Page 1

E-book collections management in UK universities: focus group report Information Automation Limited

Chris Armstrong and Ray Lonsdale

Headlines Report, November 2009


Funded by JISC, JISC Collections provides its members with a catalogue of free and subscription-based online resources such as e-journals, e-books, full text databases, digital images, online film and geospatial data. Core to the service provided by JISC Collections is the quality evaluation of online resources, the expert negotiation process and the efficient national licensing undertaken for each online resource. JISC Collections always strives to widen accessibility to online resources, save its members time and money and to evolve licensing in line with members needs and the digital environment. www.jisc-collections.ac.uk


! !

!

"#$%%&!'%(()'*+%,!-.,./)-),*!+,!! 01!2,+3)45+*6!(+$4.4+)57!! 8%'25!/4%295!4)9%4*! !

:,8%4-.*+%,!;2*%-.*+%,!<+-+*)=>!! ?).=(+,)5!@)9%4*>!A%3)-$)4!BCCD! ! ! ! ! !

!


A%*)!*%!4).=)4! !"#$%&'($)*+,-)*.$#/0--12$-02#34*+-35$63-7#8+9$3#:#33#;$+-$,)$+",2$3#6-3+$*2$+"#$<=02#34*+-35$63-7#8+>$ 63-4,;#;$?@A$BC$D),4#32,+,#2$E,+"$:3##$-).,)#$*88#22$+-$FG$8-D32#$+#H+$#/0--1$,)$+"#$:,#.;2$-:$ ID2,)#22$*);$J*)*K#L#)+$'+D;,#29$M)K,)##3,)K9$J#;,8,)#$*);$J#;,*$'+D;,#2N$$ • O"#3#$+"#$+#3L$<#/0--1>$,2$D2#;$,)$+",2$3#6-3+9$,+$3#:#32$+-$K#)#3,8$#/0--12$*);$#/0--1$ 8-..#8+,-)2$+"*+$+"#$D),4#32,+5$.,03*35$"*2$L*;#$*4*,.*0.#N$$ • O"#3#$+"#$+#3L$<#/+#H+0--1>$-3$<8-D32#$+#H+$#/0--1>$,2$D2#;$,)$+",2$3#6-3+9$,+$3#:#32$+-$ #.#8+3-),8$4#32,-)2$-:$0--12$+"*+$2D66-3+$+*DK"+$8-D32#$2+D;#)+2$P#NKN$D);#3K3*;D*+#2Q$*);$ *3#$#,+"#3$#22#)+,*.$-3$3#8-LL#);#;$3#*;,)KN$!"#2#$L*5$#H,2+$E,+",)$*)$*KK3#K*+#;$#/0--1$ 8-..#8+,-)N$ •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


