Best Practices AMAURY MURGADO
WHY THE OODA LOOP IS STILL RELEVANT Understanding the mind’s decision-making process can help you calm down subjects and improve your own reactions.
he OODA loop was created by Air Force colonel John Boyd in the late 1950s. He was a Korean War fighter pilot and a student of combative engagements. Col. Boyd’s understanding of the time-sensitive nature of decision-making based on his experience led him to develop the OODA loop. Once understood, it laid out a winning tactic that helped explain successful fighter pilots and their seemingly enhanced abilities. But it’s not just for fighter pilots. Every law enforcement officer needs to understand the OODA loop because it explains how people act and react in a demanding, evolving, and highly charged situation. This decision-making model can be used to deconstruct verbal and physical confrontations. It also provides a structure for understanding how the mind processes information and takes action in other situations.
consists of four parts: Observe, Orient, Decide, and Act, hence the acronym. In any confrontational situation, you as an officer observe the situation, orient yourself to it by establishing relative positioning, decide what has to be done, and then do it. Any time the situation changes, you have to adapt, and the process starts over again. The decision-making we do in law enforcement is actually a battle for time. The person with the fastest reaction time usually wins. Keep in mind, the bad guy is going through the same process and therefore fighting for the same chunk of time.
VERBAL CONFRONTATIONS There isn’t a day that goes by
PHOTO: TONI BOONE
where officers don’t have to deal with upset people who lash out at the very ones trying to help them. Getting them on track and on a manageable level is paramount to your handing of their problem. WHERE IT CAME FROM By the time you get out of your Boyd studied the aerial comcar, a subject has already made bat outcomes during the Korean most of his decisions. Talking to War and found that even though you is usually the last part of his U.S. pilots flew inferior jets they Every time you move and shoot you are using the OODA loop. OODA loop. This is why it is so difstill beat their adversaries 10-1. ficult to talk to a person when he is Through further research, he was able to decode the process and learn some critical charac- fired up. Simply ordering him to calm down does absolutely teristics about decision-making and reaction time. Boyd no good. He won’t respond the way you want because he is concluded that there were only two ways to beat someone locked in his own loop. You have to break the subject’s conin aerial combat: speed up your decision-making (and thus centration by changing his focus. This starts him on a new reaction time) or slow down theirs. This same principle ap- loop or, at the very least, breaks the one he is on even if only for a brief moment. plies to law enforcement. I was on a call years ago dealing with an out-of-control “he said, she said” domestic disturbance. While dealing with my HOW IT WORKS half, I quickly changed the conversation and asked a question Any time you react you are processing information and making decisions using the OODA loop. The OODA loop about the interior decoration of the living room, focusing on a 14
POLICE JANUARY 2013
For more Best Practices go to www.PoliceMag.com/bestpractices
PHOTO: KEVIN DILLON
beautiful painting. It totally caught the person off guard. It was like seeing someone slamming on the brakes. The woman literally said, “What, huh, what did you just say?” My off-the-wall question was just enough to break her OODA loop and start me down the path to calming her down. In such situations, “yes or no” questions won’t work. You have to ask a question that the person has to think about before The person with the faster answering. My first attempt reaction time usually wins. usually consists of asking a question totally unrelated to the situation. If that doesn’t work, my next question is about something I think means a lot to the subject, like asking about his or her children. You’re not looking to become best friends; you just need to interrupt the person’s OODA loop long enough to get a word in edgewise. Though not 100% successful, it works more times than not.
PHYSICAL CONFRONTATIONS Your job is ultimately about obtaining control of the situation
BLACK EAGLE™ TACTICAL 20 LOW Sporty multi purpose leather shoe based on advanced running technology. > Light, dynamic & multifunctional > Extreme slip resistance
> Highly breathable > Durably waterproof
> Available in low, mid, and high
HOW SHOT S20158 Booth Quality shoes for law enforcement, fire and rescue services, hunting, work wear, and leisure time HAIX® North America Inc. 2320 Fortune Drive, Suite 120, Lexington KY 40509 Phone 859-281-0111, Fax 859-281-0113, Toll free 866-344-HAIX (4249)
even if it requires going hands on. The OODA loop works the same way here. Once a person decides he is going to hit you, he gets locked into his own loop and commits to the action. Any change on your part will make him have to start the decisionmaking process over again. For example, if a person is stepping into you before throwing a punch, you cannot let him set down that lead foot before striking. If he gets to plant his foot you’re going to get hit. You need to make a move that forces the subject to reposition and start his OODA loop over again. Since action beats reaction every time, the guy who keeps forcing the other to change his plans usually keeps the upper hand. This is also where speed comes in. The guy who moves the fastest usually wins the fight. Another example of where this tactic applies is an active shooter scenario. If you are standing across from the shooter and you each draw and then shoot, both of you will probably get hit. But if you move off his centerline, you will cause him to miss (or at least hit you in a less critical spot) because you have made him change his plans, requiring a new round of decision-making. The shooter is now going to have to lift and shift in order to shoot you. That’s why the military lives by the mantra move, shoot, and communicate.
