Page 1

The Arroyo Imbroglio in the Philippines Hutchcroft, Paul D. (Paul David) Journal of Democracy, Volume 19, Number 1, January 2008, pp. 141-155 (Article)

Published by The Johns Hopkins University Press DOI: 10.1353/jod.2008.0001

For additional information about this article http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/jod/summary/v019/19.1hutchcroft.html

Access Provided by University of the Philippines - Diliman at 05/28/10 4:01AM GMT


4(%!22/9/)-"2/',)/ ).4(%0(),)00).%3 0AUL$(UTCHCROFT

0AUL$(UTCHCROFT PROFESSOROFPOLITICALSCIENCEATTHE5NIVERSITYOF 7ISCONSINu-ADISON HASWRITTENEXTENSIVELYON0HILIPPINEPOLITICS(E ISAUTHOROF"OOTY#APITALISM4HE0OLITICSOF"ANKINGINTHE0HILIPPINES  ANDISCOMPLETINGABOOKONPATRONAGESTRUCTURESANDTERRITORIAL POLITICSINTHETWENTIETH CENTURY0HILIPPINES

7ITHTHEEXCEPTIONOF&ERDINAND-ARCOS WHOHELDPOWERFROM

TO  NO ONE IN 0HILIPPINE HISTORY HAS HAD A LONGER TENURE IN THE PRESIDENTIAL PALACE THAN 'LORIA -ACAPAGAL !RROYO 3HE FIRST ASSUMED THEPRESIDENCYIN*ANUARY WHENArPEOPLEPOWERsUPRISINGOUST ED0RESIDENT*OSEPH%STRADAFROM-ALACA^NANG0ALACEANDELEVATEDHER FROMTHEVICE PRESIDENCYTOTHEHIGHESTOFFICEINTHELAND!FTERSERVING OUT%STRADAqSREMAININGTERMUNTIL -ACAPAGAL !RROYOWASELECTED FORANOTHERSIXYEARS4ERM LIMITRESTRICTIONSREQUIREHERTOSTEPDOWNIN  AFTERWHATWILLBENEARLYADECADEINOFFICE )N THE MIDST OF THIS LONGEVITY THE !RROYO ADMINISTRATION HAS FOUND POLITICAL LEGITIMACY TO BE ELUSIVE 0RESIDENT -ACAPAGAL !RROYOqS AS SUMPTION OF OFFICE THROUGH EXTRACONSTITUTIONAL MEANS PROVIDED A WEAK INITIALMANDATE/VERTHECOURSEOFHERSEVENYEARSINOFFICE ANALREADY CRISIS PRONEDEMOCRACYHASFACEDANUNUSUALLYHIGHNUMBEROFTRAVAILS INCLUDING AN UPRISING BY THE URBAN POOR THAT NEARLY BREACHED THE WALLS OFTHEPRESIDENTIALPALACEON-AY$AYABOTCHEDMILITARYMUTINY IN*ULYCORRUPTIONSCANDALSINVOLVINGTHEFIRSTFAMILYALLEGATIONS OFPRESIDENTIALINVOLVEMENTINFIXINGTHEELECTIONSAFAILEDCOUP ATTEMPT CUM POPULAR UPRISING IN &EBRUARY  THAT LED TO THE DECLA RATION OF EMERGENCY RULE CONCERTED ATTACKS ON THE PRESS AN ALARMING SPIKEINEXTRAJUDICIALKILLINGSIMPEACHMENTATTEMPTSIN  AND TWOMAJORBRIBERYSCANDALSINLATE ONEINVOLVINGTHECHIEF ELECTION OFFICER AND THE OTHER BRAZEN CASH PAYOUTS FROM THE 0ALACE TO CONGRESSPERSONS AND GOVERNORS AND A .OVEMBER  BOMBING AT THE (OUSE OF 2EPRESENTATIVES THAT KILLED A NOTORIOUS WARLORD CONGRESSMAN *OURNALOF$EMOCRACY6OLUME .UMBER*ANUARY ˆ.ATIONAL%NDOWMENTFOR$EMOCRACYAND4HE*OHNS(OPKINS5NIVERSITY0RESS




*OURNALOF$EMOCRACY

FROM-INDANAO-ACAPAGAL !RROYOVERYEFFECTIVELYWIELDSTHESUBSTAN TIALPOWERSOFTHEPRESIDENCYTOKEEPHERSELFINOFFICE ANDINTHEPROCESS SHEEXHIBITSNOQUALMSABOUTFURTHERUNDERMININGTHECOUNTRYqSALREADY WEAKPOLITICALINSTITUTIONS!STHE0HILIPPINESSUFFERSONEPOLITICALCRISIS AFTERANOTHER ITSLONGSTANDINGDEMOCRATIC STRUCTURESBECOMEINCREASINGLYIMPERILED No country in Asia .O COUNTRY IN !SIA HAS MORE EXPERI has more experience ENCEWITHDEMOCRATICINSTITUTIONSTHANTHE with democratic in0HILIPPINES DATING BACK TO THE FLEDGLING !SSEMBLYCREATEDBYTHEREVOLUTIONARYRE stitutions than the PUBLICTHATDECLAREDINDEPENDENCEIN Philippines. AFTERMORETHANTHREECENTURIESOF3PANISH RULE 4HE 5NITED 3TATESq RAPID DEFEAT OF 3PAININTHE3PANISH !MERICAN7ARLEDTOAPROTRACTEDCOLONIALCONQUEST OFTHE0HILIPPINES INTHEWAKEOFWHICHTHE5NITED3TATESEMBARKEDONITS FIRSTMAJOROVERSEASEXPERIMENTINrNATION BUILDINGs%LECTIONSPROCEEDED FROMTHEMUNICIPALLEVELTOTHEPROVINCIALLEVELTOTHE/CTOBERCON VENING OF A 0HILIPPINE .ATIONAL !SSEMBLY BRINGING TOGETHER PROMINENT ELITESFROMTHROUGHOUTTHELOWLAND#HRISTIAN0HILIPPINES 3EVERAL KEY ELEMENTS OF 0HILIPPINE DEMOCRACY CAN BE TRACED TO THE 53 COLONIAL ERA 4HE FIRST IS PATRONAGE INFESTED POLITICAL PARTIES THAT RELYHEAVILYONPORK BARRELPUBLIC WORKSPROJECTSRUNTHROUGHNATIONAL LEGISLATORS5NDER53GOVERNOR GENERAL7ILLIAM(OWARD4AFTqSrPOLICY OFATTRACTION sWHICHWASINTENDEDTOWOOTHELANDLORDCLASSAWAYFROM THE REVOLUTIONARY STRUGGLE AND TOWARD COLLABORATION WITH THE 5NITED 3TATES THEECONOMICELITEOFTHE3PANISH COLONIALERAWASTRANSFORMED INTO A POLITICAL ECONOMIC ELITE THAT CONTINUES TO WIELD POWER TODAY "ECAUSE REPRESENTATIVE INSTITUTIONS IN THE 0HILIPPINES EMERGED BEFORE THECREATIONOFSTRONGBUREAUCRATICINSTITUTIONS ITWASEASYFORPATRON AGE HUNGRYPOLITICOSTOOVERWHELMTHENASCENTADMINISTRATIVEAGENCIES OFTHECOLONIALSTATE4AFTLIKEDTOEVOKEIMAGESOF.EW%NGLANDuSTYLE DELIBERATIVE DEMOCRACY BUT THE END RESULT IS BETTER THOUGHT OF AS A 0HILIPPINEVERSIONOF4AMMANY(ALL 3ECOND THECOLONIALPOLITICALSYSTEMENSUREDEXCLUSIONOFTHEMASSES ANDCONTROLBYANATIONALOLIGARCHYNURTUREDBY53RULE4HEFRANCHISE WASLIMITEDTOATINYELECTORATEANDDIDNOTBEGINTOEXPANDSUBSTANTIALLY UNTIL THE LATE COLONIAL AND EARLY POSTCOLONIAL YEARS "Y THIS TIME THE DOMINANCEOFTHENATIONALOLIGARCHYWASSOWELL ENTRENCHEDTHATCHAL LENGESFROMBELOWFACEDMONUMENTALODDS ! THIRD MAJOR LEGACY IS THE PROVINCIAL BASIS OF NATIONAL POLITICS AS INFLUENTIALPROVINCIALELITESTHRIVEDINTHENATIONALARENASESTABLISHEDBY 53OFFICIALS&INALLY THESTRONGPRESIDENCYOFTHEMODERN0HILIPPINES BEGAN WITH THE EMERGENCE OF THE 0HILIPPINE #OMMONWEALTH IN  WHEN 0RESIDENT -ANUEL , 1UEZON PRESIDED OVER A WEAK .ATIONAL !SSEMBLYANDENJOYEDLARGELYUNCONTESTEDEXECUTIVEAUTHORITY


