Page 1

45 Years of Environmental News


Arcata, California

Vol. 46, No. 1

Feb/Mar 2016

NEWS Published by the Northcoast Environmental Center Since 1971

Fallen Giants Remembering Two Local Women who Fought for Conservation and inspired Generations of Activists

Lucille Vinyard and

Susie Van Kirk Cannabis Ordinance Update | Paris Climate Deal | Wolf and Elk Management Klamath Dam Relicensing | Thank you 2015 Donors | Elk River Water Board Regs

News From the Center Larry Glass NEC Board President

We’ve stayed pretty busy over the holidays here at the NEC with so much going around Northwest California. It was hard to take much of a break. Our staff went home to visit their families. Some of us worked right on through.


We spent a good deal of time participating in Humboldt County’s efforts crafting its Commercial Medical Marijuana Ordinance. The issue of cannabis cultivation and its environmental impacts have occupied a lot of time and effort for your NEC in the last five years. It looks like all the effort and education of the public and elected officials is beginning to pay off. Agencies from the local to the state are paying attention and starting to act. Because the cannabis industry has been in the shadows— doing what it wants for so long with no oversight—it has been an enormous undertaking to come up with a way to bring it under control and regulate it. County staff has done a commendable job listening to and reflecting on input which the NEC has provided them in concert



1385 8th Street - Suite 226, Arcata, CA 95521 PO Box 4259, Arcata, CA 95518 707- 822-6918, Fax 707-822-6980 EcoNews is the official bi-monthly publication of the Northcoast Environmental Center (NEC), a non-profit organization. Third class postage paid in Arcata. ISSN No. 0885-7237. EcoNews is mailed to our members and distributed free throughout the Northern California and Southern Oregon bioregion. The subscription rate is $35 per year.

The ideas and views expressed in EcoNews are not necessarily those of the NEC.

with our allies EPIC, SAFE and Humboldt Baykeeper.


The NEC continues to work to protect the many wild road-less areas that were dropped from the Thompson Wilderness bill enacted several years ago. The idea to make another attempt at protection for these areas was hatched before Jared Huffman was elected. We approached him as a candidate and he was excited by the concept. Since then we’ve worked tirelessly with Cal-Wild to help craft a large public lands bill. The result is a Wild and Scenic Rivers & Wilderness bill with an important restoration component. As we write this we are days away from handing it over to Congressman Huffman and his staff.

We are keeping up to date on the latest moves on this through our participation in the Northwest Forest Campaign Network.

Collaborative Efforts

Forest Planning

The Forest Service is beginning the process of updating or completely rewriting their individual forest plans—in addition to rewriting the whole Northwest Forest Plan that revolves around the Northern spotted owl. To date, there has been only one Forest Service meeting in our area (Region 5). Most of the action so far has been in Washington/Oregon (Region 6).

Our efforts to work with the U.S. Forest Service in both Six Rivers and Trinity National Forests through the Trinity Collaborative have continued. We are making some progress, especially with regard to Six Rivers. Many years of inaction follow decades of abuse and mismanagement. The collaborative effort is bringing Timber and Environmental groups together, with a diverse mix of community members, to try to find common goals and achieve results in managing our public lands. While it’s been slow going, we actually have found common ground in an effort to try and move the Forest Service forward.

Editor/Layout: Morgan Corviday

NEC Board Of Directors

EcoNews Intern: Rebekah Staub

President - Larry Glass, Safe Alternatives for our Forest Environment, Vice-President - Dan Sealy, At-Large, Secretary - Jennifer Kalt, Humboldt Baykeeper, Treasurer - Chris Jenican Beresford, AtLarge, Gary Falxa, Calfornia Native Plant Society, CJ Ralph, Redwood Region Audubon Society, Richard Kreis, Sierra Club, North Group. Scott Greacen, Friends of the Eel River, scott@ Tom Wheeler, Environmental Protection Information Center, Bob Morris, Trinity County Representative, AtLarge,

Advertising: Proofreaders: Karen Schatz, Midge Brown, Kris Diamond Authors: Larry Glass, Dan Sealy, Jennifer Kalt, Sarah Marnick, Dr. Loon, Delia BenseKang, Margaret Gainer, Tom Wheeler, Felice Pace, Anne Maher, Madison Peters, Jerry Martien, Ned Forsyth, Rebekah Staub, Suzanne Guerra, Monte Merrick, Colin Fiske Cover Photo: Lucille Vinyard looks up at an old growth redwood near Redwood Creek and Emerald Creek, 1967. Photo: Dave Van de Mark.

NEC Staff

EcoNews Editor: Morgan Corviday, MPA Outreach Coordinator Delia Bense-Kang, Coastal Cleanup Coordinator: Madison Peters, Membership Associate: Sydney Stewart, Office Associate: Anne Maher,

Humboldt Baykeeper

Fiscally sponsored by the NEC Director: Jennifer Kalt, Bay Explorations Staff: Jasmin Segura,

The Promotion of Merv George Jr. to Forest Supervisor of Six Rivers has been a game changer for our efforts. Merv’s frankness and receptiveness to us has been a very refreshing change and we look forward to continuing to work with him and all of his staff at Six Rivers. Congressman Jared Huffman has also become involved in helping us to reach or goals and is very supportive of our work.

NEC Member Groups Humboldt Baykeeper 707-268-0664

Sierra Club,North Group, Redwood Chapter

California Native Plant Society North Coast Chapter

Redwood Region Audubon Society,

Friends of the Eel River, 707-822-3342

Safe Alternatives for our Forest Environment (SAFE)

Environmental Protection Information Center (EPIC), 707-822-7711

NEC Affiliate Members Friends of Del Norte

Mattole Restoration Council, (707) 629-3514

Zero Waste Humboldt

Mail b ox Letters to the Editor Editor: INVASIVE HUMAN SPECIES? I wholeheartedly agree with the appeal by Jim Clark of the Redwood Region Audubon Society in calling for new Audubon membership with expertise in the social and political sciences, (EcoNews, Dec. 2015, Jan. 2016). As economic and social conditions worsen, the impact on our besieged environment intensifies. Homelessness is a national epidemic with complex causes and a clear solution (housing). Men, women, and children lacking safe alternatives are struggling in Eureka’s wet and cold open spaces despite a city rich in empty buildings and vacant lots. Comparing the homeless to “invasive species” or recreational “camping” only contributes to the economic, political and ideological prejudices that are delaying progress in getting people housed. Residents and representatives must abandon their prejudices and begin housing Humboldt’s one percent homeless population, (the national and county average) or homelessness will continue to broaden its negative impacts upon many other issues and organizations. The Audubon and environmental groups can remind county supervisors of their obligation under the California Welfare and Institutions Code to take responsibility in serving all county residents with the same enthusiasm the supervisors

demonstrated in their settlement of the lawsuit filed by local developers’ “Coalition for Property Rights”. The settlement, and pending medical marijuana legislation, represents unprecedented deregulation of rural development in our headwaters at a time of biodiversity collapse, climate change, and fresh water depletion, promising far more extensive and enduring environmental damage over the coming decades than the unavoidable damage caused by chronic homelessness. People of good will have been unwilling to see the destitute in their humanness as entitled to the same care, compassion, and concern that would be extended to one’s friends, neighbors or loved ones. It’s what Martin Luther King described as being, “crucified by conscientious blindness”. Sincerely, George Clark, Eureka CA Write a Letter to the Editor! Letters should be 300 words or less, should be relevant to material covered in EcoNews, and must include the writer’s address and phone number. Letters may be edited and shortened for space. The NEC reserves the right to reject any submitted material for any reason (e.g. size, content, etc.).

Send to

3 5 6 6 7 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 21 22

2015 Donor Thank Yous Cannabis Ordinance Update Responding to Local Oil Spill State Elk and Wolf Management Weed Comes to the Woods Paris Climate Change Agreement Elk River & New Water Board Regs Eye on Washington Underwater Parks Day Two Fallen Giants: Lucille Vinyard Two Fallen Giants: Suzie Van Kirk Klamath Dam Relicensing Process Zero Waste Humboldt Humboldt Baykeeper EPIC Sierra Club, North Group California Native Plant Society Creature Feature: California Newt Kids’ Page: Loony Loons Check out our Follow us

Leave a North Coast Legacy Give a gift that will endure beyond your lifetime. Leave a lasting legacy by naming the Northcoast Environmental Center as a beneficiary of your will, trust, or other estate plans.

Your bequest will help us advocate for and educate about the North Coast and the KlamathSiskiyou bioregion for future generations. To learn more, call us at 707-822-6918. The NEC is a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization, EIN 23-7122386.

Catch the NEC’s EcoNews Report

Every Thursday, 1:30pm on KHSU - 90.5FM Tune in for a half hour of environmental interviews and discussion on a variety of topics on the EcoNews Report! Featuring rotating cast of NEC and Member Group representatives. Past shows are archived on our website for download or streaming EcoNews Feb/Mar 2016

In This Issue


Bouquets Pete Nichols, National Director of Waterkeeper Alliance and former NEC board member and Humboldt Baykeeper director, for leading a very effective strategic planning session for NEC board and staff in January.

Noah Levy, Humboldt County Planning Commissioner, for being a strong voice for putting the environment before profit in the County’s commercial medical marijuana land use ordinance. Julie Fulkerson, for a successful term as mayor of Trinidad looking out for the environment as well as the citizens, including supporting the inclusion of Trinidad Head into the expanded National Coastal Monument, supporting the Trindad Land Trust in gainig public access to coastal areas and extension of the Hammond Trail, and implementing mandatory commercial solid waste recycling.


Thank You!

Many thanks to all of our donors, advertisers, and other community partners in 2015. As we head into our 45th year, we are grateful for so many friends and allies. From all of us at the NEC, thank you so much for your support in protecting our wondrous North Coast and all of its inhabitants!

Adam Brown & Natalia Collier Adam Lassiter Alan & Barbara Wilkinson Alan & Jean Jackman Alan Justice Alan Laurent Alan Wolski & Mary Ann Madej Aldaron Laird Alexandra Stillman Alicia Adrian Allen & Tanemi Klahn Allen Maret Amy Conway Amy Eberwein Amy Uyeki & Rees Hughes Andrew Freeman Andy Lane Anita & Tim Gilbride-Read Ann Anderson Ann King Smith Anna & Mark Stewart Anna Mae Botley Annabelle Cloner Anne & Douglas Newman Anne & Lisa Crouse Anne Nicksic Anne P. Teller Annette Parsons Anthony & Nancy Wareika Arnold Whitridge Arthur & Julianne Bettini Audrey Miller Ayala Talpai B. Thomas Parry & Julie McDonald Barbara & Paul Kelly Barbara & Robert Froehlich Barbara Cline & Geoffrey Proust Barbara J. Kennedy Barbara Kalt Barbara Kellogg Barbara Lane Barbara Taylor Barney Bartelle Bart Hinesly Ben Mattio Bernadette Cheyne Bernadette Webster & Jack Glick Bert Taylor Betty & Ellen Briggs Beverly & Donald Zeman Beverly Copeland Bill & Heidi Bourne Bill Birmingham Bob & Marilyn Schultz Bob Hughes Bob Morris Bob Stobaugh Jr Brandon Drucker Bret Harvey & Maggie Fleming Brett Watson

Brian & Laura Julian Bruce & Pam Kessler Bruce & Marlene Ehresman Bruce Campbell Bruce Slighton Byrd Lochtie Cafe Mokka & Finnish Country Sauna & Tubs Carl Chatfield & Susan Anderson Carol & CJ Ralph Carol & John Wiebe Carol Brant Carol Toffaleti & Bill Croft Carol Woods Caroline & David Moyer Carolyn & Peter Lehman Carolyn Ayres Cary Frazee & Stephen Nielson Cat Koshkin & Patrick Cleary Catherine B. Hanafi Catherine J. Walling Catherine Sennott Chandler & Paula Dawson Charles B. Mills Charles Chamberlin Charles Krull Charles Minton Charlie Butterworth Charlie Davison Charlie Solo & Sandra Antonson Cheryl Lisin Chet Ogan Chip Sharpe & Celestine Armenta Chris & Peggy Toole Chris & Richard Beresford Chris & Wendy Cole Christopher Matthews Cistercian Monastery Claire and Eugene Perricelli Clark A. Fenton Claudia Kamas Claudia Nelson-Huggins & Mark Hapgood Claudia Paliaga & C. Peter Jermyn Clifford Anderson Colin Anderson Colin Fiske Colleen Haining & David Imper Community Foundation of New Jersey: Mr. and Mrs. David J. Epstein Connie Stewart Corey Gene Rush Corinne Frugoni Craig Knox Crestmark Architectural Millworks, Inc. Cynthia Savage & Stanley Hino Damian Centanni

Damon Maguire Dan Ehresman Dan Raleigh Dan Sealy Dandelion Herbal Center Daniel & Claire Grunbaum Daniel Wassenaar Danny Hagans Darlene Amann Daryl & Phyllis Chinn Dave & Leah Alcyon David & Brigid Baker David & Kerry Gibbs David & Kimberly Everett David Baxter David Kiel & Amey Miller David She’om Rose Deanna R. Thrift Deborah Filipelli Debra Farber-Bush Debra Harrison & Greg Blomstrom Dennis Rael Denny Dorsett Desiree Angeli Diana Jacobs & Rick Elefant Diane & Barry Welch Diane Brown Diane Fairchild Beck Diane Ryerson Dianne Rosser Dick Scheinman Don & Edie Butler Don & Melinda Groom Don & Susan Allan Don & Sylvia Garlick Don and Trudi Walker Don Barry & Sarah Maninger Donald & Andrea Tuttle Donna Knight Donna Lydon & David Maciolek Donna Sund-Caldwell & Kevin Caldwell Donna Wildearth Doug Kent Dr. & Mrs. Nancy Slenger Dr. James P. Smith, Jr. Dr. Robert & Martha Haynes E.M. Zsa Zsa Dallenback Ebsco Industries, Inc. Ed & Bobbie Gross Edge Gerring & Melanie Kasek Edgepoint Graphics Eleanor & James Gayner Emily Morris Emily Sinkhorn Eric & Joan Olson Eric & Mary Almquist Erica Upton & Terry Roelofs Erich Schimps Erin Kelly Ernie Wasson Evan & Sara Baxter F. Jon Leiderman Felicia Oldfather, Trust Fortuna Library Frances & Francis Ferguson Francis Taylor Fred & Joan Ann Tempas Gail Coonen Gail Popham Garrison Tucker Gary & Janice Anderson Gary Garcia, M.D.

