

The President’s Message

“Peace cannot be kept by force; it can only be achieved by understanding.” - Albert Einstein
We made it through January, and as we continue to celebrate the wonderful things the BCBA community has accomplished, I believe it’s important to acknowledge that January was a heavy month for many of our members. Our community was faced with uncertainty, and we watched as fear and chaos swept through. Many experienced the threat of losing their livelihoods, only to have those fears later recanted. I believe it’s important to hold space for those who are fearful, regardless of political alignment. As Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. famously said, “…Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.” I would add to that: we must also extend grace. I urge each of us to offer grace to opposing counsel, the bench, and our neighbors during these turbulent times.
One of my key initiatives during my presidency was to evaluate the 10-year track to the presidency of our organization. I believe this lengthy process has directly contributed to the decline in applications for positions on the Executive Council. It’s essential for the vitality of any organization to evolve, and simply maintaining traditions
for the sake of tradition doesn’t necessarily serve us. In August 2024, a subcommittee was formed to review this issue, which included past president Rebecca Fleming, Judge Michael Barranco, Executive Council member Michelle Siri, Young Lawyers chair Briah Gray, and Jonathan Anderson. The subcommittee recommended that the 10-year track be shortened. On January 31, 2025, the Executive Council convened via Zoom to vote on the matter. Unfortunately, the majority voted against shortening the track. While the vote did not go in the direction I hoped, I still believe the feedback gathered through the survey and the discussions surrounding this topic were valuable, and I remain hopeful that change will come, either through continued dialogue or as the result of future necessity. I encourage every member to continue sharing their perspectives with the Executive Council, particularly if the 10-year track has influenced your decision not to apply for a position on the council.
On January 30, 2025, nearly 500 attendees gathered at Martin’s Valley Mansion to celebrate BCBA’s 103rd Annual Black-tie Bvent, affectionately known as “The Prom.” The mission was simple: create a space to connect, meet new and old members, and, most importantly, have a great time. Thanks to the support of our generous sponsors Stein Sperling, Nguyen Roche Sutton, One Promise, Vallit Dispute & Valuation Advisors, W Home Group, ASAP, Evernet, Excelsia Injury Care, Gross Mendelsohn, Legal Papers, MSBA, Minnesota Lawyers Mutual, and Planet Depos, this goal was certainly accomplished. A special thank you to our phenomenal Executive Director, Rachel Ruocco; Deputy Director, Amy Gantz-Cheatham; and Lawyer Referral Coordinator, Alpha Bah for their tireless efforts in making this event a success. The prom is back— and stronger than ever. I’ve already heard from many of you, “I’ll see you next year.”
As we welcome Black History Month, I leave you with more wisdom of the late Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.: “If we are to have peace on earth, our loyalties must become ecumenical rather than sectional. Our loyalties must transcend our race, our tribe, our class, and our nation; and this means we must develop a world perspective.”
Best Regards, Sondra M. Douglas, President Baltimore County Bar Association, 2024-2025
2024-25 Officers
President Sondra M. Douglas
President-Elect Richard Grason VI
Secretary Robert K. Erdman, Jr.
Treasurer Tyler J. Nowicki
Executive Council
Michelle Daugherty Siri
Alaina L. Storie
Mariela C. D’Alessio
Hon. Michael S. Barranco
Stuart A. Schadt
Syeetah Hampton-EL
Lisa Y. Settles
Immediate Past President
Briah M. Gray
Young Lawyers Chair
Rachel M. Ruocco
Executive Director
Amy Gantz-Cheatham
Deputy Director
The Executive Director’s Message

I am excited to share that the BCBA Member Resource Guide is now available on the homepage of our website! This exclusive member benefit is designed to connect you with valuable resources and trusted businesses that support the legal community. Simply log in to access the guide and explore a curated list of services and professionals tailored to your needs.
The Member Resource Guide will be published quarterly, with the next issue coming soon. If you know of businesses that would benefit from being listed, please send them my way—we are always looking to expand our network of trusted partners.
As always, thank you for being a valued member of the Baltimore County Bar Association!
- Rachel Ruocco, Executive Director Baltimore County Bar Association

February District Court State’s Attorney’s Schedule
Date:
Date:





Judge Charles Dorsey, Chair charles.dorsey@mdcourts.gov
Marissa Beth Joelson, Vice Chair mjoelson@lawpga.com 917-226-6472
Elizabeth Hill 410-274-0877
David C.M. Ledyard david@ledyardlaw.com
Jay Miller jmiller@lawpga.com
Andrew Cooper 410-303-0013
Cooper 917-226-6472
Carol Ghinger Cooper
Carol Ghinger Cooper chc1220@comcast.net 410-491-1042
Tom Rafter tom@tomrafterlaw.com
Tara Leigh Ross 410-790-8417
Judge William Simmons william.simmons@mdcourts.gov
Chris Flohr cflohr@bflwamd.com 443-838-1811
Chris Flohr cflohr@bflwamd com 410-491-1042 443-838-1811
Meg Garrett mrobinsongarrett@yahoo.com 240-474-7677

simmons@mdcourts gov
Kate Sinclair ksinclair@silvermanthompson.com
Gabriel Steele steelegabe@gmail.com
Let
FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT LEAD JUDGE – CRIMINAL
Effective immediately, in the event of a court closure due to inclement weather, all video bench warrant, bail reviews, and habeas corpus hearings will be heard the next business day. If the closure is on a Monday, any video arraignments and afternoon juvenile transfer status conferences will be carried over until the following Tuesday, or the next day that courts are opened, even if delayed . In the event of a delayed opening, generally all video hearings will be heard upon court opening.
PLEASE BE ON TIME FOR CASES IN THE CIRCUIT COURT.
Robert E. Cahill, Jr. Lead Judge-Criminal
For Distribution in the Advocate and on the Circuit Court’s Website
cc:
BCBA Court Administration Judges, Circuit Court
Erin Smith, Director, Central Assignment
Christine Shoobridge, Court Operations Manager - Civil and Assignment Divisions
Brittany Jackson, Criminal Case Manager
Jimmy Black, Sheriff’s Office
Scott Shellenberger, State’s Attorney
James Dills, District Public Defender
Eric Brooks, Records Manager, BCDC

