Page 1

The development of Italian migration and asylum policies, between Europe and the Mediterranean Ferruccio Pastore (FIERI) Migration. Taking a look beyond the “Safe Mediterranean� Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, Rome, 9-10 December 2013


My approach • A long-term perspective on the development of Italian migration and asylum policies • Main focus on exogenous determinants (as opposed to endougenous, domestic ones) • Two main fronts of interaction: Europe (EU and MS) and the Neigbourhood (SS and TS, mainly in the Mediterranean) • Problematic relation between these two external sides of Italian M&A policies • Understanding these geopolitical tensions now more important than ever F. Pastore (FIERI), KAS workshop, 10 December 2013


Two external sides of Italian M&A policies

F. Pastore (FIERI), KAS workshop, 10 December 2013


The founding phase (1990s): Domestic priorities and European imperatives 1990: Suppression of ‘geographical reservation’ and belated start in setting up a national asylum system 1990-1998: Lengthy process of Schengen accession linked with development of migration control apparatus Late 1990s-onwards: Quotas, regularizations and the struggle to set up functioning admission channels in a closed Europe F. Pastore (FIERI), KAS workshop, 10 December 2013


Competing sets of demands taking shape on both sides

Demand for burden-sharing

Pressure to stem irregular flows and co-manage legal ones

Pressure to control ext. borders and host asylum-s.

Demand for wider legal channels

F. Pastore (FIERI), KAS workshop, 10 December 2013


The phase of ideological securitization and the ambiguous relations with Europe (2000s) • Migration and asylum policies under the CentreRight: symbolical legislation, policy neglect and bureaucratic continuities • Bilateral cooperation on migration controls with North African regimes and ambiguous attitude of EU and MS • Italian openness to intra-EU migration and ‘Europeanization’ of Italian migration system F. Pastore (FIERI), KAS workshop, 10 December 2013


Economic crisis and Mediterranean instability: Italian migration policies at a critical juncture • Impact of the crisis on migration in Italy: persisting pull factors and declining integration capacity • North African tormented transitions and weakening of cooperative migration control regimes Emerging South-North M&A divide: growing demand fo solidarity, revived spectre of transit migration, crisis of Schengen Emerging South-North intra-EU mobility divide: the debate on 'benefit tourism' and risks of EU disruption F. Pastore (FIERI), KAS workshop, 10 December 2013


Fronts of growing intra-EU tension on migration, asylum and mobility

S pectreof andS/N

transitflow s M & Adivide

rtcepS foe dna N /S

flew ra te o iru s m m o tilb y id iv ed

F. Pastore (FIERI), KAS workshop, 10 December 2013


2 OPPOSED SCENARIOS and TURNING POINTS Scenario I: Re-nationalisation - Dismantling (or hollowing) Schengen - Just formal solidarity on mixed flows - Selective freedom of movement Scenario II: Upgrade of cooperation • First proposals of the Task Force Mediterranean COM2013 (869) • Single European Labour Market Turning points: - Most decisive EP elections in history - 3 pillars of Mediterranean future: Syria, Lybia and Egypt F. Pastore (FIERI), KAS workshop, 10 December 2013

PASTORE, Ferruccio "The development of Italian migration and asylum policies"  
Read more
Read more
Similar to
Popular now
Just for you