0AUL$(UTCHCROFT



4HESE LEGACIES WERE THE FOUNDATIONS FROM WHICH 0HILIPPINE POLITICS EVOLVEDAFTERINDEPENDENCEIN!MONGTHETRENDSOFTHESAND THESWERETHEFURTHEREXPANSIONOFSUFFRAGE THEEMERGENCEOFCHAR ISMATICAPPEALS ANEWPROMINENCEFORTHEMEDIA THEEXPANSIONOFCIVIL SOCIETY ENHANCEDPRESIDENTIALMOBILIZATIONOFTHEARMYANDCOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENTAGENCIES ANDTHEINCREASINGCOSTOFELECTIONS4HEGENIUS OFrCACIQUEDEMOCRACY sAS"ENEDICT!NDERSONEXPLAINS WASITSCAPACITY TOROTATEPOWERATTHETOPWITHOUTEFFECTIVEPARTICIPATIONOFTHOSEBELOW &ERDINAND-ARCOSUNDERMINEDTHESYSTEMOFREGULARROTATION HOWEVER BEGINNINGINWHENHEBECAMETHEFIRSTPOSTWARPRESIDENTTOBERE ELECTED TO A SECOND TERM 4HREE YEARS LATER PARTLY IN AN EFFORT TO SKIRT THE TWO TERM LIMIT IMPOSED BY THE  #ONSTITUTION -ARCOS DECLARED MARTIALLAW(ISPERSONALISTIC AUTHORITARIANRULE AMPLYREWARDEDBYSUC CESSIVE53PRESIDENTSINEXCHANGEFORCONTINUEDUNHAMPEREDACCESSTO 53MILITARYBASES ENDUREDFORMORETHANTHIRTEENYEARSUNTIL 7HEN PEOPLE POWER CONFRONTED -ARCOSqS TANKS ON THE STREETS OF -ANILAIN&EBRUARY THE0HILIPPINESBECAMEABEACONOFHOPEFOR DEMOCRATS AROUND THE WORLD !S #ORAZON !QUINO WAS PROPELLED FROM GRIEVINGWIDOWTODEMOCRATICICONANDTHE0HILIPPINESBEGANITSTRAN SITION OUT OF AUTHORITARIAN RULE THERE WAS MUCH TO CELEBRATE ABOUT THE EXUBERANCEOFTHECOUNTRYqSDEMOCRATICSPIRIT/PPOSITIONTO-ARCOSHAD NURTUREDTHEGROWTHOFVIBRANTCIVILSOCIETYORGANIZATIONSDEDICATEDTO PROMOTINGTHEINTERESTSOFFARMERS THEURBANPOOR WOMEN INDIGENOUS PEOPLES AND OTHERS WHO HAD LONG BEEN MARGINALIZED BY THE COUNTRYqS POLITICAL SYSTEM ! NEW BREED OF INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISTS SEEMINGLY FEARLESSINTHEIRDESIRETOEXPOSECORRUPTION EMERGEDAFTERTHECOUNTRYqS TRANSITIONBACKTODEMOCRACY%LECTIONSBROUGHTFORTHHIGHTURNOUTSAND EXTENSIVECIVICINVOLVEMENT 4HE COUNTRYqS RETURN TO DEMOCRATIC STRUCTURES HOWEVER REVEALED MANY UNDERLYING PROBLEMS &IRST NUMEROUS COUP ATTEMPTS AGAINST THE !QUINOGOVERNMENTDEMONSTRATEDTHEDIFFICULTIESOFRETURNINGTHEMILI TARYTOTHEBARRACKSAFTERMORETHANADECADEOFMARTIALLAW3ECOND THE -AOIST INSURGENCY OF THE #OMMUNIST 0ARTY OF THE 0HILIPPINES AND ITS .EW0EOPLEqS!RMYCONTINUEDINMANYPARTSOFTHEARCHIPELAGO ASSISTED BYSUCCESSIVEGOVERNMENTSqFAILURESTOADDRESSIMMENSESOCIOECONOMIC DIVIDES)NTHE3ULUARCHIPELAGOANDPARTSOFTHELARGE SOUTHERNISLANDOF -INDANAO -USLIMSECESSIONISTSCHALLENGEDTHECENTRALGOVERNMENTAND DEMANDED ATTENTION TO THEIR LONGSTANDING GRIEVANCES 4HIRD THE EFFEC TIVEREINSTATEMENTOFPREuMARTIALLAWELECTORALANDREPRESENTATIVESTRUC TURESFACILITATEDTHERESTORATIONOFTHEPOWEROFTHEOLDLOCALCLANS WHO DOMINATEDTHENEWLYCONVENEDLEGISLATUREIN-ANILAANDUSEDTHENEW DEMOCRATICDISPENSATIONASANOPPORTUNITYTOREINVIGORATEPRIVATEARMIES THATHADBEENDISMANTLEDUNDER-ARCOS&OURTH WHILEPOLITICALPARTIES EXPANDED IN NUMBER THEY REMAIN TODAY NEARLY INDISTINGUISHABLE FROM ONEANOTHERINTERMSOFPROGRAMMATICANDPOLICYPOSITIONS




*OURNALOF$EMOCRACY

0OLITICIANS HAVE LITTLE ALLEGIANCE TO PARTY LABELS FREQUENTLY BOLTING FROMONEPARTYTOANOTHERINSEARCHOFTHEGREATESTACCESSTOPATRONAGERE SOURCES0OLITICALDIVIDESAREEVER SHIFTING UNITINGFORMERRIVALSANDDI VIDINGFORMERALLIESINACONTINUALPROCESSOFALIGNMENTANDREALIGNMENT ALMOSTENTIRELYDIVORCEDFROMCOHERENTPOSITIONSONPOLICIESORPROGRAMS !TTIMES ITSEEMSASCOMMONFORCANDIDATESTOPUTUPPARTIESASITISFOR PARTIESTOPUTUPCANDIDATES0OLITICALSCIENTIST.ATHAN1UIMPOPROVIDES PERHAPSTHEBESTDESCRIPTIONOFCONTEMPORARY0HILIPPINEPOLITICALPARTIES rCONVENIENTVEHICLESOFPATRONAGETHATCANBESETUP MERGEDWITHOTH ERS SPLIT RECONSTITUTED REGURGITATED RESURRECTED RENAMED REPACKAGED RECYCLED REFURBISHED BUFFEDUPORFLUSHEDDOWNTHETOILETANYTIMEs )N AN ENVIRONMENT IN WHICH POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS ARE WEAK DIFFER ENCESINLEADERSHIPSTYLESHAVEAPARTICULARLYLARGEIMPACTONPOLITICAL OUTCOMES 4HE FOUR POST -ARCOS PRESIDENTS VARY ENORMOUSLY IN THE QUALITY AND GOALS OF THEIR LEADERSHIP #ORAZON !QUINO R u WIDOWOFAMARTYREDPOLITICIAN MIGHTBECHARACTERIZEDASANELITERES TORATIONIST SINCEHERMAJORACHIEVEMENTWASTOREBUILDTHEELITE DOMI NATEDDEMOCRATICSTRUCTURESUNDERMINEDBYHERAUTHORITARIANPREDECES SOR&ORMERGENERAL&IDEL2AMOSRu WASTHEMILITARYREFORMER WHO ACHIEVED CONSIDERABLE SUCCESS IN BRINGING ABOUT ECONOMIC RE FORMTHROUGHDEFTMANIPULATIONOFOLD STYLEPATRONAGEPOLITICS*OSEPH %STRADARu AFORMERMOVIESTAR WASTHEPOPULISTSELF AG GRANDIZER WHO BUILT A STRONG FOLLOWING AMONG THE MASSES AND THEN REDISTRIBUTED WEALTH IN FAVOR OF HIS FAMILY AND FRIENDS ANGER OVER HIS CORRUPTIONLEDTOHISDOWNFALLVIAr0EOPLE0OWER))sIN*ANUARY &INALLY 0RESIDENT'LORIA-ACAPAGAL !RROYORuPRESENT AFORMER PRESIDENTqSDAUGHTERANDTHEHOLDEROFADOCTORATEINECONOMICS MIGHT BECALLEDTHEGREATCOMPROMISER GIVENHERWILLINGNESSTOACCOMMODATE ANYONEABLETOHELPHERRETAINTHEPRESIDENCY

!N%LECTION3CANDALAND)TS!FTERMATH /NTHESURFACE THE-AYMIDTERMELECTIONSSEEMEDTODEM ONSTRATETHEVITALITYOF0HILIPPINEDEMOCRACY3OME CANDIDATES CONTESTED MORE THAN   LOCAL AND NATIONAL POSTS 4WO THIRDS OF REGISTERED VOTERS EXERCISED THEIR RIGHT TO VOTE (UNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF CITIZENS MOBILIZED TO GUARD THE POLLS IN FOUR FIFTHS OR MORE OF THE NATIONqSPRECINCTS ANDTOMONITORTHEVOTECOUNTAFTERWARD)NTHESENA TORIALELECTIONS WIDELYVIEWEDASAPOPULARREFERENDUMONTHE!RROYO ADMINISTRATION CANDIDATES RUNNING UNDER AN AD HOC LABEL OF r'ENUINE /PPOSITIONsENDEDUPWINNINGAMAJORITYOFTHESEATSATSTAKE DE SPITE LARGE SUMS EXPENDED BY THOSE WHO CAMPAIGNED UNDER THE PRESI DENTqSRIVALBANNEROFr4EAM5NITYs ! CLOSER LOOK HOWEVER REVEALS THAT THE 0HILIPPINE ELECTORAL PRO CESSISALIVEBUTNOTWELL4HEMOSTRECENTELECTIONSWENTFORWARDUN


