A Tragedy of Nimtoly 33 ward of South Dhaka city (Former 69)
INTRODUCTION Fire has invented for better living and building structure developed for improved and comfortable livelihood. With the course of time the desire of comfort and improved living concluded the acceleration of building construction. The alarming rates of population growth together with fragile economy instigate people to live in urban areas. Limitations of urban land together with high claim of building infrastructure compel creation of high rise building. Excessive of cost of land and clumsy regulatory and planning authorities helps to construct building of larger floors and levels than the normally allowed.
Thus the urban areas mostly Dhaka city has transformed to a hectic city engaging its inhabitant into the approximately all types of artificial hazard of life menacing. Fire is one of those hazard whose frequency mounting day by day mostly in buildings. In Dhaka fire is an uncontrollable risk especially in high rise buildings mostly constructed violating the national building code. The frequency of fire event is common in Dhaka city, mainly in dry season. Fire occurred in the slum areas, garments factories and manufacturing industries are common news topic during the season. Because of fire incidence there are loss of numerous lives and valuable properties in the city.
RATIONALE OF THE STUDY Dhaka is the capital city of Bangladesh and the largest city in the country. As the center of both national and municipal government administration, the city is experiencing a construction boom, particularly with respect to roads and larger modern buildings. The growth in infrastructure presents both challenges and opportunities. The lack of appropriate mechanisms to guarantee fire safety in new development remains to be one of the outstanding issues. These include building approval process, provision of additional fire fighting facilities, and fire safety regulations. The consequences had been dense building concentrations, flammable building materials, narrow roads, improper installation of electrical system, and others. These are only some of the visible issues connected with the high rate of urban fire incidences. Lack of funding to repair damaged infrastructure facilities, such as fire hydrants, electrical system, and roads also contribute to fire vulnerability. Looking at Dhaka city closely, one would be simply stupefied to see the frightful chaos that has now endangered the lives of millions and millions of its residents. What is required under the circumstances is not shifting focus on this or that problem as they arise but to look at all of these great living hazards for its people in totality as the outcome of a lack of a planned city. Dhaka and its suburbs are considered to be holding no less than 14 million people. A big part of this population has their homes in the old part of the city. The population density is also the greatest in these older parts of the city. But the old city presents a spectacle of complete chaos that keeps the people here hostages to a devastating fire incident. Any modern city must be zoned properly between residential, industrial, commercial and other areas. But rows and rows of dingy buildings are found in old Dhaka which was never planned for safety. The structures have hardly any spacious stairways for the urgent exiting of people. The maze of these buildings are served in most cases by alleys so narrow in some cases that even two rickshaws cannot pass side by side in them. In case of a fire incident, the large vehicles of the fire service find the narrow lanes and by-lanes practically impassable. Besides, as the latest tragic fire incident showed, these buildings house both humans in large number as well as quickly inflammable materials of all sorts such as plastics, chemicals, polythene, etc. Make-shift factories of all kinds abound there from polythene bag making ones to plastics industries of the cottage type. The gas lines in these areas are often found leaking and prone to causing accidents on coming in contact with even a slight spark from somewhere. The rapid urban growth greatly increases the vulnerability of the countryâ€™s major population and economic centers. Increasing urbanization in the context of Dhaka presents major challenges and opportunities for the reduction of disaster impact in the future. While floods have the greatest impact to the countryâ€™s population as a whole, fires cause the greatest loss of life and property in the urban areas. Dense building concentrations, narrow roads, flammable building materials, aging water supply and electrical system, as well as the lack of resources to upgrade preparedness and response skills have resulted in a growing risk of large scale, multiple structure fires. Fire incidents are very common in Dhaka city, especially in relatively densely populated areas. The damage of property and loss of human life are intensified by different factors. The number of fire incidents in Dhaka was 1,861 in 2003, 2,053 in 2004, and 2,279 in 2005 (The New Age, February 10, 2007). Not only in Dhaka but also other major cities which have dense and unplanned urbanization suffer the wrath of fire from time to time. For instance, fires broke out at Rahattarpul and Badurtala in Chittagong on 10th March, 2006. The fire, which originated from an electric short circuit, burnt assets worth about Tk.7 lakh, the fire officials said (The New Age, March 11, 2006).
Number of reported fire incidences in Dhaka city
Name of the Month January February
Number of fire incidents 1233 1828
Assumable damage 334579500 352165300
Assumable rescue 574284500 486172200
March April May June July August September October November December
1967 1819 1396 971 892 936 815 845 1057 1162
294589000 177068600 392708700 636665805 524635205 567745305 538750420
663983300 929989000 679583300 890282806 780566530 910399707 879755910
Loss of life Japan Garden City death toll 7, Garib and Garib Co. death toll 21 Nimtoly death toll 119 Lili Chemicals death toll 10 Hamim Group death toll 26, Khilkhet Mosquito Coil death toll 6 189
This paper provides an analytical description about social vulnerability assessment to fire hazard on word number 69 of Dhaka city. OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY Fire Hazard is a most common phenomenon in Dhaka city. Unplanned high rise buildings, over population, lack of responsible government may be the main causes behind this. The specific objectives are:
• • •
Know the spatial and temporal dimension of fire hazard in 69 number word of Dhaka City Identify the causes of fire and its effect in study area Recommendation for mitigation of onset of fire
LITERATURE REVIEW Fire is the rapid combination of oxygen with fuel in the presence of heat, typically characterized by flame, a body of incandescent gas that contains and sustains the reaction and emits light and heat. Hazard has been defined as a chemical or physical condition that has the potential for causing damage to people, property or the environment. It can include an inherent chemical or physical characteristics such as acute toxicity, corrosivity, or the potential for fire and explosion. Hazard could also result from conditions of operation, such as high temperature or pressure, or the combustion of operating conditions and chemical characteristics.
