Page 1

Weekly Article Application of Composite Interphase Spacers to Interphase Spacers to Prevent Conductor Galloping Prevent Conductor Galloping


UTILITY PRACTICE & EXPERIENCE

Application of Composite Interphase Spacers to Prevent Conductor Galloping

T

he use of composite insulators on transmission lines has increased steadily in recent years due to their well-known performance advantages as well as their lower acquisition and life cycle costs. At the same time, these insulators have also offered solutions in other areas where ceramic insulators have not proven ideal due to their weight and fragility. One such application is as interphase spacers to prevent conductor galloping. In this case, composite spacers serve to improve the aerodynamic or ‘aeroelastic’ behavior of lines exposed to difficult climatic effects such as changing temperatures and wind as well as combinations of wind with ice or sleet deposits. Interactions of these have the potential to produce harmful stresses on different parts of the line through induced motion and conductor vibration – stresses that can cause extensive damage and also endanger line service performance. This article, extracted from an INMR World Congress contribution presented by insulator specialist Alajos Bognar from Hungary, examines the problem of conductor galloping and how application of composite interphase spacers can help control it.

60

INMR® Q1 2012

INMR Issue 95 (A).indd 60

aPPlication

of

comPositE intErPhasE sPacErs

to

PrEVEnt conductor galloPing

20/02/12 2:52 PM


Spacers installed on lines near Shenyang, in northern China.

Because of complex physics and the highly unpredictable way conductor motions and vibrations can develop over time, it is often impossible to predict and deal with all potential future galloping problems during the design stage of an overhead line.

wind. This makes them susceptible to development of sustained, cyclic conductor motions or vibrations. The specific type of vibration depends on several factors and can take different forms:

1. Aeolian Vibrations These are caused by alternating wind forces and impart an oscillating Finding the best solution when such problems arise first requires evaluating lifting force to the conductor. This type of vibration is characterized by service experience to gain the frequencies in the range from 5 to necessary insight into all the factors 100 Hz, with amplitudes of only a that influence onset of destructive few mm up to the full diameter of stresses and vibrations on the line. the conductor. The phenomenon is This way, there is the greatest chance dangerous, because fatigue-bending of finding the most effective measures stress can occur at or near conductor to keep these within allowable limits. fixation points such as clamps and cause breakage of individual strands. Interphase spacers are among the It is common to use special dampers control devices available to engineers (e.g. the Stockbridge damper) to to prevent the most dangerous minimize the level of such vibrations. kinds of vibrations, such as those caused by ‘sleet jump’. But in order 2. Wake-Induced Oscillations to understand how these devices Such oscillations are typical only for can help and to better assess their bundle conductors for which some effectiveness, it is necessary to first sub-conductors are in the wake review some important principles. induced by those to the windward side. The latter then provide a Development of Vibrations shielding effect on their leeward counterparts. Along Transmission Lines Even though transmission lines have Four types of such wake-induced a highly flexible form and relatively slender profile, they are continuously motion can be distinguished: subspan mode (in a section between exposed to the forces of climate and

aPPlication

INMR Issue 95 (A).indd 61

of

comPositE intErPhasE sPacErs

to

two spacers of the bundle); vertical galloping; horizontal galloping; and rolling. Basically, the oscillation is produced by the wake, which induces lower drag coefficients and creates lifting forces on leeward sub-conductors. Due to this kind of aerodynamic instability, the leeward conductor starts to move and, because of conductor spacers inside the bundle, the windward conductor is forced to participate in the movement. While this kind of vibration does not usually lead to a pronounced

Photos: INMR ©

Introduction

Transmission line in Canada during high crosswinds.

PrEVEnt conductor galloPing

Q1 2012 INMR®

61

20/02/12 2:52 PM


reduction in phase-to-phase distances, a portion of the wind’s mechanical power is absorbed by the conductors and can cause fatigue, especially if repeated over long periods of time.

line design and specific mode of excitation. This form of conductor galloping can affect several neighboring spans and last from only a few minutes to much longer.

3. Galloping Conductor galloping (also referred to as dancing) is a phenomenon where transmission line conductors vibrate with very large amplitudes. This produces violent dynamic stresses in the conductors that can lead to damaged insulator strings and tower structures. Under certain conditions, conductors having different potential can come into contact or dangerously approach one another such that a short circuit occurs. Preventing this phenomenon is therefore of fundamental importance in maintaining reliable service of the line.