0AUL$(UTCHCROFT



DERTHESHADOWOFTHEPRESIDENTIALELECTION AFTERWHICH0RESIDENT -ACAPAGAL !RROYOWASACCUSEDOFPERSONALINVOLVEMENTINANATTEMPT TOFIXTHERESULTS"ECAUSESHECAMEINTOOFFICEINVIAPEOPLEPOW ER -ACAPAGAL !RROYOqSFIRSTTHREEYEARSINTHE0ALACEWEREDOGGEDBY QUESTIONSOFLEGITIMACYvEVENTHOUGHTHE3UPREME#OURTHADGIVENITS IMPRIMATUR TO HER ASCENSION 4HE PRESIDENT WAS DETERMINED TO CORRECT THISATTHEBALLOTBOX ANDINTHEELECTIONSHERCONSIDERABLEPATRON AGE RESOURCES WERE SKILLFULLY DEPLOYED TO LOCAL POLITICIANS THROUGHOUT THEARCHIPELAGO4HEREWEREMANYALLEGATIONSOFIMPROPERUSEOFPUBLIC FUNDS MANIPULATION OF GOVERNMENT PROGRAMS AND TAMPERING WITH THE VOTECOUNT BUTELECTION MONITORINGGROUPSWEREGENERALLYHAPPYTODE CLARETHERESULTSrFREEANDFAIRs-ANYFEAREDTHECONSEQUENCESOFVICTO RYBY-ACAPAGAL !RROYOqSMAJOROPPONENT &ERNANDO0OE *R APOPULAR MOVIE STAR WITH CLOSE TIES TO DEPOSED PRESIDENT %STRADA 4HE .ATIONAL -OVEMENTFOR&REE%LECTIONS.!-&2%, INPARTICULAR SEEMSTOHAVE BEEN MORE CONCERNED WITH GIVING -ACAPAGAL !RROYO LEGITIMACY THAN WITHSAFEGUARDINGTHESANCTITYOFTHEBALLOT 7ITH THE HELP OF rFREE ELECTIONs MONITORS -ACAPAGAL !RROYO MAN AGEDTOWEATHERCRITICISMANDENJOYTHELEGITIMATIONOFHERMILLION VOTE MARGINOVER0OE"YMID  HOWEVER THINGSHADSTARTEDTOUNRAVEL )N-AYCAMEACCUSATIONSTHATHERHUSBANDANDSONWERETAKINGMONTHLY PAYMENTS FROM GAMBLING LORDS 4HIS HAD PARTICULAR RESONANCE BECAUSE HERPREDECESSOR *OSEPH%STRADA HADBEENDRUMMEDOUTOFOFFICEPARTLY DUETOACCUSATIONSOFHEADINGUPALUCRATIVEGAMBLINGSYNDICATE-OST DAMAGING HOWEVER WAS THE BOMBSHELL THAT HIT THE HEADLINES IN *UNE 4APESOFWIRETAPPEDCONVERSATIONSWERERELEASED THOUGHTTOCON TAIN THE VOICE OF THE PRESIDENT TALKING TO A #OMMISSION ON %LECTIONS #/-%,%# COMMISSIONERAMIDTHECOUNTINGOFBALLOTSINTHEWEEKS AFTERTHE-AYELECTION)NONEOFT QUOTEDSEGMENTSAIDTOBEFROM LATE-AY AFEMALEVOICEEXPRESSESCONCERNFORTHEELECTORALMARGINr3O ) WILL STILL LEAD BY MORE THAN ONE - OVERALLs WHILE A MALE VOICE PROMISESTOWORKTHINGSOUT 4HESEACCUSATIONSPRODUCEDAFIRESTORMOFANGERAGAINSTTHE0ALACE ANDLEDTOANATIONALLYTELECASTAPOLOGYFROMTHEPRESIDENTON*UNE 3HE ADMITTED TO IMPROPER CONVERSATIONS WITH THE COMMISSIONER UNSA VORY#/-%,%#VETERAN6IRGILIOr'ARCIs'ARCILLANO BUTDENIEDTHATIT WASHERVOICEONTHELEAKEDTAPES)NRETROSPECT ITSEEMSTHAT-ACAPAGAL !RROYOHADBROUGHTUPONHERSELFASTRINGOFPRESIDENTIALBADLUCKPER HAPSUNRIVALEDSINCE2ICHARD.IXONDECIDEDTORECORDHISCONVERSATIONS INTHE/VAL/FFICE&IRST 'ARCILLANOHADBEENNAMEDACOMMISSIONERIN &EBRUARY SEEMINGLYTODOWHATEVERMIGHTBENECESSARYTOGUAR ANTEE A DECISIVE !RROYO VICTORY IN -AY 4HE 0ALACE THEN BROUGHT THE )NTELLIGENCE3ERVICEOFTHE!RMED&ORCESOFTHE0HILIPPINES)3!&0 UN DERITSWINGTOMONITORELECTION RELATEDCONVERSATIONS INCLUDINGTHOSE OF'ARCILLANOLIKELYOUTOFCONCERNTHATHEMIGHTCUTDEALSFORHIMSELF




*OURNALOF$EMOCRACY

THATCOULDBEDISADVANTAGEOUSTOTHEADMINISTRATION )3!&0PROCEEDED TOTAPETHESECONVERSATIONS ANDTHEPRESIDENTSEEMINGLYHADTHEMISFOR TUNEOFHAVINGHEROWNCONVERSATIONSWITH'ARCILLANOLEAKEDTOOPPOSI TIONFIGURESBYDISGRUNTLEDMILITARY INTELLIGENCEOFFICERS 4HE SECRET TAPES QUICKLY BECAME PART OF THE PUBLIC DOMAIN AND THROUGHOUT THE COUNTRY THE LEGENDARY r(ELLO 'ARCIs GREETING COULD BE HEARD AS A CELL PHONE RING TONE 4HE COUNTRY WAS RIVETED BY WHAT CAME TO BE KNOWN AS THE r(ELLO 'ARCIs SCANDAL AND ON  *ULY  THEREWASACONCERTEDPUSHTOFORCETHEPRESIDENTFROMOFFICE&IRSTCAME THE RESIGNATION OF TEN MEMBERS OF THE CABINET FOLLOWED BY CALLS FOR THE PRESIDENTqS RESIGNATION BY FORMER ALLIES REFORMIST ELEMENTS OF THE ,IBERAL 0ARTY THE INFLUENTIAL -AKATI "USINESS #LUB AND FORMER PRESI DENT!QUINO/PINIONPOLLSREGISTEREDOVERWHELMINGMAJORITIESINFAVOR OF RESIGNATION OR IMPEACHMENT -ACAPAGAL !RROYO SURVIVED THE CRISIS WITHTHECRITICALSUPPORTOFFORMERPRESIDENT2AMOSAND(OUSE3PEAKER *OSEDE6ENECIA *R TOWHOMSHEREPORTEDLYPROMISEDTHATSHEWOULD STEPDOWNFROMOFFICEANDUSHERINACONSTITUTIONALSHIFTTOWARDPARLIA MENTARYGOVERNMENT )N ITS FIGHT FOR SURVIVAL THE !RROYO ADMINISTRATION QUICKLY TRIED TO SHIFTTHETOPICFROMELECTORALSCANDALTOPOLITICALREFORM)NHERANNUAL 3TATE OF THE .ATION ADDRESS IN LATE *ULY  -ACAPAGAL !RROYO DE CLAREDTHATrOURPOLITICALSYSTEMHASDEGENERATEDTOSUCHANEXTENTTHAT ITqS VERY DIFFICULT TO LIVE WITHIN THE SYSTEM WITH HANDS TOTALLY UNTAINT EDs7HILETHISSTATEMENTWASNODOUBTANEFFORTTOEMPHASIZESYSTEMIC RATHER THAN PERSONAL ACCOUNTABILITY IT HAD BECOME CLEAR TO MANY THAT 0HILIPPINE DEMOCRACY WAS BADLY IN NEED OF REFORM 7HILE THE CRISES OFANDHADBEENPRIMARILYCONCERNEDWITHTHELEGITIMACYOF INDIVIDUALLEADERS THEr(ELLO 'ARCIsCRISISHIGHLIGHTEDTHELEGITIMACY DEFICIT NOT ONLY OF AN INDIVIDUAL LEADER BUT ALSO OF AN ENTIRE POLITICAL SYSTEM)NHERSPEECH THEPRESIDENTURGEDTHECOUNTRYTOrSTARTTHEGREAT DEBATEONCHARTERCHANGEsANDSPECIFICALLYMENTIONEDBUTDIDNOTEX PLICITLYENDORSE THEPOSSIBILITYOFSHIFTINGTHECOUNTRYqSPOLITICALSTRUC TURESFROMPRESIDENTIALTOPARLIAMENTARYANDFROMUNITARYTOFEDERAL !LTHOUGH THE 3PEAKER OF THE (OUSE MAY HAVE DESIRED MORE WHOLE HEARTEDSUPPORTFORASHIFTTOPARLIAMENTARISM DE6ENECIANONETHELESS CAMETO-ACAPAGAL !RROYOqSAIDIN3EPTEMBERBYENSURINGTHATANIM PEACHMENTATTEMPTWOULDNOTMUSTERTHENECESSARYSUPPORTOFONE THIRD OFTHEMEMBERSOFTHE(OUSEOF2EPRESENTATIVES4HISISCONSISTENTWITH HISTORICAL PATTERNS IN0HILIPPINEPOLITICS4HEPOWEROFTHEPORKBARREL ENABLESPRESIDENTSTOMAKEORBREAKTHESPEAKER WHOINTURNMUSTDE LIVERTHELOYALTYOFTHEOVERWHELMINGMAJORITYOFTHE(OUSE /THERFACTORSALSOASSISTED-ACAPAGAL !RROYOINHERFIGHTFORSURVIV AL &IRST THE LATE  DEATH OF &ERNANDO 0OE *R HER OPPONENT IN THE ELECTIONS DEPRIVED THE OPPOSITION OF AN OBVIOUS FIGURE AROUND WHOM ITCOULDRALLY3ECOND STRONGPUBLICSENTIMENTAGAINSTTHEPRESIDENTDID


