The WINTER Collection 2023

Page 1


The Masterpiece Collection n.

A finely curated collection of our most exceptional properties.

Innovating the luxury real estate industry with a global network of exceptional agents. GLOBAL REACH OUR NETWORK LOCAL EXPERTISE Countries & Territories Offices Worldwide Sales Associates 81 1,100 25,000 Our brand. Your benefit. Sotheby’s International Realty

Exceptional properties demand exceptional service. A platform reserved for our most remarkable properties.

Masterpiece Collection homes are represented and marketed like no other properties across Long Island and the New York City Area.

All the experience and expertise of Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty is brought to every transaction from initial engagement and marketing to sale and closing.

Masterpiece is a designation worthy of the heritage and prestige of the Sotheby’s name.

Meet our Masterpiece Collection Luxury Market Specialists.

Aliana Russo Corporate Katherine Cirelli Corporate Miriam Ainbinder Stony Brook / Port Jefferson Kimberly Bancroft Locust Valley Barbara Candee Locust Valley Donielle Cardinale Mattituck Bonnie Devendorf Locust Valley Jason Friedman Great Neck Lois Kirschenbaum Wheatley Plaza Patrick Mackay Locust Valley Gayle Marriner-Smith Cutchogue Patricia Moroney Manhasset Saskia Valentine Port Washington Scott Wallace Rockville Centre / Garden City Bonnie Williamson Huntington Laura Zambratto Cold Spring Harbor

A comprehensive Residential Luxury Real Estate Market Report of our current Masterpiece Towns.

All sales included in this report are above $1.5M.

Residential Sales 2021 - 2022. 1.5M and above. (1/1/2021 - 12/31/2022) *stats based on MLSLI system information.


The village of Brookville, located on the North Shore of Long Island in Nassau County, was originally farms and woodlands known as Suco’s Wigwam. In 2009, Businessweek named Brookville the wealthiest town in America.

Number of Sales

Avg. Days on Market Average Price Median Price Highest Price

Centre Island

The 605 acre peninsula has over four miles of coast line bordered by Cold Spring Harbor and Oyster Bay Harbor. Centre Island is located along Long Island’s north shore in an area often referred to as the Gold Coast.

Number of Sales Avg. Days on Market Average Price Median Price Highest Price

Kings Point

A village within Great Neck, this affluent suburb offers its residents access to some of the most top-rated schools throughout Long Island. Among the homes offered here are a number of beautiful Estates.

Number of Sales Avg. Days on Market Average Price Median Price Highest Price

Locust Valley

People are drawn to this unique area for its natural beauty retained through vast land preserves, botanical gardens and arboretums. Lattingtown, Mill Neck and Matinecock. Locust Valley is the perfect place to settle.

2021 22 165 $2,859,409 $2,450,000 $5,200,000

2022 28 100 $2,774,000 $2,213,500 $8,300,000

Number of Sales

Avg. Days on Market Average Price Median Price Highest Price

2021 4 315 $5,500,000 $5,350,000 $8,100,000

2022 6 139 $4,475,000 $3,500,000 $9,000,000

2021 1 7 $7,000,000 $7,000,000 $7,000,000

2022 1 136 $1,600,000 $1,600,000 $1,600,000

2021 13 69 $3,118,462 $2,295,000 $8,800,000

2022 19 130 $2,758,682 $2,300,000 $7,950,000


Muttontown has a country feel with large expanses of trees and shrubbery only to be occasionally interrupted by homes. Also known as “Horse Country” with its 600 acre preserve is a perfect retreat for the horse lover.

Number of Sales Avg. Days on Market Average Price Median Price Highest Price

2021 31 115 $2,454,828 $2,299,000 $7,999,888

2022 43 139 $2,233,779 $2,045,000 $4,550,000

Old Westbury

Old Westbury and The Brookvilles are known for their beautiful rolling hills, their open spaces with 2-5 acre minimum acreage and their tree lined lanes. Many private golf and country clubs make their home here.

Number of Sales Avg. Days on Market Average Price Median Price Highest Price

2021 39 178 $3,144,692 $2,300,000 $18,000,000

2022 36 108 $3,296,944 $2,645,000 $12,450,000


The town of Setauket is located on the North Shore in Suffolk County enriched with beautiful homes of all sizes. Setauket has played a key part in American history and provides public access to West Meadow Beach, Wetlands Preserve, and The Frank Melville Memorial Park.