:-3LD.*+#;$,)$-3;#3$+-$+3,*)KD.*+#$#,+"#3$E,+"$TRU$;*+*9$-3$E,+"$;*+*$#L*)*+,)K$:3-L$+"#$VD*.,+*+,4#$ 2D34#52$-:$*8*;#L,82$*);$2+D;#)+2N$ $ !"#$:-8D2$K3-D629$E",8"$-)$*4#3*K#$3*)$:-3$*$6#3,-;$-:$*0-D+$^_$L,)D+#29$E#3#$3#8-3;#;$*);$ 2D02#VD#)+.5$+3*)283,0#;$,)+-$J,83-2-:+$O-3;$;-8DL#)+29$E",8"$8-D.;$0#$,L6-3+#;$,)+-9$*);$ *)*.52#;$D2,)K9$+"#$`a,4-$A$2-:+E*3#N$ $ `-$63-0.#L2$E#3#$#H6#3,#)8#;$,)$-3K*),2,)K$*);$8-);D8+,)K$+"#$.,03*35$:-8D2$K3-D629$*);$+"#$+,L#$ :3*L#$E*2$*;"#3#;$+-N$U..$:-8D2$K3-D62$63-;D8#;$*$E,;#$3*)K#$-:$3,8"$3#26-)2#2$*);$+"#$ ,)+#34,#E#32$:-D);$+"#$8"-,8#$-:$;*+*$8-..#8+,)K$L#+"-;-.-K5$+-$0#$*663-63,*+#$*);$2D88#22:D.N$ $ IJ! ?).=(+,)!8+,=+,/5! ! IJK! L)()'*+%,!.,=!=)-.,=!8%4!)#$%%&5! !"#$94+-.46!4)59%,5+$+(+*6!8%4!5)()'*+%,9$*);$8-)2#VD#)+.5$+"#$L*7-3$2-D38#$-:$;#L*);$:-3$8-D32#$ +#H+2$*);$#/+#H+0--129$,2$2+,..$+"#$63#3-K*+,4#$-:$+"#$.,03*35N$O",.#$+"#3#$3#L*,)2$#4,;#)8#$+-$ ;#L-)2+3*+#$+"#$)##;$+-$;#4#.-6$*8*;#L,8$2+*::>2$*E*3#)#22$-:$2#.#8+,-)$2-D38#29$+"#3#$,2$2-L#$ ,);,8*+,-)$-:$+"#$K3-E,)K$6*3+,8,6*+,-)$05$*8*;#L,8$2+*::$,)$+"#$2#.#8+,-)$-:$#/+#H+0--12N$ &)+#3#2+,)K.59$.,03*3,*)2$6#38#,4#$*$2L*..$0D+$2,K),:,8*)+$,)83#*2#$,)$+"#$8-)+3,0D+,-)$+-$2#.#8+,)K$)#E$ +,+.#2$05$6-2+K3*;D*+#$2+D;#)+29$#26#8,*..5$,)$+"#$:,#.;2$-:$L#;,8,)#$*);$0D2,)#22$2+D;,#2N$ $ !"#$.,03*3,*)2>$4,#E2$-:$+"#$L*7-3$8.'*%45!*H.*!=4+3)!*H)!,))=!8%4!)#$%%&5$*3#$+"*+$#/0--12W$$ o 8*)$*;;3#22$+"#$8"*..#)K#2$63#2#)+#;$05$;,2+*)8#$.#*3),)K$2+D;#)+29$2+D;#)+2$-)$ 6.*8#L#)+2$,)$"-26,+*.2$-3$E-31,)K$,)9$:-3$#H*L6.#$#)K,)##3,)K9$.*0-3*+-3,#2$ o -::#3$6-+#)+,*.$2-.D+,-)2$+-$+"#$L*)*K#L#)+$,22D#2$2D33-D);,)K$2"-3+$.-*)$8-..#8+,-)2$ o *;;3#22$+"#$;#L*);$:-3$LD.+,6.#$8-6,#2S*88#22$$ o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b-.,85N$U$8-LL-)$+"#L#$3D)),)K$+"3-DK"-D+$L*)5$-:$+"#$2D07#8+$.,03*3,*)2>$3#26-)2#2$ ,2$+"*+$+"#$%&'($#/0--12$8-)+3,0D+#;$.,++.#$+-$#H,2+,)K$8-..#8+,-)2$-:$#/0--12$-E,)K$+-$+"#$6*D8,+5$-:$ )DL0#32$*);$+"#$:*8+$+"*+$+"#5$E#3#$)-+$*.E*52$8-3#$+-$+"#$2D07#8+$*3#*2N$U)-+"#3$2,K),:,8*)+$+"#L#$ +"*+$#L#3K#;$E*2$+"#$:*8+$+"*+$+"#$+#H+0--1$63-4,;#;$#.#8+3-),8*..5$L*5$0#$*)$-.;#3$#;,+,-)$c$ 2-L#+,L#2$-.;#3$+"*)$63,)+$#;,+,-)2$*.3#*;5$,)$+"#$8-..#8+,-)$c$*::#8+,)K$,+2$6#38#,4#;$4*.D#$*);9$ +"D29$,+2$D2#N$$ $ IJB! <+'),5+,/! O,+"$3#26#8+$+-$+"#$94+'+,/!-%=)(5!.,=!*H)!'%,'%-+*.,*!(+'),5+,/!+552)59$.,03*3,*)2$:##.$D)/ 8-)2D.+#;9$E,+"$6D0.,2"#32$*);$*KK3#K*+-32$)-+$.,2+#),)K$+-$+"#,3$4,#E2$-)$+"#$)*+D3#$-:$+"#$.,8#)8#2$


