Page 1

Immigration Crisis in USA: Separating the facts from the fallacies!

Family based immigration or merit based? Put a stop to legal immigration or tighten curbs on illegal migration? What about the Dreamers? Do they deserve to stay on or should they be deported? If they are allowed to stay on then would it open the floodgates to hordes of new migrant children who illegally cross the border? These and other questions are haunting the American psyche in the current political environment. Not a day passes with some new update on the debate revolving around immigrants to USA. The lines are clearly divided across party and public lines with some advocating a strong conservative policy with respect to immigrants to USA and some advocating a more liberal policy towards migrants.

Proper perspective required for immigration crisis As with most other debates centered on policy, both sides have their strong points and weak spots. The people in favor of immigration point to all the migrants who succeeded in their own domains. Steve Jobs, Satya Nadella, Sunder Picchai success stories are gloriously highlighted by the pro-immigration camp. At the other end of the spectrum, the falling wage rate is blamed on the influx of cheap labor who enter the borders either illegally or via sponsorship of a family member. Given this scenario it becomes important to view the debate around immigration in proper perspective. We take a look at each aspect of the conversation around immigrants to USA and attempt to separate the fact from the fiction


Family based immigration process to USA Most opponents of family based immigration claim that this scheme opens the way to endless lines of immigrants who are brought in by their family members. According to a well-known story propagated by the opponents of this scheme, immigrants to USA continue to sponsor their immediate family members who then earn citizenship and then sponsor their family members add infinitum, leading to a large mass of immigrants flooding the United States and causing everything from wage deflation to social and economic devaluation. The reality - Unless we are looking at immigration through a time-lapse video, it is virtually impossible for family based immigration to set off a chain migration scheme. Any immigrant to USA who wishes to sponsor a family member has to become a citizen before he can do so. The time taken for obtaining citizenship can run into as many as one or two decades. The migrants to USA who enter as adults, it becomes highly impossible for them to sponsor many generations of immigrants to USA. Also the premise that family based immigrants to USA are of no value to society is itself flawed, according to an opinion piece in the Washington Times, family based migrants perform the important task of providing the much needed succor and stability that the primary immigrants require to succeed in their area of work. These individuals far from being a burden on society, become an integral part of the community, take up volunteering activities and act in ways that uplift their societies and towns in USA.

H1B immigration and H4 EAD The debate around immigrants to USA is strongly centered on the issue of H1B holders and more particularly the Employment Authorization Document (EAD) granted to their dependent spouses who come on H4 visa to USA. The opponents of H1B immigration argue that it is exploited by companies in USA who are using this route as a means to hire cheap skilled labor in order to cut costs. And furthermore the H4 EAD that is granted to H4 dependent spouses reduces the number of jobs available to local citizens and intensifies the unemployment in the country. The reality - H1B visa holders are highly skilled and have to go through a rigorous vetting process in order to qualify for a visa. The opinion that H1B visa holders are under skilled migrants who are allowed to enter USA to provide cheap labor is totally false. Moreover, many a time, local positions are left unfilled by citizens either through a lack of talent or lack of interest on the part of citizens. These positions are ably filled by the H1B visa holders, thus leading to an increase in overall productivity. As productivity improves at each level, wealth is created which in turn opens up many new job opportunities and boosts the country’s economy. If the immigrants to USA can do well here financially they save and support families in home country, which in turn boosts the economy of home country. H4 immigrants to USA, too if provided with an opportunity to work and earn for themselves can contribute to the American society in more positive ways than if they were forced to sit at home. These and other debating points show us the importance of an open stance towards immigration process to USA. Immigration can be a means to improve not just the life of the immigrant, but the host country as well. Nowhere is this more self-evident than in the United States of America.

Immigration Crisis in USA: Separating the facts from the fallacies  

Work & Settle in USA is a dream of every Indian. Take Assistance of Global Tree, best Overseas Immigration Consultants to Migrate to USA und...

Immigration Crisis in USA: Separating the facts from the fallacies  

Work & Settle in USA is a dream of every Indian. Take Assistance of Global Tree, best Overseas Immigration Consultants to Migrate to USA und...

Advertisement