin or the geology prevents the use of a long wall system or continuous mining machine. • Shortwall mining. Shortwall mining currently accounts for less

than one percent of annual deep mine production. It involves the use of a continuous mining machine and accompanying movable roof supports. The continuous miner shears coal panels 150-200 feet wide and sometimes more than half-a-mile long. Once the shearing is done, coal is removed from underground mines by two basic methods: shuttle cars, which take coal to a central loading area in the mine and/or belt conveyors, which remove coal to the surface. In recent years, both the mobility and capacity of conveyor system has increased, helping to improve the efficiency of coal removal.

Support the businesses that are featured in this special

James Banasky


“Serving Utah since 1955” Specializing Trucking Insurance Commercial General Liability Workers Compensation Insurance Surety Bonds, Health and Life Insurance

1-800-371-7803 Fax: 435-637-7811

Mobile Sandblasting • Industrial Door Service • Commercial • Gas • Oil Fields • Mine • General Building • Maintenance

Mike Prichard Owner

Residential & Commercial Industrial Repair

718 North 200 East Price, UT 84501 (435) 637-2262 (435) 650-1823

Utah Railway Co.

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 13







Utah Railway Company 1221 South Colorado Ave Provo, UT 84606 801-356-9163

A Genesee & Wyoming Company

Safety is our number-one priority at GWI every day. Since our crews are on and off equipment much more frequently in short line railroading and industrial switching, we’re proud that our safety record rivals the Class I railroads. Utah Railway Company operates freight service on owned track from Mohrland to Helper Terminal, UT (45 miles). URC’s core business is the movement of coal. Our railroad has been an integral part of Utah’s coal industry, having transported more than 140 million tons of coal in its history. Today URC transports some 60,000 carloads of coal each year for movement to power plants and industrial customers. URC has connections with BNSF and UP at Provo and Utah Railway Junction, as well as at Grand Junction, Colorado. We directly serve over 50 shippers of various sizes with volumes ranging from a single car to 100-car unit trains of commodity. Our Rail Link employees loaded 360 million tons of Powder River Basin coal last year -- approximately 35% of all coal burned in America. Rail Link is the only contractor with a service product accepted by both Class I railroads in the Basin. Customer service provided by highly skilled and dedicated employees has been the cornerstone of Utah Railway’s success over the years. We take pride in our can-do attitude toward exceeding our customers’ expectations and attracting new customers to the railroad.

14 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010


for the long haul

The cornerstone of any longwall mine is custom engineered and manufactured equipment designed to increase production and work in conjunction with each mines' unique and specific conditions. Longwall Associates is the only OEM longwall conveyor manufacturer specializing exclusively in custom longwall conveyor systems. Since the company's inception Longwall Associates has built a remarkable reputation engineering and handcrafting custom equipment for mines across the USA, China, Mexico and Australia. Whether integrating revolutionary safety features, extending equipment life, maximizing production while simultaneously reducing operating costs, or effectively mining low seam or high seam coal, the experts at Longwall Associates deliver custom high performance, consistent equipment to suit your precise requirements every time. Customizing equipment is just one way Longwall Associates delivers solutions for the long haul, to you. Call us today to see why more top producing mines trust Longwall Associates to supply their equipment.

Tel: 276.646.2004 USA - China - Mexico - Australia Web:

©2010 Longwall Associates Incorporated

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 15

Mining department continues quality training The mining department at the College of Eastern Utah continues to provide quality training throughout the state of Utah with over 130 companies a year participating in the courses. The Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) has awarded the state of Utah a grant to help subsidize training for Utah’s miners. The CEU mining department is the state agency program responsible for miners’ health and safety training courses and programs designated to reduce mining accidents, injuries, and illnesses. CEU continues to support the program and recognizes its important roll to the community, industry and the state of Utah. Despite the economic slowdown, the mining department continues to be a viable program at the College of Eastern Utah. The department trained over 1,860 stu-

dents accumulating about 3,900 hours in the classroom during the last grant year. Several types of mining operations such as coal, gold, copper, uranium and sand/ gravel are among the list of businesses that utilized this program. Over 130 participating companies, including businesses from outside the state, were trained and indicated they will be recurring customers. This year’s workload is expected to be about the same. The instructors teach on campus, at the energy training center, and on site. They traveled throughout the state as far north as Weber County and as far south as Wayne County. An ongoing alliance with the Custom Fit Training program helps Utah businesses with limited budgets. Custom Fit Training is available for qualifying businesses needing specialized or upgrade (Continued on page 17)

Miners are trained at a CEU mining department course.

Filter Service & Testing Corporation “Specialists in Clean Air Filtration” * New State-of-the-Art Manufacturing & Dry Cleaning Equipment for all your filtration requirements * Diesel Exhaust Filters for Underground Mining - MSHA Tested - Compliant with 30CFR, Sections 72.500-72.502 * Manufacture, Rebuild & Clean Industrial Filters * Distribution for High Performance Diesel Oxidation Catalysts, Ceramic Filter, Passive & Active Visit our website at

2100 E. 5000 S. Ridge Rd. PO Box 1466 435-637-3567

16 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010


on the Surface and Underground

Bucyrus works with you to boost your productivity. That’s our way of doing business. You would not expect anything less from Bucyrus. The news is we now rely on the accumulated experience of 300 years in the design and manufacturing of high productivity equipment for surface and underground mining. With Bucyrus you can rely on a global network of world-class service which will support you in increasing your productivity – for the long run. This is how we have been doing business for a long time. Nothing has changed. It is just getting better.

Reliability at work

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 17

Mining department continues quality training: (Continued from page 15) training such as 30 CFR Parts 46 and 48 annual refresher (surface and underground), mine rescue, electrical re-certification, surface and underground mine foreman and fireboss preparation; special emphasis safety training which includes classes in roof, back and ground control, powered haulage, machinery safety, electrical safety, handling materials, slip and fall of persons, fall of rib, side or highwall, and handtools; MSHA approved instructor training, supervisory/management training; and 30 CFR Parts 46 and 48 entry level new miner training (surface and underground). Courses can be customized to fit students’ needs, helping with the expansion and revitalization of the company. This partnership allows the Mining Department to continue to offer low-cost, qual-

ity training, when, how, and where the businesses want it. Three dedicated full-time instructors, in conjunction with adjunct instructors and staff, deliver training to operators, miners, prospective miners, contractors, and others working on mine property. Instructors Dale Evans (Dept. Chairman), Randy Mabbutt and Steve Radmall are seasoned miners training miners with decades of experience that they share enthusiastically with their students. Their humor and stories from personal experiences, along with wellequipped classrooms and up-todate teaching materials, captures student’s attention and provides a positive, enjoyable learning experience. Dedicated part-time staff contributes to the success that the mining department enjoys. Office coordinator, Trudy Sherman, pro-

Castle Country

Orthopaedics & Sports Medicine Fellowship trained in Arthroscopy and Sports Medicine

• General Orthopaedics • Sports Medicine • Arthroscopy • Trauma and Fractures • Total Joint Replacement • Carpal Tunnel Syndrome • Minimally Invasive Orthopaedic Surgery For Appointments Call:


377 N Fairgrounds Rd • Price

Ben Mead learns at a training station using an interactive module.

vides office support to the department chairman, instructors, and students. Thanks to great technical support from their part-time media and technical support specialist, Jesse Jensen, the staff and students have state-of-the-art computer labs equipped with excellent interactive, competency-based training where students can learn at their own pace. The modern classrooms and teaching aids run with little interruption due to Jesse’s expertise. Working with other groups helps keep training at the highest standards. The mining department is an active member of the Rocky Mountain Mine Rescue Association and each year hosts the annual coal mine rescue contest. This will be the 34th year it has been held, showing the long-term commitment they have toward mine rescue training. Steve Radmall is the lead instructor who has traveled to several mine sites to train teams on-site and in their underground environment. During the winter months, he trains teams indoors at the energy training facility north of Helper. The old warehouse at the center is marked off with scaled-down entries and pillars, and mine rescue teams are given a recue problem to practice and hone their skills for contests and actual emergency situations in a heated or air condi-

tioned environment. Teams have access to a modern well-equipped mine rescue room for apparatus preparation, care and maintenance. The department continues to work with the Utah Labor Commission and enjoys the association. They work hard together to ensure that the miner certification program is done at the highest standards and meets the needs of the mining industry. The close association with MSHA’s educational fields service specialists is critical to the program’s success. The state’s grant program operates under their guidelines to ensure the safety and health training is done to the utmost standards. They host workshops throughout the year held by the Miner’s Hospital and many other groups interested in educating Utah miners. The CEU Mining Department is a part of the Division of Workforce Education which is under the direction of Miles Nielson, Associate Vice President. Information is available by contacting the Mining Department at the College of Eastern Utah by calling 435-472-4736 or 472-4738 or e-mailing or For Custom Fit Training information Utah businesses may call Bill Vande Sluis (435) 613-5460 or e-mail:

18 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Local coal production down from 2008 totals By Richard Shaw The economy has taken its toll on Utah coal production in the last year and new figures support the fact that the decline could go deeper in 2010 as well. The view is also different for the three counties that produce any measurable amount of coal in the state. Initial figures show that production in 2009 for Carbon County was 9,365 thousand short tons. This compares to 11,533 thousand short tons in 2008. The most the county has ever produced since records was kept passed out of mines in 2007 when 11,811 thousand short tons were produced. For Emery County the drop was much less. In 2009 figures show that the county produced 5,704 thousand short tons, which recording 5,796 in 2008. Emery’s coal production has been going

down for years since it hit its height in 1994 when the county turned out 17,334 thousand short tons. Sevier County production also fell between 2008 and 2009. In 2008 the Sufco Mine (the only mine in Sevier) produced 6,946 thousand short tons while in 2009 that dropped to 6748. The most the county ever produced was 7,908 in 2006. The total production for Utah in 2009 was 21,717 thousand short tons. Nationally that qualifies Utah as the 14th biggest coal producer in the United States. Wyoming continues to be the largest producer of coal in the country with 464,143 thousand short tons (2008 figures). While Utah has all underground mines (nine of them) the cowboy state has only one, but instead has 19 sur(Continued on page 20)

At times this past year Wildcat Loadout in along Consumers Road stood idle as did some other coal facilities in the area this year. The total tonnage produced was down.

Professional Electrical Engineering Services Since 1996 Electrical Construction Since 2007 Electrical Power System Design – Oil & Gas, Mining, Other Planning Feasibility Studies and Cost Estimates Substation Design, Construction, Repair and Preventive Maintenance Transmission / Distribution Design and Construction Electrical Trouble Shooting and Repairs Commercial Electrical Construction PLC/HMI Installation and Programming Design and Installation of Control/Automation systems Surface/Underground Electricians for Mining Applications


Now Providing Underground/Surface Electrical Inspections for MSHA Compliance

Open to the Public since 1967

We Specialize in Turn-Key Electrical Engineering Design and Electrical Construction Services Currently Hiring Journeyman and MSHA Certified Electricians (435) 613-0700 90 East 1300 South Price, Utah

373 South 100 West Price, UT 84501 435-637-3603 | 1-800-378-3603

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 19

Since 1947 Tires are our business, Service is our name.

Serving the Mining Industry for 63 years with Quality Service, Integrity and Experience

Pollution control continues to play role Coal-fired power plants, like the one above, employ pollution control systems, as mandated by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). As coal’s role in the energy industry evolves, so will coal-related pollution control systems.

Providing good jobs to keep America self-reliant for her natural gas needs.

1099 Eighteenth Street, Suite 2300 303.293.9100

Denver, Colorado 80202


Featuring a full line of the best tire systems available:

200 East Main Street, Price 637-2480 • 1-800-491-2480

20 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Local coal production down from record 2008: (Continued from page 18) face mines, one of them one of the largest in the world. Other states that are in the 13 places ahead of Utah in terms of production include West Virginia (second), Montana (fifth), Colorado (ninth) and New Mexico (12th). The coal produced in Utah is transported to users in three different ways; truck, rail and conveyer. In 2008 14,426 thousand short tons were transported by rail, 7,335 thousand short tons by truck and 3,097 thousand short tons by conveyer. At the present time no coal from Utah is being shipped on water by any means. Utah coal that is produced is used for a number of purposes with the largest amount of coal being consumed by electrical generation (in 2008 21,648 thousand short tons). Industrial use consumes 3,227 thousand short

tons and residential and commercial consumers use nine thousand short tons. While coal is for all purpose produced only in three counties, the largest recoverable reserves of coal lie in Kane County where it is estimated 8,025.5 million short tons of coal lay under the ground. This coal has not been developed and it appears that it will not be because 99 percent of it lies within the boundaries of the Escalante Staircase National Monument. Recoverable reserves in Eastern Utah include 1,007.1 million short tons in Emery County, 988.6 million short tons in Carbon and 889.9 million short tons in Sevier County. These coal deposits lay in a number of coal fields on which mineral rights are divided largely in favor of the federal government (the U.S. government owns nearly 80 of the land in Eastern Utah).

The mineral rights land ownership on the Wasatch Plateau is divided 75 percent federal, 24 percent by the state and one percent private. In Salina Canyon land above reserves takes a 68/32 federal to state split. In Emery private land has a large impact by Utah standards with land over 9 percent of the reserves, while the state has 23 percent and the feds retain 68 percent. The land that has the least amount of federal ownership is the Bookcliffs, where they own 61 percent and the state has 30 percent. The rest is private land.

The gross money that coal brings into Utah depends year to year on the price of the black rock. In 2008 the average price per short ton was $27.68. Preliminary estimates are that in 2009 the price rose to around $29. Consequently in 2008 coal produced in the state brought in $672 million. Estimates are that in 2009 the coals produced value was $629.8 million. (The source for this article was the Utah Geological Survey).

Canyon Fuel Company

Canyon Fuel Company, LLC 225 North 5th Street Suite 900 Grand Junction, CO 81501

Phone 970-263-5130 Fax 970-263-5161

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 21

Questar’s new gas plant named for dinosaur Questar Transportation Services (QTSC), a subsidiary of Salt Lake City-based Questar Pipeline (QPC), has been operating a new natural gas-processing plant near Price since last summer. Named in honor of a locally discovered dinosaur, the Price Raptor Processing Plant was built adjacent to QPC’s existing main line 104, an interstate pipeline north of Price. The plant has a processing capacity of up to 120 million cubic feet per day of natural gas. It was designed to help QPC meet hydrocarbon dewpoint tariff requirements for volumes delivered via main line 104 to Kern River Pipeline’s receipt point near Goshen. According to Jack Ahern, the QPC engineer who oversaw construction of the plant, the Raptor plant operates “basically, like a very complex refrigerator.” Using propane as a refrigerant, he ex-

plained, the plant chills gas from main line 104 to as low as minus30 degrees Fahrenheit. The lower temperature causes the heavier hydrocarbons in the gas stream, such as propane, butane and ethane, to condense. In their liquid state, these heavier hydrocarbons can be “stripped” (or removed) from the gas stream, transferred to a stabilizing system, and then stored in pressurized tanks. The remaining “residue” gas stream, with its hydrocarbon dewpoint now signifi-

cantly reduced, is blended with richer, unprocessed gas to produce a combined stream meeting the hydrocarbon dewpoint required by Kern River at the Goshen Tap. Prior to constructing the Raptor plant, QTSC leased three portable chiller units to process gas delivered to Kern River. The Raptor plant can recover up to 700 barrels (about 30,000 gallons) of liquid hydrocarbons per day, which are then sold to local companies for further processing

and resale to retailers such as propane dealers. QTSC began designing the Raptor plant in the spring of 2008 and started construction in April 2009. QTSC began operating the plant last August. Allan Bradley, QPC president and CEO, praised the Raptor Plant project team’s execution saying, “The Raptor Plant was completed 45 days ahead of its anticipated Oct. 1 in-service date and at a cost that was under budget,” said Bradley.