Gaye Ayton Gayle Garman & Gary Falxa Gena Pennington Gene & Sharyn Lodes Genia Garibaldi Geoffrey & Mary Caldwell George & Kathy Burtchett George & Margaret Strong George Cocks Gerald & Barbara Meral Gerald Dickinson Gerald Drucker & Lynda McDevitt Gerry & Leonide McKay GHD Engineering Consultants Gil & Mediha Saliba Gillian Oglesby Gilly & Jeff Black Ginni Hassrick Glenda Nikolauson Glenn Siegfried Gordon Leppig & Julie Neander Greenway Partners Greg & Kay Gibson Greg & Linda Rose Greg Freer Greg Jensen Greg Movsesyan Gregory & Carol Conners Gregory & Rene Nesty Gretchen Ziegler Guy & Cindy Kuttner Gwen Baluss Hal & Wendy Harden Hanna Sturtz Harriet Hass Harry Lowther & Ursula Bredow Harry Spehar Hart Welsh, Jr. Hassanah Nelson Heidi Benzonelli Heidi Woog & Thomas Archie Jr. Heinrich & Peggy Kaestle Henry and Mody Hollomon Herb Roth Holly & Melvin Kreb Howard Williams Howie Freiman & Barbara Rich Humboldt Area Foundation Humboldt Patient Resource Center Humboldt State University Library Periodicals Dept. Ilene Mandelbaum & Steve Barager Irith Shalmony J.A. Savage Jacqueline McCauley Jacques Gagne & Kristine Long Jaffa Dugan Wahlberg James & Joan Boulden James & Susan Bentz James & Virginia Waters James A. Kealey James Benson James Elliott James H. Diego & Shirley Reynolds James Matthews James McDermott James Moore James O’Brien Jan Rowen Jane & Richard Wilson

Janelle Adsit Janet & John Lewis Janet Dickey Janet Hodder & Michael Graybill Janet Romine Janice Andersen Janice Murayama Janis & Gary Friedrichsen Janis Schleunes Janis Taylor Jay Bonestell Jay Sooter Jay Sooter & Margaret Taylor Jay Ziegler Jean Lawrence-Siebuhr & William Siebuhr Jean McCord Jean McGurk Jean Turner Jeanne Pendergast Jeff & Tracy Boyer Jeff & Zina Hogue Jeff Dillion Jeff Russell Jeffery Johnson Jeffrey Morris Jeffrey Soble Jennifer Fowler Jennifer Taylor Jesse Blacksmith & Sharon J. Phillips Jessica Brooks Jill & Scott Demers Jill Duffy Jim & Donna Clark Jim & Karen Athing Jim Froland Jim Test Jim Zoellick Jimmy & Julia Johnson Joan Del Monte Joan F. Kienzle Joanne & Robert Fornes Jodi Greene Joe & Kimberly Scriven Joe & Patricia Dougherty Joe and Barb MacTurk Joe Tyburczy Joel Armin-Hoiland John & Barbara Brimlow John & Darsty McAlinn John & Dona Blakely John & Judith Longshore John & Karen Reiss John & Laura Hennings John & Jaqueline Peterson John Coonen John Crater John Hunter John Jennings John K. Moore John Mertes John Puschock & Catherine Berchok John R. Swanson John Sacklin & Mary Hektner John Wrigley & Alison O. Lee John Yoakley Jon Lee Joshua Asarian Joyce Hough & Fred Neighbor Joyce King Jud Ellinwood & Andrea Webb Judith Hinman Judy Sears

Julie & Lonnie Haynes Julie Evens Julie Fulkerson Justin Smith Kara Lynn Klarner Karen & David Hammer Karen & Gordon Schatz Karen & Jim Havlena Karen & Thomas Newton Karen Spencer Karin Engstrom Karole Ely Katherine A. & Michael G. Clark Katherine Almy Katherine White Kathleen & Philip Vogelsang Kathleen Cecere Kathleen Imfeld & April Quigley Kathryn Donahue Kathryn Radke & John Williams Kathy & Dick Laforge Kathy Weber Katie & John Amodio Katrina Nystrom Keith & Gail Lester Ken Carpenter Ken J. Collins Kenneth H. Houldsworth Kerry & Garrett Watty Keytra Meyer Kimberley Pittman-Schulz & Terry Schulz Kimberly Tays & Stanley Binnie Kit Crosby-Williams Kit Davenport Kris Kunard-Blevins & L.D. Blevins Kristi Wrigley Kurt Lauer Kurt Stegen L. N. Dolbeare Larry & Donna Ulrich Larry & Jeanine Lancaster Larry Glass Larry L. Karsteadt Laura Morse Laurel & Scott North Lauri Rose Laurie, Kurt & Ben Lingemann Lee & Chris House Leif Joslyn Leila & Seven M. Gompertz Donor Advised Fund in Memory of Michael Gompertz Leon & Kathryn Kos Leroy E. French Lesa Coleman Lesa Lyon Lesley Meriwether Linda & Doug Sievers Linda Doerflinger Linda M. & John M. Gaffin Linda M. Barker Linda Woodward Lindsay Merryman & Robert Wiele Linnea Mandell Lisa & Peter Sorensen Lisa Buscho Lois Drobish Lois Mellert Lori Dengler & Thomas E. Lisle Lorraine Miller-Wolf & Richard Wolf

Continued on next page

Continued from prior page Lydia Garvey Lynda & Paul Roush Lynda Hughes Lynn C. Berner Lynn Halpern Lynn Hunsinger Lynn Inouye & Mark Langner Lynn McCulloch Madhavi DeVault Maggie Murchie & Tom Bronchetti Manette & Philip Gerstle Manhard Consulting, LTD. Marcia Miller Marcia Rautenstrauch Margaret & Mark Shaffer Margaret Gainer Margaret Nulsen & Chris Frolking Maria Mehegan Mariane Gilbert Marie Granshaw Marie Kelleher-Roy Marilyn Foote & John Christianson Mario & Marilyn Zelaya Marj Early Mark & Patricia Andrews Mark Andre Mark Cortright & Linda Miller Mark G. Ellis Mark Mills-Thysen Mark Northcross Mark Rebelo Mark Sullivan & Kiva Mahoney Martin R. Haase Martin Swett Marvin Goss Mary Anderson Mary Ann Matthews Mary Conway Mary Gelinas & Roger James

Mary Jo Sweeters Mary Jo Weisgerber & Roberta Welty Mary Mallahan & David Bazard Mary McNelis Mary Schroeder Marylyn & Timothy PaikNicely Matthew Marshall Maureen Hart McKelvey-Daugherty Family Foundation Melissa and Patrick Kangas Melissa Bukosky & Khashayar Boodjeh Melissa & Christian Stepien Melissa Zarp Melody & Gerald Hamilton Mendocino Maples Nursery Merldene Friel Michael & Jeanice Gross Michael & Kari Love Michael Evenson Michael J. Dehority Michael Rizza Michael Shapiro & Dr. Wendy Ring Michele & Doug Kamprath Michele Fell-Casale Michele Olsen & Roland Lamberson Michelle Large Mike & Cindi Whitehead Mike & Jane Minor Mike Diggles Mike Strande MikkiMoves Real Estate Millie Brucker Milton J. Boyd, Ph.D. Mordechai Liebling & Lynne Iser Morgan Corviday Nan L. Abrams Nanci Lewis Nancy & Mike Tout Nancy Bailey

Nancy Correll Nancy Ihara Nancy Marie Nancy Reichard Nancy Stephenson Nancy Stevens Natalynne DeLapp Nehemiah Stone Neil Palmer & Janelle Egger Norman & Carolyn & Rachael Bell Norman & Jean Dyche North Coast Co-op North Group Sierra Club Ollie Weber P. Greenberg Pam Mendelsohn Pat Bitton Patricia Brennan Patricia-Anne & George WinterSun Patrick & Melissa Hooven Patrick A. Carr Patsy Givins Paul & Kay Schulz Paul & Margaret Abels Paul Allen & Leslie Lollich Paul Blank & Annette Makino Paul Galloway Peggy & Jack Irvine Peter & Cheryl Lewis Peter Galvin Peter Martin Peter Stroud & Karen Ingels Petra Bingham PG&E R.D. & G.L. Gilchrist Rae Shiraishi Ralph & Tecla Pierotti Randy Sherer Rebecca Deja Renay Radniecki & Bill Bowman Rhonda Geldon & Carl Meyers Richard & Carol Laursen

Invest in the Future Join our Monthly Giving Program Support the NEC throughout the year effortlessly with automatic, repeating online payments. Or if you prefer to pay by check, we can give you return envelopes!

Richard & Catherine Christo Richard & Sylvia Cardella Richard Ballew & Iris Ruiz Richard Engel Richard Hansis Richard Jay Moller Richard Kreis Richard L. Pederson Richard Ridenhour Richard Salzman Rick Tomar Rita Carole R.L. & J.E. Friedrichsen Rob & Barb Thompson Robert & Elisabeth Hawthorne Robert & Janet Mountjoy Robert & Marsha Rodrigues Robert A. Rutemoeller Robert B. Flint, Jr. Robert Benson & Becky Evans Robert Childs Robert Fox Davey Robert Johnson & Paula Rhude Robert Lockett & Adrienne Wolf-Lockett Robert McCreath & Lois Decoux Robert McLaughlin Robert McLaughlin & Theresa Rumjahn Robert McSkimming Robert Steeck Robert W. & Joanne Thoman, Jr. Robin & Leonard Wolff Robin Hamlin Robin Renshaw & Richard Swisher Ron & Arleen Smith Ron & Jill Miller Ron & Melanie Kuhnel Ronalda & Daniel Jordan Russell & Tina Marier Ryan Emenaker

Thank You 2015

Monthly Donors Alan & Barbara Wilkinson Carol & CJ Ralph Chris & Richard Beresford Daniel Wassenaar Daryl & Phyllis Chinn Don & Melinda Groom Don Barry & Sarah Maninger Gordon Leppig & Julie Neander

Guy & Cindy Kuttner Jeanne Pendergast Jim & Donna Clark Julie & Lonnie Haynes Karin Engstrom Keytra Meyer Margaret & Mark Shaffer Mary Gelinas & Roger James Millie Brucker Pat Bitton Ryan Henson

For more information, call the NEC at 707-822-6918

Ryan Henson Sallie Grover Sally Williams Sandra Hill Sanders-Raigosa Family Sandy Bar Ranch Sara & Daniel Frost Sara Pillow Sarah Herbelin Schwab Charitable Trust Scott & Lucinda Bradshaw Serials Department, Green Library Shawnee Alexandri & Tryphena Lewis Sheila Marks Sherry & Barry Douglas Shirley M. Hillman Silicon Valley Community Foundation: Edison Sky Lloyd Sorrel & Dorothy Klein Stacy Becker Stan & Patricia Larson Steve & Suzanna Bowser Steve Railsback & Margaret Lang Steven & Sharon Kramer Steven Evans Steven Martin Steven McSkimming Stuart Moskowitz Sue Britting Susan & Joseph Bower Susan B. Campbell Susan D. Turner & Robert W. Sizoo Susan Eigenbrodt & Carl Tuck Susan Evans & Mark Meissner Susan Haase Susan K. Barnstein Susan M. Shalit Susan Marelich Susan N. Dunn Suzanne & Neal Crothers

