Z3 PORTFOLIO
EXCLUSIVITY LISTED BY JORDAN DICKMAN
First Vice President of Investments 513-878-7735 jordan.dickman@marcusmillichap.com
NICK ANDREWS
First Vice President of Investments 513-878-7741 nick.andrews@marcusmillichap.com
AUSTIN SUM
Senior Associate 513-878-7747 austin.sum@marcusmillichap.com
2
ADG MULTIFAMILY
CONFIDENTIALITY & DISCLAIMER The information contained in the following offering memorandum is proprietary and strictly confidential. It is intended to be reviewed only by the party receiving it from Marcus & Millichap and it should not be made available to any other person or entity without the written consent of Marcus & Millichap. By taking possession of and reviewing the information contained herein the recipient agrees to hold and treat all such information in the strictest confidence. The recipient further agrees that recipient will not photocopy or duplicate any part of the offering memorandum. If you have no interest in the subject property, please promptly return this offering memorandum to Marcus & Millichap. This offering memorandum has been prepared to provide summary, unverified financial and physical information to prospective purchasers, and to establish only a preliminary level of interest in the subject property. The information contained herein is not a substitute for a thorough due diligence investigation. Marcus & Millichap has not made any investigation, and makes no warranty or representation with respect to the income or expenses for the subject property, the future projected financial performance of the property, the size and square footage of the property and improvements, the presence of absence of contaminating substances, PCBs or asbestos, the compliance with local, state and federal regulations, the physical condition of the improvements thereon, or financial condition or business prospects of any tenant, or any tenant’s plans or intentions to continue its occupancy of the subject property. The information contained in this offering memorandum has been obtained from sources we believe reliable; however, Marcus & Millichap has not verified, and will not verify, any of the information contained herein, nor has Marcus & Millichap conducted any investigation regarding these matters and makes no warranty or representation whatsoever regarding the accuracy or completeness of the information provided. All potential buyers must take appropriate measures to verify all of the information set forth herein. Prospective buyers shall be responsible for their costs and expenses of investigating the subject property.
PROPERTY SHOWINGS ARE BY APPOINTMENT ONLY. PLEASE CONTACT ANDREWS | DICKMAN FOR MORE DETAILS.
ADG MULTIFAMILY
3
4
ADG MULTIFAMILY
the table of
CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
00
C I N C I N N AT I OVERVIEW
01
WESTSIDE
02
page
8
page
18
page
28
R O S E L AW N
03
page
54
ADG MULTIFAMILY
5
6
ADG MULTIFAMILY
CALABASAS, CALIFORNIA | HQ
80+ | OFFICES
2,500 | EMPLOYEES
UNRIVALED SUCCESS IN THE MIDWEST Nick Andrews
First Vice President Investments Director, NMHG
Jordan Dickman
First Vice President Investments Director, NMHG
INVESTMENT ADVISORS
Austin Sum
Senior Investment Associate
Garry Schloemer Investment Associate
JD Schmerge Investment Associate
Brian Johnston
Tim VanWingerden
Investment Associate
Investment Associate
DEBT & STRUCTURED FINANCE
Chris Litzler
Jim Leonard
Senior Director MMCC
Senior Managing Director of Capital Markets MMCC
CLIENT RELATIONS
VALUATION & RESEARCH
Sam Petrosino
Jennifer Bauer
Financial & Research Analyst
Client Relationship Coordinator
OPERATIONS & MARKETING
Brittany Campbell-Koch Director of Operations
Josh Caruana
Vice President Regional Manager Indianapolis | Cincinnati | Louisville St Louis | Kansas City
Kristin Smith Marketing
Alex Papa
Marketing Coordinator
John Sebree
Sidney Bills
Office Administrator
Senior Vice President National Director National Multi Housing Group
Liz Popp
Midwest Operations Manager
Michael Glass
Senior Vice President Midwest Division Manager National Director, Manufactured Home Communities Group
ADG MULTIFAMILY
7
8
ADG MULTIFAMILY
Z3 PORTFOLIO
00 section
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY summary - 10 strength in numbers - 12 unix mix - 14 breakdown - 16 ADG MULTIFAMILY
9
LAROSE PLACE
WYOMING CROSSING EAGLE WATCH
10
ADG MULTIFAMILY
CINCINNATI, OHIO
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Z3 PORTFOLIO. 353
UNITS
1,481,603 PORTFOLIO NOI
96%
AVERAGE OCCUPANCY
883
AVERAGE UNITS SQFT
.88
AVERAGE RENT PER SQFT
ADG MULTIFAMILY
11
Z3 PORTFOLIO
STRENGTH IN NUMBERS Marcus & Millichap is pleased to present The Z3 Portfolio, 353 units of apartment living across 3 assets in the desirable Cincinnati. The portfolio provides the investor a hardto-find opportunity with phenomenal potential due to its solid submarket fundamentals, top-notch employment, high demand, and market proven rental upside in each of the markets. Fundamentals of the portfolio are unmatched as it outperformed the rest of the market through 2020.
*See repected executive summary pages for debt information*
12
ADG MULTIFAMILY
STRONG STABILIZATION • Z3 portfolio boasts an average of 6% physical vacancy factor on the trailing 12 months across all three assets.
CONSISTENT COLLECTIONS • Z3 shows a 98% collection rate through 2020, one of the most trying years for apartment properties to ever endure.
MARKET PROVEN RENTS • Average rents on the portfolio are anywhere from 5-7% below market competition, a clear path to increasing value through organic rental appreciation.
RUNWAY FOR RENTAL GROWTH
• The average rent across the portfolio comes in at $0.88 per square foot while the average rent per square foot across the metros is $1.07.
STRONG MARKET FUNDAMENTALS
• Z3 Portfolio gives and incoming investor the opportunity to invest in one of the top ten most COVID resilient markets in the nation.
HIGH BARRIER TO ENTRY
• With low inventory velocity through most of the markets the portfolio is in, this gives an incoming investor the ability to build immediate scale to reduce operation costs over 353 units
FAVORABLE UNIT MIX • Z3 Portfolio offers a very attractive unit mix of over 80% two and three bed unit layouts maximizing Gross Potential Rent opportunity for an incoming investor.
