Page 10

A10 January 20, 2012 The Richmond News

Opinion T H E

a Canwest newspaper

Published every Wednesday & Friday by the Richmond News, a member of the Glacier Media Group. 5731 No. 3 Road, Richmond, B.C. V6X 2C9 Phone: 604-270-8031 Fax: 604-270-2248


Publisher: Lori Chalmers lchalmers@ Distribution: 604-249-3323 distribution@richmond-news. com Classified: 604-630-3300 Fax: 604-630-4500

Editor: Eve Edmonds Sports: Mark Booth mbooth@ Reporters: Alan Campbell acampbell@ Michelle Hopkins mhopkins@ Photographer: Chung Chow

Sales Manager: Dave Hamilton dhamilton@ Sales Representatives: Don Grant Shaun Dhillon Stephen Murphy smurphy@ Angela Nottingham anottingham@richmond-news. com Sales Support: Kelly Christian kchristian@richmond-news. com

The Richmond News is a member of the Glacier Media Group. The Richmond News respects your privacy. We collect, use and disclose your personal information in accordance with our Privacy Statement which is available at or by calling 604-589-9182.

Follow us on



Cautionary tale behind tactics to smoke Tories out A few thousand federal Liberals gathered in Ottawa over the weekend to gossip about leadership and try to come up with some innovative new policy ideas that might seize the public’s imagination. None of their ideas were very innovative or even particularly new, but nonetheless, most of them were voted down. No republicanism here, thank you very much. One of the few ideas that did get the green light was the legalization of marijuana. Prohibition is a hugely expensive, utterly failed policy. We’re joined in this by such diverse voices as the Fraser Institute, The Economist, Time Magazine, former secretaries general of NATO and the UN, and our own Sen. Larry Campbell, among many, many others. So there’s certainly no shortage of thoughtful analysis available on this issue. But the Liberals still have a lot of hard policy work to do for this to graduate from an attention-seeking gimmick to a serious election platform plank. In a Canadian context, the foremost issue will be our trade relationship with the Americans, who will no doubt be aghast at having the world’s largest legal grow-op on their doorstep. Chaos at the border means harm to the economy, which likely means lost jobs. That’s probably not the easiest way to unseat a Conservative government. Besides, voters for whom this is a pressing issue have likely already long since found a home in the NDP. So we applaud the Liberals for taking a bold, if symbolic, step. Now let’s see if they can back it up.


A fond farewell to Wind Waves The Editor, I’m going to miss you, Wind Waves. You have been a whimsical, graceful beacon of colourful cheer; Especially on cold, grey days with rain and snow all around. From a distance it seems as if playful extraterrestrials have come to visit; Compelling adults, teens, seniors and children to photograph you, touch you and sometimes climb within you. I wonder what would happen if a survey was done today as to whether we should keep you at Garry Point; Now that so many of us have had the chance to enjoy your elegant shapes and flowing lines, whispering, “We are all connected.” My eyes and mind appreciate the symbolism in your sparkling globe. I am one person who will be so very sad when we lose you, Wind Waves. Christine Durgo Steveston

Letters policy The editor reserves the right to edit letters for brevity, clarity, legality and good taste. Letters must include the author’s telephone number for verification. We do not publish anonymous letters.

Send letters to The Editor, Richmond News, 5731 No. 3 Road Richmond, B.C. V6X 2C9 Fax: 604-270-2248 or e-mail:

East, West, not so different with money Way back in the dawn of economic prehistory, there was the coin. Some of the first coins in the world were created in the kingdom of Lydia, in what is now Turkey, but was then part of the Greek sphere of influence. Trading chunks of metallic ore was one way to pay the goat merchant. Coins were easier to carry and standardized, and you could stamp the face of the king on them, too, creating evercirculating propaganda. Around the same time, independently, someone in China was doing the same thing. Remember that, it’ll be important later. Coins eventually became important because they were preferable to chunks of metal. More than 2,000 years after the first coining, ur-economist Adam Smith noted that 20 pounds of pure silver was less valuable than the equivalent amount of silver coins, due to the trustworthiness and ease of spending the coins. Money was becoming abstracted. It could also be abstracted further into paper currency — banknote used to be, literally, a note from a bank saying that owner had some gold or silver locked up. But eventually the paper became just as important, and money was finally decoupled from precious metals, about 2,500 years after the first coins were stamped. From there, it was an easy step to money that only

Matthew Claxton PAINFUL TRUTH

existed as electrons. Which brings us to the great big world of imaginary value, the realm of bonds and debt, interest and collateralized debt obligations. Each abstraction of money has created a boom. The first Lydian king to create really pure and standardized coins was Croesus, whose name became a byword for wealth. Paper money — and not just banknotes, but interest, bonds, and stockmarkets — made the industrial revolution possible. It also made speculative bubbles easier than ever to create. In the early 1700s there was a kind of stock market mania in England, with the gigantic South Seas bubble at the top, but also stocks floated that raised a million pounds to develop a perpetual motion device, and another “company for carrying on an undertaking of great advantage, but nobody to know what it is.” The creator of that scheme collected 2,000 pounds and vamoosed. People aren’t so stupid as to do this kind of investing anymore, of course. (Not people with lots of money, but the stupid and gullible

can always be found who will give up a few thousand dollars to a Nigerian scam.) Now the really clever people have to believe their own nonsense. That’s how we got the sub-prime mortgage meltdown. People convinced themselves the price of housing would always rise. They must have believed that, after all, or the entire sub-prime business would have been insane on the face of it. Of course, nothing goes up forever. Hey, remember how China invented coins independently? It appears they’ve also independently invented an insane housing boom. After trying communism for a few years, the Chinese are ready to follow us right off a different, capitalist cliff. Chinese government regulations keep interest rates low, making socking your money in a bank a poor investment. The stock market is not seen as fair or transparent. But housing has been booming, so many, many people have been buying an extra apartment with their savings. The question about the Chinese housing bubble is increasingly if, not when, it will burst. There are those who say nothing is wrong. But frankly, they should buy some perpetual motion stock. Matthew Claxton is a reporter with the Langley Advance.

Richmond News January 20 2012  

Richmond News January 20 2012

Richmond News January 20 2012  

Richmond News January 20 2012