Issuu on Google+

Consider the statement(oid) ‫ = ڶ‬NO ONE DOES KNOW N IS TRUE [1] THEN ~‫ = ڶ‬SOME DO KNOW N IS TRUE [2] , WHERE N is any statement Let ‫ = ڦ‬SOME DO KNOW N IS TRUE [3] THEN ~‫ = ڦ‬NO ONE DOES KNOW N IS TRUE.[4] FROM THE RIGHT HAND SIDES OF [1] AND [4] ‫ڶ =~ڦ‬ ~ ‫ڦڦڦ=ڶ‬ SAY EQ 6s 5,6 Now let N =‫ ڶ‬IN EQ [1] AND N = ‫ڦ‬IN EQ [3] THIS DO IMPLY THAT N = ~N. SIMILARLY FROM [2] AND [4] ~N = N THIS DOES PROVE THAT IF ‫ = ڶ‬NO ONE DOES KNOW N IS TRUE THEN ‫= ڶ‬/= NO ONE DOES KNOW N IS TRUE SINCE LAWS OF CONTRADICTION AND NON CONTRDICTION BOTH ARE VIOLATED. LAW OF CONTRADICTION ‘ IT IS ABSURD THAT BOTH A AND NOT A ARE TRUE. IJTIMA UN NAQIDAIN. LAW OF NON CONTRADICTION “ IF A IS TRUE THEN NOT A IS FALSE AND IF NOT A IS TRUE THEN A IS FALSE”


refutation of alleged statements of unknowable truth