ADG MULTIFAMILY
13
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Z3 PORTFOLIO IN DETAIL
1
BEDROOM 61 Units 35,857 SF
14
ADG MULTIFAMILY
2
BEDROOM 244 Units 221,320 SF
3
BEDROOM 48 Units 54,432 SF
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY UNIT MIX SUMMARY
PROJECTED
MARKET
AVERAGE EFFECTIVE
Rentable
Total
Units
SF
SF
One Bedroom
61 Units
588 SF
35,857 SF
$623.67
$1.06
$38,044
$663.88
$1.13 SF
$40,497
$698.00
$1.19 SF
$42,578
Two Bedroom
244 Units
907 SF
221,320 SF
$778.74
$0.86
$190,014
$810.03
$0.89 SF
$197,648
$842.95
$0.93 SF
$205,680
Three Bedroom
48 Units
1,134 SF
54,432 SF
$943.84
$0.83
$45,304
$980.00
$0.86 SF
$47,040
$1,056.25
$0.93 SF
$50,700
Totals / Wtd. Averages
353 Units
883 SF
311,609 SF
$774.40
$0.88 SF
$273,362
$807.89
$0.92 SF
$285,185
$846.91
$0.96 SF
$298,958
Unit Type
Total Rent Rent/Unit Rent/SF
Potential
Total Rent Rent/Unit Rent/SF
Potential
Total Rent Rent/Unit Rent/SF
Potential
Summary
ADG MULTIFAMILY
15
Year 1
(Rent Roll/T12 Income)
INCOME EXPENSES
FINANCIAL BREAKDOWN
Current GROSS POTENTIAL RENT
(Recapture LTL, Stabilized Occupancy and Other Income, Normalized Expenses)
% of GPR
Per Unit
% of GPR
Per Unit
4.94%
9,695 (479) 9,216
$3,587,494 ($71,750) $3,515,744
2.00%
10,163 (203) 9,960
All Units at Market Rent Gain (Loss) to Lease GROSS SCHEDULED RENT Other Income Other Income Total Other Income
$3,422,220 ($169,030) $3,253,190
T12 T12
$27,613 $64,422
T12
0.85% 1.98%
78 182
$28,947 $67,534
0.82% 1.92%
82 191
GROSS POTENTIAL INCOME Physical Vacancy Employee Units Bad Debt Concessions Allowance EFFECTIVE GROSS INCOME
$3,317,612 ($214,802) ($22,969) ($75,986) ($39,620) $2,964,235
T12 T12 T12 T12
6.60% 0.71% 2.34% 1.22% 84.20%
9,398 (609) (65) (215) (112) 8,397
$3,583,278 ($175,787) $0 ($35,157) ($17,579) $3,354,754
5.00% 0.00% 1.00% 0.50% 91.50%
10,151 (498) 0 (100) (50) 9,504
% of EGI 4.46% 0.00% 4.46% 3.90%
Per Unit 374 0 374 327
$132,118 $0 $132,118 $114,725
% of EGI 3.94% 0.00% 3.94% 3.42%
Per Unit 374 0 374 325
Non-Controllable Real Estate Taxes 2019 Taxes Paid Adjustment for Sale Total Real Estate Taxes Insurance Utilities Electric Electric Vacant Gas Water & Sewage Trash Removal Total Utilities Total Non-Controllable Controllable Contract Services Snow Removal Landscaping/Grounds Pest Control Total Contract Services Repairs & Maintenance Marketing & Promotion On-Site Payroll Payroll Taxes & Benefits General & Administrative Management Fee Telephone & Cable Replacement & Reserves Total Controllable
$132,118 $0 $132,118 $115,476
Auditor
$23,265 $11,021 $65,823 $281,893 $56,570 $438,572 $686,166
T12 T12 T12 T12 T12 T12
0.78% 0.37% 2.22% 9.51% 1.91% 14.80% 23.15%
66 31 186 799 160 1,242 1,944
$23,730 $11,241 $67,139 $287,531 $57,701 $447,343 $694,186
0.71% 0.34% 2.00% 8.57% 1.72% 13.33% 20.69%
67 32 190 815 163 1,267 1,967
$13,309 $21,197 $17,047 $51,553
T12 T12 T12
0.45% 0.72% 0.58% 1.74%
38 60 48 146
$12,355 $35,300 $12,355 $60,010
0.37% 1.05% 0.37% 1.79%
35 100 35 170
$75,567 $280 $352,654 $46,083 $53,602 $118,569 $8,143 $90,015 $796,466
T12 T12 T12 T12 T12
2.55% 0.01% 11.90% 1.55% 1.81% 4.00% 0.27% 3.04% 26.87%
214 1 999 131 152 336 23 255 2,256
$194,150 $26,475 $317,700 $52,950 $52,950 $134,190 $12,355 $91,815 $942,595
5.79% 0.79% 9.47% 1.58% 1.58% 4.00% 0.37% 2.74% 28.10%
550 75 900 150 150 380 35 260 2,670
T12
T12
TOTAL EXPENSES
$1,482,632
50.02%
4,200
$1,636,782
48.79%
4,637
NET OPERATING INCOME
$1,481,603
49.98%
4,197
$1,717,973
51.21%
4,867
Year 2
Year 3
(...Stabilized Occupancy) % of GPR
Per Unit
% of GPR
Per Unit
$3,695,119 ($73,902) $3,621,217
2.00%
10,468 (209) 10,258
$3,805,973 ($76,119) $3,729,853
2.00%
10,782 (216) 10,566
$29,815 $69,560
0.82% 1.92%
84 197
$30,709 $71,646
0.82% 1.92%
87 203
$3,690,776 ($181,061) $0 ($36,212) ($18,106) $3,455,397
5.00% 0.00% 1.00% 0.50% 91.50%
10,455 (513) 0 (103) (51) 9,789
$3,801,499 ($186,493) $0 ($37,299) ($18,649) $3,559,059
5.00% 0.00% 1.00% 0.50% 91.50%
10,769 (528) 0 (106) (53) 10,082
$132,118 $0 $132,118 $117,020
% of EGI 3.82% 0.00% 3.82% 3.39%
Per Unit 374 0 374 332
$132,118 $0 $132,118 $119,360
% of EGI 3.82% 0.00% 3.82% 3.45%
Per Unit 374 0 374 338
$24,205 $11,466 $68,482 $293,281 $58,855 $456,290 $705,428
0.70% 0.33% 1.98% 8.49% 1.70% 13.21% 20.42%
69 32 194 831 167 1,293 1,998
$24,689 $11,696 $69,852 $299,147 $60,033 $465,416 $716,894
0.71% 0.34% 2.02% 8.66% 1.74% 13.47% 20.75%
70 33 198 847 170 1,318 2,031
$12,602 $36,006 $12,602 $61,210
0.36% 1.04% 0.36% 1.77%
36 102 36 173
$12,854 $36,726 $12,854 $62,434
0.37% 1.06% 0.37% 1.81%
36 104 36 177
$198,033 $27,005 $324,054 $54,009 $54,009 $138,216 $12,602 $93,652 $962,789
5.73% 0.78% 9.38% 1.56% 1.56% 4.00% 0.36% 2.71% 27.86%
561 77 918 153 153 392 36 265 2,727
$201,994 $27,545 $330,535 $55,089 $55,089 $142,362 $12,854 $95,525 $983,427
5.85% 0.80% 9.57% 1.59% 1.59% 4.00% 0.37% 2.76% 28.34%
572 78 936 156 156 392 36 271 2,774
$1,668,217
48.28%
4,726
$1,700,321
49.21%
4,817
$1,787,180
51.72%
5,063
$1,858,738
53.79%
5,266
ADG MULTIFAMILY
17
18
ADG MULTIFAMILY
Z3 PORTFOLIO
01 section
CINCINNATI OVERVIEW cincinnati overview - 20 world class employment - 22
ADG MULTIFAMILY
19
OVERVIEW
CINCINNATI, OH The steady and stable nature of the Cincinnati apartment market was undoubtfully a benefit through 2020. The MSA saw a 2.7% annual increase in effective asking rents on new leases which matched the market’s norm for the 2010s decade. This growth put Cincinnati at #14 amongst the 50 largest markets for rent growth in 2020. Although occupancy was down 0.3 points from the prior year’s rate, the 4th quarter 2020 occupancy rate (96.4%) ranked #11 among the top 50 markets and #3 regionally. Only Q1 2020 saw net move-outs, although that’s typically the case in the local market due to seasonal demand patterns, the three subsequent quarters saw huge demand and absorption totaled 1,563 units. That is 38% above the 20-year norm for annual absorption. During the peak of the pandemic challenges the job market declined 4.6%, this ranked Cincinnati 3rd best among the Midwest and was significantly better than the national average of 5.8%.
DEMOGRAPHICS Population: 2,190,000 Median age: 38 MSA median HHI: $62,743 1.77% 1 - year growth
MSA median home value: $173,500 4.83% 1 - year growth 20
ADG MULTIFAMILY
Total units in MSA: 162,761 2020 deliveries: 2,231
Average occupany: 96.4%
occuany growth: -.03% Average rent in 2020: $1,022 rent growth: 2.7%
ECONOMIC OVERVIEW Prior to the pandemic, Cincinnati’s economy grew at a moderate rate – averaging an estimated growth pace of 2.1% annually in the five years ending Q1 2020. However, the economy contracted 2.4% in 2020. By November of 2020 the pandemic induced the loss of 51,200 jobs putting the employment rate at 4.8%, below the national average of 6.4%. Cincinnati has experienced less severe economic impacts compared to other cities, this fact is credited to the divers and stable employers that call Cincinnati home. There are eight fortune 500 companies headquartered in Cincinnati: Kroger, Procter & Gamble, Fifth Third Bancorp, American Financial Group, Cincinnati Financial, Western & Southern Financial Group, Cintas & Ak Steel Holding. In addition to the nationally recognized powerhouse corporations, Cincinnati has placed a specific focus on programs to foster and promote entrepreneurs and start-ups. Also the city has made significant investments in facilities and infrastructure to support medical research, and other scientific innovations to attract and retain talent found at the University of Cincinnati. The Innovation Corridor by Uptown Consortium is the largest single development in Cincinnati since the Great American Ball Park and will be a state-of-the-art science and research hub next to UC.