CARBON COUNTY Go with us into a bright future!

Carbon County Commissioners John Jones, Mike Milovich & Bill Krompel

Carbon County Commissioners

working in partnership with the Energy Industry to provide access to economic and recreation opportunities for our citizens.

22 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Nelco is about four decades of local service For more than 36 years, Nelco has fulfilled the construction needs of communities in the Castle Country area and has truly become the area’s “preferred contractor.” Neil Frandsen founded Nelco in 1973 with a clear aspiration of being an exceptionally reliable and quality contractor. Nelco began as a small contracting firm performing primarily excavation work for residential homeowners and developers. Residential site and utility work continues to remain one of Nelco’s key specialties. By 1980 Nelco was taking on increasingly larger jobs involving trucking and heavy excavation. The early ‘80s marked Nelco’s entrance into the energy industry where they have become highly specialized as a support contractor for the area’s coal and natural gas production companies, building new sites,









pipelines, roads, performing reclamation work, etc. In behalf of the energy industry, Nelco has excavated hundreds of miles of trench for pipelines, built hundreds of miles of road, excavated untold volumes of earth for sites, hauled millions of barrels of water, and much more. In 1991, with the purchase of their first screening plant and thus entering the aggregate production business, Nelco became a full service contractor capable of completing large heavy construction projects. Today Nelco’s aggregate production operation produces a wide range of high quality, crushed-to-spec aggregates that are used for their projects and are also sold to customers. Nelco has multiple quarries in the area with stockpiles ranging from screened pea gravel to large landscaping (Continued on page 23)

Access to almost 2 million industrial MRO items Same day/next day delivery Engineering, fabrication and repair services Powerful e-business capabilities 24/7 emergency service

We sell all types & sizes of metal. Come in or call for a quote. Check out our Hydraulic Services:

Fabricate cylinders. Repair cylinders, valves, pumps & motors. We Weld and Machine most metals. Over 23 years in business doing mine, power plant and farm manufacturing & repair.

230 N. Center Cleveland, Utah 435-653-2325 322 South Highway 55, Price, UT 84501 • (800) 280-7880

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 23

Nelco is about four decades of local service: (Continued from page 22) boulders – all ready for sale. Nelco experienced a great period of growth during the ‘90s as they adapted to meet the mounting needs of their valued customers. The growth Nelco was experiencing initiated Larry Jensen becoming Neil’s partner in 1994. Larry had been a trusted and key employee of Nelco since 1975, and was tremendously influential in developing the company’s excellent reputation. Neil and Larry continue to own and operate the business. The new century is bringing new and exciting opportunities to Nelco. In 2005, having outgrown their old location due to the growth of the company, it became necessary for the company to build a new headquarters a few miles south of Price on state highway 10. This first rate, 20-acre lo-

cation includes a large fleet maintenance, welding and machine shop, a large office building, and plenty of room for storage and parking of the company’s fleet of more than 200 trucks, trailers, and heavy equipment. Since 2002, while continuing their other specialty work, Nelco has developed another area of expertise in commercial site work and has performed site work for a large number of new business and municipal buildings in the area. No job is too big or too small for Nelco to give their best work to perform. Every team member at Nelco is dedicated to being the best at what they do. This company mentality has made Nelco “Castle Country’s preferred contractor.” Nelco’s customers are pleased to refer Nelco’s services to others. Due to Nelco’s exceptional work, some customers even—time and

time again—ask Nelco to follow them outside of the area to carry out their construction work. Nelco’s highly skilled and expe-

rienced management team and crews are eager to do whatever it takes to get the job done right, on time and within their budget.

New construction and renovating for the mining, power generating community! Commercial Construction for Banking & Business/Residential/Metal Buildings We can help you!

Stilson and Sons Construction Inc. 390 N. Main P.O. Box 593 • Orangeville, UT 84537 435-748-2636 • Cell 749-1390 or 820-4012 • Fax 748-2646

24 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Gas production dominated by Uintah Basin By Richard Shaw While a lot of coalbed methane gas is produced south of the Bookcliffs in Utah, it is the Uintah Basin which knocks the socks off production in the state. The basin sits on gas deposits of associated and non-associated gas that are huge. In 2008 Uintah County produced 273,253,486 thousand cubic feet of natural gas. Carbon was second in the state with 94,546,746 thousand feet of gas, much of which is coal bed methane. Duchesne County was third in the state with 26,575,078 thousand cubic feet of gas production while Emery came in fourth with 16,703,949 thousand feet of coalbed methane. As a state, Utah (in 2008) had a total of 6,643 billion cubic feet of known reserves. Utah is eighth in the nation in gas production with Texas having the largest reserves at 77,546 billion cubic feet.

The producing fields in the Carbon – Emery area include Drunkerd’s Wash (49,378,444 thousand cubic feet), Nine Mile (20,970,638 thousand cubic feet), Peters Point (14,313,577 thousand cubic feet), Helper (13,735,819 thousand cubic feet) and the Buzzard Bench field in Emery County (9,989,197 thousand cubic feet). Mineral rights held by owners of land above gas deposits is important. The federal government owns the majority of the land in Utah, so their cut of the natural gas is larger than other groups with 285,342 million cubic feet of production in 2008. The state had a production from its lands of 93,762 million cubic feet. Native American lands within the state had a production of 28,869 million square feet. (The source for this article was the Utah Geological Survey).

A gas drill derrick stands tall during drilling operations for natural gas.


Ellis L. Pierce P.O. 792 332 Railroad Ave. Price UT 84501 Phone: (435) 637-3211 Fax: (435) 637-6628

THE LEADER IN QUALITY MINING AND INDUSTRIAL CHEMICALS Ellis L. Pierce - President P.O. Box 761 - Price, UT 84501-0761 332 West Railroad Ave. - Price, UT

Corp. Office: 1-800-845-5060 Fax: (435) 637-6628

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 25

Types of gas important to extraction process By Richard Shaw It’s hard to believe in this day and age of high energy prices and in times when energy seems to be in shorter and shorter supply from year to year that natural gas was once considered a nuisance. When people began looking for oil to fuel cars and machines, and to lubricate what was rapidly becoming a modern society, gas often accompanied oil deposits. That gas was part of what brought the oil to the surface once it was struck, but developers saw it as a problem. In the early days of petroleum development, probably billions of cubic feet of gas were burned off to get rid of it. Today it has become a valued commodity. Oil wells with gas are often utilized for both forms of energy. The gas that comes with oil is called associated gas. But while

gas can be good in this day of energy capture and use, not all gas it created equal either. Underground natural gas exists in many different kinds of forms and in many different kinds of deposits. And where it naturally occurs is not only important, it is problematic. Gas falls into two categories in terms of extraction – conventional gas and unconventional gas. Generally, conventional natural gas deposits are the most practical, and easiest, deposits to remove from the ground. However, as technology and geology grows as a science, unconventional natural gas deposits are beginning to become more viable as a practical supply. Because of these changes, what unconventional gas is, is difficult define because basically the target (Continued on page 38)

One of the operators on a gas drill derrick.

Hey Dad! Think Safety First! Think Safe! Be Safe! Come Home Safe!

Safety...Let’s Live with It!

26 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Is the future set for robotic coal miners? By Richard Shaw Not many years ago the United States defense department envisioned fighter planes and bombers that could take the fight to the enemy without endangering a pilot’s life. Even as late as the late 1980s that still seemed the fabric of science fiction. Today drones in Afganistan regularly take off and target enemy leaders and fighters with bombs and missiles as the pilots watch through a screen while they sit at an airbase in Nevada. Drones can stay in the air, high above enemy targets for hours and hours, while a pilot sits back, has a cup of coffee, or even hands off the duties of the mission to another pilot because it is time for him to go home because his shift is over. If this kind of technology can be used to fight a war, in a far off

land, people have reasoned, why can’t this technology be used to mine under the ground, making life safer and better for those who would venture under to get minerals, gems and yes, coal to power the world? When the continuous miner was invented in the 1940s, coal mining took a large step forward. Not only could a lot more coal be extracted from the mine at once, but with remote controls, operators could stand in back of the machine and stay out of the way for roof falls and side tunnel blow outs. Longwalls even took this entire idea ten steps farther, by cutting back the number of people needed underground and almost continually mining with little human assistance. But still miners need to be there; deep in the (Continued on page 40)

Tavaputs Ranch Corporate Retreats, Family Getaways, Range Creek Tours and so much more!


A longwall machine in operation in a coal mine. As mines become more automated robotics will become a bigger and bigger part of coal mining. The process began with the invention of the continuous miner and has resulted in various developments over the years, now culminating in the huge machines that grind away at a seam of coal several hundred feet long.

Nielson Concrete Products

Escape the workplace environment and lose yourself in serenity. The perfect place for Corporate Retreats, Tavaputs Ranch will pamper you and exceed your every expectation. We are the great escape from the workplace.


Ranch 435-636-5008

Home 435-637-1236

Rock Solid

Nielson Concrete Products offers the best in quality and service for all of your concrete needs. With state certified concrete, we offer a liquid color system capable of matching colors from any manufacturer. We employ skilled drivers that provide exceptional service and the know-how to develop custom mix designs tailored to the needs of any project. Together, We Move Mountains

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 27

Does Sevier experience set stage for future? By David Anderson and Richard Shaw Does the experience that Sevier County has been having over a 270 (MW) megawatt power plant bode poorly for the future of coal generated power plants? That question can only be answered as the plans to build that plant near Sigurd continue, now with a new twist. That twist being natural gas. The plant’s planners are thinking of converting the plant to methane power because opposition of some locals and environmental groups have basically halted the coal generation idea. The plant is to be built by NEVCO Energy Company and has been in the planning (Continued on page 61)

Proposed View

This rendering shows what the proposed Nevco power plant would look like once it is built near Sigurd. The smoke stack on the power plant is planned to be 460 feet high. In comparison, the height of the radio towers at KSVC and KCQY in Richfield – shown red – are about 300 feet high.


UA Local 140 Pipefitters, Plumbers, HVAC&R If you want quality work

Price City Electric Power Price City is proud to provide dependable electrical power to its residents. Remember the following power conservation and cost saving tips: 1. Use low consumption fluorescent bulbs with electronic ballasts; 2. Properly insulate homes and businesses for all weather conditions; 3. Use natural ambient light when available; 4. Business should avoid demand spikes that increase use and costs. Price City...A friendly, progressive community.

performed by skilled craftsmen then contact the Utah Pipe Trades UA Local 140


Price City Elected Officials: (left to right) Councilmember Rick Davis Councilmember Jeanne McEvoy, Mayor Joe L. Piccolo, Councilmember Richard Tatton, Councilmember Kathy Hanna-Smith Councilmember Jeff Nielson

Union Contractors who employ our highly trained professionals finish on time and within budget. Union members earn a living wage to invest in our communities. A partnership that benefits everyone involved.



185 East Main Street, P.O. Box 893, Price, Utah 84501 • 435-637-5010

MT. TIMPANOGAS TEMPLE For more information about our accredited Federal Bureau of Apprenticeship Training program call: Director Dan Smith at: Phone (801) 295-6198

Pipefitters, Plumbers, HVAC&R UA Local 140 2261 So. Redwood Rd. Salt Lake City, UT 84119 Phone (801) 973-6784

28 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

The future of coal and technology By Kevin Scannell Coal has been considered to be the workhorse of man for centuries, possibly thousands of years. It has been burned in fireplaces and stoves to produce heat in living spaces and in business settings. While it is used on a small scale to heat homes, coal is also used for other kinds of industrial production such as to produce paper and in the cement and man-made stone industry. The largest single consumer of coal in the world is as a fuel for power plants, and since the beginning of World War II, the amount of coal used for generating electricity has doubled each decade. With this history in mind, how will our future be affected by coal? That is one of the major questions currently facing the U.S. at this time. And the answer to the

question is not as easy as it seems. Coal contributes a lot to the world, especially here in the U.S., and trying to move away from it to focus on other sources doesn’t seem to be happening anytime soon – not with the knowledge that coal reserves in the U.S. are currently projected to last for at least another 200 years. Utah generates a significant amount of electricity from locally supplied coal, providing the power market with distinct supply advantages and enabling residents to enjoy low energy costs. In fact, coal constitutes the most widely distributed fossil fuel in the world and 92 percent of that coal is used to generate electrical power, providing approximately one-half of the electricity in the U.S. In Utah, coal alone generates about 90 percent of (Continued on page 59)

A Rocky Mountain Power employee tests water samples for usability at a power plant in Castle Valley. Coal’s importance, as well as the technology that drives it, continue to develop as time goes on.

Over 30 Years Experience Providing Excellent 24 Hour Customer Service and satisfaction. D.C. Armature | 3 Phase Motor | Sales & Service | Repair Founded in 1976

Industrial Electric Motor Service, Inc. 225 West 500 South Orangeville, UT 84537 P.O. Box #485 435-748-2828 Fax: 435-748-2089

Motor Repair is our Specialty. Baldor Motor & Drive

Industrial Electric Motor Service, Inc. provides electric motor repair and rewinding services. The company was incorporated in 1976 and is based in Orangeville, Utah. David Hinkins is proud to be a part of the Energy Industry serving Carbon & Emery Counties.

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 29

Renewable energy pros and cons By Carolyn Campbell Utah is fortunate to have abundant and diverse energy resources, according to Jason Berry, Manager, Utah State Energy Program. “There is an enormous potential to meet our demand for power,” he said. To promote and identify Utah’s utility-scale electrical renewable energy resources, former Governor Huntsman commissioned the Utah Renewable Energy Zones (UREZ) Task Force to identify Utah’s geographical areas where renewable energy development could occur. The task force assessed the electrical generation potential of wind, solar, and geothermal technologies. They also identified new and existing transmission needed to bring renewable energy generation sources to market. The task force study identified renewable energy zones in

Utah totaling approximately 13,262 square miles, with an estimated 837 gigawatts of electrical generating capacity. One gigawatt equals 1,000 megawatts. One megawatt supplies enough energy to meet the electrical needs of approximately 750 Utah homes at any given moment. The UREZ task force’s goal is to promote the development of renewable energy resources to meet the goal of supplying 20 percent of Utah’s electricity through renewable sources by 2026. Utah’s renewable electric capacity is dominated by hydroelectric power. “Hydro electric power makes up the majority of Utah’s renewable energy, through small hydroelectric power plants along the Wasatch Front and further down on the Wasatch plateau,” Berry ex(Continued on page 31)

These wind mills, located at the mouth of Spanish Fork Canyon, are a part of Utah’s effort to embrace renewable energy sources.