Fill out the online form here, or email rruocco@bcba.org


Assistance Center of Towson Churches: It’s A Fact 2025
The Assistance Center of Towson Churches (ACTC), formed in 1985, is an ecumenical consortium of 50 congregations joined to efficiently and effectively reach out with help for the needy in our communities. They now include 21 zip codes in central Baltimore County, four of which also span Baltimore City and we serve there, too. ACTC’s staff consists of a director, a center supervisor, and two assistants and team of 200+ trained volunteers, who stock the food pantry, assist with special projects, interview clients, provide assistance and make referrals. Located behind Calvary Baptist Church, at 116 W. Pennsylvania Ave. in Towson, ACTC is open Monday-Friday, from 10 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. and Wednesday from 4-7 p.m.
EMERGENCY SERVICES
Food – A 7-day supply of nonperishable foods; fresh produce, meat, dairy and bakery items as available given every two weeks to food-insecure families in our service area.
Shelter – Rental eviction prevention and limited motel stays.
Clothing – Referrals to the Surprise Shop for free clothing.
Medicine – Payment for prescriptions and help obtaining medical supplies.
Transportation – Funds for gasoline, bus tokens, and bus passes for verifiable job hunting or doctor appointments.
Fuel/Utilities – Utility cut-off prevention and help in crisis oil situations.
Homeless/Stranded Help – Daily bagged lunches; referrals for other needed services; mail.
Toiletries – Health and hygiene items, baby and feminine supplies, cleaning supplies & paper goods.
Referrals – Help locating other agencies for further assistance.
NUMBERS THAT COUNT: 2024
Pounds of food distributed 303,631
Value of food distributed $586,000
Unique number of families receiving groceries 1,883 who received over 25,000 bags of food
Number of visits to pick up groceries 14,576
Homeless & dependents assisted 229 who received 8,129 bag lunches
Families helped financially 236 requested
Financial help total $158,829
Veterans & dependents assisted 55
BCDC Released persons assisted 31
Helped with transportation 339
Volunteer hours 12,002+
Thanksgiving Baskets 2,678
Adopted Christmas children 316; more than $48,506 estimated value of gifts
For further information, visit ACTC’s Web page at www.actcserves.org. 1/2025
The McCammon Group

Hon. Christopher Panos (Ret.)
Retired Associate Judge, Circuit Court for Baltimore City
The Honorable Christopher Panos has joined The McCammon Group after eleven years of dedicated service as an Associate Judge on the 8th Judicial Circuit Court for Baltimore City. He previously served as an Associate Judge for the District Court of Baltimore City and as a Special Master for the Family Division of the Circuit Court for Baltimore. Prior to his tenure on the bench, Judge Panos enjoyed a successful career in civil litigation including family law, bodily injury, and commercial matters. He is a Life Fellow of the Maryland Bar Foundation and a Fellow of the Baltimore City Bar Foundation. Judge Panos’ memberships include the International Association of LGBTQ+ Judges, Maryland State Bar Association, and Bar Association of Baltimore City. Judge Panos co-chaired the BABC Bench-Bar Committee and chaired the BABC Family Law Committee. Additional memberships have included the MSBA Standing Committee on Professionalism and the MSBA Family and Juvenile Law Section Council. Judge Panos now brings this exemplary record of excellence and experience to The McCammon Group to serve the mediation and arbitration needs of lawyers and litigants in Maryland and beyond.
Portrait Unveiling for the Honorable Robert E. Cadigan
On November 15, 2024, the Baltimore County Bar Foundation held the portrait unveiling ceremony for Baltimore County Circuit Court Judge Robert E. Cadigan. Judge Cadigan spent over three decades as a formidable civil trial lawyer and eleven years on the bench for the Circuit Court for Baltimore County. His portrait unveiling was a testament to the admiration, love and respect that those who knew him shared for him both as a person and a jurist.
Judge Cadigan’s three children, Robb, David and Claudia were present along with his grandchildren and numerous other family members and dear friends. David Cadigan, Judge Cadigan’s younger son, spoke on behalf of the family. He spoke of a dedicated father who loved his family and his career. A man who was honored to be appointed to the bench and took his role very seriously but never lost his sense of humor. Dave spoke of his Dad’s dry wit and uncanny comedic timing. He was not one to shy away from the tough cases or decisions, nor was he one to shy away from doing what it took to garner a smile from his kids or maybe make them blush a bit. He was known to dress in a full bunny outfit for Easter and hop around the neighborhood to the delight (or chagrin) of his kids. He also loved his Irish heritage and had a full suit in green along with pointy shoes that were a must for St. Patrick’s Day.
I had the honor and privilege of being one of Judge Cadigan’s law clerks and of being asked by his family to speak at his portrait unveiling. Speaking after Dave Cadigan is no easy feat. The love of the Cadigan family was felt throughout the room as Dave spoke. While I knew a different version of Judge Cadigan, mainly his role as a jurist, many aspects of the family man overlapped with the jurist. When asked to speak, my first thought was, “How does one convey this man’s amazing sense of humor and quick wit?” Little did I know that would be a theme throughout the speakers at the portrait unveiling. Judge Cadigan took his job very seriously, and some cases weighed on him more than others, especially when lives, freedom and/or custody were on the line, but he still lived for the joyous moments. He absolutely loved the smiles of adoption day and shared with every family how it was the absolute best part of his job.
Judge Cadigan brought his sense of humor to his chambers daily and was known to share stories and jokes with his chambermate, the Hon. Norris Byrnes, over a

