Issuu on Google+

3EPTEMBER 

)SSUE"RIEF

! M E R I C A N ! C A D E M Y O F ! C T UA R I E S

7ADING4HROUGH -EDICAL)NSURANCE0OOLS!0RIMER 0OLICYMAKERSHAVEBEENEXPLORINGTHEUSEOFPOOLINGMECHANISMSASAMEANSTOEXPANDTHEAVAILABILITYOFHEALTHCARECOVERAGE $ISCUSSIONSATBOTHTHEFEDERALANDSTATELEVELSHAVEFOCUSEDONMEDICALINSURANCEPOOLSANDTHEIRPOTENTIALTOPROVIDEMORE STABLEANDAFFORDABLEHEALTHINSURANCECOVERAGE 0OOLINGISESSENTIALFORAVIABLEINSURANCEPROGRAM BUTBYITSELFITSNOGUARANTEE!SPOLICYMAKERSEXPLORETHEUSEOFALTERNATIVE POOLINGARRANGEMENTSINVOLVINGDIFFERENTRATINGMECHANISMSANDORBENElTREQUIREMENTS ITISIMPORTANTTOUNDERSTANDHOW THESEALTERNATIVESWILLAFFECTEXISTINGPOOLS ANDHOWEXISTINGPOOLSWILLAFFECTTHENEWPOOLS0OOLINGMUSTUSETECHNIQUESTO MINIMIZESELECTIONINAVOLUNTARYINSURANCEMARKET/THERWISE POOLSTHATATTRACTTHOSEWITHHIGHEREXPECTEDCLAIMSWILLHAVE HIGHERRATESANDAPREMIUMSPIRALCOULDRESULTUNLESSSUBSIDIZEDBYSOMEMECHANISM 4HISISSUEBRIEFDESCRIBESTHETYPESOFMEDICALINSURANCEPOOLS HIGHLIGHTSISSUESTHATAREFUNDAMENTALTOPOOLING ANDILLUSTRATES HOWCHANGESWITHINAMULTIPLESMALL EMPLOYERPOOLWOULDAFFECTMEDICALCOSTS4HEPAPERALSODESCRIBESDIFFERENTRATINGMETH ODSANDEXAMINESTHEPOTENTIALEFFECTSOFINTRODUCINGANEWRATINGMECHANISMINANEXISTINGINSURANCEMARKET

-EDICAL)NSURANCE0OOLS 4HEPOOLINGOFRISKISFUNDAMENTALTOALLTYPESOFINSURANCEBECAUSELARGEPOOLSOFSIMILARRISKSEXHIBITSTABLEANDMEA SURABLECHARACTERISTICSTHATENABLEACTUARIESTOESTIMATEFUTURECOSTSWITHINANACCEPTABLERANGEOFACCURACY4HIS INTURN ENABLESACTUARIESTODETERMINEPREMIUMLEVELSTHATWILLGENERALLYBESUFlCIENTTOFUNDCLAIMSANDADMINISTRATIVECOSTS THATARESTABLEOVERTIME RELATIVETOOVERALLCOSTTRENDS7HILETHISPAPERFOCUSESONMEDICALINSURANCE THEABILITYTOAC 4HE!MERICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUARIESISANATIONALORGANIZATIONFORMEDINTOBRINGTOGETHER INASINGLEENTITY ACTUARIESOFALLSPECIALIZATIONSWITHINTHE5NITED3TATES!MAJOR PURPOSEOFTHE!CADEMYISTOACTASAPUBLICINFORMATIONORGANIZATIONFORTHEPROFESSION!CADEMYCOMMITTEES TASKFORCESANDWORKGROUPSREGULARLYPREPARETESTIMONYANDPRO VIDEINFORMATIONTO#ONGRESSANDSENIORFEDERALPOLICY MAKERS COMMENTONPROPOSEDFEDERALANDSTATEREGULATIONS ANDWORKCLOSELYWITHTHE.ATIONAL!SSOCIATIONOF)NSURANCE #OMMISSIONERSANDSTATEOFFICIALSONISSUESRELATEDTOINSURANCE PENSIONSANDOTHERFORMSOFRISKFINANCING4HE!CADEMYESTABLISHESQUALIFICATIONSTANDARDSFORTHEACTUARIAL PROFESSIONINTHE5NITED3TATESANDSUPPORTSTWOINDEPENDENTBOARDS4HE!CTUARIAL3TANDARDS"OARDPROMULGATESSTANDARDSOFPRACTICEFORTHEPROFESSION ANDTHE!CTUARIAL "OARDFOR#OUNSELINGAND$ISCIPLINEHELPSTOENSUREHIGHSTANDARDSOFPROFESSIONALCONDUCTAREMET4HE!CADEMYALSOSUPPORTSTHE*OINT#OMMITTEEFORTHE#ODEOF0ROFESSIONAL #ONDUCT WHICHDEVELOPSSTANDARDSOFCONDUCTFORTHE53ACTUARIALPROFESSION -EMBERSOFTHE3MALL'ROUP-ARKET4ASK&ORCEINCLUDE+AREN"ENDER !3! -!!! &#! #HAIRPERSON2ONALD%"ACHMAN -!!! &3!$AVID*"AHN -!!! &3!*AMES%$RENNAN -!!! &#! &3!*OHN$&LEMING -!!! !3!,EONARD+OLOMS -!!! &3!2ICHARD-.IEMIEC -!!!$AVID!3HEA*R -!!! &3! -ARTHA-3PENNY -!!! A3!-ARK$7ERNICKE -!!! &3!AND*EFFREY-ILLER -!!! &#! &3! -#!