All chemicals exhibit acute toxicity at some level of exposure and many chemicals are flammable, so we invariably want to know “how hazardous is it?” There have been many attempts to qualify the degree of hazard based on inherent chemical characteristics, including in regulations. Once we understand the inherent hazard of the chemical, it is possible to develop the technological and administrative system, commensurate with the type and degree of hazard, so we should need safely manage the chemical. In Bangladesh a few study has so far been made on fire hazard and some other related issues. M. has done a thesis paper for his degree of masters of Science in 1986. There he suggests a model fire hazard assessments model and select fire hazard zones in Dhaka. Bangladesh Fire Service and Civil Defense, maintain fire service and civil defense week. Every year and they published a book yearly. Only fire service and civil defense gather and compiled fire incidence data, but fire data are not available in other organization so, in the absence of proper and available data the comprehensive study on macro level still lacking. The literature reviewed by the researcher has been summarized as follows: BFSCD, every year BFSCD maintains fire service and civil defense week and published a souvenir with the information about fire incidence, where, when and how fire occur, number of death and injure, amount of property losses, lack of their instruments and activities, recover etc. BFSCD compile fire incidence data in their control room. They also has library that provide journal which helps to take information about fire and fire hazard. Safer Cities 7, AUDMP LUDMP The Lao PDR Urban Disaster Mitigation Project (LUDMP) was launched in July 2002 under the Asian Urban Disaster Mitigation Program (AUDMP) of the Asian Disaster Preparedness Center (ADPC). The main objective of the project is to reduce disaster vulnerability of population, infrastructure, and economic assets in the Lao urban areas to fire and traffic accidents. It focuses on establishing systems for risk assessment and disaster mitigation and incorporating such system into the urban development planning of Vientiane and other major cities and communities in Lao PDR. AUDMP The Asian Urban Disaster Mitigation Program (AUDMP) is the first and largest regional program implemented by ADPC. The AUDMP started in 1995 with core funding from USAID’s Office of Foreign Disaster Assistance (OFDA) until 2004. The program was developed with the recognition of increased disaster vulnerability of urban populations, infrastructure, critical facilities and shelter in Asian cities. In an environment where good governance and decentralization are high in most countries’ political agenda, AUDMP aims to demonstrate the importance ofand strategic approaches to urban disaster mitigation as part of the urban development planning process in targeted cities of Asia. AUDMP supports this demonstration by building the capacity of local authorities, national governments, NGOs, businesses and others responsible for establishing public and private sector mechanisms for urban disaster mitigation as part of city management. AUDMP also facilitates knowledge sharing and dialogue between key stakeholders to promote replication of AUDMP approaches to other cities and countries worldwide. Currently, the AUDMP approaches have been introduced and sustained by national partner institutions in targeted cities of Bangladesh, Cambodia, India, Indonesia, Lao PDR, M. (1990), M. studied about “a fire hazard assessment model and fire hazard zone in Dhaka SMA.” In his research he illustrated about fire hazard and among the major factors argumentation fire proneness of the city are used to highly inflammable material for housing, and open flames for cooking, lighting and heating in low income residential area, maintenance of little or no fire gap between and among
structure, faulty systems of generation, transmission and distribution of electricity and frequent incendiary attacks on vehicles during political disturbance. In addition lack of segregation of land uses, congested roads lanes and by lanes, storage of water supply, and above all, the general lack of fire fighting knowledge of citizens have made extinguishment extremely difficult when fire breaks out. Manuals of fireman ships (1993), a journal was published from the home ministry of London and in this journal highlighted that the contribution of hazard brought about by the introducing of new materials to considered the most important ways in which materials, in the fire context, can affect hazard. It will be noted that some quite small fires, involving limited amount of plastic materials rapidly give rise to large volume of smoke. A difference is that where as the smoke from what might be considered traditional materials used in furnishing could be controlled or dispersed by ventilation, the behavior of plastic materials is different in that ventilation not only increase the rate burning but also increase the rate of smoke production. The rapid production dense smoke and toxic gases means that time available for escape from the upper floor of the normal domestic dwelling may be as little as two or three minutes from onset of flaming combuston. This partially accounts for the fact that over recent years the number of people requiring rescue from fires in the UK has increased substantially. To prevent the spread of fire within the building provision is made is subdivide the building into compartment with restricted floor on cubic capacity. This is done by means of compartment walls and compartment floors which are elements of structure and there for requires fire resistance. The objects have two fold; 1. To prevent rapid fire spread which could trap the occupants of the building. 2. To reduce the chance of fires becoming large on the basis that large fires are more dangerous not only to occupants but to people in vicinity of the building. When fire occurs in a building it is essential that fire appliances and personnel can approach the building as quickly as possible. Different types of appliances will require different access conditions. The turning circle of a turntable ladder will be larger than that of a pumping appliance and probably the clearance height will also be greater. Fire testing, if correctly designed and carried out may in some cases, be the only available and reliable indication of a materials behavior in a given fire situation. It can thus be a vital factor in giving detailed answers to questions put in identifying and assessing fire hazard. It must be remembered that fire behaves is a complex manner and any information gleaned from a particular fire test must not be over-estimated on taken as a prediction of a probable course of an actual fire. It can only predict the behavior of the test material in the restricted situation of the test itself. A fire test result that shows as acceptable performance by the tested material can never be taken to guarantee a safe situation. METHODOLOGYIn order to fulfill the objectives of the study an empirical approach has taken. Following this approach a plan was prepared to collect data frothavailable relevant sources
. Figure: Dhaka City with selected study area Geography is concerned with environmental and human interrelationship in a spatial context. Thus the main concern of the study is to find out the spatio-temporal dimension of the fire hazard situation with the passage of time in Bangladesh. The various steps of the methodology are: SELECTION OF THE STUDY AREA Word number 69 of Dhaka City Corporation is selected for the study. The main purpose of the study is to examine the spatio-temporal dimension of the fire hazard situation. Fire is a social hazard, which can occurred both in urban and rural areas. Fire hazard are mostly occurred by activities. It can occur in houses, shopping malls, in water bodies, in forest; several causes are responsible for fire hazard. So, to show the spatio-temporal dimensions of fire hazard in study area. For in depth study Dhaka City Corporation is selected to risk analysis for short period of time (two years). DATA COLLECTION Dealing with any real life problem it is often found that data at hand are inadequate, and hence, it becomes necessary to collect data that are appropriate. There are several ways to collecting the appropriate data which differ considerably in context of money costs, time, and other resources at the disposal of the researcher (Kothari, 1996). In this practical research purposes data were taken two ways: PRIMARY DATA Primary data was collected through questionnaire survey by structured and semi structured questionnaires. For collecting data through questionnaires, 4 categories of sample population were selected. It will be also helpful to know the causes of fire hazard and its effects. The categories are Kacha, Semi Kacha, Pakka, and High rise building (5th storied and above). Data were collected from shops, ware house, factories, residential areas, and high rise apartments. 50 settlements (4 categories) were surveyed in the study area using questionnaires. For the selection of individual households random sampling method has been adopted. Data also comes from a survey conducted on Fire Service and Civil Defense head office in Dhaka Division.