much-needed cup of coffee. While the bunny outfit never made it to the courthouse (at least not in my tenure), the green suit came on St. Patrick’s Day along with the pointy shoes. Our chambers also had the privilege of the Judge serenading us with songs from the Phantom of the Opera as he strolled into chambers from the bench, ceremoniously whipping his robe up to hide half his face and complete the performance. He also performed “rose ceremonies” with fresh roses that were in chambers in such dramatic fashion. The producers of The Bachelor would have been quite proud. These moments came to him so spontaneously and authentically and brought much needed levity to the hard job he was tasked with performing daily.
Judge Cadigan valued civility and collegiality among the members of the bar, and bench. He expected litigants and lawyers to treat one another with the respect the







courtroom and their cases deserved. He taught his law clerks the value of working hard but doing it respectfully. You can lose a case, but never lose who you are. Don’t lose your sense of humor or your self-respect or the respect of the profession you are a part of.
The final speaker at the portrait unveiling was former Baltimore County Executive and Circuit Court Judge, the Hon. James (“Jim”) T. Smith. Jim spoke about his best friend for nearly 3 decades. A friendship formed on the bench but that long outlived both men’s time on the court. Jim Smith and Judge Cadigan met and became fast friends on the Circuit Court bench. Jim spoke also of Judge Cadigan’s quick wit and humor. Once again, the leprechaun suit, a theme of the day, was part of the story. Jim also shared how Judge Cadigan participated in a follies type program at the retirement of Chief Judge Robert Bell in which Judge Cadigan portrayed attending “baby judge school” looking much like a cherub with, among other things, his large baby bonnet and bib on. There were also stories of wonderful friends who traveled



together to shows, plays and various trips. Jim recounted stories of Judge Cadigan’s trip to Paris where the judge donned his beret, scarf, striped shirt and fake mustache while speaking with a lovely French accent. (Maybe this was the birth of the Phantom of the Opera bit.)
Jim also shared stories about a man deeply dedicated to family. The love of Judge Cadigan’s life, his adoring wife Dorothy, by his side throughout his career and travels. The Judge took so much pride in his family, sharing stories of the accomplishments of Robb, Dave and Claudia, and on occasion their mishaps, but they were always shared with love and that impeccable Cadigan humor. Even when he was ill and in declining health, the Judge wouldn’t miss flying to Cleveland to be at grandparents’ day at Claudia’s son’s school. The love of family and friends meant so much to Judge Cadigan and he cherished and nourished those relationships, proudly showing everyone the value of those he loved.
One poignant and very special moment was shared by Jim
BCBA Partnership
Are you looking to expedite your video and audio e-discovery process?
All active members of the BCBA can now receive our Starter Plan for free for 6 months! ($450 value)


ABOUT SIID
SIID is an AI-powered eDiscovery tool that expedites evidence review and early case assessment workflows by automatically detecting crucial insights within large datasets.
*Must be an
FOLLOW THIS LINK & USE PROMO CODE SIIDBCBA24
WHAT YOU GET:
UP TO 3 CASE CREATIONS PER MONTH
5 GB OF STORAGE ON OUR CJISCOMPLIANT GOVCLOUD SYSTEM EMAIL SUPPORT
Want to learn more?
Schedule a one-one-one call with a member of our team: click here.
at the portrait unveiling. That is the story of the hinge. Judge Cadigan and then Judge Smith forged a beautiful friendship while both serving on the Baltimore County Circuit Court bench. When Judge Smith decided to resign from the bench to campaign for Baltimore County Executive, Judge Cadigan gifted Judge Smith with a bronze hinge. The hinge symbolized the connection that these friends had formed and served as a reminder that even if they were moving to different locations or in different roles, their bond of friendship should not, and ultimately would not, be allowed to grow apart or be broken. Over the years, their friendship never missed a beat, even when Jim Smith left the courthouse and, throughout all the years, the hinge never left Judge Smith. In fact, it was one of the many “props” that came to the courthouse for the portrait unveiling, along with photos of the leprechaun suit and a rose for the rose ceremony.
Following the ceremony, the Cadigan family invited everyone to join them at the Charles Village Pub to raise a glass and share a meal in honor of their Dad. The laughs were plentiful. The love and respect could be felt throughout the room and Judge Cadigan would have absolutely adored the bagpiper who played beautifully. He would’ve been even more proud seeing Claudia perfectly dance an Irish jig. The entire ceremony and celebration after were the perfect embodiment of a man who loved his family, loved the law and loved laughter. The legacy left by Judge Robert E. Cadigan will live on in all who knew him. On behalf of the Cadigan family, and all who knew and loved him, our heartfelt gratitude to the Baltimore County Bar Foundation for commissioning his portrait. Thank you.
– Christine Britton, Esq.




