Page 1

S e le c tio n o f th e Eu rop e a n Ca p ita l o f Cu ltu re 2018 in th e N e th e rla n d s

THE S ELECTION P AN EL

F IN AL S ELECTION REP ORT

Am s te rd am , S e p te m be r 2013


1. In tro d u c tio n In a ccor da nce wit h t he Decision 1622/2006/E C of t h e E u r opea n Pa r lia m ent a n d t h e Cou n cil of 24 Oct ober 2006 est a blish in g a Com m u n it y a ct ion for t h e E u r opea n Capit a l of Cu lt u r e even t for t he yea r s 2007 t o 2019 (h er ein a ft er r efer r ed t o a s “t h e Decision”), a com pet it ion h a s been or ga n ised t o n om in a t e a Du t ch cit y t o t h e E ur opea n Ca pit a l of Cu lt u r e (E COC) t it le for t h e yea r 2018. Th e Cou n cil of t h e E u r opea n Un ion h a s a lr eady n om in a t ed Va let t a in Ma lt a as t he com pa n ion E COC for 2018. Th e m a n a gin g a u t h or it y of t h e E COC com pet it ion in t h e Net h er la n ds is t h e Dut ch Min ist r y of E du ca t ion , Cu lt u r e a n d Science. Th e pr ocedu r e for im plem en t in g t his Decision in t h e Net her la n ds wa s set ou t in t h e docu m ent “Ru les of P r ocedu r e – Com pet it ion for t h e 2018 E u r opea n Ca pit a l of Cu lt u r e t it le in t h e Net h er la n ds” sign ed by t h e St a t e-Secr et a r y for E du ca t ion, Cu lt u r e a n d Science in Sept em ber 2012 (h er ein aft er r efer r ed t o a s “t h e Ru les”). Th e Min ist r y h as assign ed Dut ch Cu lt u r e, cen t r e for int er n at ion a l cooper a t ion (t h en SICA Du t ch Cen t r e for In t er n a t ion a l Cu lt ur al Act ivit ies) wit h t h e or ga n is a t ion of t he m eet ings of t h e Select ion P a n el. In a ccor da n ce wit h t he Decision a n d t he Ru les, t h e Du t ch Min ist r y of E du ca t ion, Cu lt u r e a n d Scien ce is r esponsible for t he or ga n isa t ion of t h e E COC com pet it ion in clu din g t h e n om in a t ion of n a t ion a l exper t s for t h e Select ion P a n el, or ga n isat ion of pr e-select ion a nd fin a l select ion m eet in gs a n d coor din a t ion of visit s of t h e r epr esen t a t ives of t h e Select ion P a n el t o t h e pr e-select ed cit ies. In a ccor da n ce wit h Ar t icle 6 of t h e Decision, t h e Select ion P a n el wa s a ppoin t ed by t he Du t ch St a t e Secr et a r y for Cu lt ur e on 25 Sept em ber 2012. It was com posed of 7 in dependen t exper t s nom in a t ed by t h e E u r opea n in st it ut ion s (2 by t h e E u r opean P a r lia m en t , 2 by t h e Cou n cil of t h e E u r opea n Un ion , 2 by t h e E u r opea n Com m ission a nd 1 by t h e Com m it t ee of t h e Region s) a n d 6 indepen den t exper t s n om ina t ed by t h e Du t ch St a t e Secr et a r y for Cult u r e. Th e P a n el elect ed Ma n fr ed Ga u lh ofer a s t h e Ch a ir a n d Nyn ke St ellin gsm a a s t h e Vice-Ch a ir . All m em ber s of t he Select ion P a n el h a ve sign ed decla r at ion s of n on -conflict of in t er est con cer n in g t h eir eva lu at ion of t h e applica t ions m a de by t h e ca ndida t e cit ies. On 31 Decem ber 2012 t h e m a n dat es of E r n a H en n icot -Sch oepges a n d Con st a n t in Ch ir ia c (bot h m em ber s who pa r t icipat ed in t h e pr e-select ion st a ge) expir ed, a n d An u Kivilo a nd Nor ber t Riedl wer e n om in a t ed by t h e Cou n cil of t h e E u r opea n Un ion t o r epla ce t h em .

2. P re -s e le c tio n F ive Du t ch cit ies r espon ded t o t h e ca ll of applica t ions pu blish ed in Decem ber 2011 by t h e Min ist r y for t he t it le of E u r opea n Ca pit al of Cu lt u r e 2018 in t h e Net h er la nds by su bm it t in g a n a pplica t ion by t h e dea dlin e:

1


Th e Ha g u e , Ein d h o v e n , Le e u w a rd e n , Ma a stric h t a n d U tre ch t . Un der Ar t icle 7 of t he Decision , wh ich dea ls wit h t h e pr e -select ion st a ge, t h e P a n el a ssessed t h ese a pplica t ion s a ga inst t h e cr it er ia st at ed in Ar t icle 4 of t h e Decision. Th e pr e-select ion m eet in g t ook pla ce in Am st er dam on 29 a n d 30 Novem ber 2012, a n d t h e P a n el r ecom m en ded t o sh or t -list in g t h e followin g t hr ee cit ies for t h e fin a l select ion ph a se: Ein d h o v e n , Le e u w a rd e n a n d Ma a s tric h t . F ollowin g t h e pr e-select ion m eet in g, t h e P a n el su bm it t ed a r epor t t o t h e Du t ch Min ist r y of E du cat ion , Cu lt u r e an d Science a n d t h e E u r opea n Com m ission wit h r ecom m enda t ions con cer n in g the a pplica t ions m a de by the sh or t -list ed cit ies. (h t t p://ec.eu r opa.eu /cu lt u r e/ou r -pr ogr a m m es-a nd-a ct ion s/capit a ls/com pet in gcit ies_en .ht m )