Suzanne & Rusty Burke Sydney Stewart Tara Root Teddee-Ann Boylan Teresa H. Uyeki Teresa Kosmac Terry & Gary Strachan Terry Raymer Thomas & Doris Montgomery Thomas & Roberta Preble Thomas Allyn Burns Thomas Casadevall Thomas J. Clark Thomas Phillips & Melissa A. Martel Tibora Girczyc-Blum Todd Rowe Tom & Kathy Hinz Tom & Sue Leskiw Tom & Barbara Peters Tom Buoye Tom Cockle & Carol Lawrence Tom Wheeler Val Monschke Valerie Raymond & John Falxa Vinnie Peloso & Debbie Krukonis Virginia Burley Virginia Plambeck Virginia Sloan Vivian Ziegler W.G. & Cyanne McElhinney Ward Headstrom Warren & Gisela Rosengren Wildberries Marketplace William B Hansell William & Benjamin & Elizabeth Etgen William & Wilma Follette William E. Rodstrom Wolfgang Oesterreich

Special Thanks to those who donated in memory of

Sid Dominitz Alexandra Stillman Andrew Freeman Bruce Campbell Catherine Sennott Dan Sealy Don Barry & Sarah Maninger Doug & Ann King Smith Felicia Oldfather, Trust Ginni Hassrick Janice Murayama John & Darsty McAlinn Laurel & Scott North Linda & Doug Sievers Maria Mehegan Mary Jo Sweeters Nancy Reichard Pam Mendelsohn

Paul Allen & Leslie Lollich Richard Engel Robert McLaughlin Stacy Becker Stan & Patricia Larson Susan Marelich Teresa H. Uyeki

County Cannabis Ordinance: Reigning in Existing Grows Tom Wheeler, EPIC Humboldt County is moving forward with regulating medical cannabis production with a final ordinance set to be passed as we go to print. With the language of the ordinance still being solidified by county planning staff, nothing is set in stone until the Board of Supervisors takes a final action. However, below is our best reading of the tea leaves as to where the Board stands as of press time (spoiler alert: it looks pretty decent): • No new operations in forestlands and incentives for cultivators operating in environmentally-sensitive locations (steep terrain, upper watersheds, too close to streams or wetlands, etc.) to retire, remediate, and/or relocate to flatter agricultural lands. • All operations must adhere to strict environmental requirements, including a prohibition on stream diversions from May 15 to October 31, prohibition of non-organic pesticides, prohibition of use of trucked water, and stream setbacks. • For commercial outdoor and mixed-light (a.k.a. “light-deprivation”) operations, tiered permitting will require more stringent, site-specific review for larger grows. • Operations between 500-5,000 sq. ft. will require a zoning clearance certificate (a ministerial permit— after all conditions are met). • Operations between 5,000-10,000 sq. ft. will require a special use permit, which provides an additional layer of oversight. It is handled by county planning staff, much like a zoning clearance certificate, but affords notice to neighbors to give them the opportunity to provide feedback to staff. Planning staff, neighbors, or the public may request a formal hearing before the Planning Commission. • Operations greater than 10,000 will require a conditional use permit. • For indoor operations, all operations require zero net energy or a carbon offset to limit climate change impacts. • For industrial or commercial parcels, up to 5,000 sq. ft. with ministerial permit and up to 10,000 sq. ft. with conditional use permit. • For lands zones for agricultural production (AG and AE), the ordinance would cap operations at 5,000 sq. ft. limited to existing structures. • Grows up to 22,000 sq. ft. will be considered through a master planning process with accompanying EIR. • Set noise abatement standards for generators to a decibel level appropriate to avoid harm to wildlife and neighborhood disturbance, likely between 25db and 60db.


Overall, the ordinance is pretty decent—and given the myriad of stakeholders and the complexity of the issue—we’ll take pretty decent. Included are a number of hard fought battles (and victories), most notably no new operations in forest lands (including Timber Production Zone or TPZ lands)! With limited exceptions, new cultivation will not be considered until a thorough analysis of cumulative environmental impacts can be done at some point in the notso-distant future. How did we get here? To quote the Grateful Dead, “What a long, strange trip it’s been.” In October 2014, California Cannabis Voice Humboldt (CCVH) invited EPIC, the NEC, and SAFE to participate in an early stakeholders meeting for a draft ordinance that CCVH intended to submit to voters. For the next year, CCVH was hard at work developing an ordinance, issuing a half dozen draft ordinances, with environmental voices providing critical review and comment. While CCVH was hard at work, the state got in the Google Earth images showing the same location (near Alderpoint) from 2004 and game. On September 11, 2015, 2014. The pattern of canopy loss, road building and forest fragmentation is easy the North Coast Regional to see. What’s harder to see from satellite images is the habitat loss, erosion, dewatering of streams and other impacts to water quality and wildlife. Images and text Water Quality Control Board posted on Facebook by Humboldt County 3rd District Supervisor Mark Lovelace. passed a waiver of waste discharge requirements for commercial This is the crux of the issue within the development cannabis producers, the first real environmental of Humboldt County’s ordinance—a sweet regulation directly applied to cannabis. In Fall spot must be achieved that will maximize 2015, the State legislature passed a trio of laws to participation while providing enough oversight and regulate medical cannabis production (AB 243, environmental protection. AB 266, & SB 642). These laws expressly gave Collectively, we are in the process of ushering the county permission to regulate commercial in a new paradigm for commercial cultivation of medical cannabis production and provided a medical cannabis in Humboldt County. We are deadline, March 1, 2016, by which counties were preserving local control, beginning to mitigate to promulgate local regulations. Just four days the adverse impacts of unregulated cannabis later, on September 15, 2015, CCVH decided not production, and providing a legitimate framework to run an independent voter initiative campaign for legal economic activity that can benefit both and turned their ordinance over to the Board of farmers and the public. Supervisors to use as a template. Once the ordinance is adopted, the final The Humboldt County Supervisors environmental document will be circulated for were tasked with striking a balance between public review and comment, and will be finalized competing forces. If cultivators do not in late February or early March. Stay tuned as participate, no performance standards or the County develops a tax measure to ensure environmental mitigations will be followed, funding for enforcement, which will be a crucial which would not help attenuate the problems aspect to the reform of marijuana laws and the facing our watersheds and human communities. end of prohibition.

Feb/Mar 2016


Oiled Wildlife Team Responds to Local Spill

Monte Merrick, Bird Ally X Last month, a truck hauling diesel fuel wrecked in Northern Humboldt County on US 101 near Big Lagoon. It was reported that approximately 1000 gallons of diesel fuel leaked from the overturned trailer, some of which made it into the waterway. Diesel fuel is unlike crude oil or less refined fuels— it evaporates quickly but it also kills more quickly, causing severe respiratory injuries and skin burns on any wildlife who come in contact with it. Initially, it was believed that all of the spilled fuel had been contained and no animals had been impacted. However, early Monday morning, local Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) personnel spotted two ruddy ducks (Oxyura jamaicensis) that appeared to be contaminated by the diesel fuel. Bird Ally X (BAX) staff along with other responders from CDFW and the Oiled Wildlife Care Network (OWCN) were in the field searching for affected animals by afternoon. By late Wednesday, one ruddy duck had been found dead—later confirmed to be oiled. Other wild animals were likely killed by the diesel. Still, this spill could have been much worse. Thousands of birds use Big Lagoon as a winter home. The Lagoon had breached over the weekend as well and the water level fell considerably, possibly helping dissipate the petro-toxin. We were lucky that instead of a major disaster, we had an opportunity to improve our capabilities and insure preparedness for any future accidents or spills, as part of our work with the OWCN. The Oiled Wildlife Care Network is a little known agency in California jointly administered by UC Davis’ Wildlife Health Center and an oil spillspecific department within CDFW, the Office of Spill Prevention and Response (OSPR). This unique network of universities, agencies and wildlife care providers are dedicated to providing the “best achievable capture and care of oil-affected wildlife.” The OWCN has nearly 40 member organizations and several primary care facilities specifically built for large scale spill responses along the California coast. BAX was founded by wildlife rehabilitators and spill responders who each have a long history with the OWCN. We’ve worked hard to bring Humboldt Wildlife Care Center up to the standards required to be a member organization. When oil spills here in our backyard or anywhere in California (as we saw last Spring in Santa Barbara) BAX staff can be mobilized to provide whatever help is needed. If you’re interested in becoming a qualified oiled wildlife responder, volunteering with us at our Bayside wildlife clinic is an excellent first step! Call 707-822-8839 or email

EcoNews Feb/Mar 2016

State Elk and Wolf Management Under Review

Bull elk bellows near Prairie Creek Redwoods State Park. Photo: Linda Atkins, CC.

Tom Wheeler, EPIC

Department of Fish and Wildlife Shows Cards to Delist Wolf The California Department of Fish and Wildlife recently released its draft Wolf Conservation Plan, a document which will shape the way the Department approaches wolf recovery in California. The Plan may impact protections afforded to the grey wolf under the state and federal endangered species acts. While the Plan emphasizes nonlethal management strategies in the short term, EPIC is concerned that the Plan will ultimately result in loosened protections and wolf hunts. In the Plan, the Department of Fish and Wildlife indicates that it will seek to “delist” or remove protections from the endangered species act if the state reaches nine packs, consisting of just 50 to 75 wolves. The Plan does not seek to ground this number in science. Why? Because this number can’t be justified. The best available science shows that such a small number is too fragile to deem the species recovered. Wolf management has traditionally focused on lethal control, killing wolves if they demonstrate predation on livestock. EPIC’s Program and Legal Coordinator, Tom Wheeler, argues that nonlethal control methods are both more humane and more effective. “Nonlethal deterrence, such as range riders, herd management techniques, and electric fences, has been proven to be effective in protecting livestock from predation.” The Conservation Plan was spurred by the discovery of a wolf in California in 2011. The wolf, OR-7, was named “Journey” because of his long adventure to reach the Golden State. The lone Continued on page 19 wolf traveled in and...


Weed Comes to Local Activists Celebrate Our Public Lands “This land is your land, the Woods: this land is my land” the Environmental Wars Begin

- Woody Guthrie

Dr. Loon returns after a five-year break. This is the second of several excerpts from The Price of a Life: Shells, Gold, Carbon Notes and Weed in the Humboldt Bay / Six Rivers Region.

Dr. Loon The shutting down of the Humboldt Bay Nuclear Power Plant in 1976 was a historic event, especially for downwind residents and the children of South Bay School. But it had another long-term significance. It announced the arrival of another spirit of valuation in the Pacific Northwest, a different way of accounting. It had taken years to find its voice, but now the message was unmistakable: the weed economy was here. By weed I mean a lot more than marijuana. Any logger will tell you that environmental politics is the effect of smoking too much dope—but they are related in a more essential way. Like the plant, weed economics is nothing new. It’s been the practice of human beings for millennia. It arrived in Humboldt County years before anybody thought to grow pot for money and donate it to environmental causes. The drug laws are only one way to keep a thumb on this segment of the economy. Some environmental activists will resist this association with the ganja-smoking underclass, and swear they never touch the stuff. It’s probably true. But it’s crucial to remember this: the thing that got called “environmentalism” is itself a weed—that is, a thing not belonging to those in power, growing without permission, always where it’s not wanted. After all, a weed is just a plant whose use has not yet been discovered. The weed economy also has a common root, and a kindred spirit, in the shell exchange that regulated human affairs in this region for centuries. It strives to achieve balance, pay back what is taken, and acknowledges the principle of the gift. The weed economy also allies itself with the economy of the natural world, another connection it hasn’t always gotten right. But up to the mid 1970s it had stayed faithful to the idea that economics is not exempt from the laws of ecology. We should have protested loudly the first time this spirit of valuation was called “environmentalism.” Continued on page 20


On Wednesday, January 20, committed activists representing EPIC, the NEC, Humboldt Baykeeper and our community at large met at the Mike Thompson Wildlife Area to rally in support of national public lands with birding binoculars, signs, instruments—and snacks! National public lands are under threat from both armed extremists at the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge and their buddies in Congress, like Rep. Walden (R-OR) and Rep. Bishop (R-UT), who routinely introduce legislation to weaken public ownership and control over national lands. Our national public lands are our history, set aside by folks like Teddy Roosevelt who had the foresight to know that these lands are special. National public lands are also our legacy, to be enjoyed by countless generations into Photo: Jennifer Kalt the future. Viva la public lands!