!MER ICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUAR IES 3EVENTEENTH3TREET.73EVENTH&LOOR7ASHINGTON $# 4EL&AX WWWACTUARYORG +EVIN#RONIN %XECUTIVE$IRECTOR .OEL#ARD $IRECTOROF#OMMUNICATIONS #RAIG(ANNA $IRECTOROF0UBLIC0OLICY #ORI%5CCELLO 3ENIOR(EALTH&ELLOW (OLLY+WIATKOWSKI 3ENIOR(EALTH0OLICY!NALYST&EDERAL ยน4HE!MERICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUARIES!LL2IGHTS2ESERVED


CURATELYESTIMATEADEQUATEPREMIUMLEVELSISTHEFOUNDATIONOFINSURANCEANDALSOAPPLIESTOOTHERINSURANCE LINES INCLUDINGLIFEANDPROPERTYANDCASUALTY )NSIMPLESTTERMS MEDICALINSURANCEPOOLSARELARGEGROUPSOFINDIVIDUALENTITIESEITHERINDIVIDUALSOREM PLOYERS WHOSE MEDICAL COSTS CLAIMS ARE COMBINED FOR EVALUATING lNANCIAL EXPERIENCE ANDOR DETERMINING PREMIUMS4HESIZEOFTHEPOOLMAYVARYFROMAFEWHUNDREDINDIVIDUALSTOHUNDREDSOFTHOUSAND%VERYPOOL HASELIGIBILITYREQUIREMENTSFORINDIVIDUALMEMBERS%LIGIBILITYREQUIREMENTSSUCHASEMPLOYMENT GROUPSIZE OR ASSOCIATIONMEMBERSHIP FOREXAMPLE ARETHEKEYELEMENTSTHATBINDMEMBERSOFTHEPOOLTOGETHER (OWGROUPSAREPOOLEDANDHOWPREMIUMSVARYWITHINAPOOLDEPENDSONMANYFACTORS INCLUDINGSTATELAWS THEREGULATORYENVIRONMENT ANDINSURERPRACTICES"ECAUSETHESEFACTORSVARYBYSTATE POOLINGPRACTICESAND RATINGPRACTICESVARY