Number of Sales Avg. Days on Market Average Price Median Price Highest Price

2021 5 50 $1,814,000 $1,775,000 $2,350,000

2022 9 238 $2,231,444 $1,875,000 $3,775,000

The neighborhood offers a spectacular view of the Hudson River on its western border and notable restaurants throughout, including the Odeon, made famous by the novel Bright Lights, Big City, along with a number of luxury hotels and other accommodations.


Number of Sales Avg. Days on Market Average Price Median Price Highest Price

2021 485 196 $4,835,217 $3,562,417 $49,500,000

2022 375 159 $4,733,708 $3,725,000 $26,000,000

Upper Brookville

Upper Brookville is

Arboretum and Coe Hall Mansion and home to many more historical mansions with pastoral acreage sporting horse paddocks, barns, ponds, golf courses and the nearby Tilles Center for the Performing Arts.

Number of Sales Avg. Days on Market Average Price Median Price Highest Price

2021 28 127 $2,376,571 $2,037,500 $5,750,000

2022 21 109 $2,208,190 $2,050,000 $4,050,000


Some of the most magnificent oceanfront and Bayfront homes can be found in Westhampton, as well as exceptional waterfront estates. Just a bike ride or strolls away from all of the amenities in the village; including restaurants, shops, and places of worship.

Number of Sales Avg. Days on Market Average Price Median Price Highest Price

2021 25 119 $2,562,600 $2,285,000 $5,000,000

2022 21 170 $2,400,500 $1,863,000 $6,700,000

the home of Planting Fields

Street in Auvers-sur-Oise by Vincent van Gogh

Welcome to the latest edition of The Collection.

We are proud to present the Winter edition of our digital magazine: The Collection. In the following pages you will find some of the most special, impressive, and unique properties that we have the honor of representing. Whether you are in the market to purchase a new home, or like many of us, just appreciate stunning properties, this is for you. Enjoy! Katherine Cirelli and Aliana Russo

The Masterpiece Collection
Realty Cover Property “The Bagatelle” PAGES 36 - 37
Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International

Let’s explore the most impressive properties in: Brookville Centre Island Kings Point Locust Valley Muttontown New York City Old Westbury Setauket

Upper Brookville Westhampton


Brookville, NY – “Shangri-La”

MLS# 3403644. $38,000,000.

A Timeless World-Class Masterpiece defined by grace & style, “Shangri-La” is an unparalleled Gold Coast Estate designed for luxurious living, gracious entertaining & the enjoyment of Art. This stately residence was designed by the renowned architectural firm Shope Reno Wharton. Located on 21.86 captivating acres, the estate is a symphony of Artistry & Design. Complemented by breathtaking and vibrant landscaping, there are two idyllic Ponds & a Conservatory Greenhouse. Two swimming Pools each have their own Cabana. There is an additional Cabana with a full Catering Kitchen. This serene & refined estate impeccable captures sophistication & elegance. Architectural excellence & tasteful appointments make this the ultimate in luxury and lifestyle. World-class design, masterful detailed workmanship and the finest materials culminate in a spectacular estate imbued with the tranquility and grace that is “Shangri-La”.

Sandy Binder


Centre Island, NY – “Morning Tide”

MLS#3343809. $10,750,000

Morning Tide, designed by renowned architects Austin Patterson Disston, is situated on Centre Island, a wonderful enclave of elegant estates in commuting distance to New York City. Custom built in 2005, the fabulous shingle-style Colonial home overlooks Oyster Bay Harbor and Cold Spring Harbor with 220 feet of waterfront. Every possible amenity has been included in its sixteen rooms including 6 bedrooms, 5.5 baths which grace 3.46 luxurious acres. There is a versatile private guest suite located on the first floor. The spa, pool, pool house with bath and outdoor shower, plus tennis court and pavilion create the perfect sanctuary. A home built and maintained with love, style, and class.

Katie Cuddeback, c.516.238.9919

Kings Point, NY – “Chateau North”

MLS# 3414883. $12,000,000.