0AUL$(UTCHCROFT



NOTTRANSLATEINTOAREPEATEPISODEOFPEOPLEPOWER$EMONSTRATIONSWERE CALLED BUTTHEYFAILEDTODRAWLARGECROWDS-ANYATTHETIMESPOKEOF rPEOPLEPOWERFATIGUE sBUTTHEREWASPROBABLYADEEPERDISILLUSIONMENT AT PLAY 4HIS TIME AROUND IT WAS DIFFICULT FOR CITIZENS TO NURSE HOPES THATAMERECHANGEINLEADERSHIPWOULDFIXTHEPROBLEMSOFTHECOUNTRY -ANYSEEMEDTIREDOFBEINGPAWNSININTRAELITESQUABBLESTHATULTIMATELY BROUGHTLITTLECHANGE4HIRD -ACAPAGAL !RROYOWASAIDEDBYWIDESPREAD CONCERNS OVER THE POSSIBILITY THAT THE VICE PRESIDENT FORMER NEWSCAST ER .OLI DE #ASTRO MIGHT COME TO POWER !LTHOUGH STRONG IN TERMS OF MASSAPPEAL DE#ASTROISNOTHIGHLYRESPECTEDAMONGTHOSEINTHEUPPER CLASSESANDHASALLEGEDLYPROFITEDFROMUNSEEMLYJOURNALISTICPRACTICES &INALLY THEPRESIDENTHADDONEAMASTERFULJOBOFCULTIVATINGTHELOYALTY OFKEYGENERALS$ESPITESIGNIFICANTDISCONTENTINTHELOWERRANKS THETOP BRASSHASUPUNTILNOWREMAINEDFIRMLYINHERCAMP

!4ENDENCY4OWARD!UTHORITARIANISM 4HE LOYALTY OF THE GENERALS BECAME ESPECIALLY VALUABLE IN &EBRUARY  WHEN A COMBINATION OF JUNIOR OFFICERS ON THE RIGHT AND CIVILIAN FORCES ON THE LEFT WANTED TO CELEBRATE THE TWENTIETH ANNIVERSARY OF THE DOWNFALL OF -ARCOS WITH A PUTSCH TO BRING DOWN -ACAPAGAL !RROYO 7HEN CERTAIN TOP OFFICERS WERE ASKED TO JOIN THEY REPORTED THE PLOT TO THE0ALACE4HISTHENLEDTOTHEDECLARATIONOFEMERGENCYRULE COINCIDING WITHTHEANNIVERSARYOFTHECOUNTRYqSTRANSITIONTODEMOCRACYTWODECADES EARLIER!S3HEILA#ORONELOBSERVES r4HATMORNINGIN&EBRUARYSAWTHE MEETINGOFTHETWOMOSTPOWERFULNARRATIVESOFRECENT0HILIPPINEHISTORY THE DECLARATION OF MARTIAL LAW IN  AND THE  POPULAR UPRISING 7HAT&ILIPINOSGOTINWEREPALEVERSIONSOFBOTHs)NTHEEND THE DEMONSTRATIONSWERESUPPRESSED BUTTHESTATEOFEMERGENCYLASTEDONLY AFEWWEEKSANDWASLATERRULEDILLEGALBYTHE3UPREME#OURT -ACAPAGAL !RROYOqSDEPENDENCEONTHEMILITARY COMBINEDWITHHER ADMINISTRATIONqSOWNINCLINATIONTOLAUNCHACRACKDOWN LEDTOTHE*UNE DECLARATIONOFANrALL OUTWARsAGAINSTTHENEARLYTHREE DECADE OLD COMMUNISTINSURGENCY4HISCAMEAMIDMOUNTINGCONCERNOVERTHEKILL INGSOFHUNDREDSOFLEFTISTS ACTIVISTS ANDCHURCHPERSONNELr!SSENIOR OFFICIALSANDMILITARYOFFICERSLABELEDMEMBERSOFTHELEGALLEFTpENEMIES OFTHESTATE qANDFAILEDTOCONDEMNTHEKILLINGSCONSISTENTLYATALLLEVELS OFGOVERNMENT sCONCLUDESA!MNESTY)NTERNATIONALREPORT rFEARS GREWTHATELEMENTSWITHINTHEARMEDFORCESMIGHTINTERPRETTHISASATACIT SIGNALTHATPOLITICALKILLINGSWEREALEGITIMATEPARTOFTHEANTIINSURGENCY CAMPAIGNs!CCORDINGTO(UMAN2IGHTS7ATCH NOTASINGLEPERPETRATOR HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY PROSECUTED 0RESIDENT -ACAPAGAL !RROYOqS OWN INVESTIGATIVECOMMISSIONCONCLUDESTHATrSOMEELEMENTSINTHEMILITARY WEREBEHINDTHEKILLINGOFACTIVISTSsANDTHATRANKINGARMED FORCESPER SONNELHAVEFAILEDINTHEIRDUTYTOINVESTIGATE PUNISH ANDPREVENTTHE




*OURNALOF$EMOCRACY

KILLINGS!FTERANEARLYFACT FINDINGMISSION A5.SPECIALRAPPOR TEUREXPRESSEDCONCERNABOUTTHEIMPACTOFTHESEKILLINGSONTHEDEMO CRATIC PROCESS r)T INTIMIDATES VAST NUMBERS OF CIVIL SOCIETY ACTORS IT SENDSAMESSAGEOFVULNERABILITYTOALLBUTTHEMOSTWELLCONNECTED AND ITSEVERELYUNDERMINESTHEPOLITICALDISCOURSEWHICHISCENTRALTOARESO LUTIONOFTHEPROBLEMSCONFRONTINGTHISCOUNTRYs &URTHERCHALLENGESTODEMOCRATICDISCOURSEHAVECOMEINTHEFORMOF ATTACKSONTHEPRESS)N 2EPORTERS7ITHOUT"ORDERSDECLAREDTHAT r;A=FTER)RAQ THE0HILIPPINESISTHEMOSTDANGEROUSCOUNTRYFORJOURNAL ISTSs4HIRTY TWOJOURNALISTSWEREKILLEDFORTHEIRREPORTINGBETWEEN AND BUTONLYTWOCASESHAVELEDTOCONVICTIONS4HEGOVERNMENT COMMISSION ON MEDIA AND ACTIVIST KILLINGS POINTS THE FINGER AT rLOCAL POLITICIANS WARLORDS OR BIG BUSINESS INTERESTSs DRIVEN BY A RANGE OF MAINLYLOCALMOTIVES!NEWERMODEOFMEDIAHARASSMENTWASLAUNCHED BYTHEPRESIDENTqSHUSBAND r&IRST'ENTLEMANs*OSE-IGUEL!RROYO WHO INFILEDDEFAMATIONSUITSSEEKINGATOTALOFMILLIONINDAMAGES AGAINSTJOURNALISTS(EOBJECTEDTOSTORIESACCUSINGHIMOFINVOLVE MENTINVOTERIGGINGANDCORRUPTIONIFCONVICTEDOFDEFAMATION ACRIMI NALOFFENSE THEJOURNALISTSCOULDALSOFACEIMPRISONMENTFORSIXMONTHS TOSIXYEARS!GOVERNMENTATTEMPTTOCHARGEOTHERJOURNALISTSWITHSEDI TIONINTHEWAKEOFTHE&EBRUARYCOUPATTEMPTWASBLOCKEDBYTHE 3UPREME #OURT )T IS NOT CLEAR TO WHAT EXTENT THESE LEGAL CHARGES WILL INTIMIDATEOREMBOLDENTHEMEDIA PARTICULARLYGIVENTHATLIBELANDSEDI TION LAWS HAVE NOT IN THE PAST BEEN EFFECTIVE MEANS OF CURBING MEDIA CRITICISMOFGOVERNMENTOFFICIALS#OMBINEDWITHTHEKILLINGS HOWEVER THESE LEGAL CHARGES MUST BE VIEWED AS AN ATTACK ON ONE OF THE MAJOR BULWARKSOF0HILIPPINEDEMOCRACY 7HILEDEMONSTRATINGITSAUTHORITARIANINCLINATIONS THE!RROYOGOVERN MENTSIMULTANEOUSLYSTEPPEDUPTHECAMPAIGNTOREVAMPTHECOUNTRYqS DEMOCRATICSTRUCTURES!SIN THISWASMOTIVATEDINPARTBYANEED TOENCOURAGE3PEAKERDE6ENECIAqSACTIVESUPPORTINQUASHINGASECOND IMPEACHMENTATTEMPT4HISGOALWASACCOMPLISHEDIN!UGUST JUST ASTHE0ALACEWASMOBILIZINGTENSOFTHOUSANDSOFLOCALPOLITICIANSINTHE PROVINCES TO SUPPORT CHARTER CHANGE VIA A NATIONWIDE rPEOPLEqS INITIA TIVEs-ILLIONSOFSIGNATURESFROMTHROUGHOUTTHECOUNTRYWERESOLICITED INFAVOROFASHIFTFROMABICAMERALPRESIDENTIALSYSTEMTOAUNICAMERAL PARLIAMENTARYSYSTEM BUTTHE3UPREME#OURTRULEDIN/CTOBERTHATTHE CAMPAIGNFELLSHORTOFCONSTITUTIONALREQUIREMENTS )NADESPERATEYEAR ENDMOVE DE6ENECIAANDHISALLIESINTHE(OUSE TRIEDTOPUSHFORREVISIONOFTHECONSTITUTIONvCREATINGAUNICAMERALPAR LIAMENTvTHROUGHTHEALTERNATIVEMODEOFCONSTITUENTASSEMBLY4HEAL READYSCHEDULED-AYCONGRESSIONALPOLLSWOULDBECANCELEDINFA VOROF.OVEMBERELECTIONSFORANINTERIMPARLIAMENTARYBODYTHAT WOULDSERVEUNTIL-ACAPAGAL !RROYOWOULDSERVEOUTHERTERMAS PRESIDENTUNTIL ATWHICHPOINTBOTHSHEANDDE6ENECIAWOULDBE


