Global Mountain Sustainability Forum, Sexten/Sesto, 05 October 2020
Dealing with risks in the mountains. Yesterday. Today. Tomorrow? Jakob Rhyner
The hazards
Snow avalanche: Davos
Tottent (unknown location)
Deep-seated landslide: Brienz-Brinzauls Rock avalanche / mud flow: Bondo
Rockfall : Gotthard (highway)
Green energy generation: Zervreila (Switzerland)
A village disappeared Source: Kraftwerke Zervreila
Vals-Zervreila (1911).
Photo: Rudolf Zinggeler
Disaster Risk: 1. Landslide into lake, spill over around 25 fatalities 2. Damage to dam, rapid discharge around 1‘500 fatalities
cf. From Gefährdungsanalyse Kanton Graubünden, (public)
4
Dealing with with risks in the 13th century:
the Schöllenen bridge
Picture by Roland Zumbühl
Teufelsbrücke
Schöllenen gorge The first user…
Source: Denkmalpflege Schweiz
Teufelsstein
5
Early efforts to reduce avalanche risks (14th century) Picture by Roland ZumbĂźhl
Bannwald Andermatt 6
17th/18 century - religious connotations J. L Bleuler (1792-1850 )
Picture by Roland ZumbĂźhl
7
Traversing the Alps in the 18th century Stellenweise musste auch durch eine kleine Lawine erst ein Hohlweg gegraben oder eine grössere im Bogen umfahren werden. In some places, one had first to dig hollow path through a small avalanche or drive around a larger one. Ernst Haeckel Als die gefährlichsten Stellen des Herabstieges, das durch die vielen Lawinenstürze berüchtigte wilde und düstere Val Tremola, wo im vorigen Jahre eine Lawine einen Postschlittenzug mit 45 Menschen in den Tiefen des Abgrundes begraben hatte, erst vorüber waren, ging es nun vollends mit lustiger Geschwindigkeit weiter.
When the most dangerous parts of the descent, the wild and gloomy Val Tremola, notorious for its many avalanche chutes, where last year an avalanche had buried a post sleigh with 45 people in the depths of the abyss, had only just passed, the journey continued at a fun speed.
8
19th century - first scientific-technical attempts Johann Coaz Vallascia TI
Johan Coaz (1822-1918)
Dry stone walls • Effective small/medium avalanches with average snow height • With their decay the are turning into a rockfall risk! • Partly protected as cultural heritage
Source: hochparterre 9
20th century – systematic hazard and risk research
WSL Institute for Snow and Avalanche Research SLF, Davos Founded 1936
10
Modern avalanche defense measures
Männlichen
11
Hazard maps – supported by avalanche flow modelling Local experience combined with expert knowledge by engineers Since around 15 years: strong support by GIS-based modelling RAMMS - Rapid Mass Movement Simulation P. Bartelt et al. Swiss Snow and Avalanche Research Institute (SLF), Davos • snow avalanche • mud flow, • rock fall / avalanche https://www.slf.ch/en/services-and-products/ramms-rapid-massmovement-simulation.html
permanent post-event verification!
European cooperation – the ToDos LACRUX.COM Klettermagazin, 25 December 2019 Wir stehen zu dritt auf der Dreiländerspitze in der Silvretta. Einer von uns in Tirol, einer in Vorarlberg, einer in Graubünden. Wir befinden uns in zwei verschiedenen Staaten in drei verschiedenen Verwaltungszonen. Je nachdem in welche Richtung wir abfahren, gilt eine andere Lawinenprognose. Das SLF in der Schweiz spricht von einer Gefahrenstufe Eins, der Lawinenwarndienst Vorarlberg von einem Zweier und die Tiroler geben gar einen Dreier aus. The three of us are standing on the three-country peak in the Silvretta. One of us in Tyrol, one in Vorarlberg, one in Graubünden. We are in two different states in three different administrative zones. Depending on the direction in which we descend, a different avalanche forecast applies. The SLF in Switzerland speaks of a danger level one, the avalanche warning service Vorarlberg of a two and the Tyroleans even issue a three.