3. F in a l s e le c tio n All t h r ee cit ies su bm it t ed t h eir com plet ed applica t ions for t h e t it le of E u r opea n Ca pit a l of Cu lt ur e 2018 by t h e fin a l closin g da t e on 12 J u ly 2013. A delega t ion of fou r P an el m em ber s visit ed t he t h r ee shor t -list ed cit ies in pr epa r a t ion of t h e fin a l select ion m eet in g: Leeuwa r den (2 Sept em ber 2013), E in dhoven (3 Sept em ber 2013) a nd Ma a st r ich t (4 Sept em ber 2013). Th e delega t ion consist ed of t h e followin g m em ber s of t h e Select ion Pa n el: Mr s Nynke St ellin gsm a , Mr Din gem a n Ku ilm a n (r eplaced by Mr s J a n n eke va n der Wijk in Ma a st r ich t ), Sir J er em y Isa a cs a n d Mr J or di P a r do. Th e delega t ion wa s a ccom pa n ied by a r epr esen t at ive of t h e E u r opea n Com m ission (Mr Sylva in P asqu a ), a r epr esen t at ive of t h e Min ist r y of E du ca t ion , Cu lt u r e a nd Scien ce (Mr H en k H eika m p) a nd t wo r epr esen t at ives of Dut ch Cu lt u r e (Ms Ch r ist in e va n Blit t er swijk a n d Ms Soph ie Logot h et is). Th e fin a l select ion m eet in g t ook pla ce in Am st er da m on 5 Sept em ber a n d 6 Sept em ber 2013. All 13 P a n el m em ber s pa r t icipa t ed in t h e m eet in g. Repr esent a t ives of t h e E u r opea n Com m ission (Mr Ka r el Ba r t ak, H ea d of t h e Cr ea t ive E u r ope P r ogr a m m e Cu lt u r e Un it a n d Mr Sylva in P a squ a , m a n ager of t he E u r opea n Ca pit a l of Cu lt u r e a ct ion ) a n d t h e Du t ch Min ist r y of E du ca t ion, Cu lt u r e a n d Scien ce (Mr H enk H eikam p) wer e pr esen t a s obser ver s. Du t ch Cu lt u r e wa s pr esen t for t h e or ga n isa t ion of t h e m eet in g. Befor e t he m eet in gs wit h t h e ca ndida t e cit ies, t h e five delega t es who pa r t icipa t ed in t h e visit s t o t h e cit ies ext en sively r epor t ed ba ck t o t h e ot h er P a n el m em ber s a bou t t h eir fin din gs a n d exper ien ce m a de on locat ion.

2


Th en , E in dh oven , Leeuwa r den (on 5t h Sept em ber ) a n d Ma a st r ich t (on 6t h Sept em ber ) pr esen t ed t h eir com plet ed bids t o t h e P a n el. All t h r ee cit ies wer e r epr esen t ed by loca l a u t h or it ies at t h e level of Ma yor , a ccom pa n ied by ea ch of t h e a r t ist ic t ea m s as well as r epr esen t at ives of cu lt ur a l in st it u t ions a n d t h e bu sin ess sect or , ar t ist s a n d you n g people. Th e fin a l select ion m eet in g con sist ed of a 30-m in u t es pr esen t a t ion by t h e r epr esen t at ives of ea ch pr e-select ed cit y, followed by a 90-m in u t es qu est ion a n d a nswer session wh ich focu sed on a ll a spect s of t h e pr oposa ls . (Th is sch edu le differ ed fr om t h e in it ia l 60 m in u t es for t h e qu est ions a nd a nswer s session a s st a t ed in t he Ru les. Th e P a n el r equ est ed t o ext en d t h is t o 90 m in u t es an d a ll t h r ee pr e -select ed cit ies a ppr oved). In it s in t er n a l deba t e t h a t followed t h e pr ese nt a t ions, t he P a n el car r ied ou t a n in -dept h a ssessm en t of t h e infor m a t ion pr ovided by t h e ca n dida t e cit ies in t h eir bidbooks , t h e feedback on t h e visit s, t h eir or a l pr esen t at ion s a n d a n swer s pr ovided t o t h e exper t s’ qu est ions du r in g t h e h ea r in gs. It wa s clea r t o t h e P a n el t h a t con sider able effor t h ad been m a de by a ll t h r ee cit ies t o u pda t e t h eir applicat ions a n d t o t ake a ccou n t of t he r ecom m en dat ions put for wa r d by t h e P a n el in t h e pr e-select ion r epor t . To eva lu a t e t h e bids, t he P a n el: 

t h or ou gh ly eva lu a t ed t h e ext en t t o wh ich t h e ca n didat e cit ies m et t he object ives of t h e E u r opea n Capit a l of Cu lt u r e in it ia t ive, a s set out in Ar t icle 3 of t h e Decision, a n d t h e cr it er ia defined in Ar t icle 4 of t he Decision , n a m ely “t h e E u r opean Dim ension” a n d t h e “Cit y a n d Cit izens” dim en sion ;

a ssessed t h e qu a lit y of t h e r esponses pr ovided by t h e cit ies t o t he qu est ion s in clu ded in t h e a pplica t ion for m ;

con sider ed t h e over a ll ca pa cit y of t h e cit ies t o en su r e t h e im plem en t a t ion of t he even t , n ot a bly t he gover n a n ce, t h e budget , t h e su ppor t of loca l a n d r egion a l a u t h or it ies a n d t h e bu sin ess sect or .

