Page 1

Mayer Hoffman McCann to Pay $300,000 Penalty for Municipal Audits: Accounting Today

Welcome, Ran My Account LOGOUT

HOME

|

NEWS

E-NEWSLETTERS |

|

BLOGS

|

|

AT TV

WEB SEMINARS |

PODCASTS

WHITE PAPERS |

|

POLLS

E-BOOKS |

|

RANKINGS

|

SLIDESHOWS |

EVENTS

|

CURRENT ISSUE

ACCOUNTING TECHNOLOGY |

|

CPE

|

CHANNELS

|

ACCOUNTANTS CONFIDENCE INDEX

Search Accounting Today

Mayer Hoffman McCann to Pay $300,000 Penalty for Municipal Audits

Related Articles Companies Disclosing More

Audit Fees Rose Last Year

Print

Email

Advanced Search

about Auditors

Follow Accounting Today

Assurance News

Reprints

ADVERTISEMENT

Changes Proposed to

Share

Like

2

Auditor's Report Don’t Shoot the Auditors,

IRVINE, CALIF. (JUNE 4, 2012) BY MICHAEL COHN

Please Other areas of interest

Accounting firm Mayer Hoffman McCann has agreed to pay a $300,000 penalty to

Auditing

the California Board of Accountancy, plus investigation costs of up to $50,000, and

Legal Matters

be subject to two years’ probation, for its audits of the California city of Bell, where a

Regulation

number of officials have been accused of fraud and public corruption. As a result of the settlement, the firm, which is affiliated with CBIZ, will be allowed to continue to practice in the state of California. The firm had been facing a six-month stay on its license, but it will be able to practice while remaining on probation. State Controller John Chiang issued a critical report in December 2010 on the Irvine

MOST READ

MOST EMAILED

office of the firm’s audits of Bell’s accounts for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2009. “MHM appears to have been a rubberstamp rather than a responsible auditor committed to providing the public with the transparency and accountability that could William Hancock

have prevented the mismanagement of the city’s finances by Bell officials,” he said in a statement. “Had MHM fully complied with the 17 applicable fieldwork standards, it

would have led them to identify some—if not all—of the problems my office has uncovered since August.”

Former IRS Manager Sentenced on Conflict of Interest Charges for Running Her Own Tax Business IRS Admits Sending Erroneous Penalty Notices IRS to Increase Audits of Prior- and

Eight former public officials from the city are facing public

Subsequent-Year Tax Returns

corruption charges, according to the Los Angeles

How Wal-Mart’s Waltons Maintain Their

Times. Chiang noted that the firm had relied primarily on

Billionaire Fortune with Estate Taxes

comparisons to prior-year financial statements, requesting information on variances in excess of

Business Tax Pros Anticipate Tax Reform in Washington

$200,000 and 15 percent from the prior year. For example, a $300,000 loan to a local business was not flagged for additional review because the same loan with the same value appeared in prior-year statements. Instead, auditors should have reviewed the age and collectability of a loan that showed no repayment. The now-defaulted loan was made without the City Council’s knowledge.

http://www.accountingtoday.com/news/Mayer-Hoffman-McCann-Penalty-Bell-Audits-62850-1.html[9/16/13 7:49:15 AM]

ADVERTISEMENT


Mayer Hoffman McCann to Pay $300,000 Penalty for Municipal Audits: Accounting Today Mayer Hoffman McCann announced last Friday that the California Board of Accountancy has completed its investigation of the firm’s audit of the financial statements of the City of Bell, for the year ended June 30, 2009. As a result of the investigation, MHM has entered into a settlement agreement with the CBA by which it will continue to practice in California without interruption. The CBA’s review was prompted by various reports of fraud, abuse and corruption involving City of Bell officials. There were eight specific criticisms identified by the CBA, which focused primarily on audit documentation issues, rather than audit procedures. “We appreciate the professionalism and input of the representatives of the CBA throughout their investigation,” said MHM president William Hancock in a statement. “We have taken the events at Bell and the findings of the CBA very seriously, and we have used this as an opportunity to renew our commitment to high-quality audit services. As recognized by the CBA, and in addition to addressing the audit documentation issues noted by the CBA, over the past two years we have implemented a wide array of improvement measures in response to the current city and municipal audit environment, including enhancement of our government audit methodology and processes, and additional continuing education programs and training for our professionals.” “We have also undergone two independent examinations covering our California city and municipal audit practice,

Taking a Financial Planning Practice to the Next

each of which has concluded that we are in compliance with audit quality control standards,” Hancock added. “In

Level

short, we have emerged as a better firm, committed to serving the public interest and our California clients.”

SEPTEMBER 12, 2013

U.S. Wealth Management CEO John Napolitano The CBA cited several factors that generated a favorable disposition of the CBA to Mayer Hoffman McCann, an

talks about how accounting firms can build their

outside spokesman for the firm noted. “We were never the subject of any prior disciplinary action by the CBA,” he

financial planning practices and become successful

said. “We accepted responsibility at an early stage in the proceedings. We were cooperative in all respects during

at it.

the investigation. We proactively developed and implemented remedial measures that enhanced and elevated procedures in our local government auditing practice.” Under the settlement agreement with the CBA, MHM is subject to two years’ probation. During the probation period, MHM is subject to certain terms outlined in the settlement order such as submission of quarterly written reports, personal appearances for interviews with the CBA, a practice investigation conducted by representatives of the CBA, and required dissemination of the settlement order to all MHM professional personnel in California. Also as part of the settlement agreement, MHM plans to commission another peer review of the firm’s California governmental audit practice group before July 31, 2013. The firm has agreed to pay a $300,000 administrative penalty and reimburse CBA’s investigation costs for an amount not to exceed $50,000.

