Airtable vs Trello: The Best of Task and Project Management process.st/airtable-vs-trello December 6, 2018
Ben Mulholland December 5, 2018
“Airtable vs Trello. Which is better?“ Our team had been using Trello for years and had only recently undergone a transition to Airtable. We were having a tough time adjusting (old habits die hard), and my Process Street colleague Ben Brandall was trying to get to the bottom of why. We love improving our productivity using everything from business process automation to focus music, and this case was no different. Trello is a powerhouse of task management but Airtable is a masterful mix of database, spreadsheet, task and project management app. How are you supposed to choose? That’s why I’m writing this post. After having used both apps personally and professionally for more than three years, I’ve been able to get to grips with who these apps are designed for and what makes them useful. Most of all, you can learn from this to see which app would suit you instead of spending years testing them out yourself. 1/10
Let’s get started.
Airtable vs Trello: The basics
Focus The primary difference between Trello and Airtable is their focus. Trello is designed to help you manage tasks in a simple but effective Kanban view. Airtable is capable of storing huge amounts of data as a database, then creating dynamic views to let you sort everything from basic data to complex tasks with custom filters and parameters. Trello is a claw hammer. Airtable is the whole toolbox. That doesn’t mean we’re done with the comparison, as Airtable’s wider applications aren’t inherently good or bad. It all depends on the context you approach it from and what role you need it to perform. Trello is a fantastic tool that’s simple to use and great for its specific purpose. Airtable lets you do much more but it’ll take time to learn each of its components effectively, and can be a little overwhelming for those unfamiliar with it.
Platforms First let’s take a look at the platforms they are available on. While there aren’t any differences between the two apps’ availability, it’s useful to know that they’re both available native to almost every platform. Plus, it’s always useful to have a bullet-point comparison in an Airtable vs Trello comparison. Airtable available platforms: 2/10
Windows Mac iOS app Android app Web-based Trello available platforms: Windows Mac iOS app Android app Web-based The only platform these apps aren’t available on is Linux, which isn’t too much of an issue considering that the web-based version of both are fully functional and easy to use (if you know how to use the app). From experience, however, Trello’s mobile apps are a little easier to navigate than Airtable due to the tighter focus and fewer features.
Features As mentioned in the focus section of this post, Trello is much more limited in its features than Airtable. Again, this isn’t a bad thing due to the more focused nature of the app, and it’s a boon in terms of how easy it is to pick up but it’s worth reinforcing. The simple version Airtable is designed to be a database, spreadsheet, and project management app combined. 3/10
The core is formed of a spreadsheet-style database which can store entries for anything you want. Once you have some data to work with, you can link data entries together and arrange them into views from grids to galleries, and calendars to Kanban boards. These views can then be sorted by any variables you’ve defined and filtered to remove unnecessary information. Imagine a spreadsheet that let you link your data together to create smart views that you can customize to show almost anything you want. That’s Airtable in a nutshell. Trello, meanwhile, is wholly dedicated to being a Kanban board in which you can create “cards” to move between various columns. While it might seem the lesser, Trello’s simple (compared to Airtable) nature is much less imposing and confusing, letting anyone immediately see what they need to with almost no training. Both Trello and Airtable allow you to collaborate with your team by assigning them to specific tasks and pieces of data, controlling their permission levels, and tracking their activity through things like comment logs on your tasks. The full rundown The sheer variety of features is too much to dive into without some idea of what they add up to in the full app, hence the simplified overview above. However, we’d be doing Airtable and Trello a disservice to ignore their specific differences. So, courtesy of GetApp‘s list-based comparison, the full rundown of each app’s features can be seen below. Airtable and Trello shared features: @mentions API Access control Automatic backup Automatic notifications Collaboration tools, review, and workspace Commenting Custom fields Data import/export and synchronization Document storage Drag and drop interface Email integration File management Filtered views Multiple projects Permission management 4/10
Project management, tracking, and time tracking Projections Real-time data Search Tagging Task management, planning, scheduling, and tracking Third-party integration To-do lists Airtable unique features: Action management Active directory integration Advertising management Agile development Applicant tracking Application integration Attendance management Audit trail Availability management B2B integration Barcode scanning Budgeting Bug tracking Built-in database Bulk send Business analysis Calendar management Campaign planning, management and scheduling Cataloging Categorization Charting Chat Client management Communication management and calendar Compensation management Content filtering Custom charts, development, forms, and online databases Dashboard creation Data filtering, mapping, and storage management Database access Event management Forms management Full-text search 5/10
Inbox management Inventory management Message board Multi-department/project Product catalog Progress reports and tracking Project development, budgeting, estimating, notes, planning, templates, and workflow Reporting and statistics Research management SMS integration Single sign-on Social media integration Status tracking Supplier management Template management Time/task reporting Video management Workflow management Trello unique features: Activity dashboard, management, and tracking Assignment management and tracking Data import Deadline tracking Desktop notifications Email invitations, reminders, and notifications Employee management File transfer Labeling Prioritizing Real-time notifications and updates Retrieval SSL security Secure data storage User activity monitoring Voting
Integrations Being a database, Airtable naturally has the ability to more readily integrate with other services but that doesnâ€™t mean Trello leaves its users high and dry.
Airtable has built-in integrations with services including Google Drive, Dropbox, Evernote, MailChimp, Slack, social media platforms (Facebook, Twitter, etc) and even Trello. It also has an API which allows you to create your own integrations, and can link to 1,000+ other apps via Zapier. Trello, meanwhile, has a more limited (but nonetheless powerful) integration library. Native integrations include Google Drive, JIRA and Slack, and its API allows developers to create their own integrations. It also has access to the vast library of apps that Zapier has to offer. Trello has a slight advantage in terms of its Zapier integration, as it has more Trigger (13) and Action (18) options than Airtable (2 and 2 respectively), meaning you can get more specific with the various stages and/or effects of the integration. This allows users to more easily automate their tasks and boards, creating Zaps to automate any and every repeatable action.