F ollowin g t h e fin al select ion m eet in g (a t 4.30 p.m . on 6 Sept em ber 2013), a pr ess con fer en ce wa s h eld at F elix Mer it is in Am st er da m t o a n n ou n ce t h e r esult of t h e select ion pr ocess. At t h e pr ess con fer en ce, t h e Du t ch Min ist er for E du cat ion , Cu lt ur e a nd Scien ce, Mr s J et Bu ssem a ker , was h a nded over t h e r ecom m en da t ion by t h e Ch a ir of t h e P a n el, Mr Ma n fr ed Ga ulh ofer .

4. Th e Ev a lu a tio n by th e S e le c tio n P a n e l Th e P a n el n ot ed t h a t t h e select ion of t h e Dut ch E u r opea n Ca pit a l of Cu lt u r e 2018 wa s a difficu lt ch oice du e t o t h e in t en sive a n d t ou gh com pet it ion bet ween t h e t h r ee excellen t ca n didat e cit ies. All t h r ee cit ies, while pr oposing ver y differ en t a ppr oa ch es for t h e E COC even t , pr ovided t h e P an el wit h t hr ee ver y convin cin g a n d well pr epar ed bid docu m en t s t h a t sh owed evidence of a t h or ou gh pla n n ing t a kin g in t o a ccou n t t h e m u lt it u de of a spect s n eeded t o be con sider ed wh en h ost in g su ch a n im por t a n t event . 3


Th e P a n el em ph asised t h a t t h e gr eat effor t s in vest ed by a ll t hr ee cit ies wou ld be ben eficial t o ea ch on e, wh a t ever t h e fin a l r esult of t h e com pet it ion wou ld even t u a lly be, a s t h ey wou ld cont r ibut e t o st r en gt h en in g t h e r ole of cu lt u r e in t h e cit ies’ developm en t st r at egies a n d st im u la t in g a n d en r ich in g t h eir cu lt u r a l life. Th e P a n el fu r t h er n ot ed t he ca r efu l wor k u n der t a ken by each ca ndida t e cit y t o t ake in t o a ccou n t t h e r ecom m en dat ions for m u la t ed in it s pr e-select ion r epor t . Th e t ext s of t h e bid docum en t s wer e, of cou r se, fur t h er t est ed dur in g t h e pan el's cit y visit s a n d a t t h e Qu est ion a nd An swer sessions. Th e P a n el h igh ligh t ed t h e followin g ch a r a ct er ist ics of E in dh oven’s, Leeu wa r den ’s a nd Ma a st r ich t ’s bids. Ein d h o v e n Un der t h e sloga n “Im agin a t ion designs E u r ope” t he cit y of E in dh oven pr esen t ed it self t oget h er wit h t h e four ot h er cit ies of Br a ba n t St a d a n d t h e pr ovin ce of Br a ba nt , a ddr essin g a n d developin g fu r t h er t h e quest ion s r a ised in t h e pr e -select in g ph a se. E in dh oven ’s bid wa s built a r ou n d t h r ee m ain t h em es: 

We E xplor e t h e F u t u r e

We Con n ect P eople

We Make t h e Cit y

Th e P a n el u n der st ood fr om t he pr esen t at ion t h a t t h e cit y of E in dh oven a n d it s su r r ou ndin g a r ea h a ve been a wa r ded t it les like t h e on e of being t h e In t elligen t Com m u n it y of t h e Year 2011 or t he on e of bein g t h e m ost in vent ive cit y in t h e wor ld in 2013, bu t t h e E COC bid pr ovided for t h e oppor t u n it y t o r einfor ce t he st ill in sufficien t r ole of ar t a nd cu lt u r e in t he cit y as well a s t o fu r t h er con n ect a r t a n d cu lt u r e wit h cr ea t ivit y, in n ova t ion, t ech n ology a n d scien ce t h a t a r e syn on ym ou s for t h e l ife in t he cit y. Th e E in dhoven delega t ion point ed out t he n eed for t h e cit y t o r edefin e it self as a cu lt u r a l h u b, su ppor t ed by t h e a r t ist s, cit izen s a n d scient ific cen t r es pr esen t in t he r egion . Th e cor e of t he E in dh oven a ppr oa ch is t h e con cept of “P r oeft uin en” (best t o be t r a n sla t ed by “exper im ent a l ga r den s”) t h at wou ld a ct a s cr ea t ive la bor at or ies - based on a “m u lt iple h elix” m odel m ixin g a ll t ypes of st a keholder s inclu din g t h e a r t com m un it y, t h e busin ess sect or , scien ce a n d t h e cit izen s – a n d wou ld give a m ple r oom for exper im en t a t ion a n d for t h e gen er a t ion of cu lt u r a l a n d societ a l in n ova t ion . Th e P r oeft u in concept was illu st r a t ed by a sh or t pr esen t a t ion on t h e P r oeft u in E xper ien ce Cent r e: a cen t r al pla ce t o visit t he m et h od, pr ocess a nd out com es of t h e P r oeft u inen . “Pr oeft u in en” gen er a t ed pr oject s wou ld con t r ibut e a bou t a t h ir d of t h e t ot a l pr ogr am m e, a sign ifica n t pr opor t ion . An ch or pr oject s, developed in a m or e t r adit ion a l m a n a gem en t a ppr oa ch , would fill t h e r est of t h e pr ogr a m m e. Th e P a n el pr a ised t h e com bin a t ion of a r t s, design , t ech n ology a nd scien ce as pr esent ed by E in dh oven . Th e P a n el wa s a lso ver y posit ively im pr essed by t h e h igh level of 4


