The local paper for Downtown wn
WEEK OF JULY STUDIO ART ◄ P.12
COUNCIL HEARS LATEST L TRAIN SHUTDOWN PLANS TRANSPORTATION DOT plans major reconfiguration of 14th Street to accommodate “extraordinary volume of buses” during subway closure BY MICHAEL GAROFALO
People opposed to the Trump administration’s immigration policies gathered in Manhattan’s Foley Square Saturday morning. Photo: Natasha Roy
NEW YORKERS RALLY AGAINST TRUMP POLICIES ACTIVISM Thousands cross Brooklyn Bridge in protest of administration’s immigration tactics BY NATASHA ROY
In 90-degree heat Saturday, thousands marched across the Brooklyn Bridge to protest the Trump administration’s policy of separating immigrant families at the country’s southern border. Protesters convened midmorning in Foley Square and from there headed to the bridge, many holding signs with phrases such as “families belong together” and “where are the children?” Families with young children showed up, and old and young marched and volunteered.
Volunteers from Neighbors Link, a Westchester-based nonprofit that works to integrate immigrants into the community, marched across the Brooklyn Bridge with a long banner. Jeremy Sussman, 50, of Bedford Hills, said that immigrants made America the country it is, and that the country should be more welcoming to immigrants than it is now. “That’s what keeps America vibrant,” Sussman said. “That’s what makes America a great country to be in.” The protest, which locally was sponsored by dozens of organizations, including the New York Immigration Coalition, the American Civil Liberties Union and Sanctuary for Families, was part of the Keep Families Together rallies that drew tens of thousands across the nation Saturday.
Beginning next April, much of 14th Street will be closed to through-traffic and converted to a dedicated “busway” to serve displaced subway riders during the 15-month shutdown of the L train. From 5 a.m. to 10 p.m. every day, the busiest stretch of 14th Street — from Ninth Avenue to Third Avenue eastbound and between Third Avenue and Eighth Avenue westbound — will be reserved primarily for bus trafﬁc. Eliminating excess traffic on 14th Street is necessary to make way for “an extraordinary volume of buses” along the corridor during the shutdown, MTA and NYC Department of Transportation officials explained at a June 26 City Council hearing. Roughly one bus every minute will run along 14th Street during peak hours, serving an estimated 84,000 riders each day. In response to feedback from members of the public and elected officials, the latest iteration of the agencies’ joint L train shutdown mitigation plan will permit limited local access to 14th Street within the “busway” zone for private vehicles. Vehicles will be allowed to access 14th Street for pick-ups and drop-offs, deliveries and parking garage access, but will only be permitted to travel on 14th Street for a single block before exiting, subject to
The shutdown of the L train, scheduled to begin in April 2019 and last 15 months, will impact the commutes of 400,000 daily riders. Photo: Steven Strasser
This will, without question, be the biggest logistical, customer service and community challenge that I’ve ever faced.” NYCT President Andy Byford
enforcement by traffic cameras. “I think we’ve hopefully found a balance here that will provide the local access that we’ve heard loud and clear that residents need while keeping those buses moving,” DOT Commissioner Polly Trottenberg said.
Beginning in April 2019, L train service will be suspended for 15 months to repair damage to the Canarsie Tunnel caused by flooding during Hurricane Sandy in 2012. L Train service within Brooklyn will continue during the tunnel repairs, but no trains will run on the Manhattan side of the tunnel or between the boroughs. The logistical challenges presented by the shutdown are immense. The 15-month project will affect 225,000 daily riders who commute between Brooklyn and Manhattan on the L and another 50,000 who use the line to travel within Manhattan. Were the L Train a stand-alone transit system, New York City Transit President Andy
CONTINUED ON PAGE 6
CONTINUED ON PAGE 15 Downtowner
O OTDOWNTOWN.COM @OTDowntown
Crime Watch Voices NYC Now City Arts
3 8 10 12
Restaurant Ratings Business Real Estate 15 Minutes
14 16 17 21
WEEK OF APRIL
SPRING ARTS PREVIEW < CITYARTS, P.12
FOR HIM, SETTLING SMALL CLAIMS IS A BIG DEAL presided over Arbitration Man has three decades. for informal hearings about it He’s now blogging BY RICHARD KHAVKINE
is the common Arbitration Man their jurist. least folks’ hero. Or at Man has For 30 years, Arbitration court office of the civil few sat in a satellite Centre St. every building at 111 New Yorkers’ weeks and absorbed dry cleaning, burned lost accountings of fender benders, lousy paint jobs, and the like. And security deposits then he’s decided. Arbitration Man, About a year ago, so to not afwho requested anonymity started docuhe fect future proceedings, two dozen of what menting about compelling cases considers his most blog. in an eponymous about it because “I decided to write the stories but in a I was interested about it not from wanted to write from view but rather lawyer’s point of said Arbitration view,” of a lay point lawyer since 1961. Man, a practicing what’s at issue He ﬁrst writes about post, renders and then, in a separatehow he arrived his decision, detailing blog the to Visitors at his conclusion. their opinions. often weigh in with get a rap going. I to “I really want whether they unreally want to know and why I did it,” I did derstood what don’t know how to he said. “Most people ... I’d like my cases the judge thinks. and also my trereﬂect my personalitythe law.” for mendous respect 80, went into indiMan, Arbitration suc in 1985, settling vidual practice
MANHATTAN'S APARTMENT BOOM, > PROPERTY, P.20
In Brief MORE HELP FOR SMALL BUSINESS
The effort to help small seems to businesses in the city be gathering steam. Two city councilmembers, Robert Margaret Chin and Cornegy, have introduced create legislation that wouldSmall a new “Office of the within Business Advocate” of Small the city’s Department Business Services. Chin The new post, which have up told us she’d like to would and running this year, for serve as an ombudsman city small businesses within them clear government, helping to get through the bureaucracy things done. Perhaps even more also importantly, the ombudsman and number will tally the type small business of complaints by taken in owners, the actions policy response, and somefor ways to recommendations If done well, begin to ﬁx things. report would the ombudsman’s give us the ﬁrst quantitative with taste of what’s wrong the city, an small businesses in towards important ﬁrst step ﬁxing the problem. of for deTo really make a difference, is a mere formality will have to the work process looking to complete their advocate are the chances course, velopers precinct, but rising rents, -- thanks to a ﬁnd a way to tackle business’ is being done legally of after-hours projects quickly. their own hours,” which remain many While Chin “They pick out boom in the number throughout who lives on most vexing problem. said Mildred Angelo,of the Ruppert construction permits gauge what Buildings one said it’s too early tocould have the 19th ﬂoor in The Department of the city. number three years, the Houses on 92nd Street between role the advocate She Over the past on the is handing out a record work perThird avenues. permits, there, more information of Second and an ongoing all-hours number of after-hours bad thing. of after-hours work the city’s Dept. problem can’t be a said there’s with the mits granted by nearby where according to new data jumped 30 percent, This step, combinedBorough construction project noise Buildings has data provided in workers constantly make efforts by Manhattan to mediate BY DANIEL FITZSIMMONS according to DOB of Informacement from trucks. President Gale Brewer offer response to a Freedom classiﬁes transferring they want. They knows the the rent renewal process, request. The city They 6 “They do whatever signs Every New Yorker clang, tion Act go as they please. work between some early, tangible small any construction on the weekend, can come and sound: the metal-on-metal or the piercing of progress. For many have no respect.” p.m. and 7 a.m., can’t come of these that the hollow boom, issuance reverse. owners, in business moving The increased beeps of a truck has generto a correspond and you as after-hours. soon enough. variances has led at the alarm clock The surge in permits
SLEEPS, THANKS TO THE CITY THAT NEVER UCTION A BOOM IN LATE-NIGHT CONSTR NEWS
A glance it: it’s the middle can hardly believe yet construction of the night, and carries on full-tilt. your local police or You can call 311
Newscheck Crime Watch Voices
for dollars in fees ated millions of and left some resithe city agency, that the application dents convinced
2 City Arts 3 Top 5 8 Real Estate 10 15 Minutes
12 13 14 18
CONTINUED ON PAGE
We deliver! Get Our Town Downtowner sent directly to your mailbox for $49 per year. Go to OTDowntown.com or call 212-868-0190
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
WHEN DINING IS TOO DARN LOUD HEALTH Why the Health Department should rate restaurant sound levels BY ARLINE L. BRONZAFT, PH.D.
When a couple with two children and demanding jobs want to spend an evening together, they often decide to have dinner in a nearby restaurant where they can sit, talk and eat. When young people want to get to get to know the person they have just met online, they seek out a neighborhood restaurant where they can converse and become better acquainted. Two senior friends who have not seen each other for a while seek a restaurant which will allow them to have a good meal while catching up with each other’s recent activities. Lone diners also have complained to me about loud restaurants. In other words, according to Zagat and Consumer Reports: restaurants are just “too darn loud.” New York City has a noise code that attempts to lower the din of construction, air compressors and circulation devices and music from commercial establishments. But this code does not
Empty = quiet at Hard Rock Cafe in Times Square. Photo: Rayitno, via ﬂickr
ACTIVITIES FOR THE FERTILE MIND
thoughtgallery.org NEW YORK CITY
Pregame Your Brain: What’s in Your Blood
FRIDAY, JULY 6TH, 6PM Caveat | 21 Clinton St. | 212-228-2100 | caveat.nyc The “science fair for adults” Pregame Your Brain gets into the ﬂow with a night dedicated to blood. Researchers, authors, artists, and animal experts will man stations with 10-minute speed lessons while you conduct your own BAC experiments at the bar (free).
Images on the Run: Contemporary Street Photography
WEDNESDAY, JULY 11TH, 6:30PM International Center of Photography | 250 Bowery | 212-857-0000 | icp.org Inspired by ICP’s exhibition Henri Cartier-Bresson: The Decisive Moment, contemporary street photographers come together to talk about their own decisive subjects and scenes (free, advance registration requested).
Just Announced | TimesTalks: Glenn Close and Meg Wolitzer | Sacriﬁce & Sexism
TUESDAY, JULY 31ST, 7:00PM The TimesCenter | 242 W. 41st St. | 888-698-1870 | timestalks.com Six-time Academy Award nominee Glenn Close joins best-selling author Meg Wolitzer to talk about the new ﬁlm The Wife, based on Wolitzer’s acclaimed novel of the same name ($55).
For more information about lectures, readings and other intellectually stimulating events throughout NYC,
sign up for the weekly Thought Gallery newsletter at thoughtgallery.org.
address loudness inside restaurants. The City Health Department does rate restaurants on environmental issues such as temperature and cleanliness but not on sound, even though sound is an environmental issue. I strongly urge that ratings of restaurants include an assessment of sound levels to which diners and employees are exposed My long-term research and writings have focused on the adverse effects of loud sounds and noise on mental and physical health. Unquestionably, workers in loud, noisy restaurants, are in danger of suffering hearing impairment. Loud sounds and noise have also been linked to adverse mental and physical health effects; readers can go to www.growNYC.org/noise to learn more about the deleterious impacts of noise. The New York Times recently reported on several studies that link loud music with eating less healthy foods and softer music with healthier food choices. Further research on the relationship between sound levels and food choices are called for before we can affirmatively state that loud restaurants contribute to health issues like obesity. I will continue to follow the research in this area.