Free plan Itâ€™s always useful to test out an app before you have to commit to a payment plan, and both Airtable and Trello allow for that with their free plans.
Airtable free plan: Unlimited boards 1,200 records per base 2GB attachment space per base Revision and snapshot history up to 2 weeks No access to Blocks (extra views for your data such as maps, graphs, etc) Trello free plan: 7/10
Unlimited boards, lists, cards, members, checklists, and attachments Power-Ups limited to one per board File link/attachment size limited to 10MB For testing these services out and even full use by an individual or a small team, both free plans are more than enough to suit your needs. In terms of how the limitations affect the intended use of the apps though, Airtable’s is arguably more likely to become an issue as time goes by. Trello’s free plan only limits users in terms of the size of file attachments (up to 10MB), a lack of in-depth user permission options, and only one Power-Up (built-in integration) per board. The user permission levels shouldn’t be much of an issue until your team grows to a reasonable size and you feel the need to protect your more sensitive data. Even then, there’s always the option of creating a separate board for each team and giving people permission to those boards as needed. It’s more cumbersome in terms of syncing tasks but even that can be negated by using Zapier integrations.
The Power-Ups are useful but Zapier allows you to circumvent the need for built-in integration. In fact, the most stringent limitation is probably the file size limit, as you can’t upload anything of a reasonable size with a 10MB limit. Airtable, while having a perfectly serviceable free plan, will quickly reach its limit if you’re using it as it’s intended. 1,200 records is a lot for individual and even small-scale team usage, but this puts a definitive cap on how long you can use Airtable for before you’ll have to upgrade or start an entirely new base and (essentially) archive your old data entirely. 8/10
Again, Airtable’s free plan is good and perfect for testing the app out. However, if you’re a sizable team or you’re looking for a long-term solution for managing your data, tasks, and projects, bear in mind that you’ll have to upgrade to the paid plan sooner or later.
Pricing Airtable and Trello have similar pricing plans in terms of the amount and method of billing (per user per month, with a discount for paying annually). The key difference is that Trello focuses on expanding user permission options, built-in integrations and file attachment sizes in its paid plan. Airtable instead starts by expanding the limitations of the free plan and only brings extra features and customization into the higher paid plans. Airtable paid plans: Plus: $10/user/month (when paid annually) Includes: Everything from the free plan, up to 5,000 records per base, 5GB attachment space per base, and 6-month revision and snapshot history. Pro: $20/user/month (when paid annually) Includes: Everything from Plus, up to 50,000 records per base, 20GB attachment space per base, 1 year revision and snapshot history, access to blocks (modular apps for bases), advanced color and styling options, customisable forms, advanced calendar features, and extra permission/visibility options for your bases and views. Enterprise: Variable Includes: Everything from Pro, increased number of records per base, 1,000GB attachment space per base, 3 years revision and snapshot history, dedicated customer success manager, onboarding and training, single sign-on, unlimited workspaces, a consolidated company account, an enterprise-wide admin panel, and enhanced deletion recovery. Trello paid plans: Business class: $9.99/user/month (when paid annually) Includes: Everything from the free plan plus unlimited Power-Ups, attach files up to 250MB, full user permission management (including sharing link and board access permissions), custom board backgrounds and stickers, and priority email support. Enterprise: $20.83/user/month (when paid annually) Includes: Everything from the business plan plus Single Sign-On, 2-Factor Authentication, personalized onboarding assistance, priority email and phone support, file encryption, intrusion detection, custom security review, and enhanced SLA. It’s easy to see the difference in the target audiences (and, to some degree, the intended users) of these apps in their pricing plans.
While both are perfectly usable on their free plan, Trello opens all of its features (aside from some support and security services) in its cheapest paid plan. Airtable, meanwhile, steadily increases its feature list over the course of all of its plans while also extending the available storage base (for almost everything). In other words, the pricing plans are built in a way that the size of your team and extent of your needs will dictate which tool will suit you better. Trello’s tighter focus as a task management app is more suited to smaller teams, and this is reflected in its pricing plans. Most of the value of Trello comes with its free plan and $10/user/month paid plan, reserving mostly the extra security a larger team would need for the more expensive plans. Airtable, meanwhile, benefits from its wider feature list and use cases. There’s plenty of value in its free and lowest paid plan but most decent sized teams would want to go for the more expensive deals to get access to all of the features. It’s not necessarily a bad thing though – Airtable just knows that larger teams are more likely to need its comprehensive database and project management services, and charges accordingly.
Airtable vs Trello: context is everything In a straight-up “which tool is more useful” fight of Airtable vs Trello, Airtable is the winner. It’s not limited to task management, can achieve a similar role to Trello using its Kanban board views, and can really help to organize and document every element necessary for a team to succeed. However, that doesn’t mean I’d recommend Airtable over Trello. It’s all about context. I’d be more inclined to confidently recommend Trello to anyone looking to organize their tasks and projects more efficiently. It’s much easier to get started with and less prone to small mistakes messing up your whole database. Depending on how you set up your Airtable account, your interlinked records can really suffer from unintentional mistakes. In short, if you’re looking for a tool to help you manage your efforts and get organized, give Trello a go. If you’ve already tried Trello or you’re a team which also needs a database to help store their data, Airtable is definitely worth your time – just be patient when getting to grips with it for the first time.
Airtable vs Trello - which is better? Find out with this full comparison using our team's 3+ years of experience with these apps!
Published on Dec 7, 2018
Airtable vs Trello - which is better? Find out with this full comparison using our team's 3+ years of experience with these apps!