Issuu on Google+

!PRIL 

)SSUE"RIEF

! M E R I C A N ! C A D E M Y O F ! C T UA R I E S

,ONGEVITYAND2ETIREMENT0OLICY -ODERNIZING!MERICAS2ETIREMENT0ROGRAMS TO+EEP0ACEWITH,ONGEVITY %XECUTIVE3UMMARY 4HECOSTOFRETIREMENTBENElTSISCLOSELYLINKEDTOTHELONGEVITYOFRETIREES!SLIFEEXPECTANCYINCREASES SODOTHElNANCIALRESOURCES NEEDEDTOFUNDPENSIONPLANS ASSUMINGAlXEDRETIREMENTAGE)NCREASESINLIFEEXPECTANCYSHOULDPROMPTPERIODICREEXAMINATIONOFRETIRE MENTPOLICY WHICHRESULTSINBRINGINGRETIREMENTPOLICYINTOLINEWITHCHANGINGCIRCUMSTANCES 2ETIREMENTPOLICYAFFECTSLABORPOLICY)NDECIDINGWHENTORETIRE WORKERSAREINmUENCEDBYTHEAVAILABILITYOFRETIREMENTBENElTSANDBY HOWMUCHTHOSEBENElTSAREINCREASEDIFEMPLOYEESCONTINUETOWORKAFTERBENElTSARElRSTAVAILABLE4HEAVAILABILITYOFHEALTHBENElTSIN RETIREMENTCANBEEVENMOREIMPORTANTTHANCASHBENElTS &OREMPLOYERSWITHTRADITIONALDElNEDBENElTPENSIONPLANS THEHIGHERCOSTSASSOCIATEDWITHINCREASESINLONGEVITYMAYBEAFACTORIN THEDECLINEINDElNEDBENElTPLANS&OREMPLOYEES INCREASINGLONGEVITYMAYHAVERESULTEDINAREDElNINGOFRETIREMENTASAGRADUALPROCESS THATCANOCCUROVERANUMBEROFYEARS INSTEADOFAONE TIME ALL OR NOTHINGEVENT!LTHOUGHGRADUALRETIREMENTHASBENElTEDEMPLOYERS ANDEMPLOYEESALIKE CURRENTLAWSANDREGULATIONSPRESENTSIGNIlCANTOBSTACLES 4HE!MERICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUARIES2ETIREMENT3ECURITY0RINCIPLES4ASK&ORCEDEVELOPEDTHISISSUEBRIEFTOEXAMINETHEEFFECTTHAT INCREASEDLONGEVITYCOULDHAVEONBENElTADEQUACYINRETIREMENT4HISISSUEBRIEFCONSIDERSRETIREMENTOPTIONSAVAILABLETOWORKERS)TALSO CONSIDERSPOLICYOPTIONSAVAILABLETOPOLICY MAKERS

4HE!MERICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUARIESISANATIONALORGANIZATIONFORMEDINTOBRINGTOGETHER INASINGLEENTITY ACTUARIESOFALLSPECIALIZATIONSWITHINTHE5NITED3TATES!MAJOR PURPOSEOFTHE!CADEMYISTOACTASAPUBLICINFORMATIONORGANIZATIONFORTHEPROFESSION!CADEMYCOMMITTEES TASKFORCESANDWORKGROUPSREGULARLYPREPARETESTIMONYANDPRO VIDEINFORMATIONTO#ONGRESSANDSENIORFEDERALPOLICY MAKERS COMMENTONPROPOSEDFEDERALANDSTATEREGULATIONS ANDWORKCLOSELYWITHTHE.ATIONAL!SSOCIATIONOF)NSURANCE #OMMISSIONERSANDSTATEOFFICIALSONISSUESRELATEDTOINSURANCE PENSIONSANDOTHERFORMSOFRISKFINANCING4HE!CADEMYESTABLISHESQUALIFICATIONSTANDARDSFORTHEACTUARIAL PROFESSIONINTHE5NITED3TATESANDSUPPORTSTWOINDEPENDENTBOARDS4HE!CTUARIAL3TANDARDS"OARDPROMULGATESSTANDARDSOFPRACTICEFORTHEPROFESSION ANDTHE!CTUARIAL "OARDFOR#OUNSELINGAND$ISCIPLINEHELPSTOENSUREHIGHSTANDARDSOFPROFESSIONALCONDUCTAREMET4HE!CADEMYALSOSUPPORTSTHE*OINT#OMMITTEEFORTHE#ODEOF0ROFESSIONAL #ONDUCT WHICHDEVELOPSSTANDARDSOFCONDUCTFORTHE53ACTUARIALPROFESSION -EMBERSOFTHE2ETIREMENT3ECURITY0RINCIPLES4ASK&ORCEINCLUDE"RUCE$3CHOBEL -!!! &3! &#! CHAIRPERSON%DWARD%"URROWS -!!! %! -30!!NNA -2APPAPORT -!!! %! &3!2ICHARD'3CHREITMUELLER -!!! &3!*OHN4URNER4HOMAS&7ILDSMITH -!!! &3!*OHN#7ILKIN -!!! &3!AND-ANHA 9AU -!!! %! &3!