Fig.1: Development of galloping as a standing wave.

Interaction of Iced Conductors & Wind

One of the most common ways galloping develops is as a result of interaction between a steady, moderately strong crosswind that acts on an asymmetrically iced conductor surface. Through this type of ‘self-excitation’ process, periodic, high amplitude vibrations (or oscillations) can occur on either single or bundle type conductors. The amplitudes can approach the value of the sag and have motion mainly in the vertical plane, with frequencies of between 0.15 and 1 Hz depending on

Example of snow adhesion to conductors in China.

Most of the observed galloping in this case takes the form of standing waves that occur with one, two or sometimes as many as 10 loops in a span (although galloping events with three or less waves per span are most common). In the case of more than three loops, the galloping generally has smaller amplitudes. When this problem develops, the oscillating motions of the phase conductor and overhead ground wire can lead to contact. Alternatively, the critical air gap breakdown distance between conductors of different phases or between the phase conductor and ground wire can be reduced. This will result in short-circuit and operation of the relevant circuit breakers to switchoff the line. In the case of automatic reclosing, switch-on will be successful. However, contact or approach of the conductors will quickly reoccur because of the periodicity of the galloping phenomenon. The repetitive short circuit can then damage the conductors through the high energy, high temperature power arcs that develop between the conductors as they approach too close to one another or come into contact. The negative mechanical effects have to be considered as well (as mentioned above). One of the main processes contributing to galloping is the formation of an ice coating on the

Predicting the exact dynamic behavior of a transmission line can prove highly complex and studying it can be done only under real service conditions or alternatively using test lines that duplicate all the relevant climatic conditions.

62

INMR® Q1 2012

INMR Issue 95 (A).indd 62

aPPlication

of

comPositE intErPhasE sPacErs

to

PrEVEnt conductor galloPing

20/02/12 2:52 PM


A CIGRÉ survey reported that the majority of power supply companies use interphase spacers with polymeric insulators due to their low weight and high flexibility under compression loading. conductor. Since a conductor’s surface is not perfectly smooth, some snow adheres to it and marks the onset of ice deposit formation. From that stage on, the torsional rigidity of the conductor (or conductor bundle) becomes important. The rotating (or twisting) torque that develops as ice forms causes the conductor to turn and the snow deposit gradually increases to the point that a complete sleeve has been created around the conductor. A secondary problem – known as ‘sleet jumping’ – is caused by the large ice deposit that has formed. This is because when conductors become covered by ice there is a tendency that the conductor closest to the ground will shed its ice first. Upon unloading, this lower conductor can jump toward the upper conductor, possibly leading to a temporary short circuit. Once the lower conductor has recovered from its initial ‘ice jump’, it often settles into a new position with less sag than before and this can persist for a long period of time. If the upper conductor has still not shed its ice load, the reduced separation distance between the two can result in air gap breakdown between the phases. These examples serve to illustrates the complexity of the problem and that predicting the exact dynamic behavior of a transmission line can prove challenging. Studying it can therefore best be done only under real service conditions or

Examples of application of composite interphase spacers.

64

INMR® Q1 2012

INMR Issue 95 (A).indd 64

aPPlication

of

comPositE intErPhasE sPacErs

to

alternatively using special test lines located in areas that exactly duplicate all relevant climatic conditions. Recently, simulation tools have become available to track development of the conductor galloping process. Some even take into account whatever control devices have been put in place to prevent or reduce the problem. However, these simulations need to be validated by continually analyzing actual phenomena and parameters obtained from real service conditions in the field.

Controlling & Preventing Galloping

Because of the dangerous effects of galloping, several alternative approaches have been used to avoid or at least reduce the problem. These include: • Changing Line Routing or Design Fully eliminating the potential for galloping is often impossible without high incremental costs in line design or construction. For example, the route of the line can be changed to areas where ice deposition becomes far less likely. Similarly, conductor cross-section can be increased as can clearance between conductors. • Application of Damper/De-tuners These devices are based on the fact that torsional (or twisting) movement of a bundle conductor arrangement and its vertical motion (because of lifting forces) interact with one another. The instability

PrEVEnt conductor galloPing

20/02/12 2:53 PM


that causes galloping is enhanced when the frequencies of these two motions are close to each other (i.e. there is synchronization / resonance).