4YPESOF-EDICAL)NSURANCE0OOLS ,ARGE %MPLOYER0OOLS !LLPOOLSAREFORMEDFORTHEPURPOSEOFCOMBININGTHEMEDICALEXPERIENCEOFITSMEMBERSINORDERTOMAKEFUTURE CLAIMSMOREPREDICTABLE,ARGEEMPLOYERSGENERALLYMORETHAN EMPLOYEES ALMOSTUNIVERSALLYWILLHAVEA POOLCONSISTINGSOLELYOFTHEIROWNEMPLOYEESWITHPREMIUMSGENERATEDENTIRELYFROMTHECLAIMSOFTHEIREMPLOY EESANDDEPENDENTS ALTHOUGHSOMEEMPLOYERSALSOINCLUDERETIREESANDTHEIRDEPENDENTSWITHINTHEPOOL0OOL MEMBERSHIPISUSUALLYAUTOMATIC WITHAVERYLARGEPERCENTAGEOFEMPLOYEESPARTICIPATINGDUETOTHESIGNIlCANT PREMIUMSUBSIDIESTHEEMPLOYEROFTENPROVIDES4HEPROCESSOFELECTINGˆORNOTELECTINGˆTOPARTICIPATEINA HEALTHINSURANCEPROGRAMISREFERREDTOAShSELECTIONvASWELLAShTAKEUPvANDITPLAYSACRITICALROLEINTHESUCCESS ORFAILUREOFANYMEDICALINSURANCEPOOL4HISWILLBEDISCUSSEDINMOREDETAILLATERINTHEPAPER !LARGE EMPLOY ERPOOLISFORMEDASANINCIDENTALBY PRODUCTOFTHEEMPLOYERSBUSINESSPROCESSESANDACTIVITIESANDELIGIBILITYFOR SUCHAPOOLISBASEDSOLELYONANINDIVIDUALSEMPLOYMENTWITHTHELARGEEMPLOYER%MPLOYMENTCANBETHOUGHT OFASTHEhGLUEvTHATBINDSTHEPOOLMEMBERSTOGETHER 0OOLMEMBERSAREGENERALLYDIVERSEASFARASAGE GENDER ANDHEALTHSTATUS)FTHEREAREENOUGHMEMBERS THEIRDI VERSITYPRODUCESFAIRLYSTABLEMEDICALUTILIZATIONANDCLAIMSTHATCANBEUSEDASTHEBASISFORPREDICTINGFUTUREPRE MIUMS)NCONTRAST POOLSWITHLOWMEMBERSHIPCANEXPERIENCEEXTREMEmUCTUATIONSINUTILIZATIONANDCLAIMS 3OMEINDIVIDUALSAREHIGHUSERSOFMOREINTENSIVESERVICESANDARECONSIDEREDHIGHERRISKS WHILEOTHERSWHOUSE FEWERSERVICESARECONSIDEREDLOWERRISKS)NEVERYPOOLTHEHEALTHIERRISKSSUBSIDIZETHEUNHEALTHYRISKS&OR APOOLTOREMAINVIABLEANDINTACT ITMUSTBEOFSUFlCIENTSIZETOREmECTABALANCEDCROSS SECTIONOFRISKS)F APOOLISCOMPOSEDONLYOFHIGHRISKS THEPREMIUMSWILLBEHIGH)NAVOLUNTARYMARKET HIGHPREMIUMSRESULT INHEALTHIERRISKSELECTINGORSELECTING NOTTOPARTICIPATEBECAUSETHEYDONOTPERCEIVETHEPREMIUMSASBEINGA WISEECONOMICALPURCHASE!SARESULT THEPOOLISMADEUPOFADISPROPORTIONATESHAREOFLESSHEALTHYRISKS!NTI SELECTIONRESULTSWHENTHEREISNOECONOMICINCENTIVEFORHEALTHYINDIVIDUALSTOPURCHASEINSURANCE!NTI SELEC TIONISPARTIALLYMITIGATEDINALARGE SINGLE EMPLOYERPOOLBECAUSETHEEMPLOYERGENERALLYFUNDSTHEMAJORITYOF THEPREMIUM PROVIDINGAVERYREALECONOMICINCENTIVEFOREMPLOYEESTOPARTICIPATEREGARDLESSOFTHEIRHEALTH RISKS3INCETHEEMPLOYEESARENOTRESPONSIBLEFORTHEMAJORITYOFTHECOSTOFTHEPROGRAM THEIREXPECTEDRETURN INTHEFORMOFCLAIMCOMPENSATIONISEQUALTOORGREATERTHANTHEPREMIUMCONTRIBUTIONSTHEYMAKE 4HEEMPLOYERFURTHERLIMITSSELECTIONBYREQUIRINGMEMBERSTOENROLLONLYATACERTAINTIMEˆWHENTHEYBE COMElRSTELIGIBLEAFTERCOMPLETIONOFANYPROBATIONARYPERIOD ANDATANNUALOPENENROLLMENTS"ENElTSARE OFTENLIMITEDFORTHETREATMENTOFPRE EXISTINGCONDITIONSFORINDIVIDUALSWHOWAIVEDINSURANCEENTIRELYWHEN THEYWERElRSTELIGIBLEANDNOWWANTTOPARTICIPATE4HESEENROLLMENTRESTRICTIONS COUPLEDWITHLIMITEDBENElTS FORPRE EXISTINGCONDITIONS HELPMINIMIZETHEPOSSIBILITYOFhJUSTINTIMEvINSURANCEWHEREEMPLOYEESWOULD DELAYTHEPURCHASEOFINSURANCEUNTILTHEYNEEDCARE%MPLOYMENTPRACTICESANDPROCESSESACTASTHEhGLUEvTHAT KEEPPOOLMEMBERSINTACTANDPROVIDEABARRIERAGAINSTENTRYBYADISPROPORTIONATENUMBEROFHIGHRISKS &IGURE!ILLUSTRATESADISTRIBUTIONOFCLAIMSANDTHEMEMBERSWITHCLAIMSATTHOSELEVELSFORATYPICALLARGEEMPLOYER )335%"2)%&3%04%-"%2


&)'52%!