!MER ICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUAR IES 3EVENTEENTH3TREET.73EVENTH&LOOR7ASHINGTON $# 4EL&AX WWWACTUARYORG +EVIN#RONIN %XECUTIVE$IRECTOR .OEL#ARD $IRECTOROF#OMMUNICATIONS #RAIG(ANNA $IRECTOROF0UBLIC0OLICY (EATHER*ERBI 3ENIOR0ENSION0OLICY!NALYST ยน4HE!MERICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUARIES!LL2IGHTS2ESERVED


"ACKGROUND $EMOGRAPHICS )N WHEN3OCIAL3ECURITYlRSTPAIDMONTHLYRETIREMENTBENElTSANDTHENUMBEROFPRIVATEPENSIONPLANS WASJUSTBEGINNINGTOGROW INDIVIDUALSREACHINGAGELIVED ONAVERAGE FORANOTHERYEARS&URTHERMORE MANYWORKERSENTEREDTHELABORFORCEATAGE IMMEDIATELYAFTERGRADUATINGFROMHIGHSCHOOL4HESEINDIVIDU ALSCOULDEXPECTTOWORKFORYEARSBEFOREATTAININGhNORMALvRETIREMENTAGE7HENPLANNINGFORRETIREMENT THEREFORE APENSIONPLANCOULDANTICIPATETHATCONTRIBUTIONSNEEDEDTOlNANCEYEARSINRETIREMENTCOULD BEMADEOVERA YEARPERIOD4HENUMBEROFYEARSSPENTINRETIREMENTFORAFULL CAREERWORKERWASABOUT PERCENTOFTHENUMBEROFYEARSSPENTINTHELABORFORCE &ASTFORWARDTOTHEDEMOGRAPHICSOFPENSIONPLANNINGHAVECHANGEDSIGNIlCANTLY!PPROXIMATELYTWO THIRDSOFELIGIBLENON DISABLEDWORKERSCLAIM3OCIAL3ECURITYRETIREMENTBENElTSATAGERATHERTHAN AND THEYENTERTHELABORFORCEATALATERAGE OFTENATAGEOREVENOLDER RATHERTHANAGE4HISLEAVESABOUT YEARSOFWORKBEFOREANEXPECTEDRETIREMENTATAGE ATWHICHPOINTREMAININGLIFEEXPECTANCYISAPPROXIMATELY YEARS4HEREFORE WHENPLANNINGFORRETIREMENTNOW APENSIONPLANCANANTICIPATEABOUTYEARSOFCONTRI BUTIONSFORAFULL CAREERWORKERTOlNANCEABOUTYEARSOFRETIREMENT4HENUMBEROFYEARSSPENTINRETIREMENT ISABOUTPERCENTOFTHENUMBEROFYEARSSPENTINTHELABORFORCE!STHELENGTHOFTHERETIREMENTPERIODHAS INCREASED THEWAYPEOPLESPENDITHASCHANGEDASWELL-ANYPEOPLERETIREFROMONEJOBANDCOLLECTBENElTSBUT CONTINUETOWORKINANOTHERJOB EITHERFULL TIMEORPART TIME 4HUS FROMTO THERATIOOFTHENUMBEROFYEARSSPENTINRETIREMENTTOTHENUMBEROFYEARSSPENTINTHE LABORFORCEHASINCREASEDFROMPERCENTTOPERCENT A PERCENTINCREASEINYEARS4HISPERCENTALSO REmECTSTHEINCREASEINCONTRIBUTIONRATESTHATWOULDBENECESSARYTOlNANCETHESAMELEVELOFBENElTSIN ASIN"ECAUSETHISINCREASEINTHECONTRIBUTIONLEVELISNOTAFFORDABLE THETRENDAMONGPENSIONPLANSIN RECENTYEARSHASBEENTOREDUCETHELEVELOFRETIREMENTBENElTS3OCIAL3ECURITYISACCOMPLISHINGTHISBYINCREAS INGTHENORMALRETIREMENTAGEGRADUALLYFROMTO ASMANDATEDBYLEGISLATIONENACTEDIN4HISCHANGE RESULTSINGREATERACTUARIALREDUCTIONSˆANDTHEREFORESMALLERBENElTSˆFORWORKERSWHOCLAIMRETIREMENT BENElTSATAGE ASMOSTDO 4HEINCREASINGWILLINGNESSOFOLDERWORKERSTOREMAINPRODUCTIVECANBESEENFROMTHETRENDINLABOR FORCEPAR TICIPATIONRATESFORWORKERSOVERAGE&ORMEN LABOR FORCEPARTICIPATIONRATESFORTHOSEAGED REACHED ALOWOFPERCENTINANDCLIMBEDBACKTOPERCENTBYTHEMOSTRECENTYEARFORWHICHDATAARE AVAILABLE 3IMILARLYFORWOMEN LABOR FORCEPARTICIPATIONRATESFORTHOSEAGED REACHEDALOWOFPERCENT INANDCLIMBEDTOANALL TIMEHIGHOFPERCENTBY !SSUMINGTHATTHEECONOMYCONTINUESTOGROWANDLEVELSOFNETIMMIGRATIONDONOTCHANGEDRAMATICALLY THE INCREASINGDESIREOFEMPLOYERSTORETAINOLDERWORKERSCANBEINFERREDFROMTHEEXPECTEDIMPACTOFTHELARGECO HORTOFBABYBOOMERSRETIRINGINTHENEARFUTURE4HESOCIETALREASONSFOREMPLOYMENTOFOLDERWORKERSLINKTO THENEEDFORWORKERS TALENTSHORTAGESINSPECIlCOCCUPATIONS ANDTHEINTERESTSANDNEEDSOFTHESEWORKERS/VER THENEXTYEARS THENUMBEROFWORKERSPAYING3OCIAL3ECURITYTAXESISEXPECTEDTOINCREASEBYPERCENT FROM MILLIONTOMILLION)TWILLTAKEALMOSTYEARSTHEREAFTERFORASIMILARINCREASE4HISDRAMATICSLOWINGOF LABORSUPPLYGROWTHWILLPUTINCREASINGPRESSUREONEMPLOYERSTOTRYTORETAINOLDERWORKERS &ROMTHEEMPLOYEEPERSPECTIVE THEDEMOGRAPHICREALITYOFSPENDINGMOREYEARSINRETIREMENTSHOULDRAISECON CERNSABOUTTHEADEQUACYOFRETIREMENTBENElTS ESPECIALLYWHENCONSIDERINGEARLYRETIREMENTOPTIONS7HEN EMPLOYEESWORKLONGER THEYAREMORELIKELYTOHAVETHENECESSARYlNANCIALRESOURCESINRETIREMENTBECAUSE 4HEYHAVEMOREYEARSTOSAVEOREARNBENElTCREDITINTRADITIONALDElNEDBENElTPLANS ANDMOREYEARS TOACCUMULATEINVESTMENTASSETSINDElNEDCONTRIBUTIONPLANS !SSETSFROMLUMPSUMSCANBEUSEDMORERAPIDLYBECAUSETHEPERIODOFTIMEOVERWHICHTHEYWILLBEUSED ISSHORTER "ENElTSTHATAREPAIDASANNUITIESWILLSTARTATALATERDATE ANDEARLYRETIREMENTREDUCTIONS IFANY WILLBE SMALLER )335%"2)%&!02),