30 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Consol Energy donates to safety CONSOL Energy, Inc. has made its second $250,000 donation to support the $1.5 million Western Mining Presidential Chair in Mine Safety in the University of Utah’s department of Mining Engineering. The donation – which brings the endowment to nearly $1 million – was presented to University of Utah officials last week by CONSOL by Bart Hyita, vice president and chief operating officer of CONSOL. The Chair in Mine Safety was established in 2009, with CONSOL Energy and Barrick Gold North America as key contributors. Since then, donations have been received from Rio Tinto Kennecott, Rocky Mountain Power, Arch Coal, Intermountain Electronics, John T. Boyd & Co., and many alumni of the Department of Mining Engineering. “We’re really grateful for CONSOL’s leadership in establishing and supporting the safety chair,” said Professor Mike Nelson, chair of the Department of Mining Engineering. “We’ll soon be able to hire a faculty member who can educate our students in mine safety, and who will also take the lead in establishing a center for promotion and establishment of progressive and


CONSOL Energy, Inc. officials have made a second donation of $250,000 to the University of Utah Department of Mining Engineering to help fund a professorship in mine safety. From left to right: Bart Hyita, CONSOL chief operating officer for coal; Jimmy Brock, CONSOL senior vice president for northern West Virginia; Gary Takenaka, CONSOL general manager for applied improvements; Mike Nelson, chair of mining engineering at the University of Utah; and Frank Brown, dean of the College of Mines and Earth Sciences, University of Utah.

effective safety and health systems in the mining industry, through education, outreach, research, advocacy and development.” CONSOL Energy Inc. (NYSE: CNX) is the largest producer of highBTU bituminous coal in the United States. Named one of America’s most admired companies by Fortune magazine, CONSOL Energy has evolved from a single-fuel mining company

into a multi-energy producer of highBTU coal and gas. Together, coal and gas fuel two-thirds of the nation’s pow-

er. CONSOL operates 18 coal mining complexes in six states, including the Emery mine near Emery Town.

Hydraulic Repairs Inc.

P.O. Box 577, Price, Utah 84501 Bus. (435) 637-6211

CONSOL Energy has one of the nation’s largest mine rescue teams, ready to take action if mine safety is compromised.

Hug a coal miner today!

Serving Carbon and Emery Counties for 29 Years!

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 31

Renewable energy pros and cons: (Continued from page 29) plains. “A major one is the Flaming Gorge hydroelectric power plant.” There are also increasing amounts of energy from geothermal power within the state. Raser Technologies plans to build several more 10 megawatt scale geothermal plants in southwestern Utah. The 203-megawatt Milford wind farm came online in late 2009. The biomass portion of Utah’s renewable energy is mainly from Wasatch Front landfill gas operations, according to Berry. He adds that the SunSmart solar array in St George is Utah’s first utility-owned solar installation. Alternative energy is derived from any renewable energy source other than fossil fuels, such as coal and oil. “Alternative energy” is an umbrella term that refers to any usable energy source that is intended to

replace fuel sources without the undesired consequences of the replaced fuels. “A big benefit to renewable energy is that there is no cost once the project is developed,” Berry said. “We don’t have to pay for the wind to blow or the sun to shine.” Renewable energy is also considered clean, because it isn’t taken from fossil fuels and is a product of sources that do not use up natural resources or harm the environment. Biomass energy, solar energy, wind energy, tidal energy and hydroelectric energy are all examples of types of alternative energy. According to Western Resource Advocates’ Renewable Energy Atlas of the West, Utah’s biomass resource potential for electricity generation is approximately one million megawatt hours annually. As of 2006, Utah was producing

4,000 megawatt hours of electricity from biomass. According to the Biomass Task Force report from the Western Governors Association, biomass has the potential to supply 15,000 megawatts of electricity to the Western states by the year 2015. At a production cost of 8 cents per kilowatt hour, 10,000 megawatts could be provided. Biomass energy is composed of organic material obtained mainly from plants and animals. It may consist of fermented animal waste, agricultural crops, grains and other natural products. Biomass materials have the potential to supply 15 times more energy than that produced by the sun and wind. Heat and electricity are generated during biomass energy production. It can be used to produce an alcohol is that is comparable to coal and can be used to replace our current gasoline needs.

A natural gas called biogas and biofuel are products obtained from biomass energy. Biomass briquettes produce electricity. According to Utah Clean Energy, a volunteer-based public interest group that serves as an independent resource for clean energy policy, regulatory, and consumer information, biomass projects can strengthen rural economies, and, in some cases, provide additional income to farmers and ranchers. In rural areas, people use biomass as a source of heat for cooking and heating purposes. Anaerobic digestion systems can provide farms and ranchers with a viable means for reducing waste streams and generating onsite energy and/or fuels. Biomass energy helps in solid waste management by reducing pollution. Daily incineration of biological wastes cuts down (Continued on page 33)

Quality Mining & Industrial Products E CI

Complete Range of Products for: • Mining • Industrial • Construction (435) 637-1110 • 42 S. Carbon Ave. Price UT (307) 362-1917 • 2028 Sunset Drive Rock Springs, WY

32 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010


Xf!epoÖu!kvtu!! qpxfs!uif!dpnnvojuz-!! !xfÖsf!b!qbsu!pg!ju/ !Bbspo!Hjmnpsf!!!


March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 33

Renewable energy pros and cons:

Biomass comes in various forms, some of them are even beautiful to look at.

DEPARTMENT OF MINING ENGINEERING 135 S. 1460 E. #313, SLC, UT 84112 801.585.5176 DEGREES

(Continued from page 31) the levels of expulsion into the atmosphere, helping to maintain an ecological balance of carbon present in the environment. The electricity generated from biomass is much cleaner than that obtained from fossil fuels. The concept of biomass has been known to man since the time our forefathers began using it as an energy source. Because there is an abundance of organic waste and agricultural waste generated every day, and because biomass energy is produced from these wastes, it is an easily available, inexhaustible resource. It is also cost effective, because it is usually generated and supplied in the same area, so that the installation of large pipelines is not required. One drawback to biomass energy is the cost of raw biomass mate-

rials. In comparison to fossil fuel as far as being a ready-to-use product, biomass energy carries additional processing costs. The process of extraction – collecting, harvesting and storing raw biomass materials – is expensive, especially considering the large volumes required compared to fossil fuels. “The woody biomass from Utah’s forests is resource-expensive, because you have to pull it out and then truck it somewhere. It involves driving truckloads of wood for miles,� Berry said. Too, the extra costs extend to installing technology to process and recycle wastes from biomass materials. Compacting, chipping, shredding or cutting huge volumes of biomass is often necessary. For small biomass plants, such cleaning technology may not be economically feasible. (Continued on page 39)

Supplying the technical expertise to Utah’s mining industry for over 100 years.


%60(06 3K' '(*5((352*5$06


Starting salaries among the highest paid for engineers High demand for B.S. graduates - job placement nearly 100%





Contact us for exciting and rewarding career opportunities.

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 35

34 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010



1556 East 100 South • Price, Utah 84501 | 435-637-7291 • 435-637-4663

Reliability Performance Profitability

“We believe that our commitment to continued technological improvement allows us to provide the level of quality, service and dedication our Customers have come to rely on.”

Your PRECISION Motor Repair Facility

Tram’s new Microlog data collector/ analyzer provides unmatched versatility, reliability and functionality in our ongoing efforts to provide our Customers with the most timely and accurate diagnoses of potential mechanical or electrical problems as they develop, and prior to catastrophic failures which can be extremely costly. Every motor that comes through our shop must pass rigorous baseline vibration and performance standards prior to release to our Customer.

Our Precision Rebuilds are analyzed with the use of our SKF Thermal Camera. This camera uses infrared thermography to visualize troublesome hotspots quickly and easily, enabling Tram techs to perform comprehensive image analysis. This removes any doubt of the integrity of the motor providing a Precision rebuild for our Customers.

24 HOUR EMERGENCY SERVICES Please Call 435-637-7291

The Data Recorder allows us to present accurate information to our Customer regarding rates of temperature and time throughout the burn-off process before rewinding as well as the baking process after dipping or vacuum pressure impregnation coating is applied to windings.

Our SKF Electrical Discharge Detector Pen detects electric discharge in motor bearings. Electrical discharge is the result of motor shaft voltages discharging to earth through the bearings causing erosion, lubricant degradation and bearing failure.


36 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Growing gasification slated for future By Kevin Scannell Coal is considered, by some, to be the cheapest, most abundant source of power available in the United States. With the research that shows coal providing about 50 percent of the U.S. electricity needs and the U.S. having enough coal for the next 200 years, it can be assumed that coal will play a part in the country’s future. But with the prices and availability of oil becoming future concerns, the push for more renewable and reliable energy sources has been brought back to the forefront. The energy concerns are bringing about a renewed interest in technologies such as methanization, liquefaction and gasification. The National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) describes

the gasification process as a process for the conversion of carbon-based materials (feedstock) such as coal into synthesis gas (syngas) that can be converted to separate hydrogen and carbon dioxide gas streams as a way to make clean electricity while preventing the release of carbon dioxide. One goal of the NETL’s program is to be able to sequester 90 percent of the carbon from coal with minimal impact to the cost of electricity. Coal gasification can also convert coal into transportation fuels like gasoline and diesel through the Fischer-Tropsch process. Also the hydrogen obtained from gasification can be used for various purposes such as powering a hydrogen economy, making ammonia or upgrading fossil fuels. (Continued on page 37)

Coal, such as is heaped up near Dugout Mine, can be made into natural gas or into motor fuel through processes developed a long time ago. Cost, resources to do it and now enviromental questions, however, have prevented that from happening to any meaningful degree as of yet.

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 37

Growing gasification slated for future: (Continued from page 36) There are four coal gasification plants currently in the U.S., but none of them produce fuels. Two of the plants produce electricity: The Wabash River Plant in West Terra Haute, Ind., and Tampa Electric’s Polk Station located near Mulberry, Fla. The other two plants produce chemicals: The Great Plains Synfuels Plant near Beulah, N.D. and the Tennessee Eastman Kingsport Power Plant in Kingsport, Tenn. The Great Plains Synfuels Plant produces pipeline-quality synthetic natural gas and related products and is considered to be the cleanest energy plant operating in the state of North Dakota. Some other interesting facts about the plant listed on the Web site include: Average daily production of natural gas is about 153 million cubic feet, the majority of which is

then piped to Ventura, IA for distribution in the eastern U.S. The Synfuels Plant supplies carbon dioxide to the world’s largest carbon capture and storage project in the world in Saskatchewan, Canada. Dakota Gas currently captures about 2.8 million metric tons of carbon dioxide per year. The $2.1 billion plant began operating in 1984. Using Lurgi gasifiers, the Synfuels Plant gasifies lignite coal to produce valuable gases and liquids. About $400 million has been invested in the Synfuels Plant since 1988 to achieve environmental compliance, improve efficiency and invest in new byproduct development. With worldwide gasification capacity projected to grow 70 percent by 2015 – with 80 percent of the growth occurring in Asia, Tom Sarkus, dep-

uty director of the Office of Major Demonstrations with the NETL, said that one ton of coal equals about two barrels of oil and has other associated costs that go with it. With the appetite for energy growing all over the world, he thinks gasification of coal is an interesting, but very costly, way of getting energy sources. It can cost anywhere between $70 to $90 a barrel to make gasoline from coal, according to Sarkus. “Energy appetite and consumption has grown over time,” Sarkus said. “There is going to be a lot of financial heavy lifting that needs to be done. You can’t snap your finger and just have all of these things be done so quickly.” Sarkus said that the country of South Africa has about 40 percent of their gasoline derived from coal. Another fuel that can be derived

from coal is jet fuel, which is made from coal and petroleum. With the large coal reserves available inside of the country, Sarkus believes that building more synthetic fuel plants would benefit the country in more than a few ways. “The price of oil would cause reason to build plants or not,” Sarkus said. “Questions in the future we need to answer are how many plants would need to be built and what would the total cost be. But by building a few plants we could be sending a signal to oil producing countries, possibly creating an insurance policy for the future.” Three things that can come from the gasification process include chemicals, fuels and electricity with integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC), according to Sarkus. (Continued on page 45)

38 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Types of gas important to extraction process: (Continued from page 25) keeps moving. What was unconventional last year, may through some process, become conventional gas tomorrow. In general terms, unconventional natural gas is gas that is gas that is more difficult to extract from the ground, and because of that is more expensive, sometimes to the point of being un-economical. So what is considered unconventional natural gas changes over time, and even from gas field to gas field? The costs of gas extraction plays a part in determining whether or not a particular deposit may be unconventional, or simply too costly to extract. Overall, there are six basic categories of unconventional natural gas. These types include deep gas, tight gas, gas-containing shales (stone that holds gas), coalbed methane, geopressurized zones, and sub-sea hydrates.

• Deep natural gas is natural gas that exists in deposits very far underground, beyond what is termed ‘conventional’ drilling depths. This gas is often 15,000 feet or deeper. This is much deeper than conventional gas deposits, which are usually only 3,000-4,000 feet underground. The gas in the West Tavaputs Field near Nine Mile Canyon, for example, is considered deep gas. However, deep gas has become more conventional. Exploration, and extraction systems have substantially improved in the last 10 years, making drilling for this type of gas cost effective. Producing it to make a profit lies in many factors that must be considered before drilling. Tight gas is natural gas that exists in very tight formations underground, trapped in hard rock, in sandstone or limestone formations that are highly impermeable and

Free to Breath


Black Lung and Respiratory Diseases Clinics Is a federally funded program to help Our community with respiratory problems. Are you or have you been a: *Coal Miner *Uranium Miner *Railroader * Construction worker *Welder * Cement Worker * Sawmill worker or *Farmer/Rancher We can be of service to you with our Annual Screenings. 1. Our services include EKG 2. Spirometry (PFT) 3. Chest X-ray 4. Complete Nursing Assessment 5. Physical Exam And a Complete Work History

NOWCAP/Black Lung & Respiratory Diseases Clinics Will also assist you in filing for your Black Lung and/or Uranium Benefits. Call Ms. Anita O’Neil, Office Manager at 435-613-8790 or stop by 15 Carbon Ave. Price, UT NOWCAP/Black Lung & Respiratory Diseases Clinics also serves Wyoming and Montana

non-porous. It takes a lot of effort to extract gas from a tight formation. Several technologies exist that allow natural gas to be extracted from tight formations, including fracturing and acidizing. Cost, however, can be high. Tight gas makes up a large portion of the nation’s natural gas reserves. Government agencies estimate that between 15-20 percent of the gas that could be used for practical purposes is tight gas. • Shale gas also is unconventional gas. Shales were created from the mud of shallow seas that existed about 300 million years ago. Shale is a sedimentary rock, which can crumble and sheets into thin, parallel layers. It is a soft rock, but doesn’t break down when exposed to moisture. Shale can contain gas between layers, but it is very hard to remove and thus expensive. With present technology removing gas from shale is a dicey proposition because so little comes out with present technology. Again as processes improve, however, it could become a valuable source of gas sometime in the future. • Coal can also create natural gas called coalbed methane. That is the kind of gas that is being produced by the wells drilled in Carbon and Emery counties. Coalbed methane is trapped underground. It can be released by either mining activity or by drilling. This gas has always been a problem for the mining industry, except unlike with oil, its danger was much higher and has caused a myriad of casualties over the years because of explosions. Coalbed methane could be a large supplier of natural gas for consumer use with this kind of gas being about eight percent of total reserves. • Geo-pressured gas. Geo-pressurized zones are formed by layers of clay that are deposited and compacted very quickly on top of more porous, absorbent material such as sand or silt. Natural gas is present

A drilling rig in operation.

in the clay and that gas is squeezed out by the rapid compression of the clay. This gas enters the more porous sand or silt deposits. This natural gas, due to the compression of the clay, is deposited in the sand or silt. Geo-pressure zones are located at great depths between two and four miles down in the Earth. All this makes removing the gas very complicated and of course expensive. While exact estimates of the amount of this kind of gas that exists vary, it appears it may be one of the largest sources of gas available to U.S. suppliers. • Methane hydrates were just recently discovered as a source of natural gas. In these formations, water is frozen around methane, which encases it in a kind of cage. While new to the energy supply, these hydrates may contain more gas than at first believed. However, new discoveries often had downsides that come out in environmental factors. Research on this type of natural gas deposit is now underway. Obviously the world is running out of the easy gas to extract, and these unconventional sources are part of the world’s energy future.