DEMOGRAPHIC OVERVIEW Population growth in Cincinnati remains modest, as the metro’s population expanded just 2.5% from 2014-2019, below the U.S. average of 2.9%. During that period the majority of Cincinnati’s growth came from the 55+ age segment which grew 11.5%. The 20-to 34-year-old segment grew modestly over the five-year period increasing 2.1% which was above the national average of 1.6%. A very strong aspect to Cincinnati’s population is the level of education amongst the working age population with 37% of that segment having a bachelor’s degree or higher compared to the national average of 33.1%. The modest population growth coupled with a modest pipeline has maintained occupancies between 95%-97% over the last six years with the average occupancy in Q4 of 2020 being above the six year average at 96.4%. The average effective asking rents have outperformed the Midwest averages since 2011 and in 2020 the average effective rents grew by 2.7% outpacing the Midwest average of 0.8% and the national average of -1.1%.
ADG MULTIFAMILY
21
CINCINNATI
WORLD CLASS EMPLOYMENT
(1 of 3)
In 2017, Amazon announced that is was investing $1.49 billion to create the retail titain’s first air cargo hub for packages. The company is clearing about 920 acres at The Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky International Airport (CVG). Judge-executive Gary Moore says that it will not only be the largest building in Boone County, it will also be the largest in this party of the country. Currently, CVG is the largest cargo hub airport in the nation without the new Amazon Hub. The project broke ground in May 2019 and will be completed in 2021.
22
OPENING SF INVESTMENT
2021 3M $1.5B
Jobs Created
2,000+
ADG MULTIFAMILY
“We’re going to move Prime from twoday to one-day, and this hub is a big part of that.” Jeff Bezos, Founder & CEO, Amazon
ANDREW J BRADY ICON MUSIC CENTER
Unique in design and capacity, the $27 million sate-of-the-art Andrew J. Brady ICON Music Center is set to open fall 2021 and will be unparalleled to any other music venue in the region. It is being designed to fill Cincinnati’s need for a year-round, flexible music venue. The ICON’s maximum capacity is much larger than any other indoor venue of its kind in the area. MEMI is developing the venue to feature both indoor and outdoor stages and seating. The indoor venue has a capcity of 4,500 and the outdoor area has a capacity of 8,000.
OPENING Maximum Capacity Investment Events Hosted Annually
2021 12,500 $27M 170
ADG MULTIFAMILY
23
CINCINNATI
WORLD CLASS EMPLOYMENT 1
(2 of 3)
ICON MUSIC CENTER | 25 Race Street Unique in design and capacity, the $27 million state-of-the-art Andrew J. Brady ICON Music Center is set to open in early 2021 and will be unparalleled to any other music venue in the region. Designed to fill the community’s need for a yearround, flexible music venue, the ICON will feature a general admission main floor and two balconies and will be able to host multiple configurations for indoor concerts up to 4,500 capacity, all year long. With an adjustable capacity, the new venue will allow for intimate, connected experiences between fans, their favorite artists and their peers. The ICON’s maximum capacity is significantly larger than any other indoor performance venue of its type in the region.
27M
state of the art 24
ADG MULTIFAMILY
4,500 capacity
2021 open
2
THE FOUNDRY | 505 Vine Street 3CDC plans to move ahead with the conversion of the 3.5-story, 200,000-square-foot building that was home to a Macy’s department store. The property will be transformed into the Foundry, a mixeduse building with about 150,000 square feet of office and 35,000 square feet of retail/restaurant space. The total investment for the project is expected to be about $50.8 million.
51M 150,000 35,000 investment
office space
retail space
ADG MULTIFAMILY
25
CINCINNATI
WORLD CLASS EMPLOYMENT 3
(3 of 3)
INGALLS BUILDING | 6 East 4th Street SREE Hotels LLC, a Charlotte-based hotel owner and management company, purchased the building back in 2018. While the team from SSRG manage the concrete upgrades, SREE has been working on plans to convert the former office building into a 126-room, Courtyard by Marriot hotel. The firm plans to maintain the historical feeling of the lower levels while transforming them into a lounge, bar and a grab-and-go station as well as meeting rooms, public spaces and a library. The rest of the building will be converted into hotel rooms.
26
ADG MULTIFAMILY
4
KIMPTON HOTEL | 432 Walnut Street The boutique hotel, which is expected to include a restaurant, fitness center and rooftop bar, would employ 116 and have the capacity to serve 55,000 room nights per year, generating more than $15 million in annual revenue.
116
NEW JOBS
28
ADG MULTIFAMILY
Z3 PORTFOLIO WESTSIDE
02 section
westside overview - 30 westside projects - 32 eagle watch overview - 36 wyoming overview - 38 the competitive set - 40 financials - 46
ADG MULTIFAMILY
29
OVERVIEW
WESTSIDE The steady and stable nature of the Cincinnati apartment market was undoubtfully a benefit through 2020. The MSA saw a 2.7% annual increase in effective asking rents on new leases which matched the market’s norm for the 2010s decade. This growth put Cincinnati at #14 amongst the 50 largest markets for rent growth in 2020. Although occupancy was down 0.3 points from the prior year’s rate, the 4th quarter 2020 occupancy rate (96.4%) ranked #11 among the top 50 markets and #3 regionally. Only Q1 2020 saw net move-outs, although that’s typically the case in the local market due to seasonal demand patterns, the three subsequent quarters saw huge demand and absorption totaled 1,563 units. That is 38% above the 20-year norm for annual absorption. During the peak of the pandemic challenges the job market declined 4.6%, this ranked Cincinnati 3rd best among the Midwest and was significantly better than the national average of 5.8%.
DEMOGRAPHICS Population: 24,893 Median age: 35 MSA median HHI: $48,432 MSA median home value: $117,650
30
ADG MULTIFAMILY
Total units in MSA: 11,736 Average occupany: 89% Average rent in 2020: $900
ECONOMIC OVERVIEW Prior to the pandemic, Cincinnati’s economy grew at a moderate rate – averaging an estimated growth pace of 2.1% annually in the five years ending Q1 2020. However, the economy contracted 2.4% in 2020. By November of 2020 the pandemic induced the loss of 51,200 jobs putting the employment rate at 4.8%, below the national average of 6.4%. Cincinnati has experienced less severe economic impacts compared to other cities, this fact is credited to the divers and stable employers that call Cincinnati home. There are eight fortune 500 companies headquartered in Cincinnati: Kroger, Procter & Gamble, Fifth Third Bancorp, American Financial Group, Cincinnati Financial, Western & Southern Financial Group, Cintas & Ak Steel Holding.
SNAPSHOT
8 2%
Fortune 500 Companies Cincinnati Growth Pace
DEMOGRAPHIC OVERVIEW Population growth in Cincinnati remains modest, as the metro’s population expanded just 2.5% from 2014-2019, below the U.S. average of 2.9%. During that period the majority of Cincinnati’s growth came from the 55+ age segment which grew 11.5%. The 20-to 34-year-old segment grew modestly over the five-year period increasing 2.1% which was above the national average of 1.6%. A very strong aspect to Cincinnati’s population is the level of education amongst the working age population with 37% of that segment having a bachelor’s degree or higher compared to the national average of 33.1%. The modest population growth coupled with a modest pipeline has maintained occupancies between 95%-97% over the last six years with the average occupancy in Q4 of 2020 being above the six year average at 96.4%. The average effective asking rents have outperformed the Midwest averages since 2011 and in 2020 the average effective rents grew by 2.7% outpacing the Midwest average of 0.8% and the national average of -1.1%.
ADG MULTIFAMILY
31
LOCAL OVERVIEW
WESTSIDE
LICK RUN PROJECT
$110
Million Project
The Lick Run Water Way is a $110 million project spanning nearly 2 miles between Queen City Ave and Westwood Ave. The project will more efficiently manage storm water runoff and provides the community with recreational parks and green space. The project not only better addresses stormwater run off, but also beautifies the nearly 2 mile strip lined with retail and residential properties attracting more visitors to the area. The development is the single largest public investment into north Fairmont, and has smaller like kind projects in Price Hill and Westwood. All of the projects were put in place to better manage stormwater runoff and replace dated systems with astatically pleasing and efficient solutions.