 4HEYFACELESSCONCERNABOUTINmATIONERODINGTHEREALVALUEOFTHEIRBENElTSDURINGALONGPERIODOF RETIREMENT 5LTIMATELY AWORKERSDECISIONTOCONTINUEWORKINGPASTNORMALRETIREMENTAGE ORATTHEVERYLEAST UNTILNORMAL RETIREMENTAGE CANHAVEASIGNIlCANTIMPACTONTHEADEQUACYOFBENElTSINRETIREMENT 2ETIREMENT!GESIN0ENSION,AW "ECAUSETHE53#ONGRESSINTENDEDPRIVATEPENSIONSTOBEUSEDFOROLD AGEINCOMESUPPORT THEAGESATWHICH BENElTSCANCOMMENCEARELIMITEDBYMINIMUMANDMAXIMUMAGEREQUIREMENTS!GEISTHEMINIMUMAGE ATWHICH3OCIAL3ECURITYRETIREMENTBENElTSCANBERECEIVED)NK PLANS WORKERSCANTAKETHEIRBENElTS STARTINGATAGEWITHOUTA PERCENTTAXPENALTYTHATISLEVIED WITHCERTAINEXCEPTIONS WHENBENElTSARE TAKENATYOUNGERAGES EVENIFTHEYARESTILLWORKINGFORTHESPONSORINGEMPLOYER4HEYCANRECEIVETHESEBENElTS PENALTY FREEASEARLYASAGEIFTHEYHAVESTOPPEDWORKINGFORTHEEMPLOYERPROVIDINGTHEPLAN!TAGE WORKERSCANRECEIVEBENElTSFROMAN)NDIVIDUAL2ETIREMENT!CCOUNT)2! ORA2OTH)2!WITHOUTPENALTY4HE MAJORITYOFWORKERSINDElNEDBENElTPENSIONPLANSCANRECEIVEBENElTSATARETIREMENTAGEOF 3OCIAL3ECURITYSNORMALRETIREMENTAGEISGRADUALLYINCREASINGFROMTO!FTERATTAININGNORMALRETIREMENT AGE BENElCIARIES CAN COLLECT 3OCIAL 3ECURITY BENElTS AND WORK WITHOUT LOSING BENElTS UNDER THE RETIREMENT EARNINGSTEST4HERETIREMENTEARNINGSTEST WHICHCAUSESALOSSOFIN3OCIAL3ECURITYBENElTSFOREVERYIN EARNINGSOVERAMODESTEXEMPTAMOUNT IN DOESNOTAPPLYATNORMALRETIREMENTAGEOROLDER %VENTHOUGHTHENORMALRETIREMENTAGEFOR3OCIAL3ECURITYISNOLONGER ITISSTILLAKEYAGEINTHERETIREMENT INCOMESYSTEM)TISTHEAGEATWHICHMOSTPEOPLEQUALIFYFOR-EDICAREHEALTHINSURANCEBENElTSANDOLD AGE POVERTYBENElTSFROMTHE3UPPLEMENTAL3ECURITY)NCOME33) PROGRAM!PRIVATE SECTORPENSIONPLANMUST BEGINPAYINGBENElTSBYAGETOELIGIBLEPARTICIPANTSWHOARENOLONGERWORKINGIFTHENORMALRETIREMENTAGE ISNOTEARLIER )NPRIVATESECTORDElNEDBENElTPLANS THE%MPLOYEE2ETIREMENT)NCOME3ECURITY!CT%2)3! HASBEENINTERPRETEDASSETTINGAMAXIMUMNORMALRETIREMENTAGEOF !GEISTHEMAXIMUMAGETOWHICHEMPLOYEESCANDELAYRECEIVINGPENSIONBENElTS UNLESSTHEYARESTILLWORK INGATTHElRMSPONSORINGTHEPLAN3UBSTANTIALOWNERSMUSTBEGINTAKINGBENElTSATAGEWHETHERORNOT THEYCONTINUETOWORK )TISALSOTHEMAXIMUMAGELIMITFORMAKINGCONTRIBUTIONSTOATRADITIONAL)2! ALTHOUGH THEREISNOAGELIMITFORCONTRIBUTIONSTOA2OTH)2! )NCENTIVESTO2ETIREATA3PECIlC!GE $ESPITETHEDEMOGRAPHICCHALLENGESFOREMPLOYERSANDEMPLOYEESWHENCONSIDERINGRETIREMENTOPTIONS PRI VATE SECTORPENSIONPLANS ANDEVEN3OCIAL3ECURITY OFFERANUMBEROFINCENTIVESFOREARLYRETIREMENT %MPLOYER SPONSOREDPENSIONPLANS %ARLYRETIREMENTFEATURESINDElNEDBENElTPLANS INCLUDINGEARLYRETIREMENTWINDOWSANDPAYMENTOFUNREDUCED BENElTSATANEARLYAGE PROVIDEANINCENTIVETORETIREEARLY PARTICULARLYWHENEARLYRETIREMENTBENElTSAREHEAVILYSUBSI DIZED7ITHRESPECTTOEARLYRETIREMENTWINDOWS IFTHEREISAPATTERNOFWINDOWSBEINGPERIODICALLYPROVIDED EMPLOYEES WILLWAITFORTHEMANDTIMETHEIRRETIREMENTACCORDINGLY%ARLYRETIREMENTWINDOWSARESPECIALINCENTIVESTHATENCOUR AGERETIREMENTATASPECIlCPOINTINTIME SUCHASCASHBONUSESANDORIMPROVEMENTOFPENSIONBENElTS (OWEVER DEPENDINGONHOWBENElTSAREADJUSTEDFORWORKAFTERRETIREMENT ADElNEDBENElTPLANMAYALSOOF FERINCENTIVESTOWORKBEYONDNORMALRETIREMENTAGE&OREXAMPLE AFULLACTUARIALINCREASEAFTERNORMALRETIRE MENTAGEPROVIDESSOMEINCENTIVEFORPARTICIPANTSTOCONTINUETOWORK!NOTHERINCENTIVEISTHATDElNEDBENElT PLANSGENERALLYDONOTANDCANNOT RESTRICTWORKATOTHEREMPLOYERS ANDSOMEDONOTEVENRESTRICTWORKATTHE SAMEEMPLOYER-ANYEMPLOYEESCHOOSETORETIREFROMALONG SERVICEEMPLOYER COLLECTBENElTS ANDCONTINUETO WORKATADIFFERENTJOBORASAREHIREDRETIREE4HISISAGRADUALFORMOFRETIREMENTTHATCANBEMUTUALLYBENElCIAL TOEMPLOYEESANDEMPLOYERS $ElNEDCONTRIBUTIONPLANSALSOOFFERINCENTIVESTOCONTINUEWORKING!CCOUNTBALANCESCONTINUETOGROWASAN EMPLOYEECONTINUESTOWORK ANDUSUALLYNEWCONTRIBUTIONSCANBEMADETOTHEPLANS2ESEARCHHASSHOWNTHAT )335%"2)%&!02),