.OTE4HEINFORMATIONPROVIDEDIN&IGURE!ISFORILLUSTRATIVEPURPOSESONLY7HILETHEMAGNITUDEOFTHENUMBERS INDICATESEXPERIENCEFORLARGEEMPLOYERSINGENERAL THEACTUALNUMBERSFORANYPARTICULAREMPLOYERWOULDVARY 4HEEMPLOYERDECIDESTHELEVELOFBENElTSOFFERED THECHOICEOFBENElTS ANDTHEAMOUNTOFSUBSIDYPROVIDED $ECISIONSLEFTTOINDIVIDUALEMPLOYEESAREGENERALLYLIMITEDTOPARTICIPATIONTAKE UP INTHEPOOLANDCHOICEOF BENElTPLAN"ECAUSEOFTHEEMPLOYERSUBSIDY TAKE UPRATESHAVEHISTORICALLYBEENVERYHIGH!LARGEEMPLOYER ESSENTIALLYMAKESTHEHEALTHCAREDECISIONSFORTHEEMPLOYEESRATHERTHANINDIVIDUALEMPLOYEESELECTINGTOSEEK COVERAGEONTHEIROWN )NDIVIDUAL0OOLS 0OOLSOFINDIVIDUALSWHOPURCHASEINSURANCEAREATTHEOTHERENDOFTHECHOICESPECTRUM)NDIVIDUALSMUSTACTIVELY SEEKANDPURCHASEMEDICALINSURANCEANDMUSTFUNDTHEENTIRECOSTOFTHEPREMIUMINADDITIONTOALLCOSTSHARING PROVISIONSOFTHEBENElTPLAN)NDIVIDUALSJOINTHEPOOLSOLELYBECAUSETHEYWANTTOPURCHASEINSURANCE NOTBECAUSE THEYAREALREADYMEMBERSOFANOTHERGROUP SUCHASEMPLOYEES!DVERSESELECTIONISTHEREFOREAMAJORCONCERNIN THEINDIVIDUALMARKET)NDIVIDUALSMUSTAPPLYFORMEMBERSHIPINTHEPOOLANDMUSTMEETEXPLICITMEMBERSHIP REQUIREMENTS WHICHCANVARYBYTHEPARTICULARPOOL4HESEREQUIREMENTSWILLHAVEDIFFERENTEFFECTSONCLAIMCOSTS 4HELOWESTCLAIMCOSTSAREEVIDENTINPOOLSWHEREINDIVIDUALSMUSTSATISFYANINSURERSMEDICALUNDERWRITINGRE QUIREMENTS4HEREQUIREMENTSMAYBELOOSE REQUIRINGONLYASERIESOFANSWERSONANAPPLICATIONFORCOVERAGE RESULTINGINAFAIRLYHIGHNUMBEROFUNHEALTHYMEMBERS/RTHEREQUIREMENTSMAYBESTRINGENT REQUIRINGPHYSICIAN STATEMENTSANDBLOODANDmUIDTESTS RESULTINGINHEALTHIERMEMBERS-ORESTRINGENTREQUIREMENTSWILLGENERALLY PRODUCEPOOLSWITHLOWERINITIALCLAIMCOSTSTHANINPOOLSWITHLESSSTRINGENTREQUIREMENTS4HEUNDERWRITINGPRO CESSISGENERALLYAPPLIEDONANINDIVIDUALBASIS THUSANAPPLICANTMAYBEACCEPTEDWHILEADEPENDENTISREJECTED 4HEEFFECTSOFUNDERWRITINGWEAROFFOVERTIMEASINDIVIDUALSWHOWEREHEALTHYATTHETIMEOFAPPLICATIONACQUIRE NEWHEALTHCONDITIONS%VENPOOLSTHATCOMBINEINDIVIDUALSWHOWEREPREVIOUSLYUNDERWRITTENWITHANONGOING STREAMOFNEWENTRANTS HOWEVER WILLHAVELOWEROVERALLCLAIMCOSTSTHANPOOLSWITHOUTUNDERWRITING 4HEHIGHESTCLAIMCOSTSAREINPOOLSCOMPOSEDOFHIGH RISKORUNINSURABLEINDIVIDUALS CALLEDHIGH RISKPOOLS 4YPICALLY INDIVIDUALSMUSTHAVEBEENREJECTEDBYONEORMOREINSURANCECOMPANIESFORMEDICALREASONSTOEN ROLLINAHIGH RISKPOOL-EDICALCOSTSINTHESEPOOLSWILLBEVERYHIGHBECAUSETHEYARECOMPOSEDONLYOFSICK PEOPLEWITHSERIOUSHEALTHCONDITIONSWHOAREEXPECTEDTOBEHIGHUSERSOFMEDICALSERVICES7HILETHEPREMI UMSFORHIGH RISKGROUPSARETYPICALLYPERCENTOFTHEPREMIUMINTHEINDIVIDUALMARKETFORASTANDARDRISK ORHIGHER THEYAREUSUALLYINSUFlCIENTTOFUNDCLAIMSANDADMINISTRATIVEEXPENSESANDTHEREFORENEEDTOBE SUBSIDIZEDBYOUTSIDESOURCES!POOLCOMPOSEDOFHIGH RISKINDIVIDUALSWILLNOTRESULTINLOWPREMIUMSAND #OMPREHENSIVE(EALTH)NSURANCEFOR(IGH 2ISK)NDIVIDUALS .INETEENTH%DITION  PUBLISHEDBY#! )NCINCOOPERATIONWITHTHE.ATIONAL !SSOCIATIONOF3TATE#OMPREHENSIVE(EALTH)NSURANCE0LANS

