Issuu on Google+


! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

"!#$%&'!()!*+$,+&--!./!0(123!45''()!6!*&1&+!78!439),:! 439;1&+-!<$5+!1$!=(>! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !


! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ?@A! ! B(13!13&!&>2&;1($)!$C!1D$!=5)E9/-!&%&+/!F$)13G!=9F5&'H-!F$13&+!I$5(-9!D$+J-! C5''! 1(F&! C$+! -&%&)! E9/-! 9! D&&JG! -$F&1(F&-! ;5''(),! E$5.'&! -3(C1-! D3&)! 9! 2$K D$+J&+!29''-!()!-(2J!$+G!9-!(-!$C1&)!13&!29-&G!9)$13&+!&F;'$/&&!-5EE&)'/!L5(1-!E5&! 1$!&>395-1($)!$+!9!.&11&+!M$.!$;;$+15)(1/!&'-&D3&+&8!!N&+!D$+J;'92&²13&!O@K3$5+! #&D!P9),!P9),!Q9+E&)!RRS!6!=&9C$$E!T&-195+9)1²(-!$)&!$C!13&!F$+&!;$;5'9+! 49)1$)&-&!+&-195+9)1-!()!13&!"'39F.+9!9+&9!1391!.$+E&+-!13&!2(1(&-!$C!=9)!Q9.+(&'! 9)E!0$)1&+&/!*9+J8!!R51!2$)1+9+/!1$!D391!(1-!)9F&!-5,,&-1-G!13&!&-19.'(-3F&)1!(-! QRORQJHUQHZLWKDVLQIDFWEHHQRSHUDWLQJVLQFHWKHODWHµVZHOOEHIRUHWKH %9''&/!D9-!$%&+;$;5'91&E!./!-(F('9+!N$),!P$),K$D)&E!&91&+(&-G!9)E!D3('&!13&!-&1! F&)5!(-!C9+!C+$F!&>2&;1($)9'²F(>(),!13&!5-59'!1+9E(1($)9'!E(-3&-!D(13!-19)E9+E! B&-1&+)!C9+&!'(J&!-;9,3&11(G!$F&'&1-G!9)E!(2&!2+&9F²(1-!'$),K-19)E(),!3(-1$+/!39-! .+9)E&E!#&D!P9),!P9),!Q9+E&)!9-!9!'$29'!+&-195+9)1!$C!E(-1()21($)G!-5(19.'&!C$+! 9)/!.9)L5&1!$+!C9F('/!,913&+(),8!!! !

U3&! F9()! E()(),! +$$F! (-! -;92($5-! 9)E! .+(,31²13&! 29+;&1! F9+$$)G! 13&!

$%&+3&9E! '(,31! C(>15+&-! E&2$+91&E! D(13! .+9(E&E! ,$'EK2$'$+&E! 19--&'-²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


!"! ! D3('&!D&9%(),!.&-(E&!+$5)E!19.'&-!$+!.$$13-8! !

R51!9C1&+!13&!'5)231(F&!+5-3G!E5+(),!13&!.+(&C!'5''!.&C$+&!13&!'91&!9C1&+)$$)!

9)E! &%&)(),! 2+$DE-! 9++(%&G! I$5(-9! ;95-&-! 1$! 19J&! 3&+! -$'&! F&9'! .+&9J8! ! =(11(),! 9F$),!13&!+&-1! $C!13&!D9(1! -19CC!91!13&!'9+,&-1!19.'&!()!13&!E()(),!+$$FG!-3&!9)E! 13&! $13&+-! 9+&! -$$)! M$()&E! ./! 13&! -(>! 2$$J-²C$5+! 0&>(29)! )91($)9'-! 9)E! 1D$! (E&)1(29'! 1D()! .+$13&+-! C+$F! P$D'$$)²D3$! &%&+/! E9/! 29+1! $51! 13&! &>921! -9F&! C$$E!C$+!9''!$C!13&F!1$!-39+&:!!D$)1$)!-$5;G!-1&9F&E!%&,&19.'&-!D(13!$/-1&+!-952&G! +$9-1&E! ;$+JG! -1&9F&E! D3(1&! +(2&8! ! U3&)! D3('&! 23$;-1(2J-! $+! C$+J-!9+&! ,+(;;&E² ;'91&-! 9)E! .$D'-! ;9--&E! .92J! 9)E! C$+13G! +(2&! -2$$;&E²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

"1! 13&-&! '91&! 9C1&+)$$)! .+&9J-G! 0$''/! )$+F9''/! -9/-! -$F&13(),! 9'$),! 13&!

OLQHV RI  ³, P VWDUYLQJ WR GHDWK´  RU  ³&DQ \RX KHDU P\ VWRPDFK" ! 71! J&&;-! JURZOLQJVLQFH,JRWKHUH´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¶W7DLZDQHVHVKHDQGKHUIDPLO\KDGLPPLJUDWHGIURPPDLQODQG&KLQD 13&!F9M$+(1/!$C!3&+!'(C&!39%(),!.&&)!-;&)1!()!13&!N9(E(9)!Y(-1+(21!$C!R&(M(),!D3&+&! KHU HOGHUO\ SDUHQWV VWLOO UHVLGH  )RU WKDW PDWWHU VKH GRHVQ¶W OLYH ZLWKRXW KHU 35-.9)E! $+! $D&! 9)/13(),! $)! 13&! 3$5-&! 13&/! 39%&! +&2&)1'/! ;5+239-&EG! )$+! E$&-! -3&!D$+J!C5''!1(F&!'(J&!I$5(-98!!N&+!3$5+-!91!13&!+&-195+9)1!9+&!'&--!139)!C(%&!()!9!


!!! ! E9/G!M5-1!&)$5,3!-$!1391!-3&!29)!9;;'/!3&+!1(;-!9)E!.(F$)13'/!;9/23&2J-!1$!D391!! -3&! 39-! M$J(),'/! +&C&++&E! 1$! 9-! 3&+! +&9'! %$291($):! ! ;'9/(),! F93M$),! 5)1('! 13&! .5+,&$)(),!'(,31!$C!E9D)8! !

I$5(-9G! 13$5,3G! .&9+-! )$! ()D9+E! +&-&)1F&)1! $+! 3(EE&)! &)%/! 1$D9+E! 3&+!

2$KZRUNHU¶V SHUFHLYHG FDUHIUHH H[LVWHQFH HYHQ LI VKH VHFUHWO\ VXVSHFWV 0ROO\¶V 35-.9)EG!'(J&!-$!F9)/!$C!13&!F9()'9)E&+-!D3$!39%&!9'-$!.$5,31!)(2&+!+&-(E&)1(9'! 3$F&-!()!13&!%9''&/G!39E!;+$.9.'/!&F.&ZZ'&E!3(-!D9/!()1$!9!.+(,31&+!C515+&!'(%(),! 9.+$9E8! ! U$! 13&! 2$)1+9+/G! -3&! (-! ;+$5E! $C! 3$D! -3&! 39-! -19+1&E! C+&-3! ()! "F&+(29G! E$(),!D&''!91!13&!-$+1!$C!M$.!-3&!D$5'E!39%&!$)2&!13$5,31!.&)&913!3&+-&'C!.92J!()! U9(;&(²3$D! -3&! 9)E! 3&+! 35-.9)EG! D3('&! 1&F;$+9+('/! -&;9+91&E! ./! 13&! &)1(+&! .+&9E13!$C!13&!*92(C(2!$2&9)G!9+&!&923!F9J(),!3$)&-1!-92+(C(2&-!()!$+E&+!1$!-9%&!9! E&2&)1! E$D)! ;9/F&)1! C$+! 13&(+! $D)! =9)! Q9.+(&'! $+! 0$)1&+&/! *9+J! 3$5-&G! +&,9+E'&--! $C! 13&! '$)&'()&--! -3&! $C1&)! C&&'-! D(13$51! 3(F! $+! 3&+! C9F('/! $+! 3&+! C+(&)E-!)&9+./8!!"!M$.!(-!9!M$.G!-3&!39-!+&;&91&E!1$!3&+-&'CG!'(J&!9!F9)1+9G!$)!13$-&! QLJKWV ZKHQ VKH FDQ¶W VOHHS DQG KHU OHJV DFKH IURP WKH FRQVWDQW PRWLRQ RI KHU E9/-G!13&!F5-2'&-!$C!3&+!29'%&-!.5+)(),!E&&;!.&'$D!13&!-J()8!! !"#$"%#&'#%()(*+,# -(.#)"+#,(/(0##,W¶VDVPDOOSU(2&G!-3&!.&'(&%&-G!C$+!13&!+&D9+E-!1391!-5+&'/!9D9(1!3&+! DQG 6DPXHO LQ WKH \HDUV WR FRPH  $ VPDOO SULFH LQGHHG IRU KHU VRQ¶V JRRG &E5291($)! 9)E! '$),K1&+F! 39;;()&--G! 9-! D&''! 9-! 3(-! C+&&E$F! C+$F! 13&! &)C$+2&E! 2$)-2+(;1($)! $C! F('(19+/! -&+%(2&²1391! 2$F;5'-$+/! +(1&! $C! ;9--9,&! ()1$! F9)3$$E! C$+!&%&+/!3&9'13/!U9(D9)&-&!F9'&G!13&!1+9()(),!$C!/$5),!F&)!1$!C(,31!9,9()-1!9)! &>;&21&E!43()&-&!()%9-($)G!1$!E('(,&)1'/!;+$1&21!13&!(-'9)E!./!9)/!F&9)-!;$--(.'&! C+$F!13&!F9()'9)E!&)&F/!1$!D3(23!35),+/!0$''/!.&'$),-8! !

I9-1! <+(E9/²D3('&! -1+&123(),! 9)! 9+F! 1$D9+E! 13&! 2$FF5)9'! ;'911&+! $C!

URDVWHGSRUNDWWKHWDEOHµVFHQWHUWKHQSXVKLQJWKHPHDWDURXQGZLWKFKRSVWLFNV 1$! C()E!13&! .&-1! ;(&2&-! C$+! 3&+! ;'91&²0$''/!39EG! ()! 9! )$)239'9)1! F9))&+G! 9-J&E! /RXLVD  ³:K\ LVQ¶W \RXU KXVEDQG KHUH DOUHDG\"  6KRXOGQ¶W KH EH WDNLQJ FDUH RI \RXDQGWKHER\",W¶VQRQHRIP\EXVLQHVV,NQRZ%XWLWVHHPV²)$!$CC&)-&² MXVWDOLWWOHELWVWUDQJH,PHDQ\RXPDQDJHHYHU\WKLQJE\\RXUVHOIGRQ¶W\RX"´! !

³1RWHYHU\WKLQJ´/RXLVDVDLGKHVLWDQWO\³0\KXV.9)E!&9+)-!9!,$$E!D9,&!


!#!! ! 91!13&!;$D&+!2$F;9)/G!-$!3(-! ()2$F&!3&';-! 5-!$51!$)!13(-!&)EG!1$$8!!7C!3&!29F&! RYHUQRZLWZRXOGQµWEHHDV\IRUKLPWRILQGZRUNWKDWSD\VDVJRRGFHUWDLQO\QRW! WKHVDPHNLQGRIZRUN$Q\ZD\,WKLQNLW¶VEHWWHUOLNHWKLVIRU!DZKLOH´! !

³'RQ¶W\RXHYHUUHJUHWOHDYLQJ"0D\EH\RXFRXOG¶YHVWD\HGSXWDQGGRQH

ZHOOIRU\RXUVHOILQ7DLZDQULJKW"´! !

I$5(-9! -19+&E! ()1$! 3&+! .$D'! $C! +(2&! D(13! 9! '$),G! F&E(191(%&! ,9Z&G! 9-! (C!

-&9+23(),! C$+! 9)! 9)-D&+! ()! 9! 2+/-19'! .9''8! ! T5-3(),! C$+D9+EG! 13&)G! '(J&! 13&! 2+(--2+$--(),! '9)2&-! $C! $;;$-(),! 9+F(&-G! 2$)C'(21(),! 13$5,31-! D+&-1'&E! .92J! 9)E! C$+13! D(13()! 3&+! F()EG! ;+$F;1'/! L5&''&E! ./! 13&! -$C1K-;$J&)G! 9--&+1(%&! ;$D&+! $C! KHURZQYRLFH³1R´VKHILQDOO\VDLG³QRUHJUHWV´! !

³1HYHUPLQG´VDLG0ROO\!D9%(),!3&+!23$;-1(2J-!()!C+$)1!$C!3&+!C92&!D3('&!

FKHZLQJ³,WDONWRRPXFK´! !

³,W¶VRND\´!

!

=F('(),!;$'(1&'/G!I$5(-9!C&'1!+&'(&%&E!D3&)!0$''/!-1$;;&E!9-J(),!L5&-1($)-8!!

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¶V VHOILVK .&39%($+²3(-! -5-;&21&E! ()C(E&'(1(&-G! 3(-! &%9-(%&)&--G! 3(-! 9.('(1/! 1$! F9J&! 3&+! C&&'! '$%&E!D3('&!91!13&!-9F&!1(F&!-&&J(),!13&!9CC&21($)-!$C!%9+($5-!D$F&)8!!=F9''!19'J! LVXVHOHVVVKHWKHQZDQWHGWRZKLVSHULQ0ROO\¶VHDU0\SODWHLVQ¶W\RXUSODWH DQGP\EXVLQHVVLVQ¶W\RXUEXVLQHVV! !

[&1!9-(E&!C+$F!.+(&C!()1&+921($)-!D(13!0$''/!9)E!13&!C'$$+!F9)9,&+G!I$5(-9!