People who wish to eat their meals in restaurants that also permit them to converse with their fellow diners can do a Google search that directs them to sites listing quieter eateries. One site, Soundprint, provides information on restaurants and also lists an app which can, with some degree of accuracy, measure sound levels. You can then decide whether the restaurant you are dining in provides the “sound” atmosphere you are comfortable with. The goal of the Soundprint app is to satisfy people who are seeking dining experiences that focus both on food and conversation. If it becomes clear that people desire to have some quiet while dining, then restaurant owners will seek out ways to acoustically treat their establishments in ways that will lower the din. They may also attempt to keep the music lower as well. Restaurant owners care about meeting the needs of their customers and if lower sound levels are called for, I believe they will consider the sounds of their restaurants for their workers and their customers. It is time for restaurant owners. workers, diners and city officials to join together to lower the decibel levels within restaurants.
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
CRIME WATCH BY JERRY DANZIG STATS FOR THE WEEK Reported crimes from the 1st district for the week ending June 24 Week to Date
Year to Date
476 460 3.5
Grand Larceny Auto
Photo by Tony Webster, via Flickr
TINTED AND TAINTED A Spring Street sunglasses store was hit by robberies on consecutive days. In the ﬁrst incident, just after 7:30 p.m. on Saturday, June 23, a man in his late 50s and an accomplice broke into the Sunglass Hut at Spring Street and West Broadway to take two pair of sunglasses totaling $765. Police were able to identify the man as Michael McNeil, 57, and arrested him on robbery charges. In the second incident, at 2:50 p.m.
the following Sunday, two people in their 20s entered the store with one telling a 20-year-old employee he had a gun and threatened to use it. He then took roughly $14,000 in eyewear off the shelves, put them in a blue bag and left.
SUV BROKEN INTO A Minneapolis man learned the hard way not to leave valuables in a car parked on the street overnight in
the Big Apple. Sometime between midnight and 8 a.m. on Monday, June 18, someone shattered the driver’sside rear window on the man’s 2018 Nissan Armada and took four suitcases. The man told police the suitcases were contained clothing, jewelry, and electronics worth a total of $35,400.
STEAL DIFFERENT A employee of the Apple Store tech boutique at 185 Greenwich St. told
police that at 6:43 p.m. on Saturday, June 16, one man and two women, all in their mid-30s, were seen on surveillance cameras removing six pairs of Apple AirPod headphones, an Insta360 ONE camera accessory bundle, and a variety of Beats headphones from display shelves on two of the store concealing the items in plastic shopping bags. The trio then walked past all points of sale and exited the store without paying. The merchandise is worth $2,634.
SEVENTEEN AND SORRY Yet another teenager discovered how good Saks Fifth Avenue security is. At 3:30 p.m. on Wednesday, June 20, a 17-year-old girl inside the Saks store at 225 Liberty St. removed and concealed a purse valued at $1,750 and a wallet priced at $250 before attempting to leave the location without paying. She was arrested and charged with grand larceny.
IT’S MORE THAN A TEXT It’s the efficient way to learn about power outages. Text REG to OUTAGE (688243) and follow the prompts to sign up for text alerts.* Learn more at coned.com/textalerts *Messaging and data rates may apply.
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
DrawingBYBoard MARC BILGREY
POLICE NYPD 7th Precinct
19 ½ Pitt St.
NYPD 6th Precinct
233 W. 10th St.
NYPD 10th Precinct
230 W. 20th St.
NYPD 13th Precinct
230 E. 21st St.
NYPD 1st Precinct
16 Ericsson Place
FIRE FDNY Engine 15
25 Pitt St.
FDNY Engine 24/Ladder 5
227 6th Ave.
FDNY Engine 28 Ladder 11
222 E. 2nd St.
FDNY Engine 4/Ladder 15
42 South St.
ELECTED OFFICIALS Councilmember Margaret Chin
165 Park Row #11
Councilmember Rosie Mendez
237 1st Ave. #504
Councilmember Corey Johnson
224 W. 30th St.
State Senator Daniel Squadron
250 Broadway #2011
Community Board 1
1 Centre St., Room 2202
Community Board 2
3 Washington Square Village
Community Board 3
59 E. 4th St.
Community Board 4
330 W. 42nd St.
66 Leroy St.
135 2nd Ave.
Elmer Holmes Bobst
70 Washington Square
HOSPITALS New York-Presbyterian
170 William St.
Mount Sinai-Beth Israel
10 Union Square East
4 Irving Place
46 East 23rd
US Post Office
201 Varick St.
US Post Office
128 East Broadway
US Post Office
93 4th Ave.
HOW TO REACH US:
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR:
212-868-0190 email@example.com otdowntown.com
Include your full name, address and day and evening telephone numbers for veriﬁcation. Letters that cannot be veriﬁed will not be published. We reserve the right to edit or condense letters for libel, good taste, grammar and punctuation. Submit your letter at otdowntown.com and click submit at the bottom of the page or email it to firstname.lastname@example.org.
TO SUBSCRIBE: Our Town Downtown is available for free below 23rd Street in select buildings, retail locations and news boxes. To get a copy of downtown neighborhood news mailed to you weekly, you may subscribe to Our Town - Downtowner for just $49 per year. Call 212-868-0190 or go online to StrausNews.com and click on the photo of the paper or mail a check to Straus Media, 20 West Ave., Chester, NY 10918
NEWS ITEMS: To report a news story, call 212-8680190. News releases of general interest must be emailed to our offices by 12noon the Thursday prior to publication to be considered for the following week. Send to email@example.com.
BLOG COMMENTS: We invite comments on stories at otdowntown.com. We do not edit those comments. We urge people to keep the discussion civil and the tone reﬂective of the best we each have to offer.
PLACE A CLASSIFIED AD: Call 212-868-0190. Classiﬁed ads must be in our office by 12pm the Friday before publication, except on holidays. All classiﬁed ads are payable in advance.
PREVIOUS OWNERS: Tom Allon, Isis Ventures, Ed Kayatt, Russ Smith, Bob Trentlyon, Jerry Finkelstein
Information for inclusion in the Out and About section should be emailed to firstname.lastname@example.org no later than two weeks before the event.
Our Town Downtown is published weekly by Straus Media-Manhattan, LLC. Please send inquiries to 20 West Ave., Chester, NY 10918.
DO YOU HAVE SOMETHING YOU’D LIKE US TO LOOK INTO? DO YOU HAVE SOMETHING YOU’D LIKE US TO LOOK INTO? DO YOU HAVE SOMETHING YOU’D LIKE US TO LOOK INTO? Email us at NEWS@STRAUSNEWS.COM
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
PERIL IN THE PARKS CITYSCAPE Amid the magnificence of Manhattan’s green spaces, there is also decay, dilapidation and deterioration, a new report finds BY DOUGLAS FEIDEN
Riverside Park can be a paradise for West Side joggers — except for its uneven pathways, degraded trails, displaced treads on stone stairways and pavements ruptured by cracks and potholes. Corlears Hook Park can be a downtown oasis fanned by balmy breezes off the East River — until you need a comfort station. The facilities have been closed or non-functioning for two decades. DeWitt Clinton Park in Hell’s Kitchen can be a child’s fantasyland with a dog run, frog fountain and trio of concrete play mules, Pal, Gal and Sal — but forget about getting in from 12th Avenue. Its two dilapidated entry staircases have been shuttered and inaccessible for years. The East River Esplanade near Gracie Mansion can be a glorious place to watch the tugs, barges and pleasure boats – but you have to watch your feet, too. Sinkholes are common, and a chunk of the seawall last year collapsed into the water at 88th Street. Those were among the findings of an exhaustive new report released last week by the Center for an Urban Future
If we don’t catch up now, it will metastasize into an even bigger problem.” Eli Dvorkin of the Center for an Urban Future
documenting hundreds of examples of crumbling conditions, infrastructure failures and urgent, unmet needs at the city’s 1,485 parks, including the 282 in Manhattan. The think tank’s researchers cited inadequate or overdue maintenance, chronic and long-term underfunding and a cumbersome capital process for parks projects — all leading to sky-high costs and multiyear delays in making the ﬁxes, which in turns exacerbates a collapsing infrastructure. Bottom line: Horticulture dies, retaining walls disintegrate, drainage systems decay, recreation centers leak, bathrooms go without water, stairs vanish, benches are overturned, pathways are pockmarked, ﬂooding is prevalent and puddles are deep, the report found. To be sure, Eli Dvorkin, managing editor of the research institute and one of the authors of “A New Leaf: Revitalizing New York City’s Aging Parks Infrastructure,” credits the de Blasio administration with upping investment, enlarging the
central budget for repairs, adding staff for maintenance and taking a planning-oriented approach to grapple with future problems. “We give the administration full credit for ﬁnally investing in chronically underfunded parks after decades of underinvestment,” he said. But more can be done: “We’re going to have to double down on this commitment to parks, go beyond what we’ve already committed to — and make new efforts to tackle unsexy, unglamorous and often invisible infrastructure needs,” Dvorkin added.
A CENTURY WITHOUT A MAJOR FIX Based on an analysis of historical records from the city’s Dept. of Parks and Recreation, as well as data on capital projects and site surveys of 65 parks, “A New Leaf” determined that: • The average Manhattan park last underwent signiﬁcant infrastructure rehabilitation work in 2002, or 16 years ago. • Manhattan has the city’s oldest parks – the average age is 86 – and of its nine largest parks, all of them covering more than 50 acres, eight of them, or an impressive 89 percent, received substantial capital upgrades in 2017. • But the borough also has 105 medium-sized parks, defined as one acre to 50 acres in size, and of those, only 36, or 34 percent, were renovated last year. • The island’s 164 small parks, defined as less than one acre,
An uprooted bench tilts askew in Sara D. Roosevelt Park south of Houston Street downtown. Photo: John Surico / Center for an Urban Future
The entryway to DeWitt Clinton Park at 12th Avenue and 52nd Street has been fenced off for years because of a pair of dilapidated and inaccessible stairways. Photo: Google Street View received the least attention. Only 26 of them, or 16 percent, received upgrades. • At least 46 mini-parks citywide, including triangles, trafﬁc islands and plazas, haven’t undergone capital work in nearly a century. • One such site is Sherman Square, a fenced-in traffic triangle dating to 1891, where Broadway, Amsterdam and 70th Street come together. Long associated with the 1971 film “Panic in Needle Park,” it has been cleaned up, but it hasn’t been significantly upgraded in 100 years. • Another is Lafayette Square, a park since 1870, where Morningside Avenue, Manhattan Avenue and 114th Streets intersect. Its centerpiece is a statue of the Marquis de Lafayette and George Washington shaking hands, and it looks splendid. But it hasn’t been renovated in a century. “This administration has invested in strengthening the city’s parks system from top to bottom,” a Parks Dept. spokesperson said in responding to the report. “Capital programs, including the $318 million, 65-park Community Parks Initiative and the $150 million Anchor Parks project, are bringing the ﬁrst structural improvements in generations to sites from playgrounds to large flagship parks,” she added. Indeed, in Riverside Park, for instance, the reconstruction of pathways and shoring up of retaining walls, as well as interior plumbing projects and general capital site work, is well underway. Design work has been completed to reconstruct the Corlears Hook Park comfort station. Procurement, now 60 percent ﬁnished, is expected to wrap up in October, followed by a construction cycle that could take up to 18 months. That means, after a two-decade wait, a new facility could open by 2020.