0AUL$(UTCHCROFT



ELIGIBLETORUNFORPARLIAMENTANDSEEKTHEPOSTOFPRIMEMINISTER4HE PLANWASASPECTACULARFAILURE3ENATORS NOTSURPRISINGLY WEREOPPOSED TOREFORMSDESIGNEDTOABOLISHTHEIRCHAMBER ANDTHEYWEREJOINEDBY THE #ATHOLIC BISHOPS ANTI !RROYO FORCES AND THOSE WHO FAVORED CON STITUTIONALCHANGEBUTWANTEDITTOCOMETHROUGHTHEMOREDELIBERATIVE MODEOFAPOPULARLYELECTEDCONSTITUTIONALCONVENTION

%LECTION)NTRIGUE !SSOONASTHEPLANWASDEFEATED THECOUNTRYqSPOLITICALELITESREFO CUSEDTHEIRATTENTIONONTHE-AYMIDTERMELECTIONS)THASALREADY BEENNOTEDTHATINTHE3ENATEvWHEREHALFTHESEATSAREELECTEDEVERY THREEYEARSFROMASINGLE NATIONALDISTRICTv-ACAPAGAL !RROYOqSFORCES WERESOUNDLYDEFEATED4HEMOSTSTUNNINGREBUKETO-ACAPAGAL !RROYO WAS THE ELECTION OF OPPOSITION SENATOR !NTONIO 4RILLANES )6 ACCUSED OF BEING A MASTERMIND OF THE FAILED ANTI !RROYO MUTINY OF *ULY  4HE  YEAR OLD FORMER NAVY OFFICER WON ELEVEN MILLION VOTES FOR AN ELEVENTH PLACEFINISH DESPITECAMPAIGNINGFROMHISPRISONCELL)NTHE (OUSE AS WAS TO BE EXPECTED THE PRESIDENTqS CONTROL OVER PATRONAGE RESOURCESENSUREDTHATTHEADMINISTRATIONCOALITIONWOULDBESUCCESSFUL INGAININGANOVERWHELMINGMAJORITYOFTHESINGLE MEMBER DISTRICT LEVELSEATS )NASIN THEELECTIONSREVEALEDMAJORSHORTCOMINGSINTHE COUNTRYqS DEMOCRATIC STRUCTURES 4HE 0HILIPPINE BALLOT IS PROBABLY ONE OF THE MOST ARCHAIC IN THE WORLD AS VOTERS ARE REQUIRED TO FILL IN BY HAND THENAMESOFALLCANDIDATESFORWHOMTHEYAREVOTING4HEVOTE TALLYISTHENCOMPILED ALSOBYHAND7ITHTHIRTYMILLIONBALLOTSCASTLAST -AY EACHCONTAININGTHEVOTESFORROUGHLYTOPOSITIONS ELECTION OFFICIALSFACEDTHEGARGANTUANTASKOFCOUNTINGALMOSTABILLIONPREFER ENCES IN ALL 4HIS LABORIOUS PROCESS IS HIGHLY SUSCEPTIBLE TO FRAUD !S OFFICIALELECTIONTALLIESBEGINTHEIRLONGMIGRATIONFROMLOCALPRECINCTS THROUGHOUTTHE0HILIPPINEARCHIPELAGOTO-ANILAOVERTHECOURSEOFSEV ERALWEEKS POLITICIANSCANUSEAVARIETYOFTACTICSTOSUPPLEMENTRETAIL VOTEPURCHASESWITHWHOLESALEMANIPULATIONOFTHEVOTECOUNT )N EACH OF THE LAST TWO ELECTIONS THE #OMMISSION ON %LECTIONS HAS DEMONSTRATED ITSELF TO BE FABULOUSLY INCOMPETENT AND OFTEN VERY COR RUPT INPERFORMINGITSTHREEBASICTASKSOFPREPARINGFORELECTIONS EXE CUTINGTHEPOLLINGPROCESS ANDCOUNTINGTHEVOTES.!-&2%,REPORTED THATIN DUETOHUGEERRORSIN#/-%,%#qSVOTERLISTS rDISENFRAN CHISEMENT MAY HAVE RUN AS HIGH AS TWO MILLION VOTERSs 4HERE HAS LONGBEENTALKOFMODERNIZINGTHEBALLOT BUTALLEGATIONSOFCORRUPTION HAVEIMPEDEDCHANGE-OSTRECENTLY IN A#/-%,%#ATTEMPTTO AUTOMATETHEELECTORALSYSTEMWASNULLIFIEDBYTHE3UPREME#OURTDUE TO BIDDING VIOLATIONS &INALLY THE LONG VOTE COUNT PROVIDES AMPLE OP PORTUNITIESFORELECTIONOFFICIALSTOSOLICITPAYOFFSNOTONLYFROMTRAILING