39+E'/! -;&9J-! 1$! 13&! $13&+-! 5)'&--! (1! (-! +&L5(+&E! $C! 3&+! 1$! E$! -$8! ! =3&! .+(),-! 9! %925$5-! E&F&9)$+! 1$! 13&! -19+1! $C! 3&+! -3(C1! 9)E! 29++(&-! (1! 5)1('! 13&! &)EG! 9'D9/-! ;&+C$+F(),! 3&+! 19-J-! &CC(2(&)1'/G! 9)E! 13&)! 3&9E-! 3$F&! D(13$51! -9/(),! ,$$E./&8!! U$! -$F&! $C! 13&! D9(1! -19CCG! -3&! 2$F&-! $CC! 9-! E(-19)1! 9)E! 5)C+(&)E'/G! 9)E! ()!!!!!!!!!!!!!


!$% ! 49)1$)&-&G! 1391! Q59),Z3$5! +&,($)! E(9'&21! -3&! 29)! .9+&'/! E(-2&+)! 9)E! 39-! )&%&+! '(J&E! 13&! -$5)E! $CG! 13&/! 39%&! J(EE&E! D(13()! &9+-3$1! 1391! (C! -3&! D&+&! -&)1! C'/(),! OLNH D URFNHW LQWR RXWHU VSDFH VKH ZRXOG SUREDEO\ H[WLQJXLVK WKH VXQ¶V ZDUPWK R51G! ()! +&9'(1/G! (1! (-! -(F;'/! 3&+! ()9.('(1/! 1$! &),9,&! 13&(+! '9),59,&! D&''! 1391! 39-! 2+&91&E!13&!E(-19)2&G!3&+!()9E&L591&!,+9-;!$C!V),'(-3!9)E!49)1$)&-&!1391!&>1&)E-! RQO\ DV IDU DV WKH LWHPV OLVWHG RQ WKH UHVWXDUXDQWµV PHQX  7KHUH DUH DOVR WKRVH 9DJD9+EG!C+5-1+91(),!F$F&)1-!D3&)!9!9)!V),'(-3K-;&9J(),!25-1$F&+!;+&--&-!3&+! IRUVRPHWKLQJVKHFDQ¶WXQGHUVWDQGDOWKRXJKHYHQWKHQ/RXLVDVWLOOPDQDJHV!1$! +&F9()! D$$E&)G! -$F&1(F&-! -2+(..'(),! +9)E$F! F9+J-! ()! 3&+! )$1&;9E! 9-! (C! C$''$D(),! &%&+/! ()2$F;+&3&)-(.'&! D$+EG! .&C$+&! 9.$51KC92(),! 1$! ,$! 9-J! 13&! C'$$+! F9)9,&+!<+9)2(-!C$+!9--(-19)2&8! !

³%RVV´  VKH FDOOV )UDQFLV ZKR ZDV ERUQ LQ +RQJ .RQJ EXW UDLVHG DQG

&GXFDWHGLQ/RV$QJHOHV³%RVV´VKHVD\VXVXDOO\ILQGLQJKLPLQWKHIR\HUZKHUH KHJUHHWVWKHFXVWRPHUV³,¶PKDYLQJWURXEOHJHWWLQJDQRUGHUGRZQ´! !

Y+&--&E! (FF925'91&'/! ()! 9! .'92J! -5(1! D(13! 9! 2'(;K$)! .$D! 1(&G! )9++$DK

-3$5'E&+&E!9)E!19''G!<+9)2(-!)&%&+!9;;&9+-!.$13&+&E!D3&)!-3&!-&&J-!3(F!$518!!7)! C921G! 3&! )&%&+! 9;;&9+-! C'5-1&+&E! ./! 9)/$)&! $+! 9)/13(),G! )$EE(),! 9)E! -F('(),! 9F(E-1! 13&! D$+-1! $C! -(1591($)-²$.M&21($)-! $C! ;$$+! -&+%(2&! 9)E! .9E'/! 2$$J&E! HQWUHHV D GLVK LQDGYHUWHQWO\ GXPSHG RQ D FXVWRPHU¶V ODS 13&! ()C+&L5&)1! -L59..'&! 9F$),! C9F('(&-! $+! '$%&+-! 1391! .&2$F&-! 1$$! %$29'²9.-&)1'/! +5..(),! 91! 13&! .9)E! $C! R5EE3(-1! ;+9/&+! .&9E-! $)! 3(-! +(,31! D+(-1! E5+(),! -523! 5);'&9-9)1! 2(+25F-19)2&-8!!R&(),!9!-&&F(),'/!2$)1&)1!.923&'$+!;9-1!13&!9,&!$C!C$+1/G!3(-!'&9)! .5('E! -5,,&-1-! 1391! 3&! D9123&-! D391! 3&! &91-! 1$! 9! C95'1G! 9)E! D3('&! )$1! 91! 9''! &CC&F()91&G! 3&! 39-! 9! -$C1! F9))&+! $C! -;&9J(),! 9)E! 9! ,&)1'&! E(-;$-(1($)8! ! N(-! &/&.+$D-!9+&!)&91!9)E!%&+/!13()G!9-!13$5,3!13&/!39E!.&&)!29+&C5''/!E+9D)!$)!3(-! C92&!D(13!9!C&'1K1(;!F9+J&+8!!N(-!-3()/G!-F$$13!-29';!-3$D-!)$!1+92&!$C!39(+G!9)E! 3(-!'$),G!9,('&!.$E/!F9)&5%&+-!C'5(E'/!9.$51!13&!+&-195+9)1²'(J&!9!+$%(),!;9-1$+! $%&+-&&(),!13&!2$FF5)($)!$C!3(-!-&91&EG!9.-$+.&E!;9+(-3($)&+-8!!! !

U$!)$!-F9''!E&,+&&G!<+9)2(-!+5)-!13&!&)1(+&!+&-195+9)1!./!3(F-&'CG!9)E!39-!

E$)&!-$!C$+!13&!'9-1!&(,31!/&9+-!-()2&!13&!$D)&+G!0+8!43$DG!39E!;9--&E!9D9/8!!")E!


!&% ! ZKLOH 0U &KRZ¶V ZLGRZ LV QRZ WKH VROH SURSULHWRU²F9))(),! 13&! 29-3! +&,(-1&+! &%&+/! E9/! 9)E! &%&+/! &%&)(),G! J&&;(),! 9! 2'$-&! D9123! $)! 13&! E9('/! &9+)(),-²-3&! OHDYHV DOO RWKHU DVSHFWV RI WKH EXVLQHVV WR )UDQFLV¶ FDUH WUXVWLQJ KLP DERYH 9)/$)&!&'-&8!!V%&)!9-!9!)&D!&F;'$/&&G!I$5(-9!)$1(2&E!13&!-;&2(9'!.$)E!.&1D&&)! 13&!1D$G!9'F$-1!'(J&!F$13&+!9)E!-$)8!!B(13!,+9/!39(+!E/&E!M&1K.'92J!$)!9!F&'$)K -(Z&E! 3&9EG! 9)E! )&%&+! C9('(),! 1$! .&1+9/! 9! C$)E)&--! C$+! E$5.'&KJ)(1! ;$'/&-1&+! E+&--&-! 1391! 9+&! 1$$! -)5,! 9,9()-1! 3&+! 235../! C$+FG! 0+-8! 43$D! (-! 9! ()2$FF5)(291(%&! D$F9)! D3$! F$-1'/! $;&)-! 3&+! F$513! D3&)! 19J(),! ;3$)&K()! $+E&+-!$+!13&!$229-($)9'!+&-&+%91($)8!![&1!D3&+&!<+9)2(-!(-!2$)2&+)&EG!I$5(-9!39-! $.-&+%&E! C+$F! 9C9+! 13&! ()1(F91&! F9))&+! ()! D3(23! 0+-8! 43$D! -5FF$)-! 3(F! 2'$-&+G! ,+())(),! 91! M5-1! 3(F! 9)E! 3(F! 9'$)&G! D3(-;&+(),! -$F&13(),! E(-2+&&1'/! 9-! 3&+!C(),&+-!;91!$)&!$C!3(-!F9)(25+&E!39)E-8! !

U3&! C$)E)&--! (-! 5)E&+-19)E9.'&G! I$5(-9! 39-! 13$5,318! ! U3&+&! (-! 9! )915+9'!

D9+F13! 9.$51! <+9)2(-G! 9! -1&9E()&--! 1391! ;51-! ;&$;'&! 91! &9-&8! ! ")E! -3&! 29)! 9'-$! 5)E&+-19)E!D3/!0+-8!43$D!D$5'E!C&&'!()2'()&E!1$!1$523!3(-!39)E-²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³1RSUREOHP,¶OOWDNHFDUHRILW ()!9!-&2$)E8!!B3(23!19EOHLVLW"´! !

U3(-!&%&)(),G!3$D&%&+G!(1!D9-!<+9)2(-!D3$!39E!-$5,31!$51!I$5(-9G!29''(),!

3&+! M5-1! 9C1&+! -3&! D3(ZZ&E! ;9-1! 3(F! ()! 13&! C$/&+²3&+! ;5+-&! -D(),(),! C+$F! 9! -3$5'E&+G!3&+!9;+$)!.5)23&E!()!9!C(-1!9-!-3&!+5-3&E!1$!29123!13&!)&>1!.5-!3$F&² 3(-!-$C1!%$(2&!C9('(),!1$!+&923!3&+!.&C$+&!-3&!39-1('/!&>(1&E!13+$5,3!13&!&)1+9)2&! GRRUV  ³/RXLVD´  KH UHSHDWHG SXUVXLQJ KHU RXWVLGH ZKHUH VKH WXUQHG ZLWK D VWDUWOHGH[SUHVVLRQ6KHKDGQ¶WSUHYLRXVO\HQFRXQWHUHGKLPEH\RQGWKHFRQILQHV $C!13&(+!D$+J;'92&G!9)E!-19)E(),!13&+&!$)!13&!-(E&D9'J²9D9-3!()!13&!C'91!'5-1&+!$C!


!'! ! ;9+J(),! '$1! '(,31-G! )&9+! 29-19D9/! 2(,9+&11&! .511-G! -)$11/! -;'911&+-! $C! -;(1G! 9)E! C'911&)&E!;(&2&-!$C!E(-29+E&E!,5F²3&!D9-!+&F$%&E!C+$F!13&!2'&9)!&)%(+$)-!1391! -5(1&E!3(F]!'92J(),!13&!;+$;&+!2$)1&>1!$C!1HZ.DQJ.DQJ¶VEXUQLVKHGLQWHULRUKH '$$J&E! 9-! 13$5,3! 3&! D&+&! 9! 3$5-&K1$K3$5-&! ()-5+9)2&! -9'&-F9)G! $+G! D$+-&G! 13&! 1/;&!1391!35-1'&E!,(+'-!13+$5,3!9!3(,3KHQGHVFRUWVHUYLFH³,¶YHJRWVRPHWKLQJWR VKRZ\RX´KHVDLGVXGGHQO\ZDONLQJEDFN WRZDUGWKHHQ1+9)2&!9)E!F$1($)(),! IRUKHUWRIROORZ³&RPHRYHUKHUHDVHFRQG´! !

3UHVHQWO\ VKH VWRRG ULJKW EHVLGH KLP LQ IURQW RI WKH UHVWDXUDQW¶V

D()E$D;9)&! E$$+-G! D9123(),! 9-! 3&! -'(E! 9! C(),&+! 9+$5)E! 9! -(),'&! 39)ED+(11&)! )$1(2&!1391!39E!.&&)!19;&E!9,9()-1!13&!()-(E&!,'9--8!!=3&!;&&+&E!2'$-&+G!-L5()1(),G! H[FHSW VKH FRXOGQ¶W UHDG PXFK (QJOLVK DQG DV D UHVXOW WKH PHDQLQJ RI WKH 9E%&+1(-&F&)1!D9-!'$-1!$)!3&+8! !

³0XVLFQLJKWDW1HZ.DQJ.DQJWKLV6XQGD\´KHVDLGWUDQVODWLQJIRUKHU

3(-! C(),&+! 13&)! 5)E&+'()(),! 13&! -&QWHQFHV RI WKH QRWLFH DV KH VSRNH  ³(QMR\ D D$)E&+C5'! E())&+! 1$! 13&! &)239)1(),! -1/'(),-! $C! 9D9+EKD())(),! %($'()! %(+15$-$! =9F5&'! 4358! ! R+(),! 13&! &)1(+&! C9F('/8! ! #$! 9EF(--($)! +&L5(+&E8! ! *&+C$+F9)2&-! EHJLQDWSP6XQGD\$SULOWK&DOOIRUUHVHUYDWLRQV´! !

"1!9!'$--!C$+!D$+E-G!-3&!,'9)2&E!91!3(FG!C&&'(),!9!J)$1!$C!E+&9E!C$+F(),!()!

3&+!-1$F923G!9)E!F9)9,&E!9!1()/!,+()8!!")E!/&1G!9-!13&!J)$1!1(,31&)&EG!-3&!39E!)$! +&9-$)! 1$! .&! 19J&)! 9.92J8! ! \)! 13&! F$+)(),! -3&! D9-! 3(+&EG! <+9)2(-! 39E! 9'+&9E/! .+$5,31! 5;! 13&! (E&9! $C! =9F5&'! ;'9/(),! 91! 13&! +&-195+9)1G! .51! 1391! D9-! 13+&&! F$)13-!9,$G!9)EG!-()2&!13&)G!)$13(),!C5+13&+!D9-!-9(E8!!N$D&%&+G!-$F&D3&+&!()! KHUPLQGVKHDOZD\VVXVSHFWHGWKDWKHUVRQ¶VYLROLQSOD\LQJZDVZK\VKHJRWWKH M$.8! !