)335%"2)%&3%04%-"%2


WILLNOTBESELF SUSTAINING-ERELYFORMINGAPOOLWILLNOTAUTOMATICALLYGUARANTEETHATCOSTSWILLSTAYLOWAND STABLEINTHEFUTURE

-ERELYFORMINGAPOOLWILLNOTAUTOMATICALLYGUARANTEE THATCOSTSWILLSTAYLOWANDSTABLEINTHEFUTURE

/THER-EDICAL0OOLS 3OMETIMESINSURERSPOOLSEVERALMID SIZEEMPLOYERSTOGETHER4HEPREMIUMSFORANYSPECIlCEMPLOYERWILLBE ABLENDOFTHEIROWNEXPERIENCEANDTHEEXPERIENCEOFTHEPOOLASAWHOLE4HEAGGREGATEMEDICALCOSTSINTHESE POOLS HOWEVER WILLAPPROACHTHOSEOFALARGEEMPLOYERBECAUSETHEPOOLISINCIDENTALTOOTHERBUSINESSPRO CESSESANDACTIVITIESANDMID SIZEEMPLOYERSWILLGENERALLYHAVESIMILARDEMOGRAPHICSANDHEALTHRISKS /THERPOOLSMAYBECOMPOSEDOFMANYSMALLEMPLOYERSWITHALARGECOMBINEDMEMBERSHIP4HEEXPERIENCE OFALLEMPLOYERSISPOOLEDTODETERMINEBASICPREMIUMCOSTS ALTHOUGHTHEPREMIUMSFORANYSPECIlCEMPLOYER MAYVARYBASEDONDEMOGRAPHICSANDTHEHEALTHSTATUSOFITSEMPLOYEESANDORDEPENDENTS4HEDEMOGRAPHICS FORANYSPECIlCSMALLEMPLOYERMAYNOTBEINDICATIVEOFTHEDEMOGRAPHICSOFTHEOVERALLPOOLBECAUSETHEREARE NOTENOUGHEMPLOYEESINANYSPECIlCSMALLEMPLOYERGROUPTOREmECTTHEENTIRESPECTRUMOFRISK)NSURANCEFOR INDIVIDUALSINTHESEPOOLSISNOTTYPICALLYUNDERWRITTEN3INCESMALLEMPLOYERSARENOTREQUIREDTOOFFERINSUR ANCEPROGRAMS EITHERLEGALLYORCOMPETITIVELY THOSEWHODOOFFERSUCHCOVERAGEOFTENHAVEHIGHERCLAIMCOSTS DUETOTHEINDIVIDUALSELECTIONINVOLVEDINTHEEMPLOYEESDECISIONTOPURCHASEACOMMONEXAMPLEISFORAN OWNERTOOFFERINSURANCETOSECURECOVERAGEFORHISHERSELFANDDEPENDENTS 0OOLSOFSMALLEMPLOYERSMAYALSO HAVEHIGHERCLAIMSCOSTSBECAUSESMALLEMPLOYERSOFTENDONOTHAVETHESTRINGENTEMPLOYMENTREQUIREMENTS THATLARGEEMPLOYERSMAYHAVE,ARGEEMPLOYERSAREMOREAPTTOHAVEFORMALPROCESSESINPLACETOSELECTIVELY RECRUITEMPLOYEESWHOMEETPHYSICALREQUIREMENTSFORCERTAINJOBS FOREXAMPLE WHILESMALLEMPLOYERSTYPICALLY DONOTHAVESUCHEMPLOYMENTREQUIREMENTS &IGURE"ILLUSTRATESRELATIVECLAIMCOSTSBYEMPLOYERSIZEUSINGTHECOSTSFORGROUPSWITHMORETHANEMPLOYEESAS THEBASEFORCOMPARISONINASTATEREQUIRINGTHATGROUPINSURANCEBEOFFEREDTOEMPLOYERSWITHONEORMORELIVES )NTHISSTATE INSURINGENTITIESWEREREQUIREDTOPROVIDEGUARANTEE ISSUECOVERAGETOGROUPSOFONESELF EMPLOYED INDIVIDUALS WITHINTHESAMERATINGBANDSASTHEYWEREREQUIREDTOUSEFORSMALLEMPLOYERGROUPSGROUPSOFBE TWEENTWOANDEMPLOYEES 4HE(EALTH)NSURANCE0ORTABILITYAND!CCOUNTABILITY!CT()0!! REQUIRESINSUR ANCECOMPANIESTOPROVIDEGUARANTEE ISSUECOVERAGETOEMPLOYERGROUPSOFBETWEENTWOANDEMPLOYEES &)'52%" 2ELATIVE#LAIM#OSTSBY%MPLOYER3IZE