*OURNALOF$EMOCRACY

CANDIDATESWANTINGTOPADTHEIRVOTES BUTALSOFROMLEADINGCANDIDATES NEEDINGTOPROTECTTHEIRVOTESAGAINSTTHECHEATINGOFOTHERS !FTERTHE-AYELECTIONS ITTOOKALMOSTTWOMONTHSBEFORETHE TWELFTH RANKED CANDIDATE WAS PROCLAIMED A VICTOR IN THE 3ENATE CON TEST -ANY OF THE CHARGES AND COUNTERCHARGES FOCUSED ON -INDANAOqS REMOTE PROVINCE OF -AGUINDANAO THE DETAILS OF WHICH ILLUSTRATE COM PLEX INTERACTIONS BETWEEN THE ADMINISTRATION #/-%,%# AND LOCAL POWERHOLDERS)NTHERUN UPTOTHEELECTIONS EACHREGIONOFTHECOUNTRY WASPUTUNDERTHESUPERVISIONOFAPARTICULAR#/-%,%#COMMISSION ER "ENJAMIN !BALOS A POLITICAL ALLY OF THE &IRST 'ENTLEMAN WHO HAD BEENAPPOINTED#/-%,%#CHAIRIN ASSUMEDINITIALRESPONSIBILITY FOR THE POLLS IN -INDANAO AND THEN PLACED KEY LIEUTENANTS IN STRATEGIC POSTS )N -AGUINDANAO HIS PROVINCIAL ELECTION SUPERVISOR WAS A WELL KNOWNPROTÈGÈOF'ARCILLANOWHOHADMERITEDFREQUENTMENTIONINTHE r(ELLO 'ARCIsTAPESANDWASLINKEDTOSUSPICIOUSLYSTRONGPRO !RROYO RESULTS IN THE  ELECTION 7ITHOUT THE EFFECTIVE OVERSIGHT OF EITHER #/-%,%# OR ELECTION MONITORS WHO WERE BARRED FROM MANY LOCALI TIES -ACAPAGAL !RROYOqSPOLITICALALLIESIN-AGUINDANAOWEREABLETO DELIVERASWEEPTOHER4EAM5NITYSENATORIALCANDIDATES 4HE KEY FIGURE IN SECURING THIS OUTCOME WAS 'OVERNOR !NDAL !MPATUAN WHO COMMANDS A SUBSTANTIAL PARAMILITARY FORCE AND HAS A REPUTATION FOR USING VIOLENCE AGAINST HIS POLITICAL ENEMIES r7HATEVER THEPRESIDENTWANTS HEWILLFOLLOW sSAIDAFAMILYFRIENDTO.EWSBREAK r ISWHAT-AqAMWANTSs!MPATUANISNODOUBTWELL REWARDEDBY THE0ALACE BUTSEEMINGLYCUTSDEALSFORHISOWNBENEFITASWELL!MONG THE4EAM5NITYHOPEFULS ITISREPORTEDTHATrTHERANKINGOFINDIVIDUAL CANDIDATES DEPENDED ON HOW MUCH THEY WOULD PAY UPs 2UMOR HAS IT THAT THE TOP SENATORIAL SLOT IN -AGUINDANAO WENT TO A NORTHERN ,UZON STRONGMANFORTHESUMOFMILLIONPESOS53   !SIDE FROM MONEY VIOLENCE IS ALSO A USEFUL TOOL FOR GAINING POLITI CALPOWER!CCORDINGTOPOLICESTATISTICS THEREWEREELECTION RELAT EDKILLINGSIN MORETHANDOUBLETHATOFTHELASTGENERALELECTIONS IN  )N  THERE WERE  ELECTION RELATED KILLINGS MARGINALLY MORETHANTHEPERSONSKILLEDINTHELASTMIDTERMELECTIONS IN !CCORDING TO POLITICAL SCIENTIST *OEL 2OCAMORA THE HIGH STAKES OF THE POLITICALGAMEENCOURAGECANDIDATESTOUSEWHATEVERMEANSPOSSIBLETO ACHIEVEVICTORY %LECTIONSPROVIDETHEFORMALEXPRESSIONOFLOCALPOLITICALCONTESTSTHATHAVE HISTORICALLYBEENMAINLYABOUTWHOCONTROLSTHERESOURCESFROMTHECENTRAL GOVERNMENT AND ILLEGAL ECONOMIC ACTIVITY    4HE CONTEST OVER CONTROL OFTHESEACTIVITIESGIVESAPREMIUMTOLEADERSWITHSKILLSINMANIPULATING ILLEGALITYANDTHEUSESOFVIOLENCE

!TTHELEAST ONECANSAYTHATTHENATIONALPOLICEANDTHE0HILIPPINE ARMED FORCES ARE UNABLE TO SAFEGUARD THE ELECTORAL PROCESS FAR MORE


0AUL$(UTCHCROFT



DISTURBING IS WHEN THEIR COERCIVE POWER IS DEPLOYED IN FAVOR OF ONE CANDIDATEOVERANOTHER!NOTHERARMEDFORCE THECOMMUNIST.ATIONAL 0EOPLEqS!RMY HASUSEDITSCOERCIVECAPACITYFORACOMBINATIONOFEN TREPRENEURIAL AND POLITICAL ENDS EXTORTING PERMIT TO CAMPAIGN FEES IN THEAREASTHATITCONTROLS OCCASIONALLYHIRINGITSELFOUTFORINTRAELITEPO LITICALASSASSINATIONS ANDINTIMIDATINGRIVALOPPONENTSONTHELEFT 4HE ANALYSIS THUS FAR HAS FOCUSED ON THE CHALLENGES OF DEMOCRAT IC PROCESS IN PARTICULAR THE CONDUCT OF FREE FAIR AND SAFE ELECTIONS %QUALLY IMPORTANT IS THE CAPACITY OF A POLITICAL SYSTEM TO PROVIDE THE CITIZENRY WITH THE OPPORTUNITY FOR DEMOCRATIC OUTCOMES NOTABLY CLEAR CHOICESAMONGCONTENDINGVIEWSANDPROGRAMS$EMOCRACYSHOULD AF TERALL INVOLVECITIZENSINTHEIROWNGOVERNANCE0HILIPPINEDEMOCRACY ASITHASDEVELOPEDOVERTHEPASTCENTURY HOWEVER PRIVILEGESPERSON ALITIESANDPATRONAGEOVERPARTIESANDPLATFORMS%LECTORALVICTORYTHUS FREQUENTLYINVOLVESPROMISINGVOTERSSOMESHORT TERMGAIN WHETHERIT BETHEPURCHASEOFAVOTEORTHEPLEDGETOCONSTRUCTAHEALTHCENTER ROAD ORNEIGHBORHOODBASKETBALLCOURT 4HIS PRODUCES HIGH COST POLITICSvCOSTLY IN MONETARY TERMS AND IN THEGROSSUNDERMININGOFTHEDEMOCRATICIDEAL7HENCANDIDATESBUYOR COERCE THEIR WAY INTO OFFICE THEY HAVE LITTLE REASON TO BE ACCOUNTABLE TOTHEELECTORATE4HEIRACCOUNTABILITY RATHER ISTOTHOSEWHOHAVEFI NANCEDTHEPASTCAMPAIGNEFFORTANDTOTHOSEWHOMIGHTBECALLEDUPON FOR ASSISTANCE DURING THE NEXT ELECTIONS !S 0HILIPPINE ELECTIONS HAVE BECOMEINCREASINGLYCOSTLY THEYHAVEENCOURAGEDPOLITICIANSTOBECOME MORECREATIVEINRAISINGFUNDS WHETHERTHROUGHTHEPROMISEOFLEGISLA TIVEANDREGULATORYFAVORS REAL ESTATESCAMS INVOLVEMENTINGAMBLING SYNDICATES ORLINKSTODRUGLORDSANDTHEUNDERWORLD)NASURPRISINGLY CANDID MOMENT 3PEAKER DE 6ENECIA EXPLAINED THE SYSTEM r)TqS THE DRUGLORDSANDTHEGAMBLINGLORDSWHOFINANCETHECANDIDATES3O FROM$AY/NE THEYBECOMECORRUPT3OTHEWHOLEPOLITICALPROCESSIS ROTTENs

0ROSPECTSFOR0OLITICAL2EFORMAND#HARTER#HANGE 4HE 0HILIPPINES HAS NOW HAD A LONGER STRETCH OF LIFE AFTER -ARCOS THANLIFEUNDER-ARCOS!STHEPOST -ARCOSERAENTERSITSTHIRDDECADE THEHIGHHOPESFORDEMOCRACYVOICEDINTHEMID SHAVEGIVENWAY TODISILLUSIONMENTWITHTHECOUNTRYqSLOWQUALITYOFGOVERNANCE0OLLS MEASURING OVERALL SATISFACTION WITH rTHE WAY DEMOCRACY WORKSs WERE IN THE RANGE OF  TO  PERCENT UNDER 2AMOS AND  TO  PERCENT UNDER%STRADA INEACHCASEPEAKINGATPERCENTAFTERTHEIRRESPECTIVE VICTORIESINTHEGENERALELECTIONSOFAND RESPECTIVELY5NDER -ACAPAGAL !RROYO THE RANGE IS  TO  PERCENT PEAKING AT  PER CENTINTHEWAKEOFTHEMIDTERMELECTIONSTHATBROUGHTOPPOSITION VICTORIESINTHE3ENATE.OOTHERPOST -ARCOSPRESIDENTHASHADLOWER