Y5+(),! 3&+! ()1&+%(&DG! (1! D9-! <+9)2(-! D3$! 39E! ;$'(1&'/G! 9'13$5,3!

LQGLIIHUHQWO\ H[SODLQHG KH ZDVQ¶W WRR LQWHUHVWHG LQ KLULQJ VRPHRQH WKDW ODFNHG ;+&%($5-! D9(1+&--(),! &>;&+(&)2&G! -$F&$)&! 1391G! 5;$)! +&9'(Z(),! 13&! E&F9)E-! $C! 13&!M$.G!D$5'E!'(J&'/!L5(18!!7)!F$-1!29-&-!-523!9!2$FF&)1!D$5'E!()E(291&!13&!&)E! $C!13&!()1&+%(&DG!9)E!+(-(),!C+$F!3&+!-&91G!15,,(),!91!3&+!-J(+1G!I$5(-9!D$5'E!39%&! H[FXVHGKHUVHOI,QVWHDGKH¶GJRQHRQWRDVNDERXWKHUEDFNJURXQGKHUSHUVRQDO


!(! ! 3(-1$+/8! ! =$²D(13()! 3(-! -F9''! $CC(2&G! 9-! 3(-! 39)E-! +&-1&E! $)! 13&! E&-J²-3&! 39E! $.'(,&E!3(F8! !

=&E91&'/!.51!1$!13&!;$()1G!-3&!-;$J&!.+(&C'/!$C!3&+!'(C&!()!U9(;&(G!3&+!E&-(+&!

C$+! 9)! "F&+(29)! &E5291($)! C$+! 3&+! -$)G! 9)E! D391! 3&+! 35-.9)E! E(E! C$+! 9! '(%(),8!! =3&!1$'E!3(F!13&/!D&+&!-9%(),!1$!.5/!9!3$5-&8!!U3&!D3$'&!1(F&!3&!J&;1!3(-!,9Z&! C(>&E! $)! 3&+G! -9/(),! '(11'&G! 3(-! 39)E-! )&%&+! -3(C1(),8! ! U3&)G! ()! ;9--(),G! -3&! PHQWLRQHGKHUVRQ¶VVNLOOZLWKWKHYLROLQDQGKRZSULRUWRPRYLQJWRWKH6WDWHV =9F5&'!39E!D$)!-&%&+9'!2$F;&1(1(%&!1+$;3(&-!9)E!+(..$)-!.&295-&!$C!3(-!19'&)18!!! !

³1RZWKDW¶VIDQWDVWLF´)UDQFLVVDLGUDLVLQJKLVKDQGVDQGFODVSLQJWKHP

WRJHWKHU  ³<RX PXVW EH YHU\ SURXG³  $V LI D EULJKW OLJKW KDG VXGGHQO\ EHHQ 15+)&E!$)!()-(E&!3(-!3&9EG!13&!5)+&9E9.'&!C929E&!3&!D$+&!D9-!&2'(;-&E!./!9!C92&! WKDW VPLOHG ZDUPO\ DW KHU  ³<RX NQRZ 7!5-&E! 1$! ;'9/! 13&! %($'()!F/-&'CG! 9! '$),G! ORQJ WLPH DJR  1RZDGD\V , UHJUHW , GLGQ¶W NHHS DW LW EXW , GRQµW WKLQN , ZDV .'&--&E! D(13! 13&! +(,31! 19'&)1²QRW \RXU VRQµV NLQG RI WDOHQW DQ\ZD\´  $V LW 39;;&)&EG! 3&! D&)1! $)! 1$! -9/G! 13&! )$1($)! $C! 3(+(),! 9! %($'()(-1! 1$! ;'9/! 91! 13&! +&-195+9)1G! $)2&! $+! 1D(2&! 9! D&&JG! D9-! -$F&13(),! 3&! 39E! -&+($5-'/! &)1&+19()&E8!! ³'R \RX WKLQN SRVVLEO\ \RX DQG \RXU VRQ ZRXOG EH LQWHUHVWHG"´  6RPHZKDW 2$)C5-&E!./!13&!L5&-1($)G!5)-5+&!$C!D3&13&+!-3&!$+!=9F5&'!D9-! .&(),!$CC&+&E!9! ;$-(1($)G! -3&! )$EE&E! D(13$51! -;&9J(),8! ! B(13! 1391G! 3&! +&923&E! 92+$--! 13&! E&-JG! VKDNLQJ KHU KDQG  ³*UHDW´ KH VDLG ORRNLQJ VWUDLJKW DW KHU  ³/HW PH VKRZ \RX DURXQG´! !

%XW XQWLO WKLV HYHQLQJ /RXLVD KDGQ¶W WKRXJKW PXFK DERXW WKHLU HDUOLHU

2$)%&+-91($)8!!=19)E(),!$51-(E&!13&!+&-195+9)1!D(13!3(FG!;$()1(),!91!13&!)$1(2&!$)! 13&! E$$+G! 3&+! 3$9+-&G! ,+91&C5'KVRXQGLQJ YRLFH VDLG  ³<RX QHHGQ W JR WR WKLV WURXEOH´  ZKHQ LQ WUXWK KLV LQWHQWLRQV KDG EHHQ VR RYHU]HDORXV WKDW LW &F.9++9--&E!3&+8! !

³$QGEHIRUH,IRUJHW´)UDQFLVFRQWLQXHG³WKHVHDUHIRU\RX´+HKHOGXS

DSKRWRFRSLHGVWDFNRI´[´IOLHUVWKDWKHµGEHHQKROGLQJGLVFUHHWO\DWKLVVLGH '(J&!9!-5+;+(-&!,(C1G!D+(11&)!./!3(-!$D)!39)E!()!.$13!43()&-&!9)E!V),'(-3G!9!%($'()! 9)E!.$D!E+9D)!91!&923!2$+)&+!$C!13&!SDJH³<RX29)!,(%&!13&-&!1$!9''!/$5+!C+(&)E-!!


!)% ! DQGUHODWLYHV,W¶OOKHOSVSUHDGWKHZRUGDERXWKLVSHUIRUPDQFHDQGDQ\RQHZLWK 9!C'(&+!,&1-!9!C+&&!/59)!/9),!$+!(2&E!1&9!$C!13&(+!23$(2&!$)!=5)E9/8!!09J&!-5+&!/$5! WHOOWKHPWKDW´! !

³2K´VKH!-9(EG!-19+(),!91!13&!C'(&+-8!!^)9.'&!1$!F9J&!-&)-&!$C!13&!V),'(-3!

-&21($)G!-3&!+&9E!13&!2$++&-;$)E(),!43()&-&!239+921&+-!D(13!&9-&²13&!F&--9,&!$C! 13&!C'(&+!F(++$+(),!D391!3&!39E!1$'E!3&+!D9-!E(-;'9/&E!91!13&!&)1+9)2&8!!!! !

³6RXQGRND\"´!

!

#$1!L5(1&!-5+&!(C! 9!=5)E9/!+&2(19'!D9-!+&9''/!13&!.&-1! (E&9G! -3&! )$EE&E!()!

DJUHHPHQWQHYHUWKHOHVVHYHQZKLOHVD\LQJ³,GRQ¶WNQRZ,PHDQLW¶VVREXV\RQ 6XQGD\VDOZD\VVRSDFNHG0D\EH7KXUVGD\LQVWHDGWKLQJVDUHVORZHU´! !

N&+!D$+E-!-&&F&E!1$! -)9;!3(F!C+$F!3(-!&)135-(9-1(2!-191&]!3(-!C(),&+1(;-!

F$%&E! 1$! 1$523! 3(-! E&%$1($)9'! .&9E-G! 13&! 2+&9-&-! $)! 3(-! C$+&3&9E! ,+&D! E&&;&+8!! ³1RQR7KXUVGD\LVQ¶WDVJRRG´KHVDLGDIWHUDPRPHQWRIFRQVLGHUDWLRQ³:H ,&1! 9! '9+,&! E())&+! 2+$DE! $)! =5)E9/! &%&)(),-G! 235+23,$&+-! 9)E! 13&! +&1(+&E! -&18!! ,¶PVXUHWKH\¶GHQMR\WKHLUPHDOVDFFRPSDQLHGE\\RXUVRQ¶VSOD\LQJDQGZHFDQ XVH DQ HPSW\ SLWFKHU IRU KLV WLS MDU  6R ,¶OO JHW DQ DUHD VHW XS IRU KLP E\ WKH OREVWHUWDQNEHFDXVHWKHQKH¶OOEHLQIXOOYLHZRIHYHU\RQH´$OODWRQFHKHVP('&EG! C'9-3(),!3(-!5))915+9''/!D3(1&!1&&13G!E$(),!-$!()!13&!F$-1!-()2&+&!9)E!,&)(9'!D9/! SRVVLEOHWKHQKHVDLG³,W¶OODGGDOLWWOHVRPHWKLQJVSHFLDOWRWKHSODFHGRQµW\RX WKLQN"3OXVLW¶OOEHHQMR\DEOHIRUPHWRR$QGLILWJRHVZHOOZHFDQGRLW&%&+/! ZHHNKRZµVWKDW"´! !

7KHUH ZDVQ¶W UHDOO\ DQ\WKLQJ HOVH /RXLVD IHOW VKH FRXOG VD\ RWKHU WKDQ

PXVWHULQJDUHVHUYHGVWLOWHG³7KDQN\RX´! !

#$+!E(E!-3&!C&&'!13&!5+,&!1$!E&2'()&!D391!D9-G!9C1&+!9''G!9!J()E!,&-15+&!$)!

3(-! ;9+1G! -$F&13(),! 1391! F(,31! .&! .$13! ;$-(1(%&! 9)E! .&)&C(2(9'! C$+! 3&+G! =9F5&'G! 9)E!13&!+&-195+9)18!!R51!39E!2$F;'&1&!&>395-1($)!)$1!-$!13$+$5,3'/!2'9(F&E!3&+G! -3&! F(,31! 39%&! 39E! 13&! ;+&-&)2&! $C! F()E! 1$! +&C5-&! 13&! -192J! $C! C'(&+-G! -(F;'/! EHFDXVH VKH GLGQ¶W NQRZ ZKDW WR GR ZLWK WKHP  QRQ&! $C! 3&+! 2'$-&! C+(&)E-! $+! C9F('/! F&F.&+-! D&+&! ()! 13&! 2$5)1+/8! ! =1(''G! -3&! 922&;1&E! 13&! C'(&+-! 9)/D9/G! UHWXUQLQJ)UDQFLV¶VPLOHHYHQWKRXJKKHUWKRXJKWVZHUHDOUHDG\IDUIURPZRUN!


!*% ! DQWLFLSDWLQJ WKH EDWK VKH¶G WDNH WKH VDWLVI\LQJ PHDO VKH¶G FRRN IRU KH+-&'CG! 9)E! WKHYLGHRWDSHVRIGXEEHG-DSDQHVHVRDSRSHUDVVKH¶GZDWFKZKLOHUHOD[LQJRQWKH '(%(),!+$$F!2$5238! !

³7KDQN\RX³/RXLVDVDLGDJDLQJODQFLQJDWKHUZDWFK7KHEXVKDGFRPH

DQGJRQHDQGWKHQH[WRQHZRXOGQ¶WDUULYHIRUDQRWKHUILIWHHQWRWZHQW/!F()51&-8!! %XW VKH GLGQ¶W IURZQ  6KH ZDV WRR WLUHG  0RVW GD\V VKH UHPLQGHG KHUVHOI DUH '(J&!13(-8! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !


! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ?_A! ! #$D! C92(),! 9! /&''$DK1('&E! D9''! 2$%&+&E! $%&+! D(13! ,+&9-&K-;911&+&E! -L59+&-! $C! 9'5F()5F! C$('G! I$5(-9! F9J&-! E())&+! ()! 3&+! J(123&)²;&+-;(+(),! )&9+! 9! .5..'(),! ;$1! $C! ,+$5)E! ;$+J! -1&DG! &%&+/! -$! $C1&)! 5-(),! 13&! .92J! $C! 3&+! 39)E! 1$! D(;&! 3&+! C$+&3&9E²9)E! -1(+! C+(&-! &,,-! 9)E! 1$F91$&-! $)! 9! F&--/! -1$%&1$;! '()&E! ./! F$+&! IRLO WKH DOXPLQXP VKHHWV FRDWHG E\ WKH RLO\ UHPQDQWV RI IRXU PRQWK¶V ZRUWK RI 3&+!2$$J(),8!!=$$)!13&!2$)1&)1-!$C!13&!D$J!9+&!-2+9;&E!()1$!9!.$D'!9)E!-&1!$)!13&! 2$5)1&+8! ! U3&)! 23$;;&E! ,9+'(2! 9)E! C+&-3! -;()923! 9+&! 9EE&E! 1$! 13&! D$JG! (FF&E(91&'/! -(ZZ'(),! 9-! 3&+! D$$E&)! -;915'9! .&,()-! -1(++(),8! ! R+&913(),! ()! 13&! 3&91G!13&!9+$F9-!D9C1(),!5;!91!3&+G!-3&!39-!-5FF$)&E!3&+!23('E3$$E!.51!E$&-)H1! C5''/!+&9'(Z&!(18!!U3&!-1&9F(),!$E$+-!-3&!()39'&-²13&!F&9'!-3&!(-!F9J(),G!13&!D$J! (1-&'C²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

³6KXQJK\R´/RXLVDHYHQWXDOO\FDOOVRXWZKHQWUDQVIHUULQJWKHVSLQDFKDQG

JDUOLFWRDSODWH³'LQQHU´! !