IMPROVING YOUR OODA LOOP
The only way to improve your OODA loop is through training. It’s not something you think about; it’s something you do. Ever wonder why you do the same small number of defensive tactics moves over and over again the entire length of your career? They work in part because of the OODA loop. Because how you train
POLICE JANUARY 2013
is how you fight, you have a handful of techniques you default to under stress. You have worked on them so much you don’t think about it, you just do it. This shortens your OODA loop and increases your reaction time. It’s thinking less and acting more that gives you an advantage. That’s why those who don’t train don’t react well. By the time they finish processing their OODA loop, it’s already too late. Or worse, they make the one and only decision they know and stick to it even if it’s not working. Officers who skip training help increase the bad guy’s ability to steal their response time. The saying “He who hesitates is lost” certainly rings true. Malfunction drills are a great example. When you practice them regularly your movements are as smooth as silk; when you don’t practice, you look like you’ve never done them before. But have you ever watched someone on the range dealing with a malfunction that isn’t a typical stoppage? You usually see the guy keep doing the same thing over and over again until he just stares at his gun wondering what to do. This happens when you don’t have a way to break your own loop. This is why it’s getting more and more common to see people training at police ranges looking left and then right after they shoot. This action is part security check and part breaking their loop. The only way to improve reaction time is to train, train, and then train some more. If skill sets don’t become second nature they act as boat anchors. The THE OODA LOOP more time it takes for you to get into action, the more time ➔ 1. The OODA loop is as you give to the bad guy. relevant today as it was when first developed in the 1950s.
➔ 2. OODA stands for
BEAT THE BATTLE FOR TIME The OODA loop is a form of dy-
namic decision-making that is as easy to understand as it is to apply. It will help you beat ➔ 3. You perform hundreds the battle for time. If you still of OODA loop cycles a don’t see the usefulness of day without realizing it. the OODA loop, perform this ➔ 4. You can either speed up simple drill taught to me by a your reaction time or fellow combatives instructor. slow down theirs. Have a coworker place a ➔ 5. You can apply this small towel on her right shoulconcept to verbal and der. Tell her you are going to physical confrontations. snatch the towel and she has to stop you. Most of the time, she will. After a few tries, tell her to recite her social security number or something else that makes her think. Then have her try to stop you again. You’ll grab hold of the towel each and every time. You win not only because action is faster than reaction, but more importantly, because you are able to divide the person’s attention and therefore successfully change her OODA loop. Observe, Orient, Decide, and Act.
Amaury Murgado is a special operations lieutenant with the Osceola County (Fla.) Sheriff’s Office. He is a retired master sergeant from the Army Reserve, has over 25 years of law enforcement experience, and has been a lifelong student of martial arts.
Choose the University that meets yoU where yoU are. Earning a degree will give you the edge you’re looking for, whether you are starting your career or making your move into management. You can make it happen with Bellevue University’s bachelor’s and master’s degree programs covering the wide spectrum of public safety careers.
Flexible credit transfer policy! If you’ve earned credit from other accredited institutions, we accept that credit toward our degrees – including ALL the credit from your associate’s degree. Some of your professional training may also earn credit!
Secure your share of the American Dream Scholarship!
Apply Today! Classes start year-round. We’re ready when you are.
A non-pro�t university, Bellevue University is accredited by The Higher Learning Commission and a member of the North Central Association of Colleges and Schools • www.ncahlc.org • 800-621-7440 • Bellevue University does not discriminate on the basis of age, race, color, religion, sex, national origin, or disability in the educational programs and activities it operates. Bellevue University, 1000 Galvin Road South, Bellevue, Nebraska 68005. 3416-1112