Meanwhile, a $1 million to $3 million project to rebuild the DeWitt Clinton Park staircases has been funded, but only ﬁve percent of the design work has been completed, according to the Parks Dept. website. Neither procurement nor construction can begin until the scope of work for the project is designed, which means that the reopening of the western approaches to the park is still years away. As for the East River Esplanade, a $15 million ﬁrst phase of a city initiative to reinforce and reconstruct river-facing seawalls on the East Side is underway. But unforeseen design work has resulted in delays of several months on a project originally scheduled to be completed back in May. The Parks Dept. spokesperson said that Parks Commissioner Mitchell Silver has “streamlined the capital process” to bring infrastructure improvements online faster, a policy reform that is
acknowledged in the Center for an Urban Future’s report. “Looking forward, initiatives like the newly funded catchbasin program and an ongoing capital needs assessment program will ensure that New York City parks needs are accounted for and addressed in the years to come,” she added. Dvorkin said it’s encouraging that the Parks Dept. has ﬁnally initiated a full systemwide assessment of its future infrastructure needs, better positioning it to address and anticipate problems down the road. But he questioned the time frame: “At the current rate, we believe the assessment will take 20 years to complete,” he said. “At that point, major infrastructure categories will have exceed their natural lifespan.” And Dvorkin added, “If we don’t catch up now, it will metastasize into an even bigger problem.” email@example.com
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
Follow Our Town Downtown on Facebook and Twitter
Downtowner During the L train shutdown, transportation officials plan to prohibit most private vehicle traffic on 14th Street and create a “busway” carrying 84,000 passengers per day. Image: NYC DOT/MTA
LCONTINUED TRAIN FROM PAGE 1 Byford noted, its daily ridership would place it among the ten busiest in North America. “This will, without question, be the biggest logistical, customer service and community challenge that I’ve ever faced,” Byford said.
PENALTIES FOR DELAY Council Speaker Corey Johnson, whose district includes the western half of 14th Street, pressed Byford on the likelihood that the project would be delayed. “I think I speak for everyone in New York City when I say it better be a hard stop at 15 months and not go longer than that,” Johnson said. Byford said he is “95 percent certain or north thereof” that the project will be finished within the 15-month timeframe, citing incentives for early completion and penalties for delays in the service contract. “I think we could bring it in early,” Byford said.
Johnson said that additional traffic on smaller numbered streets north and south of 14th Street is a critical concern, citing the safety hazards posed to pedestrians and cyclists by commercial vehicles illegally using those roads to travel across town instead of 14th Street. Police enforcement must “be meaningful from the very beginning as a deterrent, so that people know from day one of the shutdown that they cannot be doing crazy things on side streets,” Johnson said. The NYPD plans to deploy 102 traffic enforcement agents and 46 police officers to facilitate traffic during the shutdown. “There’s no way, unfortunately, that we can say this is not going to have a congestion effect,” Trottenberg said. “It clearly is.” Trottenberg said that there has already been an increase in cyclist volume in advance of the L train closure. DOT ofﬁcials scrapped earlier plans to install a two-way bike lane on 13th Street and will instead install separate one-way lanes on 12th and 13th Streets protected
from traffic by plastic bollards. The city will also expand the number of Citi Bikes and docking stations in Brooklyn and Manhattan to meet an anticipated increase in demand for the bikeshare service during the shutdown. Transportation officials project that 79 percent of displaced L train riders will use other subway lines as an alternative during the shutdown. The MTA will adjust service on the J, M, Z, G, C, E and 7 lines to accommodate L riders with more frequent and/or longer trains. Roughly 17 percent of L train riders are projected to opt for interborough bus service. The MTA will launch four new highfrequency bus routes between Brooklyn and Manhattan during the shutdown. During peak hours, 80 buses per hour will travel over the Williamsburg Bridge, which will be subject to new high-occupancy vehicle restrictions. Four percent of displaced L train commuters are expected to use a new East River ferry service.
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
THE BATTLE OVER NEIGHBORHOOD’S BEST ELIZABETH STREET GARDEN To place an ad in this directory, Call Douglas at 212-868-0190 ext. 352.
HARDWARE ELEGANCE IN HARDWARE
This Summer, let us do the cooking!
Debating dual needs of the community: green space vs. housing for low-income seniors
A Luxury Hardware Experience 860 Lexington Avenue 646-922-8707 eleganceinhardware.com
MON-SAT 10:30AM-6PM | SUN 12PM-6PM
BY NATASHA ROY
The tension in the room was palpable during a June 25 community meeting concerning the future of Elizabeth Street Garden. In December, the city announced its plans to raze the nearly one-acre stretch of a sculpture garden in Nolita to make room for low-income housing geared toward LGBTQ seniors. The future development, called Haven Green, will also house Habitat for Humanity New York City and SAGE, according to a press release from the city. “In addition to continuing to serve low- and moderateincome New Yorkers across the city, Habitat NYC will provide credit counseling and education services to residents and community members, as well as manage the ongoing maintenance and programming for the open public space,” the press release said. “A portion of the Habitat NYC space will serve as a flexible workspace for community activities.” Haven Green would house 123 low-income senior citizens. However, the Friends of Elizabeth Street Garden are ﬁghting to save their green space. At the community board meeting, the group’s president, Jeannine Kiely, spoke about saving the garden, and she later told Our Town that it would be preserving an essential community space. “What I love about the garden is it’s one of the few public spaces that brings people together from all different ages and walks of life, and it’s sort of a melting pot,” Kiely said. “You don’t really get that anywhere else in this neighborhood ... I’ve met so many different people who live in the community, and it really becomes sort of a informal community center.” While most people at the meeting hoped to save the garden, many citizens and nonprofits advocated for the low-income housing. Several of those in favor of the devel-
Come visit the nation’s largest art & antiques center featuring 100 galleries and over 40 categories. Enjoy time on our 3 ﬂoors of antiques, ﬁne art, and every category in-between Buy or sell, we welcome your visit 7 days a week.
Lock & Door Hardware Architectural Hardware Decorative Hardware Plumbing
1050 2nd Ave. bt. 55th & 56th Sts.
opment accused the garden’s supporters of not caring about senior and homeless New Yorkers who need affordable housing. The Friends countered this sentiment, saying the group had proposed an alternate site for the development at 388 Hudson St. The Friends said that by building at 388 Hudson St., the city could create ﬁve times as much housing for low-income seniors. But Cooper Square Committee Executive Director Steve Herrick said he doesn’t believe the number of apartments that could be built at the alternate site can feasibly be that high, and that more research needs to be done on the site. “I’m thinking you can build maybe 150 to 200 apartments, assuming there aren’t major impediments to building there,” Herrick said. The Cooper Square Committee works with many seniors in need of affordable housing, and Herrick said the board of directors is in support of the development. Herrick had attended the community meeting, and he said he understood that residents want to preserve the garden, but he also believes some don’t want to see a changing demographic in the area. “There’s a crisis,” Herrick said. “There’s 1.2 million seniors in New York City, and the population’s gonna go to 1.6 million in 20 years. Where are they gonna live? They’re aging in place in tenement buildings, including in Little Italy. They need housing. That’s the reality.” At the meeting, several families and seniors voiced their desire to save the garden because
of its position as a community center, but business owners in the area, like Lovely Day’s Kasuza Jibiki, are also concerned that with the departure of the garden comes the departure of customers. Jibiki said many people who eat lunch at the garden during the day will come into her restaurant to pick up food. “I think lots of businesses actually chose this block because of the garden,” Jibiki said. Several low-income residents themselves feel strongly about the garden’s potential erasure. Jennifer Romine lives in affordable housing on Spring Street, and she said that while there’s been a misrepresentation that only rich, selfish people want to save the garden, low-income New Yorkers in the area need the park space. “It’s one of the most congested, heavily trafficked neighborhoods in the ﬁve boroughs,” Romine said. “I’ve seen the health of the community transformed in a myriad of wonderful ways since this garden has become open to the public.” Romine said several seniors in her building are concerned because they physically can’t walk to parks, like Washington Square Park, that are farther from their homes. Families with children in her building have also expressed sadness over the idea of the garden disappearing. “These people really, they can’t afford fancy after-school programs and lessons and things,” Romine said. “They need a park. They need a park to go on the weekends.”
Seniors stop by Elizabeth Street Garden regularly to spend time together. Photo courtesy of Jennifer Romine
SKY LOCKSMITH & HARDWARE Lighting
Restoration & Repairs Lampshades Custom Lighting For The World’s Finest Homes Bespoke
Mention This ad and Receive A FREE In Home Consult in NYC!
BhonBhon Lighting BHONBHON.COM | (212) 397-3710 Visit Our Lighting Showroom 43-01 21st. Long Island City
PERSONAL TRAINING soZo concept
NEW MUL-T-LOCK ClassicPRO Installed FOR JUST $135 PLUS TAX
24/7 EMERGENCY LOCKSMITH SERVICE 212-288-7773 Store Locations: 1574 1st Ave / 182 E. 73rd / 2212 Broadway
*O)PNFt*O0GmDF Personal Training Bringing Fitness to the home & ofﬁce for over 20 years! No Weights Free Needed! Consult TRX
Call us! 800-915-4266 www.iconnel.com
KARPOFF AFFILIATES KARPOFF AFFILIATES is your single stop for senior life transitions and real estate brokerage needs. We provide peace of mind and ensure that each project is handled with respect and integrity.
www.KarpoffAfﬁliates.com mkarpoff@karpoffafﬁliates.com 212.358.8044 290 Third Avenue, Ste 26C, NYC 10010
Senior Care Companions, Homemakers, Polish/English, Live-in or Hourly, Educated, Mature Experienced, Since 1992.
Kerry Aissa Founder
Upper West Manhattan Church of Christ 80 YEARS!
Meeting at 891 Amsterdam Ave. @ 103rd St. In Hosteling International For more information: Call 212-729-8356 www.uwmchurchofchrist.com
Draperies Shades Shutters Blinds Motorization Window Film Upholstery Fabric & Trim Flooring Paint
SEMI-ANNUAL CUSTOM DECORATING SALE GOING ON NOW! UPPER WEST SIDE 469 AMSTERDAM AVE. 212.501.8282 WINDOWFASHIONS.COM
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
Write to us: To share your thoughts and comments go to otdowntown.com and click on submit a letter to the editor.
THE COMMUNITY RX BY BETTE DEWING
Civic meetings’ local concerns need coverage even when members’ minds and hearts are on the murder of 15-year-old Lesandro (Junior) Guzman-Felix, which happened the night before the East 79th Neighborhood Association’s June meeting. And just now a news ﬂash — ﬁve persons shot to death in the newsroom of their Maryland community newspaper. How long, dear Lord, how long? And this latest mass murder of innocents, must remind us how Hasidim call every such murder a cataclysm.
The slaughter of Junior was a case of mistaken identity. And no one came to his rescue when gang members dragged him from a bodega to the street where he was repeatedly stabbed to death. Imagine! You know how it was all caught on video cameras and soon went viral so thousands were outraged and saddened that this good young man suffered such a terrible and wrongful death. Yes, and how no one in the bodega and on the street came to his aid. The priest at Junior’s funeral, overﬂowing with mourners, said: if we see something we must do something — not just take videos.