COP21 Yields Historic Climate Agreement

Rebekah Staub Leaders and representatives of almost 200 countries met in Paris in November at the 21st Conference of the Parties (COP21), or Climate Change Conference, to discuss climate change in November. Two weeks of deliberations led to an unprecedented deal that formally recognizes climate change “as an urgent and potentially irreversible threat to human societies and the planet.” The historic agreement is a turning point in global efforts to address climate change, as extensive COP conferences have taken place regularly for two decades without resolution. The Paris climate deal is also historic because for the first time in COP history, participating countries agreed on the need to keep the global average temperature from rising 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels. For years, 2 degrees was more or less accepted as the standard limit of allowable increase to discuss—in spite of scientific data revealing a point of no return.

If global temperatures increase by 2 degrees Celsius, the world would be long past the point of preventing devastating consequences, including increasingly extreme weather patterns, flooding, and droughts. Widespread food and water shortages would be inevitable; climate refugees would be a persistent global problem. Scientists who have analyzed this climate change deal say it will cut global greenhouse gas emissions by half enough as necessary to delay the catastrophic events that would follow a 2 degrees Celsius rise. However, the climate change agreement is non-binding—meaning that the success of the agreement in achieving reduced carbon emissions is reliant on countries voluntarily following their stated commitments. The deal is not legally binding by law. The U.S. was the primary force pushing for the agreement to be non-binding due to the fact that the current Congress would be unwilling to pass such legislation. Continued on page 20

Feb/Mar 2016


New Book: California’s Botanical Landscapes

Local author and botanist Michael Kauffman says he was very fortunate to have been a part of the book project now in print titled California’s Botanical Landscapes: A Pictoral View of the State’s Vegetation (CNPS Press 2016). Over the past five or more years this book has evolved through volunteer efforts as a service to those passionate about California’s flora and dedicated to the life work of John O. Sawyer. Kauffman contributed time with photographs for many of the ecoregions as well as coauthoring the Klamath Mountain chapter with Sawyer. This new book surveys our state’s native vegetation with photos and text exploring each of 14 ecoregions across the state. It includes a wide array of photographs of broad-scale vegetation patterns paired with in-depth, interpretive descriptions written by California’s top plant ecologists.

• Over 300 pages, arranged by ecoregion into 14 vibrant chapters • Descriptions of the key vegetation alliances and rare plant species for each region • A discussion of current threat and management concerns for each region • More than 600 photographs California’s Botanical Landscapes is a must-have for anyone interested in the botanical diversity of California’s broad and diverse vegetation—written for botanists, ecologists, environmental scientists, natural historians, and plant lovers of all kinds.

EcoNews Feb/Mar 2016

Elk River Residents Challenge New Water Board Regs Jerry Martien

More than 17 years after Charles Hurwitz (owner of Maxxam/Pacific Lumber Company) was forced to shut down his liquidation logging in Elk River, the Northcoast Regional Water Board has issued new regulations to deal with ongoing timber harvests and the 600,000 cubic yards of silt remaining in the river. A federal EPA official has described the years of delay as “analysis paralysis.” Upriver residents who have endured floods of increasing severity say the new regulations are just another chapter in the state’s failure to restore and protect water quality because regulatory agencies favor big timber over downstream property owners and fish. Despite a change of ownership, water quality has gotten steadily worse under Humboldt Redwood Company (HRC) management. A new EPA-funded Technical Analysis for Sediment summarizes years of studies and recommends a “zero load allocation” for silt. A new Waste Discharge Requirement (WDR) states the amount of sediment HRC is allowed to contribute to the watershed is: zero. A long-awaited plan to restore water quality—known as the Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL)—also says, “the loading capacity for additional sediment is defined as zero.” Clearly, the river is unable to carry any new sediment. A Restoration and Stewardship Program proposes to increase the river’s capacity to absorb sediment, allowing timber operations to continue, and then expand as conditions improve. HRC presently harvests in Elk River at a higher rate than Maxxam, though it uses different methods and calculations. Green Diamond’s clear-cutting in the watershed is not addressed in the new plans. Water Quality staff describes these standards as “stringent,” and points to numerous measures that will reduce sediment from HRC timber operations: increased setbacks from water courses, a reduced overall cut, a ban on winter operations, and a prohibition from logging in extremely erosive “high-risk” South Fork Elk River tributaries. Water Quality’s executive director has already delayed a 600-acre HRC harvest plan, adjacent to Headwaters On February 5, Water Quality staff will hold a workshop on the Technical Analysis and TMDL Action Plan at the Humboldt County Agricultural Center, 5630 South Broadway, Eureka. Comment on those documents is due by February 15. (Comment period on the WDR closed January 18.) Final adoption of the TMDL is scheduled for April 7 at the Wharfinger Building, Eureka. All the relevant plans and documents may be found at the Water Quality Board website, http://www.waterboards.

Forest and residential neighborhoods, that will affect several of those high-risk watersheds. Residents maintain that Water Quality’s zero doesn’t really mean zero. Kristi Wrigley, a thirdgeneration Elk River apple farmer, asks, “Why permit any new logging, and generate sediment that will get into the river, if the TMDL says no new sediment?” She points to the “Tier 2” exemptions of the previous WDR, which also promised zerosediment logging, but then only counted sediment if it was proven to have come from landslides within the timber harvest plan. Miles of roads have already been opened in the high-risk watersheds using those Tier 2 exemptions. The new WDR would also empower the Chair of the Water Quality Board to grant “exceptions” to its prohibition against logging in the high-risk tributaries of the South Fork. If he finds that HRC has made “a meaningful contribution” to water quality, such as restoring a flood channel, a culvert, or a damaged water system, he can set aside those prohibitions. “And what about the North Fork?” Wrigley asks about the watercourse that has left several feet of silt in her orchard. “Water Quality seems to want to make it an industrial waste ditch.” Environmental advocates also agree that the harvest rate—an annual average of 2% of HRC’s 20,000 acres of Upper Elk River—is still much too high for this steep and damaged watershed and that the proposed setbacks are still inadequate. Residents say they don’t feel included in the restoration process—which is not expected to begin for another five years. In May of 2014, residents submitted a petition to Water Quality asking for a moratorium on all Elk River logging until the watershed has begun to recover, but they have not received a response. HRC maintains that its timber harvesting adds no silt to the river. They have protested the new restrictions, and behind their complaints are the deep pockets of John Fisher, heir of the Gap fortune and owner of both HRC and Mendocino Redwood (not to mention the long-suffering Oakland A’s). HRC has already sued the Board to approve their South Fork timber harvest plan. Submit written comments to the Regional Water Quality Board, attn: Alydda Mangelsdorf email: fax: 707-523-0135 mail: California Regional Water Quality Control Board —North Coast Region ATTN Alydda Mangelsdorf 5550 Skylane Blvd, Suite A Santa Rosa, CA 95403.


Eye on

Washington Dan Sealy, NEC Legislative Analyst

The Good News from Washington As 2015 showed signs of backsliding in most areas of environmental protection and public land use, the strength of local voices aligned with national organizations prevailed to shut down some of the worst legislation coming out of Congress. Yes, grass roots organizations like the Northcoast Environmental Center do make a difference. We helped stop bills that would remove or limit public scrutiny of large timber operations, give salvage logging a huge pass on public comment, ignore science and remove endangered species protection, and ship even more water to California’s Central Valley. The NEC joined with thousands of others in letter after letter to our congressional delegation opposing these bad bills. In doing so, we enabled them to prove their constituents were against slashing our environmental laws in order to favor corporate interests. Most of those victories were accomplished at the last minute in conference committees behind closed doors. The good news out of 2015: Your voice counts, but only if you participate. The other good news out of Washington this year relates to climate change. Not only did President Obama stop the Keystone XL pipeline from running the dirtiest tar sands oil from Canada to the Gulf of Mexico to ship to foreign countries, but the Obama Administration also made bold commitments at the 2015 UN Climate Change Conference in Paris (see page 7). Many following the events were surprised that the U.S. went beyond expectations toward reducing our impacts on climate change. Much of the success of the conference is based on industrial nations, like the U.S., helping poorer countries who R I V E R


Find great, inexpensive books to relax with by the river 6th & H Streets Arcata • 826-2545 Open Mon-Fri 10am-6pm • Sat 10am-5pm

want the same energy benefits as industrialized nations. A skeptical Congress will have to fund those climate initiatives in the coming years. The ultimate success of our country’s commitments will be sealed in the 2016 presidential and congressional elections. The bad news: Congress reversed our 40-year ban on exporting American crude oil. The final Omnibus (a funding bill with lots of “riders”) included the decision to allow export of U.S. crude oil to China and other countries. Why? So energy corporations can maximize their profits, plain and simple. The effort to sway Congress and the public was led by the American Petroleum Institute President and CEO Jack Gerard. The result will be higher gas prices for everyone. Next time you hear a politician or oil executive suggest we need to assure energy independence so we do not have to rely on our “enemies” in the Middle East for oil, remind them of the 2015 push to allow American oil companies to export oil for the first time since 1975. If you are a wolf or a sage grouse, 2015 was not a good year for you either. Though most of the bad bills related to endangered species were stopped, sage grouse and wolves did not fare well. Our vigilance is needed to assure future generations see them in the wild.

What’s Coming? What’s coming? All or most of those bad bills will be put forward again. HR 2647, the socalled “Resilient Forest Act” that would allow thousands of acres of forests to be logged with little or no public input, is already back on the table in the House of Representatives. That bill was very nearly included in the Omnibus funding bill but was removed at the last minute due to community opposition. There is no time to rest. Bad bills, of which there is no shortage, need to receive strong, immediate and forceful opposition. The NEC is providing just that —with your support. 2016 is, of course, an election year. Look for lots of grandstanding by all parties and little accomplishment, but with this Congress, perhaps that is yet another good thing. Happy 2016!

Because fracking (unconventional hydrocarbon extraction) threatens water and air quality wherever it is used, a group calling themselves H u m b o l d t Community Rights is recruiting volunteers to collect signatures to place an ordinance on the ballot for the November 2016 election that would ban fracking in Humboldt County. Signatures will be collected from eligible voters in February through April. People interested in supporting this initiative are invited to sign up at the group’s website: In November 2014, the people of Mendocino County voted overwhelmingly to pass Measure “S,” a community bill of rights ordinance which makes fracking illegal in that county, reinforced with fines and incarceration. By passing a similar measure here in Humboldt County, more people and a larger contiguous area of the North Coast will be protected from the hazards posed by fracking. Community bill of rights ordinances use the California Constitution, Article 2, Section 1: “All power is inherent in the people” as a legal basis for local people to establish human rights and legal rights for natural environments. Based on this constitutional provision, the proposed Humboldt County ordinance asserts citizens have the right to local self-governance and rights to clean water and air, safe soil, freedom from toxic trespass, peaceful enjoyment of home, and a sustainable energy future by giving ecosystems and natural communities legal rights, all with respect to the single issue of banning fracking.

Japan Tsunami Marine Debris Call or email the NEC to register in advance, or for more information: or 707-822-6918.

Monitoring 9

Local Group Promotes Anti-Fracking Initiative

Humboldt County: SAMOA BEACH


SATURDAY @ 9:00 AM April 16, 2016

SUNDAY @ 10:00 AM April 17, 2016


Beach Cleanups Feb/Mar 2016


18th Annual Seed and Plant Exchange Colin Fiske

In 1999, a small group of Humboldt County residents began what would become a treasured local tradition—the annual spring Seed & Plant Exchange. This year, its 18th year, the event takes place on March 26 at the Arcata Community Center, presented by the Humboldt Permaculture Guild. Participants bring local seeds or live plants to this free exchange (if they can), and take whatever they reasonably expect to use. People bring seeds they’ve saved themselves or left-over commercial seed, as well as live plants or cuttings from their gardens. Several seed companies also usually donate seed to make sure no one goes home empty-handed. The only hard-and-fast rule is that no invasive plants are allowed. The event itself has grown from a small gathering into a bona fide institution. For the last several years, the event has drawn over 1,000 participants. Fresh, locally sourced food is served; local musicians provide entertainment. Local food, agriculture, and sustainability-related nonprofits and businesses provide educational materials and sell products and services. Workshops teach the basics of seed saving and other important topics for local gardening and sustainable living. A month earlier, on February 13 at the Bayside Grange, be a part of a related but newer tradition— the 3rd Annual Fruit Tree & Scion Exchange. This event follows the same format as the Seed & Plant Exchange, but the focus is on swapping scion wood—the pieces of wood cut from living trees which can be grafted onto other related trees or rootstock to propagate a particular variety of fruit. Our region has great potential for perennial agriculture and fruit production. Grafting information and demonstrations will be provided. The Humboldt Permaculture Guild is a regional, community-based, grassroots group which aims to promote permaculture ideas and practices on the North Coast. To find out more about the Guild, its two signature annual events, and permaculture in general, look up the Guild on Facebook or contact

Underwater Parks Day Celebrated, Under Water (from the Sky)

Delia Bense-Kang, NEC MPA Outreach Coordinator

Cleanup Collaboration The Northcoast Environmental Center and Humboldt Surfrider Chapter will now be collaborating with PacOut Green Team on a regular basis. Every other last Saturday of the month from 9-10 am, these three organizations will tackle the area from the New Navy Base Road to north of Samoa County Park and Boat Ramp. These events are a fun easy way to get out and practice a little environmental stewardship. Enter to win raffle prizes simply by showing up!