EMPLOYEESWITHONLYDElNEDCONTRIBUTIONPLANSRETIRELATERTHANTHOSEWITHDElNEDBENElTPLANS(OWEVER IF APLANISCHANGEDANDEMPLOYEESAREGIVENALIMITEDTIMETORETIREUNDERTHEOLDPLAN THISCREATESAPOWERFUL INCENTIVETORETIREDURINGTHELIMITEDPERIOD 3OCIAL3ECURITY !S NOTED 3OCIAL 3ECURITY RETIRED WORKER BENElTS ARE PAYABLE BEGINNING AT AGE  FOR WORKERS WITH  YEARS OFWORKCOVEREDBY3OCIAL3ECURITY0RIORTOTHEATTAINMENTOF NORMALRETIREMENTAGE ARETIREMENTEARNINGS TESTREDUCESBENElTSBYPERCENTOFEARNINGSINEXCESSOFAMODESTEXEMPTAMOUNT IN FROM EMPLOYMENTORSELF EMPLOYMENT%LIGIBILITYFORTHESEBENElTSISASTRONGINCENTIVEFORRETIREMENT WHEREASTHE RETIREMENTEARNINGSTESTISASTRONGDISINCENTIVETOWORKANDEARNMORETHANTHEEARNINGS TESTEXEMPTAMOUNT (OWEVER BENElTSFORPEOPLEWHOCONTINUEWORKINGPASTAGEAREINCREASEDTOOFFSETTHEBENElTSLOSTBYPOST PONINGRETIREMENT "EGINNINGATNORMALRETIREMENTAGE THERETIREMENTEARNINGSTESTNOLONGERAPPLIES SOFORPEOPLEWHODONOT CLAIMBENElTSBEFORENORMALRETIREMENTAGE 3OCIAL3ECURITYPROVIDESNOFURTHERDISINCENTIVETOCONTINUEWORK ING/FCOURSE BYTHATTIME MOSTPEOPLEHAVEALREADYCLAIMED3OCIAL3ECURITYBENElTSANDHAVEATLEASTPARTIALLY RETIRED -EDICALBENElTS )FANEMPLOYEROFFERSMEDICALBENElTSTOACTIVEEMPLOYEESANDNOTTORETIREES ITPROVIDESASTRONGINCENTIVEFOR EMPLOYEESTOCONTINUETOWORKUNTIL-EDICAREELIGIBILITYATAGE ORATLEASTUNTIL#/"2!BENElTSAREAVAILABLE TOBRIDGETHEGAPTO-EDICAREELIGIBILITY#/"2!PROVIDESFORMEREMPLOYEESANDRETIREESWITHACONTINUATION OFHEALTHCARECOVERAGEATGROUPRATESONATEMPORARYBASIS 4HEIMPORTANCEOFTHISISSUEDEPENDSONWHETHER ASPOUSEOROTHERFAMILYMEMBERHASFAMILYMEDICALCOVERAGE 2ETIREEMEDICALCOVERAGEATYOUNGERAGESBEFORE-EDICAREELIGIBILITYSERVESASYETANOTHERENABLEROFEARLYRETIRE MENT)FTHECOSTTORETIREESISLOWTHENRETIREEMEDICALCOVERAGEOFFERSSOMEINCENTIVETORETIREEARLY(OWEVER IF THEHEALTHCAREPROGRAMFORRETIREESISLESSATTRACTIVETHANFORACTIVES ITWILLBEADISINCENTIVETOEARLYRETIREMENT

