Program Outcomes Report
2012 - 2013 Evaluators Include:
Gerard Banez, PhD
Program Director, Pediatric Pain Rehabilitation Program The Cleveland Clinic Childrenâ€™s Hospital
Literacy Coach Cleveland Metropolitan School District
Our Mission America SCORES inspires urban youth to lead healthy lives, be engaged students and have the confidence and character to make a difference in the world.
Program Model In the 2012-13 school year, America SCORES Cleveland (SCORES) provided after-school programming for over 500 youth in 10 Cleveland public schools, teaching soccer, creative writing and service-learning to measurably improve fitness, literacy and community engagement. SCORES’ innovative tri-curricular approach effectively demonstrated to young people how physical activity, creativity and teamwork promote a sound body, mind and heart.
As a popular sport requiring minimal equipment, soccer is accessible to children regardless of economic status. Soccer engages youth with their peers in vigorous activity and provides a platform for teaching fitness and nutrition. Youth who play soccer also learn the values of teamwork, sportsmanship and discipline.
Creative thinking promotes problem solving and performing instills public speaking skills. Writing and performing poetry gives youth an outlet to express emotionally charged experiences that may inhibit their ability to perform academically. Creative writing also encourages a personal connection to literature, which deepens classroom engagement.
Volunteerism instills in children a sense of compassion, social responsibility, and personal worth. Through service-learning projects, children develop leadership skills and collaborative experiences at an early age. Youth apply their knowledge to group-selected community projects, which inspires self-efficacy and pride.
Who are Poet-Athletes?
Poet-Athletes are the youth participating in the America SCORES Cleveland program. The term poet-athlete is used to signify the holistic approach SCORES uses to celebrate each participant’s creativity and physical activity.
Elementary school poet-athletes met five days a week for 60-90 minutes each day, for 20 weeks of the school year. Two days per week, poet-athletes met with their Writing Coaches (SCORES-trained school teachers and qualified community members) for creative writing workshops. Three days per week, poetathletes met with their Soccer Coaches (school teachers and qualified community members) for soccer practices and games. Middle school poet-athletes met four days a week for 60-90 minutes each day, for 10 weeks in the spring. Two days per week, poet-athletes met with their Writing Coaches for creative writing workshops and community service activities. Two days per week, poet-athletes met with their Soccer Coaches for soccer practices and games. SCORES united children, teachers, families and community partners with a support system for learning and celebrating youth’s achievements. SCORES met The Ohio Afterschool Network guidelines for providing high quality after-school programming, and all curricula was aligned to State and National Standards in language arts, physical education and service-learning.
2012-2013 Outcomes Report 2
Methods of Assessment America SCORES Cleveland conducts comprehensive evaluations to continually assess the successes and/or needs of the program from poet-athletes, coaches and parents. All assessments and surveys are administered as pre/post measurement unless otherwise noted, and quantifiably measures levels of literacy, fitness, school engagement, self-confidence, leadership skills, cooperation and teamwork, and healthy behaviors and activities. (* Post-only assessments)
Literacy: WRITING ASSESSMENTS: Take place every year in the fall and spring. Poet-athletes are asked to write
a poem or short story on any topic they choose. They must complete their writing within a set time limit and are assessed using a rubric in various categories of writing including ideas, organization, voice, word choice, sentence fluency, presentation and conventions.
Physical Fitness: PACER TEST: This test involves running continuously between two points that are 20 meters apart. These runs are synchronized with a pre-recorded CD which plays beeps at set intervals. As the test proceeds, the interval between each successive beep reduces, forcing the poet-athlete to increase their speed over the course of the test. This Pacer Test has become recognized as one of the most popular and valid tests used to estimate a person’s maximum oxygen uptake, or aerobic fitness. (Aerobic fitness refers to a person’s ability to exercise at low/moderate intensity for a long duration utilizing oxygen for metabolism.)
iSOCCER ASSESSMENT: This is a skill-specific assessment, which evaluates growth in technical abilities that are fundamental to the game of soccer. SCORES currently uses three assessments from the iSoccer Program (www.playisoccer.com).