com m it m en t of t h e cit y, kn owledge inst it ut es an d t h e bu sin ess sect or t o en ga ge wit h ar t a n d cu lt u r e. It wa s a lso eviden t for t h e P a n el t h a t t h e bid was a n excellen t ou t com e of t h e h u ge effor t s a n d invest m ent s m ade in, a nd t h e su ccess exper ienced by, t h e r egion over t h e pa st yea r s, a nd wa s clea r ly r oot ed in t h e cit y's lon g-t er m developm ent st r a t egy. Th e P a n el wa s a lso im pr essed wit h t h e st r ong will of t h e cit y t o becom e a showca se of h ow t o live in a difficu lt post -indu st r ia l t im e u sin g cu lt u r e t o ch an ge t h e cit y a n d im pr ove livin g con dit ion s. Th e P a n el n ot ed t h a t t h e bidbook wa s ver y well st r u ct ur ed a nd offer ed a clear a n d wellpr epar ed pla n for t he yea r s leadin g t o 2018 a s well as t h e yea r of t h e t it le, dem onst r at in g t h er eby a la r ge pot en t ial. It welcom ed t h e idea of pilot edit ion s of lar ge a n ch or pr oject s fr om 2014 on wa r d as well as t h e concept in t er im pr esen t at ion s in t he for m of bien n ales. Wh ile pr a isin g t h e P r oeft u in con cept a s a pot en t ia lly ver y int er est in g exper im en t a l m et h od wit h h igh cr ea t ive pot en t ia l, t h e P an el felt t h a t t h e wa y it wou ld pr odu ce in n ova t ive r esu lt s ba sed on a t r u ly in n ova t ive a ppr oach h a d n ot been pr esen t ed con vin cin gly en ou gh eit h er in t h e bid -book n or dur in g t h e h ea r in g. Th e P a n el’s im pr ession wa s t h a t t h e P r oeft u in en wou ld n ot be as explor a t ive a s on e cou ld h a ve expect ed, du e t o t h e ada pt a t ion of wh at seem ed a linea r in n ovat ion pr oce ss lackin g r oom for fu zzin ess. It a lso r em a in ed u n clea r h ow t h e qu a lit y a n d coh er ence of t h e pr oject s wou ld be dir ect ed. Th e P a n el was t h er efor e scept ica l a bou t t h e P r oeft uin m et h od’s a bilit y t o fully deliver it s cla im ed pot en t ia l. Th e "Cit y a n d Cit izen s" dim ension of t h e E in dh oven bid t h a t wa s con n ect ed t o a la r ge ext en t t o t h e P r oeft u in m et hod wa s n ot a s con vin cin g a s one could h a ve wish ed eit h er . Th e P a n el a ckn owledged t h a t t h e pr ogr a m m e was la r gely focused on pr ofession a l in n ova t ion especia lly in design , but it felt at t h e sam e t im e t h a t it la cked a bot t om -up a ppr oach , deeply r oot ed in t he cit y’s popu la t ion . As for t h e E u r opea n dim en sion, it seem ed t o t h e P a n el it was u n der explor ed. Th e link bet ween in n ova t ion a n d t h e E u r opea n Dim ension was n ot m a de su fficient ly clea r a n d t h er e was n o st r on g r efer ence in t h e pr ogr am m e t o ot h er E u r opean cit ies or r egions fa cin g t h e sa m e ch a llenges E in dh oven cur r en t ly is. Th e P a n el was given t h e im pr ession t h a t E in dh oven wish ed t o pr ofile it self r a t h er a s a globa l cit y t h a n a E u r opea n cit y. Alt h ou gh it wa s m a de clea r wh at E u r ope ca n lea r n fr om E in dh oven, pr esen t ed a s a "t est cit y" for t h e r est of t h e con t in ent , t h e ot h er wa y a r ou n d sh ou ld h a ve been h igh ligh t ed m or e. As a wh ole, t h e pr ogr am m e ou t side of t h e P r oeft u in en, a lb eit of h igh qu a lit y, st r uck t he P a n el a s n ot bein g t h e m ost in n ova t ive t h e cit y of E in dh oven cou ld br in g for wa r d a s t h e E u r opea n Capit a l of Cult u r e. Le e u w ard e n Leeu wa r den ’s cen t r a l m ot t o h a d been sh ift ed fr om “Mien skip” t o “Iepen Mienskip” a t fin a l select ion st a ge, wit h “Mien skip” bein g a collect ive F r isia n t er m for va lu es su ch a s 5


m u t u a l r espect , equ alit y a n d r esponsibilit y in t h e com m u n it y. Th e Leeu wa r den t eam poin t ed ou t t ha t t h ese a r e t h e va lu es t h a t in spir e E u r opea ns ever y da y a nd con sequ ent ly, Mien skip h a d in spir ed t h e en t ir e bid a s a veh icle of beh a viou r a l ch a n ge a n d im pr oved cooper a t ion in t h e wh ole of E u r ope. Leeu wa r den consider ed t h r ee t h em a t ic dom a in s t o be of h igh est r eleva n ce bot h t o E u r ope as a wh ole a n d t o Leeuwa r den a n d F r isia : 