0OLICY/PTIONS !SAVERAGELIFEEXPECTANCYINCREASES THECOSTOFTRADITIONALRETIREMENTBENElTS ABSENTACORRESPONDINGCHANGE INRETIREMENTAGES WILLGROWSTEADILY"OTHMENANDWOMENARELIVINGLONGER ANDWOMEN WITHTHEIRGREATER LONGEVITYANDINCREASINGYEARSOFWORK AREMOREHEAVILYREPRESENTEDAMONGRETIREDWORKERSTHANINTHEPAST 7OMENOFTENCOLLECTBENElTSASSPOUSESOFWORKERS)NCREASINGLONGEVITYAFFECTSTHECOSTOFRETIREMENTBENElTS OFFEREDBYEMPLOYERS THERESOURCESTHATINDIVIDUALWORKERSNEEDTOMAINTAINTHEIRSTANDARDOFLIVINGINRETIRE MENT ANDTHEPOOLOFPOTENTIALWORKERSAVAILABLETOEMPLOYERS,ONGEVITYALSOAFFECTSTHECOSTOFGOVERNMENT SPONSOREDPROGRAMSSUCHAS3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICARE 0OLICY MAKERSMAYWANTTOCONSIDERATLEASTTHREEDIFFERENTPOTENTIALGOALSINTHISAREA &OCUSONASYSTEMTHATWORKSWELLFORINDIVIDUALWORKERS ENSURINGTHATANADEQUATEINCOMEWILLBE AVAILABLEWHENTHEYRETIRE  )NCREASETHEmEXIBILITYOFTHESYSTEMFORBOTHWORKERSANDTHEIREMPLOYERSˆMAKINGITEASIERFORWORK ERSTOTAILORTHEIRWORKINGCAREERSANDRETIREMENTPLANNINGTOMEETTHEIRINDIVIDUALNEEDSANDPREFER ENCESANDFOREMPLOYERSTOMANAGETHEIRLABORANDBENElTCOSTS  "ETTERBALANCETHECOSTANDBENElTSOFOURRETIREMENTINCOMESYSTEMACROSSGENERATIONS 4HEPOLICYOPTIONSPRESENTEDBELOWWOULDPROVIDEMOREINCENTIVESANDFEWERDISINCENTIVESFORWORKERSTODELAY RETIREMENTANDCONTINUEACCUMULATINGRETIREMENTSAVINGS7EARENOTNECESSARILYADVOCATINGANYOFTHEPOSSIBLE CHANGESNOTEDBELOW