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 39

Renewable energy pros and cons: (Continued from page 33) Another disadvantage of biomass energy is the greenhouse gases that are produced when biomass is burned, said author Erik Leipoldt, who frequently addresses environmental issues. Exhaust gas-cleaning technology must be applied to biomass energy plants to make them truly environmentally friendly. “Utah’s woody biomass does put out some emissions; there would be an air quality issue,” says Berry. Setting up a biomass power plant also requires huge space and the recycling of wastes requires a large amount of water. Moreover, biomass energy depends largely on grown crops. “These crops will take up huge tracts of land if biofuels are to replace fossil fuels to a significant extent. The land might also require deforestation to clear it first,”

indicated Leipolt. Such land is also needed for feeding Earth’s growing population of billions of people. As another alternative energy possibility, Utah’s solar resources are clearly abundant. Utah has a tremendous and largely untapped solar resource, and the potential for solar development is widespread across the state, according to Utah Clean Energy. The UREZ task force identified 6,371 square miles of land with a theoretical potential of about 826 gigawatts of utility-scale capacity in solar energy. According to the UREZ’s report, this amount of concentrating solar potential could generate over 1.5 million gigawatt hours per year – equivalent to the annual electricity demand of over 150 million average Utah homes. According to Utah Clean Energy, utility-scale solar also has the ability to stimulate needed economic

HELPER UTAH SERVICE CENTER Think of Us for Specialized Hydraulic Repair Services! Wagner Distr. Service Center Pumps - Motors - Valves - Cylinders Complete Testing Equipment


610 Industrial Road Highway 50 & 6 Helper, Utah 84526 Phone: 435-472-3452 Fax: 435-472-8779 Rock Springs Office 307-382-9787

development in the state; for example a 100 megawatt concentrating solar power plant has the potential to create over 1,000 new jobs and generate $370 million in private investment. Solar energy comes from the sun, the greatest source of energy known today. It is a free source of efficient energy. It is also a renewable resource. As long as the sun exists, its energy will reach Earth. Solar energy is one of the fastest growing energy resources in the world, providing an inexhaustible and clean source of electricity and heat. Solar’s primary benefit is its ability to provide “peak power” during the hot summer months, supporting potentially strained electricity grids and reducing the need to bring on new peaking capacity. It releases no water or air pollution because there is no

chemical reaction from the combustion of fuels. Solar energy can be used very frequently for practical uses, such as heating and lighting. There is a possibility that solar power can replace traditional electricity sources in many places, especially where there is abundant sunshine. But, on the other hand, solar power does not produce energy if the sun is not shining. Nighttime and cloudy days seriously limit the amount of energy produced. In addition, solar power stations can be very expensive to build. And, unfortunately, not all places are ideal for solar power. Wind power is the conversion of wind energy using wind turbines, which transforms the kinetic energy into mechanical power. Utah’s extreme diversity in landscape and (Continued on page 46)

40 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Is the future set for robotic coal miners: (Continued from page 26) ground, under tons of rock, risking their lives. In the last ten years, developments have taken place that may put the mining industry where those drones over Afganistan fly today, technology wise – at a day when a miner can sit above ground and totally run a machine that will dig out the coal, load it and bring it to the surface without a human being touching it. And it may be much closer than many think. One of the first mining robots was developed eight years ago at Carnegie-Mellon University’s Robotics Institute. It was called “Groundhog” and it looked like a four-wheeler. It used lasers to “see” in dark tunnels and to map abandoned mines – some of the most dangerous work, according to experts. During a test researchers sent “Groundhog” into an abandoned mine in Pennsylvania where it slogged deep into the orange muck, successfully navigating with its laser rangefinders. If nothing else, the idea of using unmanned vehicles – or robots – to go into mines where conditions are dangerous, or to rescue people, has been one of the main objectives of researchers. In 2005, a robot went into a Kentucky coal mine that had been producing acid-type smoke and heat. The underground passage to the mine could not be traversed by a human without special gear. It was the first time a robot was sent into a coal mine ahead of humans to check the situation and to see if it was safe. Using robots in rescue operations can be complicated however. The lasers that guide robots don’t work well in smoky or misty environments. Scientists are working on using sonar and radar to overcome these problems. Mines around the world are already testing various kinds of

technologies to remove coal from deep under the ground without a human presence. For instance, in Korea mining fields are likely to see a new cadre of remote-controlled robotic coal-miners by about 2014. The state-run Korea Coal Corp. (KOCOAL) signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) a couple of years ago with three Korean engineering institutions and companies for the development of intelligent coal-mining robots. It is thought that these robots will increase productivity by working around the clock and going deeper into the ground than humans can safely go. The company has research teams that will be working with the Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology and a Korean university that will jointly work on the project. Once the miners are developed and tested for about half a year they are expected to be in place, actually mining coal, not just doing rescue or dangerous work. The U.S. mining industry, however, has shown little interest in funding such research until very recently. Robots are expensive, and developing them for the exact purposes needed make them even more so. Advances in other technology have already reduced the number of miners in the U.S. by 68 percent over the last 40 years. Today, nationwide, about 100,000 people work in the coal-mining industry, so the incentive may not be there as much as it once was. Safety, one of the biggest reasons to consider robots, has also changed a lot over the years. Since around 1990, fatalities have declined by 67 percent, and injuries by 51 percent, according to the National Mining Association. Certainly some of it is a question of money. Could robots be that much more efficient than a

human being that their cost would be worth what it may be. The industry is talking about hundreds of millions of dollars, maybe even into the billions range to make machines that are viable and durable enough to stand the circumstances in wet, dusty and danger-filled mines. And in today’s depressed economy, where no one is sure which direction economic conditions are headed, with coal under fire from environmentalists and even governments like never before, and with federal funding for such research drying up, the ques-

tions of whether to mechanize more or not is larger than ever. Finally there is also a downside, as there is with any technological development. The coal industry, man-power wise, is already a skeleton of what it was 50 years ago due to technological advances. Eliminating most people completely from a mine would bring the number of people running it down considerably. And with steel hands and claws actually pulling the black material out of the ground, it could be the end of a profession and an era.

Ecoshale tests successful By Mary Bernard In October, Dr. Laura Nelson, vice president of Ecoshale, said the company’s pilot project, in the Bookcliffs, has produced a high quality oil-shale product. “We did so working closely with the Environmental Protection Agency to make an environmentally sensitive product,” she stated. Nelson was briefing the Utah Board of Oil, Gas and Mining at the Uintah Basin Applied Technology College in the success of Ecoshale’s feasibility test. Ecoshale’s synthetic product has properties rated by the American Petroleum Institute (API) as 39 condensate oil and between 34 and 35 prompt oil with no fines, or impurities, in the oil. Based on the test study, Nelson projects full-production at 30,000 barrels a day would cost $20.21 per barrel, not including transportation. Her comments came shortly after Interior Secretary Ken Salazar called for an investigation into Bush-era oil shale leasing practices in Utah, Colorado and Wyoming. While Salazar’s comments refer to oil shale leases on federal lands, Nelson says Ecoshale

is developing less obtrusive extraction techniques on state lands. She notes the Salt Lake-based Ecoshale operates a test facility on “17,000 acres on Utah State School Institutional Trust Lands property roughly 60 miles southeast of Vernal.” Geologists estimate that “there’s about 1.5 billion barrels of in-place oil shale resource on these properties,” says Nelson, who adds conservatively that only 500 million barrels are recoverable. Deposits of the Green River Formation oil shale are found from the surface to a depth of 100 feet with the richest strata found inside the parcels occupied by Ecoshale. “Ecoshale has access to the largest block of surface mineable resource in region,” says Nelson. “The resource is called kerogen, an organic matter with petroleum-like qualities which is heated in above ground capsules to extract oil from the shale.” The shale is mined, crushed and placed into a nearby bentonite-line earthen capsule where the oil product are extracted. It’s a slow heating process that produces a high quality product. The capsule and related structures occupy about five acres.

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 41

Ob s jec s tive Not influenced by emotion or personal opinion.

Our unbiased investment guidance is not influenced by sales quotas, company directives or proprietary investment products. Contact us today for more information or to schedule a consultation.

Mutual Funds IRA Rollovers & Transfers Stocks & Bonds Annuities

Anita M. Bruno

Importance, availability of energy persists There’s no doubt the United States and other industrialized countries are absolutely dependent on energy. Those in the industry understand just how important it is that energy is available to the masses at all hours of the day, every day of the year.

Financial Consultant 62 N. 100 W. Price, UT 84501 (435) 637-1479

Alternative Investments

A Registered Investment Adviser Member FINRA/SIPC

42 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Drilling that well is all very complicated When the Colorado Division of Wildlife (DOW) purchased a 13,200acre parcel of wildlife habitat in western Colorado in the early 1980s, it seemed like a great deal for them and sportsmen. Funds for the purchase of Garfield Creek State Wildlife Area (SWA) came from the sale of hunting and fishing licenses, so everyone thought that is what it would only be used for. The purchase of the land was a good thing for hunters and fishermen, who got access to the land. The area around Garfield Creek was always quiet, largely agricultural. Few surmised that the growing technology in the energy industry, natural gas retrieval in particular, would make Garfield County a center of the energy

industry with a growth rate beyond other counties in the state. In 2008, Garfield Creek SWA was opened up to natural gas drilling. Some Coloradoan’s find this to be a rape of land meant for another purpose, while others see it just as the way things are. For those drilling for oil and gas in today’s environment, the steps they must now go through and the time it takes is just as surprising. Even when they do have access to the mineral rights or lease them from state or federal government entities, they must also face a lot of things they didn’t find standing in the way not that many years ago. In the case of Garfield, Orion

Oil is doing the drilling and they are working with state wildlife officials to mitigate the damage to the land, the flora and the fauna. But that doesn’t mean there is still not opposition and concern by many in the surrounding communities and across Colorado. The plan does restrict the company’s operations quite substantially. Orion cannot have any surface activity within the SWA until after the wildlife have migrated back to the higher elevations after winter. In addition, their work needs to be completed each year before the big game rifle hunting season begins in the fall. That leaves only a few months of the year that the energy company can work inside Garfield SWA. Orion has

Federal Onshore Lease Exploration & Potential Production Timeline

also put up a million dollars to install a water supply line that cuts out all the truckloads (estimated to be 2,400) of water that would be needed to operate the wells). Bill Barrett Corporation has faced a similar situation in the local area, but they have not only had to contend with wildlife considerations, but archaeological ones as well. Complex problems often have no easy answers, and conflict does arise between groups, companies and often government. So between exploration costs, permiting costs, and environmental protection costs, the expense of drilling wells is no longer an inexpensive endeavor, as if it ever was.

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 43

Nielson Crane Service



With Certified Crane Operators on staff and state-of-the-art cranes up to 170-ton in capacity, we can meet your project needs. When you need crane service, Nielson Construction has the lift. Together, We Move Mountains

Coal continues to fuel nation, economics While some expect coal to quickly disappear from the nation’s energy infrastructure, it’s availabilty, price and maturity as an energy producer has assured it’s continued place in national energy production for many years to come.

Phillips Machine Service, Inc. TM

Home of the

Freedom Car

Available in both Battery and Cable Versions

We are the Continuous Miner Rebuild Specialist Let us rebuild your miner or sell you one of our rebuilt machines!

Now with two locations to better serve our customers.

Phillips Machine Service, Inc. 367 George Street Beckley, WV 25801 (304) 255-0537

Phillips Machine West 1440 Highway 50 Delta, CO 81416 (888) 874-9910

44 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Miners Hospital brings services to workers By Carolyn Campbell Warren Oviatt began working as a miner in 1970. He started out at Swisher Coal in Carbon County. For a few months in 1972, he mined for Peabody Coal at Deer Creek. From then until his scheduled retirement in July 2009, he has worked for American Coal. Oviatt’s gradual hearing loss began during his first ten years as a miner. He worked 15 or 20 years before the loss was evident in everyday life. “I had to turn the TV up louder and ask people to repeat what they said,” he recalls. Twenty years ago, a Price audiologist prescribed a hearing aid for Oviatt’s left ear. Two years ago, he visited the Miners Hospital and Clinic which is part of the University Health Care Network at the University of Utah in Salt Lake City. “A graduate student in audiology

tested my hearing,” recalls Oviatt. “He was supervised by one of the instructors. They determined that I now needed hearing aids in both ears.” Oviatt explains that the hearing aids he received are state of the art. “I got the treatment I needed,” he said. Oviatt is one of 380 patients who have been served by the Miners Hospital since it was established in 2004. Today, he also serves on the advisory board for the hospital. Utilizing his experience in mining, EMT and fire fighting work, he assembled a presentation for the doctors that explained mining machinery and techniques and showed how injuries could result from mining. He continues to interface with medical personnel to provide insight regarding mining operations and subsequent injuries and to increase public awareness of the Miners Hospital. He recalls one individual who suf(Continued on page 60)

Shauna Vincent, Dana Hughs and Holly Horton are members of the staff a the Utah Miners Hospital which is located within the University of Utah Hospital. Carolyn Wiggins, not pictured, is the manager of the hospital. The offices for the hospital are located in Suite 1B295 in the main hospital building.

Thank you Customers & Employees 1946-2010

64 YEARS Carbon Transport

Serving the Energy Producers of South Eastern Utah

Proud to be a part of the Energy Industry, Serving Southeastern Utah for over 60 years.

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 45

Growing gasification slated for future: (Continued from page 37) IGCC is the technology that turns coal into gas – synthetic gas. It then re-

moves the impurities from the coal gas before it is combusted. This results in lower emissions of sulfur dioxide, par-

Mine Systems Company Mine Systems Co. was established by Charles Bardsley in 1996. The operation started at the Business and Technical Assistance Center in Price. As business increased, the company was able to purchase a shop in Helper, and at present, they have a fully-equipped and manned electrical repair and fabrication facility with over 6,000 square feet. MSCO is a family-owned business that is committed to the future. Their vision is to create superior customer value and continue to be a high quality supplier of new, refurbished and repaired electrical systems, components and mining supplies.