But these videos so importantly showed the world the extreme viciousness of this abominable act — and enabled the capture of up to eight suspects, all but one in their early 20s. They all face life in prison if convicted of Junior’s killing. Although the Scared Straight program is directed to juveniles, prison life needs to get out there for every age group to see. This program must be revived! And yes, we need to build communities in a time when again, too many go it alone. And surely faith groups should lead this “no man is an island” crusade. The meeting of the East 79th Street Association was held at Temple Shaaray Teﬁla on East 79th Street, which decades ago replaced the Colony movie theater where showings, especially compared to today’s
ﬁlms, were fairly benign. And some of us believe violence of the ﬁctional kind can lead to the real thing. Not so unrelatedly ... some called for protests at Gracie Mansion to protest proposed zoning changes that could endanger low-rises, Deplored were the new high-rise luxury condos going up in every neighborhood — whole blocks reduced to rubble and along with them affordable homes and small businesses. And public protests are so needed on all the above. But also millennials and more men must get into the act. I just learned that Loretta Ponticelli has departed this life at age 96. Ah, Loretta was such a stalwart member of the East 79th Street Association and her efforts were invaluable in saving the Cherokee Post Office on York Avenue. Until age took its often inevitable toll, she was responsible
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR TRAFFIC PRACTICES Several comments on the mess that is Manhattan traffic: 1. When I enter a cab, I leave the door open until I hook up the seat belt; this way the driver can’t zoom away with me unbelted. 2. It’s important to see the big picture here; by not limiting the number of ride-share vehicles, as the city does with medallions, the city is wrecking the lives of yellow cab owners and drivers, jamming up the streets of Manhattan to the point of insanity, and most important of all, causing declines in the number of subway and bus users, which means less and less income to the MTA. Every time I drive in Manhattan I see these cars with T&LC license plates stopping abruptly in moving lanes, cutting across two to four lanes of traffic, double parking to pick up customers and just jamming up the roads, which makes for longer drives. The NYPD does next to nothing to enforce traffic laws on drivers, bikers or pedestrians!
Plan”: Mayor de Blasio is correct in moving ahead with his plan to modify admission criteria at the city’s specialized high schools. Such a move is long overdue. The plan presented will take into consideration several components as to a student’s qualifications for admission rather than using one single test. Margaret Chin and New York State Assembly Member Rebecca Seawright in their opposition are merely playing to their constituents. Other than calling for more discussions, they have not submitted any real counter proposals that would address the double issues of a very ﬂawed admission policy as well as a school system which is one of the most segregated in the country. DOE officials, the political eduation committee in Albany along with the schools chancellor should move ahead and put into place the needed reforms concerning these “elite schools.” B. Wallace Cheatham Tribeca
SUBWAY CHALLENGES James Battaglia Upper East Side
SCHOOLS AND DIVERSITY Re your article of June 14-20, “AsianAmerican Assail School Diveristy
How will New York City Transit President Andy Byford deal with some of the many daily challenges millions of customers face in our travels? As subway riders, we have to deal with conductors who close the doors while
for tenants City & Suburban Homes tenants looking after one another, especially vulnerable elders. If she were around now. she’d be actively concerned about those without air conditioning. One wonders did she get enough caring help in her time of need? Heartfelt thanks, dear Loretta — you are very much missed. Of course, heartfelt thanks, too, to all members the East 79th Street group and to its president, Betty Cooper Wallerstein, who do so much to make city life more of a community so needed for mental as well as physical health. We are grateful for all such groups but in a city of almost 8 million, their numbers are like the proverbial drop in the bucket. Caring communities are needed like never before. Like never before. Your help is needed.
subway stations. Many riders would gladly pay this small price to ensure working bathrooms rather than face the current unpleasant alternatives which contribute to dirty subways. Larry Penner Great Neck, NY
PARKING PERMIT DEBATE
Opponents of Mayor Bill de Blasio’s proposal to overhaul admissions to specialized high schools held a rally at City Hall June 10. Photo: State Senator Marty Golden, via Facebook passengers attempt to transfer from a local to the express train. Try looking for the proper way to depose of your old newspaper as more trash cans are removed from more stations. Riders have to deal with aggressive panhandlers, those hogging two seats, yawning, coughing or sneezing without covering up and acrobatic performers swinging from subway car poles. Many have grown tired dealing with rats, mice and litter. New York City Transit should consider installing separate cans for recycling newspapers, plastic and glass along with
regular garbage. Selling advertising on the side of cans could generate revenue to help cover the costs of more frequent off-peak and late-night collection and disposal. The odds of ﬁnding a working safe clean bathroom are limited. Until the early 1960s, most subway stations had clean, safe, working bathrooms with toilet paper. Revenues generated from a 10-cent fee helped cover the costs. Why not consider charging a fee between 25 cents and a dollar? This could help provide secure, fullyequipped bathrooms at most of the 471
Re “Safe Spaces,” (May 3-9), I disagree with the City Council’s proposal to designate parking permits for residents above 60th Street. This proposal is not only impractical, but very expensive to accomplish, let alone enforce. Cars and commercial vehicles come into Manhattan every day and they have a right to park. Some motorists have problems parking, but this is mainly because of Citi Bike taking up parking spaces, and the constant digging up of our streets by construction companies and Con Edison. How do they propose issuing permits when there is no places to park whil construction work is going on? I own a car, and live in the proposed area. I have never had a problem parking my behicle. These City Council members who proposed this should leave well enough alone. If they want to alleviate congestion, they should allow truck deliveries to supermarkets and restaurants after the rush hours are over. Charles Petz Upper East Side
President & Publisher, Jeanne Straus firstname.lastname@example.org
STRAUS MEDIA your neighborhood news source email@example.com 212-868-0190
Vice President/CFO Otilia Bertolotti Vice President/CRO Vincent A. Gardino firstname.lastname@example.org
Associate Publishers Seth L. Miller, Ceil Ainsworth Regional Sales Manager Tania Cade
Account Executives Fred Almonte, David Dallon Director of Partnership Development Barry Lewis
Editor-In-Chief, Alexis Gelber Deputy Editor Richard Khavkine
Senior Reporter Doug Feiden
Director of Digital Pete Pinto
Staff Reporter Michael Garofalo
Director, Arts & Entertainment/ NYCNow Alizah Salario
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
KARPOFF AFFILIATES is your single stop for senior life transitions and real estate brokerage needs.
The all-volunteer Bloomingdale Aging in Place provides UWS seniors with an active social life and a sense of civic involvement
tIf you or your family member needs to renovate their existing home to allow them to BHFJOQMBDFPSJTMPPLJOHUPEPXOTJ[F XFDBOIFMQ t*GZPVXBOUUPNPWF XFDBOTFMMZPVSIPNF BTTJTUXJUIQBDLJOH PWFSTFFQSPGFTTJPOBM NPWFSTBOEQSPWJEFTVQQPSUUPSFEVDFTUSFTT8FXJMMNPWFZPVPVUPGTUBUFPSCBDLUP /FX:PSL*GZPVBSFMPPLJOHGPSBOBTTJTUFEMJWJOHSFTJEFODF XFDBOIFMQ t*GZPVIBWFMPTUTPNFPOF XFXJMMPSHBOJ[FBOEBTTFTTJUFNTMFGUJOUIFIPNFBOEmOEB buyer for the residence in order to lessen the hardship during this difďŹ cult time. t Karpoff AfďŹ liates created the signature service Moving On NYC to address these needs. 8FIFMQNBOBHFFWFSZEFUBJM DPOOFDUJOHXJUIBUUPSOFZT FTUBUFHVBSEJBOT TPDJBMXPSLers and caregivers. You will deal with one person from start to ďŹ nish. t8FSVOUBHBOEFTUBUFTBMFTBOEQSPWJEFBQQSBJTBMTGPSKFXFMSZ FTUBUFTBOEmOFBOtiques. We also offer total auction services.
BY STEPHAN RUSSO
The term â€œAging in Placeâ€? has become imbedded in our lexicon when discussing the realities of growing old and the importance of staying active. â€œIn placeâ€? means New Yorkers are not leaving the city or running off to retire elsewhere. And who can blame them? What better place to spend these years than in this beloved city that offers myriad opportunities for continued personal growth and civic involvement? In 2009, a group of active West Siders decided to answer this question for themselves by creating an all-volunteer network called Bloomingdale Aging in Place (BAiP). Their mission was to build community among older adults who live between West 96th and 110th Streets. From a block association newsletter survey and a steering committee meeting, residents were asked what was most needed to help their elderly neighbors stay in their homes. The overwhelming response was the need for an active social life and connection to other residents who were concerned about feeling isolated. Fast forward ten years, and what began as a handful of volunteer group activities and helping-hand visits has blossomed into an a full-blown organization with over 1200 members, 70 group activities, and panel discussions and social events organized by the volunteers themselves. Why are efforts like BAiP so necessary today? The data is very clear about the shifts in our population. The baby boomer generation leaving the workforce is becoming one of the fastest growing demographics. In New York City alone, the Department for the Aging projects that by the year 2040 the number of residents over the age of 60 will rise to close to 2 million â€” over 20 percent of the population, There is probably no city in the country that does more than New York to create a safety net of programs that enables residents to stay in their homes
Arlene Seffern (far right) with her BAiP-sponsored knitting group. Photo: Stephan Russo and continue to live productive and meaningful lives. Some of these services are geared for lower-income seniors, but the public investment is clearly aimed at ensuring that all of our neighbors continue to thrive as they age. Over ten years ago, the city launched its Age-Friendly NYC initiative to address the needs of an aging population. The project has focused on civic engagement, housing, public spaces, transportation and health and social services. The current city leadership has increased funding over the prior administration by more than $82 million dollars to improve its more than 250 senior centers, decrease home-care waiting lists, provide weekend meals to those receiving homedelivered food and enhancing its case management services. I recently joined BAiP as I retired last year from my career in the non-proďŹ t sector. I also just turned 67 and am facing the challenge of figuring out how to spend my next twentyplus years (depending on the actuarial assumptions I use). Last November, I moved my 92 year-old mother to a senior residence in Florida when she decided she could no longer tolerate the NYC winters. Like many of my sandwich generation, I recognized through helping her how challenging life can be as the aging process kicks into high gear. Last month I attended a BAiP panel discussion led by two knowledgeable attorneys titled â€œOver My Dead Body.â€? I thought there would be few attendees, but when I entered the second floor of the Bloomingdale library on West 100th Street, I encountered a throng of more than 100 people who had gathered to learn about wills, revo-
cable trusts, health proxies and what happens to your apartment if you are alone and die in the hospital. (Did you know that you could disinherit your children but not your spouse?) Want to feel uplifted? Sit in on one of BAiPâ€™s activities. Arlene Seffern is 82 years old, and used to work in a knitting store on Broadway. She also spent part of her working life as a bookkeeper at several nonprofit organizations. Arlene felt that she had a special artistic ability. Her weekly BAiP knitting group has become a godsend to her. â€œEvery time I am in my knitting group, my face lights up,â€? Arlene said. â€œI get so much joy out of teaching the group and the members care deeply for each other. When one group member was having cataract surgery and had no one to be with her, another member picked her up and stayed with her.â€? It was a wonderful example of what BAiP calls calls N2N â€” its Neighbor-to-Neighbor program â€” and considers a core organizing principle. Caitlin Hawke, one of the many forces behind BAiP, characterizes the effort as â€œconnecting democracy to action.â€? â€œItâ€™s like threading a needle between having a structure and encouraging members to create opportunities themselves,â€? Hawke said. Membership is open if you live within the area bounded by West 96th and 110th Streets from Riverside Drive to Central Park West. To learn how more about BAiP and how you can become involved, visit their website at bloominplace.org or call 212-842-8831. Stephan Russo is the former Executive Director of Goddard Riverside Community Center.
We provide peace of mind and ensure that each project is handled with respect and integrity.