Surveys*: SELF-EFFICACY ASSESSMENT: Measures a person’s belief about his or her ability and capacity to
accomplish a task or deal with the challenges of life. This term encompasses a person’s ability to succeed across a variety of outcome sets including: academic engagement, physical fitness, sense of belonging and increased self worth. Self-efficacy in each of these areas is assessed through youth, parent and coach surveys. Parents respond to survey questions that focus on their child’s experience in the SCORES program, and Coaches focus on how they perceive that the SCORES program affects students across a variety of outcome sets including: language arts skills, levels of self-confidence, leadership, cooperation and teamwork, and general attitude towards school.
2013-2013 Outcomes Report 3
Youth Participants Demographics Youth Served:
419 48% Male 52% Female 100% of Cleveland Metropolitan School District (CMSD) students are considered economically disadvantaged according to the Ohio Department of Education 2012-2013 School Year Report Card. Therefore, all CMSD students are eligible for the Federal Free Lunch Program.
“My favorite part of America SCORES is being able to work with people and have a team that works together.”
“I love poetry because I can express myself and have fun while doing it.”
— Chayce Lightner, Age 12 (front right) R.G. Jones School in the Puritas-Longmead Neighborhood
“I used to get into a lot of trouble at school. America SCORES has taught me how to express myself without using my fists.” — Treshaun Anderson, Age 13 (left) Willow School in the Slavic Village Neighborhood
— Karter Harris, Age 11 Michael R. White School in the Glenville Neighborhood
“Soccer [is my favorite part of SCORES] because I like to learn and be a better player.”
— McKayla Ayala, Age 8 (left) Artemus Ward School in the Puritas-Longmead Neighborhood
2012-2013 Outcomes Report 4
Literacy Outcomes Paired samples t-tests revealed a statistically reliable difference between pre- and post-season writing and reading assessments.
Writing samples composed by poet-athletes were assessed in the categories of writing including the use of creativity/ideas, voice, mechanics/structure, presentation and use of metaphor and simile. On average, students’ scores improved in each of the following categories: • Voice: 27% • Presentation: 13% • Creativity/Ideas: 20% • Word Choice: 16% • Mechanics/Structure: 14% • Sentence Fluency: 17%
70% of poet-athletes that completed both Pre- and Post-Writing Assessments showed improvement on their total scores.
“I learned that I like writing poems because it brings out the real me.”— A SCORES Poet-Athlete
Student Self-Efficacy Assessment Poet-athletes are given a survey that provides a holistic view of their self in the areas of academic engagement, sense of belonging and increased self worth. •
93% of students said that they try to stay out of trouble and avoid detentions so that they do not miss SCORES.
• 89% of students said that they play sports or exercise more on their own because of the SCORES program. • 95% of students said that they try not to be absent from school because they do not want to miss SCORES.
POET-ATHLETE TESTIMONIALS “I joined SCORES to achieve new goals and make school a better place.”
“This program helps build my confidence and lets me express my feelings.” “I liked working as a team and making a difference in our community.”
2012-2013 Outcomes Report 5
Physical Fitness Outcomes Pacer Test
In Fall 2012, 58% of the elementary school poet-athletes who completed pre- and post- testing demonstrated an improvement in the number of shuttles run. Overall, elementary school poet-athletes achieved a 5% increase in the number of shuttles run from pre-to post-season, with 19% improving their scores by 50% or more.
Program effects on soccer skills were evaluated with iSoccer assessment. In both seasons, poet-athletes at the elementary and middle school levels exhibited improvements in each of the three iSoccer skills evaluated (Toe Taps, Foundations, Wall Passes).
These results suggest improvements in aerobic fitness following program participation in both seasons.
These findings suggest that children were more comfortable with the soccer ball and had better fundamental skills following program participation in both seasons.
Average iSoccer Results
In Spring 2013, 68% of the elementary school poetathletes who completed pre- and post- testing demonstrated an improvement in the number of shuttles run. Overall, elementary poet-athletes achieved a 24% increase in the number of shuttles run from pre- to postseason, with 29% improving their scores by 50% or more. At the middle school level, 56% of the poet-athletes completing both pre- and post- testing demonstrated an improvement in the number of shuttles run. Overall, middle school poet-athletes achieved a 13% increase in the number of shuttles run from pre- to post-season, with 10% improving their scores by 50% or more.
