Page 8


North Coast news daily:

Indo hissy fit a taste of year to come

Volume 31 #31

January 11, 2017

Stop learning and save the species Educating yourself could be the downfall of civilisation – seriously. That’s the message from a US academic from the University of Connecticut who believes that over-educated ‘elites’ pose a threat to the stability of western societies. Professor Peter Turchin ( heads research using a mathematical model called cliodynamic, which measures historical events as statistical data. While it is no crystal ball, he argues, ‘History needs to become an analytical, predictive science.’ His theory centres around social indicators, which he says are related, despite not appearing to be. They include ‘stagnating or declining real wages, a growing gap between rich and poor, overproduction of young graduates with advanced degrees and exploding public debt…’    In a 2008 essay, Turchin explained how patterns cut across historical periods and regions. One pattern is the oscillation between population decline and instability, such as peasant uprisings and civil wars.  He writes, ‘Applying the above approach to eight secular cycles in medieval and early modern England, France, the Roman Empire and Russia, we find that the number of instability events per decade is always several times higher when the population was declining than when it was increasing. ‘The probability of this happening by chance is vanishingly small. The same pattern holds for the eight dynasties that unified China, from the Western Han to the Qing, and for Egypt from the Hellenistic to the Ottoman periods.’  Important factors in twentieth-century revolutions were the rapid demographic change and elite over-production (or over-education), he says. ‘When Tony Blair was Britain’s prime minister, he set out to increase the proportion of youth getting higher education to 50 per cent. He was presumably unaware that the overabundance of young people with advanced education preceded the political crises of the age of revolutions in western Europe, in late Tokugawa Japan and in modern Iran and the Soviet Union.’ But Turchin is optimistic – he says records show that societies can avert disaster.  ‘We need to find ways to ameliorate the negative effects of globalisation on people’s wellbeing. Economic inequality, accompanied by burgeoning public debt, can be addressed by making tax rates more progressive. Ours is the first society that can perceive how those forces operate, even if dimly.’ Seven years ago, he predicted on that ‘the next decade is likely to be a period of growing [political] instability in the US and western Europe.’ And three years ago he said the peak of political turmoil will occur in the 2020s. While Australia is thankfully a more egalitarian society, we may be on a similar trajectory, thanks to a merchant banker PM in a shrinking top hat. At least Australia’s falling education standards align with Turchin’s theory that we need a dumbeddown population to avoid catastrophe. Hans Lovejoy, editor News tips are welcome:

The Byron Shire Echo Established 1986 General Manager Simon Haslam Editor Hans Lovejoy Photographer Jeff Dawson Advertising Manager Angela Cornell Production Manager Ziggi Browning

Nicholas Shand 1948–1996 Founding Editor

‘The job of a newspaper is to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable.’ – Finley Peter Dunne 1867–1936 © 2017 Echo Publications Pty Ltd – ABN 86 004 000 239 Mullumbimby: Village Way, Stuart St. Ph 02 6684 1777 Fax 02 6684 1719 Printer: Fairfax Media Brisbane Reg. by Aust. Post Pub. No. NBF9237

8 January 11, 2017 The Byron Shire Echo


he first week of 2017 was dominated by the distraction of Australia’s spat with Indonesia – or more properly Indonesia’s spat with Australia. The problem, it was belatedly revealed, was that the rotating troops training at the Campbell barracks in Perth were unhappy about some of the written material handed out for them and also about a couple of crude cracks from the local boys. Not too serious, one might have thought; no more than locker room banter, as Donald Trump would no doubt call it. But obviously the crack fighters of Kopassus have not read The Australian. Apparently they are unaware that giving insult and offence to ethnic and religious groups is part of the Australian way of life – the bulwark of free speech. Any attempt to impose political correctness (or tact, or civility, as it used to be called) is an attack on democracy itself. It’s just as well the sensitive souls of Kopassus had not been told about section 18c of the Anti-Discrimination Act – they may well have complained to the Human Rights Commission and where would we be then? Instead, they reported their dismay up the chain of command to the defence supremo, the abrasive Gatot Nurmantyo, who promptly suspended all co-operation between the two countries. After a major kerfuffle, it appears that the suspension would, in fact, be suspended, but only after some major grovelling from our hapless defence minister Marise Payne. The upshot is likely to be that relations will continue – with a fervent desire to be good neighbours from the political leaders of both sides, but fraught with tension and misunderstanding from just about everyone

else. The theory remains that Indonesians are all right to visit, but we still don’t regard them as full allies or equals: they would almost certainly fail Peter Dutton’s planned for a revised citizenship test, let alone satisfy his demands that European religious folk songs should be compulsory for primary schools children. But we digress. This particular foreign affair may be over, at least for now. But it is an indication of how easily things can spiral out of control if due diligence is not applied outside our borders as well as within them. I noted last week