Ocean Night

The NEC’s Delia Bense-Kang and Madison Peters (center) celebrate Underwater Parks Day at the Humboldt Bay Tourism Center with representatives of MARE and PacOut.

Ocean Night is climbing the ladder in Humboldt’s social scene. The NEC, Surfrider Humboldt Chapter, and Humboldt Baykeeper host surf films and ocean-related environmental documentaries every first Thursday of the month at the Arcata Theater Lounge. This restored art deco theater has one of the largest screens in Northern California and a full pub menu and bar. For over five years, Ocean Night has consistently drawn crowds of 50-100 people. In January, an estimated 200 people filled the room. Providing a family-friendly, inexpensive, educational, and just plain fun social gathering, Ocean Night is set to continue throughout 2016.

Underwater Parks Day

Even while on land, Humboldt celebrated Underwater Parks Day on January 9 literally under water from the onslaught of heavy rain. Marine Protected Areas (MPAs)—sometimes referred to as “underwater parks”—conserve and restore wildlife and habitats in our ocean, just as national and state parks do on land. The Northcoast Environmental Center hosted two events to mark the occasion: a guided walk in the Ma-le’l Dunes and a Celebration/ Information night in Old Town Eureka. Despite the stormy weather, tour guides Carol Vander Meer of Friends of the Dunes, Marnin

Robbins of the California Department of Fish and Wildlife and Delia Bense-Kang of the NEC) showed up decked out in rain gear, eager to learn about the two unique protected areas, the Male’l Dunes and the adjacent Samoa State Marine Conservation Area (SMCA). The Ma-le’l Dunes were set aside by the U.S. government in the mid 1800s, and the California MPA network was completed in 2012. Vander Meer led the excursion through the dune forest, over the foredunes, and through the wetland swales to the open beach. These areas are protected, but they are open to the public. The Samoa SMCA and Ma-le’l Dunes are some of Humboldt County’s best coastal areas for walks, picnics, and beachcombing. Later, the PacOut Green Team, the Marine Applied Research and Exploration Team (MARE), and Humboldt Surfrider joined the NEC at the Humboldt Bay Tourism Center to showcase a display of local information materials about MPAs and ways to enjoy them. The grand prize raffle item of the evening was a SUP paddle adventure for two (provided by Tim Haywood of Pacific Outfitters) that went to winners Molly Daly and Bryce Pierce. Daly stated, “Having the opportunity to see the research and talk to people about protecting local marine life was the highlight of my Saturday. It was really interesting and fun!”

BRANT ELECTRIC Calif. License #406330


(707)822-3256 EcoNews Feb/Mar 2016


Remembering Two Fallen Giants

Lucille Vinyard

by Dan Sealy Lucille Vinyard was called the “Mother of Redwood National Park” by a former park superintendent. I’m sure that quote will be used often in the many memorials for this amazing woman as we mourn her passing in December. Lucille was born on December 17, 1918 in Santa Cruz, California. I try to imagine what Santa Cruz and redwood forests must have been like in her childhood. I asked Lucille what sparked her interest in redwoods and she told me her mother used to take her on picnics near their home. Those trees were home. She said they were beautiful, and could not imagine cutting one down. This was her motivation to organize with the local chapter of the Sierra Club in the early 1960’s to stop the “mowing down” of the trees she loved. She saw the creation of a National Park as a solution. Lucille defied all stereotypes. She was a Republican until Reagan slashed funding for conservation. She not only loved bird-watching, hiking, backpacking and rafting, but was also an avid golfer, fisherman and hunter. Though her wardrobe of choice was blue jeans and a work shirt, she loved recalling the exact pink dress she wore to a hearing about Redwood National Park so she would stand out amongst the dark-suited men. It was always an honor to visit Lucille and her husband Bill (a botanist and professor) in


their home perched above Moonstone Beach. Adventure, laughter and dedicated conservation work co-existed in their home. The Northcoast Environmental Center owes much of its beginnings to Lucille’s dedication. She was present at the organizational meeting of the NEC on November 24, 1970 and was a founding board member representing the North Group of the Sierra Club’s Redwood Chapter. Lucille was a fighter, who inspired me and other activists like me. Once after giving a talk promoting the creation of Redwood National Park, a logger from the audience threatened to shove her house into the ocean. In public hearings to expand Redwood National Park she was spat on and not-sosubtly threatened with a knife. She and I laughed at having to quickly hide by rolling into a logging road ditch on private timber land above Redwood Creek to avoid being caught. We were determined to give witness to the clearcutting devastation wrought by timber companies above Tall Trees Grove. Without the likes of Lucille we surely would not have Redwood National Park and we might not have the Trinity Alps, Marble Mountain or Russian Wilderness areas. Lucille and I laughed recalling the bus trip we took over Oregon Pass on 299 in the early 1970’s to testify at an all night Forest Service hearing to protect the Trinity Alps. The bus slid and swerved on the snowy road but the busload of conservation activists encouraged the driver on. I will never forget that ride or the energy she shared at that hearing. It would be wrong to think that saving our natural areas was “man’s work.” Lucille was right

there on the frontline along with Kaye Chaffee, Susie Van Kirk and many other women. Lucille and her female comrades reminded us what women leaders can do. Lucille’s battle was never complete. Longtime friends Joe Gillespie and Dave Van de Mark gathered around Lucille’s dining table to look at maps in 2014, discussing new efforts to add over 300,000 acres of wilderness protection in our region. She and Dave nodded heads as they pointed out trails and mountains that were outside wilderness boundaries and needed protection. This was the Lucille I had known for 45 years. This autumn, I met with Lucille so she could sign her letter to add acres of wilderness across the mountains she loved, but would also include portions of Redwood Creek Valley in Redwood National Park to wilderness, as she had always hoped for. Lucille wrote: “As I look at the forests, mountains and rivers in this place I call home, I am proud of the work we did, but I also know it is not complete. I encourage you to fulfill our obligation to protect these lands for this and future generations. In this rapidly growing nation we need to assure our people of all ages have access to places of inspiration and recreation.” Though Lucille received several awards for her conservation work, her real reward was hiking and rafting in places she helped save for future generations. It would be nice if the struggle was over and all was saved, but that is not the case. Fortunately Lucille and her conservation friends have inspired generations of activists to continue this important work. We need to be brave, like Lucille, and never give up.

Above: Lucille stands on newly fallen redwoods near Elam Creek inside the proposed Redwood National Park boundary, October 22, 1967. Photo: Dave van der Mark. Photo page 13: Crop from a group photo from the 2004 Caltrans Cushing Creek groundbreaking including Lucille and Susie standing together. Photo: Dave Van der Mark.

Feb/Mar 2016


See next page for information on sending in your memories of Lucille and Susie!

Susie Van Kirk

by Suzanne Guerra The late 60s were a time of great change on the North Coast. A decade-long battle had resulted in the establishment of Redwood National Park in 1968, and in the formation of several active conservation groups in the region by 1969. Susie planned to complete her MA in biology at HSU, where her husband Bob Van Kirk had been appointed to the faculty. She began to study and explore the local area, where she met environmentalists Lucille Vinyard and Dr. Rudi Becking. Inspired by the first Earth Day in 1970, local conservation groups formed an umbrella organization, the Northcoast Environmental Center, and Susie joined the first board of directors in 1971. In 1972, Caltrans proposed conversion of Highway 101 through Arcata from a four lane highway to an eight lane freeway, calling for the removal of more than 200 homes and businesses in the heart of the town. The Van Kirk’s home was located at the eastern boundary of the demolition zone so she could see the scale of the damage. Susie joined the student based Stop-at-Four Committee, and represented the Committee when they submitted a petition to the City Council to halt the project. While the Council turned down the initiative and construction moved forward, the conflict spurred major changes in the composition of the City Council and a shift in local politics. Chris Beresford, a longtime NEC volunteer who resided in the same neighborhood, recalls “Get-Out the Vote” meetings at the Van Kirk house.

EcoNews Feb/Mar 2016

Beginning a long collaboration with NEC director Tim McKay, Susie soon became an integral part of the NEC’s team of researchers and advisors; often representing the Sierra Club’s-North Group and providing detailed analyses and comments on timber harvest plans and environmental impact reports. Logging on adjacent private lands was considered a threat to Redwood National Park, and by 1972, the student organized Emerald Creek Committee began working with the NEC—joining a larger effort led by the Sierra Club to expand the Park. In 1973, California’s Z’berg-Nejedly Forest Practices Act had increased public regulation of private logging. When the National Forest Management Act of 1976 directed national forests throughout the country to prepare forest plans based on sustained yield of all forest resources, Susie’s comments helped to shape the direction of plans for Six Rivers, Klamath and Shasta-Trinity National Forest, and later provided analyses of herbicide spraying on forestlands. Archivist Edie Butler would later observe, “Through her grasp of the complexity of an issue (the result of countless hours of research and study) Susie has helped others to be informed and to advance the quality of discussions and public deliberations.” The freeway expansion project in Arcata had aroused public concerns about housing shortages and the loss of historic buildings and structures. A volunteer group had been organized to inventory historic properties, the Historic Sites Society of Arcata (HSSA), and Susie became their primary researcher and documentarian. The first historical resources survey of Arcata was the basis for her best known book, Reflections of Arcata’s History: Eighty Years of Architecture. Applying her thorough and methodical approach to historic preservation, she would write more than three dozen historic property nominations, a dozen publications on regional architectural history, and numerous local histories and reports. In 2000, she collaborated with preservation consultant Kathleen Stanton on the “Local Legacies Oral History Project” to document

the post WWII logging boom and subsequent environmental movement of the last half of the 20th century. Cited by local librarians as the foremost authority on Humboldt County newspapers, in 2004 Susie completed an extensive study of Northwestern California Newspapers for the HSU library ( Her unique understanding of both natural and cultural history was evident in her work on the Lyons Ranch in the Bald Hills, a National Register of Historic Places nomination. The Lyons family was mixed race, Mrs Lyons was Hupa, and the ranch was in the Chilula home territory. As historian Jerry Rohde explained, “She told me that if she could do anything she wanted it would be this—trying to restore what years of genocide and repression had cast asunder.” Susie’s historical research, like all of her projects, reflected a strong sense of social justice and a conviction that she had a responsibility to serve as an advocate. Susie had begun to work with food programs, homeless and houseless shelters in the 1990s, and befriended many individuals, helping each in important and lasting ways. In nominating Susie for the 1999 Woman of Achievement award, Edie Butler stated, “Susie Van Kirk works quietly and diligently to make this region a better place for all of us. I wish that she were in the limelight more but she would not want that. Her works have touched every one of us and they will have a positive impact for years and years to come.” Left: Susie evaluating a scrapbook at the 2002 Bayside Grange Photo History Day while another volunteer takes notes. Photo: Suzanne Guerra. Below: Susie Van Kirk, published on the cover of the NorthCoast Journal, 2004. Submitted by Suzanne Guerra.


Share Your Memories of Lucille and Susie

March 18 Deadline for Student Bird Art Contest For the 13th year, Friends of the Arcata Marsh and Redwood Region Audubon Society are co-sponsoring a Student Bird Art Contest in conjunction with Godwit Days. Some $550 in prizes will be awarded to Humboldt County students from kindergarten through high school who submit a drawing of one of 40 suggested species or another common local bird. Prize(s) also will be awarded for the best rendition of a bird in its natural habitat. Entries will be judged by local wildlife artists and educators. Awards will be presented at the 21st Godwit Days Spring Migration Bird Festival on Saturday, April 16 at 11 a.m. All entries will be displayed at the Arcata Community Center during the Festival and copies of winning artwork will be shown at the Arcata Marsh Interpretive Center in May. A flyer with complete rules and a list of suggested birds is posted at or can be picked up at the Arcata Marsh Interpretive Center, Strictly for the Birds in Old Town Eureka, or by sending a self-addressed stamped envelope to Sue Leskiw, 155 Kara Lane, McKinleyville 95519. Flyers will be mailed to all schools in Humboldt County. Artwork may be dropped off at Strictly for the Birds, 123 F Street, Eureka, or the Arcata Marsh Interpretive Center, 569 South G Street, Arcata, or mailed to Sue at the address listed above. Entries must be received by Friday, March 18 to be considered. Questions should be e-mailed to

We at NEC understand that no one person or group could cover all the important, passionate work Lucille and Susie did for our community and for our earth. We were fortunate to work with them. We know many of our friends and readers have stories to share about these two women and we invite you to share those with us. We will put as much of them on our website in upcoming months as possible. If you would like to share some stories, please mail them to NEC Board Vice-President Dan Sealy at The more concise your memories and tributes are, the more likely we can make everything available on the NEC website. We will also be archiving all tributes for future reference and research.