32
ADG MULTIFAMILY
DELHI TOWNSHIP MIXED USE PROJECT The 14 acre site commonly called the Remke site located on Delhi Pike was purchased by the Delhi Township in 2019 and has been identified as the location for the new Delhi Mixed Use Project. The multi phase development will revitalize the Delhi Pike Commercial Corridor creating a more walkable and economically diverse hub for the community. Some of the notable project aspects are a community center, co-op business spaces, market rate and affordable rental units, as well as ground floor retail with green space and safer traffic flow. The final bids and details from developers are being reviewed through the summer with the goal to have a finalized plan by the fall of 2021.
ADG MULTIFAMILY
33
LOCAL OVERVIEW
WESTSIDE
$250 26,000
Million Project
TQL MAJOR LEAGUE SOCCER STADIUM
Seats
FC Cincinnati and their fans finally have a stadium to match their caliber of play and enthusiasm. The stadium was completed in May 2021, can hold 26,000 spectators and cost a total of $250 million. Located in the West End neighborhood, the stadium draws tens of thousands of fans weekly from April to November in addition to the other events hosted there out side of the MLS season. Of the three location options being decided between, the West End was selected due to the numerous economic benefits that would stem from the stadium’s present.
34
ADG MULTIFAMILY
$16 143,000
Million Project
HISTORIC MERCY HIGH SCHOOL RENOVATION
SQFT
Cincinnati Public Schools recently received the 2021 ASHRAE Technology Award of Engineering Excellence for the renovation that converted the former all-girls Mercy High School in Westwood off Werk Rd. into Gamble Montessori High School. CPS was able to modernize the space and systems for the 100 year old historic land mark at half the cost and half the time an equivalent ground up development would have cost and taken. The renovation cost $16 million and updated roughly 143,000 square feet of space.
ADG MULTIFAMILY
35
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
EAGLE WATCH IN DETAIL
1
BED | 1 BATH 16 Units 547 Avg SF $699 RENT
2
BED | 2 BATH 80 Units 888 Avg SF $799 RENT
LENDER: FANNIE MAE | LOAN CLOSE DATE: 10/30/20 LOAN TERM: 12 YEARS | LOAN BALANCE: $3,861,000 INTEREST RATE: 3.40% | REMAINING IO PERIOD: 50 (MONTHS)
79,792 SF 1971 YEAR BUILT 831 AVERAGE UNIT SIZE $782 AVERAGE RENT 95% OCCUPANCY 36
ADG MULTIFAMILY
INVESTMENT HIGHLIGHTS Marcus & Millichap is pleased to present Eagle Watch and Wyoming Crossing, each consisting of 96 units of apartment living located in Western Cincinnati only two minutes from one another and ten minutes from downtown teeming with top notch employment. Located in the submarket of Westwood, these properties provide a very favorable unit mix of two-bedroom layouts and competitive rental rates in a city full of strong market fundamentals.
Strong Demand for Housing: • Current ownership has taken advantage of constrained housing need from the city’s section 8 program, leading to a higher-than-average market rent across the property. This is a government funded program which gives new ownership comfort in not only strong rental rates, but strong collections as well. There is a decreasing supply and increasing demand for section 8 living in Cincinnati and that spread only continues to grow year over year, producing higher than market rents for these types of assets
Favorable Unit Mix: • Both assets provide a favorable unit mix boasting 85% of the units being two-bedroom layouts increasing the GPR opportunity for incoming investors.
City Investments into the submarket: • The City of Cincinnati’s targeted public investment in the area has drastically increased following the Lick run project which has already begun to move a tremendous volume of money and activity into the local submarket. Upon completion we expect to see an increase in tenant move-ins in an already high occupancy market leading to continued rental growth.
ADG MULTIFAMILY
37
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
WYOMING CROSSING IN DETAIL
1
BED | 1 BATH 12 Units 716 Avg SF $699 RENT
2
BED | 1 BATH 84 Units 850 Avg SF $802 RENT
LENDER: FANNIE MAE | LOAN CLOSE DATE: 10/31/20 LOAN TERM: 10 YEARS | LOAN BALANCE: $4,446,000 INTEREST RATE: 3.26% | REMAINING IO PERIOD: 50 (MONTHS)
79,992 SF1967YEAR BUILT 833 AVERAGE UNIT SIZE $789 AVERAGE RENT 92% OCCUPANCY 38
ADG MULTIFAMILY
INVESTMENT HIGHLIGHTS Marcus & Millichap is pleased to present Eagle Watch and Wyoming Crossing, each consisting of 96 units of apartment living located in Western Cincinnati only two minutes from one another and ten minutes from downtown teeming with top notch employment. Located in the submarket of Westwood, these properties provide a very favorable unit mix of two-bedroom layouts and competitive rental rates in a city full of strong market fundamentals.
Strong Demand for Housing: • Current ownership has taken advantage of constrained housing need from the city’s section 8 program, leading to a higher-than-average market rent across the property. This is a government funded program which gives new ownership comfort in not only strong rental rates, but strong collections as well. There is a decreasing supply and increasing demand for section 8 living in Cincinnati and that spread only continues to grow year over year, producing higher than market rents for these types of assets.
Favorable Unit Mix: • Both assets provide a favorable unit mix boasting 85% of the units being two-bedroom layouts increasing the GPR opportunity for incoming investors.
City Investments into the submarket: • The City of Cincinnati’s targeted public investment in the area has drastically increased following the Lick run project which has already begun to move a tremendous volume of money and activity into the local submarket. Upon completion we expect to see an increase in tenant move-ins in an already high occupancy market leading to continued rental growth. ADG MULTIFAMILY
39
EAGLE & WYOMING RENT MATRIX
Property Name Lafeuille Wyoming Crossing Villa Hills Eagle Watch Rapid Run 40
ADG MULTIFAMILY
Year Built # Units 1974 207 1967 96 1979 140 1971 96 1967 72
Avg SF 859 805 755 717.5 825
Avg Rent/ Avg Rent SF $827 $0.96 $775 $0.96 $764 $1.01 $749 $1.04 $743 $0.90