Elementary School Fall 2012
Average iSoccer Results
Average Shuttles Run
Middle School PRE POST
2012-2013 Outcomes Report 6
Survey Outcomes In addition to poet-athletes, America SCORES Cleveland also surveys Coaches, classroom teachers, principals and parents of each participant to measure program benefits and impacts. Indicated below are key outcomes and testimonials from the surveys completed at the end of the fall and spring seasons.
Coach Survey Outcomes
• 96% of coaches believe that the SCORES program helps increase levels of cooperation and teamwork. • 96% of coaches believe that the SCORES program helps students develop leadership skills. • 92% of coaches believe that the SCORES program improves students’ self-confidence.
“The SCORES program helps them form values, teamwork and organization.”
“SCORES gives the students certain leadership skills they wouldn’t have without the program.”
Parent Survey Outcomes •
94% of parents believe that SCORES helps improve their child’s overall academic
performance. • 95% of parents believe that the amount of time their child spends exercising has increased because of SCORES. • 92% of parents believe that the amount of time their child spends reading has increased since joining SCORES. • 92% of parents believe that SCORES has helped increase their child’s self-confidence.
“My daughter has ADHD, so doing extracurricular activities can be a challenge. Now that she is in SCORES, she actually wants to go to school and loves being part of a team.”
“Each and every day my child had a positive story concerning what happened at SCORES that day.”
Principal and Classroom Teacher Survey Outcomes
• 100% of principals and classroom teachers believe that the SCORES program increases students’ levels of self-confidence. • 100% of principals and 94% of classroom teachers believe that the SCORES program increases student’s cooperation and teamwork in the classroom.
PRINCIPAL AND TEACHER TESTIMONIALS
“This program has increased parent involvement at my school and it has also improved the culture and spirit of the building.”
“SCORES provides all participants a greater sense of team and pride. All SCORES students keep up on grades and behavior because they want to participate.”
2012-2013 Outcomes Report 7
America SCORES Cleveland would like to thank the following local and national sponsors who made our program a success during the 2012-2013 school year: WORLD CUP $500,000 + Bestfoods Educational Foundation Corporation for National and Community Service LEAGUE CHAMPIONS $100,000-$249,999 adidas America TEAM CHAMPIONS $50,000-$99,000 Fairmount Minerals Foundation Third Federal Foundation SCORING CHAMPIONS $25,000-$49,999 The Cleveland Foundation
FANS $5,000-$9,999 AXA Advisors Howard & O’Brien Associates, Inc. The United Black Fund of Greater Cleveland SUPPORTERS $2,500-$4,999 Aon Foundation Jones Day KeyBank Foundation Medical Mutual of Ohio NOSHOK, Inc. Ohio Savings Bank RPM International, Inc.
MVPS $10,000-$24,999 The Abington Foundation Eva L. and Joseph M. Bruening Foundation Martha Holden Jennings Foundation MyCom Initiative Nord Family Foundation The Stocker Foundation The Thomas H. White Foundation, a KeyBank Trust U.S. Soccer Foundation
America SCORES Cleveland Board of Directors
F O U N D AT I O N
America SCORES Cleveland Staff
Ruth Coffey (Chair) — Invacare Corporation
Debra Pence-Meyenberg, Executive Director
Michi Eaton (Secretary) — Quanex Building Products
Matthew Williams, Program & Soccer Director
Matthew Milcetich (Treasurer) — KeyBank Silvia Garcia-Luengo — Loparex Meredith Holt - Walgreens Take Care Health System
Paul Khacherian, Education & Evaluation Director Alissa O’Neill, Comm. & Development Associate Allie Cozzone, Program Coordinator
Gregg LaSpisa - AXA Advisors Kristin Lewis — Fairmount Minerals Vikki Meldrum — Communications Professional Laura Mimura — KeyBank John O’Brien — Howard & O’Brien Associates Brian Slife — Aon Rita Tersigni Grabowski — CPA
America SCORES Cleveland 3631 Perkins Ave., Unit 2CE Cleveland, OH 44114 (216) 881-7988 www.AmericaSCORESCleveland.org www.Facebook.com/SCORESCleveland