Elevating Excellence



Sondra Douglas Principal, Family Law
Laura Llanso Personal Injury Morgan Kirby Estate Planning
Joseph Moeller Commercial Litigation
Vida Mokhtari Personal Injury

Meet the Members of the State’s Attorney’s Office

Patrick Brooks
University of Baltimore School of Law
Practicing Law for 2 years
Were you involved in any activities in law school that led you to the SAO?
Throughout my 2L and 3L years I worked at a small firm that does criminal defense work, which is where I got hooked on criminal practice. I was also a Rule 19 student attorney for the Civil Advocacy Clinic, which is where I learned that I love being in the courtroom.
What is your position with SAO?
I’m an ASA II in Circuit Court: sort of a hybrid, Felony Trial Team while still handling some PJT dockets.
How long have you been with SAO?
Two years.
What about District/Circuit Court do you like? Dislike?
I really liked all the trials in District Court, and miss the different flavors of the three courthouses around the County, but do not miss driving all over. It’s nice to only have to go to Circuit Court now, especially with my tenminute commute. I was a Judicial Law Clerk in Circuit before joining SAO, and it’s great to be able to interact and work with all the people I got to know who work in other areas of the courthouse.
Pet peeve in this line of work?
Mean and/or angry people… You can be unhappy in your own life if you want, but don’t take it out on the rest of us.
What do you like to do when you aren’t at work?
I really like to prepare, serve, and eat good food. I worked in restaurants for fifteen years before going to law school. I like to hit the gym and get outside. I’ve lived right by the Loch Raven Reservoir since 1L year, and I love the water and the woods. I also really enjoy spending time with family. I’ve got three little brothers in the area, all with kids of their own.
What is the craziest/funniest/most district court thing you have seen happen in court?
During cross on a defendant in a drunk and disorderly case out of Arbutus…
Me: And then you drank four Natty Daddys…
Defense Counsel: Objection your honor, I don’t see the relevance of them being Natty Da…
Defendant, interrupting from the stand: “THEY’RE 8% YOUR HONOR!”
Defense Counsel: Withdrawn.
Or, reading in a statement on a plea… Officers responded to the Double TT Diner in Catonsville for a disturbance. Observed a man in a devil costume with a three-foot long sword engaged in a fight with a security guard. “Drop the sword, Devil, I will F***ing taze you.” Devil refused to comply; officers deployed tazers.
Highlight moment in court/career (so far).
One-hour guilty verdict on First Degree Felony Murder in my first murder trial.
What is it you like about criminal law?
It’s real. I like the people and the stories.
Any involvement in the Baltimore County Bar Association?
I’m not a member, but I should be and I should get more involved.
A fun fact about yourself…
My record at Raising Cane’s is eleven chicken tendies. And, just today, I ate 10 street tacos from Taco Bravo.

Baltimore County Bar Association Young Lawyers Committee Presents
D i s t r i c t
C o u r t
C h a m b e r s
C h a t


February 11, 2025
12:oo p. m. - 1:00 p. m.
Hon. Bruce Friedman Hon. Michael Pate
When: Tuesday, February 11 at 12:00pm
Baltimore County District Court Judges Bruce Friedman and Michael Pate
Where: Virtual Zoom Meeting
Registration Required. Click HERE to register.
Link emailed upon registration.

Join the Young Lawyers Committee as we host an informal, guided conversation with members of the District Court Bench.
Meet the Juvenile Magistrate Intern

Caelyn Sullivan
Towson University
3rd year undergrad
Originally from Fallston, MD
What prompted your interest in interning for a juvenile Magistrate?
For the past few years, I have known I want to go to law school to become an attorney. Within the past two years, I started looking into areas of law I would like to specialize in, and juvenile law stuck out to me. When my professor from Towson, Professor Miller, told our class there was an internship opening under a juvenile magistrate, I knew it was my chance to see if I wish to continue in juvenile law.
What do you hope to get out of this experience?
I hope to learn many things, which I know I will, about the juvenile court system. Juvenile justice is very different from the adult system, in ways I would have never thought of. I also hope to see how a courtroom functions, from the clerks and bailiffs to the state’s attorneys and defense attorneys. How long is your internship?
My internship is from January to May of 2025. Have you given any thought to an area of law you would like to practice?
I have thought long about which areas of law I would like to study, and four have stuck out to me the most: criminal law, juvenile law, family law, and agricultural law.
What about those areas of law interest you?
Criminal law: Criminal law is the first type of law I saw, and since then it has always been an option. My high school forensics teacher has us watch the O.J. Simpson trial in class, and I could barely focus on the forensics aspect of the documentary. My eyes were focused on the attorneys and how they worked.
Juvenile law: Juvenile law was a recent discovery for me, as I always assumed that juvenile law was grouped into family law. It wasn’t until Professor Miller’s class that I discovered it had its own category. Children deserve a chance to be heard on why they committed a crime,
and I want to be able to give them the chance. Not all children are bad, many just make poor decisions, as we all did their age, but they are labeled as bad. I want to give them a chance to show everyone, their families, friends, teachers, and the world that they are not defined by their poor choices.
Family law: Family law is a type of law that hits close to home with me, as I am from a divorced family. Additionally, I watched how hard it was on my mother to fight for my little cousin in court when his father passed.
Agricultural law: I am from Fallston, MD which is a rural area in Harford County. Throughout my childhood, if I wasn’t playing sports, I would be on a farm feeding horses, cleaning stalls and riding horses. In recent years, it has been a growing conversation that farmers are being bought out of their land by companies to build homes and developments. One of the farms that I boarded my horses at did sell part of their land, and now when I drive by, I see houses blocking the view of the farm.
What do you like to do for fun?
When my face is not buried in my textbooks, I love to be outdoors. Whether it is taking a hike through the local parks or taking road trips to new places, I will be outside when the weather is nice.