=(11(),! 2+$--K'&,,&E! ()! 13&! F(EE'&! $C! 13&! '(%(),! +$$F! C'$$+G! 2$F;'&1&'/!!!!!!


##!! ! 9.-$+.&E!./!D391!13&! U`!+9E(91&-G!=9F5&'!23$$-&-!)$1!1$!3&9+!3&+8!!`&+,(),!$)! '95,31&+!9)E!D(13!3(-!'(;-!;9+1&EG!3&!29)H1!'$$J!9D9/!C+$F!9)!&;(-$E&!$C! 1*-&23# 4*++(/'G! &-;&2(9''/! D3('&! =1&%&! ^+J&'! ,$%&+)-! 13&! -2+&&):! ! 1391! -;9-F$E(2G! -$2(9''/! 9DJD9+E! .'92J! 1&&)9,&+! D&9+(),! '9+,&G! 13(2J! ,'9--&-G! 3(,3KD91&+! ;9)1-G! -5-;&)E&+-G!9!F5'1(K2$'$+&E!29+E(,9)!-D&91&+G!9)E!D3$!19'J-!()!9!-)$+1(),G!3(,3K ;(123&E! 922&)18! ! N&! ;9/-! )$! 911&)1($)! 1$! I$5(-9! 9-! -3&! 2$F&! 9)E! ,$&-²9)! ()E(-1()21!C$+F!F$%(),!9'$),!13&!&E,&!$C!3(-!;&+(;3&+9'!-(,31G!29++/(),!.$D'-!9)E! ;'91&-! $C! C$$E! 1$! 13&! $;&)! E()(),! +$$F! 9+&9²5)1('! 13&! %$'5F&! $C! 3&+! %$(2&! ()2+&9-&-G!13&!1$)&!+&,(-1&+(),!9-!9!D9+)(),!+913&+!139)!9!;+$F;1(),8! !

³'LQQHU<RXKHDUPH"´!

!

³2ND\´KHDQVZHUVPHHNO\IURZQLQJDOORIDVXGGHQ!

!

aU5+)!(1!$CC!9)E!2$F&!&918a!

!

\)2&!3&!M$()-!3&+!91!13&!E()(),!19.'&G!-3&!39-!9'+&9E/!-2$$;&E!+(2&!C$+!3(FG!

39-! '9(E! 3(-! 23$;-1(2J-! )&91'/! 5;$)! 13&! +(F! $C! 3(-! .$D'8! ! R51! &%&+/! )(,31! (-! '(J&! 1$)(,31]! 13&/! -(1! 92+$--! C+$F! &923! $13&+²13+&&! $+! C$5+! E(-3&-! $C! C$$E! .&1D&&)! 13&FG!9!+(2&!2$$J&+!$225;/(),!9!-;$1!91!13&!19.'&!D3&+&!3(-!C913&+!D$5'E!)$+F9''/! 39%&!.&&)!C$5)E²&91(),!()!-('&)2&!-9%&!C$+!13$-&!F$F&)1-!D3&)!I$5(-9G!)$1(2(),! 1391!=9F5&'H-!.$D'!(-!9'F$-1!&F;1/G!,&-15+&-!3&+!23$;-1(2J-!91!9!E(-3G!9)E!-9/-!1$! KLP³(DWWKLV´<HVWHUGD\LWZDVOHHNDQGVKUHGGHGSRUNQRZLWLVWKHVSLQDFK 9)E!,9+'(28!!! !

³0P´KHUHSOLHVQRGGLQJZLWKKLVPRXWKIXOORIULFHDQGQHYHUUHVLVWLQJ

3&+!2$FF9)E-G!3&!9EE-!9!-&2$)E!-&+%(),!$C!-;()923!1$!3(-!.$D'8! !

"C1&+! 9! D3('&G! -3&! 9(F-! 3&+! 23$;-1(2J-! 91! D391! +&F9()-! $C! 13&! -1(+KC+(&E!

HJJVDQGWRPDWRHV³)LQLVKLW´! !

³0P´!

!

")EG! $C! 2$5+-&G! 3&! E$&-! &>921'/! 9-! -3&! -9/-G! J&&;(),! 3(-! 3&9E! '$D&+&E! ()!

$+E&+! 1$! 9%$(E! &/&! 2$)19218! ! V>2&;1G! 1$)(,31G! 13&+&! (-! F$+&! 139)! E())&+! $)! 3(-! F()EG!F$+&!139)!9!E&-(+&!1$!2$)-5F&!3(-!F&9'!L5(2J'/!-$!3&!29)!+&15+)!1$!13&!U`]! 13&+&!(-G!3&!.&'(&%&-G!-$F&13(),!(F;$+19)1!1391!F5-1!.&!9EE+&--&E8!!U3&)!D(13!9! C9(+! E&,+&&! $C! 9;;+&3&)-($)G! =9F5&'! ;(2J-! 3(-! D$+E-! 29+&C5''/G! D&(,3(),! 13&F!!!!


#$! ! EHIRUHDVNLQJ³0DFDQ,JHWDSDLURIUROOHUEODGHV"´+HVQHDNVDORRNDWKHUDQG -&&-!1391!-3&G!1$$G!39-!3&+!3&9E!'$D&+&EG!25;;(),!3&+!2&+9F(2!.$D'!()!$)&!39)E8! !

³:KDWUROOHUEODGHV"´!

!

V)2$5+9,&E! 1391! 9! L5&-1(RQ ZDV RIIHUHG DQG QRW DQ HPSKDWLF ³1R´

=9F5&'! +9(-&-! 3(-! 23()! D3('&! -&11(),! 3(-! .$D'! 9)E! 23$;-1(2J-! E$D)8!! ³5ROOHUEODGHV²\RXNQRZZLWKIRXUZKHHOV´! !

I(C1(),! 3&+! 3&9E! 9)E! +&923(),! C$+! 13&! -$/! -952&G! -3&! ,(%&-! 3(F! 9! -D(C1G!

GHWDFKHGJODQFH³:KDWIRU"´! !

N(-! F$513! $;&)-! -'(,31'/G! D9)1(),! 1$! +&;'/G! .51! )$13(),! 2$F&-! $518!!

,QVWHDG KH ZDWFKHV KHU GULEEOH VR\ VDXFH LQWR KHU ERZO DQG ZKHQ VKH¶V GRQH I$5(-9!-19+&-!-1+9(,31!91!3(F8!!N&!)$D!C&&'-!3&+!()-5CC(2(&)1!;91(&)2&!D9)(),G!13&! 9))$/9)2&!.&)&913!3&+!-J()!D9(1(),!1$!&F&+,&8! !

³+RZPXFK"´!

!

³,GRQ¶WNQRZ´KHVD\VTXLHWO\!

!

I$5(-9! )$E-G! 3&+! &>;+&--($)! 5)239),&E! 9-! (C! -3&! 39E! 9)1(2(;91&E! 3(-!

UHVSRQVH³<RXQHHGDQHZERZIRUWKHYLROLQQR"<RXGRQµWQHHGUROOHUEODGHV´! !

")E! 1391G! =9F5&'! +&9'(Z&-G! (-! 13&! &)E! $C! (18! ! U3&+&! D$5'E! .&! )$! 39'C!

922&;19.'&!2$F;+$F(-&!13(-!1(F&²)$1!'(J&!'9-1!F$)13!D3&)!3&!9-J&E!3&+!1$!.5/! WKHPDGRJDQGZDVWROG³$FLW\LVQRSODFHIRUDGRJ6KXQJK/$8!!Y$,-!)&&E!9!'$1! $C!-;92&8!!7!13()J!9!F$5-&!D(''!F9J&!9!.&11&+!;&1!3&+&G!E$)H1!\RX"´+HORZHUVKLV 3&9E!9,9()!9)E!+&-5F&-!&91(),G!'(-1&)(),!9-!-3&!13&)!239),&-!13&!-5.M&21G!-1&&+(),! 3(-! +&L5&-1! 1$D9+E! 1391! ()&%(19.'&! '(19)/! .+$5,31! $)! ./! 3(-! ;&+2&(%&E! C9('(),-! $+! )&&E'&--! D9)1-G! 9)E! /&1G! 9-! (1! (-! +&;&91&E! 1$! 3(F! '(J&! 9)! $%&+E5&! -2$'E(),G! (-! 92159''/!5)+&'91&E!1$!&(13&+8! !

³$OOGD\\RXWKLQNDERXWIXQ´VKHVD\VDGPRQLVKLQJKLPZLWKDVKDNHRI

KHUFKRSVWLFNV³<RXDOUHDG\IRUJHWHYHU\WKLQJ\RXUIDWKHUWROG\RXGLGQµW\RX" [$5!-3$5'E!C$25-!$)!F&F$+(Z(),!13&!%$29.5'9+/G!9)E!;+921(2(),!%($'()8!!"-J! F&! C$+!+$''&+.'9E&-8!![$5!J)$D!3$D!F523!F$)&/!7!-;&)E!$)!/$5+!'&--$)-b!!V)$5,3! WREX\XVDKRXVH'R\RXNQRZWKDW"´! !

<&&'(),! 9-! 13$5,3! 3(-! .$E/! (-! -3+()J(),G! =9F5&'! ,(%&-! 3&+! 9! -F9''! )$EG!!!!!


#&! ! J)$D(),! 1391! (C! 3&! +&-;$)E-! $13&+D(-&! -3&! F(,31! 2$)1()5&8! ! R51! 39%(),! -522&--C5''/!1&+F()91&E!13&!1$;(2!$C!()'()&!-J91&-G!I$5(-9!C9''-!-('&)1!9)E!;(2J-!5;! 3&+!.$D'8!!! !

³<RX VKRXOG EH VWXG\LQJ´  VKH VD\V D IHZ VHFRQGV ODWHU  ³VR KXUU\ DQG

&91²WKHQVWXG\1R79´! !

"! F(-&+9.'&! '$$J! 9'1&+-! 3(-! &)1(+&! C92&G! ;5-3(),! 3(-! '(;-! $51D9+E! ()1$! 9!

;$518! ! 7! 391&! /$5G! 3&! 13()J-G! 9)E! 2$%&+1'/! (F;9'&-! 9! D&E,&! $C! 1$F91$! D(13! 9! 23$;-1(2JG!1D(-1(),!13&!51&)-('!9-!(C!3&!D&+&!-19..(),!91!3&+!3&9+18!!5#,*+(#3"67! !

R&C$+&! '$),G! I$5(-9! 2'&9+-! 3&+! .$D'! 9)E! 13&! &F;1/! E(-3&-! $CC! 13&! 19.'&G!

'&9%(),!=9F5&'!9'$)&!1$!C()(-3!3(-!F&9'8!!R51!-$$)!-3&!+&15+)-G!3$%&+(),!9.$%&!3(-! -1$$;&E! .$E/! '(J&! 9! 1&923&+! F$)(1$+(),! 13&! ;+$,+&--! $C! 9! -15E&)18! ! U3&)! 9-! (C! ;'5),(),!C+$F!13&!-J/G!WKHVWDFNRIIOLHUVODQGLQIURQWRIKLP³<RX UHSOD\LQJDW .DQJ .DQJ RQ 6XQGD\´  VKH VD\V  ³0\ ERVV ZDQWV \RX WR JLYH WKHVH WR \RXU IULHQGV DQG WHDFKHUV DW VFKRRO WRPRUURZ  7HOO WKHP WKH\ FDQ JHW D IUHH GULQN´ <$+! 9! F$F&)1! 3&H-! 1$19''/! ;5ZZ'&EG! -$F&D391! E(-2$)2&+1&E8! ! 7! E$)H1! 39%&! 9)/! C+(&)E-!91!-23$$'G!3&!9'F$-1!1&''-!3&+G!.51!C(,5+&-!(1H-!.&11&+!1$!-19/!L5(&18!!*5-3(),! KLV ERZO DVLGH KH UHDFKHV IRU D IOLHU UHDGLQJ LW ZLWKRXW VD\LQJ D ZRUG  ³,I \RX SOD\ ZHOO´  VKH VD\V WXUQLQJ WR JR  ³ZH OO J&1! -$F&! F$)&/²VR \RX SOD\ ZHOO´ +HU YRLFH FURVVHV IURP WKH GLQLQJ URRP LQWR WKH NLWFKHQ DGGLQJ  ³<RX PDNH -$F&!F$)&/G!13&)!/$5!29)!3&';!F&!;9/!C$+!/$5+!%($'()!'&--$)-!D(13!0+-8!N$)&/! :DQJRND\"´! !

T&9E(),!13&!C'(&+!$%&+!9)E!$%&+G!=9F5&'!-19+1-!1$!,&1!13&!(E&9!1391!3(-!'(C&!(-!

9!J()E!$C!;&+;&159'!2(+2'&G!C$+&%&+!2/2'(),!3(F!9+$5)E!1$!2$++&-;$)E(),!-(1591($)-8!! =()2&! 3&! D9-! -(>! 3(-! F$13&+! 39E! +$51()&'/! ;51! 3(-! 19'&)1-! $)! E(-;'9/! -$! $13&+-! 2$5'E! 9;;'95E! 3(F8! ! <$+! 9! /&9+! 9)E! 9! 39'C! (1! D9-! 13&! ;(9)$G! 9)E! 13&)G! 91! -$F&! ;$()1G! (1! .&29F&! 13&! %($'()8! ! \)2&! 9! D&&J! 3&! D$+J&E! D(13! 9! ;+(%91&! ()-1+521$+G! '&9+)(),! 13&! =5Z5J(! F&13$E! 5)1('! (1! .&29F&! ;9+1! $C! 3(-! F9++$D8! ! V%&+/! -(),'&! )(,31! 3&! ;+921(2&E! C$+! 3$5+-! $)! &)E².&C$+&! E())&+G! 9C1&+! E())&+²13&! D&&J&)E-! .&(),! )$! &>2&;1($)8! ! U3&+&! D9-! '(11'&! 1(F&! 1$! C$+F! -&+($5-! C+(&)E-3(;-G! $+! 1$! ()1&+921! D(13! 3(-! ;&&+-! .&/$)E! 13&! -23$$'/9+E8! ! R51! D3('&! -1(''! ()! U9(D9)G! 3(-!!!!!!!