SECONDARY DATA Secondary data have collected from official records like library, journals, yearly reports, statistical year book, Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS), daily news paper etc. Bangladesh Fire Service and Civil Defense collect data and compiled those data in their own format and every year they published a year book when Fire Service and Civil Defense week they maintained. Key Informant Interview (KII), comments have been received from BFSCD officials and data also received from published books and journals. PROBLEMS OF DATA COLLECTION Data collection is one of the most problems in this type of studies. Fire hazard data collection is hard to due to its nature of data. Study and fire hazards issue in Bangladesh is surround by manifold problems. The present study is constrained by lacks of sufficient information and statistics. The main problem of the research is that there is not sufficient location information about occurring of incident relates to fire hazard. More time was required to fulfill the wide coverage in this research work. The study have to completed within a short period of time. It has affected the selection of methodology enhance the result of study may be affected too. The study has some limitations about data collection. It also can affect the result of study. There may have some limitations in the data summarization in the analysis of data. However taking all the collected information into consideration it has been tried to present and high light these as much as accurately despite many limitation faced a researcher. ANALYSIS OF DATA After collecting raw data from field work, data were transferred to reference table. Then, the data were processed manually and presented mainly to tabular form. For easy understanding data were analyze using percentage. For data analyze several techniques were used. STATISTICAL METHOD Collected data from different sources were compiled, tabulated and analyze through MS Excell. â€˘
Frequency of fire incidence has been done by the following equation (Clarke, 1986)
Fire frequency (Ft)
Where, Nt equals the number of incidence of fire in a thana during the Period T, At equals the area of the thana (in Sq. Km) and T equals the time period (in years). USING GIS SOFTWARE In graphic methods, the results of statistical data were presented by pie diagram, bar diagram and histogram etc. PHOTOGRAPHY Fire fighting, Mohora, Recover, Losses, Death, Casualty and various serious incident of fire are presented by ph
FIRE AS A HAZARD
INTRODUCING FIRE SERVICE AND CIVIL DEFENSE Fire service and civil defense is one of the most important department of Bangladesh Government. It plays a vital role in providing safety and to lives and properties of the people. The importance of this department is on the increase with the industrialization, modernization and urbanization of the country. It has become an inseparable component of industrial and urban areas of the society.
Fire Service was set-up in the year 1948 soon after separation of Indo-Pak Sub-continent in 1947 which continued till 1982.The present directorate of Fire Service & Civil Defense was created by amalgamating the erstwhile Fire Service and Civil Defense Department under the Ministry of Home Affairs and Rescue Service under the Ministry of Communication in the year 1982. as the
responsibilities of these Department / Services wear inter related. Fire Service and Civil Defense Directorate of Bangladesh like elsewhere, in the world is one of the lead government agencies, which is responsible for responding first during any disaster. We have been working hand in hand with all other government as well as non-government organization in the management of natural and man-made disasters. Needless to say that Bangladesh is a disaster-prone country, which regularly experiences natural disasters such as flood, cyclone, tornado and medium low level earthquake. as Bangladesh is an earth quake prone country, it is predictable that major earth quake may attack this country at any time. So, to cope up with the probable vulnerable situation Bangladesh Fire Service & Civil Defense taking Step to increases modern equipments and skilled rescuer through short term & long term training plan with regards to Collapsed Structure Search & Rescue (CSSR). The aim of Bangladesh Fire Service & Civil Defense is to provide training to the people with regards to preventive and precautionary measures of different types disasters, fight the fire, rescue trapped persons, render first aid and transports victims from vulnerable area to safer place acting as a first responding department. The motto of Bangladesh Fire Service and Civil Defense is `Speed, Service & Sacrifice.’ Objectives of the fire service and civil defense of Bangladesh are: To minimize the destruction of wealth and properties of the Nation To minimize the number of casualties To minimize the number of death. The word fire is a chemical processes, which involves burning of any substance(combustion). The combustible material that burns with the help of oxygen result in the production of heat and light is called fire. Fire is not always harmful but only when goes out of control (Raihan, 2006)
FIRE Fire is defined as a chemical process involving rapid oxidation of a combustible material producing heat and flame. Fire thus involves a chemical union between oxygen and fuel (or combustible material) the has a temperature raised to its ignition point by addition of heat (Martin and Kanury, 1982) Fire code Fire code F Find I Inform R Restrict E Extinguish or Escape Source: workshop on fire hazard management, 2006 FIRE TYPES Table 2.1: Fire types Class of Fire Class A (Solid)
Suitable extinguishing media/equipments/tools
Class B (Liquid)
Petrol, gasoline, paraffin, diesel and other petroleum products such as paint, varnish and turpentine
Class C (Gas)
Methane, propane, hydrogen, carbon monoxide and other
Class D (Metal)
Potassium, sodium, magnesium and other
Class E (Electric)
Fuse boxes, energized electrical equipment, computers and other electrical sources. Source: Bangladesh Fire Service and Civil Defense, 2006
Wood, paper, textile, rubbish, jute, hay, coconut, tobacco
1. 2. 3. 1. 2. 3. 4. 1. 2.