)335%"2)%&!02),


2OLEOFTHEGOVERNMENT  2EMOVEBARRIERSTOPROGRESS4OALLOWSOMEOFTHEPENSIONPLANREVISIONSNOTEDABOVE FEDERALPENSION LAWSANDREGULATIONSWOULDREQUIRECHANGES2EGULATIONSRELATEDTOTHE!GE$ISCRIMINATIONIN%MPLOY MENT!CT!$%! ALTHOUGHGENERALLYOUTSIDETHESCOPEOFTHISISSUEBRIEF SHOULDBECLARIlED&OREXAM PLE ITWOULDBEVERYUSEFULIFTHEREGULATIONSINCLUDEDEXTENSIVEILLUSTRATIONSSHOWINGPHASEDRETIREMENT APPROACHESTHATTHEREGULATORSBELIEVEDONOTVIOLATE!$%!4HISWOULDPERMITEMPLOYERSTOFASHION INNOVATIVEPROGRAMSWITHLESSDOUBTASTOTHEIRACCEPTABILITY)NADDITION THESTATUTEITSELFSHOULDBE REVIEWEDTOENSURETHATITDOESNOTPUTUPUNNECESSARYBARRIERSTOINNOVATION  /FFERCARROTSANDSTICKS4OENCOURAGEPENSIONPLANREVISIONS FEDERALREGULATIONSREGARDINGTAXTREATMENT AND0"'#COSTSCOULDBEAMENDED&OREXAMPLE )23RULESCOULDDISALLOWQUALIlEDPLANSTHATLETWORK ERSRETIREhTOOEARLYvUNLESSTHEEMPLOYERHASANECESSARYBUSINESSPURPOSEORTHEEMPLOYEEISDISABLED !NYINCENTIVESANDDISINCENTIVESWOULDHAVETOBEDESIGNEDCAREFULLYTOAVOIDUNINTENDEDHARMTOTHE PRIVATEPENSIONSYSTEM  0ROVIDEALEVELPLAYINGlELD3OMEOLDERCOMPANIESHAVEAHIGHCOSTSTRUCTURERELATEDMOSTLYTOTHESIZEOF THEIRRETIREDPOPULATIONS WHOARERECEIVINGGUARANTEEDBENElTSUNDERDElNEDBENElTPLANSANDOTHER TRADITIONALBENElTS7HEREPOSSIBLE ANYLEGISLATEDCHANGESSHOULDREmECTTHECURRENTANDFUTUREOBLIGA TIONSOFSUCHEMPLOYERS 'OVERNMENTSHOULDENCOURAGEEMPLOYERSTORETAINOLDERWORKERS !SBABYBOOMERSPREPARETORETIRE EMPLOYERSWILLBELOOKINGATTHEPOTENTIALFORASIGNIlCANTLOSSOFKNOWLEDGE ANDEXPERIENCE ANDMAYSEEKTORETAINMANYOFTHESEWORKERS-AKINGTHEFOLLOWINGCHANGESTODElNEDBENElT PLANS COULDENCOURAGETHERETENTIONOFOLDERWORKERS

'OVERNMENT2ULES!FFECTING2ETIREMENT0LAN$ESIGN !S A MATTER OF SOCIAL POLICY OUR TAX STRUCTURE PROVIDES POWERFUL INCENTIVES FOR EMPLOYERS TO MAINTAIN BROAD BASEDEMPLOYEERETIREMENTPLANS&ROMTHESTANDPOINTOFTAXPAYERSASAWHOLE THESEPLANSCRE ATEALOTOFVALUETOSOCIETY BUTINTRADEFORTHEIRVALUE THESEINCENTIVESAREEXPENSIVE4AXRATESCOULD BESOMEWHATLOWERIFTHEINCENTIVESDIDNOTEXIST&ORTHISREASON TAXPOLICYINCLUDESRULESDESIGNEDTO ENSURETHATRETIREMENTPLANSELIGIBLEFORTHEINCENTIVESPROVIDEBENElTSONAFAIRANDEQUITABLEBASIS&OR EXAMPLE THEREARERULESDESIGNEDTOCONTROL $ISCRIMINATIONAGAINSTLOWERPAIDWORKERS $ISCRIMINATIONAGAINSTOLDERWORKERS $ISSIPATIONOFRETIREMENTSAVINGSBEFORERETIREMENTTIME $ELAYSINCOMMENCINGBENElTSUPONRETIREMENT 4HEEXTENTTOWHICHBENElTSAREEXTREMELYHIGH WHETHERORNOTDISCRIMINATORY 4HEEXTENTTOWHICHTHEBENElTPROGRAMFAILSTOREmECTTHENEEDSOFNON WORKINGSPOUSES 4HEEXTENTTOWHICHEARNEDBENElTSCANBELOST EVENIFTHELOSSCONSTITUTESATRADEOFFMUTUALLY AGREEABLETOPARTICIPANTANDEMPLOYERAND 4HEEXTENTTOWHICHTHESPONSORINGEMPLOYERCANEXERCISEPARTICIPANT BY PARTICIPANTDISCRETION REGARDINGOPTIONALBENElTPAYMENTDATESANDFORMS 4HESERULESAREADMINISTEREDPRIMARILYBYTHE)NTERNAL2EVENUE3ERVICE)23 THE$EPARTMENTOF,ABOR ANDTHE%QUAL%MPLOYMENT/PPORTUNITY#OMMISSION7HILEGENERALLYDESIRABLE THERULESCANSOMETIMES HAVEUNINTENDEDANDUNDESIRABLECONSEQUENCES4HISCANBEESPECIALLYTRUEIFARULETHAT#ONGRESSARTICU LATESINVERYBROADTERMSBECOMESTHESUBJECTOFDETAILEDANDFORMULAICINTERPRETATIONBYANADMINISTRA TIVEAGENCY )NCONSIDERINGOPTIONALSOLUTIONSTOTHEPROBLEMSDESCRIBEDINTHISISSUEBRIEF ITISIMPORTANTTODETERMINE THEEXTENTTOWHICHANOPTIONMAYCONmICTWITHANEXISTINGRULE)NSOMECASES ITMAYBEDESIRABLETOMILI TATEFORMODIlCATIONOFTHEEXISTINGRULEˆEITHERBY#ONGRESSORBYTHERELEVANTADMINISTRATIVEAGENCY )335%"2)%&!02),