0%2#%.4!'%

    





  %-0,/9%23):%

)335%"2)%&3%04%-"%2

 




.OTE4HEINFORMATIONPROVIDEDIN&IGURE"ISFORILLUSTRATIVEPURPOSESONLY7HILETHEMAGNITUDEOFTHENUM BERSINDICATESREALEXPERIENCE THEACTUALNUMBERSWOULDVARY

/THER)SSUES $ECISION-AKING !SINGLEEMPLOYERMAKESTHEPURCHASINGDECISIONSFORALLEMPLOYEES SERVINGASTHEhGLUEvTHATHOLDSEMPLOYEES TOGETHER&ORABLOCKOFEMPLOYERSWITHLIVESEACH THEREAREPURCHASINGDECISIONS SOTHEhGLUEvISVERY THINANDWEAK4HEREISNOGUARANTEETHATALLGROUPSWILLREMAININTHEINSURANCEPOOLORTHATTHEREWOULD BEREPLACEMENTSFORTHOSEWHOLEAVE!SINGLE EMPLOYEEGROUPWILLALMOSTALWAYSFORMAPOOL WHERETHE hGLUEvISVERYTHICKANDSTRONG

!SINGLEEMPLOYERWITHEMPLOYEESISNOTTHESAME ASGROUPSWITHEMPLOYEESEACH !DMINISTRATIVE#OSTS *USTASFORMINGAPOOLDOESNOTAUTOMATICALLYRESULTINLOWERMEDICALCOSTS APOOLALSODOESNOTNECESSARILY RESULTINLOWERADMINISTRATIVEEXPENSES4HEADMINISTRATIVECOSTSINAPOOLOFSMALLEMPLOYERSVSALARGE EM PLOYERPOOLMAYBECLASSIlEDDIFFERENTLY BUTTHEACTUALCOSTSWOULDLIKELYBESIMILAR,ARGEEMPLOYERSHAVEHU MANRESOURCEDEPARTMENTSTOHANDLEHEALTHINSURANCEISSUESSUCHASENROLLMENTANDPREMIUMCOLLECTION4HEY WILLOFTENUSEBENElTCONSULTANTSINSTEADOFANINSURERSSTAFFFORPLANDESIGNISSUES3MALLEMPLOYERS ESPECIALLY VERYSMALLEMPLOYERS USEINSURANCEAGENTS WHORECEIVEACOMMISSIONFORTHEIRSERVICES TOSELLTHEPLAN ENROLL EMPLOYEES ANDSERVEASALIAISONWITHTHEINSURER4HUSTHEADMINISTRATIVEEXPENSESFORLARGEGROUPSVSSMALL GROUPSARELIKELYNOTCOMPARABLE4HEREARE SOME ADMINISTRATIVEEXPENSESTHATAREGREATERFORSMALLGROUPS SUCHASBILLINGANDINITIALUNDERWRITING/THERADMINISTRATIVEFUNCTIONS SUCHASPAYINGCLAIMS COMPLIANCE OR PROVIDERNEGOTIATIONS OFFERLITTLEOPPORTUNITYFOREXPENSESAVINGSINANYMEDICALINSURANCEPOOL 0ROVIDER2EIMBURSEMENT ,ARGEINSURINGENTITIESTHATHAVEMEMBERSCONCENTRATEDINACONlNEDGEOGRAPHICAREAAREOFTENABLETONEGOTIATE MOREFAVORABLEPROVIDERREIMBURSEMENTLEVELSTHANANINSURINGENTITYOFTHESAMESIZEWHOSEMEMBERSHIPISDIS TRIBUTEDACROSSSEVERALSTATESORWHICHHASSMALLERINSURINGENTITIES)TISCOMMONPRACTICEFORANINSURERTOMAKE THESAMEPROVIDERREIMBURSEMENTLEVELSHOSPITALORPHYSICIANCHARGES AVAILABLETOEACHOFTHEPOOLSITMANAGES