Na t u r e a n d Cu lt u r e

Cit y a n d Cou nt r yside

Com m u n it y a n d Diver sit y

Leeu wa r den ’s pr esen t at ion was su ppor t ed by a video fea t u r in g you n g people fr om sever a l E u r opea n cou nt r ies ba ckin g t h eir bid. Th ey a lso sh owed t h e willin gn ess of t he pu blic t o (a ct ively) pa r t icipa t e in t h e bu ild-u p t o 2018. Th e P a n el was im pr essed by t h e pr ogr ess m ade by t h e cit y in fu r t h er developin g m a n y a spect s of t h e in it ia l bid in lin e wit h t h e r ecom m enda t ions offer ed in t h e pr e -select ion ph a se. In pa r t icu la r , t h e P a n el pr a ised t h e in n ova t ive a n d a u t h en t ic wa y t h e Leeu wa r den bid t r ied t o a ddr ess som e of t h e m ost pr essin g issu es t h at a r e bot h com m on t o loca l, m a in ly r u r a l, com m u nit ies a ll over E u r ope a n d E u r opea n in t h eir essen ce t hr ou gh cu lt u r e. Th e focu s on issu es su ch a s t h e r e-eva lu a t ion a n d r e-defin it ion of t h e r elat ion sh ip bet ween cit y a n d t h e cou nt r yside, t h e n eed t o fu r t h er pr om ot e a n d fost er cu lt u r a l a nd en vir on m en t a l sust a ina bilit y, a n d t h e open in g-u p of h ist or ica lly ver y coh esive a nd in wa r d-lookin g com m un it ies wa s welcom ed by t h e P a n el a s bein g a n a u t h en t ic a nd desir a ble object ive. Th e bid a lso dir ect ed t he P a n el's a t t ent ion t o t h e pr oblem of livin g wit h r isin g sea -levels in a n er a of clim at e ch an ge. Th e E u r opea n Dim en sion wa s well cover ed by t h e ba sic a ppr oa ch of focu sin g on issu es im por t a n t t o com m u n it ies a n d people in a ll Eu r opea n cou nt r ies a n d by t h e a ddit ion a l m ot t o of “cr iss-cr ossin g com m u n it ies”, a con cept t h a t wa s well r eflect ed in a n u m ber of pr oject s pr esen t ed. Mor eover , Leeu war den con vin cin gly expr essed t h e u r ge t o r edefin e E u r ope a s a socia l n et wor k of diver se com m u n it ies. Th e in spir at ion of na t u r e on m a nkin d t r a n spir ed t h r ou gh ou t t h e bid a n d t h e pr esen t a t ion a n d was a st r on g point of t h e Leeu wa r den bid, especially t h e con nect ion wit h ot h er wet la n ds in E u r ope a n d sim ila r ‘Mien skip s’ a cr oss t h e cont in en t . Th e P a n el a lso a ppr eciat ed t he pr om inen t posit ion of t h e r ole of lesser -used a n d m in or it y la n gu a ges in E u r ope an d t h e con nect ion t h e pr ogr a m m e int en ds t o bu ild wit h ot her m in or it y cu lt u r es speakin g t h eir r espect ive m in or it y la n gu a ges in ot h er E u r opean cou n t r ies. 6


Th e P a n el a lso was im pr essed by t he focus of t h e h olist ic a n d in t elligen t concept of t he Leeu wa r den bid on t he fu t u r e, in n ova t ion a nd you n g people r a t h er by doin g t h a n by t a lkin g a bout t h ese issues. You n g people a r e a t t h e cor e of t he bid, in t h e or ga n isa t ion of t h e even t as well a s com m u n ica t ion. Th e pr ogr a m m e t a r get s loca l com m u n it ies a ll over E u r ope usin g in n ova t ive m et hods a n d t ech n ologies. It is con cen t r a t ed on issu es im por t a n t for t h e fu t u r e of people livin g in E ur ope m or e t h a n in t h e pa st a n d even t h e pr esen t . Th e P a n el wa s im pr essed by t h e scope a n d a m bit ion set out in t h e eva lu a t ion a n d m on it or in g object ives, pr esent ed in a SMART for m a t . Th e P a n el a lso t h ou gh t t h a t t h r ou gh t h e m a n y E u r opea n a n d in t er n a t ion a l pa r t n er sh ips developed in t h e la st few m on t hs, t h e bid h a d n ow r ea ch ed a cr it ica l m a ss in t er m s of pr oject s a n d pot en t ia l au dien ces. Th e "Cit y a nd Cit izens" dim en sion was well cau gh t n ot only by t h e Mien skip m ot t o, but a lso by t h e eviden t en t h u siasm t hr ou gh ou t t h e pr oject of en ga gin g wit h cit izens. P a r t icipat ion a n d in clu sion a r e key t o t he Leeu wa r den a ppr oach (in clu din g a n im pr essive u se of volun t eer s) a n d in spir es all pa r t s of t h e pr oject ; t h e Leeu wa r den pr ogr a m m e sh ows m a ny pla n s t o con n ect t he cit izens, in pa r t icu la r you n g people a nd m igr a n t com m u n it ies, bot h t o t h e E COC pr oject a n d t o ea ch ot h er wit h in t h e r egion a n d a cr oss bor der s t o t h e wh ole of E ur ope. Th e P a n el n ot ed t h e specific pr ogr a m m es t o in t egr a t e a n d en ga ge t he P olish wor ker s n ow in t h e Leeu war den com m u n it y. Th e P a n el point ed ou t t h a t a lot of pr ogr ess h a d been m a de in t h e st r u ct u r in g of t he or ga n isa t ion of Leeuwa r den 2018 since pr e-select ion st a ge, eviden cin g t h e t ea m 's com m it m en t a n d openn ess t o lear n fr om t h e ou t er wor ld . H owever , m or e wor k was n eeded t o set u p a st r on g deliver y fou n da t ion for t h e im plem en t a t ion of a pr ogr a m m e of t h e sca le of a E u r opean Ca pit a l of Cu lt u r e. Th e P a n el a lso n ot ed t h a t t h e per iph er al loca t ion of Leeuwa r den (bot h geogr a ph ica l a n d cu lt u r a l) wou ld pr ove t o be a ch a llen ge t o m a kin g t h e pr ogr a m m e a su ccess t hr ou gh ou t E u r ope. Ma a s tric h t Ma a st r ich t ’s m ission wa s “E u r ope Revisit ed”, wr it in g t h e “lost ch apt er” on cu lt ur e in t h e 1992 E U Tr ea t y of Maa st r ich t . Ma ast r ich t applied for t h e t it le wit h t h e suppor t of t h e en t ir e E u r egion Meu se-Rh in e wh ich cover s 10.500 km ² in t h r ee cou n t r ies wit h t h r ee differ en t la n gu a ges, t hr ee differ ent polit ica l a nd a dm in ist r a t ive syst em s), a n d com pr ises a popu la t ion of 3,9 m illion in h a bit a n t s. Th e bid was su ppor t ed by t he join t st a t em ent sign ed by t h e 13 a ut h or it ies r epr esen t in g t h e E u r egion , Th e bid a im ed a t bu ildin g on t h e t igh t cu lt u r al a n d h ist or ica l r ela t ions bet ween t h e cit ies of t he cr oss-bor der ar ea t o m ake t h is r egion becom e one h ear t in E u r ope, wh er e or din a r y cit izens wou ld en joy "E u r ope" in t h eir da ily lives. Th e E COC t it le wou ld be t h e livin g pr oof of t his a m bit ion . Th e followin g four pr ogr a m m e lin es wer e used a s t hem es of “Eu r ope Revisit ed”: 