 )NPRIVATERETIREMENTPLANS THECUSTOMARYNORMALRETIREMENTAGEOFCOULDBERAISED EITHERBYAD HOCPLANCHANGESORBYINDEXINGTHEAGETOREmECTPASTEXPERIENCEINLONGEVITY4HISCHANGEMAYREQUIRE ACHANGEINPENSIONLAW!TTHESAMETIME THEEARLYRETIREMENTAGECOULDBEINCREASEDALONGWITHTHE NORMALRETIREMENTAGE

7HILERAISINGTHENORMALRETIREMENTAGEMAYALLOWEMPLOYERSTORETAINWORKERS THEISSUEOFHOWSUCHA CHANGEWOULDAFFECTEMPLOYEESINPHYSICALLYDEMANDINGJOBSORTHOSEWITHPOORHEALTH BUTNOTELIGIBLE FORDISABILITYBENElTS MUSTBEADDRESSED!CCORDINGTOA3OCIAL3ECURITY!DMINISTRATIONREPORT FEWERWORKERSAREEXPECTEDTOBEINPHYSICALLYDEMANDINGJOBSˆAPPROXIMATELYPERCENTTOPERCENT INASOPPOSEDTOTHEPERCENTIN&ORTHEPURPOSESOF3OCIAL3ECURITY GRADUALLYRELAXINGTHE ELIGIBILITYCRITERIAFORDISABILITYBENElTS WHICHISALREADYDONEFORBENElCIARIESATOLDERAGES ADDRESSES THECONCERNTOSOMEDEGREE!mEXIBLEEMPLOYER SPONSOREDDElNEDBENElTSYSTEM WHICHCOULDPROVIDE BENElTSTAILOREDTOTHEINDIVIDUALASPECTSOFEACHCOMPANYSWORKFORCE MAYALSORESOLVESOMEOFTHE CONCERNSASSOCIATEDWITHTHISSEGMENTOFTHEWORKFORCE

 $ElNEDBENElTPLANSOFTENPROVIDESUBSIDIZEDEARLYRETIREMENTBENElTSFOREMPLOYEESWHOHAVELONG SERVICE AREINPHYSICALLYDEMANDINGJOBS ORAREINVOLVEDINPLANTSHUTDOWNS3UCHBENElTSCOMMENCE BEFORENORMALRETIREMENTAGEWITHLITTLEORNOREDUCTIONTOREmECTTHEEARLIERANDLONGERPAYOUT ANDMAY BEACCOMPANIEDBYBRIDGEBENElTPAYMENTSUNTIL3OCIAL3ECURITYBEGINS)NMANYCASES THESEBENElTS SERVEANIMPORTANTPURPOSEINMANAGINGTHEWORKFORCE BUTINOTHERCASESTHEYMAYFORCEOUTVALUABLE EMPLOYEES4HEPROBLEMISTHATTHESEPLANSOFFERTHESUBSIDIZEDBENElTSTOOTHERSWORKERSASWELL  #ASHBALANCEANDPENSIONEQUITYPLANSCOULDSERVEASALTERNATIVESTOTRADITIONALDElNEDBENElTPENSION PLANS4HECOSTSOFSUCHPLANSAREFAIRLYLEVELOVERANEMPLOYEESCAREER NOTBACK LOADEDASINATRADITION ALPLAN ANDTHUSDONOTPOSEABARRIERTOHIRINGANDRETAININGOLDERWORKERS7ITHCASHBALANCEPLANS HOWEVER CARESHOULDBETAKENTOENSURETHATOLDERWORKERSWOULDNOTBEADVERSELYAFFECTEDBYASHARP REDUCTIONINFUTUREBENElTACCRUALSOCCURRINGDURINGACONVERSIONFROMATRADITIONALDElNEDBENElT PLANTOACASHBALANCEPLAN 'OVERNMENTCOULDCHANGE3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICARE  !LTHOUGH 3OCIAL 3ECURITYS NORMAL RETIREMENT AGE NOW IS GRADUALLY RISING FROM  TO  IT COULD BE EXTENDEDBEYONDBYASCHEDULEORBYINDEXINGITTOLONGEVITY3OCIAL3ECURITYSEARLYRETIREMENTAGE OFHASLONGSERVEDASANIMPORTANTBENCHMARKFORRETIRING2AISINGITTOKEEPPACEWITHTHENORMAL RETIREMENTAGE FOREXAMPLE BYMAKINGBENElTSFORMERLYPAYABLEATNOTPAYABLEUNTILANOLDERAGE COULDHAVEAPOWERFULEFFECTONALLRETIREMENTPROGRAMCOSTS/FCOURSE SHOULDDIRECTLYINCREASINGTHE RETIREMENTAGENOTBEACCEPTABLETOTHEGENERALPUBLIC ASANALTERNATIVE CHANGESINTHEBENElTFORMULA CANACHIEVESIMILAROBJECTIVES  4OENCOURAGEEMPLOYMENTOFOLDERWORKERS -EDICARECOULDBEMADETHEPRIMARYHEALTHCARECOVER AGE BEGINNING AT AGE  REGARDLESS OF EMPLOYMENT STATUS .OTE THAT INCREASING -EDICARES ELIGIBILITY AGEWOULDNOTRESULTINSUBSTANTIALCOSTREDUCTIONSBECAUSEPEOPLEINTHEIRMID SHAVERELATIVELYLOW -EDICAREEXPENSES 'OVERNMENTSHOULDENCOURAGEWORKERSTODELAYRETIREMENT 'IVENTHEDEMOGRAPHICREALITIESTHATPEOPLEARELIVINGLONGERANDSPENDINGMORETIMEINRETIREMENT PURSUING ANEWVISIONOFRETIREMENTASAPROCESSRATHERTHANASINGLEEVENTISCRITICAL$ElNEDBENElTPLANSCANBEMODI lED WITHTHEENCOURAGEMENTOFFAVORABLE)23RULEMAKING TOALLOWWORKERSMOREmEXIBILITY ESSENTIALLYALLOWING THEMTODELAYTHEIRRETIREMENT  -ANYRETIREESWOULDCONTINUETOWORKWITHCURRENTEMPLOYERSONAREDUCEDWORKSCHEDULEˆOFTENRE FERREDTOASPHASEDRETIREMENTˆIF)23RULESMADETHISMOREFEASIBLE3UCHAPOLICYWOULDSLOWTHELOSS OFINSTITUTIONALKNOWLEDGEHELDBYOLDERWORKERS WHILERECOGNIZINGTHATRETIREMENTCANBEAPROCESSTHAT ALLOWSBOTHEMPLOYERSANDEMPLOYEESTOBENElT