is to prevent the most dangerous consequence from conductor galloping, namely phase-to-phase short-circuits. Attaining this is relatively straightforward and involves The solution is therefore to separate providing in-span mechanical the frequencies through some form of couplings between phases, thereby external intervention – a solution such maintaining phase-to-phase as offered by so-called ‘pendulum clearances at some pre-determined, de-tuners’. The de-tuning pendulum acceptable limit. increases torsional frequency but is not able to dampen the torsion. Moreover, from the oscillation One such anti-galloping device damping point of view, these devices with promising results on e.g. twin provide further benefit by limiting horizontal bundle test lines is the any torsional (twisting) motion of Torsional Damper and De-tuner (TDD), conductors or conductor bundles. which combines a de-tuning effect (as Such control (damping) is achieved above) with high torsional damping. since the flexible composite insulators act to increase the conductor’s • Interphase Spacers torsional stiffness. This type of The main concept behind the arrangement offers other advantages application of interphase spacers as well that arise from the flexibility

of the composite spacer. Should conductor vibration act to reduce phase-to-phase clearance, its energy can be absorbed by the spacer’s inherent resilience. Indeed, in several practical applications phase spacers are even placed to connect all three-phase conductors (conductor bundles), resulting in a several times over cross-connected system of sub-spans. This serves to greatly enhance the dynamics of the original system. For example, it could happen that not all phases are unstable when one or two phases are galloping. However, the connections through the spacers between the stable and unstable phase(s) provide the latter with additional aerodynamic and mechanical damping.

Power frequency electric stresses across an interphase spacer are about 73% higher than for phase-to-ground insulation because spacers are subjected to lineto-line voltage. Interphase Spacers as Anti-Galloping Devices General Set-up of Interphase Spacers As discussed, perhaps the most serious consequence of large amplitude galloping is electrical failure caused by contact or critical approach of conductors with different

Photos: INMR ©

Two grading rings are typically required for interphase spacers.

aPPlication

INMR Issue 95 (A).indd 65

of

comPositE intErPhasE sPacErs

to

PrEVEnt conductor galloPing

Q1 2012 INMR®

65

20/02/12 2:53 PM


Example of conductor clamp after galloping test. Only minor wear on hinge part will not affect continued functionality. Typical test set-up with 4 conductor bundle for galloping test on interphase spacers. The power frequency electric stresses across an interphase spacer are about 73% higher than for phase-toground insulation because spacers are subjected to line-to-line voltage. Stress release grading rings must therefore be applied at both ends for voltages of 154 kV and higher. The electric field distribution of phase spacers is different from that of typical suspension insulators in that the spacer's field is symmetrical. The field closer to the end fittings is also higher than for suspension units.

Typical set-up of snow dropout test.

potentials. To avoid this, it is logical to mechanically fix the clearance between the conductors inside the span utilizing insulating structures. While this solution has been applied in the past using ceramic insulators, their weight has created problems because of the modification needed to the preadjusted sag and stress of conductors, especially in the case of lower voltage transmission lines. Their installation and periodic servicing have also proven to be comparatively difficult. For these reasons, this kind of application is virtually completely covered these days by composite insulators. In fact, starting in the late 1980s and early 1990s, installation of composite interphase spacers accelerated rapidly and a CIGRÉ

66

INMR® Q1 2012

INMR Issue 95 (A).indd 66

aPPlication

survey at the time reported that the majority of responding power supply companies used interphase spacers with polymeric insulators due to their low weight and high flexibility under compression loading.

Electrical Design of Interphase Spacers

When it comes to electrical design, the requirements and test methods for interphase spacers are similar to those of normal suspension or tension insulators. Key design parameters include:

Regarding pollution performance, because of the excellent surface hydrophobicity of silicone, no problems should be expected for composite phase spacers equipped with housings made from this material. For example, outdoor weathering trials were conducted with such spacers at a test site on Japan’s Okinawa island, where they were exposed to continuous contamination by salt wind as well as frequent typhoons. In spite of the heavy coastal pollution and wind loads, no evidence of erosion or other deterioration was found after several years of service.