*OURNALOF$EMOCRACY

APPROVALRATINGSTHAN-ACAPAGAL !RROYO WHOISTHEFIRSTTOPLUNGEINTO NEGATIVE NUMBERS IN HER rNET SATISFACTION RATINGs  PERCENT IN -AY  IMPROVINGTO PERCENTIN*UNE/NEMAJORBRIGHTSPOTFOR -ACAPAGAL !RROYO HOWEVER HASBEENTHEVERYRESPECTABLEECONOMIC GROWTHRATES WHICHHAVEGAINEDHERSUBSTANTIALSUPPORTFROMELEMENTS WITHINTHEBUSINESSCOMMUNITY4HEADMINISTRATIONCANALSOPOINTWITH PRIDE TO RECENT PROGRESS IN PEACE NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE MAJOR -USLIM SECESSIONISTGROUPIN-INDANAO 4HESE IMPORTANT SUCCESSES NOTWITHSTANDING 0HILIPPINE DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTIONS ARE NOT INSPIRING FAITH AMONG THE CITIZENRY )N THE MONTH PRIORTOTHEELECTIONS PERCENTOFTHOSESURVEYEDEXPECTEDVOTE BUYINGANDPERCENTANTICIPATEDCHEATINGINTHEVOTECOUNTSUBSTAN TIALLYHIGHERPERCENTAGESTHANTHOSEREGISTEREDPRIORTOTHEAND ELECTIONS )NASURVEY #/-%,%#WASAMONGTHEFOURAGENCIES THATTHEPUBLICRATEDASrVERYBADsINTERMSOFrSINCERITYINFIGHTINGCOR RUPTIONs 4HERE HAVE LONG BEEN PROBLEMS AT #/-%,%# BUT THE LEVEL OF POLITICIZATION UNDER THE !RROYO GOVERNMENT IS PERCEIVED TO BE PAR TICULARLYGRAVE3IMILARSTORIESCANBETOLDREGARDINGTHEDECLINEOFOTHER IMPORTANTPOLITICALINSTITUTIONS INCLUDINGTHE(OUSEOF2EPRESENTATIVES CURRENTLYSUBORDINATEDTOTHE0ALACEEVENMORETHOROUGHLYTHANUSUAL  THEJUDICIARYWITHTHE3UPREME#OURTANIMPORTANTANDENCOURAGINGEX CEPTION THE/FFICEOFTHE/MBUDSMANNOWHEADEDBYTHEPRESIDENTqS FORMERCHIEFLEGALCOUNSEL ANDTHEMILITARYRECALLTHEUSEOFMILITARY INTELLIGENCEFORELECTORALPURPOSES DISCUSSEDABOVE  -ANYBELIEVETHATTHEBESTWAYTOADDRESSTHISDISILLUSIONMENTISTO REFORM DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTIONS "UT THOSE WHO ADVOCATE rPOLITICAL RE FORMsHAVEARANGEOFIDEASASTOWHATSHOULDBECHANGEDANDTOWHAT EXTENT AS WELL AS HOW TO ACCOMPLISH THE CHANGES 'IVEN CURRENT LEV ELS OF DISILLUSIONMENT SOME SUGGEST THAT WHATEVER POLITICAL SET UP THE 0HILIPPINESPRESENTLYHASSHOULDBEDISCARDED)FTHECOUNTRYISCURRENTLY UNDER A PRESIDENTIAL SYSTEM IT SHOULD SHIFT TO PARLIAMENTARISM )F IT IS CURRENTLYUNITARY THENFEDERALISMISTHESOLUTION 4HE BIGGER THE CHANGE HOWEVER THE GREATER THE RISK OF UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES LEADING SOME TO CALL FOR WELL TARGETED INCREMENTAL RE FORMS INSTITUTED WITH PARTICULAR GOALS IN MIND ! CENTRAL OVERARCHING GOALSHOULDBETHEFOSTERINGOFSTRONGERANDMOREPROGRAMMATICPOLITICAL PARTIES)NTHESEPAGESNEARLYADECADEAGO 'ABRIELA-ONTINOLAARGUED THAT r;M=EANINGFUL SOCIAL CHANGE HAS BEEN INHIBITED BECAUSE POLITICAL PARTIES HAVE FAILED TO STRUCTURE POLITICAL COMPETITION TO ALLOW FOR THE REPRESENTATIONOFTHEINTERESTSOFTHEPOORANDMARGINALIZEDSECTORSs ! GOOD STARTING POINT WOULD BE SUCH MODEST ELECTORAL REFORMS AS PRE PRINTEDBALLOTS ACONSOLIDATEDTICKETFORTHEELECTIONOFPRESIDENTSAND VICE PRESIDENTS ANDANOPTIONFORSTRAIGHT PARTYVOTING 4WOSOMEWHATMOREAMBITIOUSELECTORALREFORMS ONEFORTHE3ENATE AND ONE FOR THE (OUSE COULD HAVE MUCH GREATER IMPACT IN PROMOTING


0AUL$(UTCHCROFT



STRONGERPARTIES4HEFIRSTWOULDBETOSCRAPTHECURRENTSYSTEMINWHICH SENATORS ARE ELECTED FROM ONE NATIONWIDE DISTRICT THIS LEADS TO INTRA PARTYCOMPETITIONANDFORCESEACHCANDIDATETOCUTHISORHEROWNDEALS WITHLOCALPOWERHOLDERSTHROUGHOUTTHEARCHIPELAGO4HESECONDCHANGE WOULDBETOABOLISHTHECURRENTPARTY LIST SYSTEM THROUGH WHICH  PERCENT OF THE Incremental measures of MEMBERSOFTHE(OUSEARESELECTED7HILE political reform rather MOST STANDARD PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTA than a wholesale shift TION SYSTEMS REQUIRE PARTIES TO ACHIEVE A to parliamentarism CERTAINPERCENTAGEOFTHEVOTEINORDERTO HAVESEATSINTHELEGISLATURE THE0HILIPPINE or federalism seem to hold greater promise for PARTY LISTSYSTEMISDISTINGUISHEDBOTHBY A VERY LOW FLOOR  PERCENT AND BY THE success. PRESENCEOFACEILING)NCREDIBLY NOSIN GLEPARTYISPERMITTEDTOHAVEMORETHAN THREESEATSINTHELEGISLATURE4HISENTIRELYUNDERMINESTHEGOALOFAGGRE GATINGINTERESTSUNDERONEPARTYLABEL&OLLOWINGTHEEXAMPLEOF*APAN AND3OUTH+OREA THE0HILIPPINESCOULDCONSIDERADOPTINGAMIXEDSYS TEMINVOLVINGBOTHSINGLE MEMBER DISTRICTSEATSANDSOMEELEMENTOFA MORESTANDARDPROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATIONSYSTEM !NOTHERWELL TARGETEDREFORM MORERELEVANTTOPROCESSTHANTOOUT COMES RELATES TO ELECTORAL ADMINISTRATION #/-%,%# SHOULD BE RE STRUCTUREDFROMTOPTOBOTTOMvFROMITSCENTRALOFFICEIN-ANILATOITS EXTENSIVE NATIONWIDE FIELD STRUCTUREvIN ORDER TO DEVELOP THE CAPACITY TO MAINTAIN ACCURATE LISTS OF VOTERS AND EXECUTE AN ACCURATE AND EXPE DITIOUS VOTE COUNT !LLEGATIONS OF ELECTION FRAUD INVOLVING POLITICIANS AND#/-%,%#OFFICIALSNEEDTOBEINVESTIGATEDBYINDEPENDENTPROS ECUTORS WILLING AND ABLE TO PRESS CHARGES FOR WRONGDOING 4HE PERFECT OPPORTUNITYFORLEADERSHIPCHANGECOMESINEARLY AS#/-%,%# CHAIR"ENJAMIN!BALOSSTEPSDOWNINTHEWAKEOFBRIBERYCHARGES AND THREE ADDITIONAL SLOTS ON THE SEVEN MEMBER NATIONAL COMMISSION WILL ALSONEEDTOBEFILLED !SAPRACTICALMATTER INCREMENTALMEASURESOFPOLITICALREFORM RATH ERTHANAWHOLESALESHIFTTOPARLIAMENTARISMORFEDERALISM SEEMTOHOLD GREATER PROMISE FOR SUCCESS )N RESPONSE TO THE TWO LATE  BRIBERY SCANDALS THE0ALACEDUSTEDOFFPROPOSALSFORCHARTERCHANGEINYETAN OTHER ATTEMPT TO CHANGE THE TOPIC TO POLITICAL REFORM 3UCH PATENT PO LITICAL OPPORTUNISM HAS TURNED MUCH OF THE PUBLIC AGAINST THE IDEA OF CONSTITUTIONAL REVISION !FTER HIS ATTEMPTS WERE SPURNED IN LATE  EVEN 3PEAKER DE 6ENECIA NOW SEEKS A MORATORIUM ON CHARTER CHANGE 3ENATORSCONTINUETOOPPOSETHEABOLITIONOFTHEIRCHAMBER ANDONECAN PRESUME THAT THE FIVE SENATORS CONSIDERING BIDS FOR THE PRESIDENCY IN  ARE PARTICULARLY AVERSE TO THE PARLIAMENTARY OPTION #ONSIDERING THESEFACTORS THEREISUNLIKELYTOBERENEWEDMOMENTUMFORSWEEPING CONSTITUTIONALCHANGESUNTILAFTERTHEPRESIDENTIALELECTIONS