Water type fire extinguisher Dry powder fire extinguisher Water jet and water spray Foam fire extinguisher Dry powder fire extinguisher Carbon dioxide fire extinguisher Water spray fire extinguisher Dry powder fire extinguisher Carbon dioxide fire extinguisher
1. 2. 3. 1.
Dry sand fire extinguisher Soda ash fire extinguisher Dry powder fire extinguisher Dry chemical fire extinguisher
HOW FIRE SPREAD Fire spread by several processes as follows: CONDUCTION: Metal such as copper, aluminum and steel are good conductor. These metals become hot when exposed to fire. Ther heat is spread along the lengthof the metal. If the metal is in direct contact with a fuel the temperature of the fuel will rise to the ignition temperature where spontaneous comb station will occur. CONVECTION: When fire occurs the surrounding air is heated and expands, thus becoming buoyant. The light air rises and is replaced by cool air, causing air circulation. This process transfers the hot air and other fire products to the upper floors through the lift shaft, escalator and unprotected duct. This phenomenon will reslt in the vertical spread of the fier to the upper part of the building, thereby preventing the occupants from leaving the building.
RADIATION: Fire spread can occur through radiation, radiation is heat transferred through electromagnetic waves. When fire occurs, heat is transferred through radiation whereby beating up the surrounding and when a certain combustible is exposed to radiation becomes extremely heated to the point of ignition, the process of decomposition occurs and the combustible involved will spontaneously so of ignite. ( Bangladesh Fire Service and Civil Defense).
Figure: Fire in Nimtoli Area A â€˜normalâ€™ fire is caused by the decomposition process which is a series of chemical reaction known as a chain reaction. The main contributing factors of fires are as follows: Table 2.2: Factors of Fire Natural factors Fire caused by a disaster or a natural factor Accidental factors Fire caused by negligence, carelessness of human error Incendiary Fire caused by a deliberate of treacherous human act Source: Bangladesh Fire Service and Civil Defense HAZARD AND DISASTER A potential damaging physical events, phenomenon or human activity that may caused the loss of life or injure, property damages, social and economic disruption or environmental degradation. Hazard can include latent conditions that may represents future threats and can have different origins: natural (geological, hydormeorological and biological) or induced by human processes (environmental degradation and technological hazard). Hazard can be single, sequential or combined in their origin and effects. Each hazard is characterized by its location, intensity frequency and probability (Alan 2006).
Fire is both a friend and foe mankind but a single incidence of such a devastating, may cause enough damage in one area than fire become hazardous. It also defined as any fire that was deported to at least one of the fire service station of Bangladesh Fire Service and Civil Defense. There are some sources which will help us to know about fire hazard. These are:
2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
Short circuit (for electrical wins and switch board) Naked light Unmindful smoking Mechanical heat and spark Explosive and fire works Radiation Spontaneous combustion
The probability of harmful consequences or expected losses (death, injuries, properties, livelihood, economic activities, disrupted or environmental damages) resulting from interaction between natural or human induced hazard and vulnerable condition. Conventionally risk is expressed by the national Risk-Hazard × Vulnerability. Some discipline also include the concept of exposure to refer particularly to physical aspects of vulnerability. Beyond expressing a possibility of physical harm is crucial to recognize that risk are inherent or can be created or exist within social systems. It is important to consider the social context in which risk occur and that people therefore don’t necessarily share the same perceptions of risk and their underling causes (Alan 2006). IDENTITY FIRE HAZARD For identifying the hazard it is necessary: 1. Indentify possible sources of ignition and verify their position with regard to the flammable materials 2. Analyze the layout of room and exit in case of emergency 3. Organize the fire fighting service Table 2.4: Identify fire hazard by source Type of source Flames smoldering sources Hot surface
Electrical overheating Spontaneous combustion
• • • • • • • • • • • •
Smoking materials Oil-fires boilers Hot work such as flame cutting and gas welding Hot places Exhaust manifolds Heating pipes Faulty machinery Mechanical sparks from welding friction Electric sparks Spark from electrical discharge Electric arc welding Over loaded wiring on equipment with a short circuit or a short to earth
Rotting vegetable matter Chemicals or organic materials
CHAPTER IV: DATA ANALYSIS AND RESULTS
Figure: 33 number word of Dhaka City Corporation PEOPLE’S AWARENESS OF FIRE: CHI-SQUARE TES Observed data: Education level
People aware of fire
Below primary level Primary level Secondary level Higher secondary level Graduation Total Expected data:
0 0 0 0 5 5
People aware of fire
Below primary level 0.8 Primary level 1 Secondary level 1.9 Higher secondary level 0.3 Graduation 1 Total 5 We get expected cell by following formula:
People not aware of Total fire 8 8 10 10 19 19 3 3 5 10 45 50 People not aware of Total fire 7.2 8 9 10 17.1 19 2.7 3 9 10 45 50
Expected cell = Chi-Square test: Let Null hypothesis (Hₒ): Awareness of fire hazard are equally/evenly distributed within all education group people. Alternative hypothesis (H1): Awareness of fire hazards are not equally distributed within all education group people.
Significant level: 0.05 Confidence level: 95% Chi-square test formula: χ² Here, O = Observed value E = Expected value Calculation: χ² +
= 0.8 + 1 + 1.9 + 0.3 + 16 + 0.089 + 0.111 + 0.211 + 0.033 + 1.78 = 22.229 Degrees of freedom, df = (K-1) (C-1) = (5-1) (2-1) =4 Degrees of freedom 4
Alpha (probability level) 0.05, the critical value of χ² at 0.05 alpha level is 9.488 and our calculated value is 22.229, which is higher than the critical value. So null hypothesis is rejected than means awareness of fire hazards are not equally distributed within all education level people. DIFFERENT TABLES, GRAPHS, AND COMMENTS ON SURVEY AREAS Table 01: Settlement pattern of Surveyed area:
Comments: According to the pie chart we can easily see that 76% Settlement pattern is high rise building.