In today’s industrial markets and the regulation of these markets there is no room for short cuts. The company’s guarantee to their customers is that they will use only OEM parts in the repair of equipment and that equipment will be worked on or supervised by an MSHA certified Electrician. Mine Systems Company thanks their customers and suppliers that have made MSCO able to offer a quality product for a fair price. “Our employees are constantly striving for excellence. We look forward to working with you in the future,” said a spokesman for the company.

ticulates and mercury. Excess heat from the primary combustion and generation is then passed to a steam cycle, similar to a combined cycle gas turbine. Sarkus said one of the main problems facing IGCC is the high cost associated with it. One of the single biggest issues facing coal gasification is the environmental footprint it has. Because power plants are emitting a lot of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, research is being done on how to capture the carbon dioxide for use. Sarkus said that every ton of carbon dioxide that is injected into an enhanced oil field can possibly recover an additional one and a half to three barrels of oil. That could turn into a possible 40 billion barrels of oil, with another 40 billion barrels of oil after that due to a process called carbon dioxide flooding. The process involves injecting carbon dioxide into an oil reservoir in order to

increase output when extracting oil. If billions of barrels of oil were possible and the technology of gasification is advanced and refined, Sarkus said this could have the potential to reach a trillion dollars or more. “This could be a potentially big, enormous undertaking,” he said. “This could also help with pollution control and have our domestic oil production increase. Energy supply and security that goes with it is very big as well.” Sarkus said that cleaner gasification plants could possibly be built within the next five to ten years and would last about 50 – 70 years. “I don’t believe we can manage right now without coal because of how much we depend on it,” Sarkus said. “We need to develop technologies than can adapt to what the future brings, including gasification plants. “We need to use the source (coal) and use it as cleanly as we can,” he said.


Sell, Bend, Cut, Punch, Drill, Tap, and Turn to Customer’s Specs

We Design, Repair, Rebuild, and Fabricate in the Shop, Field and Underground. Beltline Structure • Steel Buildings and Structures • Steel Erection

Licensed E100 Contractor

Full Service Welding and Fabrication Shop Vertical Mill, Lathe, Radial Arm Drill, 140 Ton Iron Worker, 100 Ton Press, Two 25 Ton Overhead Cranes and CNC Plasma Table

MIG • TIG • SMAW Oxy-Gas & Plasma Cutting Soldering & Brazing

Single, Double, Triple, & Custom Belt Brackets, Hangers & Plates Mono Rail Brackets, Hangers & Plates

Aluminum Copper Bronze

Cable Brackets & Hangers

Cast Iron Stainless Steel Mild Steel Alloy Welding.

Hose Brackets & Hangers

Custom Mine Duty Trailers, Skids, Tubs, and Tanks 1814 North 1500 West, Helper Utah 84526 • Phone: 435-637-3222 • Fax: 435-636-1322

46 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Renewable energy pros and cons: (Continued from page 39)

climate significantly affect Utah’s wind resources. As a result, Utah has a wide array of locations that may be viable options for wind energy development. The task force determined that the total area of Utah’s 52 wind sites is 1,838 square miles. The greatest concentration of wind resources is located near Milford, with an estimated capacity of 2,500 megawatts. Eleven Utah wind energy sites have a capacity of at least 250 megawatts each, for a total of 2,750 megawatts. According to Utah Clean Energy, this amount of wind would provide enough energy for over 660,000 average Utah homes and yield a net economic benefit of approximately $2.7 billion dollars and would create more than 1,110 long term jobs. Wind energy is particularly efficient at producing electricity, says environmental writer, Ian Callis. “Obviously you need a lot of

wind, like along coast lines and at high altitudes. Wind power could replace up to 20 percent of our total electric consumption in the foreseeable future.” Wind is a clean source of energy with no harmful by-products such as carbon dioxide. On the downside, wind power is intermittent. Consistent wind is needed for continuous power generation. If wind speed decreases, the turbine lingers and less electricity is generated. According to Utah Clean Energy, the prospect of wind-generated energy carries concerns about aesthetics, wildlife, and land use impacts, along with competition for high-demand commodities, such as steel and cranes. Geothermal energy literally means “earth heat.” It is thermal heat derived from the Earth. Geothermal energy harnesses the heat energy present underneath the earth. Hot rocks under the ground heat water to produce steam.

Desert Mountain Corporation Serving the Rocky Mountain region for over 20 years

When holes are drilled, the steam that shoots up is purified and is used to drive turbines, which power electric generators. According to Western Resource Advocates’ Renewable Energy Atlas of the West, Utah’s geothermal resource potential for electricity generation is approximately 1 million megawatt-hours annually. As of 2006, Utah was producing 4,000 megawatt-hours of electricity from geothermal sources. According to the Geothermal Task Force Report from the Western Governor’s Association, geothermal has the potential to supply 15,000 MW of electricity to the Western states by the year 2015. On the plus side, geothermal projects can strengthen rural economies, and. in some cases provide additional income to farmers and ranchers. Anaerobic Digestion Systems can provide farmers and ranchers with a viable means for reducing waste streams and generating on-site energy and/or fuels. Biofuels can also help reduce America’s dependence on imported oil. Challenges to geothermal development include transmission and distribution limitations, high up-front capital costs and limitations relating to water constraints. Hydroelectric energy is an energy source that is mainly derived from dams.

Electricity production from the water movement is clean and does not produce waste material. Tidal energy uses the natural tides of the ocean to produce energy much in the same way as hydroelectric energy, but on a smaller scale. Berry explains that over the past three decades, environmental laws have become more and more restrictive. “You can’t just throw up a dam on a river,” he said. Seeking approval from state and federal regulators can require years of effort. Many Utah hydropower projects are more than 40-years-old, utilizing facilities built in the late 1800s. With current energy high energy prices in a struggling economy, there is great interest in identifying energy resources that aren’t being fully utilized. Also, with many countries signing the Kyoto Treaty, which carries a goal of reducing greenhouse gas, efforts to reduce pollution and greenhouse gases are a primary focus in today’s culture. Alternative or renewable energy sources show significant promise in helping to reduce the amount of toxins that are byproducts of energy use. Not only do they protect against harmful by-products, but using alternative energy helps to preserve many of the natural resources that we currently use as sources of energy.

DUST CONTROL SOIL AND ROAD STABILIZATION EROSION CONTROL Licensed and bonded / No job too large or too small Call for a free quote today, 1-800-375-9264

Flaming Gorge Dam in Daggett County is a good example of a hydro-electric project built in the middle part of the 20th century. Most of the lake behind it lies in Wyoming and comes from the Cowboy State. The power goes to various venues around the west. Getting a dam built today in that same spot would face strong environmental opposition.

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 47

Water can be a problem for drilling operations By Mary Bernard Utah’s Division of Oil, Gas and Mining (DOGM) estimates that 90 percent of drilling waste is water. with the rest comprised of drilling mud andsludge. How much water? Roughly “150 million barrels of water (were) produced through drilling activities last year in Utah,” says Gil Hunt, DOGM associate director. Of that, 80 percent of the waste water is pumped underground, 14 percent is treated and discharged over the surface and six percent is transported to evaporation pits in the Uintah Basin’s disposal facilities. It’s six times the volume of drilling waste water disposed in 1999. And, not all of it comes from the Uintah Basin’s drilling activities. “Out-of-state waste comes in from drilling operators with facilities in two states, Utah and Colorado,“ says Hunt,

who explains the division’s regulatory authority doesn’t extend to neighboring states. How much drilling waste for disposal comes from out-of-state? When pressed about this, Hunt admits, “we just do not have an idea of the type or amount of waste being brought in for disposal in the Basin.” Speaking before the Board of Oil, Gas and Mining board meeting in Vernal last fall, Hunt said the problem of waste disposal was one of ever-increasing volume. “The practice of hauling reserve pits material to an off-site disposal facility is fruaght with problems,” Hunt wrote in a March 2009 DOGM memo. The memo states the division’s preferred regulatory stance is that water and other by-products form the drilling remain and be mitigated in place. That means injection over re-

moval. But finding suitable subsurface geology to inject waste materials or completing the regulatory compoliance for the process has been difficult. Hunt says that the alternative involves surface disposal facilities with “evaporation pits, landfarms, compost operations and water treatment surface discharge.” The regulations that govern drilling waste and water disposal are overseen by DOGM. According to the director the division is updating their procedures to face the growing demand for disposal and the abuse of existing regulations. For example, “operators are constructing deeper evaporation pits, taking more out-of-state waste, and placing •unauthorized waste in landfarms,” says Hunt. He recommends in the future that “no drilling mud, sludge or any wet non-water materials from reserve

pits and the drilling process be allowed at landfarms or other disposal facilities.” Some of the abuses of the disposal permits are inadvertent - others are intentional. Regulations regarding the disposal of chemical-ladened waste material and water vary by state. Colorado requires disclosure of chemicals in 50gallon drums to be disposed. But, no state requires complete information about the chemicals from reserve pits for disposal. The chemicals are residual fluids from hydraulic fracturing methods used in drilling. One, chemical compound is hydrogen sulphide, which accounts for the odor generally associated with evaporation pits. Hunt stated that better up-front methods for evaluating and monitoring treatment locations should from the divisions efforts in updating procedures.

48 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

March 2009 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 49

Western mines lead the way New roof bolting technologies are increasing performance and safety in underground mining By Russ Myers Managing Director, Brady Mining The goal in mining has always been to produce the largest possible tonnage at the lowest possible cost under the safest possible conditions. This focus on continuous improvement has always been at the forefront of mining here in the West. The economy may continue to fluctuate; however, demand for power generation remains strong and perhaps is the only constant in an environment of debate and political wrangling. To meet ever-increasing production demands, mine operators must keep their operations running with the latest technology available. A business located here in Utah is investing in developing products and technologies to increase production and safety with the hardest material known to man… Diamond. Mankind has revered the diamond for thousands of generations. It has been a symbol of strength and often associated with mystical properties. The phrase “diamond in the rough” ironically describes the untapped potential uses for diamond today. Brady Mining, located in Orem, has been adapting this technology to roof bolt drilling. It makes sense

to use the hardest material known to man in some of the hardest conditions known to man. Due to its excellent thermal stability and abrasion properties, a single diamond bit is capable of replacing hundreds of carbide bits while improving overall safety. The production challenge for many mine operators can be directly traced to traditional carbide bits, which have been used for decades in mining operations. These outdated bits quickly dull while drilling and need to be frequently replaced. The tedious task of continually replacing bits slows down the bolting process and limits the amount of coal that can be produced. Equipment downtime is opportunity lost, severely decreasing production and creating safety concerns as miners scramble to replace roof bolting bits before mining operations can continue. New and continually advancing diamond technology is delivering results for many mine operators throughout the world. These innovative new tools are allowing miners to drill faster, increase tonnage, reduce equipment downtime and improve overall safety. Using polycrystalline diamond (PDC), Brady Mining ceramic roof bolt bits are delivering unmatched performance and cost savings.

Polycrystalline diamond bits are safer to use and are more efficient than traditional carbide bits.

Brady Mining uses polycrystalline diamond (PDC) to develop arguably the strongest roof bolting bits used in the mining industry.

According to the U.S. Bureau of Mines, “three substantial improvements that make PDC bits more cost effective and safer to use have been reported. First, PDC drill bits have shown to have a bit life of 200-600 times longer than the conventional WC-Co (carbide) bits. Second, the penetration rate of PDC bits is about 40 percent higher than WC-Co (carbide), requiring fewer labor hours to install the bolts. The increase in bit life can also dramatically reduce non-fatal injuries associated with roof bolting because of reduced driller interaction with the roof bolter. Third, when using PDC bits, there is a much smaller chance for frictional ignition of methane, which is present in many mines” (Comparison of Respirable Dust Generation, Laxman S. Sundae, et. al., 1995). The Brady Mining PDC bit design not only saves overall cost by replacing hundreds of carbide bits, but it also results in a large time savings when weighted against replacing carbide bits on a frequent basis. This allows miners to quickly support the roof and reduce their exposure. Additionally, the unique structure of diamond in a PDC bit allows for the diamond edge to maintain its sharpness throughout the life of the bit. In contrast, carbide roof bits immediately begin to dull, creating a wear flat on the

cutting edge – requiring more thrust, which significantly lowers the rate of penetration from the start to the eventual completion of the hole. Unfortunately, this carbide wear flat also begins to pulverize the rock instead of cutting and removing it, generating much more respirable dust than with diamond bits. The U.S. Bureau of Mines further reported, “results show that when drilling dry, the polycrystalline diamond compact bits produced 71–88 percentless dust than the tungsten carbide bit.” Given the many apparent benefits created with the use of diamond miners were quick to accept Brady PDC bits. Brady Mining is the leader in highdensity ceramic roof bolt mining tools for both wet and dust hog applications – focused on improving the production and safety of today’s underground mining operations. The engineering expertise and unique diamond technology built into every product makes Brady Mining tools perhaps the longest lasting and most technically advanced products on the market. Brady Mining offers a proven track record of performance, delivering unmatched durability and toughness from the easiest to the most difficult of roof-bolting conditions. For more information on Brady Mining roof bolt bits and other products, call 800-535-7419 or visit:

50 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Local news – it’s what we do. And it’s freely available online, 24/7

Sun Advocate

Emery County


March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 51

Helping you produce the Energy we all use

New 24 Hour Pay at Pump for Public Fueling All major credit cards accepted at the pump SERVING CARBON, EMERY, UINTAH AND DUCHESNE COUNTIES

Nothing says ‘power’ like a generator Electrical generators are at the heart of every power plant. While they may vary in shape, size and output, they all do the same thing – convert mechanical energy to electrical energy. Carbon and Emery counties are actually home to more than a half dozen mass-production electrical generators.

STANDARD LABORATORIES, INC. Coal Analysis and Sampling Environmental Capabilities Soil, Overburden, & Rock Mechanics Contract Laboratory Operation Quality Assurance Programs Skyline Facility 345 East 625 North, Huntington, UT 84528 Telephone: (435) 448-2644 Fax: (435) 820-8936

. . . Where quality is standard!

Gasoline • Diesel • Oil Chevron & Conoco Lubricants Mining, Gas Exploration Take it to the MAX. Automotive Engine Oils

352 W. Main, Price • 435-637-0094 •

Standard Laboratories, Inc. is an analytical services firm specializing in energy and the environment. We began over a halfcentury ago as a family business in Appalachian coal country, producing accurate high integrity data at a fair price. We’re still committed to those friendly, reliable, cost-effective solutions Standard Laboratories, Inc. has been the contract laboratory for Arch Coal Inc. since 2000, servicing their 3 Utah coal mines with 2 labs in Utah. The labs are located in Salina, servicing SUFCo and onsite at Skyline Mine, servicing Dugout Canyon and Skyline mines. The need for more analysis and service in the Castle Valley has provided Standard Laboratories, Inc. the opportunity to open a lab in Huntington Utah last year. The lab will provide coal analysis, sampling, sampler inspections, as well as gas analysis for underground mines. Standard Laboratories, Inc. currently operates over forty laboratories in the U.S. specializing in coal sampling and analysis, with additional analytical capability in soil, water, environmental and geochemical matrices. Testing capabilities are comprehensive, ranging from routine mine control work and large washability studies to trace analyses for over one thousand analytes and complex research programs.