Wednesday, February 19
5:00 PM
Baltimore County Circuit Court
Old Jury Assembly Area
*Refreshments Provided*
Addressing Financial Issues in Divorce
A general overview of business valuation, income analysis, and asset tracing in family law.
PRESENTED
BCBA FAMILY LAW COMMITTEE

Presenters
Ret. Hon. Kathleen G. Cox
Mark W. Norris, CPA/ABV, CVA, MAFF, ASA - Vallit Advisors
Richard Wolf, CPA/ABV, CFE, CVA, CGMA - Gross Mendelsohn



What the BCBA Means to Me

I joined the BCBA in January of 2018. I did so as a way of getting to know members of the Baltimore County legal community. What I have gotten out of the membership and participation on various committees is so much more than I could ever have imagined.
The first committee I joined was the Professionalism Committee. At the first meeting I walked into a room in the courthouse not knowing a single person. We discussed nominees for the Plumhoff Award. Despite the fact that I did not know the nominees or even what the award was about, the members of the Committee welcomed me without hesitation, answered my questions, and even let me cast a vote. Those first few members I met in that meeting remain some of my closest friends in the Bar Association to this day.
I also joined the Family Law Committee. I joined to both meet family law practitioners but also to learn about an area of law I do not practice. Family law also overlaps significantly with one of my primary practice areas, child abuse, and I thought learning about custody and divorce
would help me evaluate my cases, which it absolutely has. Through the monthly programming, either by Zoom or inperson dinners, not only have I learned more about family law, but I have developed a network of knowledgeable practitioners who I am comfortable going to with questions. They also know how to have a good time!
Those first two Committees and the friends that I made on them, flowed into participation with the Civics and Law Academy (Public Awareness and Speakers Committee), being sworn in to the Supreme Court Bar (organized by the BCBA), campaigning for the sitting judges, attending the Prom and holiday party, and countless other social events and experiences with amazing people that but for the Bar Association I would not know.
The last committee I am a member of is the Advocate. I began writing the criminal law update a few years ago and that has morphed into me becoming the Chair of the Committee. Writing the update has been a wonderful outlet for the caselaw junky inside me and provided an opportunity to delve deeper into issues coming out of the appellate courts. I would be remiss if I didn’t use this as an opportunity to make a pitch for contributors for future editions. We are always looking for writers to contribute articles, so if you have a novel issue in a case and want to turn your research into an article, we welcome all contributions. We also welcome anyone interested to participate in our monthly Zoom meeting to brainstorm ideas for future editions. Just let Rachel know you are interested, and she will include you on the Zoom link.

I joined the BCBA with a goal in mind. What I have gotten out of it, however, is so much more: professional development, great experiences, and most importantly wonderful friends. When I think about my participation with the BCBA I am reminded of the oft repeated words attributed to various people, “It’s not the destination, it’s the journey.” Make the BCBA part of your journey and I promise you won’t regret it!
– Jennifer Ritter, Esq., Member since 2018
BAR WARS TEAM TRIVIA

PROCEEDS TO BENEFIT E N T R Y F E E $ 1 0 0 Register Here Wednesday, February 26 @ 5pm BARLEYS BACKYARD 408 York Road, Towson


Gather your colleagues, friends, family and fellow trivia enthusiasts for an evening of brain-teasing questions, friendly competition, and endless entertainment Minimum of 2 and maximum of 10 people per team Maximum of 15 teams

Civil Law Update:
November and December 2024 and January 2025
Review of the Amicus Curiarum for November and December 2024 and January 2025, revealed the following civil case of interest:
THE APPELLATE COURT:
Jesse Francis v. Stephanie Francis, No 1637, September Term, filed September 25, 2024.
Opinion by Tang, Rosalyn, Judge
The trial court determined that, for child support purposes, Father’s veteran disability payments were “income” for purposes of calculating the child support due. Father appealed and argued that veteran’s disability benefits are intended for the service member who suffered the disability and “earned” the benefits as a result. If they are to be included, Father argued that only a portion should be included as income so that he derives some benefit from the compensation for his disability.
The Appellate Court of Maryland affirmed the lower court’s including of the full veteran’s disability payment in income for purposes of calculating the child support due. The Court held that that type of income, while not specifically listed in Maryland Family Law §12-201(b), is included in “income from any source” under subsection (b)(1) and not excluded under subsection (b)(5). Therefore, the trial court correctly included that income as income for Father when calculating the child support payable.
Gina Augustine v. Steven Wolf, No. 2322, September Term 2023, Filed November 22, 2024.
Opinion by Ripkin, Laura S., Judge
In 2018, the parents were granted joint legal and physical custody of their child, B. In 2021, Mother filed a protective order claiming that Father had sexually abused B and was granted temporary custody. While an investigation by DSS resulted in a finding of “indicated” sexual abuse, the circuit court denied the petition for protective order, finding that Mothe had not met her evidentiary burden. Following the hearing, DSS amended its findings to rule out. Mother consistently alleged that Father had abused B. In 2022,

Deputy Director
Mother filed a petition to modify child custody based on the alleged sexual abuse by Father and that it constituted a material change in circumstances. A best interest attorney (“BIA”) was appointed to represent B. Father filed a motion in limine contending that Mother was collaterally estopped from presenting any evidence or arguing that Father had abused B prior to the 2021 hearing denying the protective

Ceecee Paizs
Part 2
12
12
MARCH PM
REGISTER

Desk Yoga; Exercise Moves at your Desk
With everyone's busy lives finding time to exercise can be hard to do. Learn simple yoga and exercise moves that you can do at your desk, whether at work or at home. Yoga and exercise are proven to reduce stress and provide numerous other health benefits.
Hosted by the Legal Support Professionals Committee, this virtual event is FREE and open to BCBA members and non-members.
Speaker: Candy Carr-Smith, Professor of Wellness, Community College of Baltimore County
Certified Yoga Instructor
Bachelor of Science, Elementary Education and Master’s Degree, Secondary Education from Towson State University
Certificate of Advanced Study in Education: Leadership and Supervision , The College of Notre Dame