The Chairs of FASB and GASB on Their Shared Goals

3 Comments

AUGUST 6, 2013

Governmental Accounting Standards Board Should be way more. How much was lost during their audits. Millions I'm sure.

chairman David Vaudt and Financial Accounting Standards Board chairman Russell Golden discuss

Posted by: SpectateSwamp | April 2, 2013 12:15 PM

how they are working together on initiatives such as leasing and pension standards.

Report this Comment We currently have 3 municipalities that are being investigated. Some of the problems started back in the 70's I'm

ADVERTISEMENT

sure many of them were reported. No media or audits uncovered them. Is Arthur Anderson doing the audits? Posted by: SpectateSwamp | December 10, 2012 1:08 PM Report this Comment What is a city doing making loans to private businesses anyway? Business loans are normally obtained through banks not city governments. Sounds like MHM got off the hook fairly easy. MHM will just adjust their audit fees to cover the penalties assessed. A better for fitting penalty would be to ban MHM from auditing the City of Bell in addition to repayment of audit fees collected for a botched audit. Posted by: FAApilotCPA | June 6, 2012 2:13 PM Report this Comment

Add Your Comments...

http://www.accountingtoday.com/news/Mayer-Hoffman-McCann-Penalty-Bell-Audits-62850-1.html[9/16/13 7:49:15 AM]

SLIDE SHOW


Mayer Hoffman McCann to Pay $300,000 Penalty for Municipal Audits: Accounting Today

The Top People in Public Accounting - 2013 SEPTEMBER 8, 2013

(Only usernames will be posted along with comments. No personal information will be displayed.

The most influential people in the field of

Offensive materials and/or spam will be removed. No HTML allowed.)

accounting, according to our survey of their fellow

Post Comment

candidates.

Â

Top 10 Cities For Finance Jobs SEPTEMBER 5, 2013

Accounting Principals recently named the top 10 cities to find a job in finance in 2013, based on overall economic environment, internal data, and the volume of job openings in the past six months.

Disappearing Tax Deductions AUGUST 23, 2013

Deductions, credits and other provisions that are slated to go at the end of the year.

http://www.accountingtoday.com/news/Mayer-Hoffman-McCann-Penalty-Bell-Audits-62850-1.html[9/16/13 7:49:15 AM]


Mayer Hoffman McCann to Pay $300,000 Penalty for Municipal Audits: Accounting Today

The Gender Gap in Accounting Salaries AUGUST 2, 2013

The Institute of Management Accountants quantifies the salary gap between men and women in the accounting profession in its annual salary survey.

2013 Summer Reading for Accountants JUNE 30, 2013

Short—but valuable—reads for the profession.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

http://www.accountingtoday.com/news/Mayer-Hoffman-McCann-Penalty-Bell-Audits-62850-1.html[9/16/13 7:49:15 AM]

ADVERTISEMENT


Mayer Hoffman McCann to Pay $300,000 Penalty for Municipal Audits: Accounting Today

Financial Recovery Center

Technology

Industry Leaders Q&A

Practice Management

Products

Industry Leaders Q&A

Managing a Practice

Accounting News

Vendors

Government News

Resellers

Business News

Software Reviews

Economic Developments

Small Business Services

Financial Planning

Client Advisory Services

Retirement Planning

Payroll

Education Planning

Small Business Trends

Estate Planning

Government Resources

Succession Planning Wealth Management Financial Advisory Practice

About Us Contact Us Advertise with Us Subscribe Reprints Customer Service Feedback

Sarbanes-Oxley

Tax IRS Watch Legal Watch Tax Essentials

People on the Move

Tax Research Tax Planning

Staffing and Recruiting Regulations Marketing and Growing Your Practice Mergers and Acquisitions Legal Matters Association News

Taxes of the Rich & Dumb Celebrity Tax Foibles Odd News Accounting of the Stars

Inside Views Inside Views

SOURCEMEDIA CORPORATE SITE

BANKING American Banker Bank Technology News American Banker Magazine Credit Union Journal

MORTGAGES

Site Map

National Mortgage News

Subscription Agreement

Auditing

Tax Season Essentials

My Account Privacy Policy

Regulation

People on the Move

Aids

HOME

Audit/SOX

PAYMENTS PaymentsSource Collections & Credit Risk

CAPITAL MARKETS

HEALTHCARE & BENEFITS

Mergers & Acquisitions

Employee Benefit News

Asset Securitization Report

Employee Benefit Adviser

Leveraged Finance News

Health Data Management

Private Placement Letter

Insurance Networking News

Traders Magazine

Information Management

Securities Technology Monitor

INVESTMENT ADVISORY

MUNICIPAL FINANCE

Financial Planning

The Bond Buyer

On Wall Street

ACCOUNTING Accounting Today Tax Pro Today

ISO & Agent

Š 2013 SourceMedia. All rights reserved.

http://www.accountingtoday.com/news/Mayer-Hoffman-McCann-Penalty-Bell-Audits-62850-1.html[9/16/13 7:49:15 AM]

Bank Investment Consultant Money Management Executive Investment Mgt. Mandate Pipeline


Mayer Hoffman McCann to Pay $300,000 Penalty for Municipal Audits: Accounting Today

http://www.accountingtoday.com/news/Mayer-Hoffman-McCann-Penalty-Bell-Audits-62850-1.html[9/16/13 7:49:15 AM]

Mayer hoffman mccann to pay $300,000 penalty for municipal audits accounting to  
Mayer hoffman mccann to pay $300,000 penalty for municipal audits accounting to  
Advertisement