Thank you ~ the NEC Board

Klamath Dams Relicensing Process Begins

Because Congress failed to pass legislation before a December 2015 deadline that would have implemented the multi-stakeholder Klamath Settlement Agreements for dam removal, water sharing, and restoration, another approach must be taken to address the aged dams and the compromised water quality of the river. The California Water Board is moving forward with reviewing PacifiCorp’s application to relicense the dams which could reignite the Klamath Water War. The day this issue of EcoNews went to print, locals concerned about the future of the four Klamath River were anticipating the first of three meetings to discuss relicensing applications by dam owner PacifiCorp. The meetings were scheduled to be held in Arcata, Orleans and Yreka on January 25 and 26. After decades of bitter fights between Tribes, fishermen and irrigators, groups negotiated a water sharing agreement in 2010. Supporters believed the Klamath Restoration Agreements would balance water use between fish and farms, improve irrigation

infrastructure, fund fish restoration, and remove the lower four Klamath dams. The Agreements required congressional approval to be enacted. Despite broad support from Tribes, conservationists, irrigators, Oregon, California, and even dam owner PacifiCorp, Congress failed to take action. The Water Board held the Clean Water Act permit process in abeyance for several years while Settlement Parties appealed to Congress to enact the Agreements. “We think we can convince the Water Board to deny PacifiCorp’s license application,” says Karuk Natural Resources Director Leaf Hillman. “The dams harm water quality in ways that can’t be mitigated.” Konrad Fisher of Klamath Riverkeeper agrees. “We think the dams are destined for removal.” However, everyone agrees that this route will likely land PacifiCorp, the state, and interested parties in court for years to come. Never before has a state flat out denied a water quality permit to a dam owner. Continued on page 20

Dandelion Herbal Center Join Jane Bothwell for ........................................

• Herbal Study Classes • Herb Walks • Travel Adventures Call for class schedule PO Box 4440, Arcata, CA 95549



Feb/Mar 2016


New Laws for California Compost

Photo: Elaine Faith, CC

Margaret Gainer With millions of households in the United States struggling to have enough to eat, and millions of tons of food being tossed in the garbage, food waste is increasingly being seen as a serious environmental and economic issue. Americans are throwing out the equivalent of $165 billion each year, and the food waste rots in landfills where it produces a significant portion of U.S. methane emissions. More than a third of the waste disposed by Humboldt County is food and organic material. California has adopted five new composting laws to provide for or require commercial organics recycling, tax exemptions for recycling and composting equipment, detailing organics

infrastructure, recycling and composting reporting, and composting promotion, according to CalRecycle, the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery. ZWH looks forward to working with local jurisdictions, entrepreneurs, and community groups to solve this waste problem. Juliette Bohn and Morgan King’s presentations on “Food Waste Solutions” on October 29, 2015 clearly indicated that we have the know-how in this region. The new composting laws are intended to move California toward its 75 percent recycling goal by 2020, and to measure its progress as it reaches for this objective. CalRecycle is confident this will also boost the state economically. “These new laws encourage innovation and strengthen California’s role as the nationwide leader in sustainable living,” said CalRecycle Director Scott Smithline. This is a great opportunity for local public, private and community groups to pull together to resolve a major waste problem. For more information and to get involved, email Erika Guevara Blackwell at

New California Composting Laws AB 1826 requires businesses to set up recycling services, if they produce at least eight cubic yards of organic waste per week, beginning in April. AB 199 provides businesses with tax exemptions as an allowance for recycling and composting equipment and expands the tax exclusion for recycled feedstock to make new products. AB 876 requires local governments to report necessary organics infrastructure and locations for new or expanded infrastructure. Counties and agencies will need to forecast their estimated organic waste over a 15-year period. AB 901 names CalRecycle as the overseer of existing disposal reporting requirements, and updates reporting requirements for recycling, composting and solid waste disposal facilities. AB 1045 requires CalRecycle and other state agencies to develop and implement policies to divert organic waste from landfills and to promote uses for the material.

Californians Against Waste Director Speaks Locally Zero Waste Humboldt invites the public to a presentation on “Legislative Action for California’s Zero Waste Solutions” on Friday, March 4, 5:30–7:00 p.m. at the Humboldt State University College Creek Great Hall. Featured speaker Mark Murray, Executive Director of Californians Against Waste and HSU alum, will discuss Producer Responsibility—a core value in CAW’s

development of legislative policies and incentives for manufacturers to reduce toxicity and waste, design for recyclability, increase use of recycled materials, and recommend steps for local Zero Waste Action Plans. A $10 donation is requested at the door. For information or to RSVP, email

Solutions for Small Business Located in the Greenway Building 8 th and N in Arcata

Call for an appointment



EcoNews Feb/Mar 2016


Humboldt Bay King Tides Photo Initiative in its Fourth Year

Upper left: Map of King Tide photos on Middle, above: Mad River Slough Bridge, Highway 255 in Manila, 12-24-15. Photo: Bernie Levy. Upper right: South I Street at the Arcata Marsh, 10-28-15. Photo: Saroj Gilbert. Left: Graph of predicted and actual tide height, from

Jennifer Kalt, Director Since 2012, Humboldt Baykeeper has led the Humboldt Bay King Tide Photo Initiative, which documents the highest tides of the year and allows us to envision how flooding from rising sea level will

New Zealand Mud Snail Discovered in Local Stream

The Humboldt Bay watershed’s first known occurrence of the invasive New Zealand mud snail was discovered by a student at Humboldt State University in a daylit section of creek on campus. They have previously been reported in Big Lagoon, Stone Lagoon, and Redwood Creek in Orick. The snails reproduce by the hundreds and pose threats to native species, including aquatic insects that are the primary food source for coho salmon, steelhead, and other threatened fish species. There is no known method to eradicate the snail once it is introduced, so preventing its further spread is critical. Fishermen, researchers, and anyone else who frequently travels between riparian or aquatic locations should be sure not to spread the snails, which are small enough to go unnoticed on waders, bootlaces, and other gear. Thorough cleaning of gear followed by freezing or complete drying is the best way to ensure that


New Zealand mud snails on the bottom of a boot. Photo: Robyn Draheim, CC.

you are not contributing to the New Zealand mud snail’s expansion into Humboldt territory. You can help prevent the spread of this invasive aquatic snail by reporting suspected sightings to L. Breck McAlexander at the California Department of Fish & Wildlife’s Invasive Mussel Project in Redding via email:

increasingly impact our beaches, shoreline, neighborhoods, and low-lying infrastructure such as roads, water and sewer pipelines, electric and gas transmission lines, and sewage treatment plants. Nearly 100 volunteers have taken thousands of photographs documenting the highest of high tides at dozens of locations around the bay. Thanks to funding from the Trees Foundation’s Cereus Fund and individual contributions, we have continued to lead this effort, compiling and mapping photos while building a long-term dataset. King Tide photos from dozens of locations are posted on the Humboldt Bay King Tides Initiative’s Flickr page at humboldtbaykingtides/ (see graphic, upper left). Due to El Niño and the unusually warm ocean conditions off of California, sea levels have been elevated, causing the King Tides (highest predicted tides caused by alignment of earth, moon and sun) to be extra high this winter, resulting in the highest sea levels ever recorded in the history of tide stations at the San Diego, La Jolla and Santa Barbara tide stations. The San Diego tide station has been recording sea levels since 1906, La Jolla since 1924 and Santa Barbara since 1974. In the Humboldt Bay area, this year’s King Tides were nearly a foot higher than predicted in October, November, and December. On December 21, the actual high tide was more than one foot higher than predicted, as shown in the graph above left.

Feb/Mar 2016


The Environmental Protection Information Center

ep c

Tell the Fish and Game Commission to Protect the Humboldt Marten Tom Wheeler The coastal marten (Martes caurina humboldtensis), known best around these parts as the “Humboldt marten,” is a stealthy, cat-sized forest carnivore in the weasel family (related to minks and otters). These extremely secretive animals are known for their slinky walking motion and ability to prey on porcupines by biting them on the face. Typically about two feet long, with large, triangular ears and a long tail, they eat small mammals, berries and birds, and are preyed on by larger mammals and raptors. The Humboldt marten virtually disappeared from California due to a combination of trapping— its coat, which looks far better on the marten than on a human, is undeniably stunning—and logging. Trapping the marten is currently prohibited, but logging of marten habitat still occurs without abandon within its range. Marten prefer older forest types where they can hide from predators under a thicket of ferns, salal, and huckleberry, and where prey like wood rats abound. While they can utilize other forest types, including younger stands, these forests are not ideal for the marten. Martens are also sensitive to forest fragmentation. Aware of the risk of a hungry bobcat, the Humboldt marten does not like to be out in the open, exposed and far from a hiding spot. California’s last remaining population of Humboldt martens is so small that they were once thought to be extinct. In 1996, after 35,000 survey nights were logged using baited track plates and infrared cameras placed throughout forests in Northwest California and yielded no detections, a Humboldt marten boldly left his print on a track plate located in a remote section of Six Rivers National Forest. The Humboldt marten was alive! However, California’s sole Humboldt marten population is not doing well. In 1998, researchers estimated that there were likely around 60 martens left in California, located near the Humboldt/ Del Norte border. Alarmingly, between 2001 and 2012, the most recent survey information publicly available, the remaining population of Humboldt marten has declined to approximately 40 martens—a drop of 42 percent! Keep in mind, this

EcoNews Feb/Mar 2016

Shortly after the listing was denied, we filed our petition to list the marten under the California Endangered Species Act. On February 11, the Fish and Game Commission will determine whether to take the first step in protecting the marten under the California Endangered Species Act by deciding whether it should be a candidate for final listing. By declaring the marten a candidate, the Fish and Game Commission will trigger a one-year review period after which the Commission will make a final decision on whether to protect the Humboldt marten. This is a crucial first step. Because the federal U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service failed to honor its duty to protect the marten, it is even more critical that the Fish and Game Commission move forward with protecting the marten. Listing the marten under the California Endangered Species Act will not only prohibit humans from harming the marten—in legal parlance, all individuals are prohibited from “taking” the marten—but it will also open up private and government funding sources for restoration activities. was largely before the record setting drought. This number is so low that a single event, such as disease, poisoning or fire could eradicate all coastal marten from California. This number is also so low that the species could simply drift towards extinction. Alarmed by the extremely low population, in 2010 EPIC and allies petitioned the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to list the Humboldt marten under the federal Endangered Species Act. By listing, the species would have received important protections necessary to prevent the marten’s extinction. We were shocked in Spring 2015 when the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service refused to protect the marten. Without federal protection, but needing to do something, we turned to the California Fish and Game Commission. We sued the Fish and Wildlife Service too, for good measure, as their refusal to protect the marten was clearly against the law.


Please write to the Fish and Game Commission and ask them to protect the Humboldt marten. (Handwritten letters are the most effective!) California Fish and Game Commission P.O. Box 944209 Sacramento, CA 94244-2090

For more info visit


NORTH GROUP REDWOOD CHAPTER California Forestry Reform Moves Forward Ned Forsyth, North Group Executive Committee Member Implementation of California’s new Timber Regulation and Forest Restoration (TRFR) Program continues, following the enactment of AB 1492 in 2012. State officials and other stakeholders met in Ukiah in December for the latest in a series of public hearings to collaborate on “Planning Watershed Pilot Projects” and other aspects of the program. Now in the early stages of the Program, there is a real opportunity for citizen environmentalists, scientists, restoration practitioners, and other stakeholders, including large and small landowners and the timber industry, to take advantage of this new publicly-funded, science-based approach to conserving the public’s shared natural heritage of our magnificent productive forests. The watershed pilot projects will assess cumulative effects of past and present logging practices to identify specific restoration needs. The projects will serve as a “laboratory” for increasing efficiency and effectiveness in gathering actionable data and developing a set of best practices to serve all stakeholders. The December meeting was attended by over 50 people, and early comments emphasized their vision that the working group be active participants, not just advisors. Other remarks pointed to the key importance of describing watershed conditions at the outset, to include original conditions as well as subsequent forest damage. In order to chart a realistic pathway to an optimally functioning ecosystem, all participants should have a common understanding of the starting point. Timber Harvest Plans (THPs), while a potential source of historical watershed health data, may be subject to bias—the reported data may arise from a narrow set of legal permit requirements, rather than from true scientific inquiry.

In Memoriam


Logging roads on steep, unstable slopes have been a major source of sediment impairing water quality and destroying salmon habitat. This road failure delivered fine sediment to Shakleford Creek in the Scott River Basin. Photo: Felice Pace.