order. The court granted Father’s motion. Both Mother and the BIA opposed the motion. When Mother sought to introduce evidence relating to the alleged abuse, including a video recording f a DSS forensic interview with B, which was unavailable at the protective order hearing, she was precluded from doing so. After the merits hearing, the court modified custody, granting the parties joint physical custody and joint legal custody and granting tiebreaking authority to Father.
The Appellate Court of Maryland reversed. The ACM examined the distinctions between protective order hearings and custody modification hearing. The ACM noted that the Supreme Court of Maryland emphasized the importance of evidence of past abuse and/or past parental behavior as potentially predictive of future abusive and/or parental behavior. The Court determined that a trial court’s denial of a final protective order does not subsequently preclude evidence, argument or judicial findings of abuse in subsequent custody proceedings. Since a final custody offered, while intended to be a durable
Civil Law Update
dispensation effectuating the best interest of the child, a custody order does not hold the same degree of finality that accompanies other kinds of judgments. As such estoppel by judgment while applying to custody determinations, does not preclude a court from examining facts and circumstances previously litigated. Further, the court noted that just as courts in custody modification proceedings are not precluded from considering evidence that was before a court in a previous custody hearing, and courts evaluating motions for protective orders are not precluded from evaluating evidence related to contentions first alleged in a previous protective order hearing, neither should courts be collaterally estopped from considering evidence relate to an allegation in a prior protective order hearing in a subsequent custody hearing. The ACM conclude that concerns related to principles of finality must give way to a child’s right to have their best interests fully considered in a custody proceeding.
– Ceecee Paizs, Esq.






Bench Bar Committee: January 9, 2025 Meeting
The January meeting of the Bench Bar Committee was conducted by Zoom and called to order by the Committee’s Chair, Kerri Cohen on Thursday January 9, 2025, at 8:00am.
Approval of Minutes.
The Chair asked if there were any proposed amendments from the December 12, 2024, committee meeting. Hearing none, a motion to approve the minutes from the prior meeting was made by Harry Chase and seconded by Aidan Smith. The minutes were approved.
COMMITTEE REPORTS
The Circuit Court for Baltimore County: County Administrative Judge Report was delivered by the Honorable Dennis Robinson who was pleased to share some year-end statistics, including comparisons between 2023 and 2024:
Family Cases
In 2023, we had 107 family law cases placed on standby. In 2024, we had only 15 cases placed on standby. With 7 judges on the family law rotation the first half of this year instead of the usual 6, we expect to see these trends to continue. 7 judges is not likely to be a permanent change for the family law rotation. I did not want to put all of
the newer judges in the family law rotation at the same time, so they will be introduced gradually. Judge Epstein, our Lead Family Law Judge, and Abby Cohen, Family Law Case Manager, are doing a great job keeping family law cases on track.
Civil Cases
In 2023, we had 44 civil jury trial cases placed on standby. In 2024, there were 7. We are continuing to revisit our case management processes to do what we can to continue this trend for civil cases. Judge Mayer, the Lead Civil Judge, and Juliette Ramos, Civil Case Manager, are doing an excellent job moving civil cases.
Criminal Cases
In 2024, we tried 101 cases to verdict. There were 79 jury trials and 22 bench trials. 139 cases were resolved by stet, nol pros or plea prior to jury selection. 7 cases were resolved by stet, nol pros or plea after jury selection. These numbers continue to demonstrate that the most effective way to resolve criminal cases is being in a position to provide trials when a trial is requested. Judge Cahill, our Lead Criminal Judge and Brittany Jackson, our Criminal Case Manager, also do an excellent job with case management.

Community College of Baltimore County
Legal Studies Focus Group
Areyou an attorney or paralegalinthe
Baltimore Metro area?
CCBC’s Legal Studies Program NEEDS your input!
CCBC’s Legal Studies program is conducting a Focus Group of attorneys and paralegals in the Baltimore Metro area.
Date: March 29, 2025
Time: 9 a.m. – 12 noon
Location: CCBC Owings Mills Center 10300 Grand Central Avenue, Owings Mills, MD 21117
Registration: https://forms.office.com/r/xeAsVhaFXK

We need a variety of legal professionals (solo, small firm, medium firm, large firm, in-house, corporate, etc.) to provide input on the trends and issues impacting the legal field. Register using the above link or QR Code.
Questions? Contact Donna S. Mandl, Legal Studies Department Chair at

• As was previously reported, Magistrate Carrie Polley joined the juvenile court rotation effective January 1, 2025, and Judge Patricia DeMaio became the Lead Guardianship Judge as of January 1, 2025.
• Judge Thompsett’s investiture is today at 4:00 p.m. He is handling dockets on his own and is off to a great start. In fact, all your newer judges are off to an amazing start here. They know what they need to learn, and they are putting in the time and effort to get up to speed. The first couple of years on the bench is the steepest learning curve, and they are ascending it quickly. There are some qualified applicants already on the “short list” for the upcoming vacancies, and I know we’ll see some new names on the applicant list for the vacancies we have this year. I am pleased with where we are as a bench and looking forward to seeing and experiencing the future of this bench.
Report of the Clerk of the Circuit Court:
Chief Deputy Clerk, Greg Moskovitz was in attendance for the Clerk, Julie Ensor. He had nothing new to report. When asked a question about the clerk’s office renovations by member, Harry Chase, he reported that the renovations were going well with no disruptions to
services for customers. e
Report for the Magistrates:
Magistrate Dilip Paliath reported that Magistrate Hossein Parvizian presided over his first juvenile docket in December 2024. He also reported that Magistrate Carrie Polley would preside over her first juvenile docket January 9, 2025. That was the only report from the Magistrates. Orphans’ Court Report:
There was no report from Chief Judge Arthur M. Frank. Register of Wills Report:
There was no report from Register of Wills Alexis BurrellRohde.
Report for the District Court Bench:
District Administrative Judge Dorothy J. Wilson wished everyone a Happy New Year. She advised that the District Court Recovery Court will be expanding eligibility for alcohol related offenses. She hopes that this will be launched in March of 2025. There will be an official announcement soon. She advised that questions from the Public Defender and the State’s Attorney should be directed to Judge Kristen Davis of the Baltimore County District Court. Judge Wilson also reported that
HELP!