Normandy-inspired “Chateau North” is a waterfront French Tudor in the prestigious village of Kings Point. Just shy of 8 acres of land, this home boasts an ‘all-season’ organic English Garden with a sitting rotunda, decorative box hedging, irrigation system, exotic florals, and multiple species of fruits/vegetables. A gazebo stands at the edge of the peninsula with endless water views. Other features include a greenhouse, dock access, and swimming pool bordering the water.

Jason Friedman, c.516.236.6226

Sarah (Rudi) Friedman, c.516.643.0630

Locust Valley, NY – “Hideaway”

MLS# 3315549. $8,250,000.

This exceptional 8 bedroom brick Colonial residence is set on 8.11 prime acres. “Hideaway” reflects a classic & gracious style with luxurious amenities & floor plan for today’s living. Principal rooms are generously sized with 11 ft. ceilings, offering views of bluestone patios & impeccably manicured hedges & gardens. Outdoor space showcases multiple patios, 2 built-in grills/1 kitchenette, par 3 golf hole with 4 tee boxes, tennis court, heated saltwater pool with electric cover, fabulous pool house with eat-in kitchen, 2 beds with en suite baths & full lower level storage. App-based Savant Pro smart technology system & generator.

Christina Porter, c.516.835.5512

Christina Teagle, c.516.635.8679

Locust Valley, NY – “Wyomissing”

MLS# 3418872. $12,500,000. Cottie Maxwell, c.516.857.3011

This glorious Gold Coast Estate is a quintessential interpretation of French Normandy Architecture designed by the renowned firm, Delano & Aldrich, for retired financier, J. Denniston Lyon in 1926. Renovated to perfection with modern-day living amenities in mind, this 10-bedroom, 10.55 bath home with intimate rooms has been transformed into a masterpiece. The impressive residence sits on 6.33-acres of resplendent lawns, gardens, and hardscape. Once inside, the inviting front-to-back foyer is wrapped in gleaming pine paneling with a rich patina. The foyer opens to principal rooms that have a pleasing scale with original details that evoke a gracious and warm elegance. Many one-of-a-kind touches grace this home including an Octagonal room, 12 fireplaces, 3,000-bottled wine cellar, updates throughout with original antique details such as antique Parquet wood flooring and so much more. To us, the beauty is that you have a pool, tennis court, putting green, outdoor chef’s kitchen, and a beautiful outdoor space perfect compliment for al fresco entertaining. Privacy is emphasized and close to the quaint town of Locust Valley.

Marta Bruderman, c.516.528.8560


Mill Neck, NY – “Horseshoe”

MLS# 3443273. $5,499,000.

Elegant and sophisticated Modern Farmhouse residence. Offering a luxurious lifestyle, this magnificent 6.3-acre estate is perched high on a hill presiding over brilliant sunsets with unobstructed long water views of Mill Neck Creek. Offering six-bedrooms, the elegant and sophisticated Modern Farmhouse residence is complemented by a beautiful two-bedroom cottage, a heated saltwater swimming pool, an outdoor basketball court and acres of lush lawns and gardens. Fabulous entertainment, family, recreation, exercise and media rooms. Expansive terraces and patios with water views throughout. Radiant heat, generator, reverse osmosis water purification. Threebay attached and one-bay detached garages.

Alexis McAndrew, c.917.750.8939

Muttontown, NY – “Stone Hill Mansion” MLS# 3408399. $3,699,000. This stunning 6-bedroom estate is located at the end of a tranquil cul-de-sac in the gated Stone Hill at Muttontown community. The luxurious residence is distinguished by exceptional design and refined finishes that include Venetian plaster walls, marble and onyx floors with comfortable radiant heat, carved marble mantles, double-height and coffered ceilings. The chef’s kitchen has top-of-the-line appliances that include a 48” Wolf range. The primary suite features a vaulted ceiling, a fireplace, polished mahogany flooring, two dressing rooms, a balcony and a spa-inspired en suite bath. Bonus room. Euro style lower level designed for entertaining. Theatre fitted with sumptuous recliner seating. Fitness room with sauna. Elevator to all three levels. Crestron smart technology and sophisticated audiovisual system. Attached 3-car garage. The community offers tennis, a clubhouse, an indoor heated pool and fitness center, staffed security and landscaped beauty (fee/dues).

Huailing (Helen) Deng, c.917.859.7718 Vishal Vij, c.917.705.0774

Muttontown, NY – “Cedar Hill”

MLS# 3381199. $9,899,000.