#'!! ! F$13&+!39E!;'&)1/!$C!3&+!$D)!1(F&!1$!$%&+-&&!3(-!E9('/!;+921(2&G!-(11(),!$)!3(-!.&E! $+!-19)E(),!.&-LGHKLPDWWKHPXVLFVWDQGLQHYLWDEO\VD\LQJ³1RQRLW¶VZURQJ 'RLWDJDLQ´! !

7KH SDLQVWDNLQJ HIIRUW KRZHYHU ZDVQ¶W ZLWKRXW UHZDUG  %\ KLV QLQWK

.(+13E9/! 3&! 39E! E&%&'$;&E! 13&! 29''5-&-! $C! 9! -&9-$)&E! ;+$C&--($)9'! $)! 3(-! C(),&+1(;-G! 9)E! ./! 3(-! 1&)13! ELUWKGD\ KH¶G ZRQ QXPHURXV SUL]HV  /DVW \HDU KH ;'&9-&E!3(-!F$13&+!,+&91'/!./!!L59'(C/(),!9-!9!C()9'(-1! ()!3(-!9,&!E(%(-($)!91!.$13! 13&! U9(D9)! #91($)9'! `($'()! 4$F;&1(1($)! 9)E! 13&! U9(;&(! 4(1/! 4$F;&1(1($)G! &923! WLPHSHUIRUPLQJ0HVVHQHWµV³0HGLWDWLRQ´IURP!8,*&'!9)E!(F;+&--(),!13&!M5E,&-! ./!3$D!D&''!3&!2$5'E!;'9/!-523!9!2$F;'(291&E!;(&2&8!!V>2&;1!9''!13$-&!;+(Z&-!9+&! -1$D&E!()!9!.$>!3(,3!5;!$)!3(-!.&E+$$F!2'$-&1!-3&'CG!&)1(+&'/!F&9)(),'&--!1$!3(F! 9)E! E(-+&,9+E&E! '(J&! -39''$D! ;+$F(-&-! 1391! D$5'E! )&%&+! .&9+! C+5(18! ! =1(''G! 3(-! D&&J'/! '&--$)-! 2$)1()5&! 3&+&G! 9! .5-! +(E&! 1$! 9)E! C+$F! *9-9E&)9! &923! U35+-E9/! 9C1&+)$$)!-$!3&!29)!.&!()-1+521&E!./!0+-8!N$)&/!B9),G!13&!&'E&+'/!D$F9)!;9(E! F$)13'/!()!29-38! !

³0UV+RQH\:DQJ´KLVPRWKHUFDOOVKHUVRPHWKLQJWKDWERWKSHUSO&>&-!

9)E!9))$/-!3(F!1$!)$!&)E8!!U3&!$'E!'9E/!(-!)&%&+!M5-1!0+-8!B9),G!$+!N$)&/G!.51! DOZD\V 0UV +RQH\ :DQJ IRU VRPH UHDVRQ LW¶V DOVR KRZ VKH ILUVW LQWURGXFHG KHUVHOIVFUXWLQL]LQJKLVIDFHZLWKDFROGVWDUHZKLOHVD\LQJGXOO\³0PSOHDVHGWR F&&1!/$5G!=DPXHO,¶P0UV+RQH\:DQJ<RXPXVWGRH[DFWO\ZKDW,WHOO\RX´ %XW GXULQJ WKHLU ILUVW OHVVRQ KH TXLFNO\ QRWLFHG 0UV +RQH\ :DQJ¶V VNLOOV DV D %($'()(-1!D&+&!'(F(1&E!91!.&-1G!9)E!3&+!()-1+521($)!39-!-()2&!195,31!3(F!)$13(),!3&! GLGQ¶W DOUHDG\ NQRZ  $)E! -3$5'E! 3&! &%&+! C&&'! ()2'()&E! 1$! E$! -$G! =9F5&'! 5)E&+-19)E-! 3&! 2$5'E! ;+$.9.'/! -39F&! 13&! $'E! '9E/! ()! 9)! ()-19)1G! ;'9/(),! 3(-! %($'()! -$! C9-1! 9)E! -$! ;&+C&21'/! 1391! (1! D$5'E! '&9%&! 3&+! E5F.C$5)E&E! 9)E! -;&&23'&--8! !

#$D!'&9%(),!13&!19.'&G!3&!C()E-!3(F-&'C!13()J(QJ<RXVKRXOG¶YHERXJKWXV

D KRXVH LQVWHDG RI ZDVWLQJ PRQH\ RQ 0UV +RQH\ :DQJ  <RX VKRXOG¶YH DVNHG F&G!91!'&9-1!$)2&G!(C!7!'(J&E!;'9/(),!13&!%($'()!1$!.&,()!D(138!!U9J(),!13&!C'(&+-G!3&! &-29;&-!1$!3(-!.&E+$$F!9)E!-351-!13&!E$$+8!!U3&!$%&+3&9E!'(,31!.5'.!C'(2J&+-!()1$!


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`!;'9/(),!()!13&!'(%(),!+$$FG!13&!F51&E!E(-2$+E! $C! 1(1'&! F5-(2! 9)E! C'&&1(),! %$(2&-! 251! -3$+1! ./! ()1&+F(11&)1! .5+-1-! $C! -191(2:!! 9'+&9E/!I$5(-9!(-!$)!13&!2$523G!C'(;;(),!13+$5,3!13&!239))&'-!D(13!13&!+&F$1&²9! .9,! $C! -3+(F;KC'9%$+&E! 23(;-! .&-(E&! 3&+G! 9! .$>! $C! P'&&)&>! +&9E/! 91! 3&+! C&&1! C$+! D3&)!13&!c9;9)&-&!-$9;!$;&+9!-3&H''!-$$)!D9123!F$%&-!3&+!1$!1&9+-8!!! !

")E!D3('&!E$))(),!13&!-J5''29;G!=9F5&'!+&9'(Z&-!3(-!FRWKHU¶VDYLGLQWHUHVW

()! "-(9)! 1&'&%(-($)! E+9F9-! (-! 9! +&2&)1! ;+&$225;91($)8! ! "-! '$),! 9-! 3&! 2$5'E! +&F&F.&+G! -3&! 39E! ;+&C&++&E! %(E&$19;&-! $C! "F&+(29)! F$%(&-G! E5..&E! $+! -5.1(1'&E! N$''/D$$E! 2'9--(2-! ;5+239-&E! 23&9;'/! C+$F! 9! )(,31! F9+J&1! -19''8! ! N&+! C9%$+(1&-! DHUH DOZD\V PXVLFDOV  ,W GLGQ¶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³&KXQKWH ZK\ GRQ¶W \RX HYHU NLVV PH OLNH &DU\ Q+9)1b!!=35),K/$G!9C1&+!/$5!,+$D!5;G!/$5!-3$5'E!F9++/!"5E+&/!N&;.5+)G!$J9/b!! ,µOOWDNH&DU\*UDQWDQGGDGG\FDQKDYH/DVVLH´! !

=9F5&'!39-!)$!E$5.1!9.$51!(1:!!3(-!F$13&+!E&-(+&E!9!;9-1!'(C&!1391!)$D!$)'/!

&>(-1&E! $)! %(E&$19;&-]! -3&! E+&9F&E! $C! 9! N$''/D$$E! (F;$--(.'&! 1$! '$291&! &%&)! D3&)G! 91! '9-1G! 13&/! 39E! -1+$''&E! 1$,&13&+! 9'$),! (1-! C('13/G! 5+()&K-F&''(),! B9'J! $C! )DPH:KHUHDVVKH¶GVHOHFWHGKLV$PHULFDQQDPH!.9-&E!$)!(1-!1$)9'!-(F('9+(1/!1$!


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

U3&!E(--$)9)1!-$5)E-!2$F(),!C+$F!13&!U`!-1$;!9.+5;1'/G!C$''$D&E!-3$+1'/!

13&+&9C1&+! ./! 13&! $;&)(),! -1+9()-! $C! 13&! c9;9)&-&! -$9;! $;&+9G! 9)E! =9F5&'! C()E-! KLPVHOI \DZQLQJ DJDLQ  )HHOLQJ KH LVQ¶W TXLWH \HW WLUHG HQRXJK IRU EHG KH -1+&123&-!$51!92+$--!13&!F911+&--!9)/D9/G!.+(),(),!.$13!39)E-!.&)&913!13&!;(''$D! WR SURS KLV KHDG  ³7XKF9K+$D! &'²<+/KGD\´  KH VD\V SUDFWL2(),! 3(-! V),'(-3G! SXQFWXDWLQJWKHVHQWHQFHZLWKDFRXSOHRIQRGV³'DGD\RIIK1&+!15KF9K+$D! &'² =9K1&KGD\´  +H IL[HV KLV VWDUH RQ WKH FHLOLQJ QRW ORRNLQJ DW DQ\WKLQJ VSHFLILF ³6XQKE9/²´  %XW LQ D FRXSOH RI PLQXWHV DV LI DQ LQYLVLEOH SDOP KDG VOLG JHQW'/! 92+$--!3(-!C92&G!3(-!&/&'(E-!D(''!2'$-&!D(13$51!3(F!+&9'(Z(),!(1G!9)E!3&!D(''!C9''!C9-1! 9-'&&;G! 3(-! .$E/! ,+$D(),! 3&9%/! 5;$)! 13&! -3&&1-! D3('&! 3(-! .+&913(),! .&2$F&-! '(,31&+8! !

)RUDWOHDVWHLJKWKRXUVKHZRQ¶WPRYHDQLQFKRUGUHDPRIDQ\WKLQJKHµOO

+&F&F.&+G! $+! 3&9+! 13&! C9()1! 3(--! $C! 13&! $%&+3&9E! '(,31! .5'.! 91! 13&! ()-19)1! (1! &>;(+&-²13&!E/(),!C('9F&)1!()1&)-(C/(),!.+(,31'/!'(J&!9)!&'&21+(29'!'9-1!,9-;!.&C$+&! E9+J)&--!C'$$E-!13&!+$$F8!!#$13(),!D(''!-39J&!3(F!C+$F!3(-!F$1($)'&--!-'5F.&+]! )$13(),G!1391!(-G!5QWLOHDUO\WRPRUURZPRUQLQJZKHQ/RXLVD¶VILUPXQZDYHULQJ YRLFHZDNHVKLPXSVD\LQJ³6KXQJK/$G!13&!F$)&/!C$+!13&!.$D²7!;51!(1!$)!/$5+! GHVN´  7KHQ ILQDOO\ VWLUULQJ ORVW IRU D PRPHQW LQ WKH JDX]HK'(J&! 39Z&! .&1D&&)! -'&&;! 9)E! 2$)-2($5-)&--G! 3&! D(''! ,'(F;-&! 3&+! ./! 13&! E$$+D9/! 9-! (C! -3&! D&+&! 9;;&9+(),!1$!3(F!D(13()!9!%(-($)G!9!-39E$D/!C(,5+&!3$'E(),!9!;5+-&G!(F;$--(.'&!1$! -&&!2'&9+'/]!9)E!-3&G!()!15+)G!D(''!+&,9+E!3(F!D(13!E(-F9/G!-39J(),!3&+!3&9E!91!13&! -(,31! $C! 3(F! 13&+&:! ! -1(''! E+&--&E! C+$F! /&-1&+E9/! 9)E! .9+&'/! 9D9J&G! ;5CC/! &/&-!!!!!!


#*!! ! FUDFNHGKDOIRSHQWKH0LFNH\0RXVHVNXOOFDSSXVKHGORZRQKLVIRUHKHDG³,JRW -$F&!-3$;;(),!1$!E$!.&C$+&!D$+JG!-$!/$5!,&1!/$5+!$D)!.+&9JC9-18!!I&C1$%&+-!9+&!()! WKHUHIULJHUDWRUDQGWKHUH¶VVRPHULFHLQWKHFRRNHU09J&!-5+&!/$5!,$!.5/!1391! ERZ DIWHU VFKRRO WKHQ \RX VWDUW SUDFWLFLQJ IRU 6XQGD\ DOO ULJKW"  ,¶OO VHH \RX WRQLJKW´! !

,Q WKH WLPH LW WDNHV 6DPXHO WR PXPEOH  ³2ND\´  /RXLVD ZLOO DOUHDG\ EH

,$)&G! 3&9E(),! E$D)! 13&! 39''D9/G! 3&+! %$(2&! -&&F(),'/! '(),&+(),! .&3()EG! 1&''(),! KLP³*HWXSJHWXS\RX OOEHODWH´([FHSWKHZRQ¶WFOLPEIURPWKHEHGQRW\HW +H¶OO IDOO EDFN LQWR WKH SLOORZ VWDULQJ DJDLQ DW WKH FHLOLQJ OLVWHQLQJ WR WKH ELUGV 1D(11&+! $51-(E&! .&/$)E! 3(-! D()E$D8! ! 0()51&-! '91&+G! 3(-! -1$F923! D(''! -5EE&)'/! +5F.'&!D(13!9!;+$'$),&EG!E(-1+&--&EK-$5)E(),!,+$D'G!5+,(),!3(F!1$!+(-&]!9)EG!9-!(C! RQ FXH KH¶OO KHDU KLV PRXVH EHJLQ JQDZLQJ DW WKH EDUV RI WKH FDJH²9! C&%&+(-3G! ;&+;&159'! +911'(),! ()1&)E&E! 1$! +&F()E! 3(F! $C! (1-! &>(-1&)2&! 9)EG! F$+&! 139)! 9)/13(),! &'-&G! (1-! )&&E! C$+! -$F&13(),! 1$! &91! D3('&! '$2J&E! 9D9/! ()! 13&! %9''&/! $C! 5)D9-3&E!2'$13&-8!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !


! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ?dA! ! 7KHUH ZDV D VWRU\ /RXLVD¶V PRWKHU +DLK/5&)! '(J&E! +&;&91(),! 1$! 3&+! -&%&)! 39'CK )9J&E! 23('E+&)G! &-;&2(9''/! $)! 13$-&! -D&'1&+(),! -5FF&+! )(,31-! 9C1&+! 13&! E())&+! 19.'&! 39E! .&&)! 2'&9+&E8! ! U3&! F$5)1&E! $-2(''91(),! C9)! ;(%$1&E! 5;$)! 13&! '(%(),! URRP ZDOO HYHU\RQH¶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²3&+!35-.9)E!+&-1(),!$)!13&!1919F(!F91!.&-(E&!13&!25-3($)! D3&+&!-3&!)$+F9''/!-91²13&!$'E!F()J9!3$5-&!D$5'E!C9''!-('&)1!.&C$+&!-3&!-;$J&G! 3&+!'(;-!-(;;(),!C+$F!9!25;!$C!U9(D9)!R&&+!9)EG!9!F$F&)1!13&+&9C1&+G!;5+-(),!91! 13&!&)E!$C!9!I$),&%(1/!2(,9+&11&]!13&)!9-!-F$J&!-)9J&E!;9-1!3&+!C92&!1$D9+E!13&! 2&('(),G!-3&!2$5'E!.&,()!()!&9+)&-1G!3&+!)91(%&!'9),59,&!$C!0())9)!&)39)2(),!13&! )(,318!! !

Y5+(),! 13&! -5FF&+! $C! 3&+! &(,31&&)13! /&9+²()! 13&! 239$1(2! F$)13-!

C$''$D(),! 13&! OOe! 7)2(E&)1G! 9)E! 13&! -/-1&F91(2G! +9)E$F! J(''(),! $C! 2(%('(9)-! ./! 439),!P9(KVKHN¶VPDLQODQGWURRSV²N9(K/5&)!HQFRXQWHUHGWKH\RXQJPDQVKH¶G VRRQ PDUU\ WKH RQO\ PDQ VKH¶G HYHU UHJDUG ZLWK VRPHWKLQJ FORVH WR DIIHFWLRQ!!


$#! ! =3&! 39E! F&1! 3(F! ./! -3&&+! 239)2&! $)! D391! D9-! 9! +9()/! 9C1&+)$$)G! ()-(E&! 13&! ;9--&),&+! 29+! $C! 9! 1+9()G! C()E(),! 3&+-&'C! -&91&E! )&>1! 1$! 3(F! D3('&! .$13! 1+9%&'&E! C+$F!U9()9)!1$!=()-3(38!!=2$$1(),!9-(E&!-$!-3&!F(,31!39%&!F$+&!+$$F!1$!-1+&123! 3&+!'&,-G!3&!-&&F&E!9!'(11'&!-3/G!.51!D3&)!3&!-F('&E!-3&!D9-!(FF&E(91&'/!19J&)!./! 13&! D9+F13! $C! 3(-! F9))&+G! 13&! 239+F(),! D9/! ()! D3(23! 3&! ;$'(1&'/! )$EE&E! 3(-! 3&9E!9)E!-&11'&E!3(-!D(E&!.+$D)!&/&-!5;$)!3&+8!!"1!1391!()-19)1G!-3&!'91&+!2'9(F&EG! VKHNQHZWKH\ZHUHGHVWLQHGIRURQHDQRWKHU([FHSW³ORYH´ZDVQ WWKHH[SUHVVLRQ -3&!5-&E!D3&)!E&-2+(.(),!1391!&9+'/!911+921($)!1$!3&+!-$$)K1$K.&!35-.9)EG!)$+G!()! C921G! D9-! -523! 9)! &>;+&--($)! $;&)'/! ;+$C&--&E! C$+! 9)/13(),! -5++$5)E(),! 3&+G! '&1! 9'$)&!3&+!$CC-;+(),8! !

R51! (1! D9-! '$%&! 9''! 13&! -9F&G! 9! E&&;! E&%$1($)! -39+&E! ./! 3&+! 9)E! 3&+!

35-.9)E! 1391G! 9-! N9(K/5&)! &>;'9()&E! (1G! C$-1&+&E! 9)! ()%(-(.'&! .9++(&+! 9+$5)E! 13&F²9! )5+15+(),G! 5)-&&)! C$+2&! &)2(+2'(),! 13&F! 9)E! 13&(+! 3$F&G! -9C&,59+E(),! 13&(+! 23('E+&)! 9)EG! &%&)159''/G! 13&(+! ,+9)E23('E+&)G! 921(),! 9-! 9! J()E! $C! -3(&'E! 9,9()-1! 13&! E9+J&-1! $C! 1(F&-8! ! U3(-! C&&'(),! $C! %&)&+9.'&! ;+$1&21($)! D9-! -&)-&E! 13+$5,3$51! 13&! )&9+'/! C$5+! E&29E&-! $C! 13&! .07¶V HQIRUFHPHQW RI PDUWLDO ODZ ()1&)-(C/(),! 91! 13&! 3&(,31! $C! 13&! B3(1&! U&++$+! D3('&! 13$5-9)E-! D&+&! 5)M5-1'/! (F;+(-$)&E! $+! &>&251&E²'$29'! -23$$'! 1&923&+-G! C+(&)E-! C+$F! 23('E3$$EG! -&%&+9'! +&'91(%&-²D9)(),!$)'/!-'(,31'/!D(13!13&!+&2&)1!'(C1(),!$C!F9+1(9'! '9D!()!fgehG!/&1! ;&+-(-1(),! &%&)! 1$E9/! 9-! 13&! (-'9)E! -'$D'/! 1+9)-(1($)&E! C+$F! 9! $)&K;9+1/! -/-1&F! WRZDUGDOLEHUDOL]HGGHPRFUDF\,QRWKHUZRUGVWKHHQLJPDWLFERQGRIRQH¶VRZQ C'&-3G! .$+)! C+$F! 13&(+! 5)($)! 9)E! F9E&! ,+&91&+! 139)! 13&! -5F! $C! (1-! ;9+1-G! 39E! -$F&3$D!F9)9,&E!1$!J&;1!13&F!9''!9'(%&G!39E!9''$D&E!13&F!9''!1$!13+(%&!E&-;(1&! &%&+/13(),8! ! 7C! )$1! C$+! 13&(+! F9++(9,&G! -3&! +&F()E&E! 3&+! 23('E+&)G! )$)&! $C! 13&F! D$5'E!&>(-18!!")E!(C!)$1!C$+!9!C$+15(1$5-!F&&1(),!$)!9!;9--&),&+!1+9()!9)E!13&!J()E! -F('&!$C!9!C+(&)E'/!-1+9),&+G!-3&!C&'1!2&+19()G!)&(13&+!-3&!)$+!3&+!35-.9)E!D$5'E! KDYH EHHQ VSDUHG WKH .07¶V LQGLVFULPLQDWH ZUDWK  7KDW ZDV LW WKDW ZDV KHU -1$+/²9'D9/-!&)E(),!91!13&!;'92&!D3&+&!(1!39E!()%9+(9.'/!.&,9)8! !

#$D! 13&! F$+)(),! +5-3K3$5+! 1+9CC(2! 251-! .92J! 9)E! C$+13! 92+$--! "1'9)1(2!

R'%E8G!9'13$5,3!F9)/!$C!13&!)&(,3.$+3$$E!-3$;-!+&F9()!2'$-&E!C$+!.5-()&--8!!U3&!


$$! ! 5)'(1! -1$+&C+$)1-! '$$J! C$+'$+)G! 13&! E9+J&)&E! ()1&+($+-! 2$)%&/! 13&(+! $D)! 5)29))/! C$+F!$C!-('&)2&8!!"!1&F;&+91&!=9)19!")9!D()E!.'$D-!E+/!9(+!E$D)!13&!F$5)19()! -'$;&-! $C! 13&! =9)! Q9.+(&'! 0$5)19()-G! 9)E! -19)E(),! 91! 9! .5-! -1$;²3&+! 3&9E! '$D&+&EG! 29-59''/! $.-&+%(),! 9! 2+5F;'&E! =1/+$C$9F! 25;! 9)E! 9! 23&D(),! ,5F! D+9;;&+! 15F.'&! 9'$),! 13&! 25+.-(E&! ,511&+! 9-! (C! ;+$;&''&E! C$+D9+E! ./! F9,(2² I$5(-9!+5)-!3&+!1$),5&!$%&+!3&+!C+$)1!1&&13G!E$(),!-$!D3('&!13&!D$+J(),-!$C!3&+! F()E! +&15+)! 1$! 3&+! F$13&+8! ! R51G! 91! C(+-1G! -3&! C()E-! 3&+-&'C! 13()J(),! 9.$51! 3&+! SDUHQWV¶FRXQWU\KRXVH²3$D!13&!D()E!-39J&-!13&!2/;+&--!1+&&-!()!13&!F(EE'&!$C! 13&! )(,31G! $+! -$F&1(F&-! +911'&-! 13&! '911(2&EG! ;9;&+K2$%&+&E! D()E$D-! 9)E! -'(E(),! E$$+-!$)!13&!-1(''&-1!$C!E9/-8!!U3&)!(1!(-!3&+!F$13&+!-3&!-&&-G!9;;&9+(),!()!9!-D(+'! $C! I$),&%(1/! -F$J&²13&! -'&&%&-! $C! 9! C'$D&+K;911&+)&E! -3(+1! +$''&E! 5;! 1$! N9(K \XHQ¶V HOERZV D FLJDUHWWH KHOG OLNH D SHQFLO E\ QLFRWLQHK-19()&E! C(),&+1(;-² FRQFOXGLQJWKDWRIWHQWROGVWRU\³3HRSOHWKDWJRWRRIDUIURPZKHUHWKH\EHORQJ FDQ JHW ORVW´  3&+! F$13&+! 2951($)-! C+$F! 13&! ;9-1G! 9)E! I$5(-9! )$E-! 91! 13&! .5-! -1$;²GXWLIXOO\ DFTXLHVFHQWO\ DV LI VKH KDV QR FKRLFH EXW WR DJUHH  ³7KHUH LV VWUHQJWKLQNHHSLQJ\RXUVHOIQHDUIDPLO\RWKHUZLVHSODQWVWKDWDUHQ¶WURRWHGGRQ¶W ODVWWRRORQJ´! !

E('.#5#F)"G0!

!

B(13! 1391G! 13&! %(-($)! $C! 3&+! F$13&+! -5EE&)'/! +&2&E&-G! D3(-J&E! 9D9/G! (1!

-&&F-G!./!13&!'9-1!,5-1-!$C!13&!-5.-(E(),!D()E8!!Q$)&G!1$$G!9+&!13&!25;!9)E!,5F! D+9;;&+G! 39%(),! E&C1'/! +$5)E&E! 9! -1+&&1! 2$+)&+! +(,31! 9-! 13&! =9)19! ")9! .&,9)! 1$! E(F()(-38!!")E!9F(E!13&!-191(2!9(+!'&C1!()!13&!D()EH-!D9J&G!I$5(-9!,9Z&-!5;!91!13&! C'$D!$C!1+9CC(2G!$.'(%($5-!1$!13&!&'E&+'/!D$F9)!-(11(),!9'$)&!$)!13&!.&)23!.&3()E! 3&+²9! D$F9)! D(13! '$),! -('%&+K,+9/! 39(+G! D&9+(),! 9! )9%/K.'5&! -29+C! 9)E! 9)! $CCK -&9-$)!.&(,&!$%&+2$91G!9)E!D3$G!$)'/!-&2$)E-!.&C$+&G!39E!.&&)!-'$D'/!+(;;(),!9! -3$;;(),!+&2&(;1!9;9+1G!.(1!./!.(1G!E+$;;(),!13&!1$+)!;(&2&-!1$!13&!,+$5)E!9-!(C!-3&! D&+&!C&&E(),!;(,&$)-G!(F9,()(),!-)$DC'9J&-!D3('&!D9123(),!13&!.+&&Z&!1+9)-;$+1! 13&!-3+&E-!$C!;9;&+!&'-&D3&+&8! !

R51! 3&+! 9;;9+&)1'/! $51D9+E! -19+&! (-! F$+&! ;+&2(-&'/! 29-1! ()D9+EG! 3&+!

13$5,31-!D&(,3(),!13&!'$),K1&+F!(F;'(291($)-!$C!13&!+&2&)1!23$(2&-!-3&!39-!F9E&!