Table 02: Number of victim people in the surveyed area:
Comments: According to the surveyed area we see that 18% more people are affected by fire.
Table 03: Seasonal variation of fire incident occurred:
Comments: According to the pie chart we can see that 50% fire incident occured in the time of winter season and 46% fire occurred in the summer. Table 04: In what time most fire incident occurred:
Comments: The research find that 88% fire occured in the time of noon and night. Table 05: The reason behind fire incident:
Comments: My Surveyed area is 69 no ward in Nimtoli, where most fire incident occurred by chemical warehouses. Table 06: Knowledge about put out from fire:
Comments: Maximum people (More than 94%) do not know how to extinguish fire. Table 07: Own arrangements to deal with fire:
Comments: According the bar chart it can be said that 100% people in my research area do not have own arrangement to deal with fire. Table 08: Received training to extinguish fire:
Comments: No people received training to extinguish fire.
Table 09: Received any post fire accident training:
Comments: According to the bar chart it can be said that no people received post fire accident training. Table 10: Enough space to enter fire service car:
Comments: Fire station is very near to my survey area but lack of knowledge about fire and enough space to entrance fire service car is only reason of danger.
CASE STUDY The terrible tragedy of the Nimtoli blaze which claimed 123 lives, drew attention to the improper storage of chemicals in residential neighborhoods in Dhaka. Since the two transformers nearby fueled the blaze, another factor which deserved attention was the burning transformers, and how to improve transformer safety. This paper gathers further eyewitness accounts from the site of the disaster, and attempts to draw conclusions about the involvement of the transformers and future precautions. The literature on transformer failure is studied, so as to learn from the transformer explosion in Nimtoli. As part of the research, a series of photographs, attests to the hazardous placement of 11 KV transformers and communication cables. A case study is the recent fault in an 11 KV feeder which set fire to nearby communication cables. The proximity of communication cables to 11 KV ransformers, and the general jumble of communication cables in the streets may be greatly improved, by better planning of all parties involved. INTRODUCTION On June 3, 2010, Bangladesh had its worse fire in recent memory, when 6-8 buildings in old haka caught fire, and 121 people lost their lives. Although 50-52 tons of volatile chemicals in a makeshift warehouse greatly fueled the flames, the contribution of the transformers to the flames is irrefutable. From various media accounts of the event [1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8], a picture can be reconstructed of the tragedy, and lessons can be learnt about our practices with transformers and communication cables. Although the event has drawn attention to the storage of dangerous chemicals, the placement of two 11 KV transformers were suspect. The risks with communication cables are illustrated from a July 2010 fire from an 11 KV line spreading to the communication cables. This incident, where the author was present, did not make it to the news. THE NIMTOLI BLAZE According to most eye-witness accounts, the Nimtoli fire started at about 8:45 pm, and spread to a chemical warehouse. Locals and fire-fighters said the blaze started in a five-storey building, where an engagement function (Panchini) was going on. On the ground floor of that building, cooks had been preparing food since early afternoon." "For long exposure to intense heat from stoves, chemicals stored in adjacent room caught fire round about 8:45 pm. Soon flames engulfed the buildings and shops.â€? Sparks from electric wires and gas leaks are believed to have added to the ferocity of the blaze. The flammable chemicals acted like shooting lava, and spread the fire to surrounding buildings. There was no escape, as the flames, prevented people from leaving their buildings. At some point, the transformers near
the area exploded, throwing the whole area into darkness. Though the exact origin of the fire is unclear, it is known that 50-52 tons of chemicals stored in a five-storey building had swelled the flames, accounting for such high casualties. Considering the contribution of the transformers to the flames, the High Court directed the authorities of Dhaka Electric Supply Company (Desco) and Dhaka Power Distribution Company (DPDC) to examine all the city's transformers by an expert committee, and submit a report to it within three weeks. The two power utilities use approximately
12,000 transformers, 8,000 of them installed by DPDC and 4,000 by DESCO, to supply electricity to the capital city, said officials. POSSIBILITY THAT TRANSFORMERS STARTED BLAZE According to some eyewitness testimony, and according to Brig Gen Abu Nayeem Md Shahidullah, director general of Fire Service and Civil Defence, there is a small possibility the blaze may have started from the transformers. Some testimony in support are as follows: 1. “Some said explosion of two transformers had started the fire, while some others said it began at a bakery and then spread to the transformers.” 2. “Some witnesses said explosion of two transformers at Nawab Katra of Nimtoli started the fire around 8:45pm, while others said it all began at a bakery and then spread to the transformers.” 3. “Witness Billal Hossain, who was around 150 yards away from a transformer, said the transformer exploded and sent fireballs in three alleys. It also sent a mushroom of fire upward that came down spreading the fire in nearby buildings, he said.” INVESTIGATION CONDUCTED AS PART OF THE RESEARCH As part of this research, the Nimtoli area was visited a number of times by the author. The main location of the fire is shown, with the two transformers, the chemical warehouse (behind the grill), and the garage site of the cooking (figure 1). The cooking for the wedding was moved from under the transformer to inside the garage area, from where the heat moved to the chemical warehouse on the right. The small tea shop, with its open stove and flame, is seen in the right.