Property Name Lisa Ridge Vantage Point Aspen Village Terrace Woods
Avg Rent/ Year Built # Units Avg SF Avg Rent SF 1970 216 692 $730 $1.05 1972 775 860 $725 $0.84 1965 922 658 $703 $1.07 1965 54 718 $648 $0.90
COMPETITIVE SET
EAGLE & WYOMING
1868 Sunset Avenue, Cincinnati, OH EAGLE PROPERTY SUMMARY
96
UNITS
1971
YEAR BUILT
UNIT MIX & RENT SCHEDULE UNIT TYPE
# OF UNITS
Avg. SF
Avg. RENT
RENT PER SQFT
1x1
16
547
$646
$1.18
2x2
80
888
$767
$0.86
1905 Wyoming Avenue, Cincinnati, OH WYOMING PROPERTY SUMMARY
96
UNITS
1976
YEAR BUILT
UNIT MIX & RENT SCHEDULE UNIT TYPE
# OF UNITS
Avg. SF
Avg. RENT
RENT PER SQFT
1x1
12
716
$618
$0.86
2x1
84
850
$772
$0.91
ADG MULTIFAMILY
41
COMPETITIVE SET
VILLA HILLS
3775 Westmont Drive, Cincinnati, OH
PROPERTY SUMMARY
140
UNITS
1970
YEAR BUILT
UNIT MIX & RENT SCHEDULE UNIT TYPE
RENT
SF
RENT PER SQFT
1x1
$725
700
$1.04
2x1
$825
785
$1.05
AMENITIES UNIT FEATURES laundry facilties controlled access playground
hardwood floors
Comparables Rent Analysis
fireplace 1 Bed
balcony/patio
$600-$827
LOW
HIGH HIGH
2 Bed LOW
ADG MULTIFAMILY
COMP
$735-$976 HIGH HIGH
42
SUBJECT
SUBJECT COMP
ADG MULTIFAMILY
43
COMPETITIVE SET
LISA RIDGE
2496 Queen City Ave, Cincinnati, OH
PROPERTY SUMMARY
216
UNITS
1970
YEAR BUILT
UNIT MIX & RENT SCHEDULE UNIT TYPE
RENT
SF
RENT PER SQFT
1x1
$705
545
$1.29
2x1
$800
705
$1.13
AMENITIES UNIT FEATURES pool
heat paid
laundry facility
balconies
parking close to i-75
Comparables Rent Analysis 1 Bed
updated apts available
$600-$827
LOW
HIGH HIGH
2 Bed LOW
ADG MULTIFAMILY
COMP
$735-$976 HIGH HIGH
44
SUBJECT
SUBJECT COMP
ADG MULTIFAMILY
45
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
EAGLE FINANCIAL BREAKDOWN
1
BEDROOM 16 Units 8,752 SF
46
ADG MULTIFAMILY
2
BEDROOM 80 Units 71,040 SF
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
UNIT MIX SUMMARY
PROJECTED
MARKET
AVERAGE EFFECTIVE
Rentable
Total
Units
SF
SF
One Bedroom
16 Units
547 SF
8,752 SF
$646.33
$1.18
$10,341
$699.00
$1.28 SF
$11,184
$725.00
$1.33 SF
$11,600
Two Bedroom
80 Units
888 SF
71,040 SF
$767.65
$0.86
$61,412
$799.00
$0.90 SF
$63,920
$825.00
$0.93 SF
$66,000
Totals / Wtd. Averages
96 Units
831 SF
79,792 SF
$747.43
$0.90 SF
$71,753
$782.33
$0.94 SF
$75,104
$808.33
$0.97 SF
$77,600
Unit Type
Total Rent Rent/Unit Rent/SF
Potential
Total Rent Rent/Unit Rent/SF
Potential
Total Rent Rent/Unit Rent/SF
Potential
Summary
ADG MULTIFAMILY
47
Year 1
(Rent Roll/T# Income; Adjusted Trailing Expenses)
INCOME
GROSS POTENTIAL RENT All Units at Market Rent Gain (Loss) to Lease GROSS SCHEDULED RENT
$901,248 ($58,014) $843,234
(Recapture LTL, Stabilized Occupancy and Other Income, Normalized Expenses, Start Reno)
% of GPR
Per Unit
% of GPR
Per Unit
6.44%
9,388 (604) 8,784
$931,200 ($37,248) $893,952
4.00%
9,700 (388) 9,312
T12
1.01% 2.33%
88 205
$8,772 $20,322
0.98% 2.27%
91 212
T12 T12 T12
7.52% 1.91% 0.74% 83.40%
8,989 (660) (168) (65) 8,096
$914,274 ($44,698) ($13,409) $0 $856,167
5.00% 1.50% 0.00% 89.50%
9,524 (466) (140) 0 8,918
% of EGI 3.10% 0.00% 3.10% 4.65%
Per Unit 251 0 251 376
$24,103 $0 $24,103 $28,800
% of EGI 2.82% 0.00% 2.82% 3.36%
Per Unit 251 0 251 300
1.12% 0.23% 2.98% 11.30% 1.15% 16.78% 24.53%
90 19 241 915 93 1,359 1,986
$8,844 $1,827 $23,645 $89,596 $9,134 $133,047 $185,950
1.03% 0.21% 2.76% 10.46% 1.07% 15.54% 21.72%
92 19 246 933 95 1,386 1,937
RR T12
Other Income Laundry Income Total Other Income GROSS POTENTIAL INCOME Physical Vacancy Bad Debt Concessions Allowance EFFECTIVE GROSS INCOME
EXPENSES
FINANCIAL BREAKDOWN 48
Current
$8,490 $19,668 $862,902 ($63,388) ($16,102) ($6,212) $777,201
Non-Controllable Real Estate Taxes
$24,103 $0 $24,103 $36,135
Auditor
$8,671 $1,791 $23,182 $87,840 $8,955 $130,438 $190,676
T12 T12 T12 T12 T12
T12 T12 T12
Total Controllable
$6,326 $6,360 $4,073 $16,760 $10,209 $71 $78,382 $9,982 $11,051 $31,088 $3,280 $24,480 $185,303
0.81% 0.82% 0.52% 2.16% T12 1.31% T12 0.01% T12 10.09% T12 1.28% T12 1.42% Normalized 4.00% T12 0.42% T12 3.15% 23.84%
66 66 42 175 106 1 816 104 115 324 34 255 1,930
$3,360 $9,600 $3,360 $18,720 $52,800 $7,200 $86,400 $14,400 $14,400 $42,808 $3,360 $24,970 $265,058
0.39% 1.12% 0.39% 2.19% 6.17% 0.84% 10.09% 1.68% 1.68% 5.00% 0.39% 2.92% 30.96%
35 100 35 195 550 75 900 150 150 446 35 260 2,761
TOTAL EXPENSES
$375,978
48.38%
3,916
$451,008
52.68%
4,698
NET OPERATING INCOME
$401,223
51.62%
4,179
$405,159
47.32%
4,220
2019 Taxes Paid Adjustment for Sale Total Real Estate Taxes Insurance
T12
Utilities Electric Electric Vacant Gas Water & Sewage Trash Removal Total Utilities Total Non-Controllable Controllable Contract Services Snow Removal Landscaping/Grounds Pest Control Total Contract Services Repairs & Maintenance Marketing & Promotion On-Site Payroll Payroll Taxes & Benefits General & Administrative Management Fee Telephone & Cable Replacement & Reserves
ADG MULTIFAMILY
Year 2
Year 3
(...Stabilized Occupancy, Finish Reno on Remaining Units)
(Projected Rent Increase after Stabilization, Reno)
% of GPR
Per Unit
% of GPR
Per Unit
$959,136 ($19,183) $939,953
2.00%
9,991 (200) 9,791
$987,910 ($19,758) $968,152
2.00%
10,291 (206) 10,085
$9,036 $20,932
0.96% 2.23%
94 218
$9,307 $21,560
0.96% 2.23%
97 225
$960,885 ($46,998) ($9,400) $0 $904,488
5.00% 1.00% 0.00% 92.00%
10,009 (490) (98) 0 9,422
$989,712 ($48,408) ($9,682) $0 $931,622
5.00% 1.00% 0.00% 92.00%
10,309 (504) (101) 0 9,704
$24,103 $0 $24,103 $29,376
% of EGI 2.66% 0.00% 2.66% 3.25%
Per Unit 251 0 251 306
$24,103 $0 $24,103 $29,964
% of EGI 2.66% 0.00% 2.66% 3.31%
Per Unit 251 0 251 312
$9,021 $1,863 $24,118 $91,388 $9,317 $135,708 $189,187
1.00% 0.21% 2.67% 10.10% 1.03% 15.00% 20.92%
94 19 251 952 97 1,414 1,971
$9,201 $1,901 $24,601 $93,216 $9,503 $138,422 $192,489
1.02% 0.21% 2.72% 10.31% 1.05% 15.30% 21.28%
96 20 256 971 99 1,442 2,005
$3,427 $9,792 $3,427 $19,094 $53,856 $7,344 $88,128 $14,688 $14,688 $45,224 $3,427 $25,469 $271,919
0.38% 1.08% 0.38% 2.11% 5.95% 0.81% 9.74% 1.62% 1.62% 5.00% 0.38% 2.82% 30.06%
36 102 36 199 561 77 918 153 153 471 36 265 2,832
$3,496 $9,988 $3,496 $19,476 $54,933 $7,491 $89,891 $14,982 $14,982 $46,581 $3,496 $25,978 $277,810
0.39% 1.10% 0.39% 2.15% 6.07% 0.83% 9.94% 1.66% 1.66% 5.00% 0.39% 2.87% 30.56%
36 104 36 203 572 78 936 156 156 471 36 271 2,880
$461,106
50.98%
4,803
$470,298
52.00%
4,899
$443,382
49.02%
4,619
$461,324
51.00%
4,805
ADG MULTIFAMILY
