and never really participated in the formal credit markets.” Cutts added that having the mortgage industry pursue alternative data further is a step in the right direction. “This is a whole new way to look at consumer,” she stated. “There is an opportunity to find really good credit risk among people who have not built up a presence in the credit market.” But embracing this concept will require some adjustment by many lenders. For starters, Clemans noted that automated underwriting systems are not set up to factor in this type of data, and many lenders are not eager to do their underwriting without automation.
“It is problematic to do a manual underwriting,” said Clemans. “The lending community seems more interest in the speed of underwriting. In the conventional loan world, it is pretty much nonexistent. With FHA and VA loans, it is not the case and is much easier to do manual underwriting for those loans.” Clemans also stated that using certain records as evidence of paying bills on time may also hold potentially disqualifying information. “Filing utility data could hurt consumers due to energy assistance programs that are available to low-income consumers,” Clemans added. Mondelli admitted that one major stumbling block in this matter involves
the lack of a standardized method to categorize alternative data. “We have to be careful because there are 10 to 15 different credit data bureaus and they are anything but uniform,” he said. But despite the challenges, the movement to upgrading the credit scoring process is seen as a win-win situation for mortgage professionals. “NAMB has long-advocated for improved credit score modeling,” said Councilman. “A change is past due.” Phil Hall is managing editor of National Mortgage Professional Magazine. He may be reached by e-mail at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Why choose MBS Highway? BARRY HABIB— THE ORIGINATOR OF THE MARKET ADVISORY SERVICE Daily guidance and insights from Mortgage Market expert Barry Habib. He closed over $2 Billion in production as a Loan Originator, called the bottom of the Housing Market and currently provides sales and market training to thousands of Loan Originators across the country. STATE OF THE ART, USER FRIENDLY WEBSITE We've taken great pride in building a website that uses new technology, and enhances the user experience. No matter where you are on our site, you'll always have market data in sight. Never miss a lock alert with our real time market news and alert system.
EASILY SHAREABLE CONTENT With a touch of a button members are able to share charts showing the latest economic and housing data.
REAL ESTATE DATA & INSIDER CONTENT Show the housing opportunity in your local market to customers and real estate agents. We will provide you with affordability levels, appreciation, resale volume, new construction, and job growth…updated monthly and easily shared. There is also additional content from Art Cashin, Kiplinger letters, and much more.
MOBILE WEB APP
CALCULATORS AND TOOLS Powerful and unique calculators to help you when presenting to customers. Buy vs. Rent, ARM vs. Fixed, Paying Points, and Amortization calculator are a few examples. You can save and share the results to beat your competition.
What you're getting with your MBS Highway trial l Bond Quotes l Daily Video and Transcript l Interactive Charts l Lock/Float Advice l SMS Updates l Real Time Market News l Cashin's Corner l The Kiplinger Letters l Real Estate Market Data l By The Number$ l MBS TrendTRAKR l Social Share
Try it FREE for 14 days at MBSHighway.com/MNN
n National Mortgage Professional Magazine n JANUARY 2016
Always stay in touch with the market when on the go with our Mobile Web App. It's fast and easy to use. Whether you have an iPhone, Android, Blackberry, Windows Phone, you'll always have access to MBS Highway. No downloads, no annoying updates, just visit m.mbshighway.com in your phone or tablet's browser.
to 2008, alternative credit sourcing was linked to mortgage fraud due to a significant conflict of interest in the underwriting practices by some originators. “You cannot have a loan originator in charge of verifying alternative credit,” Clemans said. “They have an interest in the loan going through. That is kind of like putting the mouse in charge of the cheese. The proper way to verify this is to have credit reporting agencies verify it.” And that’s where TransUnion comes in with its CreditVision Link product, which was introduced in October 2015 and promoted as the first credit score to “combine both trended credit bureau data and alternative data sources—creating a more precise picture of consumer risk and their ability to manage financial commitments in a single point.” TransUnion stated that this alternative credit scoring solution would allow lenders to “score approximately 95 percent of the U.S. adult population, including tens of millions of consumers who cannot be scored by traditional credit scores.” “We’re in process of testing this with both GSEs,” said Mondelli. “That’s going to take time [to complete], but we are in the process of broaden the box beyond the FICO box.” In fairness, FICO is not totally oblivious to alternative credit scoring. In April 2015, the company launched a pilot program with LexisNexis Risk Solutions and Equifax that allowed 12 of the largest credit card issuers in the U.S. to use alternative data to identify individuals that would be unable to obtain traditional credit under the traditional scoring process. For Amy Crews Cutts, chief economist at Atlanta-based Equifax, the bridge between alternative credit scoring and traditional credit scoring covers much common ground. “The concept is very much the same,” Cutts explained. “They have a particular goal in mind: the performance of the mortgage and the likelihood of default. The challenge is to create a statistically valid model that takes into account systematically reliable and robust characteristics for people who are successful in paying back the mortgage, while bettering the filters to check out people that are not likely to repay.” Cutts also pointed out that changing demographics and post-recession economics have made alternative credit scoring more relevant in determining creditworthiness. “Alternative credit looks at three groups of people,” Cutts continued. “First, those who recently moved to the U.S.—if they could have brought their credit histories from their former countries, most likely it would have looked pretty good. Second, there are young people that just graduated from high school or college and are having a very difficult time establishing credit. Many young people use debit cards, which are great for cash but not for building up a credit history. And, third, there are people who have been here for a while