MARCH 6 - 8, 2018
THE ISET ECONOMIST A BLOG ABOUT ECONOMICS AND THE SOUTH CAUCAUS
The ISET Policy Institute (ISET-PI, www.iset-pi.ge) is an independent think-tank associated with the International School of Economics at TSU (ISET). Our blog carries economic analysis of current events and policies in Georgia and the South Caucasus region ranging from agriculture, to economic growth, energy, labor markets and the nexus of economics, culture and religion. Thought-provoking and fun to read, our blog posts are written by international faculty teaching at ISET and recent graduates representing the new generation of Georgian, Azerbaijani and Armenian economists.
What Georgia Can Teach Sweden About Energy Efficiency
Common sight around Tbilisi with clothes hanging outdoors. Source: Private photo.
FINDINGS OF THE SWEDISH STUDY
BY SELAMAWIT PETERSSON1
believe we all are bound by the notion that technology is the thing. We might be convinced it’s a sign of progress. Those very clever engineers have finally saved humanity, not just by envisioning what will save the masses from wasting their minutes and seconds, but they also help to propel all sorts of time-saving devices. There are, of course, good reasons to argue for how important technological advances are. They can be used as a means of promoting youth employment, or to assist an individual suffering from mobility concerns with vacuum cleaning. Or why not launch a space rocket floating around our solar system? Still, I strongly believe that there are some gadgets that we could assuredly live without. The one currently occupying my mind I became aware of while strolling the streets of Tbilisi. The perks of being newly introduced to a city such as Tbilisi is that you can easily lose yourself strolling down one of the many narrow lanes in the city. They showcase peculiar looking houses, yards and gardens filled with all sorts of kits. What also manifests itself is the visibility of newly washed laundry neatly parading on a wire, left outside to dry in the wind. I am not going to gush over the often colorful prints of bed linen or wears but rather point out the frequency of using outdoor air for drying clothes. Something that is not very often on display in cities in Sweden. Pretty much at the same time as I realized the regularity of this (during chilly December days), the Swedish Energy Agency released the results of a study where they compared methods of drying clothes in the most energy efficient way. So, what did the study say about the use of appliances?
Table 1 compares different types of drying appliances, considering capacity, energy use in kWh/kg, time duration, and lastly, energy use by percentage in different appliances, compared with the most energy efficient machine. As can be seen, the most energy efficient gadget one could use to dry clothes is the tumbler with heat pump. However, this is not the whole story. Dryers need to be classified as A+ or A++, which tells you how energy efficient it is (currently classification of new tumblers spans from A+++, the most effective, to C, and stretches to D for older ones). It should also be installed with a heat pump within the body of the tumbler, which recycles heat, leading to even more effective use of the heat already circulating within the machine. So, what has this to do with Georgia?
ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN GEORGIA Before I answer what this has to do with the Georgian manner of drying clothes, I would like to refer to a 2014 study conducted by USAID, assisted by AYPEG . The report mapped out household energy use in Georgia. Surveying 1,081 households, with a more or less equal distribution between rural and urban respondents, interesting themes were raised that exposed attitudes about the use of energy efficient equipment in dwellings. When asked about energy efficiency, it turns out (maybe not as a surprise for some) that 72 % of the rural and 64 % of the urban interviewees did not know the meaning of the term (Figure 2). At the national level, 25% of respondents were familiar with the meaning of the term, and about the same number of households used energy efficient light bulbs for indoor use (Figure 3). In the USAID study, those who did not have an initial understanding of the term Energy use (kWh/ kg)
Drying time (hours, minutes)
were offered an explanation by the researchers. They gave examples of areas where energy efficiency could be applied, such as the usage of appliances that are marked as energy efficient. After establishing this, the respondents were asked what energy efficient actions they envisioned in the future. As explained in Figure 4, a central heating system had a slightly higher response than the runner up, but most interestingly, 13.7 % were willing to upgrade to an energy efficient appliance (USAID, 2014). Obviously, given the earlier response to the question in the report, one could not jump to the conclusion that this has anything to do with tumblers. But it gives a hint that there is not just an existing awareness (27 % used energy efficient light bulbs), but there also seem to have been some openness to new technology. Especially bearing in mind that of those who did not have a washing machine, 48 % were actually considering buying one within three years. With the right incentives and information, these future customers could as well buy an energy efficient washing machine, which may have a spillover effect on similar or other household activities, including clothes drying.
Figure 2. Source: USAID, 2014.
regarding ownership of a tumble dryer (52 % each, Germany in third place with 47%). Finland, facing the same sub-arctic climate as Sweden, comes at fifth place but is, as noted in the Figure 5 below, one of the countries least likely to use tumble dryer. Interestingly, Finland top the use of heated rooms (a method that uses three times more energy
TUMBLER VERSUS TRADITIONAL METHODS So, let’s go back to what the Swedish report concluded. Although using a tumbler marked A++ with an installed heat pump could help save energy, relative to other alternatives, the ultimate way of saving energy remains using what Mother Earth keeps providing - sun and wind. Despite all the advanced gimmicks that are on the market, claiming to help us save time while consuming as little electricity as possible, nothing can really beat the old trick of using blustery weather. Moreover, according to existing research (e.g. Anderson, 2016), it surely leaves a question mark whether or not we save that much time by letting a tumbler do the job. Whatever the reason (my opinion is that the main attraction of tumblers is that they save space as, drawing from my own experience, many people are living in comprised apartments with a minimum of utility space), of the 10 European countries surveyed by Schmitz & Stamminger (2014), as shown in Figure 5, Sweden is at the top in the use of tumblers. Sweden and the UK are both also at the top
energy with respect to clothes-drying, in all seasons. Therefore, the most effective way to promote energy efficiency in this area could simply be to advertise the benefits of line-drying before consumption preferences change and the transition to tumblers takes place. After all, “an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.” And Sweden? In our case, instead, perhaps we could move beyond the promotion of more efficient (oftentimes hi-tech) dryers to the promotion of the “Georgian model.”
Figure 3. Source: USAID, 2014.
than tumbler dryers on average per year per household).
LESSONS FROM GEORGIA So where does this leave us with regard to Georgia and Sweden? The lead point of this blog post is that Georgians already use the most efficient way of saving
Figure 4. Where Georgian participants would like to save energy. Source: USAID, 2014.
Anderson, B. 2016. Laundry, energy and time: Insight from 20 years of time-use diary data in United Kingdom. Energy Research & Social Science 22, 125-136. USAID. 2014. Household Energy enduse survey. Hydro Power and energy planning project (HPEP). Schmitz, A., Stamminger, R. 2014. Usage behavior and related energy consumption of European Consumers for washing and drying. Energy Efficiency, (7), 937-954. Environment and Energy Policy Research Center, ISET-PI - SIDA Bilateral Associate Expert
Figure 5. Use of drying practices of clothes in 10 European countries (2011). Source: Schmitz & Stamminger (2014).
Energy use in % between other appliances and tumbler dryer with heat pump
Tumbler dryer with heat pump
Condenser tumbler dryer
Drying cabinet with heat pump
Drying cabinet with dehumidifier
Drying cabinet with (exhaust) outlet channel
Table 1. Adjusted table showing results of energy efficient appliances for drying clothes. Source: The Swedish Agency, 2017.
10 Galaktion Street
Tel: (995 32) 2 45 08 08 E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
March 6 - 8, 2018