Marilyn Karpoff Founder & CEO
212-358-8044 www.KarpoffAfďŹ liates.com NLBSQPGG!LBSQPGGBGmMJBUFTDPN Compassionate Senior Move Manager and Expert Real Estate Broker
290 Third Avenue, Suite 26C | NYC 10010 The local paper for Downtown
Advertise with Our Town Downtown today! Call Vincent Gardino at 212-868-0190
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
Tired of Hunting for Our Town Downtown? Subscribe today to Downtowner News of Your Neighborhood that you can’t get anywhere else
Dining Information, plus
Discover the world around the corner. Find community events, gallery openings, book launches and much more: Go to nycnow.com
Fri 6 FREESTYLE SOCCER JAM Fosun Plaza, 28 Liberty 4 p.m. Free 28liberty.com World-class freestyle soccer athletes will take on the plaza the day before the USA Freestyle Football Championship at this soccer jam. Think break-dancing, soccer-style. No cleats necessary.
crime news, real estate prices - all about your part of town
Cultural Events in and around where you live (not Brooklyn, not Westchester)
Now get your personal copy delivered by US Mail for just
49/Year for 52 issues
To Subscribe : Call 212-868-0190 or go online to otdowntown.com and click on subscribe
Photo: Ludovic Bertron, via Flickr
GUITAR VIRTUOSO SHANE HENNESSY
▲ SUNSET ON THE HUDSON
Rockwood Music Hall 196 Allen St. 8:30 p.m. $12 Shane Hennessy, guitarist, composer and songwriter, bring his cross-genre guitar playing and cinematically vivid compositions to New York. Don’t miss his acoustic playing that combines multiple forms of world and ethnic music. 212-477-4155 rockwoodmusichall.com
Pier 45, Hudson River Greenway & West 10th St. 7 p.m. Free Bring your friends and a blanket, and start the weekend off right with music on the waterfront. Local artists Manhattan Samba will perform as the sun goes down, so come enjoy and ease out of the week. 212-627-2020 hudsonriverpark.com
FAMILY FUN DAY AT ONE WORLD OBSERVATORY One World Observatory 285 Fulton St. 10 a.m. $28 Go vertical with the kids. Take them for a ride in the astounding sky pods that travel to highest point in New York. If heights aren’t your thing, complimentary face painting, airbrush tattoos and custom balloon animals round out a festive day of fun at One Word Observatory. oneworldobservatory.com
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
MARBLE COLLEGIATE CHURCH Sunday Worship at 11:00am Sunday Worship, led by Dr. Michael S. Bos, is the heart of the Marble Church community. It is where we all gather to sing, pray, and be changed by an encounter with God. Marble is known throughout the world for the practical, powerful, life-changing messages and where one can hear world class music from our choirs that make every heart sing. Busy? Live stream Sunday Worship with us at 11:00am at MarbleChurch.org.
Summer Spirituality Series
YOGA IN THE BATTERY
▼ ONE LOVE... OR TWELVE
LATE NIGHT WHENEVER
Deutsches Haus at NYU 42 Washington Mews 6:30 p.m. Free A woman googles her ﬁrst love and ﬁnds out he threw himself out of a ninth-ﬂoor window almost ﬁve years ago. Thus beings the novel “One Another” by New York University writer-in-residence Monique Schwitter, who will read from her book and join in conversation with her translator, Tess Lewis. 212-998-8660 deutscheshaus.as.nyu.edu
The Green Space 44 Charlton St. 7 p.m. $10 Comedian Michelle Buteau’s show “Late Night Whenever” features celebrity interviews, hilarious monologues and music from Michelle’s best friend Rob Lewis, producer to stars like Christina Aguilera and Patti LaBelle. Buteau has appeared on “2 Dope Queens” along with “Broad City,” “Key and Peele” and others. 646-829-4000 thegreenespace.org
Battery Park, State Street and Battery Place 11:30 a.m. Free, donations welcome Bring your own mat at join fellow yogis in the Woodland Lawn overlooking the fountain, the blooming bosque and majestic Lady Liberty for this weekly, open level yoga practice. Repeats every Sunday. 212-344-3491 downtownny.com
Wed 11 ▲ IMAGES ON THE RUN: CONTEMPORARY STREET PHOTOGRAPHY International Center of Photography, 250 Bowery 6:30 p.m. Free Inspired by ICP’s exhibition “Henri Cartier-Bresson: The Decisive Moment,” this panel discussion brings together contemporary street photographers Khalik Allah, Cheryl Dunn and Jacqueline Silberbush and asks them to relate the moments, subjects and scenes that deﬁne their own “decisive moments.” 212-857-0000 icp.org
Sundays, June 17 through August 26 at 10:00am Exploring a variety of topics which will be utilized to engage in a number of theological discussions. All sessions meet in the Labyrinth Room and will also be live streamed.
Marble Collegiate Church Mobile App Download on iPhone or Android With the Marble Collegiate Church app, discover a new way to connect with Marble anytime you want. Live stream, catch up on last week’s sermon, connect with ministries, keep informed and register for Marble events, make a gift and sign up to volunteer.
Our Labyrinth Walks Labyrinth walks at Marble Collegiate Church are open to all: • First Sunday of each month: 1:00-3:00pm • Wednesdays: 5:00-6:00pm (Please call the church to conﬁrm schedule) Our Labyrinth Facilitators will be available to help guide you and answer any questions you may have, while allowing you the space to walk in your own way, at your own pace.
Event listings brought to you by Marble Collegiate Church. 1 West 29th Street / New York, New York 10001 212 686 2770 / MarbleChurch.org Download the Marble Church App on iPhone or Android
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
VISITING AGNES GUND’S STUDIO MoMA’s glimpse at a great patron’s impact BY MARY GREGORY
Without patrons, we wouldn’t have art. It was true in the Renaissance. It’s true today. Visitors to the Uffizi in Florence can experience the inﬂuence, taste and reﬁnement of the Medicis, bankers to kings and popes, through the artworks they collected and then bequeathed. Visitors to MoMA’s “Studio Visit: Selected Gifts from Agnes Gund” can see how it works today. Roughly 50 of the more than 800 major works of modern and contemporary art collected by and gifted to the Museum of Modern Art by its president emerita, New Yorker Agnes Gund (daughter of a successful Ohio banker), are included in this extraordinary exhibition. It ﬁlls several galleries and spans decades, styles, media and social realities. The show opens with a beautiful 1941 painting, “Children,” by William H. Johnson, a triple portrait that’s just about as flattened, vibrant and modern as a Matisse cut-out, and ends with an enormous, potent 2017 work on paper by Kara Walker, “Christ’s Entry into Journalism,” that presents ideas on sexism, racism, and social injustices. Bookending the exhibition with 20th and 21st century African-American artists’ works was an astute choice by the curatorial team led by Ann Temkin. “My friendships with artists,” Gund has said, “as well as a sensitivity to the challenges facing women artists and artists of color, have been formative in shaping my collection.” Like the Cone sisters, whose support of Matisse and Picasso was foundational for Modernism, Agnes Gund (Aggie, as she introduces herself in the exhibition’s audio) befriended, collected and championed world-famous artists as well as those just starting out. In the exhibition, major works by iconic 20th century American masters like Ellsworth Kelly, Robert Rauschenberg and Jasper Johns have been intentionally placed in conversation with pieces by less-known con-
IF YOU GO WHAT: “Studio Visit: Selected Gifts from Agnes Gund” WHERE: Museum of Modern Art, Floor Two, Collection Galleries WHEN: Through July 22
temporary artists. Mona Hatoum is a British artist of Palestinian descent. Her “Pin Rug” made of upward facing straight pins, subverts a familiar form with contradictory, menacing material, and at the same time references the use of rugs and carpets in different cultures. Willie Cole used a steam iron to scorch images onto paper in “Domestic I.D. IV” an allusion to the history of household workers, largely female. Nick Cave’s fantastic “Soundsuit” is worn by a mannequin. Its legs are covered by small green mirrors, while the torso and head present an expansive, swirling assemblage with a gramophone horn and wires holding dozens of porcelain sculptures of birds. Cave, in his statement, explains that his ﬁrst Soundsuits were created in response to the 1991 police beating of Rodney King — an effort to disguise oneself, to disappear behind a mask. It also hearkens back to a rich history of African masks, sometimes with moveable and auditory components, that often cover the entire body. Art by women comprises much of the work in the exhibition, even though Gund, a woman collector, reveals that it was sometimes challenging to acquire. “I was told really by gallerists, and some of them women, too, that they just couldn’t sell women artists very well, because people wanted even in those days, in the ‘60s, ‘70s and 80s, they wanted a person that they could count on rising in value. I was very distressed by that,” she states in the exhibition video. Sculptor Lynda Benglis, whose elegant, torquing, gold-leafed bronze, “Ghost Dance/Pedmarks” sparkles with energy, calls Gund “the mother of contemporary art.” There’s a striking, lively 2007 abstraction, “Painters Progress” by Elizabeth Murray, and a double portrait
Nick Cave’s “Soundsuit” from 2011 might appear whimsical, but was born from outrage. Photo: Adel Gorgy. by Alice Neel that palpably evokes the personalities of its subjects, “Benny and Mary Ellen Andrews.” Complex text-based work by Jenny Holzer, Laurie Anderson’s “Self-Playing Violin” and photographer Catherine Opie’s powerful portrait “Dyke” add to a sense of the range and sophistication of Gund’s interests and vision. “Studio Visit” is far from the only place to see Agnes Gund’s impact on New York, passing through the Agnes Gund Lobby of the museum reminds us. She serves as chairman of the board of directors of MoMA PS1. She founded the Studio in a School program in the late 1970s; for more than 40 years it’s been bringing supplies, teachers and famous artists like Jeff Koons to New York public school classrooms and kids. When Vermeer’s “Girl with a Pearl Earring” visited the Frick Collection in 2013, Gund donated the money needed for free Friday-evening viewings, making the treasures of Holland’s Mauritshuis available to all who were willing to wait in line. In 2017, she sold her Roy Lichtenstein painting, “Masterpiece,” for $150 million, using the proceeds to start the Art for Justice Fund, an initiative to reform the criminal-justice system. MoMA’s selections from her more than half-century of contributions offer a glimpse of Agnes Gund and her impact — she’s a superhero of the arts with a painting for a cape.
Elizabeth Murray’s “Painters Progress,” an artwork that takes 19 panels to contain. Photo: Adel Gorgy
“Benny and Mary Ellen Andrews” by Alice Neel. Even a major collector like Agnes Gund had difficulty buying art by women in the 1960s, ‘70s and ‘80s. For decades, Gund has challenged and changed conventions. Photo: Adel Gorgy
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
Your Neighborhood News Source
BEYOND BROADWAY - DOWNTOWN The #1 online community for NYC theater:
NOW PLAYING IN YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD FROM $39
GIRLS & BOYS
802 REVIEWS ENDS AUG 26
68 REVIEWS ENDS JUL 15
44 REVIEWS ENDS JUL 15
Tooting Arts Club’s immersive staging of Sondheim and Wheeler’s iconic musical thriller.
Carey Mulligan stars in this new play from Dennis Kelly that takes you on a gripping journey.
A revival of Basil Twist’s boundary-breaking surreal show set in a 1,000-gallon water tank.
BARROW STREET THEATRE - 27 BARROW ST
MINETTA LANE THEATRE - 18 MINETTA LN
HERE ARTS CENTER - 145 6TH AVE
WHAT’S TRENDING ACROSS NYC
COMING SOON FROM $59
DESPERATE MEASURES 854 REVIEWS OPEN RUN
SMOKEY JOE’S CAFE PREVIEWS START JUL 6
An all-new incarnation of the record-breaking hit revue celebrating the best songs of Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller.
STAGE 42 - 422 W 42ND ST
A foot-stompin’, knee-slappin’ new musical set in the Old West based on ‘Measure for Measure.’ FROM $20
NEW WORLD STAGES - 340 W 50TH ST
THE HOUSE THAT WILL NOT STAND PREVIEWS START JUL 11
In the summer 1813 Louisiana passed from France to the United States. This story is inspired by Federico Garcia Lorca’s ‘The House of Bernarda Alba.’