Figure 1. The main location of the blaze, showing the two transformers, the chemical warehouse behind the grill, and the garage or site of the cooking for the wedding (photo by author). A shopkeeper and some others who were close by at the time, said that the fire had not started with the transformers. Rather, the chemicals had heated the transformers which then exploded. According to Harun, a resident of the area, the cooking for the wedding was being done just under the transformers. When the rains started, the cooking and the makeshift stove was moved into the garage area, adjoining the chemical warehouse. At some point, the cook put out the stove, and went away. After some minutes, a blanket of fumes emerged from the warehouse slowly advancing on the ground, spreading right and left along the street. All of a sudden, the fumes caught fire, immediately burning everyone who was standing on the fumes. Adjoining the warehouse was a tea shop, and a Bakhorkhani shop, which had their own stoves, which may have given the first spark to the fumes being emitted from the warehouse. The fire spread immediately to the chemical warehouse, creating the lava-like flow along the street. These were thrown like lava along the adjoining buildings, setting fire to them. The transformers were just above the chemicals, and they too caught fire from the heat below. A few other residents of the area corroborated Harun’s testimony above. As the chemicals heated the transformers which then exploded, throwing the area into darkness, it is clear the transformers were energized when they exploded. The explosion may have been less destructive, if the transformers were taken offline, when they were being heated by the chemicals. According to the
testimony of locals, it is unlikely that the transformer was the original source of the fire. However, it is clear that the transformers had caught fire from the chemical blaze, and had then contributed to the fire of the nearby buildings and the casualties in human lives. The proximity of the transformer to the first floor window is seen in figure 2. This window is also right below the apartment where the wedding was taking place. Judging from all accounts, the greatest possibility is that there was an overheating leading to a vaporization of the transformer oil. The vaporized transformer oil, upon ignition from external flames would cause an explosion and prolonged fire.
Figure 2. The first floor (just below where the wedding was taking place) showing the proximity with the burning transformers (photo by author). TRANSFORMER INSTALLATION The Nimtoli tragedy should inspire us to look again at our practices with transformers, such as their proximity to apartments, and communication cables. First and foremost is the placement of transformers. Considering that transformers are 11 KV, oil-filled explosive devices, and can burn sometimes for hours, they should be placed far away from human inhabitation. Figures 3 and 4 show common violations of this fundamental requirement. Considering that a large number of transformers are already in these situations, preventive maintenance or replacement of the transformers should be done frequently. If excessive harmonics in the power lines is a problem, the transformers should be operated at diminished capacity. After the fire, fuse cutouts were used as protective devices, in spite of the inherent risks of improper replacement of fuse wires (Figure 5) .
Figure 3. Another transformer placed close to an apartment in the Nimtoli area, illustrating the risk of an explosion or a fire.
Figure 4. A transformer in the Banani area of New Dhaka, showing the proximity of communication cables with 11 KV transformer and lines.
Figure 5. The Nimtoli building, with its new fuse cutouts, although they pose a risk because of improper fuse replacement. failures for all ranges of transformers. A good maintenance program should include the following recommendations to help achieve maximum service life. MAINTENANCE AND PRECAUTIONSA A planned program of maintenance, inspection and testing would significantly reduce the number of transformer failures for all ranges of transformers. A good maintenance program should include the following recommendations to help achieve maximum service life. INSTALLATION AND OPERATION The electrical loading should be kept within the design range of the transformer. In liquid-cooled transformers, the top oil temperature should be monitored. Transformers should be installed in locations that are compatible with their design and construction. On-line transformer monitor systems should be considered for the most critical transformers. There are a number of on-line systems currently on the market, where a variety of probes and sensors are connected to a data acquisition unit
[DAU], that provides for remote telecommunications through a modem. The systems also incorporate an "expert system" to diagnose the problem and distinguish between events that are harmless and events that are dangerous. COMMUNICATION CABLES Another risk is the close proximity of communication cables to 11 KV transformers, as seen in figures 4 and 5. The rapid proliferation of communication cables over the last few years has caused a major jumble of cables over the city streets (Figure 6). Three different types of cables are seen in the figure. 1. BTCL local loop twisted pair 2. Co-axial cables for cable TV etc. 3. Fiber-optic cables The biggest problem with BTCL cables is that some personnel resist any modernization and systematization of the existing wiring to the homes. Fiberoptic cables are kept coiled in the streets so as to accommodate any future expansion. 11 KV FEEDER SETTING FIRE TO COMM. CABLES In about July 2010, an 11 KV feeder at the bridge joining Baridhara and Gulshan caught fire, and set fire to the surrounding communication cables (Figure 7). The spectacular flames on the ommunication cables, slowed traffic on the bridge and gathered a number of spectators. In the figure, the burnt communication cables have since been replaced. The incident did not make it to the news.
Figure 7. An 11 KV feeder which caught fire, and set fire to the surrounding communication cables. The scorched shielding of the feeder is seen, but the communication cables have been replaced.
VIII. CONCLUSION The Nimtoli blaze has deservedly drawn attention to the storage of chemicals in residential areas, but it should also draw our attention to practices with transformers and communication cables. The flaming transformers contributed greatly to the death and destruction at Nimtoli. Regarding our practices with transformers, overloading or excessive harmonics are often a problem, and the appropriate larger size of transformer should be used. Communication cables are also a risk as illustrated by the recent fire set on communication cables, owing to a shorted 11 KV feeder. FIRE MANAGEMENT STRATEGY FIRE SPREAD PREVENTION Managements mean using men and resources to achieve the goals of an organization, a program, a project or a venture. In the processes, a manager is to make the effective use of a number of management strategies involving man, material, money, machine, methods, moment, movements and above all motivation (Rahman, 2001). It is a spatial type of emergency management. It is an applied science, which seeks by the systematic observation and analysis of disaster to improve measures relating to prevention, mitigation, preparedness, emergency response and recovery. To mitigate the hazard situation the following management cycle can be applied.