49
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
WYOMING FINANCIAL BREAKDOWN
1
BED | 1 BATH 12 Units 8,592 SF
50
ADG MULTIFAMILY
2
BED | 1 BATH 84 Units 71,400 SF
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY UNIT MIX SUMMARY
PROJECTED
MARKET
AVERAGE EFFECTIVE
Rentable
Total
Units
SF
SF
One Bedroom
12 Units
716 SF
8,592 SF
$618.33
$0.86
$7,420
$699.00
$0.98 SF
$8,388
$725.00
$1.01 SF
$8,700
Two Bedroom
84 Units
850 SF
71,400 SF
$772.41
$0.91
$64,883
$802.71
$0.94 SF
$67,428
$828.57
$0.97 SF
$69,600
Totals / Wtd. Averages
96 Units
833 SF
79,992 SF
$753.15
$0.90 SF
$72,303
$789.75
$0.95 SF
$75,816
$815.63
$0.98 SF
$78,300
Unit Type
Total Rent Rent/Unit Rent/SF
Potential
Total Rent Rent/Unit Rent/SF
Potential
Total Rent Rent/Unit Rent/SF
Potential
Summary
ADG MULTIFAMILY
51
INCOME
Year 1
(Rent Roll/T# Income; Adjusted Trailing Expenses)
(Recapture LTL, Stabilized Occupancy and Other Income, Normalized Expenses, Start Reno)
GROSS POTENTIAL RENT All Units at Market Rent Gain (Loss) to Lease GROSS SCHEDULED RENT
% of GPR
Per Unit
% of GPR
Per Unit
5.13%
9,477 (486) 8,991
$939,600 ($37,584) $902,016
4.00%
9,788 (392) 9,396
$11,288 $8,735 $20,539
1.31% 1.01% 2.38%
118 91 214
$11,658 $9,021 $21,211
1.29% 1.00% 2.35%
121 94 221
$883,647 ($74,854) ($25,345) ($16,328) $767,120
8.67% 2.94% 1.89% 81.37%
9,205 (780) (264) (170) 7,991
$923,227 ($45,101) ($13,530) ($4,510) $860,086
5.00% 1.50% 0.50% 89.00%
9,617 (470) (141) (47) 8,959
% of EGI 4.52% 0.00% 4.52% 4.37%
Per Unit 361 0 361 349
$34,699 $0 $34,699 $33,600
% of EGI 4.03% 0.00% 4.03% 3.91%
Per Unit 361 0 361 350
$909,792 ($46,684) $863,108
RR T12 T12
Other Income Laundry Income Collection Recovery Income Total Other Income GROSS POTENTIAL INCOME Physical Vacancy Bad Debt Concessions Allowance EFFECTIVE GROSS INCOME
EXPENSES
FINANCIAL BREAKDOWN 52
Current
Non-Controllable Real Estate Taxes
$34,699 $0 $34,699 $33,544
Auditor
$6,305 $6,780 $14,080 $74,522 $12,988 $114,675 $182,918
T12 T12 T12 T12 T12
0.82% 0.88% 1.84% 9.71% 1.69% 14.95% 23.84%
66 71 147 776 135 1,195 1,905
$6,431 $6,916 $14,362 $76,012 $13,248 $116,969 $185,268
0.75% 0.80% 1.67% 8.84% 1.54% 13.60% 21.54%
67 72 150 792 138 1,218 1,930
$4,146 $6,316 $4,751 $15,213
T12 T12 T12
0.54% 0.82% 0.62% 1.98%
43 66 49 158
$3,360 $9,600 $3,360 $16,320
0.39% 1.12% 0.39% 1.90%
35 100 35 170
T12 T12 T12 T12 T12 Normalized T12 Added
Total Controllable
$32,057 $65 $70,937 $8,561 $8,966 $38,356 $2,315 $24,480 $200,950
4.18% 0.01% 9.25% 1.12% 1.17% 5.00% 0.30% 3.19% 26.20%
334 1 739 89 93 400 24 255 2,093
$52,800 $7,200 $81,600 $14,400 $14,400 $43,004 $3,360 $24,970 $258,054
6.14% 0.84% 9.49% 1.67% 1.67% 5.00% 0.39% 2.90% 30.00%
550 75 850 150 150 448 35 260 2,688
TOTAL EXPENSES
$383,868
50.04%
3,999
$443,321
51.54%
4,618
NET OPERATING INCOME
$383,252
49.96%
3,992
$416,765
48.46%
4,341
2019 Taxes Paid Adjustment for Sale Total Real Estate Taxes Insurance
T12
Utilities Electric Electric Vacant Gas Water & Sewage Trash Removal Total Utilities Total Non-Controllable Controllable Contract Services Snow Removal Landscaping/Grounds Pest Control Total Contract Services Repairs & Maintenance Marketing & Promotion On-Site Payroll Payroll Taxes & Benefits General & Administrative Management Fee Telephone & Cable Replacement & Reserves
ADG MULTIFAMILY
Year 2
Year 3
(...Stabilized Occupancy, Finish Reno on Remaining Units)
(Projected Rent Increase after Stabilization, Reno)
% of GPR
Per Unit
% of GPR
Per Unit
$967,788 ($19,356) $948,432
2.00%
10,081 (202) 9,880
$996,822 ($19,936) $976,885
2.00%
10,384 (208) 10,176
$12,007 $9,292 $21,848
1.27% 0.98% 2.30%
125 97 228
$12,368 $9,571 $22,503
1.27% 0.98% 2.30%
129 100 234
$970,280 ($47,422) ($9,484) ($4,742) $908,632
5.00% 1.00% 0.50% 91.50%
10,107 (494) (99) (49) 9,465
$999,388 ($48,844) ($9,769) ($4,884) $935,891
5.00% 1.00% 0.50% 91.50%
10,410 (509) (102) (51) 9,749
$34,699 $0 $34,699 $34,272
% of EGI 3.82% 0.00% 3.82% 3.77%
Per Unit 361 0 361 357
$34,699 $0 $34,699 $34,957
% of EGI 3.82% 0.00% 3.82% 3.85%
Per Unit 361 0 361 364
$6,560 $7,054 $14,649 $77,533 $13,513 $119,308 $188,279
0.72% 0.78% 1.61% 8.53% 1.49% 13.13% 20.72%
68 73 153 808 141 1,243 1,961
$6,691 $7,195 $14,942 $79,083 $13,783 $121,694 $191,350
0.74% 0.79% 1.64% 8.70% 1.52% 13.39% 21.06%
70 75 156 824 144 1,268 1,993
$3,427 $9,792 $3,427 $16,646
0.38% 1.08% 0.38% 1.83%
36 102 36 173
$3,496 $9,988 $3,496 $16,979
0.38% 1.10% 0.38% 1.87%
36 104 36 177
$53,856 $7,344 $83,232 $14,688 $14,688 $45,432 $3,427 $25,469 $264,782
5.93% 0.81% 9.16% 1.62% 1.62% 5.00% 0.38% 2.80% 29.14%
561 77 867 153 153 473 36 265 2,758
$54,933 $7,491 $84,897 $14,982 $14,982 $46,795 $3,496 $25,978 $270,532
6.05% 0.82% 9.34% 1.65% 1.65% 5.00% 0.38% 2.86% 29.62%
572 78 884 156 156 473 36 271 2,804
$453,061
49.86%
4,719
$461,883
50.83%
4,811
$455,571
50.14%
4,746
$474,008
52.17%
4,938
ADG MULTIFAMILY
53
54
ADG MULTIFAMILY
Z3 PORTFOLIO ROSELAWN
03 section
roselawn overview - 56 roselawn projects - 58 larose overview - 60 competitive set - 62 financials - 68 ADG MULTIFAMILY
55
LOCAL OVERVIEW
ROSELAWN
MIDPOINTE CROSSING The Port of Greater Cincinnati Development Authority has begun the development of the MidPointe Crossing mixed-use development in Cincinnati’s Bond Hill neighborhood. The project is valued at $80 million. MidPointe Crossing will be located within one mile of Interstate 75, and has the potential for up to 500,000 square feet of office and retail. The nearby intersection of Reading Road and Seymour Avenue sees more than 37,000 vehicles each day. “MidPointe Crossing is Cincinnati’s next great office and retail location,” says Laura Brunner, Port Authority president and CEO. Located within Midpointe Crossing will be the TechSolove II Buisness Park. The TechSolve II business park lies just northeast of the fully-leased, 143-acre TechSolve business park, home to Givaudan Flavors and Quest Diagnostics. The companies at TechSolve employ more than 2,000 in business, tech, and manufacturing jobs. The TechSolve II site is targeted for similar high tech manufacturing/advanced industry. With a Port Authority – City partnership leading the site development, park tenants will have access to powerful economic development tools and financing options; including incentives for job creation and energy efficiency.