Spea kin g in Ton gu es 7


Rem em ber in g t he F u t ur e

Mir r or in g E u r ope

Livin g E u r ope.

In or der t o pr epa r e t he gr ou n d for t h e pr ogr a m m e ba sed on t h ese fou r t h em es in t he yea r s befor e t h e event , Ma a st r ich t in t r odu ced t h e con cept of a “E u r opea n Spr ing J ou r n ey” in t h e secon d bid book. Th is shou ld act a s a cen t r a l h u b for t h e pr ogr a m m e a n d a t t h e sa m e t im e h elp set t in g sails “t o con qu er E u r ope in a fr esh n ew wa y”. It was a lso m a de clea r in t h e secon d bid book t h a t t h e pr ogr a m m e sh ou ld r at h er be r ea d as a m et h od t h a n as a collect ion of sin gle a ct ivit ies. Th e P a n el was im pr essed by t h e specia l im por t a n ce t h a t was la id b y Ma a st r ich t on “Gén ér a t ion Ma a st r icht ”, you n g people bor n in 1992 a n d wh o wou ld be t h e sym bol a nd t h e face of Ma a st r icht 2018. Gén ér a t ion Maa st r ich t was a lso r eflect ed in t he t ea m pr esen t in g t h e bid t o t h e P a n el a n d you t h u n em ploym en t wa s on e of t h e foca l issu es r a ised by t h e Ma a st r icht bid. Th e E u r opea n Dim en sion was best r eflect ed by Ma a st r ich t ’s cooper a t ion wit h in t he E u r egion . Th e P a n el a ppla u ded t h e a m bit ion , t he willin gn ess a n d t h e st r on g com m it m en t of t h e ent ir e cr oss -bor der r egion a n d of it s cit ies t o wor k t oget h er , collect idea s a n d con t r ibu t e t o t h e bu dget of t h e E COC even t . Th e cr oss-bor der cooper a t ion , addr essin g local a s well as E u r opea n issu es wit h t he in t en t ion t o a dd a cu lt ur a l dim en sion t o t h e Tr ea t y of Ma ast r ich t a nd t h e det er m in at ion t o give cu lt u r e a m or e pr om inen t place in E u r opea n policy was gr ea t ly welcom ed by t h e P a n el. H owever t h e P a nel felt t h a t t h e pr oject as a wh ole lacked a clea r , con cr et e a n d well con st r u ct ed a r t ist ic vision a bou t h ow cu lt u r e m a y h elp m akin g E u r ope a bet t er pl a ce t o live in , a n d especia lly in cr ea t in g em ploym en t for t h e yout h . Th er efor e i t r em ain ed a lso u n clea r h ow t h e va r iou s elem ent s of t he pr ogr a m m e wou ld be sh aped t o a com m on E u r opea n per spect ive. Th e idea t h a t t h e ou t com es of t h e "E u r opean Spr in g J ou r n ey" cor e pr oject – t o be r ea lised in t h e r u n n in g-u p yea r s – wou ld feed m a n y differ en t pr oject s wa s felt a s a wa y t o out sou r ce t h e a r t ist ic vision . As a r esu lt , t h e P a n el felt t h er e wa s a m ism a t ch bet ween t h e bid's ver y a m bit ious a spir at ions a n d t h e m a n y (r a t h er sm a ll sca le) pr oject s in cluded in t h e bid. As wit h r egar d t o t he "Cit y a n d Cit izens" dim ension, t h e bid h igh ligh t ed am ple pa r t icipa t ion , but m ost ly r ela t ed wit h a t op -down a ppr oach . Th e con cept of in volving Gén ér at ion Ma a st r icht bot h in pr ogr am m e developm en t a n d t he or ga n isat ion of Ma a st r ich t 2018 sh owed gr ea t pot en t ia l a n d t he P a n el a ppr ecia t ed t h at t h e in volvem ent of you n g people was m ea n t t o give t h e r egion a boost wh ich it - dem on st r a bly - n eeds. H owever , it wa s n ot clea r t o t h e P a n el wh a t it s a ct u a l r ole in t h e or ga n isa t ion wou ld exa ct ly be n or a con t in u in g lega cy of t h e P a n el in su bsequ en t decision m a kin g a cr oss t he r egion . 8