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aU!$E",.#$-+"#32$;-$)-+X$*);$,:$+"#3#$,2$*$"-2+,)K$-3$6.*+:-3L$:##$-)$+-6$-:$+",29$+"#$6#38#,4#;$ 0#)#:,+2$-:$#/0--12$L*5$L,.,+*+#$*K*,)2+$2D0283,0,)KN$ $ R,03*3,*)2$#L6"*2,2#;$+"*+$'%,*+,2+*6!%8!.'')55$,2$,L6-3+*)+$:-3$*$)DL0#3$-:$3#*2-)29$)-+$+"#$.#*2+$ 0#,)K$+"#$3*,2#;$#H6#8+*+,-)2$-:$D2#329$0D+$+"#3#$*3#$*.2-$2,K),:,8*)+$.-K,2+,8*.$*);$E-31:.-E$,22D#2$,:$ #/+#H+0--12$*3#$*;;#;$+-9$*);$2D02#VD#)+.5$3#L-4#;$:3-L9$8*+*.-KD#29$:#;#3*+#;$2#*38"$#)K,)#29$ aRM29$#+8N$$ $ O,+"$3#26#8+$+-$E"#+"#3$.,03*3,#2$*8+D*..5$,)/%*+.*)=!*H)!(+'),')!*)4-59$.,03*3,*)2$E#3#$26.,+$ 0#+E##)$+"-2#$E"-$:#.+$,+$)#8#22*35$*);$+"-2#$E"-$c$6-22,0.5$0#8*D2#$-:$+,L#$8-)2+3*,)+2$-3$.*81$-:$ *663-63,*+#$21,..2$c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bU($ *2$*$L#*)2$-:$*88#22N$!"#3#$*3#$+E-$63,)8,6*.$8-)8#3)2$E",8"$E#3#$",K".,K"+#;N$],32+.5$+"#$25)!%8! +,.994%94+.*)!:LRA59$*);$2#8-);.59$+"#$8-)2,2+#)+$9%%4!Q2.(+*6!%8!4)')+3)=!G;@P!4)'%4=5$c$*)$,22D#$ +"*+$L*5$#H+#);$+-$3#8#,4,)K$*$0*+8"$-:$JUY($3#8-3;2$+"*+$;-#2$)-+$63#8,2#.5$L*+8"$+"#$2#+$-:$0--12$ +"#5$*88-L6*)5N$U$3*)K#$-:$26#8,:,8$,22D#2$-:$8-)8#3)$E*2$,;#)+,:,#;$*);$"*4#$0##)$;#.,)#*+#;$,)$ +"#$3#6-3+N$!"#$3.4+.$()!Q2.(+*6!%8!*H)!4)')+3)=!G;@P!4)'%4=5!H.5!.!5+/,+8+'.,*!+-9.'*!%,!N%4&8(%N$ :-3$+"#$.,03*35N$ $ IJS! ;'')55!4%2*)5$