Poised on 8.17 richly landscaped acres, Cedar Hill’s 9-bedroom, 12-bath Georgian-style residence is a symphony of symmetry and balanced proportion. Completed in 1916, it has been restored and expanded to perfection. Indoor SwimEx fitness spa pool, generator, garages for 5-vehicles, new slate roof, Har-Tru tennis court, swimming pool, putting and chipping green, play area and formal sunken garden.

Debra Russell , c. 516.662.5401

Cottie Maxwell, c.516.857.3011

Muttontown, NY – “Felix Domi”

MLS# 3437884. $6,300,000.

Spectacular 10.47-acre estate with magnificent 7+ bedroom residence boasts swimming, tennis and equestrian amenities that provide for an extraordinary and luxurious lifestyle. Located just 30-miles east of Manhattan on the North Shore of Long Island, this spectacular 10.47-acre Gold Coast estate is a quintessential interpretation of French Normandy architecture attributed to the masterful design of John Russell Pope. Completed in 1937, the magnificent seven+ bedroom residence is complemented by a glistening swimming pool, a hardsurface tennis court, an artist’s studio and potting shed. For the equestrian, there is an eight-stall barn with a tack room and hayloft. A turnout paddock, sand ring and jump course provide for a variety of riding pursuits.

Christina Porter, c.516.835.5512

Christina Teagle, c.516.635.8679

Old Westbury, NY – “Maison d’art”

MLS# 3294395 . $15,000,000.

This elegant and inspirational 14,000 sq.ft. stone, cedar, and glass Classic Contemporary was masterfully designed and demonstrates the architectural brilliance of renowned architect Norman Jaffe. Recently renovated to perfection, this extraordinary estate is a work of art set on 6-acres of scenically breathtaking property. The sophisticated architecture places an emphasis on the enjoyment and connection to nature and indoor-outdoor living. An impressive reception foyer opens onto a sunlit all-glass enclosed atrium with a magnificent vaulted glass roof. The exquisite interior boasts beautifully proportioned rooms and light-filled galleries, the perfect showcase for an Art Collection. Multi-level terraces surround the splendid pool setting. Inspired by the architecture of the main residence, there is a new two-story, three bedroom Cottage.

Sandy Binder, c.516.819.0000

Cover Property

Old Westbury, NY – “The Bagatelle”

MLS# 3446945 . $6,850,000.

Located on the North Shore of Long Island just 25 miles from Manhattan “The Bagatelle” is a magnificent 4.35-acre estate designed by Thomas Hastings, of Carrere and Hastings, as his country manor home. Sited around an attractive paved courtyard, the compound includes a gracious newly updated 9-bedroom residence, a 4-bedroom caretaker cottage, a 3-bedroom carriage house and a 2-bedroom gardener’s cottage. Expansive bluestone terraces and a columned gazebo overlook the new glistening cool blue heated swimming pool. Masterful original wrought iron and exquisite plaster moldings complement chic and stylish updates. Impressively-scaled and light-filled principal rooms. Elevator. 3-bay garage. Offering luxury perfect for today’s living and entertaining. This preeminent estate offers luxury perfect for today’s living and entertaining.

Karen Sharf, c.516.972.7647

Golie Oheb, c.516.790.9925

Setauket, NY – “Heron’s Cove”

MLS# 3431141. $4,850,000.

This spectacular waterfront property has stunning panoramic views of Setauket and Port Jefferson Harbors and Long Island Sound. Set back from the road near the end of a cul-de-sac the property offers an expansive backyard setting with private staircase to the beach. Take in the fresh salt air and pleasant breezes under the pergola covered patio with outdoor fireplace, the perfect setting for gatherings under the sun, moon and stars. Constructed in 2012 using only the finest materials, the interior design flourishes with layers of mouldings, high ceilings, Loewen windows and French doors (hurricane glass), and custom stateof-the-art kitchen and baths creating both a functional and elegant home.

Miriam Ainbinder, c.631.988.9200

New York, NY – “Tribeca Luxe”

MLS# PRCH-3934988. Price upon request.