Alt h ou gh t h e Ma ast r ich t bid is a bou t livin g in E u r ope, t h e P a n el felt t h e bid la cked a focu s on m in or it ies a n d t h eir r ole in a diver sified E u r ope. Th e bid in deed r a ised t he qu est ion if t h e par t icipa t in g cit ies a n d t h e r egion cou ld be t aken a s a pa r s pr o t ot o of E u r ope. Alt h ou gh t h e r epr esen t a t ives of Ma a st r icht 2018 wer e well pr epa r ed t o expla in h ow t h ey wou ld m a n a ge t h e com plexit y of t he Ma ast r ich t bid in geogr a ph ica l, a dm in ist r at ive a n d in st it ut ion a l t er m s, t h e P a n el wa s n ot fu lly convin ced t h a t a ll a r t ist ic a n d or ga n isat ion al ch a llen ges of t h is m u lt idim ension a l appr oa ch wou ld fin a lly su ppor t t h e qu a lit y of t h e pr ogr a m m e. D e c is ion All m em ber s of t he P a n el pr a ised a ll t h r ee cit ies for t h eir wor k t o pr ovide com pellin g fin a l bids for t h e E COC 2018 com pet it ion a n d t h a n ked t h em for t h eir effor t s t o pr ovide it wit h ext en sive in for m at ion a bou t t h eir pr oject s a t t h e select ion ph ase, a ls o du r in g t h e visit s. Du r in g t h e fin a l deliber a t ions of t he P a n el, t h e st r en gt h s a nd wea kn esses of t h e a pplicat ions a s viewed by t h e P a n el m em ber s wer e a ssessed ver y ca r efu lly. Th e discussion focused on t h e cr it er ia la id down in Ar t icle 4 of t h e Decision , on t h e qu a lit y a n d su st a in a bilit y of t h e cu lt u r a l pr ogr am m es a s well as on t h e capa cit y of ea ch pr e select ed cit y t o deliver a su ccessfu l even t in lin e wit h t he h igh st a nda r d r equ ir em en t s a n d visibilit y of t h e E COC t it le. F ollowin g deba t e t h e P a n el vot ed u n a n im ously t h a t one ca n dida t e cit y best m et t he object ives a n d cr it er ia of t h e E COC even t , a nd t h a t it pr ovided t h e best pot ent ia l a n d ca pa cit y for t h e or gan iza t ion of a n im pact fu l pr ogr am m e. Th e P a n el t h er efor e r ecom m en ds t h a t t h e followin g cit y in t h e Net h er la n ds be design a t ed a s t h e E u r opea n Ca pit a l of Cu lt u r e 2018 Le e u w ard e n . In a ddit ion t o t h e t r a nsla t ion of E u r ope int o com m u n it ies of va lues an d people a nd t he clea r ly dem onst r a t ed in volvem en t of cit izen s, t h e P a n el pa r t icu la r ly a ppr ecia t ed Leeu wa r den ’s h olist ic bot t om -u p a ppr oa ch an d t h e u n it y in t h e m a n a gem en t of t h e pr ogr a m m e. Th e P a n el r ecom m en ded E in dh oven a n d Ma a st r ich t t o t ake m a xim um a dva n t a ge of t he wor k a lr eady u n der t a ken in pr epar a t ion of a n d du r in g t h e com pet it ion by con t in u in g t h e cooper at ion wit h t h e cult u r a l sect or a nd con sider in g it a s a n im por t a nt a ct or in t h e cit y’s a n d t h e r egion’s developm en t .

9


5. Re c o m m e n d a tio n s o f th e S e le c tion P an e l to th e n o m in a te d c ity In a ccor da n ce wit h Ar t icle 8, P a r a gr a ph 4 of t h e Decision , t h e P a n el m a kes t h e followin g r ecom m en dat ions t o Leeu wa r den r ega r din g t he pr ogr ess t o be m ade a n d t h e wor k t o be ca r r ied ou t in a dva n ce of 2018. Th ese issu es will be t a ken u p a t t h e in for m a l post design a t ion m eet in g in a u t u m n 2014. Leeu war den is r em inded t h a t t h e pr ogr am m e i n t h e bidbook n ow for m s t h eir com m it m en t for 2018. 

Leeu wa r den 2018 is r ecom m en ded t o u se t h e m om ent u m cr eat ed by it s n om in a t ion t o st a r t focusin g it s effor t s on a ct u a lly t u r n in g Mien skip in t o Iepen Mien skip - a t ask wh ich will t a ke yea r s t o be su ccessfu lly a ch ieved;

Alt h ou gh m u ch pr ogr ess wa s m a de in t h e fin a l select ion st a ge, addit ion a l wor k will n eed t o be don e t o fur t her r ein for ce t h e m a n a gem en t st r u ct ur e of t h e or ga n isa t ion of Leeu wa r den 2018;

E ffor t s will h a ve t o be m a de t o pu t Leeu war den m or e on t h e E u r opean m a p as such a n d a s a r egion t h at is h a vin g ver y m uch in com m on wit h m a n y ot h er E u r opea n r egion s wh en it com es t o sh ape t h e fu t u r e of E ur ope;