Palestinians never have, and never will, accept what they saw as a political fix, and fought back in their own ways. Israel’s pre-emptive strike in 1967 annexed a chunk of Gaza from Egypt and a chunk of Jordan from the West Bank, and although Gaza was restored to a kind of autonomy under the newly constituted Palestinian Authority and an area of the West Bank received the same treatment, Israel sought to secure its borders through sanctions, restrictions and finally settlements. These were always illegal under international law, but in spite of a few hiccups, the de-

Apparently Kopassus is unaware that giving insult and offence to ethnic and religious groups is part of the Australian way of life. by Mungo MacCallum that Malcolm Turnbull’s government seemed completely flat-footed when faced with the very real possibility of confrontation, either economic or military or both, between the United States and China. But now our glorious leader may also be forced to a rethink over the perennial carpet of eggshells that is Israel. Australia’s longstanding position over the nation it helped to found has been that Israel has the right to exist within secure borders, but that there must eventually be a formula by which the Palestinian people can do the same – the so-called two-state solution. However, devising such a process has proved intractable for nearly 70 years. In hindsight, the impasse was always obvious: installing a Jewish population in a small area surrounded by hostile Arab neighbours was always a recipe for trouble. Many of the displaced

mands of a growing population for living space (or lebensraum, as a former expansionist regime once justified it) became the norm. And after years of frustration as negotiations stalled, Barack Obama and John Kerry finally became frustrated. Sure, Israel may be the region’s only functioning democracy – although some Palestinians living within its greater borders would argue that it is a very incomplete one. But if Israel is meant to be the good guy, why must it be so intransigent? And why do so many Israeli politicians – including, at times, prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu – flatly reject the two-state solution? Hence when a raft of western allies, including Britain, voted for a resolution condemning the settlement program, Washington broke the habit of a lifetime and abstained from vetoing it. There was outrage from the Right, of course, and Netanyahu, for

whom any criticism of his regime is anti-semitism, pure and simple, announced it was a declaration of war from one of the sponsors, New Zealand. But Australia, in the form of Julie Bishop, said that for us, nothing has changed: we always support Israel, but we also support a two-state solution. The position was barely tenable, but it was at least credible – until Tony Abbott demanded that all aid to the Palestinians be cancelled and our embassy in Tel Aviv should follow the lead of Donald Trump, who threatened to move America’s embassy to Israel. Even Abbott’s most devoted allies, the Nationals, drew the line there: Barnaby Joyce and Fiona Nash told the former leader he was not helpful. And he isn’t – so what else is new. However, he has escalated an issue which Turnbull and Bishop would much rather remains in abeyance. But even without Abbott’s unhelpful intervention, they may be forced to reconsider. Trump has made it clear that his approach will be far more partisan and aggressive: it is all but certain that he will abandon the two-state solution. And as we know, when America acts, Australia follows. To do so, of course, will further antagonise the Arab nations and embolden local jihadists at a time when Turnbull desperately wants to bring as many Australian muslims as possible into his revamped version of Team Australia. But to defy Trump’s base will outrage his recalcitrant right, for whom Israel is their own Holy Land. This is hardly the start Turnbull wants for his new year, which is meant to be about economic delivery. It will be both a domestic labyrinth demanding all his agility and yet another exciting foreign affair he could do without.

“I never want to have to cross the street to avoid you.” David Runciman Since 1992 David’s company has manufactured blinds, security doors, screens, awnings and patio covers for homes and businesses throughout Byron Shire. He never wants to avoid a customer in the street, so he insists on first-class quality and backs up what he says. Call Dave for a quote... he’ll see you’re right!

Throughout Byron Shire




14 Bonanza Drive Billinudgel 6680 4353

No Gap First Visit

For all new patients with private health insurance that includes dental cover *

$25 0 Val ue

Includes Comprehensive Examination Diagnostic X-rays Customised 3D treatment plan

No Health Fund No Problem Receive this offer for only $50 *waiting periods, annual limits & fund rules apply. Service is restricted to item codes 011, 012, 022 & 037.

Call 0266 851 264 Shop 6/18 Mullumbimbi St, Brunswick Heads

w w w. b r u n s w i c k d e n t a l. n e t Byron Shire Echo archives:

Byron Shire Echo – Issue 31.31 – 11/01/2017  

Free, independent weekly newspaper from the Byron Shire in northern NSW, Australia.

Byron Shire Echo – Issue 31.31 – 11/01/2017  

Free, independent weekly newspaper from the Byron Shire in northern NSW, Australia.