52 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Nielsen Construction faces busy year As winter slowly gives way to spring Nielson Construction is preparing to gear up for another busy production season in the Carbon and Emery county area. Nielson crews worked through the winter on a number of projects throughout the area and when spring arrives the workload will intensify as new projects gear up. Nielson Construction started out more than 40 years ago by providing service to energy producers in the area, particularly customers in mining and power and today that tradition continues as the company has expanded its capabilities to provide service in the oil and gas field and many others. It has been the diversity of the compa-

ny and its people that has helped it to weather economic storms throughout the years. One of the newest services the company provides was unveiled in 2009 when the company expanded into the concrete business and opened Nielson Concrete Services outside of Price. New to the concrete business, Wayne and John Nielson, president and vice president, set a goal for their company and people to provide the best service possible for their concrete customers and by year’s end the new plant had surpassed its first year production goals. With the spring thaw Nielson Construction people and equipment are ready to go to work for energy producers throughout the area.

Nielson Construction’s new concrete plant just off of Highway 10.

The people you know - The quality you expect - The service you can trust. Major Repair Engine Replacement • Injection Cleaning Diesel • Complete Auto Repair • Transmission Replacement • Scheduled Maintenance • Tire Rotation • Differential • Cleaning - Waxing


911 E. 100 No., Price 637-4493 • Mon-Fri 8:30 am - 6:00 pm Sat 8:30 am -1:30 pm


DRIVE LINE SPECIALIST • FREE LOCAL TOWING 925 East 100 North, Price • 637-8494 • Hours Mon-Fri 8am- 5:30 pm


955 East 100 North • 637-8512

Proud to be a supporter of the energy industry. FREE Local Towing for Major Repairs

Owner Joe Piccolo

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 53

Has an astounding 400+ new & used vehicles on the lot for you to choose from. We won’t be undersold.


“everybody gets a great deal”








Your Fleet SPECIALIST Contact Rhonda Boylen, Fleet Manager for details

Everybody gets a Great Deal! 1355 South Carbon Avenue Highway 10, Price

637-0110 • 637-4200


tonybassogm .com

54 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Call Toll Free 1-866-668-9382


Your ENERGY TRAINING PROVIDER for Utah . . . We view TRAINING as an investment, not an expense

“Training Where, When, and How YOU Need It” MINING PROGRAM Coal - Metal - Nonmetal MSHA 30 CFR Part 48

• New Miner Training for Surface / Underground • Annual Refresher for Surface / Underground

Recertification / Upgrade • • • •

Mine Foreman / Fireboss Training Mining Electrical Recertification Diesel Qualification Train the Trainer - Part 48

MSHA 30 CFR Part 46

• Shell Dredging - Sand / Gravel Surface Stone • Surface Clay - Colloidal Phosphate Surface Limestone

Specialty Training • • • • • • •

First Aid / CPR HAZCOM - Hazardous Communications Mine Rescue Fire Fighting Accident Prevention Supervisory Traininig Other Site-Specific Topics

We develop customized programs with the customer that meet their needs through: • On-site training • Open-Entry Courses • Competency-based instruction Personalized, quality instruction • Flexible scheduling and curriculum • Task-specific instruction aligned with the needs of business and industry


OSHA Courses Compliance (OSHA standards) Mechanics Hydraulics Maintenance Electrical Leadership Other Offerings As Requested

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 55

Your local news and more...we bring you the latest information on what’s happening in Carbon & Emery Counties

Sun Advocate 435-637-0732

In-County 6 months $25.00 In-State 6 months $28.00 Out-of-state 6 months $36.00

1 year $42.00 1 year $46.00 1 year $61.00

Emery County

Progress 435-381-2431

In-County 6 months $12.50 In-State 6 months $16.00 Out-of-state 6 months $19.00

1 year $25.00 1 year $30.00 1 year $35.00

Call 435-381-2431 for out of county or out of state rates. Mail form to: 410 E. Main, Castle Dale, UT 84513

Call 435-637-0732 for out of county or out of state rates. Mail form to: 845 E. Main, Price, UT 84501

Name ______________________________________________

Name ______________________________________________

Address _____________________________________________

Address _____________________________________________

City ________________________________ State ___________

City ________________________________ State ___________

Zip ________________________________ Phone __________

Zip ________________________________ Phone __________

56 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

The “houses” that energy built Money from the energy industry has been supporting the eastern Utah region for years. But most people think of it in the form of wages and taxes, and forget about royalties and severance fees companies pay to extract coal, gas and other minerals from the ground. Some of the money they pay comes back to the communities in the area through the special service districts. Some comes from the Permanent Community Impact Board. Some comes to the counties in other ways. These dollars have been spent on a myriad of projects over the years, some of which are pictured on this page.

North Springs Recreation Area (shooting range).

The new senior center at the Carbon County Fairgrounds (and the East Carbon Senior Center, not shown). Dugout Canyon Road.

The Carbon County Ambulance Garage on Airport Road and the Sunnyside/East Carbon Public Saftey building (not shown).

The new Childrens Justice Center/Family Support Center (under construction).

The Carbon County Events Center.

March 2010 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Carbon/Emery Energy Guide â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 57

Research shows coal industry, strong industry: (Continued from page 47) indicate the researchers. The coal-fueled electricity study was conducted by Adam Rose and Bo Yang, economists at Penn State University. Professor Rose heads the department of energy environmental and mineral economics. Rose and research assistant Yang used certain economic assumptions to present the findings. In the first instance, the study assumes varying levels of linkage between the coal-based electricity generation industry and other sectors of the economy. The maximum versus minimum linkage variable measures the degree to which coal-based electricity produces ripple effects that benefit other industries and sectors. The data is refined by taking into account the economic effects of using a higher-cost fuel â&#x20AC;&#x201C; in this case natural gas â&#x20AC;&#x201C; as a substitute for

low-cost coal. By factoring in the substitution prices, the study shows how coalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s economic advantages are even greater when considering the costs of using a more expensive alternative fuel to generate electricity, explain the Penn State analysts. The year 2010 was selected for modeling because regulatory programs aimed at displacing coal would need to be implemented over time, added the researchers. Because reliance on coal as a fuel source for generating electricity varies from region to region throughout the United States, the economic benefits are not evenly spread across the nation. The economic advantages for coal-producing states are evident, confirm the study results. More surprising, however, are the economic benefits realized by states that do not produce coal, but

use it as a primary fuel for electricity generation. The study concludes that coalbased electricity will result in substantial economic benefits for large and small states alike, explain the Penn State researchers. For example, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Texas and Pennsylvania stand to gain from $21 billion to $32 billion in increased economic output. Smaller states also share in the advantages provided by coal-generated electricity. For example, New Hampshire, Connecticut, Oregon and South Dakota are projected to gain from $560 million to $720 million in expanded output, according to the research findings. â&#x20AC;&#x153;This new analysis proves what we have known for a long time,â&#x20AC;? points out Stephen Miller, president and chief executive officer of the Center for Energy and Economic De-

velopment. â&#x20AC;&#x153;Electricity from coal provides economic empowerment to local communities, small businesses and working families,â&#x20AC;? adds the energy and development centerâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s chief executive officer. According to Miller, the study provides an additional level of details relative to the ongoing national energy policy debate. â&#x20AC;&#x153;Despite electricity from coalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s low cost and improving environmental performance, some special interest groups still believe we should abandon this abundant domestic energy resource,â&#x20AC;? explained the centerâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s executive officer. â&#x20AC;&#x153;The Rose-Yang study provides additional empirical proof that coalbased electricity is an essential element of a balanced energy portfolio that increases energy security and provides economic empowerment for American families,â&#x20AC;? concluded Miller.

4HE5NITED-INE7ORKERSOF!MERICA !&, #)/#,# Fighting for Working Families for 120 Years


7EARE'2%%.(/53%7/2+%23 AND42%% 42)--%23


7EARETHEPROUDMENANDWOMENOFTHE5-7! 7EARE0!2!-%$)#3AND.523).'(/-%7/2+%23


7EARE#/!,-).%23AND #/5.49'/6%2.-%.47/2+%23

7EARE7).$/7#,%!.%23AND #/.3425#4)/.7/2+%23


58 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Ask your outlets to open up and say AAHHHH. We have programs, tips and ideas to help you identify the best ways to save energy, plus cash incentives to help make the savings happen. Your home will be in top energy shape in no time. © 2010 Rocky Mountain Power

You’ll find all sorts of energy-saving answers at

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 59

The future of coal and technology (Continued from page 28) the state’s electricity. The majority of Utah’s coal is found in the Wasatch Plateau, Bookcliffs and Emery Fields. Two of Utah’s nine mining operations are considered to be major U.S. coal producers – Dugout in Carbon County and Sufco in Sevier County. In 2008, Utah ranked 14th in the nation for coal production and produced more than 24 million short tons of coal, which represents more than one percent of the total U.S. coal production in that year. The ability to build coal power plants remains under threat due to political and environmental pressures at the state and national levels. The costs to build new plants are another issue. Estimates to build a clean coal power plant project related costs at $1.5 billion with four years of construction. Comparatively, constructing a nuclear power plant can cost more than $2 billion and take five years to complete. That’s why the government is looking towards creating clean coal technology. The idea is to research and develop better ways of using coal for many different purposes. They also cite that clean coal technologies can create jobs, increase energy security, address climate concerns and coal conversion technologies, which can help unlock coal’s full potential. Tom Sarkus, deputy director of the Office of Major Demonstrations with the National Energy Technology Laboratory, knows how important coal is for the country and the world. He thinks energy in the U.S. is like a three-legged stool with petroleum, natural gas and coal each representing a leg. Since coal plays such a large role on the economy and the country in general, he said replacing coal with renewable energies is easier said than done.

Sarkus said peaking energy sources, such as wind turbines, solar and natural gas, are not cost effective compared to coal. Natural gas tends to follow gas prices and coal prices tend to follow natural gas. The price of coal is less than oil and natural gas, making it a stable source price-wise for the country. “We have a relative abundance of coal and it’s very economical here because it’s a solid fuel,” Sarkus said. According to U.S. Energy Information Administration, there are about 500 billion tons of coal available here in the U.S., but only about 55 percent of it is recoverable. About 1 billion tons of coal is used each year in the U.S., leaving a forecast of coal being a dominant resource for the next 50 to 100 years. Coal production reached a record level of 1,171.8 million short tons and the average mine-level prices increased by 21 percent to $31.25 per short ton. The number of employees increased by 6.9 percent while the national productivity declined by 4.9 percent to 5.96 short tons per miner per hour, according to the U.S. EIA Web site. There are approximately 5,400 power plants in the U.S., with about 600 powered by coal. With so many powered by coal, the push to make them run more efficiently and cleaner is bigger than before. When the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, commonly known as the stimulus, was passed, it included about $4.6 billion for fossil fuel research and development, according to John Grasser, director of fossil communications with the Department of Energy. “There was a realization inside the government in that coal is not going away,” Grasser said. “The U.S. is the Saudi Arabia of coal compared to the rest of the world.

We need to continue to learn how to use it in a cleaner and more efficient manner.” While much of the talk in the political spectrum focuses on green or clean energy jobs, there is still the possibility for a lot of growth in the future with coal-related jobs. With research needing to take place and the implementation of new technology in coal power plants, Grasser thinks clean coal technology will play a big role in the future. “I’m pretty optimistic about this (clean coal) working out in the future so we can really get around to testing out new technologies and possibly putting them into place. I don’t think we can just close all of the coal power plants and rely on other sources and fuels right now. “But none of this will happen overnight. It will take some time for this to take place,” Grasser said.

A smoke stack at a local power plant.


• Drill Core Analysis • Apparent Specific Gravity • Total Moisture • Proximate Analysis • Hardgrove Grindability • Size Tests

• Fusibility of Ash • Mineral Ash Analysis • Ultimate Analysis • Environmental Water Analysis • International Round Robin Program

Accredited by the American Association for Laboratory Accreditation (A2LA) for Coal Analysis Certified by State of Utah for the Clean Water Act (NELAP)

60 locations are available to fulfill all of your analytical and technical requirements. Utah Operations

Western Operations Headquarters

2035 North Airport Rd., Huntington, UT 85428 4665 Paris St. B-200, Denver, CO 80239 Phone: 435-653-2311 • Fax 435-653-2436 Phone: 303-373-4772 • Fax 303-373-4884 Contact: T.C.V. Coco Van den Bergh Contact: Marc Rademacher

When you need to be sure - SGS

60 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Miners Hospital brings services to workers: (Continued from page 44)

fered a leg injury 40 years earlier. “He had problems with it all along,” he pointed out. In networking with the doctors at the Miners Hospital, Oviatt described the mining equipment and explained how the injury might have happened. “They took X-rays, found the problem and were able to repair it,” he recalls. “That man does not limp on it any more. He doesn’t experience quite as much pain after years of suffering. The Miners Hospital has provided an immense benefit, to our retirees in particular.” The hospital was established following a long legal battle in which four disabled members of the United Mine Workers of America filed a complaint against the state of Utah, the Institutional Trust Lands Administration and state officials and agencies for not building such a hospital. The lawsuit cited the 1894 Utah Enabling Act, which authorized Utahns to create a state constitution. The act included a section designat-

ing 50,000 acres of land specifically for “a miner’s hospital for disabled miners.” to be conveyed at the time of statehood. A similar land allotment for an additional 50,000 acres took place in 1929. The lawsuit contended that no miner’s hospital was built from proceeds after the land was sold. In 1957, the legislature approved a bill diverting revenue from the miner’s hospital trust to the University Medical Center’s rehabilitation unit. In 1959, funds generated from the land were sent to the University of Utah and utilized for a rehabilitation center. The suit alleged that Utah had breached the trust by using the trust corpus and revenue for the benefit of the general public rather than disabled miners. In 2001, Salt Lake City attorney James Vilos, one of several lawyers representing the miners, argued that while the Utah attorney general maintained that the miners received free medical care at the University of Utah, after checking with the hospital there,

Carbon Chiropractic Center Chiropractic care making LIFE better 39 N. 600 E., Price 435-637-0450

Leading the field in:

* Spinal Decompression * Electrical Stem * Gentle Traction * Rehabilitation/counseling Sports Rehabilitation * New K-Laser * Diathermy * Bio-Meridian nutritional counseling * Laser Accupuncture