Built in 2001, 124 Hudson is truly a rare find and a unique building like no other. This intimate and quiet, 9-story building is a great escape from the hustle and bustle of New York City with an exquisitely designed lobby, 24-hour doorman, concierge, live-in manager, and private courtyard with lush gardens. The bright and spacious foyer welcomes you with wide plank, blonde oak floors, which flow into the open concept space. Find solace in the comfort of your very own library and get lost in a literary adventure or relax on the private terrace to catch some rays and enjoy the fresh air. Ideal for entertaining a large gathering or an intimate dinner, your guests will love the open floor plan, which allows you to easily move from the chef’s dream kitchen to the expansive dining room to the warmth of the living room with a wood-burning fireplace. Moments from Hudson River Park, shopping, restaurants including Nobu, The Greenwich Hotel, subways, and so much more, all at your fingertips.

James Morgan , c.631.566.5462

Westhampton, NY – “Country House”

MLS# 3374440. $2,495,000.

This 5,000+ sq. ft. haven is the builder’s own residence. It includes 16 rooms of incredible architectural detail, sited on 1+ acres. The home features double crown molding, 10’ ceilings, solid mahogany doors, and Brazilian cherry flooring. A chef’s kitchen and formal living and dining spaces comprise the main living area. The kitchen offers granite surfaces, pizza oven, double sinks, and dishwashers. A Dacor gas stove, double ovens, cozy breakfast nook, and fireplace provide incredible warmth. The main floor continues with an additional primary en suite and separate entrance. Four upper level bedrooms, sitting area, and unfinished bonus room offer exquisite comforts and incredible natural light. Over-sized Anderson windows bring outside living in throughout this home. Grounds include in-ground heated pool with stunning stone surround, outdoor fireplace and a three car garage. A true year-round or summer haven!

Deborah Pirro, c.516.637.5786

Our Masterpice Listing Agents

We’ve always been a company that prides itself on providing exceptional service to our clients, but especially our Agents. Your success is our priority.

In addition to our visionary Leadership team, we’ve built up a seasoned Sales Management team, award-winning Marketing team, and savvy Business Development team dedicated to helping you achieve your business goals—and exceeding them.

Christina Teagle 516.635.8679 Christina Porter 516.835.5512 Deborah Pirro 516.637.5786 Debra Russell 516.662.5401 Cottie Maxwell 516.857.3011 Helen Deng 917.859.7718 Vishal Vij 917.705.0774 Jason Friedman 516.236.6226 Sarah Friedman 516.643.0630 Karen Sharf 516.972.7647 Golie Oheb 516.790.9925 Marta Bruderman 516.528.8560 Katie Cuddeback 516.238.9919 Miriam Ainbinder 631.988.9200 Sandy Binder 516.819.0000 Alexis McAndrew 917.750.8939 James Morgan 631.566.5462
Masterpiece Collection Properties Sold in 2022 Serenity Sandcastle Harrow Hill Laurelwood Linden Hill Elmwood Soiree The Esplanade Preference Foxridge Sheer Bliss Eagle’s Landing Evergreen Estate Summer House Cottonwood

Embracing our Brand’s Powerful Influence The Sotheby’s Auction House

Sotheby’s is an innovative global art business serving the most discerning clients. Sotheby’s brings a world of art to the new world. The collaboration between Sotheby’s International Realty and Sotheby’s leverages our brand’s rich history, heritage and market perceptions.

This is a powerful distinguisher in the global markets we serve.


Nothing Compares.

Now, more than ever, buyers and sellers are looking for a partner to help them navigate the transaction process.

Despite market demand and increased client expectations, our local real estate advisors consistently deliver a high-quality experience.

Choose the Daniel Gale Difference.

Astoria Bay Shore Bayside Carle Place Cobble Hill Cold Spring Harbor Cutchogue Garden City Glen Head Great Neck Greenport Huntington Locust Valley Long Beach Manhasset Mattituck Mattituck Love Lane Northport Port Washington Rockville Centre Sea Cliff Shelter Island Smithtown Stony Brook Syosset Westhampton Beach Wheatley Plaza Williamsburg Stop by one of our 28 offices. From Brooklyn to the Hamptons and nearly everywhere in between.
© MMXVII Sotheby’s International Realty Affiliates LLC. All Rights Reserved. Sotheby’s International Realty Affiliates LLC fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each Office is Independently Owned and Operated. Sotheby’s International Realty and the Sotheby’s International Realty logo are registered (or unregistered) service marks licensed to Sotheby’s International Realty Affiliates LLC.