)335%"2)%&!02),


 $ElNEDBENElTANDDISABILITYPLANSENABLEWORKERSINPHYSICALLYDEMANDINGJOBSANDTHOSEUNABLETO WORKBECAUSEOFIMPAIRMENTTOCHOOSEANEARLYRETIREMENT&LEXIBILITYSTEMMINGFROMAMOREAFFORDABLE DElNEDBENElTSYSTEMWILLALLOWEMPLOYERSTODESIGNPLANSTHATlTTHENEEDSOFTHESEWORKERSWHILEALSO MEETINGBUSINESSNEEDS

#ONCLUSION $EMOGRAPHICSHAVECHANGEDSUBSTANTIALLYSINCEWHENTHEAVERAGELIFEEXPECTANCYAFTERRETIREMENTWAS YEARS)NADDITION PEOPLEARESTARTINGWORKLATERINLIFEANDENDINGITEARLIER#URRENTLY DUEBOTHTOLONGERLIFE EXPECTANCYANDEARLIERRETIREMENT PEOPLEAREMORELIKELYTOSPENDYEARSINRETIREMENT$ESPITETHESECHANGES LAWSANDREGULATIONSHAVENOTKEPTPACE4HEYDONOTREmECTTHEDESIREOFEMPLOYERSTORETAINOLDERWORKERSOR THEDESIREOFEMPLOYEESTOCONTINUEWORKING EITHERONAFULL TIMEORGRADUALLYREDUCEDSCHEDULE 4OACCOMMODATETHENEEDSOFEMPLOYERSANDEMPLOYEES WEHAVEOUTLINEDANUMBEROFWAYSTHATEMPLOYERS COULDRETAINOLDERWORKERS4HESEINCLUDERAISINGTHEEARLYRETIREMENTAGEALTERINGTHEUSEOFSUBSIDIZEDEARLY RETIREMENTAND SUBJECTTOPROTECTIONSFOROLDERWORKERS USINGPLANDESIGNSSUCHASCASHBALANCEANDPENSION EQUITYPLANSTHATPROVIDEmEXIBILITY%MPLOYEESCOULDDELAYRETIREMENT THROUGHPHASEDRETIREMENTPROGRAMS 4HEGOVERNMENTCANFACILITATEANEWENVIRONMENTFORBOTH WITHNECESSARYCHANGESINRELEVANTLAWSANDREGULA TIONS 4HE!CADEMYS2ETIREMENT3ECURITY0RINCIPLES4ASK&ORCEENCOURAGESPOLICY MAKERSTOCONSIDERTHENEEDSOF EMPLOYERSANDEMPLOYEESINLIGHTOFINCREASINGLIFEEXPECTANCYANDTODEVELOPANATIONALRETIREMENTPOLICYTHAT WILLENHANCETHElNANCIALSECURITYINRETIREMENTOFALL!MERICANS

)335%"2)%&!02),


retire_april06.4