Early skeptics decried AB 1492 a “backroom deal” and a “taxpayer subsidy” of some of California’s largest landowners and timber operators. In addition to the one percent tax on retail lumber products, the bill also provides an extension of time limits for individual THP’s and sets some liability limits for parties responsible for wildland fire damage to public resources. Under the TRFR program, the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection’s administrative responsibility for logging regulation on private lands is now formally shared with the departments of Environmental Protection and Conservation and the State and Regional Water Quality Boards. An annual report to the Legislature is mandated. Funding from the TRFR Program also goes to the Department of Fish and Wildlife’s Fisheries Restoration Grant Program. Urgency for these reforms was created by the budget problems of 2009-2010 that led to appalling staff shortages and inability to carry out THP reviews as intended by the original Forest Practice Act of 1973. Judging from the form and content of these initial public meetings for the pilot projects, there is hope for some improvement in outcomes for our imperiled wildlife. With the State’s increased commitment to gathering scientific data, increased funding to restore damaged watersheds, and more opportunities for input from the public, we should expect to make some headway against the serious losses our forests and rivers have suffered from industrialized forestry, road-building and other impacts over the years. I have some faith in our ability to mitigate some of these problems with more people involved armed with more knowledge of what we need to do.


One need not be a Sierra Club member to participate in these outings. Please join us! Saturday, February 20. North Group Sierra Club Del Norte Redwoods State Park Last Chance Coastal Trail Hike. Join us for this eight-mile ramble through lush old-growth on a stretch of Redwood Highway replaced in the 1930s. We may glimpse waters below coastal bluffs, while we pause before returning as we came. Bring water and lunch. No dogs. Carpools at 9 a.m. Valley West (Ray’s) Shopping Center, 10:30 a.m. Damnation Creek trailhead (3.3 mi. north of Wilson Creek bridge, west side Hwy. 101). Leader Ned, 707-825-3652. Heavy rain cancels. Saturday, March 12. North Group Sierra Club Prairie Creek State Park Ossagon Trail Hike. We will hike on an old overgrown road from Newton B. Drury Parkway through majestic redwoods, spruce and alder to Ossagon Rocks on a remote part of Gold Beach. We will explore the beach, tides permitting, before returning, for about a five-mile round trip. Bring water and lunch. No dogs. Carpools 9 a.m. Valley West (Ray’s) Shopping Center, 10:30 a.m. Ossagon trailhead, or by prior arrangement. Leader Ned, 707-825-3652. Heavy rain cancels.

Join Us!

The North Group’s Executive Committee meets on the second Tuesday of each month on the first floor conference room at the Adorni Center on the waterfront in Eureka. The meeting, which covers regular business and conservation issues, begins at 6:45 PM. Members and non-members with environmental concerns are encouraged to attend. When a new person comes to us with an environmental issue or concern, we often place them first or early on the agenda.

Feb/Mar 2016


NORTHCOAST CHAPTER Sign up for e-mail announcements:

Evening Programs


At the Six Rivers Masonic Lodge, 251 Bayside Rd., near 7th and Union, Arcata. Refreshments at 7:00 p.m.; program at 7:30 p.m.

For more details and later additions, visit:

Beginners, experts, non-members, and members are all welcome at our programs and on our outings. Almost all of our events are free. All of our events are made possible by volunteer effort.

Field Trips & Plant Walks

Saturday, February 27—Dune Forest Exploration. Two manzanitas and their hybrid will be targets for a day in the dune forest of the North Spit. Pink calypsos are unlikely but possible. Treks across the dunes to the beach or over the railroad to the salty shore of the bay are likely. The exact location of this outing is still being worked out, but expect between two to four miles of walking. Meet at 9 a.m. at Pacific Union School or arrange another place. Dress for being in the weather all day! Bring lunch and water. Return late afternoon. For information call Carol at 707-822-2015. Sunday, March 27—Arcata City Trail field trip. The recently completed, northernmost section of the Humboldt Bay Trail is a paved trail from Arcata Skate Park on Sunset Ave. to Samoa Blvd. Including the adjacent Shay Park, the 1.3 mile route passes three species of blackberries, at least three species of willows, four conifers, and (with a small detour) a population of the rare Howell’s miner’s lettuce (Montia howellii). We will document these and the common native and non-native plants seen along this unfamiliar path through familiar territory. Meet at the Foster Ave. side of the new roundabout on Sunset Ave. Park in the nearby neighborhood. We might do a shuttle to make the walk one way, or may add on Potawot Village or Arcata Marsh. Be prepared for weather and walking; bring your lunch and water. Please tell Carol you are coming: 707-822-2015. Saturday, April 2—Burnt Ranch and Grays Falls Day Trip. It’s fawn lily time at Burnt Ranch Campground! East along Highway 299, we may also find other spring blooms like Indian Warrior and Checker Lily. We’ll look for the minute, rare Howell’s Montia in campsite #16, then explore the varied habitats at Grays Falls Picnic Area, including the short trail down to the falls. Meet at 8:30 a.m. at Pacific Union School, 9:15 a.m. at the museum parking lot in Willow Creek, or about 10 a.m. at Burnt Ranch Campground. Dress for the weather; bring lunch, water and clippers (for clipping Himalayan blackberry). Return late afternoon. Please tell Carol you are coming: 707-822-2015.

EcoNews Feb/Mar 2016

Wednesday, February 10—David Imper and Greg O’Connell explore the North Coast’s rare plants. Beginning with a presentation about the Red Mountain Two-Flowered preserve, Dave Imper will explore the needs of establishing a conservation easement and the monitoring and habitat maintenance required for the foreseeable future. Dave hopes to engage the CNPS community in this exciting opportunity to work together in this area of unique serpentine soils that supports the only known population of Lathyrus biflorus. Following Dave’s presentation, Greg O’Connell will describe the goals of the Big Lagoon Bog restoration project, as well as the CNPS Rare Plant Treasure Hunt Program.

Wednesday, March 9—California’s Vast Habitats Seen Through Wildflowers. Local photographer Larry Ulrich began his career while travelling and working with his wife and photographic partner Donna. Experienced botanists with stunning, inspiring, and meaningful work, Larry and Donna have been making a living with a camera since 1972. They will present an overview of the many habitats in California, followed by images of a variety of native plants through the seasons. Wednesday, April 13—Continued Adventures Hiking and Botanizing in the Austrian and Italian Alps. Kjirsten Wayman, a local chemistry professor and aspiring botanist, spent the last year living in Austria and northern Italy. The Alps are home to many plants and wildflowers, both familiar and unfamiliar to the California botanist. This photographic botanical exploration will highlight a selection of interesting flora and spectacular landscapes of the Austrian and Italian Alps with only the enthusiasm a California botanist could share!

Exploring the Calflora Database On February 10, the CNPS North Coast chapter’s program will feature information about CNPS’ rare plant program. If you’re interested in learning more about California’s rare native plants, join us to explore information found on An online database of California plants, Calflora can be a great resource for information about rare, native, and naturalized vascular plants (Figure 1). To begin using Calflora, consider registering. This is a free service that allows you to contribute observations to the database. Not only will this help CNPS better understand plant distribution throughout the state, but information entered about rare plants will greatly help CNPS’ rare plant program by providing information about population sizes and verifying whether or not a species is still found at a particular location. If you’re looking just to find general details about a plant, Calflora’s search capabilities are vast. Enter

the name of the plant you’d like to learn more about (common, scientific, or just part of the name), and hit search. The search results show a distribution map, identification photographs, whether or not the plant is included in the CNPS Inventory of Rare and Endangered plants, and much more. Calflora also enables searches by location, and returns a list of plants that grow in a particular area. After clicking on “What Grows Here?” on the Calflora homepage, you will be directed to the “What Grows Here?” tool. In Figure 2, I drew a polygon around my address and learned I should be able to find 142 plants around my home. Advanced searching options are available through Calflora that allow you to customize your particular inquiry, and does not require a steep learning curve. I encourage you to explore this database, and we’ll see you February 10! by Kate Rowe

Figure 1 (left): homepage: search for plant information or enter an observation. Figure 2 (above): Searching for plants around Carlotta, CA.


Public Lands Takeover? No Thanks! The recent occupation of the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge by militant extremists is part of a movement to give away our U.S. public lands. However, the militants are not alone in the effort to sell off public lands. Oregon’s own U.S. Congressman (Republican Greg Walden) and others have emboldened a movement to seize control of these public lands. Walden recently proposed legislation to give away over a quartermillion acres of National Forest lands right here in southern Oregon and northern California. The Malheur Refuge is critical stomping ground for migratory birds. According to the refuge website, “The Refuge constitutes a small percentage of the Northern Great Basin’s total acreage but is a tremendously important source of wildlife habitat relative to other portions of the Northern Great Basin. The Refuge represents a crucial stop along the Pacific Flyway and offers resting, breeding, and nesting habitat for hundreds of migratory birds and other wildlife.” What would happen if the militants were successful in shutting down the refuge? Under private ownership, with the goal of individual profit, would the crucial migratory birds be protected? What if all our natural treasures— Crater Lake, the Wild Rogue, the Cascade Siskiyou National Monument—were similarly placed in the hands of private interests and corporations? Over 100 years ago Republican President Teddy Roosevelt established both the U.S. Forest Service and National Wildlife Reserves, creating a unique American heritage that protects wildlife and wild places.

Stand with Eastern Oregon, Speak up for Public Lands! Urge your elected officials to speak against threats to America’s legacy of public lands. While a group of militant extremists has taken over and shut down the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge, Congressman Walden has proposed legislation to give away over a quarter-million acres of National Forest lands in southern Oregon and northern California. Send a letter of support for Malheur National Wildlife Refuge and all refuges, parks, forests and protected public lands to your elected officials.

Elk and Wolves

Continued from page 6 ...out of California for four years before returning to Oregon where he established a pack near the border, the Rogue Pack. While OR-7 moved on, California recently received its first permanent pack. On August 9, 2015, a game camera caught the first definitive proof: five pups and two adults, frolicking together. The wolves, named the Shasta Pack after nearby Mount Shasta, now call California home. Another wolf, OR-25, originated from the same pack as OR-7 and has been traveling between Modoc County and southern Oregon this winter.

Is Elk Hunting Jeopardizing Local Roosevelt Elk? That’s the question being raised by EPIC in comments to the Fish and Game Commission. Our local Roosevelt elk population—the car-stopping attraction near Highway 101 in Humboldt and Del Norte counties—is one of the most significant populations in relation to its larger subspecies for two reasons: its history and its future. In regard to its history, this Roosevelt elk population is our last vestige of the past. By 1925, our local population was the only Roosevelt population left in California; the rest were hunted to oblivion. Through a combination of natural expansion of populations in Oregon and forced relocation, Roosevelt elk have spread further in the state. But this expansion also threatens the genetic uniqueness of the subspecies. Ill-conceived past management decisions have resulted in the hybridization of Roosevelt and Rocky Mountain elk. This is not unique to California. Across the West Coast, many if not most populations of Roosevelt elk interbreed with Rocky Mountain elk, putting the subspecies at risk. There are few populations, including those in coastal Del

One of the Shasta Pack wolves, identified as the first new resident pack in California. Photo: California DFW.

Norte and Humboldt counties included, that are genetically “pure.” For this reason, our Roosevelt population is significant to the larger subspecies for the future. Elk management decisions should reflect this uniqueness and prioritize its preservation. The state wants to allow approximately 16% of the total Humboldt and Del Norte populations, or 255 total elk, to be removed in the 2016 hunting seasons. However, the environmental review performed by the Department does not focus on the impacts to our specific population, instead concluding that the hunt will not harm genetics statewide—even though most other Roosevelt elk in the state have hybridized with Rocky Mountain elk. Elk recovery and wolf recovery are also, unsurprisingly, intrinsically linked. That’s how ecosystems work. Elk are wolves’ top choice of prey but as the wolf plan points out, when elk are not available wolves will switch to hunting “deer and other large herbivores”—including livestock. Without sufficient elk, wolves will broaden their range, increasing the potential for conflicts with humans and livestock. The elk hunting plan and the state’s desire to prevent or reduce livestock predation therefore seems to be at odds with each other. For more information on elk hunting and other wildlife issues, including advocacy for wolf recovery in California, please visit

Carol Ann Conners 707-725-3400 654 Main Street, Fortuna CA License #0E79262

381 Bayside Road, Arcata, CA 95521

Send a letter online here: To send a letter by mail, visit www.opencongress. org/people/zipcodelookup to find contact information for representatives for your area. Adapted from a Press Clip and Action Alert distributed by KS Wild. Visit for more information.