*OURNALOF$EMOCRACY

)NTHEMEANTIME DEMOCRATICINSTITUTIONSINTHE0HILIPPINESCONTINUE TOBEUNDERMAJORSTRESS&ORSOME DEMOCRACYHASLOSTITSAPPEALAND MILITARYINTERVENTIONHASBECOMEANATTRACTIVEOPTION4HOSEWHOWANT TO SEE THE PERPETUATION OF CIVILIAN DEMOCRATIC STRUCTURES MIGHT DRAW SOMECOMFORTFROMTHEREFLECTIONTHATTHE0HILIPPINEMILITARYHASNEVER LAUNCHEDASUCCESSFULGRABFORPOWER DESPITEMANYATTEMPTS'IVENTHE CURRENTWEAKNESSOFPOLITICALINSTITUTIONS HOWEVER ITWOULDBEAMIS TAKETODISMISSTHEPOSSIBILITYOFACOUP!FTERALL THEODDSTHATSUCHAN ATTEMPTMIGHTSUCCEEDDEPENDNOTONLYONTHECAPABILITYOFAGROUPOF DISGRUNTLEDSOLDIERSBUTALSOUPONTHENATUREOFTHEPOLITICALINSTITUTIONS THATAREBEINGTARGETED !LTHOUGHTHE0HILIPPINESCANBOASTTHEOLDESTDEMOCRATICSTRUCTURES IN !SIA THEY ARE CURRENTLY WEAK AND LACKING IN LEGITIMACY "ATTERED BYSCANDALAFTERSCANDAL THESESTRUCTURESNEEDCAREFULANDWELL CONSID EREDREFORMIFTHEYARETOSURVIVE7ITHPARTICULARATTENTIONTOTHEGOAL OF STRENGTHENING POLITICAL PARTIES IT IS IMPORTANT TO BUILD A DEMOCRACY THATCANOVERCOMEITSHISTORICALSHORTCOMINGSANDBEGINTODEMONSTRATE RESPONSIVENESS NOT JUST TO THE PRIVILEGED FEW BUT TO THE CITIZENRY AS A WHOLE ./4%3 4HANKSTO#LEO#ALIMBAHIN 3HEILA#ORONEL *OSE,UIS'ASCON AND*OEL2OCAMORAFOROF FERINGVALUABLECOMMENTSANDSUGGESTIONS!NYERRORSOROMISSIONSAREMINEALONE  &OR A MORE DETAILED STUDY SEE 0AUL $ (UTCHCROFT AND *OEL 2OCAMORA r3TRONG $EMANDSAND7EAK)NSTITUTIONS4HE/RIGINSAND%VOLUTIONOFTHE$EMOCRATIC$EFICITIN THE0HILIPPINES s*OURNALOF%AST!SIAN3TUDIES-AYu!UGUST u "ENEDICT!NDERSON r#ACIQUE$EMOCRACYANDTHE0HILIPPINES/RIGINSAND$REAMS s .EW,EFT2EVIEW-AYu*UNE u 4HECURRENTEXEMPLARSARETHE0HILIPPINE#ENTERFOR)NVESTIGATIVE*OURNALISM0#)* AND.EWSBREAKMAGAZINE .ATHAN'ILBERT1UIMPO r4HE,EFT %LECTIONS ANDTHE0OLITICAL0ARTY3YSTEMINTHE 0HILIPPINES s#RITICAL!SIAN3TUDIES-ARCH u "ANTAY%LEKSYON0EOPLEqS#OALITIONTO-ONITORTHE%LECTIONS r&INAL2EPORT ON THE  %LECTIONS s WWWIPERORGPH#%2BANTAYELEKSYONREPORTSFINAL REPORT  ELECTIONHTML  2OBERTO 6ERZOLA r4HE 4RUE 2ESULTS OF THE  0HILIPPINE 0RESIDENTIAL %LECTION "ASEDONTHE.!-&2%,4ALLY s+ASARINLAN0HILIPPINE*OURNALOF4HIRD7ORLD3TUDIES 6OL  .O    u &OR A BRIEF SUMMARY OF CORRUPTION CHARGES AGAINST THE 0ALACE SEEr3HAMEAND3CANDALINTHE&AMILY sr4HE1UEENSq'AMBIT sSPECIALEDITION I 2EPORT1UEZON#ITY 0HILIPPINES *ULY u  4HE r'LORIA 'ARCILLANOs TAPES CAN BE HEARD AT HTTPPCIJORGBLOGWP FILESTAPES PHPTRANSCRIPTIONSFROMONEKEYTAPEAREPRINTEDINr4HE1UEENSq'AMBIT su 3EE3HEILA3#ORONEL r4HE5NMAKINGOFA0RESIDENT sINr4HE1UEENSq'AMBIT s u


0AUL$(UTCHCROFT



&ORPOLLINGDATA SEE3OCIAL7EATHER3TATIONS WWWSWSORGPH-ACAPAGAL !RROYO WASTHEVICE PRESIDENTIALCANDIDATEONDE6ENECIAqS,AKAS0ARTYTICKETSHEWONTHE OFFICEWHILEDE6ENECIALOSTBADLY$E6ENECIASEEMSTOHAVECONCLUDEDTHATTHEONLYWAY HECOULDBECOMECHIEFEXECUTIVEOFTHE0HILIPPINESWOULDBEASPARTYLEADERINAPARLIA MENTARYSYSTEM  ,UZ 2IMBAN r4HE -AN 7HO 7OULD "E 0RESIDENT s I 2EPORT NO  3EPTEMBER  WWWPCIJORGI REPORTNOLIHTML  3HEILA 3 #ORONEL r4HE 0HILIPPINES IN  $EMOCRACY AND )TS $ISCONTENTS s !SIAN3URVEY&EBRUARY   !MNESTY )NTERNATIONAL r0HILIPPINES 0OLITICAL +ILLINGS (UMAN 2IGHTS AND THE 0EACE 0ROCESS s  !UGUST  u HTTPWEBAMNESTYORGLIBRARY)NDEX%.'!3! OPENOF%.' 0(, (UMAN 2IGHTS 7ATCH r3CARED 3ILENT )MPUNITY FOR %XTRAJUDICIAL+ILLINGSINTHE0HILIPPINES s*UNE HTTPHRWORGREPORTSPHILIP PINESWEBPDF 2EPORTOF)NDEPENDENT#OMMISSIONTO!DDRESS-EDIAAND!CTIVIST +ILLINGS *ANUARY 4HE5./FFICEAT'ENEVA r5.%XPERT3AYS%XTRAJUDICIAL +ILLINGS IN 0HILLIPINES ;SIC= (AVE A #ORROSIVE %FFECT ON #IVIL 3OCIETY AND 0OLITICAL $ISCOURSE s0RESS2ELEASE &EBRUARY 2EPORTERS7ITHOUT"ORDERS r0HILIPPINESv!NNUAL2EPORT sAVAILABLEATWWW RSFORG #OMMITTEE TO 0ROTECT *OURNALISTS r!TTACKS ON THE 0RESS IN  0HILIPPINES s WWWCPJORGATTACKSASIAPHILHTML&ORFULLERANALYSISOFTHECURRENTSTATEOFCIVIL LIBERTIESANDRULEOFLAWINTHE0HILIPPINES SEE(UTCHCROFT r4HE0HILIPPINES s#OUNTRIESAT THE#ROSSROADS.EW9ORK&REEDOM(OUSE  AVAILABLEATWWWFREEDOMHOUSE ORG  r)TqS $ONE (OUSE 3ET TO #ONVENE #ONSTITUENT !SSEMBLY s 0HILIPPINE $AILY )NQUIRER $ECEMBER .!-&2%, r4HE4ERMINAL2EPORTTO.!-&2%,/PERATION1UICK#OUNT s *UNE $ESPITETHEMAGNITUDEOFTHEPROBLEM THEREPORTREFUTESTHOSEWHOALLEGE rMASSIVEDISENFRANCHISEMENT sWHICHMIGHTBETAKENASFURTHERINDICATIONOF.!-&2%,qS EAGERNESSTOLEGITIMIZETHEELECTIONS !RIES2UFO r4HE3INSOF!BALOS s.EWSBREAK *ULYu3EPTEMBER uAND 'EMMA "AGAYAUA r'UNS &EALTY AND -ONEY s .EWSBREAK *ULYu3EPTEMBER  u  2OCAMORA r%QUAL /PPORTUNITY6IOLENCE sI 2EPORT &EBRUARY HTTPPCIJ ORGI REPORTPOLITICAL VIOLENCEHTML!LECKS0ABICO r7ERETHE%LECTIONS,ESS 6IOLENTs  *ULY  HTTPI SITEPHBLOGPMORE  FOR A CRITIQUE OF POLICE STATISTICS SEE"ANTAY%LEKSYON r&INAL2EPORTOFTHE%LECTIONSs 3EE!LFRED7-C#OY r#OVERT.ETHERWORLDS#LANDESTINE3ERVICESAND#RIMINAL 3YNDICATES IN 3HAPING THE 0HILIPPINE 3TATE s IN 4IM ,INDSEY AND %RIC 7ILSON EDS 'OVERNMENT OF THE 3HADOWS ,ONDON 0LUTO 0RESS FORTHCOMING  r$E 6ENECIA CALLS ON !RROYO TO SET UP NEW ADMINISTRATION s 0HILIPPINE $AILY )NQUIRER  /CTOBER  $E 6ENECIAqSCANDIDAPPRAISALCAMEAMIDMOUNTINGTENSIONSBETWEENHIMANDTHEPRESIDENT INTHECOURSEOFWHICHHISINFLUENCEHASBEENCURBED 'ABRIELLA2-ONTINOLA r0ARTIESAND!CCOUNTABILITYINTHE0HILIPPINES s*OURNAL OF$EMOCRACY*ANUARY /NTHEDANGERSOFUNINTENDEDCONSEQUENCES SEE !LLEN (ICKEN r0ARTY &ABRICATION #ONSTITUTIONAL 2EFORM AND THE 2ISE OF THE 4HAI 2AK 4HAI s*OURNALOF%AST!SIAN3TUDIES3EPTEMBERu$ECEMBER u!NARGU MENTFORINCREMENTALREFORMCANBEFOUNDIN*ÛRGEN2ÛLAND r#ONSTITUTIONAL$EBATESIN THE0HILIPPINES&ROM0RESIDENTIALISMTO0ARLIAMENTARISMs!SIAN3URVEY-AY  u

The Arroyo Imbroglio in the Philippines  

Hutchcroft, Paul D. (Paul David) Journal of Democracy, Volume 19, Number 1, January 2008, pp. 141-155 (Article) For additional information a...