Avalanche fatalities during the last decades (Switzerland)
Source: SLF Davos
https://www.slf.ch/en/avalanches/destructive-avalanches-and-avalanche-accidents/long-term-statistics.html
14
When and how did progress occur? Floods 1800
1820
1840
1860
1880
1900
1920
1940
1960
1980
12
1800
1800
1820
1840
1860
2000
3
1880
1900
1
1920
1940
2
1960
1980
3
4
2000
Avalanches
2005
4
1.
River and forest legislation
1.
First avalanche defence structures
2.
1880: River management
2.
Foundation SLF Davos
3.
Systematic hazard mapping
3.
4.
Warning systems (GIN)
1951: Massive defence programme (1.5 Bill CHF so far!) und upgrade warning systems, end 50ies : 1st model hazard maps
4.
Comprehensive early warning system IMIS-IFKIS
15
Integrated Risk Management (IRM) Defense barriers
Deflection dams
Hazard maps Warning Closure Evacuation Choice of measure combination adapted to situation ďƒ Integrated Risk Management
16
Conceptualization of IRM Recovery
Reconstruction Insurance Mitigation of indirect consequences
Prevention Land use planning Technical measures Biological measures
Risk cycle
Intervention Forecast and Warning Evacuation Closure
Risk
i : object j : scenario
Ri,j = pj . Pi,j . Ai . Vi,j . i,j
Probability of scenario
Exposition
Damage Potential
Risk Aversion Vulnerability 17
Marginal cost approach
Marginal costs
willingness to pay !
18
Protection targets Risk Category
Category 1
100 % voluntary (High risk sports)
Category 2
high degree of voluntariness
Category 3
low degree of voluntariness
Category 3
100 % involuntary (settlement areas)
Individual Risk
Collective Risk
Material damage
Max. Value of risks of death per year
Max. marginal costs per 1 saved life per year (Mio. CHF)
Max. ratio of cost of measures and cost of damage
10-2 - 10-3
1-2
1
10-3 - 2·10-4
2-5
1
2·10-4
3·10-5
-
5 - 10
3
3·10-5 - 4·10-6
10 - 20
4
Source: PLANAT Strategie Naturgefahren Schweiz Synthesebericht 2003
Protection targets – policy implemenation (Canton Bern)
1.1 Explanation of the risk strategy of the Canton of Bern of 2005In the risk strategy of the Canton of Berne, the government on August 24, 2005 adopted: -
The individual risk of death due to gravitational natural hazard processes must not increase than 10-5 to 10-6 per year.
-
If the prevention of a death by protective measures is less than CHF 5 million the measure should be implemented.
Looking into the future It’s difficult to make predictions, especially about the future (assigned to a couple of famous people, including Niels Bohr)
21
Connectedness - influence from to the mountain side and from the lowlands Energy
Tourism
Source: NOAA
Source: NOAA
Hazard risk, rising snow line
Unsteady water supply due to melting glaciers
Dynamics of tourism market(s)
„Greening“ energy market
Safe, green and attractive summer tourism
Supply of peak energy, pump storage 22
Climate impacts – overload from „steady weather“
Source: NOAA
Rossby wave
Source: südostschweiz
Forcella / Arvigo, 05 March 2014 (S. Schneiderbauer et al. Beyond the Expected - Dealing with Cases of Overload and the Residual Risk of Natural Hazards in the Alpine Region) 23
Innovative summer tourism - dealing with melting
Triftgletscher 1948 and 2006. Source:‚Die Alpen‘ Issue 07/2014.
2009
24
Good risk management is sustainable Good sustainability management is risky
Thank you for your attention! 25
HunsrĂźck-Geierlay. Source: mosel 2.0
Kontakt Office of the Bonner Allianz für Nachhaltigkeitsforschung Prof. Dr. Jakob Rhyner | Wiss. Director | 0228 73 4973 |rhyner@uni-bonn.de Sandra Gilgan | Geschäftsführerin | 0228 73 60594 | s.gilgan@uni-bonn.de Una Kliemann | Projektmanagerin | 0228 73 60615 | u.kliemann@uni-bonn.de www.bonn-alliance.uni-bonn.de