!"#3#$2##L#;$+-$*$8-)2#)2D2$4,#E$+"*+$+"#$ET;P!N.5!*H)!-%5*!%$3+%25!N.6!8%4!5*2=),*5!*%!8+,=!)# *)M*$%%&5!.,=!)#$%%&5!+,!/),)4.(9$*.+"-DK"$,+$L*5$0#$-).5$-)#$-:$2#4#3*.$3-D+#2$63-4,;#;N$!",2$L*5$ 0#$*88-D)+#;$:-3$05$+"#$:*8+$+"*+$L-2+$.,03*3,#2$*66#*3$+-$#L6"*2,2#$+"#$=b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c$)-+$+"#$.#*2+9$0#8*D2#$*8*;#L,8$ d8"*L6,-),)Ke$-:$3#2-D38#2$,2$63-0*0.5$+"#$L-2+$#::#8+,4#$E*2$-:$,)83#*2,)K$D2#N$&);##;9$+"#$:,32+$ TRU$3#6-3+$2"-E2$*$2+3-)K$8-33#.*+,-)$0#+E##)$d6*K#$4,#E2$*);$:*8D.+5$3#8-LL#);*+,-)2$ PY@f[NG^Qe9$E"#3#$dD2*K#$,2$8-)8#)+3*+#;$,)$*$:#E$4#35$2D88#22:D.$+,+.#2e9$*);$-)#$:-3L$-:$#/+#H+0--1$ +,+.#$63-L-+,-)$05$*8*;#L,82$,2$+"3-DK"$+"#$aRMN$!"#$:-8D2$K3-D62$8#3+*,).5$2*E$+"#$*;4*)+*K#2$-:$ aRM2$*);$3#8-K),2#;$+"#,3$#::,8*85X$"-E#4#39$.!'%,5*.,*!'%,')4,!+5!*H)!8.'*!*H.*!*H)!(+$4.46!+5!%8*),! )M'(2=)=!84%-!*H)!+,5*+*2*+%,.(!=)(+$)4.*+%,5!%,!U<"!=)3)(%9-),*!.,=!'%,*),*N$!"#3#$E*2$*$8.#*3.5$ #H63#22#;$)##;$:-3$.,03*3,#2$*);$;#6*3+L#)+2$+-$E-31$L-3#$8.-2#.5$+-K#+"#3$-)$,22D#2$2D8"$*2$+"#$ 252+#L*+,8$,)8.D2,-)$*);$3#L-4*.$-:$+,+.#2$:3-L$+"#$.,03*35$8-..#8+,-)N$$ $ =).5$-)#$.,03*35$L#)+,-)#;$V%%/()$*2$*$L#*)2$-:$*88#22,)K$#/+#H+0--129$*.+"-DK"$E#$*3#$2+*3+,)K$+-$ "#*3$*0-D+$+"#$D2#$-:$g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h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aRM9$3#*;,)K$.,2+29$*);$,)$.#8+D3#2N$ $ IJY! "3.(2.*+%,!%8!25)$ !"#$-4#3*..$,L63#22,-)$E*2$+"*+$5*.*+5*+'5!94%3+=)=!$6!92$(+5H)45!.,=!.//4)/.*%45$E#3#$)-+$*.E*52$ ",K".5$4*.D#;9$6*3+.5$0#8*D2#$.,03*3,#2$#,+"#3$;,;$)-+$2##$*$)##;$-3$8-D.;$)-+$*::-3;$+"#$+,L#$3#VD,3#;$ :-3$L#*),)K:D.$*)*.52,29$*);$6*3+.5$0#8*D2#$-:$+"#$4*3,#;$VD*.,+5$-:$+"#$2+*+,2+,82$63-4,;#;N$U.+"-DK"$ +"#$L*7-3,+5$-:$2+*+,2+,82$*3#$(=B`!MY/8-L6.,*)+9$2-L#$.,03*3,*)2$6#38#,4#$+"*+$+",2$*;;2$.,++.#$+-$ +"#,3$4*.D#9$*);$L*5$)-+$"#.6$E,+"$8-L6*3,2-)2$*83-22$6.*+:-3L2$;D#$+-$+"#$;,26*3*+#$(=B`!MY$ 3#6-3+2$D2#;$05$;,::#3#)+$6D0.,2"#32S*KK3#K*+-32N$$ $


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c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


Further information about JISC Collections: Web: www.jisc-collections.ac.uk Email: collections@jisc.ac.uk JISC Collections is the trading name for the JISC Content Procurement Company Limited. JISC Collections Brettenham House 5 Lancaster Place London WC2E 7EN United Kingdom Tel: +44 (0)20 3006 6000

Version 1.1, December 2009

E-book collection management in UK university libraries: focus groups report  
E-book collection management in UK university libraries: focus groups report  

This report presents the headline findings from the librarian focus groups. The focus groups investigated the attitudes and work of library...