Feb/Mar 2016



Dr. Loon

“Clearly, the Settlement Agreements [would have been] everyone’s best option. Congressional failure to approve the proposed Settlement will have a very high price. Water conflicts cannot be solved by the regular FERC process alone, which deals only with the dams. Without the Settlement...110 years of bitter water conflicts...remain unresolved,” said Glen Spain of the Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen’s Associations. Although dam owner PacifiCorp had supported dam removal within the scope of the Klamath Settlement Agreements, the company simultaneously took steps to relicense its dams. In August 2014, PacifiCorp applied for a Clean Water Act certification from the state of California—a prerequisite to dam relicensing. This certification process allows the California State Water Board to set conditions for dam relicensing that are binding on the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. In order to set conditions for a Clean Water Act certification, the Water board must prepare an Environmental Impact Report (EIR). According to the Water Board, the EIR will evaluate alternatives that may include dam removal and PacifiCorp’s proposal for continued dam operation.

But it’s hard to argue nomenclature when you’re surrounded by angry guys in hard hats and red suspenders. It was 1977. The Democrats were briefly back in power. Jimmy Carter had named Cecil Andrus to be Secretary of the Interior. Congressman Phillip Burton proposed to add 74,000 acres to Redwood National Park, and Andrus was considering it. In April, Burton announced that he would hold hearings in Eureka, where his legislation was portrayed by the timber industry—which included most of the county’s business establishment and its government representatives—as an economic apocalypse. While the government was deliberately and slowly acting to protect the public interest, Arcata Redwood was chopping down old growth as fast as it could, telling workers that the hippie environmentalists and the government were killing their jobs, their babies, and American Values. For years a quiet war had simmered between the loggers and the longhairs, mostly confined to barroom scuffles, but now the timber industry and its allies were actively stirring this antagonism into violence. On the day of the hearing every logger, truck driver, and mill worker was given the day off. Eureka businesses closed their doors. In a mile-long parade through downtown, trucks rolled at the head of a throng that marched as one. Afterward, log rigs lined the streets around the municipal auditorium and the crowd out front had the air of Paul Bunyan Days or a public execution. There were said to be axes in the crowd. Against them was this new alliance, the hip and straight communities coming together out of the culture wars of the 60s. The weed economy. I was part of a small contingent of eco-freaks who had come over from Arcata, where environmental activism had sprung up in the years following the first Earth Day. We must have seemed a wild and strange-looking crew. But at the center of our group was a very conservatively dressed woman, diminutive and fierce, pushing forward through the hooting and hollering loggers. Lucille Vinyard had come to speak on behalf of the Sierra Club, in favor of park expansion. There was a large contingent of cops and deputy sheriffs, but they weren’t there to protect Lucille. We were their new enemy. The carbon-extracting economy tells its workers and customers that the conversion of our common heritage to private profit is good business practice. Common ownership, the very idea of the commons, is its constant adversary. In this light, we see that stealing Indian land was just an early stage of America’s war against communism and then environmentalism: “They have got as far as they can go, because they own their land in common,” proclaimed Senator Henry L. Dawes of

Continued from page 13

Adapted from a Press Release and Action Alert distributed by Klamath Riverkeeper. Visit for more information. For more information on the California Waterboard’s process, see: water_issues/programs/water_quality_cert/ klamath_ferc2082.shtml

EcoNews Feb/Mar 2016

Continued from page 7

Massachusetts in 1877. “There is no selfishness,” he said, “which is at the bottom of civilization.” Turning public wealth into private commodity is our state religion, sold to us and repeated in relentless advertisement till it’s an article of human existence. No other way of thinking is possible. We carry these assumptions in places deeper than pockets. The weed economy resists this sales pitch, but in the present breakdown between growers and environmentalists we can see the consequences of forgetting their common beginnings.

The Price of a Life is being printed locally, funded by fifty-dollar pledges which will get you a signed copy and make several more copies available at cost through local bookstores, clinics, and grow shops. Address questions, comments, pledges to


Continued from page 7 Also inherent in the deal is that all countries have common responsibilities for climate change, but the extent of their participation depends on their wealth. Wealthier countries like the United States have an obligation to fund climate assistance for poorer countries. In January, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced that the Obama administration has a set of goals to solidify the United States’ involvement in responding to climate change, including increasing technical assistance to foreign governments in monitoring and controlling emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. According to EPA Administrator Gina McCarthy, the challenge for many developing countries is how to continue to grow economically in a way that does not increase emissions that will contribute to climate change. McCarthy said the EPA will share their experience as leaders of substantial environmental policies with their less resourceful nations in 2016. Despite the historic nature of COP21, citizens of the world are relying on their governments to translate the climate change deal into action. With only public scrutiny and the honor system to feed the fire, one can only hope that officials move this formal recognition of climate change into action with more earnest than the decades it took to reach this deal.



A newt trifecta in Mark West Springs, California. California newt (top), rough-skinned newt (middle), and red-bellied newt. Photo: Ken-ichi Ueda,, CC.

Many who have taken the chance to explore nature’s floor have likely stumbled upon many California salamanders or newts. One of these small dwellers is the California newt, a member of the abundant Salamandridae family, occurring only in California. It shares its genus Taricha with the roughskinned newt, the red-bellied newt, and the Sierra newt. Its range along the coast is believed to stretch from Mendocino to San Diego counties. This stocky, grainy creature can grow from two to three and a half inches in length and is yellowish brown, reddish brown, or dark brown in color. Adult newts inhabit terrestrial zones when not in the breeding season and can be found taking cover under rocks, logs, or burrows. When it is time to mate, generally between December and February, adult newts migrate to ponds, reservoirs, pools, and streams to find a partner. They can often be found in the ponds of our local Trinity Alps Wilderness. Eggs are then laid underwater from November to July in quiet pools, in bunches of seven to 47. A female can lay up to six of those egg batches in one day. The California newt goes through a metamorphosis after hatching, from larvae to adult newt. In its several month long larval stage, the juvenile newt swims with a tail fin and gills throughout its pond, eating small aquatic invertebrates and organic matter. It dwells beneath submerged logs, rocks, and stream banks. Over the course of two weeks after this period, the fin and gills shrink until

Taricha torosa

the newt crawls out of the water, with a new diet of worms, snails, slugs, sowbugs, insects, and amphibian eggs or larvae. The newt does not return to the water until it is time for it to breed, often returning to lay its eggs in the same pond where it was born. During this evolution into adulthood, the California newt acquires a dangerous trait: deadly toxicity. With skin that secretes a potent poison, it could kill a human if ingested. This fatal poison is known as tetrodoxin, a neurotoxin also found in pufferfishes and harlequin frogs. All species within the Taricha genus are toxic, but the rough-skinned newt generally has the strongest of the group’s poisons. One of the few creatures able to eat these deadly newts is the garter snake, their most common predator. It is believed that due to their extremely high tetrodoxin resistance, garter snakes and California newts have coevolved as predator and prey. Unfortunately, this lethal critter is suffering strains on its population in segments of California. Non-native predatory fish, crayfish, and bullfrogs have been introduced to newt habitat that eat newt eggs and larvae. Land development has resulted in habitat loss. Other watershed-degrading practices, such as sedimentation from wildfire or agriculture, lead to a reduction in important breeding ponds. The California newt is currently listed as a California Species of Special Concern under the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, and is a species under the National Park Service’s aquatic amphibian monitoring program.

from our back door...

ic integrity orgatonyour basket The North Coast Co-op is the only Certified Organic Retailer on the North Coast! Our knowledgeable employees handle all certified organic products in accordance with federal regulations from the delivery truck to your basket.

811 I St. in Arcata • (707) 822-5947 25 4th St. in Eureka • (707) 443-6027


Feb/Mar 2016


the Kids’ Page: Loony Loons! Did you know that loons look like ducks with a pointy

bill, but their closest living ancestors are penguins? Loons are a type of diving water bird. They dive under the water and gulp down fish, frogs, crayfish and leeches, in one bite. Their pointy sharp bill is specialized for feeding. They have red eyes that are thought to help them see under water better. Their long slender body, and webbed feet make it easier for them to swim. Loons can be found in most parts of North America. They spend the breeding season in large lakes surrounded by woods. They make their nests on the shore out of tall grasses. The mom and dad take turns sitting on the nest while the other parent finds food. Raccoons, weasels, skunks, and other predators feed on the eggs. After a month, the eggs hatch. There are usually two eggs laid per breeding season. Above: The common loon is well known for its ability to dive in the water to catch its food. Photo: Art Weber/USFWS. Left: This loon and its chick live all the way across the country in Damariscotta Lake, Maine. Photo: Keith Carver,, CC.

Word Search

The day a baby loon hatches is the first day it goes for a swim. If the water is too cold, or when the hatchling gets tired, it will rest on the mom’s back while she swims. It takes the little loon about 11 weeks before it can fly. Loons are not very good at walking on land; they hobble like their cousin the penguin. In water, they flap their wings and ‘run’ on the water for up to ¼ mile before taking off in flight. Because of this, they need bigger lakes and ponds so they have enough of a runway to take off flying. After their babies are able to fly and leave the nest, they migrate to the Atlantic or Pacific coast for the winter. Once in flight, the average loon can reach 80 mph! There are five types of loons found in North America, with the Common Loon being the most well known. Most notable about loons is the noise they make. They have a distinct call that’s been described as eerie, creepy, or ghostly. These calls can be best heard during breeding season. By Sarah Marnick

EcoNews Feb/Mar 2016





















Help us continue to advocate, educate, and bring you

Northcoast Environmental Center

1385 8th St., Suite 215, P.O. Box 4259 Arcata, CA 95521


YES! I will help the Northcoast

Environmental Center protect our watersheds, wildlands and communities! Name Address City




E-mail My gift is (check one box if applicable): in memory of

in honor of

a gift membership

Name of person _______________________________ (If gift Address ____________________________ membership)

City ________________________________

A subscription to EcoNews is included with your membership. Please choose one option: I would like to save resources and read EcoNews online. Do not mail me a print copy. Please mail a print copy of EcoNews to the address above.

I would like to join/renew my annual NEC membership. Enclosed is my payment of: (student or

$25 - Trillium low income) $100 - Coho Salmon $250 - Spotted Owl Other ________

$50 - Pacific Fisher $500 - Orca $1000 - Redwood

I would like to become a sustaining member! I pledge $___________ per month. Please bill my credit card monthly. Please send me a pack of envelopes.

Save resources, donate online:, or scan the code at right. If you prefer, mail this form with a check or fill in your credit card information below. Check enclosed (Payable to NEC) Charge my Visa/Mastercard (Circle the card type) Credit Card Number ____________________________ Exp. Date _______________

Mail to: NEC, PO Box 4259 Arcata, CA 95518 Thank you! In recognition of your generosity, we will list your name in publications as a donor.

Please check here if you would rather remain anonymous. The Northcoast Environmental Center is a 501(c)(3), not-for-profit organization. All donations are tax-deductible to the fullest extent of the law. EIN 23-7122386.

Adopt-A-Beach had its humble or “Humboldt” beginnings over 40 years ago, later becoming a statewide program coordinated by the California Coastal Commission. The annual international Coastal Cleanup Day also sprang from the success of AdoptA-Beach. The concept is similar to Adopt-A-Highway but instead focuses on a stretch of beach. Adopt a beach in Humboldt County and you too can help us to keep waste out of our oceans for the protection of ocean life—and so we can enjoy our beautiful beaches all the more!

Four Steps to Adopt Your Own Beach!! 1. Create a team (or be your own team!) 2. Choose a beach. 3. Email or stop by the NEC to fill out adoption forms. 4. Get out there and clean!

Beach of the Month With Valentine’s Day right around the corner there are many romantic spots along the beautiful Humboldt coastline that could also use a little love. How does Moonstone Beach sound? Perfect! I mean, who doesn’t love long walks on the beach with their Valentine? Picture this, you’re strolling down the beach gazing at the stunning rock formations and tide pools. Maybe you just finished a fantastic day of paddleboarding, surfing, climbing rocks or walking along the surf. You find the perfect spot to snuggle up and watch the cascade of colors as the sun sets over the ocean. You both lean in for a kiss and BAM! You just got smacked in the face with a stray piece of floating trash, ruining the aforementioned kiss. Just one piece might not seem like a day crushing incident, but even our favorite spots need a little loving from time to time. As you walk along the sand, really look and pick up those seemingly insignificant pieces of trash. No matter how small it might seem, trash does not belong on our beaches.

Moonstone Beach and many others are available for adoption!

For more information or to adopt a beach, contact or call the NEC at 707-822-6918.

EcoNews Vol. 46, No. 1 - Feb/Mar 2016  

EcoNews is the official bi-monthly publication of the Northcoast Environmental Center, a non-profit advocacy and educational organization. T...

EcoNews Vol. 46, No. 1 - Feb/Mar 2016  

EcoNews is the official bi-monthly publication of the Northcoast Environmental Center, a non-profit advocacy and educational organization. T...