102 REVIEWS ENDS JUL 21
NEW YORK THEATRE WORKSHOP - 79 E 4TH ST
A provocative romance set against the backdrop of a hotly contested election in 1925 London.
THE END OF MERMAIDS OPENS JUL 12
THEATRE ROW / BECKETT THEATRE - 410 W 42ND ST
This new play invites you to Mermaidland, Florida, the only place on earth where mermaids are real.
PASS OVER 59 REVIEWS ENDS JUL 15
PARADISE FACTORY - 64 E 4TH ST
THE PATTERN AT PENDARVIS
PREVIEWS START JUL 13
Content provided by
This mashup of ‘Waiting for Godot’ and the Exodus saga explores the spirit of young black men.
A fictionalized look at a real life closeted man in his nineties who did pioneering work in historic preservation in the midwest.
CLAIRE TOW THEATER - 150 W 65TH ST
HERE ARTS CENTER - 145 6TH AVE KEY:
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
RESTAURANT INSPECTION RATINGS JUN 20 - 26, 2018 The following listings were collected from the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene’s website and include the most recent inspection and grade reports listed. We have included every restaurant listed during this time within the zip codes of our neighborhoods. Some reports list numbers with their explanations; these are the number of violation points a restaurant has received. To see more information on restaurant grades, visit www.nyc.gov/html/doh/html/services/restaurant-inspection.shtml. Amsterdam Billiards
85 4 Avenue
380 Lafayette Street
201 First Ave
Grade Pending (16) Cold food item held above 41º F (smoked ﬁsh and reduced oxygen packaged foods above 38 ºF) except during necessary preparation. Food not protected from potential source of contamination during storage, preparation, transportation, display or service.
324 E 6th St
35 Union Sq W
Grade Pending (5) Evidence of mice or live mice present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas.
9 East 16 Street
Grade Pending (37) Evidence of mice or live mice present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas. Filth ﬂies or food/refuse/sewageassociated (FRSA) ﬂies present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas. Filth ﬂies include house ﬂies, little house ﬂies, blow ﬂies, bottle ﬂies and ﬂesh ﬂies. Food/refuse/sewage-associated ﬂies include fruit ﬂies, drain ﬂies and Phorid ﬂies.
Third Rail Coffee
159 2nd Avenue
Big Arc Chicken
233 1st Ave
Grade Pending (2)
Il Cantinori Restauraunt
32 East 10 Street
178 2 Avenue
20 East 16 Street
Grade Pending (24) Cold food item held above 41º F (smoked ﬁsh and reduced oxygen packaged foods above 38 ºF) except during necessary preparation. Filth ﬂies or food/refuse/sewage-associated (FRSA) ﬂies present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas. Filth ﬂies include house ﬂies, little house ﬂies, blow ﬂies, bottle ﬂies and ﬂesh ﬂies. Food/refuse/ sewage-associated ﬂies include fruit ﬂies, drain ﬂies and Phorid ﬂies. Food contact surface not properly washed, rinsed and sanitized after each use and following any activity when contamination may have occurred.
13 St Marks Place
55 East 8 Street
104 2 Avenue
9 E 17th St
Little Poland Restaurant
200 2nd Ave
Grade Pending (21) Evidence of mice or live mice present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas. Food not protected from potential source of contamination during storage, preparation, transportation, display or service. Food contact surface not properly washed, rinsed and sanitized after each use and following any activity when contamination may have occurred.
Gramercy Farmer & The Fish
247A Park Ave S
Grade Pending (23) Evidence of mice or live mice present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas. Food not protected from potential source of contamination during storage, preparation, transportation, display or service. Food contact surface not properly washed, rinsed and sanitized after each use and following any activity when contamination may have occurred.
7 E 14th St
Grade Pending (17) Cold food item held above 41º F (smoked ﬁsh and reduced oxygen packaged foods above 38 ºF) except during necessary preparation. Food Protection Certiﬁcate not held by supervisor of food operations.
145 2 Avenue
Sao Mai Vietnamese Cuisine
203 1 Avenue
59 1st Ave
Not Yet Graded (10) Evidence of mice or live mice present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas.
Joe & Pat’s
168 1St Ave
The Organic Grill
123 1 Avenue
Grade Pending (17) Cold food item held above 41º F (smoked ﬁsh and reduced oxygen packaged foods above 38 ºF) except during necessary preparation. Personal cleanliness inadequate. Outer garment soiled with possible contaminant. Effective hair restraint not worn in an area where food is prepared.
235 E 4th St
Grade Pending (25) Food worker does not use proper utensil to eliminate bare hand contact with food that will not receive adequate additional heat treatment. Evidence of mice or live mice present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas. Food contact surface not properly washed, rinsed and sanitized after each use and following any activity when contamination may have occurred.
Against the Grain
620 E 6th St
Not Yet Graded (79) Evidence of mice or live mice present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas. Food contact surface improperly constructed or located. Unacceptable material used. No facilities available to wash, rinse and sanitize utensils and/or equipment. Food not protected from potential source of contamination during storage, preparation, transportation, display or service. Wiping cloths soiled or not stored in sanitizing solution.
Il Posto Accanto
190 East 2 Street
274 East 3 Street
M & J Asian Restaurant
600 E 14th St
Grade Pending (26) Cold food item held above 41º F (smoked ﬁsh and reduced oxygen packaged foods above 38 ºF) except during necessary preparation. Filth ﬂies or food/refuse/sewage-associated (FRSA) ﬂies present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas. Filth ﬂies include house ﬂies, little house ﬂies, blow ﬂies, bottle ﬂies and ﬂesh ﬂies. Food/refuse/ sewage-associated ﬂies include fruit ﬂies, drain ﬂies and Phorid ﬂies. Food not protected from potential source of contamination during storage, preparation, transportation, display or service.
East Village Tavern
158 Avenue C
Not Yet Graded (19) Food not protected from potential source of contamination during storage, preparation, transportation, display or service.
296 Bleecker St
Not Yet Graded (17) Evidence of mice or live mice present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas. Food contact surface not properly washed, rinsed and sanitized after each use and following any activity when contamination may have occurred.
289 Bleecker St
Grade Pending (24) Cold food item held above 41º F (smoked ﬁsh and reduced oxygen packaged foods above 38 ºF) except during necessary preparation. Food from unapproved or unknown source or home canned. Reduced oxygen packaged (ROP) ﬁsh not frozen before processing; or ROP foods prepared on premises transported to another site. Food not protected from potential source of contamination during storage, preparation, transportation, display or service.
516 Hudson St
Grade Pending (26) Cold food item held above 41º F (smoked ﬁsh and reduced oxygen packaged foods above 38 ºF) except during necessary preparation. Evidence of mice or live mice present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas. Food not protected from potential source of contamination during storage, preparation, transportation, display or service.
11 Street Cafe
327 West 11 Street
Urban Vegan Kitchen
4143 Carmine Street
Grade Pending (19) Hot food item not held at or above 140º F. Evidence of mice or live mice present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas.
99 7th Ave S
80 Grove Street
20 7 Avenue South
Grade Pending (24) Raw, cooked or prepared food is adulterated, contaminated, cross-contaminated, or not discarded in accordance with HACCP plan. Filth ﬂies or food/refuse/sewage-associated (FRSA) ﬂies present in facility’s food and/or non-food areas. Filth ﬂies include house ﬂies, little house ﬂies, blow ﬂies, bottle ﬂies and ﬂesh ﬂies. Food/ refuse/sewage-associated ﬂies include fruit ﬂies, drain ﬂies and Phorid ﬂies. Food not protected from potential source of contamination during storage, preparation, transportation, display or service.
Murray’s Cheese Bar
264 Bleecker Street
Grade Pending (24) Cold food item held above 41º F (smoked ﬁsh and reduced oxygen packaged foods above 38 ºF) except during necessary preparation. Food worker does not use proper utensil to eliminate bare hand contact with food that will not receive adequate additional heat treatment. Food contact surface not properly washed, rinsed and sanitized after each use and following any activity when contamination may have occurred.
9 Jones St
RALLY CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 After crossing the bridge, protesters gathered in Brooklyn’s Cadman Plaza Park. People gathered in the shade and surrounded the main stage to listen to speakers. A kid’s station provided paper and markers for children to draw and play. Speakers included leaders of unions and nonprofits. They urged people to vote, to call elected officials and to keep informed. Talks went on for roughly two hours, during which marchers continued streaming into the park. The last batch of them had left Foley Square just after noon. Actors Kerry Washington, Padma Lakshmi and Amy Schumer also spoke to the crowd. Washington, a mother of two, called family separation a gross violation of human rights and led the crowd in a chant of “I matter, we matter. I am the people, we are the people.” “I love this country because it has the potential to be a more perfect union,” Washington
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com said. “But do you know what it means to be a more perfect union? It means you. It means us. It means to believe in the idea that we matter. Every single one of us.” Washington called on the protesters to be strong, said that their fight would be a marathon. She then spoke on her own experience and anger about the practice of family separation. “I am here as a lot of things today,” Washington said. “I am here as an American. I’m here as a woman who’s concerned about my ability to control my body. I’m here as the granddaughter of immigrants. I’m here as the member of a union. I am also here as a mother — and as a mother, I am outraged.” She joked that her day job is to read the words of other people, and she then read an affidavit by a mother whose son was held at an immigration center. Washington asked the crowd to keep the mother and all the families in their hearts. “This isn’t about politics,” Washington said. “This is about people.”
“IF ONLY SOMEONE WOULD CLEAN UP THIS PARK.”
BE THE SOMEONE. Every day, we think to ourselves that someone should really help make this city a better place. Visit newyorkcares.org to learn about the countless ways you can volunteer and make a difference in your community.
Cat New York Cares Volunteer
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
Lines went down the block in the last week before Glaser’s closed. Photo courtesy of Office of Ben Kallos.