-ANAGING!-ULTIPLE3MALL %MPLOYER0OOL !MULTIPLESMALL EMPLOYERPOOLTYPICALLYCONSISTSOFEMPLOYERSWITHTWOTOEMPLOYEES%VALUATINGlNANCIAL RESULTS AND DETERMINING NECESSARY PREMIUMS ARE AN IMPORTANT PART OF MANAGING A MULTIPLE SMALL EMPLOYER MEDICALINSURANCEPOOL$ETERMININGTHEEXPECTEDMEDICALCOSTSCANBEDIFlCULTIF FOREXAMPLE THEREARECHANG ESINTHESIZEMIXOFSMALLEMPLOYERSINTHEPOOL&ORINDIVIDUALINSURANCE THEAVERAGEDURATIONSINCEISSUEISA DETERMINANTOFMEDICALCOSTS/NCEMEDICALCOSTSAREDETERMINED THEREMAYBESTRINGENTRULESREGULATINGRATE INCREASESORPREMIUMRATES4HEEFFECTOFTHESEREGULATIONSONTHElNANCIALEXPECTATIONSOFTHEPOOLREQUIRES CAREFULCONSIDERATIONSINCETHEYCANAFFECTTHEPOOLSVIABILITY -ANAGINGTHEEFFECTSOFANTI SELECTIONISACRUCIALELEMENTOFASUCCESSFULPOOL s )NAVOLUNTARYINSURANCEMARKETWHEREINDIVIDUALUNITSBETHEYEMPLOYERUNITSORINDIVIDUALS ELECT WHETHERTOPURCHASEINSURANCE SELECTIONOCCURS s !GOALOFINSURANCEISTOMINIMIZEANTI SELECTION s 0OOLINGCANMINIMIZEANTI SELECTIONORINCREASEIT

)335%"2)%&3%04%-"%2


&ORILLUSTRATIVEPURPOSES 4ABLEREmECTSTHETYPICALDISTRIBUTIONOFPOOLMEMBERSBYSIZEOFCLAIMASPREVIOUSLY SHOWNIN&IGURE!)NTHISBASELINEEXAMPLE PERCENTOFMEMBERSHAVEANAVERAGECLAIMOF  ANDPER CENTOFMEMBERSHAVEANAVERAGECLAIMOF 4HEAVERAGECLAIMPERMEMBEROFTHEPOOLIS  4!",% "ASELINE-EMBERSHIP$ISTRIBUTIONAND"ASELINE#LAIM#OSTS -EMBERS #LAIMS !VERAGE .UMBER 0ERCENT #LAIM3IZE ;!= ;"=                    

4OTAL #LAIMS ;!=X;"=            

0ERCENTOF 4OTAL#LAIMS     

3UCCESSFULLYMANAGEDPOOLSWILLPRODUCEANINCREASEINTHEAVERAGECLAIMCOSTEQUALONLYTOTHEAVERAGEOFPRO VIDERPRICEINCREASESANDOVERALLAVERAGEUTILIZATIONINCREASES)NTHISCASE WITHOTHERTHINGSBEINGEQUALIENO NEWGROUPSBEINGINTRODUCED MEMBERSOFASUBSEGMENTWILLNOTHAVEASTRONGREASONTOLEAVETHEPOOLSINCE HEALTHYMEMBERSWILLNOTlNDAhBETTERDEALvELSEWHERE4ABLEILLUSTRATESTHEOUTCOMEIFTHEREWEREAPERCENT PROVIDERPRICEINCREASE&ORSIMPLICITY THEEXAMPLESASSUMENOUTILIZATIONINCREASES 4!",% "ASELINE$ISTRIBUTIONWITHA0ROVIDER)NCREASEIN#OST -EMBERS #LAIMS !VERAGE .UMBER 0ERCENT #LAIM3IZE ;!= ;"=                     )NCREASEFROM"ASELINE 