Dr. M. Kenneth Thayn Dr. John W. Thayn & Staff

Gentle Chiropractic Adjustments and care for the whole family

Serving Castle Country for 72 yrs and the tradition continues

“some of my clients have found there is no program in place,” he said. Vilos explained to the court that the rehabilitation center at the University of Utah did not handle miningrelated occupational ailments such as black lung disease. Vilos contended that, unless the miners’ ailment fit into the category of a traumatic brain, spinal cord injury or burn, they did not receive the same kind of care that they would receive if they drove to Raton, N.M., to be treated at the miners hospital there. Vilos explained that the New Mexico hospital was financed by a similar congressional land grant. The attorney added that, as far as he could determine, not a single miner had thus far received free medical treatment for a condition resulting from a miner’s injury or illness at the University of Utah. Robert Sykes, another attorney representing the miners, argued that while thousands of victims of trauma, spinal cord injuries and other maladies were treated at the rehabilitation unit, “you’re not free to expend trust funds for some public good. It has to be [used] specifically for the purpose for which they were allocated.” “The facts unmistakably demonstrate that the rehab center did not exclusively benefit miners. Rather, it operated as a service for the general public,” continued Sykes. In 2003, the 3rd District Court of Salt Lake County reached final order of settlement in the lawsuit. The court ruling stipulated that miners have unique health and disability problems related to their industry, especially in the area of pulmonary ailments, and have need of specialized care. The settlement order specified that the University of Utah would rename the rehabilitation center as The University of Utah Rehabilitation Center and Miners Hospital. The court ruling also stated that a stand-alone hospital would not be required, because disabled miners would have available to them a broader range of services than they would otherwise have if the state used the funds to build a stand-alone miners hospital. Today, to be eligible for hospital

services, a potential patient must have a mining-related illness or injury. Eligibility requirements also specify that the applicant needs to have worked in a coal, metal or non-metal mining operation for at least two years. Requirements also include residency in Utah for two years immediately before applying for hospital services. A completed application is required before an appointment can be scheduled for a miner. Applications for treatment appointments are available by calling toll-free at (866) 864-6377. Residents may also visit the Miners Hospital Web site at and print an application. “Many muscular-skeletal problems are treated at the hospital,” explains Dana Hughes, the medical treatment facility’s outreach coordinator. “These problems occur because of the type of conditions under which miners work; cramped quarters, low ceilings and heavy manual labor.” As in the case of Oviatt, noise-related hearing loss is another mining-related health issue faced by the patients. “While federal regulatory agencies have done a lot to try to reduce the noise level through engineering control and work assignments, miners who work in closed mines are exposed to tremendous amounts of noise,” Hughes explained. “This exposure has a negative impact on miners’ hearing.” The hospital conducts many hearing evaluations, added the representative. “Our program is such that we can provide hearing aids for those who have an indication of noise-related hearing loss,” pointed out Hughes. The hospital representative said the hearing tests are able to differentiate between age-related hearing loss and noise-related hearing loss. Many miners also suffer from pulmonary problems due to their proximity to dust and diesel exhaust. “Along with exposure to elements that contribute to lung problems such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, many of the miners smoke. The combination of the two factors contributes to pulmonary problems,” Hughes indicated. (Continued on page 64)

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 61

Does Sevier experience set stage for future: (Continued from page 9) for nearly a decade. The first signs of the proposal started in 2001 when a 330-foot meteorological tower was installed near the proposed site. At the time locals were told it was being done by the TDA Foundation, which as it turns out, is an organization that was made up of all the same principals as Nevco Energy. The tower was used to monitor atmospheric data, which was later used in the creation of an air quality permit application to the Utah Division of Air Quality. That permit was granted in October 2004. The permit was issued with over two dozen rather detailed restrictions, some of which resulted from a a public hearing in which the UDAQ took public comment and incorportated those into the air quality plan. In November 2004, the Sierra Club and the Grand Canyon Trust appealed the decision to the Utah Air Quality Board. At the time the Sierra Club maintained that not only would

the plant would harm the air in the area, but that it would also create vision and haze problems at nearby national parks. In July 2007, the Sierra Club was granted standing in the appeals case and oral arguments were heard in October of that year. The issue of who would have standing in the appeal of Nevco Energy’s air quality permit for the plant was key. “They will ask whoever has standing to get together and propose a schedule,” said Fred Nelson, legal counsel for the Utah Air Quality Board at the time. He said if the various parties couldn’t agree on a schedule for the appeal hearing, then the board would create a schedule. Nevco Energy consultant. Bruce Taylor said the appeal was a part of the process and that Nevco was optimistic about the outcome at the time. “We really don’t think there is a problem,” Taylor said. At the time the Sevier citizen’s group was asked for more

A natural gas powered power plant in Utah County (Vineland).

information to clarify why it should have standing in the appeals. A document was submitted in response to that request to the Utah Air Quality Board. The document detailed what members of the Sevier citizens group believe gave them a standing in the appeals process. “I’m in the fight of my life,” said James Kennon, president of the Sevier citizen’s group. The document outlined 14 concerns the Sevier citizen’s group had with the proposed power plant. Some of the claims made in the document included • The DAQ didn’t take into account the combined emissions of the other proposed power plants in Utah before issuing the permit. • The DAQ didn’t consider the use of integrated gasification combined cycle, a process that is cleaner than the proposed circulating fluidized bed. The claim was that it was not in the state’s policy of requiring best available control technology. • Scheduled control bums by the Fishlake and Dixie national forests were not taken into ccount. • Effects on the appearance of the county caused by both the physical footprint of the plant and the pollution were not accounted for in the permit. At the time, the group was asking for the permit to be declared illegal. On Nov. 7, the Utah Air Quality Board threw out the Sierra Club’s case, ruling that the company had provided the information that Utah regulations required. The fight then moved to the zoing commission in Sevier County. By this time a coalition of local citizens known as the Sevier

Citizens for Clean Air and Water had organized in opposition to the plant. They questioned the very license the plant was requesting to operate. This group would later become instrumental in keeping the plant from coming to fruition. In December of 2007, by a 3-2 vote, the Sevier County Planning and Zoning Commission approved the preliminary conditional use permit for the plant. The meeting was filled with angry people who claimed the company was lying to them about both the effects of the air pollution and the ash that would be produced by the plant. At that point, citizens groups and environmentalists began looking for other ways to stop the plant’s construction. The came upon the idea of putting the conditional use permit on the ballot instead of letting a small number of people make the decision. In November 2008, voters in Sevier County overwhelmingly approved a grassroots initiative requiring a public vote to allow a new coal-fired power plant in the area. The measure amended the zoning ordinance so that the county could not issue a conditional-use permit to a coal plant without voter approval. A 6th District judge halted the citizen referendum in October, but the state Supreme Court overturned the ruling. There were also questions whether any such vote would be legal because Nevco’s application and approval came before any such measure could be put in place. At the time, the success of the measure left the future of NEVCO’s proposed plant uncertain. At the time the company’s attorney said NEVCO may try to move the project to a different county or switch the plant to (Continued on page 62)

62 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Does Sevier experience set stage for future: (Continued from page 9) natural gas. In late 2008, lawyers for Sevier Power sent a letter to the Sevier County Commission asking them to make a final decision on the plant by January, 2009. But the decision was delayed and on May 1, 2009, Sevier Power delayed the county commissioners’ decision until two pending lawsuits could be resolved. One lawsuit concerned the county’s initial zoning approval and another, which had reached the Utah Supreme Court, was an appeal of the air quality permit issued by the state. On Dec. 4, 2009, the Utah Supreme Court overturned the Sevier Plant’s air permit, calling the Utah Division of Air Quality Board’s review of the permit “woefully inaccurate.” The court ruled in favor of the Sierra Club and remanded the permit over inadequate nitrogen

oxide limits and failure to consider integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) as a best available control technology. The ruling also held that the permit had expired, because the company failed to start construction within 18 months after it was issued. In early March (2010) representatives from the company were asked to provide a list of options by the Sevier County Commission. “There have been a lot of things that have happened with this over the past few months,” said Gary Mason, county commission member. He said since a lawsuit over the project’s zoning had been dismissed, one impediment to the process had been removed. But the commission also brought up the Utah Supreme Court decisions. “The significance of which the county is trying to ascertain,”

Mason said. “(However) we still have a valid application on our desks.” He said while the application may still have some obstacles, the county would like to move forward with the process – be that ultimately approving a power plant or not. “Is it fair to ask for 30 days for you to come back to us with some ideas?” asked Mason. Rod Clark, principal for Nevco, said his company was not ready to provide the options, but would write a letter outlining the options to the county commission before the commission’s first scheduled meeting in April. Clark said Nevco’s legal team is also still trying to sort out the Utah Supreme Court decisions. Since the permit was remanded back to the Utah Division of Air Quality for review, setting a deadline serves the purpose of the prevention of

significant deterioration of the program. Sevier Power has to submit additional information concerning integrated gasification combined cycle technology. With that meeting, the saga of the Sevier Power Station is on hold. The company has now suggested they may want to burn natural gas instead, but some in the county even oppose that, saying the plant would still be a source of pollution and an eyesore. The future of new coal fired plants getting approved almost anywhere in America now seems dim, between local opposition and well organized environmental movements battling their construction at every turn. Of course that might change should those same people’s lights go just as dim because of a lack of power generation within their given grid.

MINE SYSTEMS COMPANY Electrical, Electronic Control, Instrumentation, Automation, Battery, Power, Parts & Systems

Since 1996 - “We’ll Do It Right For You!”



MINE SYSTEMS COMPANY 110 WEST 400 NORTH HELPER, UTAH 84526 PHONE: (435) 472-3700 FAX: (435) 472-3800

Modern tech changes older power plants Modern, computer-driven management systems are replacing a lot of older analog-based predecessors in many power plants across the nation. In some cases, a single desktop computer can replace and entire control room full of monitors and controls.

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 63

Badlands Fab and Machine expands Badlands Fab & Machine is entering into the tenth year of business with expanded capabilities. Badlands has recently moved into a building five times larger than their original one. This larger facility includes 50 ton overhead crane capacity. A new service that is being offered is a full-service steel center. Metal is available for everyone, individuals and companies. Badlands will sell, cut, bend, punch, drill, tap and turn to customers specs. Metal will be kept on hand and special orders can be placed. Badlands Fab & Machine has an E100 contractors license. This license enables them to fabricate and erect steel structures and buildings. They are available to fabricate on site or on location.

Badlands also has a new CNC plasma table. With this piece of equipment and the talent that they have, they can create custom metal art, such as wall hangings, fireplace screens, tables, chairs, headboards and footboards, signs, flatbeds, handrails, and railings. New and old customers can count on their exceptional workmanship, dependability, and customer service. Badlands continues to fabricate and repair custom mine duty trailers, skids, tubs, tanks, belt line structures, and many other items. Badlands Fab & Machine is located at 1814 North 1500 West Carbonville (The former DBT Building). The new phone number is (435) 637-FABB and the fax number is (435) 6131FAB.

High Quality Name Brand Flooring

Consulting Civil Engineers & Land Surveyors • • • • • •

Mines Water Supply Pipelines Roads Sanitary Works Dams

• • • •

Surveying Subdivisions Legal Surveys Construction Staking

Excellence for more than 38 years


Box 487 • Castle Dale, Utah 84513 • Telephone (435) 381-2523

Get a square deal on the right flooring for your home with our vast selection of high-quality, name brand flooring! Plush, soft carpeting… The earthy look and feel of imported tiles… Smooth, shiny hardwood…

It’s all here. See our showroom today for an incredible selection!

Cloyd’s Floor Store “Quality you can stand on!”

66 East Main, Price • 637-5146

64 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

Miners Hospital brings services to workers: (Continued from page 60) The hospital at the U of U has also treated some cases of occupational asthma and a few cases of black lung disease, “although the coal here in Utah is not as prone to create black lung as is the coal in the Eastern states,” added the facility’s outreach coordinator Once it is determined that the individual suffers from a miningrelated condition and the patient is treated for that condition, the person’s health insurance is billed first. Then the Miners Hospital pays for remaining medical treatment expenses. If a miner has no health insurance, the Miners Hospital will pay for the cost of reasonable treatment, “whatever is considered reasonable for that condition,” notes Hughes. The hospital also pays for medications related to the mining-related illness or injury. The hospital provides medications by mail for disabled coal miners undergoing treatment who live away from Salt Lake City. Some miners who are treated at the hospital are older than age 70. “A lot of miners’ health prob-

lems occur following multiple years of wear and tear on the body,” points out Hughes. “Some of them have worked in the mine 20 or 30 years and have acquired cumulative injuries.” Although many of the patients return to work in the mines following treatment, others are retired miners who are no longer actively employed in the coal industry. Most patients are treated as outpatients. But procedures like knee replacement or carpal tunnel surgery are performed on an inpatient basis. “The Miners Hospital isn’t what you would typically think of as a hospital with beds specifically set aside for miners,” explains Hughes. “The hospital is part of the University health care system.” “Patients are hospitalized in the regular university hospital. They have access to all the specialty cares, such as the orthopedic or pulmonary specialists,” continued the outreach coordinator. Utilizing the expertise of the U of U medical personnel broadens the scope of possible treatment for miners, added Hughes. “We can also keep the costs of

medical services lower by doing this,” indicated the outreach coordinators. “In some cases, miners who live a distance away from Salt Lake City are referred to an outside health care system that is located closer to their home.” Patients are prescribed treatments like physical therapy and substance abuse treatment if their conditions are found to be mining-related. “Some occupations appear to have a higher incidence of alcohol and drug problems than others,” commented Hughes. “Mining appears to be one of these–as is the health care profession.” Patients are evaluated on a case by case basis to determine whether their substance abuse is considered to be mining-related. Along with medical treatment, the Miners Hospital offers education and outreach to patients in the form of seminars and conferences. “We conduct an annual education program in the Price and Magna areas and visit senior centers throughout the state where mines are located,” points out Hughes. In June, the hospital will col-

Automation, capacity highlight today’s coal transportation Much has changed in the coal mining business since the latter part of the nineteeth century, when a lot of coal was shoveled by hand by labororers. More modern systems built within the last thirty or fourty years can move many more times the coal with a mere fraction of the labor.

laborate with the U of U school on alcoholism and drug dependencies to co-sponsor a conference for the third year, according to the facility representatives. The conference will focus on alcohol and drug misuse inside and outside of the mines. The mining industry section is planned for supervisors, foremen, health and safety officers; training specialists, human resource personnel, operators, representatives from unions, mining associations and MSHA and others interested in the prevention and management of alcohol and substance misuse within the mining workforce. Multiple registration fee scholarships are available from the Utah Division of Substance Abuse and Mental Health on a first-come, first-serve basis for individuals who have not previously attended the conference. Residents may obtain more information by calling (801) 5384343 or toll-free (866) 864-6377. The hospital has agreed, as part of the lawsuit settlement, to provide scholarships for tuition and books at the U of U to two children or grandchildren of disabled miners annually. One scholarship is specified for students applying to the health care field. The other may be applied toward any major. Currently, four students are attending the U of U through the four- year scholarship. “Two more will be added next year,” noted Hughes. Hughes and Oviatt stress the importance of increasing awareness of the Miners Hospital “We need to get the word out that the hospital is here for all miners,” said Oviatt. “It doesn’t make a difference whether you are management or labor force. Your labor organization affiliation doesn’t matter. The hospital is there for miners to get the help that they need. If you work in the mining industry, this resource is there for you.”

March 2010 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – 65 T9 S R3E

T9 S R4E

T 5 S R 12 W T5 S R2E


T5 S R9W

T5 S R8W

T5 S R5W

T5 S R6W

T5 S R7W

T9 S R8E



T9 S R7E

T9 S R7E

T 6 S R 11 W

T5 S R3W

T5 S R4W


£ ¤


T 6 S R 10 W



T 10 S R 7 E

T 10 S R 8 E T 10 S R 15 E

( !