$&! ! C$+!3&+-&'C!9)E!=9F5&'G!9)E!&%&)!(C!-3&!15+)-!1$!C92&!13&!.&)23G!13&!D$F9)!-(11(),! 13&+&! D$5'E! +&2&(%&! '(11'&! $+! )$! )$1(2&! 9W DOO IRU WKH PHDQLQJ RI /RXLVD¶V RZQ ;&+-$)9'!3(-1$+/!(-!;5ZZ'(),!3&+G!9)EG!'(J&!13&!9-/FF&1+(29'!;913!1391!39E!'&E!3&+! C+$F!9!+5+9'!%(''9,&!1$!U9(;&(!9)E!13&)!1$!I$-!"),&'&-G!3&+!'(C&!39-!.&&)!2(+25(1$5-G! +&;'&1&! D(13! 39;;&)-19)2&G! 9'D9/-! (F;$--(.'&! 1$! ,95,&8! ! #&%&+! E(E! -3&! (F9,()&! 1+9%&'(),!-$!C9+!-$!C9-1G!)$+!E(E!-3&!&%&+!(F9,()&!3&+!35-.9)E!D$5'E!C()9''/!922&;1! 13&!C9F('/!F$%(),!9.+$9E²HVSHFLDOO\VLQFHKH¶GSUHYLRXVO\GLVPLVVHGWKHQRWLRQ 9-!.&(),!1$$!&>;&)-(%&!9)E!(F;+921(29'8! !

N$D! 2$5'E! 13&/! 9''! -5+%(%&! D(13$51! J)$D(),! 9)/$)&! 13&+&b! ! 435)K1&! 39E!

D$)E&+&E8!!B391!9.$51!13&!'9),59,&!E(CC(25'1(&-G!$+!13&!35)E+&E-! $C!5)C$+&-&&)! KDUGVKLSV WKH\¶G KDYH WR GHDO ZLWK"  :KDW DERXW HYHU\WKLQJ WKH\¶G PLVV EDFN KRPH"  3OXV WKH ULVN ZRXOGQ¶W EH ZRUWK IRUIHLWLQJ KL-! +&1(+&F&)1! ;&)-($)! C+$F! 13&!;$D&+!2$F;9)/G!$+!3&+!M$.!-&25+(1/!91!13&!.9)J8!!0$+&$%&+G!-3&!D9-!13&!$)&! ZKRGHVLUHGDOLIHLQ$PHULFDDQGKHVLPSO\GLGQ¶WVKDUHWKHVDPHGUHDP! !

U3&)! 1D$! /&9+-! 9,$G! 9-! 435)K1&! -91! $)! 13&! &E,&! $C! 13&(+! .&EG! 3(-! C92&!

25;;&E!LQ KLVKDQGV KHVDLGZLWKDQ H[KDXVWHGDOPRVWDJRQL]HG WRQH³0D\EH D&! -3$5'E! M5-1! -19+1! $%&+! -$F&D3&+&! &'-&8! ! 09/.&! D&! )&&E! -$F&13(),! )&D! 9)E! GLIIHUHQW VRPHWKLQJ H[FLWLQJ  , GRQ¶W NQRZ  ,¶P WKLQNLQJ $PHULFD LVQ¶W VXFK D .9E!(E&98!!71!M5-1!C&&'-!'(JHZH¶UHURWWLQJKHUH´! !

U3(-!-5EE&)!239),&!$C!F()E!$225++&E!91!13&!%&+/!&)E!$C!9!'$),!9+,5F&)1!

.&1D&&)! 13&FG! $)&! ()! D3(23! I$5(-9! 39E! 2$)C+$)1&E! 3(F! +&,9+E(),! 13$-&! (--5&-! 1391!39E!.&,5)!1+$5.'(),!3&+!E&&;'/:!!3(-!2$)1()59'!E(-()1&+&-1!()!3&+!.$E/!9C1&+! 3H FDPH WR EHG WKH QLJKWV ZKHQ KH GLGQ¶W DUULYH KRPH XQWLO SDVW PLGQLJKW DQ XQNQRZQ ZRPDQ¶V YRLFH RQ WKHLU DQVZHULQJ PDFKLQH DVNLQJ KLP WR UHWXUQ WKH FDOO$OORILWZDVMREUHODWHGKH¶GFODLPHGZKLOHVKHVWRRGLQIURQWRIKLPVKDNLQJ 3&+!3&9E8!!Y(E)H1! -3&! 9'+&9E/!J)$D!3&!-$F&1(F&-!D$+J&E!'91&G!$+!3&!-$F&1(F&-! &)M$/&E!9!C&D!E+()J-!D(13!3(-!.$--&-b!!N$D!2$5'E!-3&!.&,+5E,&!3(F!1391b!!N$D! 2$5'E! -3&! +&-&)1! 3(F! C$+! .&(),! 1(+&E! 9C1&+! 3&! ,&1-! 3$F&²1$$! 1(+&E! 1$! 13()J! $C! 1$523(),!3&+G!$+!&%&)!3(F-&'C8!!")E!13&!D$F9)²+,*+#G"-*)²D9-!13&!D(C&!$C!9! 2$KZRUNHUFDOOLQJKLPDERXWKHUKXVEDQG¶VXSFRPLQJELUWKGD\DQGWKHVXUSULVH


$'!! ! ;9+1/!-3&!D9-!;'9))(),!1$!13+$D!91!13&!$CC(2&8!!7C!3&!D9-!+&9''/!39%(),!9)! 9CC9(+G! D$5'E!3&!.&!-$!-15;(E!9-!1$!,(%&!3(-!F(-1+&--!13&(+!3$F&!1&'&;3$)&!)5F.&+b! !

³<HV´/RXLVDVDLGZDJJLQJDILQJHUDWKLP³\RX¶GEHWKDWVWXSLG´!

!

I$D&+(),! 3(-! C92&! ()1$! 3(-! 39)E-G! 3&! 13&)! 511&+&E! 13&! $)'/! -191&F&)1! -3&!

ZRXOGEHOLHYHZDVDFWXDOO\WUXHVD\LQJ ³/LKC5),G!)$)&!$C!(1!39-! 9)/13(),!1$!E$! D(13!/$58´$QGDPRPHQWODWHURXWRIWKHEOXHKHPHQWLRQHG$PHULFD! !

³:K\ DUH \RX EULQJLQJ WKLV XS"´  VKH VDLG  ³<RX GLGQ¶W ZDQW XV WR PRYH

WKHUHEHIRUH´! !

+HVKUXJJHG³-XVWVHHPVOLNHDJRRGLGHD7KLQJVGRQ¶WVWD\VWDEOHKHUH

13&/!)&%&+!E$8!!U9(D9)!(-!9'D9/-!9!F&--8!!U$E9/!13&+&!(-!;&92&G!.51!1$F$++$D!D3$! J)$D-8!!B3/!'(%&!'(J&!13(-8!!")/D9/G!9!'$1!$C!;&$;'&!(FF(,+91&!1$!"F&+(29G!-$!D3/! QRWXV",WKRXJKW\RXµGEHKDSS\´! !

³,GRQ¶WNQRZZKDW,DP´VKHVDLGWKHDQJHULQKHUYRLFHZDQLQJ!

!

³<RXVKRXOGEHKDSSLHU´KHVDLGOLIWLQJKLVIDFHIURPKLVKDQGVWRVKRZ

KHUDVOLJKWJULQ³<RXNQRZZKDW¶VVWUDQJH"$FRXSOHRIGD\VDJR,EXPSHGLQWR VRPHRQHZKRFDQKHOSXVRXW´! !!

B3('&!.5/(),!2(,9+&11&-!91!9!<9F('/!09+1G!3&!39E!&)2$5)1&+&E!=5!Y9KD&(G!9!

+$$FF91&! RI KLV IURP FROOHJH KH¶G ORVW WRXFK ZLWK RYHU WKH \HDUV  'HOLJKWHG 9.$51! -&&(),! &923! $13&+! 9,9()G! 13&! 1D$! E&2(E&E! 1$! ,+9.! 9! 2$CC&&! 9)E! 29123! 5;G! -(11(),!1$,&13&+!91!9!D()E$D!-&91!9-!(1!+9()&E!$51-(E&8!!! !

³1RWKLQJ FKDQJHG´  &KXQKWH WROG /RXLVD  ³+H¶V WKH! -9F&! ,5/! 7! J)&D! ()!

FROOHJHH[FHSWKH¶VORVLQJKLVKDLUJRWDORWIDWWHU7KDWGRHVQ¶WPDWWHURIFRXUVH EHFDXVHKH¶VGRQHYHU\ZHOOLQOLIH,KRQHVWO\GLGQ¶WWKLQNKH¶GDPRXQWWRPXFK ([FHSW ORRN DW KLP  +H¶V JRW WZR KRPHV  +HµV JRW D SODFH KHUH DQG KH¶V JRW D ;'92&! ()! I$-! "),&'&-! -$! 3(-! -$)-! 29)! '(%&! D(13! 13&(+! F$13&+! 9)E! 911&)E! .&11&+! VFKRROV7UXWKIXOO\,µPDOLWWOHHQYLRXV/LKIXQJ´! !

%RWKPHQKDGVWXGLHGHQJLQHHULQJWKRXJKIROORZLQJFROOHJHWKH\¶GWDNHQ

-&;9+91&!29+&&+!;913-:!!13&!U9(D9)!*$D&+!4$F;9)/!C$+!435)K1&G!9!-&+(&-!$C!E&9EK &)E! .5-()&--! %&)15+&-! C$+! Y9KD&(8! ! R51! )$D! 3(-! $'E! C+(&)E! +5)-! 9! -522&--C5'! (F;$+1i&>;$+1! 2$F;9)/! ()! U9(;&(! 9)E! I$-! "),&'&-G! 9)EG! 9-! '52J! D$5'E! 39%&! (1G!!!


$(! ! Y9KD&(!9'-$!$D)-!()2$F&!;+$;&+1/!9+$5)E!13&!=9)!Q9.+(&'!`9''&/²-&%&+9'!3$5-&-! 9)E! 9)! 9;9+1F&)1! 2$F;'&>! +&)1&E! F$-1'/! 1$! U9(D9)&-&! (FF(,+9)1-8! ! 7)! C921G! 435)K1&! +&%&9'&EG! Y9KD&(! 39E! 39'C! M$J(),'/! $CC&+&E! 3(F! 9! M$.! ;$-(1($)! (C! 3&! D9-! ()1&+&-1&E8! ! 0$+&! (F;$+19)1'/G! 3&! D9-! ;+&11/! 2&+19()! 3(-! 2$''&,&! ;9'! 2$5'E! F9J&! 13&(+! 1+9)-(1($)! 9! -F$$13&+! $)&G! )$! E$5.1! +&)1(),! $51! 9! ;'92&! 1$! 13&F! ()! I$-! "),&'&-G! -5+&'/! ,(%(),! 13&F! 9! E(-2$5)1! +91&! 5)1('! 13&/! ,$1! -&11'&E!E$D)! $)! 13&(+! $D)8! !

³6R PD\EH WKLV LV RXU EHVW FKDQFH WR JLYH LW D WU\´  KHU KXVEDQG VDLG

-$5)E(),!$;1(F(-WLF³:KDWGR\RXWKLQN"´! !

")E! C$+! 13&! C(+-1! 1(F&! ()! D&&J-G! I$5(-9! -5EE&)'/! C$5)E! 3&+-&'C! )$! '$),&+!

E&-;(-(),! 3(FG! 9! 2+$$J&E! ,+()! ;5-3(),! 91! 9! 2$+)&+! $C! 3&+! F$513! 9-! -3&! -('&)1'/! )$EE&E! 3&+! 9)-D&+8! ! U391! )(,31G! 13&/! &)E&E! 5;! 39%(),! -&>! 1D(2&G! 9)E! 13&! )&>1! F$+)(),G! 13&! -5)! D9-! '$-1! 1$! 13&F! .&3()E! 9! E&)-&! '9/&+! $C! -F$,G! /&1! 3&+! D$+'E! C&'1! ;&+C&21'/! 2'&9+! 9,9()8! ! U3&)! 9! C&D! E9/-! '91&+G! (1! D9-! 435)K1&! D3$! -19+1&E! ;'9))(),! 13&! -&&F(),'/! ()2$)2&(%9.'&! F$%&²C(,5+(),! 13&! &>921! 2$-1-G! 5-(),! 3(-! F&13$E(29'! &),()&&U¶V PLQG WR SURSHUO\ RUJDQL]H HYHU\WKLQJ LQ DGYDQFH²D3('&! -3&!.&,9)!2$)-(E&+(),!D3(23!&--&)1(9'!.&'$),(),-!-3$5'E!.&!;92J&E!9)E!-3(;;&E8!! U3&+&! D$5'E! -1(''! 2$)1()5&! 1$! .&! &%&)(),-! D3&)! 3&+! 35-.9)E! 9++(%&E! 3$F&! '91&G! 9'13$5,3!-3&!39+.$+&E!'&--!+&-&)1F&)1!)$ZEUXVKHGKHUVXVSLFLRQVDVLGHGLGQ¶W 9''$D!3&+-&'C!1$!;+&--!3(F!F523!9.$51!(18! !

")E!&%&)!9-!13&(+!;'9)-!D&+&!+&;&91&E'/!9'1&+&EG!E(-25--&E!13$+$5,3'/!C$+!

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¶V (QJOLVKK-;&9J(),! D(C&! D9-! D(''(),! 1$! 9--(-1! I$5(-9!!!!!


$)! ! RQFH WKH\ KDG PRYHG DVVXPLQJ WKH UROH RI WKH ER\¶V DXQW GXULQJ WKH LQLWLDO &)+$''F&)1!;+$2&--8! !

[&1! .&C$+&! C5''/! 2$FF(11(),! 13&F-&'%&-G! 435)K1&! C'&D! 1$! I$-! "),&'&-! ./!