Th e level of h igh in volvem en t a n d par t icipa t ion sh ou ld be sca led u p fr om t h e loca l t o a E u r opea n level;

Th e P a n el r ecom m en ds Leeu wa r den 2018 t o lin k u p wit h Um ea 2014 r ega r din g t h e co-cr ea t ion a spect of it s pr ogr a m m e developm en t in or der t o lea r n fr om Um ea’s exper ien ce;

Leeu wa r den h a s ch osen t o pu t a you n g gen er a t ion a t fr on t t h at is u sed t o or ga n ise even t s a n d pr ocesses in lin e wit h cu r r en t st at e of in for m a t ion a n d com m u n ica t ion t ech n ology a n d in wh ich offlin e a nd on lin e r ea lit y a r e fu lly int egr a t ed. Th e P a n el r ecom m en ds Leeu war den t o give t h e you n g gen er a t ion a lso a cor e pla ce in t he fu r t h er or ga n isat ion of t h e E CoC in or der t o st a y u p t o it s pr om ises m a de at select ion st a ge;

Th e digit a l a spect t h a t is in t en ded t o be a foca l pa r t of each a n d ever y pr oject sh ould becom e visible a nd t a n gible fr om t h e st a r t of a ct u a l pr oject developm ent ;

Th e bu dget sh ould be cla r ified in a wa y t h a t a nswer s t h e few qu est ions left open .

6. N e x t s te p s to w a rd s th e d e s ig n a tion In a ccor da nce wit h Ar t icle 8 of t h e Decision , t h e pr esen t r epor t h as been su bm it t ed t o t h e Com m ission a n d t o t h e Du t ch Min ist r y of E du ca t ion, Cu lt ur e a nd Scie nce a nd sh a ll be pu blish ed on t h e Com m ission ’s websit e.

10


Th e Du t ch Min ist r y of E du ca t ion, Cu lt u r e a nd Scien ce will for m a lly n om in a t e one cit y for t h e E u r opea n Ca pit a l of Cu lt u r e t it le for 2018 in t h e Net h er la n ds on t h e ba sis of t his r epor t a n d will n ot ify t h e E u r opea n P a r liam ent , t h e Cou n cil of t he E ur opea n Un ion , t h e E u r opea n Com m ission a n d t h e Com m it t ee of t h e Region s by t h e en d of t h e yea r 2013 at t h e la t est . Th e E u r opea n P a r lia m ent m a y for war d a n opin ion t o t h e E u r opea n Com m ission wit h in t h r ee m on t h s a ft er it r eceives t h e n om in a t ion. Th e Cou n cil of t h e E u r opea n Un ion, u pon a r ecom m en dat ion of t h e E u r opea n Com m ission dr a wn u p ba sed on t h e opin ion of t h e E ur opea n P a r lia m en t a n d t h e ju st ifica t ion ba sed on t h e Select ion P a n el’s r epor t , will for m a lly design a t e t h e E u r opea n Ca pit a l of Cu lt u r e 2018 in t he Net h er la n ds.

7. Mo n ito rin g p h a s e In a ccor da n ce wit h Ar t icle 10 of t h e Decision, t h e E u r opea n Capit a l of Cu lt u r e 2018, on ce design a t ed by t he E U Cou n cil of Min ist er s, will be su bm it t ed t o a m on it or in g ph ase u n t il t he begin n in g of t h e even t . Th e Mon it or in g a n d a dvisor y P a n el will be com pr ised of t h e seven m em ber s n om in at ed by t h e E u r opea n in st it u t ions. Leeuwa r den sh a ll be in vit ed t o an in for m a l post design a t ion m eet in g in la t e 2014. Th e fir st for m a l m on it or in g m eet ing will t a ke pla ce by la t e 2015 a n d t h e fin a l on e by spr in g 2017. On t he basis of t h e r epor t issued by t h e Mon it or in g a n d a dvisor y P a nel a ft er it s secon d for m al m on it or in g m eet in g, a P r ize “in h on ou r of Melin a Mer cou r i” sha ll be a war ded by t h e Com m ission pr ovided t h a t t he cit y m eet s t h e cr it er ia of t he a ct ion a n d has im plem en t ed t h e r ecom m enda t ions m a de by t h e Select ion a n d t he Mon it or in g a n d a dvisor y P a n els. Th e awa r d of t h e Melin a Mer cou r i P r ize by t h e E u r opea n Com m ission is n ot a ut om at ic. Th e P r ize sh a ll be m on et a r y a n d sh a ll be a wa r ded in pr inciple – if a ll n ecessa r y con dit ion s a r e m et – t h r ee m on t hs befor e t he st a r t of t h e r eleva n t yea r , t h a t is, by Sept em ber 2017 for t h e 2018 t it le. Am st er dam , Sept em ber 2013. Th e S e le c tio n P a n e l Ma n fr ed Ga u lh ofer , Cha ir Nyn ke St ellin gsm a, Vice-Ch a ir Ch r ist in e de Ba a n Ma r got Ger en é St eve Gr een Sir J er em y Isa a cs An u Kivilo Din gem a n Kuilm a n 11


J or di P a r do Nor ber t Riedl E lisa bet h Vit ou ch J a n n eke va n der Wijk Ru t ger Wolfson

12

Juryrapport Culturele Hoofdstad  

Het verslag van de jurybijeenkomst waarin Leeuwarden is uitgeroepen tot Culturele Hoofdstad van Europa 2018 is beschikbaar. Vandaag is het n...

Read more
Read more
Similar to
Popular now
Just for you