all scheduled evictions were cancelled last week due to the extreme cold temperatures. She would be staying all failure to pay rent evictions in the upcoming week if the temperature falls to 32 degrees and below pursuant to a new state law that went into effect October 1, of 2025.
District Court Administrator’s Report:
Maria Fields reported that the clerk’s office has been busy after the holidays.
Office of Administrative Hearings:
Administrative Law Judge William Somerville, III, stated he had nothing new to report.
Executive Council Report:
ar President Sondra Douglas reported that the BCBA Holiday party was well attended. She also reported that Baltimore County attorneys and Baltimore County Judges conducted a “Civics and the Law” panel for three Baltimore County Public schools. President Douglas again reminded all that the Baltimore County Bar Banquet will
be held January 30, 2025 and that the tickets were selling fast. The banquet will have formal seating and a jazz band playing. She advised that the Investiture of Judge Thomas R. Tompsett, Jr., would occur January 9, 2025. The Investiture of Judge Marc A. DiSimone, Jr. would be held January 23, 2025.
State’s Attorney’s Office Report:
Scott Shellenberger stated that his office is seeking attorneys to start as prosecutors in the District Court for Baltimore County. He reported that they are currently short four (4) attorneys.
Public Defender’s Office Report:
James Dills reported that the Office of the Public Defender is seeking panel attorneys for felony cases. Mr. Dills said his office is finding it difficult to find panel attorneys when the OPD has a conflict.
Report from the Baltimore County Office of Law: County Attorney James Benjamin had no report.











Nationwide and Global Coverage
Fast, Reliable, and Accurate...
CRC Salomon has more than 123 years of specialization at your service. One of the Nation’s oldest and most reliable court reporting firms in the country. We provide experienced Reporters, Realtime Specialists, LiveNote, Videoconferencing, Video Depositions, Hearings, Online Scheduling, Transcription services, and Conference Rooms. Mobile access to your documents and scheduling 24/7 Local and National scheduling. Our
• Depositions
• Hearings
• CART Services
• Arbitrations
• Notaries
• Realtime

• Conferences
• Video Service by Certified Legal Videographers
• LiveNote™
• Large conferencing facilities
• Videoconferencing
• Remote WebDeposition Latest Technologies via Laptop, iPad, and Smart Phone
• All Industry Standard Platforms (Zoom, WebEx, GoToMeeting, MS Teams, Blue Jeans, Etc..)
• Remote Counsel

Report from the Criminal Defense Bar:
The Criminal Defense Bar had no report..
Report from the Family Law Liaison:
Craig Borchers reported that there are three upcoming family law events being sponsored by the BCBA’s Family Law Committee. The first event is scheduled for 1/22/2025 @ noon via zoom. The topic is: Improving Outcomes for Families with Structured Co-Parenting. Relevant topics will be admission of evidence at trial and relevant provisions in settlement agreements. The second event will be February 19, 2025 @5pm. This event will be an in-person reception with food and drink provided. The topic is: Addressing Financial Issues in Divorce, Including Complex Income Issues and Property Evaluation. Last, the Office of Family Support Services will have an open house at the Baltimore County Supervised Visitation Center on 1/29/2025 from 4:00pm to 6:00pm. The center will be offering a six-week program called “Kids Taking the Lead”. This program will offer support to children facing separation and divorce. The service coordinator of this program is Brianna Gray.
Report from the Young Lawyers Committee:
Briah Gray reported that the Baltimore County Annual Bull and Oyster Roast will be on March 23, 2025. It will be held at The Maryland State Fair Grounds. A planning meeting for the event will be January 13, 2025.
Report from Baltimore City Bar Liaison:
Harry Chase had no report related to the Baltimore City Bar Association.

Committee Reports
Report from the Bar Foundation’s Portrait Committee:
Harry Chase asked for help with the portrait committee. He had no other news to report.
Report from Harford County Bar Liaison:
There was no report from Tyler Nowicki concerning the Harford County Bar Association.
Diversity, Equity, Inclusion & Accessibility Committee Report:
Noelle W. Newman reported that the Summers Scholars program application date has passed. She reported that ten (10) applicants will be interviewed by the committee.
The Women’s Law Center:
Judge Katie Curran O’Malley, the Executive Director of the Women’s Law Center had no report. However, she complimented the District Court and Circuit Court for the work that the Bailiff’s and Sheriff’s have been doing in serving criminal warrants on respondents in protective order cases.
Adjournment:
There being no additional business, the Chair then called for a motion to adjourn the meeting. There was a motion and a second of the motion. The meeting adjourned shortly after 8:30 am.
– Katie Curran O’Malley, Esq.


Maryand Volunteer Lawyers Service:
Make a Resolution to Take a Pro Bono Case This Year
The new year is a time to reflect on years past and think about what you want to accomplish in the coming months. For many, that includes either volunteering more for a cause you are passionate about or embarking on a new volunteer journey altogether. For others, that might include learning new skills or researching new topics. For some, that might include meeting new people or growing a community. The good news is that Pro bono work can help you accomplish all this and more. There are many organizations in Maryland where you can use legal skills you already possess to change people’s lives. One of those organizations is Maryland Volunteer Lawyers Service (MVLS). This organization provides full representation to low-income Marylanders with civil cases. Beyond this, they also create community connections with other local organizations to help provide services to more people and advocate for a more equal and just society in Maryland. To learn more about the opportunities offered by other organizations, you can also join the Bar Association’s Pro Bono Committee.
Pro bono work can help expand your knowledge, create career opportunities, and grow your community in the legal field. By participating in pro bono, it opens doors to opportunities that would not be available otherwise. By becoming a part of a pro bono panel, you grow your legal network instantly. For example, MVLS hosts multiple events that encourage attorneys on our volunteer panel to get to know each other and become more acquainted with the members of our staff. In taking training available from pro bono organizations, you build on your skills and learn new ones. MVLS provides training in every case type we accept as well as other skills like traumainformed lawyering. For example, in January we hosted a training on how to help Human Trafficking survivors address their criminal records and on February 5th, we are hosting an estate planning clinic in the community. These kinds of skills are types that you would probably have to pay to access but in participating in pro bono, they are available with a click of a button. Not only that, but our staff attorneys are also available by email, phone,