56
ADG MULTIFAMILY
MERCY HEALTH CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS The first of about 1,050 Mercy Health employees moved into the nonprofit’s new $71 million headquarters in Bond Hill in 2018. Mercy signed a 15-year lease on the building with Verus Partners. Mercy Health is the largest nonprofit healthcare system in Ohio, Mercy Health has a mission to serve the entire community, especially the poor and underserved. With five hospitals, as well as more than 180 doctor’s offices, clinics and care locations throughout Greater Cincinnati, we work to ensure that you have easy access to safe, effective, timely and cost-efficient care. The new HQ, which is off Reading Road and overlooks the Norwood Lateral, will also feature several treadmill desks on each floor, and there’s a walking path on the 25-acre campus that is nearly a mile long.
new facility
at the kickoff
VILLAGES AT DAYBREAK Developed in 2011, this quaint community features nearly 200 homes. Villages of Daybreak offers an exclusive collection of new home floor plans that are perfect for an urban lifestyle. The development was strategically positioned to support an urban, walkable community. With homes ranging from $210,300-$273,000 buyers can enjoy a 10-year tax abatement with the purchase of a new home at Villages of Daybreak.
ADG MULTIFAMILY
57
LOCAL OVERVIEW
ROSELAWN
The BH+R Plan, developed through engagement with the residents of Bond Hill and Roselawn by the Community Building Institute at Xavier University, was approved by the community councils of both neighborhoods and approved by Cincinnati City Council in 2016. The Plan has guided The Port’s commercial and industrial redevelopment initiatives in both communities. The BH+R Plan called for a focus on creating jobs and eliminating blighted properties along commercial corridors in Roselawn. On March 28, 2018, a groundbreaking was held for the Roselawn Senior Apartments on a formerly blighted commercial property and abandoned building at 1811 Losantiville. The new $11,000,000, 50-unit project incorporates community space on the ground level and is expected to open in 2019. The Port led the site development.
58
ADG MULTIFAMILY
A – Roselawn Business District | Reading and Section | Commercial Development The Port acquired a site at the Northeast corner of Reading and Section in 2018. Environmental remediation is underway to position this key site, located at the gateway to Roselawn, for redevelopment. B – TechSolve II | Business Park | Commercial and Light Manufacturing Development Formerly blighted and underutilized shopping center occupied the site. Today, only one small parcel remains available of the 13-acre park. Jet Machine, a supplier of armor components and assemblies for the military/defense, aerospace and oil and gas sectors, completed construction and opened a new $5MM manufacturing facility; creating 41 new jobs in Roselawn in 2018. The company’s expansion builds on its two additional facilities in Bond Hill, where 118 jobs were retained, and aligns with The Port’s goal of bringing new jobs to focus neighborhoods in conjunction with residential and commercial revitalization efforts. A new 26,000 SF spec industrial warehouse facility is complete and occupied, and PACE financing has brought new life to an existing 25,000 SF facility. C – 1682 Seymour TechSolve II | Public Finance Redevelopment of 25,000 SF advanced manufacturing building including energy efficiency upgrades. Energy updates financed through Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE). D – Roselawn Senior Apartments | 1811 Losantiville | Neighborhood Revitalization Property acquired through donation, and The Port removed vacant, blighted commercial structure on the site to ready for new development – Sold in April 2016 to developer building Roselawn Senior Apartments, a $11MM LEED project with 50 units.
ADG MULTIFAMILY
59
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
LAROSE
1
BED | 1 BATH 33 Units 561 Avg SF $634 RENT
2
BED | 1 BATH 80 Units 986 Avg SF $828 RENT
3
BED | 1 BATH 48 Units 1,134 Avg SF $980 RENT
LENDER: FANNIE MAE | LOAN CLOSE DATE: 2/27/18 LOAN TERM: 15 YEARS | LOAN BALANCE: $6,900,000 INTEREST RATE: 5.22% | REMAINING IO PERIOD: 0 (MONTHS)
151,818 SF1949YEAR BUILT 943 AVERAGE UNIT SIZE $834 AVERAGE RENT 99% OCCUPANCY 60
ADG MULTIFAMILY
INVESTMENT HIGHLIGHTS Marcus & Millichap is pleased to present Larose, 161 units of apartment living located in Northcentral Cincinnati, 10 minutes outside of Cincinnati’s hottest growing markets, Oakley, Pleasant Ridge, and Hyde Park. Located in the submarket of Roselawn, this property provides an investor the opportunity to acquire a unique asset in the path of redevelopment.
Convenient Location: Larose is located on a corridor of infrastructure that continues to grow both North and East from downtown Cincinnati. Many of the surrounding neighborhoods have already gone through a transitional phase and seen upward of 20-25% rental increases in the past 2 years. Roselawn strategically sits in that corridor prime for continued redevelopment.
Favorable Rent Versus Own Profile: Roselawn submarket offers a larger than average renter population as 70% of the residents rent versus own. There is a tremendous amount of transient renters in the neighborhood due to its access to Walnut Hills School District, one of Ohio’s top ranked public schools.
Consistent Rental Collections: Although the apartment industry faced one of its most trying years relating to collections across all asset types, LaRose boasted collections over 98% throughout all of 2020. Collections are expected to continue to stay strong, unsurprisingly as Cincinnati was ranked third best for limited job loss through the COVID-19 pandemic.
ADG MULTIFAMILY
61
LAROSE RENT MATRIX
Property Name Williamburg Colonial Ridge LaRose The Greenery Glen Meadows 62
ADG MULTIFAMILY
Year Built 1967 1963 1949 1966 1955
# Units 976 142 161 56 264
Avg SF 1262 779 856 750 715
Avg Rent $976 $918 $786 $779 $641
Avg Rent/SF $0.77 $1.18 $0.92 $1.04 $0.90
COMPETITIVE SET
LAROSE PLACE
6252 Joyce Lane, Cincinnati, OH
PROPERTY SUMMARY
161
UNITS
1949
YEAR BUILT
UNIT MIX & RENT SCHEDULE UNIT TYPE
# OF UNITS
Avg. SF
Avg. RENT
RENT PER SQFT
1x1
33
561
$614
$1.10
2x1
80
986
$796
$0.81
3x1
48
1,134
$943
$.83
ADG MULTIFAMILY