3(F-&'CG!F&&1(),!5;!D(13!Y9KD&(!-$!3&!2$5'E!-&&!13&!+&)19'!3$5-&!9)E!&>;&+(&)2&! "'39F.+9! C(+-139)EG! 9-! D&''! 9-! E(-25--! 13&! 239)2&! $C! &F;'$/F&)1! 91! 13&! (F;$+1i&>;$+1!2$F;9)/8!!T&15+)(),!9C1&+!13+&&!E9/-G!3&!39E!$)'/!;$-(1(%&!13(),-! 1$!-9/8!!U3&!3$5-&!D9-!,+&91G!3&!+&;$+1&E8!!U3&!+$$F-!D&+&!1D(2&!13&!-(Z&!$C!D391! KH¶GLPDJLQHGDQGWKHSURSHUW\KDGDODUJHEDFN\DUG$PRXQWDLQUDQJHFRXOG .&!-&&)!C+$F!13&!C+$)1!;$+238!!^;!9)E!E$D)!13&!-1+&&1G!,+9--!,+&D!$)!'9D)-!1391! D&+&! ;+$.9.'/! .(,,&+! 139)! 13&(+! 9;9+1F&)18! ! U3&! 9(+! D9-! ()2+&E(.'/! E+/G! E+/&+! WKDQ KH¶G WKRXJKW SRVVLEOH DQG WKH VN\ VWD\HG EOXH WKH HQWLUH WLPH  2Q WRS RI 1391G! 13&! )&(,3.$+3$$E! 9)E! 2(1/! D&+&! )(2&! 1$$]! 13&! D3$'&! 9+&9! '$$J&E! -$! 2'&9)G! D(E&! 9)E! -;+&9E! $51²)$1! E(),/! 9)E! DOO SXVKHG WRJHWKHU OLNH LQ 7DLSHL  ³,W¶V &>2&''&)1G!I(KIXQJ´KHFRQFOXGHG³,¶PVXUH\RXDQG6KXQJK\RZLOOOLNHLW´! !

R51! D(13! -523! ;+$F(-(),! )&D-! 9'-$! 29F&! 9)! 5)9)1(2(;91&E! 9)E! C()9'!

239),&!$C!13&(+!;'9)-8!!435)KWHKDGQ¶WDFFHSWHGDSRVLWLRQDW'DKD&L¶VFRPSDQ\ QRW \HW DQ\ZD\  ,W MXVW ZRXOGQ¶W SD\ HQRXJK KH H[SODLQHG DQG LW ZDV VPDUWHU 39%(),! 9! E&2&)1! ()2$F&! 9%9('9.'&! -$! 13&! C9F('/! 2$5'E! 9EM5-1! 2$FC$+19.'/! 1$! $PHULFDQOLIH,QVWHDGKH¶GUHPDLQLQ7DLSHLDWWKHSRZHUFRPSDQ\IRUDQRWKHU /&9+! $+! F$+&G! -9%(),! 9-! F523! 9-! 3&! 2$5'E! D3('&! I$5(-9! 9)E! =9F5&'! ,$1! -&11'&E! DEURDG  7KLV ZD\ KH UHDVRQHG WKH\¶G EH DEOH WR EX\ WKHLU RZQ KRPH ZKHQ KH ILQDOO\ MRLQHG WKHP WKHUH  ,Q WKH PHDQWLPH KH¶G H[SORUH ZKLFK HPSOR\PHQW $;;$+15)(1(&-! F(,31! .&! 9%9('9.'&! 9C1&+! 3&! E$&-! F$%&G! 2$)1921(),! $13&+! DFTXDLQWDQFHVZKR¶GKRSHIXOO\DVVLVWKLPZLWKILQGLQJDEHWWHUSD\LQJSRVLWLRQLQ /RV $QJHOHV  $QG IRU KHU SDUW /RXLVD ZRXOGQ¶W KDYH WR ZRUU\ DERXW PRQH\ RU SD\LQJWKHUHQWVKH¶GQHHGRQO\VRPHIRUPRIPHQLDOZRUNXQ1('!3&+!,+&&)!29+E! D9-! 92L5(+&EG! 9! C5''KWLPH MRE WKDW FRXOG FRYHU WKHLU VRQ¶V YLROLQ OHVVRQV DQG ZKDWHYHUGDLO\H[SHQVHVVKRXOGDULVH³,NQRZLWIHHOVPRUHGLIILFXOWOLNHWKLV´KH WROG /RXLVD WDNLQJ KROG RI KHU KDQG  ³EXW , SURPLVH LW¶OO UHDOO\ EH D! '$1! &9-(&+8!! <RXµOOVHH´!


$*% ! !

435)KWH¶VGHFLVLRQWRUHPDLQEHKLQGDFWXDOO\PDGHFRPSOHWHVHQVH\HWLQ

WKHEDFNRIWKH/RXLVD¶VPLQGVKHZRQGHUHGLIKH¶GJRWWHQFROGIHHW²(CG!;&+39;-G! 13&!+&9'(1/!$C!'&9%(),!U9(D9)!39E!-5EE&)'/!-&&F&E!1$$!E95)1(),!9)E!1$$!+&2J'&--! C$+! 3(F8! ! U3&)! &%&+/! -$! $C1&)! 13&-&! E9/-G! 9! E9+J&+! )$1($)! 39-! 2+&;1! ()1$! 3&+! WKRXJKWV VRPHWKLQJ VKH KDWHV FRQVLGHULQJ  SHUKDSV KH¶G QHYHU LQWHQGHG RQ ,$(),! ()! 13&! C(+-1! ;'92&]! ;&+39;-! 3&! -(F;'/! D9)1&E! 13&F! C9+! 9D9/! C+$F! 3(-! ;+&C&++&E!'(C&²9-!13$5,3!13&/!D&+&!)$!E(CC&+&)1!139)!9!1+$5.'&-$F&!F(-1+&--!9)E! 9)!(''&,(1(F91&!23('E8! !

R51!-523!(++91($)9'!(E&9-!.&2$F&!L5(2J'/!E(-F(--&E8!!=3&!9)E!435)K1&!9+&G!

DIWHUDOOVWLOOKXVEDQGDQGZLIHVWLOODFRXSOHGHVSLWHWKHYDVWGLVWDQFH+H¶GJRQH 1$!,+&91!'&),13-!1$!C()E!13&F!9!-5(19.'&!3$F&G!9)E!-3&!39-!-()2&!35),!13&(+!C9F('/! ;$+1+9(1! $)! $)&! $C! (1-! '(%(),! +$$F! D9''-8! ! U3&(+! 2$523! ()! U9(;&(! (-! 13&(+! 2$523! ()! "'39F.+98! ! U3&! U`G! 13&! +(2&! -1&9F&+G! 13&! C5+)(15+&G! 9)E! %9+($5-! ;&+-$)9'! (1&F-! ()-(E&!5);92J&E!.$>&-²9''!$C!(1!(-!13&!-9F&8!!")E!-$G!-3&!)$D!2$)%()2&-!3&+-&'CG! 9)! (F;&+2&;1(.'&! 13+&9E! $C! 2$)1()5(1/! F5-1! .()E! 2&+19()! ;&$;'&! 1$,&13&+G! UHJDUGOHVV RI WKH PLOHV EHWZHHQ WKHP  +HU PRWKHU ZDV ZURQJ VKH WKLQNV  ,W¶V F$+&!139)!9!-(),'&!'$291($)!1391!E&&;&)-!C9F('(9'!+$$1-G!F$+&!139)!9!-(F;'&!3$5-&! 9)E! 9! ;'$1! $C! '9)EG! F$+&! 139)! ;+$>(F(1/8! ! "-! '$),! 9-! 9! -&)-&! $C! 2$)-(-1&)2/! (-! F9()19()&E²$C!3$F&G!1+9E(1($)G!.&'$),(),²WKHQDIXWXUHLQRQHSODFHVKRXOGQ¶W .&!91!$EE-!D(13!13&!;9-1!()!9)$13&+8! !

=35),K/$! (-! .$5)E! 1$! 5)E&+-19)E! 13(-! 1$$! -$F&E9/G! I$5(-9! 1&''-! 3&+-&'CG!

&)%(-($)(),!3&+!-$)!.9+&'/!9D9J&!91!13&!&E,&!$C!3(-!.&EG!13&!0(2J&/!0$5-&!29;!)$! ORQJHU RQ KLV KHDG  6KH NQRZV KH¶OO VRRQ WUXGJH WR WKH EDWKURRP DQG SHH 9C1&+D9+E-G! D3('&! C92(),! 13&! %9)(1/! F(++$+G! 1$$13;9-1&! D(''! C$9F! 5;! ()-(E&! 3(-! F$513! 9-! 3&! .+5-3&-! 3(-! 1&&138! ! *+&-&)1'/G! '(J&! 3&! E$&-! &%&+/! F$+)(),G! =9F5&'! D(''!+&15+)!1$!3(-!.&E+$$F!D(13!3(-!13(2J!39(+!5)2$F.&E8!!=2+9123(),!3(-!.$11$FG! KH¶OORSHQWKHEOLQGVDQGORRNRXWWKHZLQGRZWRFKHFNWKHZHDWKHU R51!.&C$+&! E+&--(),! C$+! -23$$'².&C$+&! &91(),! 2&+&9'! $+! '9-1! )(,31H-! '&C1$%&+-! D3('&! D9123(),! 29+1$$)-²KH¶OO IHHG KLV SHW PRXVH KROGLQJ LWV IRRG LQ WKH SDOP RI KLV KDQG GDQJOLQJWKHPRXVHE\LWVWDLODQGVD\LQJ³(DWLWHDWLW´!


$+% ! !

7KHQ KH¶OO GUHVV KLF-&'CG! 9)E! F9J&! 3(-! .+&9JC9-1G! 9)E! 9++(%&! 91! -23$$'! $)!

WLPH  +H¶OO SD\ FDUHIXO DWWHQWLRQ WKURXJKRXW KLV (6/ FODVV DQG GXULQJ WKRVH $13&+! 2'9--&-! D3(23G! 5)1('! 13&! )&>1! -23$$'! /&9+! .&,()-G! 9+&! 911&)E! D(13$51! 3(F! +&2&(%(),! 3$F&D$+J! $+! ,+9E&-G! =9F5&'! D(''! E$! 3(-! .&-1! 1$! 9.-$+.! 9-! F523! ()C$+F91($)! 9-! 3&! 29)! 5)E&+-19)E²13&! 1&923&+-! F$)(1$+(),! 3(-! ;+$,+&--! 9)E! ,+9E59'!9--(F('91($)G!,(%(),!3(F!13&!E9('/!39)E$51-!-$!1391!3&!C&&'-!'(J&!9)!&L59'! ;9+1!$C!13&!2'9--!()-1&9E!$C!9!F&+&!$.-&+%&+8!!")E!D3&)!13&!-23$$'!E9/!(-!C()(-3&EG! KH¶OO EX\ KLPVHOI D QHZ ERZ  7KH UHVW RI KLV DIWHUQRRQ MXVW OLNH KLV DIWHUQRRQV 39E!.&&)!()!U9(D9)G!D(''!.&!-;&)1!;+921(2(),!13&!%($'()8!!N(-!'(C&!3&+&G!-3&!9--5+&-! 3&+-&'CG! (-! )&9+'/! 13&! -9F&! 9-! 3(-! '(C&! D9-! 13&+&²13&! &>2&;1($)! .&(),! 1391! 13&! ;$--(.('(1(&-!9+&!C9+!,+&91&+!C$+!3(F!3&+&8! !!!

U3(-! 2&+19()1/! 9.$51! =9F5&'! .+(),-! 3&+! .92J! 1$! +&9'(1/G! 9)E! I$5(-9H-!

13$5,31-!-3(C1!1$!13&!D$+'E!9+$5)E!3&+8!!=3&!,'9)2&-!E$D)!13&!.5-/!-1+&&1G!2+9)(),! 3&+!)&2J!()!3$;&!$C!29123(),!9!,'(F;-&!$C!3&+!.5-!9F$),!13&!$)2$F(),!1+9CC(28!!"''! 91! $)2&G! 13&! =9)19! ")9! +&-5F&-! .'$D(),G! &)%&'$;(),! 3&+! C5''/! ()! 13&! F$E&+91&! 3&91! $C! (1-! -;+(),! .+&&Z&8! ! <$+! 9! D3('&G! 13$5,3G! -3&! C&&'-! 13&! '(),&+(),! /&1! C9()1! 3$F&D9+E! ;5''! $C! 1391! 35F(EG! E(FG! '$),! 9,$! ;'92&! 3&+! F()E! 39E! M5-1! -5FF$)&E²D3&+&!13&!;9-1!$C!3&+!23('E3$$E!D9-!.+(&C'/!F$+&!9119()9.'&!139)!13&! SUHVHQWWKHIDFHVDQGURRPVVKH¶GVHHQVRYLYLGO\H[LVWLQJQRZRQO\DVWKH\FDQLQ F&F$+/! 9)E! ;3$1$,+9;3-8! ! R51! -$$)! &)$5,3! 3&+! .5-! 9;;&9+-G! C(>(),! 3&+! D(13()! 13&! F$F&)1G! (1-! .+9J&-! D3()(),G! 13&! E$$+! C$'E(),! $;&)! C$+! 3&+8! ! =3&! ;+$F;1'/! 2'(F.-!9.$9+EG!C$''$D&E!./!13&!&'E&+'/!D$F9)²&923!19J(),!9!-&91!E(+&21'/!92+$--! 13&!9(-'&!C+$F!13&!$13&+G!.$13!$)!13&(+!D9/!1$!-$F&D3&+&!&'-&8! ! ! ! ! ! ! !


! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

"#$%&'!%&!()*+¶6,668(! ,!-./!'0122!34/!56!718/!69:/2!5;!<1=>/0! ,!?5@5!81A/2!1!@18.!1;B!B9/2! ,!*HQHUDO7LDQ¶VZDUULRUVFRQWUROWKHZLQG! ,!³+5>!A;5C!.5C!85!D014!8./!E9509;F!.>.G´! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !



Everything Beautiful is Far Away [6, 2012 | Vol. 2]