ONE LAST TREAT FROM GLASER’S Sadness and support after a century of service from the iconic Upper East Side bakery BY OSCAR KIM BAUMAN
The air is oppressively hot, with ofﬁcial sources saying it’s somewhere in the mid-90s, but you wouldn’t be able to tell by looking at the line wrapping around the corner of First Avenue and 87th Street. In the ﬁnal week of June, those in line braved heat, humidity and rapid-onset summer storms, all in the hopes of getting one last treat from Glaser’s Bake Shop before its ﬁnal day of operation on July 1st. In a post on the bakery’s Facebook page on March 2, Herb Glaser, the grandson of founder John Herbert Glaser, broke the news of Glaser’s impending closing. The response was passionate and immediate. The post garnered over 1,300 reactions, more than 900 of which were Facebook’s “sad” reaction, as well as nearly 600 comments expressing sadness and support. One such supporter, Robyn RothMoise, who waited two and a half hours to get her last haul from Glaser’s, said she will miss the place the
shop held in the community. “I love mom and pop shops, and places where people recognize you when you come in.” She also shared her own memories of Glaser’s, remembering the way the cakes she bought always “were baked and decorated with love.” While Glaser’s remained steadfast for over a century, the neighborhood around it has seen dramatic change. Glaser’s opened in 1902, the creation of John Herbert Glaser, who immigrated from Germany and came to settle in the area now known as Yorkville, then known as “Germantown” due to its reputation as a haven for German immigrants. These days, however, it’s hard to see much German in the former Germantown. Glaser’s was one of the few remaining German businesses left, with the Schaller & Weber market a few blocks away a rare exception. A cursory look around the neighborhood will ﬁnd an Irish ﬂag at a bar around the corner to be a solitary identiﬁer of any national identity. Despite their enduring popularity, Glaser’s’ long run has not been without bumps. In December 2012, the store was briefly shut down by the Health Department after mice were discovered during an inspection. Al-
though the shop was forced to miss out on the lucrative Christmas business, it quickly returned to serving Yorkville, and received an “A” on every health inspection since. As Glaser’s’ last week neared, the shows of support only escalated. On June 29, City Council Member Ben Kallos presented the shop with a proclamation, enumerating details from its illustrious history. Amid the myriad details is one that took Glaser’s’ impact beyond the local — its fame as the possible originator of the iconic black and white cookie. While July 1st may have marked the end for Glaser’s Bake Shop, it was also a new beginning for the man who bears its name. Herb Glaser, along with his brother John, say that they plan to sell the building that houses the shop, and Herb plans to retire to his house in New Paltz. Although the Glaser family will soon depart, it was their ownership of the building that allowed them to stay open for so long. Roth-Moise noted that “it is nice that they made the choice to retire and close the shop instead of being forced to close due to rent,” while also expressing worry for the future of the neighborhood. “What we don’t need is another tall building
Council Member Ben Kallos (left) honors Glaser’s with a proclamation. Photo courtesy of Office of Ben Kallos coming in and tearing down these old buildings.” As the heat of the late afternoon sun burned on Sunday, the heat of the ovens at 1670 First Avenue died down for the last time. A few hours earlier, the block had been packed with locals and visitors alike, eagerly hoping for an edible souvenir of their own. Now, the street is quiet. Pedestrians stroll past at a brisk pace, hoping to escape the sun. Glaser’s eggshell blue sign looks a bit duller, as bright afternoon light
casts long shadows across it. Although Glaser’s may be gone, its memory lives on in all those who frequented it. Roth-Moise recalled an exchange she had with Herb Glaser, inquiring about what would become of the shop’s displays. “He said if you can take them out, they are yours. He doesn’t need any physical pieces of the store. All of his memories [pointing to his head] are up here.”
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
./ !10-2 3
!*2 3 %
*2 3 1
./ !'012 3
50"2 3 -
-012 3 *
%0-2 3 "
%0'2 3 '
!50-2 3 ,
-012 3 !#
>? 0@0? A A > @ 0;@ @ +? >> B 0
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
SUTTON TOWER GETS GREEN LIGHT BUILDINGS City rules in developer’s favor in appeal; local group vows to take case to court BY MICHAEL GAROFALO
Photo courtesy of Judith Pincus
REMEMBERING CONAN FREUD LIVES After a distinguished career in city government, one of New York’s brightest lights succumbs to a 9/11-related illness BY TOM ALLON
In seventh grade at the McBurney School on the Upper West Side many of my classmates yawned and scribbled in their notebooks during Mr. Barnes’s “New York City History” class. Except for wide-eyed intellectual Conan Freud, whose precocious knowledge of arcane city history impressed me even then. When we were asked in 1976 in that class to write a manifesto for the secession of Staten Island from the other four boroughs, I recall that Conan’s presentation stood out and made a compelling ﬁnancial case for the forgotten borough. Even then, Conan understood that to really analyze a municipality, you had to roll your sleeves up and study its complicated ﬁnances. Following the money was key to following its destiny. We both transferred to the same high school, the esteemed Stuyvesant High School in lower Manhattan. Even among the 3000 eggheads there, Conan carved out his distinct niche. He became the student government treasurer, not the sexiest perch for teenagers, but an extremely vital and important cog in the wheels of student government. Conan was the guy I went to when I felt the student newspaper I edited wasn’t getting its fair share of student government funding. He care-
fully looked over the ledger to ﬁnd some pocket of loose change and creatively moved it to satisfy his inkstained friends request. Conan was a whiz with budgets and he worked his magic even then. Unlike his fellow Stuy grads, Conan wasn’t looking for fame in law or medicine or string theory physics. He always aspire le to work in City government; his parents were civically active Westsiders and he learned the importance of community involvement at the dinner table. In fact, as I recall, his feisty mother, Olive, was one of the biggest thorns in the path of a greedy West Side developer named Donald Trump. Her activism in opposing his West Side project, Trump City, was one the reasons it took him decades to get approval for even a scaled back version of his original project. After a distinguished 30-year career in government that included stints at OMB, DOT, TLC and probably countless other acronyms — all in a budgeting capacity — Conan succumbed to a 9/11-related illness last week at the way too early age of 56. I knew him as a classmate, a friend, a husband, a father (our children attended pre-school together) and as a committed and engaged New Yorker. Like legions of his former colleagues and friends, I was very saddened to hear the news of his passing last week. Our city has lost one its brightest lights. I hope that his legacy of training young New Yorkers in the arcane ins and outs of municipal finance will continue to benefit our great metropolis. Tom Allon is the president of City & State.
An 800-foot-tall condominium tower is poised to rise on East 58th Street following a June 26 ruling by the city’s Board of Standards and Appeals to allow the project to move forward, but a local opposition group has vowed to continue its long-running ﬁght to block the skyscraper in court. Work on Gamma Real Estate’s proposed 64-story tower at 430 East 58th St., a mid-block lot between First Avenue and Sutton Place, was temporarily stopped late last year following the City Council’s approval of a zoning change intended to prevent supertall developments in the Sutton Area neighborhood. Gamma brought its case to the Board of Standards and Appeals, the city agency responsible for reviewing land use determinations, arguing that construction on the 159-unit condo building should be allowed to proceed because its foundation was substantially complete when the rezoning was enacted last November. The Board of Standards and Appeals ruled in the developer’s favor, paving the way for the project to continue. The East River Fifties Alliance, a local group that helped lead the 2017 rezoning effort, criticized the Board of Standards and Appeals’ decision and pledged to file a lawsuit to stop the project. “The East River Fifties Alliance will now take the community’s ﬁght against this monstrous, out-ofplace mega-tower to the courts and away from a city agency,” Lisa Mercurio, the East River Fifties Alliance’s communications director, said in an emailed statement. The group and other opponents of the development accused Gamma of violating city construction regulations in a rush to finish the building’s foundation before the zoning
A rendering of an earlier proposal for the East 58th Street site that called for a 950-foot condominium development. amendment was approved. “Unfortunately for the community and the City at large, the Board of Standards and Appeals abrogated its responsibilities under the Zoning Resolution, including especially its obligation to independently assess the invalidity of ill-gotten, after-hours work variances and alleged street closure permits that allowed the tower’s developer to engage in a race to complete the foundation,” Mercurio said. There is currently no timeline for
when the group expects to ﬁle its lawsuit. Gamma Real Estate did not respond to a request for comment. The Daily News reported in June that the law ﬁrm representing Gamma Real Estate in its appeal, Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel LLP, had lobbied the administration of Mayor Bill de Blasio in 2017 on Gamma’s behalf to add a grandfather clause to the rezoning proposal that would have allowed for the completion of the building. The administration added the provision to a draft of the zoning amendment, but the City Council subsequently voted to remove the clause in the ﬁnal text. As reported by the Daily News, Kramer Levin represented de Blasio during state and federal investigations into his fundraising practices (prosecutors concluded the probes in 2017 without bringing charges against de Blasio), for which the mayor owes the firm $300,000 in outstanding legal debts. The administration has denied that the relationship played any role in the decision reached by the members of the Board of Standards and Appeals, who are appointed by the mayor. “The ﬁght to preserve our residential communities against super-tall buildings will likely have to continue in court before a judiciary less likely to be tainted by the political process after today’s irresponsible decision by the Board of Standards and Appeals,” Ben Kallos, who represents the area in the City Council and championed the 2017 rezoning, said in a statement following the June 26 decision. “Once again the city is allowing a developer to ignore the laws, having hurtled forward with its illegal foundation, in full knowledge of the zoning change, then asking the city for special treatment after the fact,” he continued. “If [Gamma Real Estate President Jonathan] Kalikow’s behavior is any indication of what the city is prepared to let developers get away with, then no law on the books will prevent developers from abusing the system and winning, until the courts step in,” Kallos said.
FRICK EXPANSION APPROVED The Frick Collection won approval for its $160 million expansion proposal from the city’s Landmarks Preservation Commission on June 26, over the objections of some preservation groups. The Frick will add 27,000 square feet of new space and repurpose 60,000 existing square feet at its 1914 mansion at East 70th Street and Fifth Avenue, adding room for its collection and special exhibits, conservation work and educational programming. The approved expansion plan followed a failed 2014 expansion pitch that museum officials abandoned after being met with community opposition over the proposed elimination of the museum’s 70th Street garden. The garden will be preserved and restored under the current plan. Museum officials hope to break ground in 2020.
A rendering of the Frick Collection’s façade as it will appear following a planned expansion that won city approval in June. Image: Selldorf Architects
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
One Person’s Manhattan
HELP AND HOPE Lisa Honig Buksbaum is a woman with a mission to alleviate the suffering of others BY HARVEY COHEN
It’s 4 a.m. and the phone rings: you learn your brother has died of an asthma-induced heart attack. Two hours later, you cry as you inform your parents that their son is dead. Five weeks after that, your father is diagnosed with cancer and receives a bone marrow transplant, but the doctors say recovery is impossible and the family needs to prepare for his death. Then 10 months later, the tragedies contin- Lisa Buksbaum presents a puppet and other gifts to a patient at Beth Israel Medical Center. ue as you learn your young son has rheumat- Photo: Angeline Eckbert ic fever with heart damage and neurological impairment. Sachs, American Express, Viacom and NYC But sometimes suffering can lead to inspioffices of Cisco, Facebook, Google, Deloitte ration and hope, and a mission to alleviate and Verizon. Creating shifts in your attitude, your the suffering of others. Buksbaum, who has an MBA degree from body and overall wellbeing. So it was for Lisa Honig Buksbaum, a resiColumbia and formerly worked at major New dent of the Upper West Side and the CEO and York advertising agencies, has also used her founder of Soaringwords, a not-for-profit business and marketing skills to form sucorganization. Lisa’s father lived for 19 years cessful alliances that beneﬁt the children. Choosing to notice and celebrate good after the doctors gave up hope and her son is These partners include New York City public things even when times are difficult now 28 years old, over six feet tall and fully schools like P.S. 1 in Chinatown and P.S. 152 or painful. recovered. in Washington Heights; the Metropolitan Through her experiences with sickness Museum, MOMA, the Museum of Art and and death and recovery, Buksbaum learned Design and community groups such as the how to bring hope and healing to hospitalJCC, YMCA, Boys & Girls Clubs and local Gaining a sense of control by sharing ized children who face chronic or serious illchurches and synagogues. your creativity, kindness, strengths nesses and to offer support to their families. It’s hard to imagine, but besides all of this, and hope with others. And she is now a woman with a mission — a Buksbaum finds time to enjoy activities in mission to inspire ill children and their famiManhattan. Though she was raised in New lies to take active roles in their own healing. Jersey, her earliest and fondest memories are Soaringwords is unique among other crossing the George Washington Bridge to Flourishing even in difficult times. groups assisting sick children and their visit her grandmother in Manhattan. families as it is guided by the principle that She remembers sleeping over at her grandyou can heal by helping others who also need mother’s apartment and being too excited help. So the organization goes into hospitals to fall asleep. She fondly recalls the thrill of Connecting to your inner knowledge and works with children to create art, video, seeing Broadway plays like “Pippin,” “Cats” to heal. ﬁction and other projects that are then given and “Phantom of the Opera.” as gifts of hope to other ill children. And many These days, she walks through Central is the day that Buksbaum will hear a child say, Park six days a week to get to the Manhattan “Today was the happiest day of my life.” And JCC where she starts her day with a morning Sharing the power of positive that, of course, is what makes her day. swim and twice a week takes a Pilates class. storytelling, reading and writing. Bucksbaum developed the “soaring into In the evening, she can often be found strength” model that has been tested among walking through Central Park with her thousands of children, based on concepts of husband Jacob or visiting a museum. Every positive psychology. The model has proven Saturday morning she attends services at Recognizing and celebrating to be a source of comfort and healing, guided B’nai Jeshurun and often attends lectures moments of appreciation. by seven components: and social events at The Jewish Center. “My faith informs everything I do.” she says. Shifting: creating shifts in your attitude, “Waking up each morning is a gift and someyour body and overall wellbeing. thing I do not take for granted.” And clearly Optimism: choosing to notice and celebrate she has used that gift to ﬁnd meaning by helping children and their good things even when times are difficult or painful. Altruism: gaining a sense of control by sharing your creativity, families work through difficult situations with hope and optimism. Buksbaum has also completed a manuscript for a new book: “Soarkindness, strengths and hope with others. ing into Strength: The New Science Approach to Help You Heal.” Resiliency: ﬂourishing even in difficult times. The book highlights ﬁfteen inspirational stories of children and Imagery: Connecting to your inner knowledge to heal. their families who grappled with illness and are now thriving. After Narrative: sharing the power of positive storytelling. Gratitude: recognizing and celebrating moments of appreciation. each chapter there is a workbook section where readers can journal Soaringwords has grown and has now assisted over 500,000 chil- to bring about changes in their thoughts and actions to help them experience transformative healing in their own lives. dren and their families in 196 hospitals around the world. Here in Manhattan Buksbaum has worked with Mount Sinai Beth Israel, Weill Cornell and NewYork-Presbyterian, NYU Medical Cen- If you want help Lisa Honig Buksbaum help others, you can contact her at: lisa@ ter and Bellevue Hospital. Her corporate sponsors include Johnson soaringwords.org & Johnson, JPMorgan Chase, New York Life, BNYMellon, Goldman
AT FIRST I WAS EMBARRASSE D. ME, A CAT, LIVING WITH A SINGLE GUY. BUT WH EN I WATCH HIM PICK SOMETHING UP WITH HIS HANDS AND EAT IT, I CAN’T H ELP BUT LOVE HIM. — MARU adopted 01-10-10
Know someone we should profile in One Person’s Manhattan? Call 212-868-0190 or email email@example.com.