63
COMPETITIVE SET
SUMMIT EAST
1581 Summit Road, Cincinnati, OH
PROPERTY SUMMARY
140
UNITS
1972
YEAR BUILT
UNIT MIX & RENT SCHEDULE UNIT TYPE
RENT
SF
RENT PER SQFT
1x1
$575
576
$1.00
2x1.5
$678
800
$0.85
AMENITIES UNIT FEATURES pool clubhouse laundry facilities pet friendly
patio
Comparables Rent Analysis
balcony 1 Bed
extra storage
$600-$827
LOW
HIGH HIGH
2 Bed LOW
ADG MULTIFAMILY
COMP
$735-$976 HIGH HIGH
64
SUBJECT
SUBJECT COMP
ADG MULTIFAMILY
65
COMPETITIVE SET
WILLIAMSBURG OF CINCINNATI
200 W Galbraith Rd
PROPERTY SUMMARY
140
UNITS
1970
YEAR BUILT
UNIT MIX & RENT SCHEDULE UNIT TYPE
RENT
SF
RENT PER SQFT
1x1
$781
788
$0.99
2x1.5 Town
$850
975
$0.87
3x2
$1,460
1700
$0.86
AMENITIES UNIT FEATURES clubhouse pool laundry facilities pet friendly
patio
Comparables Rent Analysis
balcony 1 Bed
extra storage
$600-$827
LOW
HIGH HIGH
2 Bed LOW
ADG MULTIFAMILY
COMP
$735-$976 HIGH HIGH
66
SUBJECT
SUBJECT COMP
ADG MULTIFAMILY
67
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
LAROSE FINANCIAL BREAKDOWN
1
BED | 1 BATH 33 Units 18,500 SF
68
ADG MULTIFAMILY
2
BED | 1 BATH 80 Units 78,910 SF
3
BED | 1 BATH 48 Units 54,408 SF
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
UNIT MIX SUMMARY
PROJECTED
MARKET
AVERAGE EFFECTIVE
Rentable
Total
Units
SF
SF
One Bedroom
33 Units
561 SF
18,500 SF
$614.62
$1.10
$20,283
$634.09
$1.13 SF
$20,925
$675.09
$1.20 SF
$22,278
Two Bedroom
80 Units
986 SF
78,910 SF
$796.49
$0.81
$63,719
$828.75
$0.84 SF
$66,300
$876.00
$0.89 SF
$70,080
Three Bedroom
48 Units
1,134 SF
54,408 SF
$943.84
$0.83
$45,304
$980.00
$0.86 SF
$47,040
$1,056.25
$0.93 SF
$50,700
Totals / Wtd. Averages
161 Units
943 SF
151,818 SF
$803.14
$0.85 SF
$129,306
$833.94
$0.88 SF
$134,265
$888.56
$0.94 SF
$143,058
Unit Type
Total Rent Rent/Unit Rent/SF
Potential
Total Rent Rent/Unit Rent/SF
Potential
Total Rent Rent/Unit Rent/SF
Potential
Summary
ADG MULTIFAMILY
69
INCOME
Year 1 (Recapture LTL, Stabilized Occupancy and Other Income, Normalized Expenses)
GROSS POTENTIAL RENT
% of GPR
All Units at Market Rent
$1,611,180
RR
Gain (Loss) to Lease
($64,332) $1,546,848
T12
GROSS SCHEDULED RENT
Per Unit
% of GPR
Per Unit
10,007
$1,716,696
10,663
3.99%
(400) 9,608
($34,334) $1,682,362
2.00%
(213) 10,449
T12 T12 T12
0.51% 0.20% 0.18% 1.37%
49 19 17 132
$8,348 $3,228 $2,983 $22,559
0.50% 0.19% 0.18% 1.34%
52 20 19 140
T12 T12 T12 T12
4.95% 1.48% 2.23% 1.10% 86.24%
9,739 (476) (143) (215) (106) 8,800
$1,704,921 ($84,118) $0 ($33,647) $0 $1,587,156
5.00% 0.00% 2.00% 0.00% 91.00%
10,590 (522) 0 (209) 0 9,858
Per Unit 455 0 455 284
$73,316 $0 $73,316 $48,300
% of EGI 4.62% 0.00% 4.62% 3.04%
Per Unit 455 0 455 300
Other Income Bad Debt Recovery/Collection Income Discounts and Miscellaneous Late & NSF Fees Income Total Other Income GROSS POTENTIAL INCOME Physical Vacancy Employee Unit Allowance Bad Debt Concessions Allowance EFFECTIVE GROSS INCOME
EXPENSES
FINANCIAL BREAKDOWN
Current (Rent Roll/T12 Income)
$7,835 $3,030 $2,800 $21,172 $1,568,020 ($76,560) ($22,969) ($34,540) ($17,080) $1,416,871
Non-Controllable
$73,316 $0 $73,316 $45,797
Auditor
T12
% of EGI 5.17% 0.00% 5.17% 3.23%
$8,290 $2,450
T12 T12
0.59% 0.17%
51 15
$8,455 $2,499
0.53% 0.16%
53 16
$28,562 $119,531 $34,627 $193,459 $312,572
T12 T12 T12
2.02% 8.44% 2.44% 13.65% 22.06%
177 742 215 1,202 1,941
$29,133 $121,922 $35,319 $197,328 $318,944
1.84% 7.68% 2.23% 12.43% 20.10%
181 757 219 1,226 1,981
$0 $2,837 $8,521 $8,223
T12 T12 T12 T12
0.00% 0.20% 0.60% 0.58%
0 18 53 51
$4,025 $5,635 $16,100 $5,635
0.25% 0.36% 1.01% 0.36%
25 35 100 35
Real Estate Taxes 2019 Taxes Paid Adjustment for Sale Total Real Estate Taxes Insurance Utilities Electric Electric Vacant Gas Water & Sewage Trash Removal Total Utilities Total Non-Controllable Controllable Contract Services Security Expense Snow Removal Landscaping/Grounds Pest Control
Total Controllable
$19,581 $33,301 $144 $203,335 $27,540 $33,585 $56,675 $2,549 $41,055 $417,765
1.38% T12 2.35% T12 0.01% T12 14.35% T12 1.94% T12 2.37% Normalized 4.00% T12 0.18% Normalized 2.90% 29.49%
122 207 1 1,263 171 209 352 16 255 2,595
$31,395 $88,550 $12,075 $144,900 $24,150 $24,150 $63,486 $3,220 $41,876 $433,802
1.98% 5.58% 0.76% 9.13% 1.52% 1.52% 4.00% 0.20% 2.64% 27.33%
195 550 75 900 150 150 394 20 260 2,694
TOTAL EXPENSES
$730,337
51.55%
4,536
$752,746
47.43%
4,675
NET OPERATING INCOME
$686,535
48.45%
4,264
$834,410
52.57%
5,183
Total Contract Services Repairs & Maintenance Marketing & Promotion On-Site Payroll Payroll Taxes & Benefits General & Administrative Management Fee Telephone & Cable Replacement & Reserves
Year 2
Year 3
(...Stabilized Occupancy) % of GPR
$1,768,197
Per Unit
% of GPR
10,983
$1,821,243
Per Unit
11,312
($35,364) $1,732,833
2.00%
(220) 10,763
($36,425) $1,784,818
2.00%
(226) 11,086
$8,599 $3,325 $3,073 $23,236
0.50% 0.19% 0.18% 1.34%
53 21 19 144
$8,857 $3,425 $3,165 $23,933
0.50% 0.19% 0.18% 1.34%
55 21 20 149
$1,756,069 ($86,642) $0 ($17,328) $0 $1,652,099
5.00% 0.00% 1.00% 0.00% 92.00%
10,907 (538) 0 (108) 0 10,261
$1,808,751 ($89,241) $0 ($17,848) $0 $1,701,662
5.00% 0.00% 1.00% 0.00% 92.00%
11,234 (554) 0 (111) 0 10,569
$73,316 $0 $73,316 $49,266
% of EGI 4.44% 0.00% 4.44% 2.98%
Per Unit 455 0 455 306
$73,316 $0 $73,316 $50,251
% of EGI 4.44% 0.00% 4.44% 3.04%
Per Unit 455 0 455 312
$8,625 $2,549
0.52% 0.15%
54 16
$8,797 $2,600
0.53% 0.16%
55 16
$29,716 $124,360 $36,026 $201,275 $323,856
1.80% 7.53% 2.18% 12.18% 19.60%
185 772 224 1,250 2,012
$30,310 $126,847 $36,746 $205,300 $328,867
1.83% 7.68% 2.22% 12.43% 19.91%
188 788 228 1,275 2,043
$4,106 $5,748 $16,422 $5,748
0.25% 0.35% 0.99% 0.35%
26 36 102 36
$4,188 $5,863 $16,750 $5,863
0.25% 0.35% 1.01% 0.35%
26 36 104 36
$32,023 $90,321 $12,317 $147,798 $24,633 $24,633 $66,084 $3,284 $42,714 $443,806
1.94% 5.47% 0.75% 8.95% 1.49% 1.49% 4.00% 0.20% 2.59% 26.86%
199 561 77 918 153 153 410 20 265 2,757
$32,663 $92,127 $12,563 $150,754 $25,126 $25,126 $68,066 $3,350 $43,568 $453,343
1.98% 5.58% 0.76% 9.12% 1.52% 1.52% 4.00% 0.20% 2.64% 27.32%
203 572 78 936 156 156 410 21 271 2,803
$767,663
46.47%
4,768
$782,211
47.35%
4,858
$884,436
53.53%
5,493
$919,451
55.65%
5,711
Our commitment is to help our clients create and preserve wealth by providing them with the best real estate investment sales, financing, research and advisory services available
www.adgmultifamily.com 513-878-7795