Preparedness: Includes the information of a viable counter hazard plan, maintenance of inventories of resources and the training of the personal. Response: Response measures are usually those, which are taken immediately prior to an following occurrence impact with a view to saving life and protecting property. Recovery: Means the processes by which communities and the nation are assisted in returning to their proper levels of functioning. Prevention measures: Aims at impend the occurrence or to minimize its harmful effects on communities. Mitigation: Includes the measures aimed at reducing the impact of a hazard on a nation or a community. Fire is chain reaction of fuel, heat oxygen and chemical. For fire management it is necessary to maintain the following things. Never complete the figure triangle: â€˘
Where there is fuel and air keep heat away
Where there is air and heat keep fuel away
Where there is heat and fuel keep air away
Understanding the three sides of the fire triangle, and being able to recognize them in every day situation is the key to fore prevention. UNIVERSAL LAWS TO PREVENT OCCURRENCE OF FIRE There are some laws universally accepted to prevent fire hazard. Those laws are cited below. •
Control or eliminate the source of ignition
Control or eliminate materials that are easily ignited
Use non-combustible material
Use and select materials with low ignitibility
FIRE HAZARD MANAGEMENT Management of fire is important because of •
Prevention is better than cure
Saves life and valuable asset
Considering the importance of fire hazard management various steps are taken for management. REMOVE OR REDUCE THE HAZARD To remove or reduce the hazard impact we need to d o following things •
Remove unused combustible materials. Store the combustible materials in fire resistant structures. Separate sources of ignition from flammable materials
Remove unnecessary heat sources and use safer ones
Check the safety and maintenance status of electric and mechanical equipment, and repair them if necessary
Do not use open flames (gas, lighters, cigarettes, etc) in risk areas
ESTABLISH THE FIRE FIGHTING MEASURES Establish fire fighting measures Escape routes Reduce distance to exits Provide adequate
Fire extinguisher Provide an adequate number of the fire extinguisher, according
Fire alarm Provide a fire alarm system
number of emergency exit Provide alternative emergency exit Limit to crowing Always keep the exit way clear
to the kind of combustible materials present Provide hose reels and sprinklers system if necessary Periodically verify the functionality and maintenance of fire fighting equipments
ESTABLISH THE FIGHTING AND EVACUATION PROCEDURE In case of fire timely and effective action requires the cooperation of all those involved •
Every second is precious, the rapidity of the alert and action is crucial
Panic is the first enemy to fight, as it is an obstacle to proper, effective action. Information and training will help to overcome the panic
Escape routes must be cleared of any obstacles and emergency exit must never be locked. The escape routes and exit way must be checked every day.
Fire fighting procedure must be established in advance and with the participation of all the workers, in order to: •
Immediately fight the (extinction) to limit dangers, rapidly and clearly alert (alarm) the internal and external rescue teams (ambulance, fire department)
Plan an easy escape from places involved in the fire (evacuation), in a fast and orderly way.
INFORM AND TRAIN THE WORKERS Train a sufficient number of workers in fire fighting (using extinguisher) and evacuate procedures. UPDATE THE FIRE FIGHTING MEASURES •
Type and quantity of materials
Crowing of workplace
Equipment and system
ESTABLISH THE FIRE EMERGENCY PROCEDURE •
Immediately alert the floor supervisor and other workers
Try to extinguish the fire with nearest extinguisher, remove any flammable materials that may close by and, if possible, switch electrical devices off, without putting oneself in danger
If the fire can’t be controlled, sound the general alarm, then contact the fire department and ambulance service
Leave the building through the nearest exit or escape route, closing exit and windows when leaving rooms
Persons with disabilities should be assisted out of the building
Go to a designated evacuation are (emergency head quarters), located in a safe place
Check the missing workers
Gather information from escapees and arrange rescue operation with the help of fire department
LEARN SELF PROTECTION MEASURE •
If you have to pass through the smoke, stay low, protect nose and mouth with a wet handkerchief
Pay attention on opening the doors, if the door feels hot, do not open it and look for a different escape route. If there is no alternative, open it staying low and as far back as possible
If there is smoke or fire covering the first escape route, use an alternative one
Do not run if your clothes catch fire, cause air feeds flame
Get down on the floor and roll to smother the flames, take your clothes off. Someone close to you can take a blanket, carpet, etc to wrap around you and some other the falmes
TWELVE RULES FOR FIRE SAFETY •
Any anomaly such as the presence of flames, smell of burning overheating equipment, object or materials, electrical sparks, gas leaks should be signaled immediately
Periodical controls and maintenance staff should be carried out on fire protection equipment, alarms, emergency equipment and system, as well as on electric machines and devices
Make sure that escape routes are sufficient short, kept clear, illuminated, signaled, and large enough for the number of persons present; and the that emergency exit are always unlocked during working time
Use and store combustible and flammable materials from open flames, electrical equipment, engines, system or material that could overheat, equipment or object on which electrostatic charges may accumulate
Store combustible or flammable materials in appropriate that are isolated, ventilated, and fire resistant and equipped with fire extinguishing systems
Install safe electrical systems, use them properly, do not overload them, and switch electrical equipment off when not in use, except if intended to remain permanently in operation
Use open flames and all heat sources safely
Establish and respect smoking bans in the presence of combustible or flammable materials. Where smoking is allowed, use ash trays for matches, and cigarettes buts
Inform workers of fire and explosion escape routes and places where fire extinguishing system and emergency devices are located
Train workers, according to defined procedures, in the use of escape routes and the appropriate actions to be taken in case of fire. Fire alert procedure inside and outside the workplace, fire extinguishing, leading evacuation
Remove waste materials, paper or other flammables everyday
When leaving the workplace, do not leave any ignited material (coals) open flames, wate and ensure that doors or windows are closed
SAFETY OF PERSONNELS There are many hazards especially so when a fire occurs, and the following are rules which should be observed by officers and men in the interests of general safety •
• • • •
Any crew of fire fighting personnel stationed in hazardous position should have an observer attached to it whose task is to worn the man when danger is imminent, and a pre-arranged signal for this purpose should be agreed upon. A path of retreat should be planned if necessary and kept clear of all observations. The path should be illuminated if necessary by night. Men should not work inside a bund wall if there is any danger for boil over or slop over or if the work can be done adequately from outside. When it is necessary to work within a bund, points of egress should be agreed upon. Where necessary, men should be protected from radiated heat by improvised shields, and relief should be arranged at frequent intervals Breathing apparatus should be allowed to smoke. It may not be dangerous in the vicinity of the fire, yet highly so if the men move within the range of vapor elsewhere in the refinery When a boil over is probable, no one should be allowed within a considerable distance of the tank. Men should not take shelter behind tanks or building if there is any danger of their trapped by an oil wave. Direct flames from a boil over may extend several tank-diameters away from the fire.