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
YOUR 15 MINUTES
To read about other people who have had their “15 Minutes” go to otdowntown.com/15 minutes
AIRING IT OUT Theasa Tuohy draws on her own experiences, and on her mother’s, in her new novel BY SUSHMITA ROY
Open cockpits dominated the skies during the 1920s and ‘30s. And that freedom to roam the heavens was, for a time, a metaphor for an epoch when everything seemed limitless. On the ground, too, optimism spread like fog on a summer morning. And, in greater and greater numbers, women were in the forefront during those heady days. They would gain the right to vote in 1920. And, increasingly, they would take liberties not explicitly granted to them, including ﬂying. “My mother was a flyer in the ‘30s so I just sort of grew up thinking that you do what you gotta do and it didn’t bother me when people would turn me down because I was a woman. I was like — OK, go on to the next one,” said Theasa Tuohy, 83, a veteran journalist who had tenures at Newsday, The Detroit News, The Associated Press and The (Newark, N.J.) Star-Ledger. Tuohy, who lives on the Upper East Side, recently wrote “Flying Jenny,” a ﬁctional tribute to early days of wom-
en’s aviation. Taking place in 1920s and ‘30s, and loosely based on her mother’s exploits, the story explores the journey of two women: Jenny, the daring stunt pilot, and Laura, the ﬁrst woman journalist at a New York City tabloid. Drawn from the true events in Elinor Smith’s life, who, at 17, and on dare, ﬂew under all four of the New York City’s East River, Tuohy does what, maybe, she was born to do: explore the journey of various women in male-dominated ﬁelds.
How would you describe New York in the 1920s? New York of 1929 was just really fun. Laura (one of the two female protagonists) lives on Gay street and a lot of scenes come from memories; my sister-in-law lived down there for a bit. I used to live in the Village in those days and the scene with the woman screaming from the women’s house of detention came from my memory of hearing a lot of those women. My ﬁrst apartment was on Bedford Street in the Village so the stuff about Chumley’s came from the memory of its back entrance being on the same block where I lived so I thought it was something really cool that I could sneak in.
Theasa Logan Tuohy, the author’s mother and her “crate.” Photo courtesy of Theasa Tuohy
Would you say that the main character, Jenny, is inspired by your mother and the stunt pilot Elinor Smith? My mother had a pilot’s license which of course was very unusual at that time but I think she was just there for the fun of it or to join the boys. My father’s friends were pilots and even though he wasn’t a pilot himself, he flew all the time with these goofy guys. Whenever there was an air show, here is a woman, they would drag her along, to enhance the visuals or something. A lot of the stunts that Jenny pulls off, Elinor Smith did: stealing the plane, ﬂying under the New York City bridges. The kernel of who Jenny was came from Elinor smith as a stunt pilot. My mother was so tiny that she always tucked a pillow between her and the seat (which is how I got Jenny to do it); she didn’t even want to ﬂy upside down because she was scared that the pillow would fall. Jenny gets her carefree attitude from my mother probably.
How much does your story of being a woman journalist back in the day lend into Laura’s development as a character? Laura faced a lot more but I could always sense the kind of things that she faced. She was the only woman in the newsroom at the time, at the tabloid, and the only way she got that job was because she had done very well in English at Barnard and a professor leaned on the publisher to give her a job and I think that’s kind of the way you got a job in those days.
Theasa Tuohy. Photo courtesy of Theasa Tuohy
Were there any setbacks when you started your career as a journalist? I think this was right after I left the Yonkers Herald Statesman; I was sending out resumes and sending them out to every place. One news manager sent me a letter saying “please call to make an appointment for an audition,” so I called and got on the phone and said, “Mr. so and so, I am Theasa Tuohy and you told me to call for an audition” and there was dead silence for a second and then the guy said, “If you are a woman, lady, the deal is off,” but that’s the way it was and so I went to apply to another place. It was then that I went to Yonkers and the guy said, “I have got an opening at my copydesk but I don’t know. I’ll give you a week’s tryout to see what you can do.” And I said to him, “How heavy can a number 2 lead pencil and copy be?” so for me it wasn’t a big deal and I wasn’t particularly offended. I got really good experience at Yonkers: I covered city hall for a while, I covered just about everything.
And how did you land in all these different newsrooms around the country? I got offered a job by the women’s editor in the women’s section at The Detroit News and I declined even though I needed a job but I had never done that kind of work before; I only did hard news. But then within a week or so, some guy from South Carolina was hired to be the state editor and the day before he was supposed to show up for, he called in and said, “I don’t think I am gonna come up there because I just found out Detroit is north of Canada” and it truly was north of
Windsor, Canada and they were rummaging around and they just called me and offered me the job, not because they wanted a woman but just because they wanted someone. And then I got hired at Newsday because they had a women’s suit against them and they were frantically searching for women with the kind of experience that I had and there weren’t many around in those days.
Did you never think about ﬂying yourself? My father got the idea once when he had too much to drink that, you know, I should be the youngest licensed pilot in the world. There was a tiny airﬁeld near our house in California and my father was like, “Oh yeah! We are gonna go up there; I got the sky lined up!” and my mother was like “No, you are not. No, you are not.” It was a small take-off spot, the Paciﬁc Ocean was at the end of the runway and there were a lot of electric wires and my mother knew it was a dangerous airﬁeld. And that was the extent of my ﬂying: that conversation.
What advice do you have for woman journalists? I mean they are all around! I looked around one day in the newsroom and I saw all these women; there are more of them than men.
Know somebody who deserves their 15 Minutes of fame? Go to otdowntown.com and click on submit a press release or announcement.
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
COLOR GREENWICH VILLAGE by Jake Rose Whitney Museum of American Art
CROSSWORD by Myles Mellor 5
We’ll publish some of them. To purchase a coloring book of Greenwich Village venues, go to colorourtown.com/gv
43 Give out 44 Priceless? 45 More than two 46 Concert equipment 47 Swedish weaves
G U M
A M O
15 12 1
M A A R
S A Y R
R M I
G O A
I H S
E R E S
Down Across 1 People of a Broadway show 1 Closing section of a 5 Animation platform (abbr.) musical composition 2 Jewish month 8 Girl 3 Dance partner 12 Scent 4 Shock to the body 13 Coffee ___ 5 Precious 14 Muscle soreness 15 West coast town, ___ Point 6 Crack a smile 7 Arch 16 My country, ___ of thee 8 Portable computer 17 Twosome 9 Type of berry 18 Combative 10 Switchblade 21 Not pas 11 Dried up 22 Psyche 19 Spoil to an extent 23 Honey maker locale 26 Ancient writing materials 20 Mediterranean island, Mal ____ 30 Scottish cap 23 Devoured 31 Omega or ﬂaxseed 24 Father ﬁgures 32 Briskness 25 Troublemaker 36 Fake 27 “She loves __” Beatles 39 Boxing organization, for 28 Dispose of short 29 Agency of the United 40 Atop (poetic) Nations (abbr.) 41 Sauce (2 words) 33 “Hotel ____” ﬁlm 48 Make a portrait of 34 Big Blue 49 Infuriate 35 Lao-tzu follower 50 Military group 36 Bootleg whiskey 51 Alkali’s opposite 37 What shore she sells 52 Find out shells at? 53 Malay palm 38 Off-base 54 Intro to physics? 41 Hardly a blabbermouth 55 Mark of perfection 42 “Interview with a 56 Coin ____ Vampire” writer (last name)
Scan or take a picture of your work and send it to firstname.lastname@example.org.
As the preeminent institution devoted to American art, the Whitney Museum of American Art presents twentieth-century and contemporary art focusing on works by living artists.
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
Telephone: 212-868-0190 Email: email@example.com
POLICY NOTICE: We make every eﬀort to avoid mistakes in your classiﬁed ads. Check your ad the ﬁrst week it runs. The publication will only accept responsibility for the ﬁrst incorrect insertion. The publication assumes no ﬁnancial responsibility for errors or omissions. We reserve the right to edit, reject, or re-classify any ad. Contact your sales rep directly for any copy changes. All classiﬁed ads are pre-paid.
REAL ESTATE - SALE
:HDUHDSURXGPHPEHURIWKH$VVRFLDWHG3UHVV DQGWKH 1DWLRQDO1HZVSDSHU$VVRFLDWLRQ
“I WISH SOMEONE WOULD HELP THAT HOMELESS MAN.” Donate A Boat or Car Today!
“2-Night Free Vacation!”
800 - 700 - BOAT (2628)
sponsored by boat angel outreach centers
BE THE SOMEONE.
STOP CRIMES AGAINST CHILDREN
Saving a Life EVERY 11 MINUTES
alone I’m never
Life Alert® is always here for me.
Sam New York Cares Volunteer
Every day, we think to ourselves that someone should really help make this city a better place. Visit newyorkcares.org to learn about the countless ways you can volunteer and make a difference in your community.
One touch of a button sends help fast, 24/7. with
+HOSDW+RPH +HOS2QWKH*R ®
For a FREE brochure call:
Our Town|Downtowner otdowntown.com
Got an EVENT? FESTIVAL CONCERT GALLERY OPENING PLAY
Get The Word Out! Add Your Event for FREE Just $10 per day to be featured