Leading Experts Providing Value

and they host office hours every month. Our volunteers have support at every turn.
Why do our volunteers get involved in pro bono work?
Hunter Scott, Esq. of Frost Law says “The MVLS free trainings, mentorship programs, and hands-on experience with incredibly appreciative clients is invaluable, especially for newer lawyers.” Alexandria Montanio of Gordon Feinblatt said “I volunteer with MVLS because the support from MVLS staff members is excellent. If I have a question about a case or want to brainstorm a strategy or approach, someone from MVLS has always been enthusiastic about helping me better serve the client.” Finally, Tina Azarvand, who is a solo practitioner, said “MVLS offers a unique opportunity to make a concrete difference in someone’s life while strengthening the community. Whether you can take one case a year or several, every hour of pro bono service helps bridge the justice gap for Marylanders who would otherwise face overwhelming legal challenges without representation, so consider taking at least one case!” Our volunteers are passionate about the cases they take on and the mission behind taking pro bono cases.

Community Partners
At MVLS we like to say that volunteers get just as much out of taking cases as they put into them. Beyond what you as an attorney can get out of taking a pro bono case, you will greatly impact the lives of those in your community. 80% of low-income Marylanders involved in civil cases represent themselves, yet people are 6.5 times more likely to have a favorable outcome if they have representation. In many cases, these folks are being taken advantage of by the unequal justice system that exists today. By taking a pro bono case, you are helping create more access to justice for those around you. In 2024, MVLS impacted 6,135 individuals with our services. By taking a case, you can be a part of a powerful legacy of helping those in need across Maryland. A few hours of your time can change the lives of so many forever. Make someone’s Winter bright by participating in pro bono this year.
If this sounds like work you want to be doing, please consider signing up to take a case with MVLS. To apply, head to our website! If you have any questions or would like to discuss volunteering further, contact Etta Moen at emoen@mvlslaw.org
–
Etta Moen, Volunteer Coordinator for MVLS

Family Law Committee: OurFamilyWizard – Improving Outcomes for Families
Co-parenting can be filled with tension and miscommunication, but it does not have to be. OurFamilyWizard (OFW) is a web-based application frequently used in parenting agreements and court orders as a way to reduce litigation and improve family outcomes.
On January 22, 2025, Elle Barr, Esq., spoke with the Family Law Committee about how parents and practitioners can best utilize OFW’s platform to manage and document communication. Michelle, a practicing family law attorney, also serves as the Judicial Education Coordinator for OFW, where she educated judges, lawyers, and other family law professionals on how OFW can be utilized to reduce conflict and increase accountability in high-conflict co-parenting situations.
In addition to providing attendees sample language used in court orders and settlement agreements, she also demonstrated the many valuable features of the program. From the attorney’s perspective, OFW offers the best means to maintain secure and verifiable communication between two parents. The most wildly used feature of the OFW program is the messaging function, which works like traditional email and text message, but preserves
the messages, preventing the ability for anyone to edit or delete a message after the fact. The program tracks when each message was sent, when it was read, and what response was made.
In addition to the popular messaging function, OFW also offers a calendaring function where parents can visualize their on-going schedule indefinitely into the future, including time of exchanges, a unique holiday schedule, and even a trade/ swap feature. The video chat feature documents video and audio calls, providing a safe and secure means for parents to engage in virtual access time with their child. OFW has an expense reimbursement request feature, a general information sharing tool, and a journal feature many other benefits. Maintaining a free professional account allows attorneys direct access to the ongoing communications of their clients using the program.
Elle has generously offered to be a direct point of contact for any attorney questions, or needed information, including their no-questions-asked fee waiver program, and assistance with obtaining certified records. Elle can be reached at mbarr@ourfamilywizard.com.



Joseph Murtha
Andrew Jezic
Silver Spring Easton Frederick Waldorf
Baltimore County Bar Association

Save the Date

October 17
February 20
June 19 includes installation of New Officers and Executive Council
All meetings held at 4:30pm
Civics & Law Academy
11/15 CCBC Owings Mills
Memorial Service
11/21 Ceremonial
Courtroom 5 @ 4pm
National Adoption Day
11/23 Ceremonial
Courtroom 5 @ 10am

Bar Wars Team Trivia
2/26 Barleys Backyard @ 5:00pm
Bar Year Kick-Off Party
9/4 Barley’s Backyard @ 5:00pm
Bar Wars Team Trivia 9/24 Barley’s Backyard @ 5:00pm
Battle of the Beltway Bars Tailgate Party
10/13 Ravens Stadium
Lot H @ 10am Pro Bono Awards & Reception
10/22 PK Law @ 5:00pm Wines Around the World 10/30 CCMD @ 5:30pm
Supreme Court Group Admission Trip
12/4 - full day
Young Lawyers Holiday Lunch 12/6 @ 12pm
Annual Holiday Party
12/11 @ 5:30pm Civics & Law Academy 12/13 CCBC Dundalk
Young Laywers Bull & Oyster Roast 3/23 @ 2pm
Black-Tie Banquet
1/30 Martin’s Valley Mansion @ 6:30pm
Law Day Ceremony
5/1 @ 12pm
Golf Tournament 6/16 Piney Branch Country Club @ 11am
(T) 410-337-9103
(F) 410-823-3418 www.bcba.org