T 10 S R 14 E T7 S R7W T 7 S R 7 WT 10 S R 12 E T 10 S R 12 E

T7 S R8W

T7 S R9W

T7 S R6W

T7 S R5W

T 10 S R 13 E


T 10 S R 11 E T 7 S R 10 W

T 10 S R 9 E

T7 S R4W

BAD T 11 S R 6 E

T 11 S R 5 E

T 11 S R 4 E

º ¹

T 11 S R 7 E

T 11 S R 8 E


(Colton !

T 11 S R 12 E

T 11 S R 11 E

T 11 S R 9 E


T 11 S R 13 E

Gordon Creek 3 & 6 Mine Gordon Creek 2,7, & 8 Mine

T 14 S R 6 E Huntington Reservoir Cleveland Reservoir

T 14 S R 5 E

Trail Canyon Mine

T 16 S R 6 E

T 16 S R 5 E




º ¹ ( !

Huntington º Lake ¹

º ¹

( !


T 17 S R 10 E

T 17 S R 12 E

T 17 S R 11 E

T 18 S R 6 E

( !




º ¹ 10

º ¹ 57

( !


Cr ee

T 16 S R 17 E

T 16 S R 18 E


T 17 S R 16 E

T 17 S R 18 E T 17 S R 17 E


( !

T 18 S R 13 E

Woodside T 18 S R 16 E

T 18 S R 15 E

T 18 S R 14 E

T 18 S R 17 E


T 19 S R 4 E Ferron Reservoir

T 17 S R 21 E T 17 S R 20 E

T 18 S R 19 E

T 18 S R 21 E T 18 S R 20 E

( !

T 18 S R 18 E

T 19 S R 18 E T 19 S R 17 E

T 19 S R 16 E

T 19 S R 15 E

T 19 S R 14 E

T 19 S R 13 E



T 19 S R 12 E

T 19 S R 11 E

T 19 S R 10 E

T 19 S R 9 E

T 19 S R 8 E

T 19 S R 7 E

T 19 S R 6 E


T 19 S R 20 E T 19 S R 19 E



T 19 S R 3 E

T 19 S R 5 E

T 17 S R 19 E


Castle Dale

BECKWITH Duck Fork Reservoir

T 16 S R 20 E T 16 S R 21 E

T 16 S R 19 E


£ ¤



Orangeville ( !

T 18 S R 11 E

T 18 S R 10 E

T 18 S R 9 E

T 18 S R 8 E

T 18 S R 7 E

T 16 S R 16 E

T 17 S R 15 E

T 17 S R 14 E

T 17 S R 13 E

(Huntington !

T 18 S R 12 E T 18 S R 5 E T 18 S R 4 E


R iv e


T 18 S R 3 E

T 15 S R 20 E

T 15.5 S R 21 E


T 16 S R 15 E

T 16 S R 14 E

T 16 S R 13 E

T 15 S R 19 E

T 15 S R 18 E



T 17 S R 9 E

Des-Bee-Dove Mine

T 14 S R 20 E T 14 S R 19 E

T 15 S R 17 E

Horse Canyon Mine

º ¹



T 17 S R 8 E


T 15 S R 16 E

T 15 S R 15 E T 15 S R 14 E

T 15 S R 13 E

Pr i ce

T 16 S R 11 E

T 16 S R 10 E

T 16 S R 9 E

Cottonwood Waste Rock Site

Joes Valley Reservoi


Sunnyside Refuse/Slurry


Trail Mountain Mine



Deer Creek Waste Rock Site

Cottonwood Wilberg Mine

T 17 S R 4 E

º ¹

R 12 E

T 16 S R 12 E

T 16 S R 8 E

T 17 S R 7 E

T 17 S R 6 E

T 17 S R 5 E T 17 S R 3 E


T 16 S R 7 E


) "



( !

Bear Canyon Mine

Deer Creek Mine


Huntington Canyon #4 Mine

º ¹

Wellington T 15 S Prep Plant Banning Siding Loadout

T 14 S R 15 E


T 16 S R 4 E



T 15 S R 10 E

T 15 S R 9 E


( !

£ ¤

T 15 S R 11 E

Sunnyside Mine



Pigeon Hollow Jct.

( !

____ __


( !

( !

East Carbon


T0 S R0E

T 14 S R 17 E T 14 S R 16 E


Crandall Canyon

£ ¤

T 16 S R 3 E

Hiawatha Complex

( !


T 15 S R 8 E

T 15 S R 7 E

T 15 S R 6 E

Spring City

Savage Coal Terminal

( !


( !

Star Point Waste Fuel



T 14 S R 14 E T 14 S R 13 E


( !


T 15 S R 5 E

T 15 S R 4 E

T 15 S R 3 E

T 14 S R 12 E




Star Point Mine



º ¹

Miller Flat Reservoir

T 14 S R 11 E

T 14 . S R 10 E !

T 14 S R 7 E

Rolfson Reservoir

Mount Pleasant

West Ridge Mine


T 14 S R 9 E

T 14 S R 8 E

) "



( !

ge Ran

Electric Lake T 14 S R 4 E

Wildcat Loadout

Blazon #1 Mine


T 13 S R 20 E

T 13 S R 19 E

T 13 S R 18 E

( !


º ¹

T 13 S R 17 E

T 13 S R 13 E

Spring Glen



( !


T 13 S R 16 E

T 13 S R 15 E

T 13 S R 14 E


º ¹ Fairview


T 12 S R 20 E

T 12 S R 19 E T 12 S R 18 E


Beaver Dan Reservoir Boulger Fairview Reservoir Lakes

º White ¹ Oak Clear Creek Mine !(

T 13 S




T 13 S R 11 E



Skyline ºMine ¹

T 13 S R 7 E

Dugout Canyon R 12 E Mine


T 13 S R 6 E

T 13! S R 10 E (


T 13 S R 5 E

T 13 S R 4 E

( !

T 12 S R 17 E

T 12 S R 16 E



Soldier Canyon Mine

Centennial Project


T 13 S R 8 E



T 12 S R 15 E

Willow Creek Mine

T 13 S R 9 E

£ ¤

T 12 S R 14 E


Horizon Mine

( !

T 12 S R 13 E


Castle Gate Mine

T 12 S R 12 E

T 12 S R 11 E



Lower Gooseberry Reservoir

T 12 S R 10 E


( !

Cre e k

Min n i e T 12 S 6 R9 E £ ¤

T 12 S R 8 E

Scofield Reservoir

T 12 S R 6 E

Kinney No. 2 Mine


T 19.5 S R 5 E

T 20 S R 12 E T 20 S R 8 E

T 20 S R 11 E

T 20 S R 10 E

T 20 S R 9 E

T 20 S R 16 E

T 20 S R 15 E

T 20 S R 14 E

T 20 S R 13 E


T 20 S R 5 E

T 20 S R 18 E

T 20 S R 17 E

New Tech Mine (Black Jack No 1)

T 20 S R 19 E


º ¹ 10

T 20.5 S R 13 E

T 20 S R 20 E



Sa n




( !


T 20 S R 4 E


T 20.5 S R 18 E


Ri v e


( !

T 20 S R 7 E

T 20 S R 6 E


Millsite Reservoir T 20 S R 3 E

Green River ( !


( !


T 21 S R 10 E

T 21 S R 12 E

T 21 S R 11 E

T 21 S R 13 E

T 21 S R 14 E

T 21 S R 17 E

T 21 S R 16 E

T 21 S R 15 E



§ ¦ ¨ 70


T 24 S R 8 E

T 23 S R 12 E

T 23 S R 13 E

T 23 S R 14 E

T 24 S R 9 E

T 39 S R 4.5 W


( !

T 25 S R 8 E

( !


T 24 S R 14 E

( !

T 23 S R 17 E

T 40 S R 5 W

T 40 S R 4.5 W


T2 N R 5E

T2 N R 6E

T 24 S R 17 E

T 24 S R 16 E

T 24 S R 15 E

T 40 S R 4 W

T 25 S R 13 E

T 25 S R 12 E

T 25 S R 11 E

T 25 S R 10 E

T 25 S R 14 E

T 25 S R 17.5 E 313

T 25 S R 15 E T 25 S R 16 E Wanship T1 N R 5E T1 N R 4E ( !

T 25 S R 17 E T1 N R 6E

£ ¤ 89

T 41 S R 7 W

T 41 S R 6 W

T 41 S R 5 W

T 26 S R 5 E

T 26 S R 6 E

T 26 S R 7 E

T 26 S R 8 E

T 26 S R 10 E

Riv e


Roads 0





8 Miles

T 26 S R 17.5 E

T 41 S R 4 W

LY S T 26 S R 9 E

T 26 S R 11 E

T1 S R4E

T1 S R5E

T 26 S R 12 E

T 26 S R 13 E

T 26 S R 14 E

T 26 S R 15 E

T 26 S R 16 E

T1 S R6E T 26 S R 17 E

T1 N R 8E T 25 S R 19 E

T 25 S R 18 E T1 N R 7E

We b

Ri v


T1 S R7E



T 26 S R 4 E


T 26 S R 3 E

T 41 S R 4.5 W

º ¹

T 25 S R 17.5 E


( !

T 24 S R 20 E

T 24 S R 19 E



T 25 S R 9 E

T2 N R 8E

T2 N R 7E

T 24 S R 18 E

( !

§ ¦ ¨


T 23 S R 20 E

T 23 S R 19 E

T 23 S R 18 E


T 24 S R 12 E

T 40 S R 6 W


Summit #1 Mine (Blackhawk)


T 25 S R 7 E

º ¹

T 24 S R 13 E

T3 N R 8E

Boyer Mine


T 25 S R 6 E


T2 N R 4E

( !

T 23 S R 16 E


T 39 S R 4 W


T3 N R 7E




T 40 S R 7 W


T 24 S R 11 E

T 24 S R 10 E


T 25 S R 5 E

T 39 S R 5 W


( !


T3 N R 6E


T 23 S R 15 E


T 24 S R 7 E

T 24 S R 6 E

T3 N R 5E

( !


T 26 S R 18 E


T 23 S R 11 E

T 22 S R 20 E

T 22 S R 19 E T0 N R 0E

T 22 S R 18 E

T 22 S R 17 E

T 22 S R 16 E

T3 N R 4E



T 24 S R 5 E

Sevier T 25 S R 4 E



dy Mud

T 25 S R 3 E

T 24 S R 4 E


Coal Hollow

T 39 S R 6 W

T 22 S R 15 E

T 38 S R 4 W


J. B. King Mine


T 22 S R 14 E


T 39 S R 7 W

GLOBE T 24 S R 3 E

T 23 S R 10 E

T 23 S R 9 E

T 23 S R 6 E

Fremont Jct.

T 22 S R 13 E



T 23 S R 8.5 E T 23 S R 8 E

T 23 S R 7 E


T 38 S R 4.5 W



CL AL CO § ¦ ¨ ( !

T 38 S R 5 W

( !


T 23 S

( !

T 38 S R 6 W

T 22 S R 12 E



Knight Mine


T 22 S R 11 E

Long Valley Jct.

§ ¦ ¨

Hidden Valley Mine T 23 S R 4 E

£ ¤


º ¹ 24

T 22 S R 10 E


T 38 S R 7 W


Emery Deep Mine

T 23 S R 3 E

T 22 S R 9 E


T 22 S R 8 E


T 22 S R 7 E T 22 S R 6 E

º ¹ R5E

Cresent Jct.


T 22 S R 5 E

T 22 S R 4 E

( !

Thompson Springs

( !


T 21 S R 20 E

T 21 S R 19 E

T 21 S R 18 E


Flo y

T 21 S R 4 E

T 21 S R 9 E


T 21 S R 3 E

T 21 S R 8 E

T 21 S R 7 E

T 21 S R 6 E

T 21 S R 5 E


( !

T 11 S R 18 E

l Hil

T 12 S R 5 E

T 12 S R 3 E

º ¹

T 11 S R 20 E

T 11 S R 19 E

T 11 S R 17 E


T 12 S R 7 E

T 14 S R 3 E


T 11 S R 16 E


T 12 S R 4 E

T 13 S R 3 E

LA ND T 11 S R 15 E

T 11 S R 14 E

T 11 S R 10 E

( !

T0 S R0E


T 11 S R 3 E

T 10 S R 20 E

T 10 S R 19 E

T 10 S R 18 E

T 10 S R 17 E

T 10 S R 16 E

Soldier Summit

( !


( !

T 10 S R 6 E

T 10 S R 5 E

T 10 S R 4 E


T6 S R4W

T6 S R5W

T6 S R6W

T6 S R7W

T6 S R8W

T6 S R9W


T 10 S R 3 E

T0 S R0E T6 S R3W

£ ¤ £ ¤

T 9 S R 20 E

T 9 S R 19 E

T 9 S R 18 E

T 9 S R 17 E

T 9 S R 16 E

T 9 S R 15 E


( !

T 5 S R 10 W

T 5 S R 11 W

T9 S R6E

T9 S R5E




£ ¤

am Di


T 25 S R 20 E

T1 S R8E T 26 S R 19 E

T 26 S R 20 E


Water Course




Intermittent stream



Divided Highway

Stream or braided stream



Principle Highway

Union Pacific



Improved Highway

Utah Railway



Paved Local Roads

Wilderness Study Areas



Improved Local Roads

County Boundary


Unimproved Local Roads

Township and Range

Locator Map

* Data courtesy of the Utah Department of Natural Resources

66 – Carbon/Emery Energy Guide – March 2010

I Have…

exactly what you want!

 Experience  Knowledge  Confidence  Committment  Dedication Brenda Quick Associate Broker


435 637-7900 95 North 100 East Price UT 84501

CARB ON COUNTY • 16,000 Sq. Foot Exhibit Space • Meeting Rooms • State of the Art Audio, Visual, Networking & Internet • Preferred Caterers List • Dependable Staff

• Conferences, Banquets, Expositions, Trade Shows • Meetings, Seminars • Weddings, Receptions, Reunion, Family Get Togethers

“Big or Small, come and see us for all your needs!”



Events Center

310 South Fairgrounds Road • 435.636.3214 “Lets get together in Carbon County, Utah”

Septic Pumping & Locating Portable Toilet Services Hand Wash Stations

got poop? Wash Bay Sumps Grease Traps

got trash? Potable Water Hauling

30 YD Roll-Off Dumpsters PO Box 220 5115 N Hwy 6 Helper, UT 84526 SE Utah – 435-472-2580 Uintah Basin – 435-725-2580

Together, We Move Mountains For more than 40 years the men and women of Nielson Construction have operated with a simple philosophy of taking care of the customer by dedicating ourselves to going above and beyond to get the job done. That work ethic has resulted in a core of highly skilled, professional employees with a diverse range of capabilities that uniquely positions us to provide for our customers’ needs. A sampling of some of our capabilities include:

825 North Loop Road Huntington, UT. 84528


‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹ ‹

Heavy Excavation Road Construction Asphalt Paving Crane Service Welding Poly Pipe Fusion Mine Construction Mine Reclamation Concrete Services Trucking Heavy Hauling Coal Hauling Winch Truck Services Oil & Gas Field Work Water Hauling Services Hydro Vac Sevices Earthen Dam Construction Roustabout Services

2010-03 Energy Guide  
2010-03 Energy Guide  

2010-03 Energy Guide