MANAGEMENTS OF ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENTS AND INSTALLATION • • • • • • •
Keep electrical heating device at a safe distance from combustible materials such as wood and construction materials Damage to electrical equipments must be attend to immediately All electrical installations are to be inspected and tested at least thrice a year Temporary wiring connections should be reduced and due care must be given to ensure the circuit is not overloaded Ensure that all main switches are off when not in use All electrical repair and management work should be handled by qualified personnel Temporary paper of interior decoration should be kept at a distance from light and not attached to electrical wiring
AUTOMATIC FIRE DETECTION SYSTEMS Automatic fire detection systems, when combined with other elements of an emergency response and evacuation plan, can significantly reduce property damage, personal injuries, and loss of life from fire in work place. Their main function is to quickly identify a developing fire and alert building occupants and emergency response personnel before extensive damage occurs. Automatic fire detection systems do this by using electronic sensors to detect the smoke, heat or flames from a fire and providing an early warning (Rahman, 2006). The number, spacing and location of detectors must be based on:
• Field experience or testing • Engineering surveys • The manufacture’s recommendation CONTROL STRATEGIES • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
Ensure that the fire fighting equipments is adequate Ensure that all fire fighting equipment is properly handled and in good working condition Employees should be trained in using fire fighting equipments Fire fighting equipment should locate at the fire fighting access are and clearly displayed Emergency telephone numbers are to be displayed at strategic places All employees should be instructed to call the fire service and civil defense department if a fire breaks out A first aid kit should be available and it contents checked periodically Any damage of fire fighting equipment should be attended to immediately and recorded Tests and inspections on the fire fighting equipments should be done periodically Direction to the location of the pump and generator room should be displayed Ensure that all fire protection equipment and system are free from obstruction The building should have fire resistant grid to limit the floor area without obstructing the exit Ensure that any opening in a separation wall is protected by fire doors Ensure that all fire doors at the fire fighting access area are shut at all times Ensure that all interior all interior decoration such as carpets, curtains and paints are approved by the fire service and civil defense department of Bangladesh All construction and renovations must comply with the conditions of the laws of the local authorities
RECOMMENDATIONS The study was designated to analysis the spatio-temporal dimensions of fire hazard in 69 number word of Dhaka city. In order to fulfill the objectives spatial case was taken to the mapping of fire incident and casualities by collecting old records and documents for ascertaining the present situation of fire hazard. Questionnaires were drawn up for knowing the present situation. End of all types of observation clear decision can be given that, lack of awareness is the main cause of fire hazard. It is a social hazard occurred by human activities. Fire incident occurred because lack of awareness of mass people, use of highly inflammable material, open flames cooking, lighting, in low income residential areas maintenance of little or no fire gape between and among structures. Most show warehouse are situated in 69 number word of Dhaka city which contain flammable solution, most dangerous for fire incidents. Fire is series of chemical reaction known as chain reaction. It is a social hazard occurred by human activities, other causes are also responsible for fire hazard. In the last 10 years, new building construction and materials have changed considerably. Due to unplanned urbanization, build up haphazard industrialization and high rise building the number of fire incidents increasing day by day in our country. The activities of Fire Service and Civil Defense hurdled from several limitations during the fire incidents. Integrated fire protection plan could be effective to reduce the number of fire incidents. We should remember that fire accident is an incidence, where several effective factors contribute, for that reason integrated approaches will help to mitigate the problems. In our country institutional weakness is the main drawback to implement any program in this perspective following recommendation made for the improvement of the situation of fire hazard.
• • •
Need to launch awareness programs in study area cause people are educated but not aware of fire hazard which has shown in chi-square test. Adequate fire safety system should be installed in high rise building. Compulsory installation of adequate fire and smoke detectors, automatic sprinklers, warning systems and extinguishers should be enforced in all the fire prone commercial, storage and manufacturing areas of different locations in 69 number words of Dhaka city. The people in general should be educated on matters of fire protection. They should be imparted knowledge of the causes of fire drills be organized to make sure that peoples in all premises known how to use the fire extinguishment equipment, where the nearest exit is, and how to leave the building calmly and safely. Knowledge develops including education, training, research and information Public commitment and instrumental frameworks, including organizational policy, legislation and community action are needed. By knowledge, values and attitudes public participation most significantly reduce the loss of human lives and the material damages causes by hazards. Government, NGOs and civil society can play a vital rule in awareness program. Government organizations and other non-government organization will work together to reduce the number of fire incidents in the long run. They can arrange different type of program to aware people of the society. In rural areas GOs and NGOs will talk with stake holders who are vulnerable and try to understand their perception about accidents and also try to motivate them to use initiatives fire protection about accidents and also try to understand their protection systems and safety. Government should arrange special program to reduce the losses, awareness raising and training program, day observation, seminar, open discussion, rally etc. they also introduce the fire safety behavior in school level as the children will learn about fire hazard. Along with the formal education, government also can introduce the fire prevention behavior in no formal education. The building code which the Rajdhani Unnyan Kartipakkha has outlined for the owners of the building, most of the oweners are not followed that. So owners of apartment, complexes, buildings and offices must be compelled under the law adopt safety measures of their own. In this regard provisions for emergency exits and fire fighting equipment assure unquestioned importance. Close surveillance should be taken regularly in locality by City Corporation Media campaign could help the problem. TV channels and newspaper could play vital role to build awareness in community level. Fire protection slide show can be display all over in every cinema hall, Radio, TV news and electronics media could aired fire protection activities and also could display the feature and information fire hazard. To serve people properly, fire man and fire station should be increased. It is not enough to increase the fire station and fire man but also have to be increased the fire equipments. After the independence of Bangladesh BFCD have modernized but cars and equipments lack behind.
CONCLUSION In this study thinning associated with three different slash treatments has shown to be an effective means for reducing fire spread, resistance-to-control, and ecological management. In every year it has been loosing many lives and properties. Fire destroy not only the individual properties, it is as well as the properties of nation. So giving the priority of national properties we have to control the fire incidents. It is the best time for awareness.
Published on Jun 3, 2013
Fire has invented for better living and building structure developed for improved and comfortable livelihood. With the course of time the de...