Taking into account that typical applications for such spacers are in areas with cold climates, tests must also be made to evaluate spacer performance under accretion of ice • Power frequency voltage distribution and snow. Typically, such tests have along the unit and flashover under confirmed that the insulator portion contamination; of a composite interphase spacer • Switching impulse flashover voltage properly designed for heavy pollution across conductor-to-conductor gaps; will be able to withstand these high • Lightning impulse flashover voltage. service stresses as well.

of

comPositE intErPhasE sPacErs

to

PrEVEnt conductor galloPing

20/02/12 2:53 PM


Mechanical Design of Interphase Spacers

The mechanical stresses on an interphase spacer through galloping and ‘sleet jump’ include tension, bending (buckling) and fatigue caused by oscillation. The requirements for tension strength are not special but still have to be taken into account in the design of suitable hardware such as end fittings, clamps, etc. In this regard, tensile tests must be carried out on the complete arrangement. For example, the requested mechanical strength of a 275 kV interphase spacer used for 4-bundle conductor of ACSR 410 can be about 79 kN – a level which will easily be met by any well designed unit. Far more important when it comes to mechanical stress, however, is a spacer’s bending/buckling behavior. In this respect, one of the principal merits of composite insulators as interphase spacers is that the onset of buckling or a certain amount of deflection at bending presents no danger so long as the stress remains below the critical limit at which deterioration starts. To provide some indication of such stress levels, relevant figures for allowable bending stress by utilities in Japan are as generally follows: 1. allowable stress: 294 MPa; 2. proposed range of maximum design cantilever load: circa 450-500 MPa. To put these limits into perspective, it should be noted that the normal breaking stress of a good quality glass fiber-reinforced epoxy (FRP) rod is usually more than 800 MPa. Frequent galloping/vibration can produce fatigue in interphase spacers, especially in their metallic end fittings and connections, with risk of wearing out movable parts. Therefore, it is necessary to test their design and performance by simulating the galloping oscillation during a relevant large-scale test, which can be conducted with typical parameters such as:

aPPlication

INMR Issue 95 (A).indd 67

of

Example of bending of spacer after snow drop-out test.

To simulate how this process can develop, a large-scale test set-up is utilized where the effect of an ice load is provided by several weight blocks that hang on the lower conductor by means of an electro magnet. When the magnet is switched off, the weights fall and conductor jumping occurs. In a typical such test, span length can be set at 70 m and the length of the spacer at 10 m while a twin-bundle ACSR 410 conductor is used. The interphase spacer will experience a fairly large, flexible, bending during the test but there should be no visual evidence of defect. The maximum stress in the FRP rod can reach a value of 290 MPa and once the stress is removed, the spacer must return to its original shape.

Installation of Interphase Spacers

Installation methods for interphase spacers.

Frequency of oscillation: approx. 1Hz Amplitude of oscillation: 10 to 20 cm Number of oscillations: 106 cycles Such a test is deemed passed when there are no visible changes in the structure or in parts such as conductor clamps. A further important design feature that must be tested is the ability of the interphase spacer to withstand the stresses when heavy ice/snow loads on the conductor (bundle) in the lower position suddenly drop. In this situation, the lower conductor suddenly jumps upward even as the conductor (bundle) in the upper position remains loaded. An interphase spacer located between the two will therefore be subjected to great compression stress.

comPositE intErPhasE sPacErs

to

After clarifying the electrical and mechanical loads as well as geometric data for the critical spans where interphase spacers are intended for application, it is necessary to decide where to locate them within the span. In this regard, a variety of factors usually have to be taken into account. However, it must be emphasized that symmetrical distribution lengthwise should be avoided since this placement could promote the development of standing waves in the span or sub-spans. Some typical arrangements can be seen in the accompanying Figure. Generally, the ideal number and location of the interphase spacers in each case will then depend on the line’s length of span.

Final Remarks

To collect some of the knowledge and data presented in this article, a full-scale test line was set-up in a mountainous area of Japan and this subsequently became the site of numerous different tests. The above explanations on how composite interphase spacers can combat conductor galloping and ‘sleet jump’ problems on transmission lines up to 500 kV were obtained based on the results of these tests. 

PrEVEnt conductor galloPing

Q1 2012 INMR®

67

20/02/12 2:53 PM

Application of Composite Interphase Spacers to Interphase Spacers to Prevent Conductor Galloping Pre  

INMR weekly article http://www.inmr.com © 2013 INMR : Independent T&D Information Resources | World's Leading Transmission and Distribution...