NOT SO INSTANT REPLAY Tim Brunsden
As the majority of my arts practice involves working with video in some form, I've used GYM JAMS as a framework to examine some of the ethical questions I've come across regarding documentation in terms of practical approach, respect and realism. As with any project, it's essential to try and get a grasp of what's happening. In this case, there were lots of different creative activities in Howe Bridge, a large clinical space that required some navigating between planned events. There was an impressive running schedule, with each activity designed to encourage the users of the sports centre to think about the space differently, linking sports to ideas around creativity and art. On a basic level, it was essential to record a little bit of everything to try and reflect a fair representation of the day. Initial planning meetings revealed that to cover everything effectively, we would need additional camera support so I brought in Wes Story, someone who I had worked with previously who I knew would be good at filming on the fly. I asked Wes to focus on getting some general interviews with key people as well obtaining some vox pops from participants and some of the organisers, so that things could be put into perspective. Having two cameras of course also gives a broader scope to cover the larger community events and games.
Generally, if you are employed by, or working with a team putting on a event, there is a sense of control and shared aim about what the footage will be used for - evaluation, publicity, or to meet funding requirements. You also want to capture a sense of excitement and fun. When you're explaining to potential interviewees what their contribution is for, they understand, but there is also a kind of knowing expectation that comes with that. People (particularly young people) are quite media savvy, so if you want to grab a quick soundbite, it's hard to avoid the usual suspects of it keeps us off the street' or I've not done this before. I find people are usually happy to say something on camera if they've had a good experience, less so if they haven't. A lot of this is down to an individual approach, timing and luck. I think there is always a question of balance between creating a record of what happened and manipulating this to make something appear better or worse than it actually was. I've had experience of people asking me to photoshop in things to make something look like it worked better that it did. So, there's a questions about what do you do if you're documenting an event that doesn't go to plan? I would say that striking a fair balance and trying to capture the spirit of what happened is something to aim for both in filming and the edit afterwards. With GYM JAMS, there was a lot of tech experiments planned into the project, some of which, for one reason or another, didn't materialise as expected on the day. This of