4OTAL #LAIMS ;!=X;"=            

0ERCENTOF 4OTAL#LAIMS     

)N4ABLE TOTALCLAIMSANDTHEAVERAGECLAIMINCREASEBYPERCENT.EVERTHELESS THEDISTRIBUTIONOFCLAIMS EQUALSTHATUNDERTHEBASELINEEXAMPLE )F THE DISTRIBUTION OF MEMBERS BY SUBSEGMENT WERE TO CHANGE HOWEVER THE EQUILIBRIUM OF THE POOL COULD CHANGE RESULTINGINANINCREASEABOVETHEAVERAGECLAIMCOSTIN4ABLE!LTHOUGHTHERESULTCOULDBEASMALLER CLAIMCOST THISISRARE 4ABLEILLUSTRATESHOWAVERYMINORSHIFTINTHEDISTRIBUTIONOFCLAIMSCOSTSCANPRODUCE ASIGNIlCANTINCREASEINTHEAVERAGECLAIMCOST

)335%"2)%&3%04%-"%2


4!",% #HANGEIN"ASELINE$ISTRIBUTIONNO0ROVIDER)NCREASEIN#OST -EMBERS #LAIMS !VERAGE .UMBER 0ERCENT #LAIM3IZE ;!= ;"=                     )NCREASEFROM"ASELINE 

4OTAL #LAIMS ;!=X;"=            

0ERCENTOF 4OTAL#LAIMS     

)N4ABLE THESHAREOFMEMBERSWITHTHELOWESTAVERAGECLAIMOFDECREASESFROMPERCENTTOPERCENT ANDTHESHARESWITHAVERAGESOF AND INCREASEFROMPERCENTTOPERCENT ANDFROMPERCENT TOPERCENT RESPECTIVELY4HERELATIVELYSMALLSHIFTINTHEDISTRIBUTIONOFCLAIMSINCREASESTHEOVERALLAVERAGEPER MEMBERBYPERCENT FROM TO  )FTHISMEMBERSHIFTISCOMBINEDWITHTHEPERCENTPROVIDERPRICEINCREASE THEAVERAGECLAIMPERMEMBER INCREASESEVENFURTHER ASILLUSTRATEDBY4ABLE 4!",% #HANGEIN"ASELINE$ISTRIBUTIONANDA0ROVIDER)NCREASEIN#OST -EMBERS #LAIMS !VERAGE 4OTAL .UMBER 0ERCENT #LAIM3IZE #LAIMS ;!= ;"= ;!=X;"=                                 )NCREASEFROM"ASELINE 

0ERCENTOF 4OTAL#LAIMS     

4HECOMBINATIONOFTHEPERCENTINCREASEINPROVIDERPAYMENTSANDTHESHIFTINMEMBERSHIPDISTRIBUTION TOHIGHERCLAIMCLASSESRESULTSINAPERCENTINCREASEINTHEAVERAGECLAIMPERMEMBER4HEAVERAGECLAIMPER MEMBERUNDERLIESTHEPREMIUMSPAIDBYEMPLOYERSMEMBERS!NINCREASEOFPERCENTCOULDBEANINDUCE MENTFORTHOSEINTHELOWERCOSTSUBSEGMENTSTOLEAVETHEPOOLSINCE s )NDIVIDUALUNITSWILLSEEKTOMAXIMIZETHEIROWNECONOMICINTERESTSTHROUGHTHESELECTIONPROCESS IFAL LOWED s )NSURINGENTITIESHAVEANECONOMICINTERESTTOATTRACTLOWEST COSTRISKS IFALLOWED

)335%"2)%&3%04%-"%2


-ANAGEMENT4ECHNIQUES 3EVERALYEARSAGO MANYSTATESALLOWEDINSURERSTOMANAGEANDPRICETHEIRSMALL EMPLOYERPOOLSWITHLITTLEREGULA TION RESULTINGINEXCESSIVERATEINCREASESANDRE UNDERWRITING ANDTHEUSEOFOTHERTECHNIQUESTOFORCEEMPLOYERS TODROPCOVERAGE3UCHPRACTICESWOULDGENERALLYBECONSIDEREDUNACCEPTABLETODAYANDSTATESHAVESINCEADOPTED REGULATIONSTOLIMITTHEPREMIUMSPAIDBYMEMBERSOFANINSURERSSMALL EMPLOYERPOOLRELATIVETOOTHERMEMBERS INTHEPOOL4HEFEDERALGOVERNMENTHASENACTED()0!! WHICHREQUIRESGUARANTEEDISSUEFORGROUPSOFBETWEEN TWOAND ALLOWINGEMPLOYERSTHEABILITYTORENEWCOVERAGE()0!!DOESNOT HOWEVER ADDRESSRATEREGULATION 3TATESCOMMONLYUSETHEFOLLOWINGTHREERATINGMETHODS 0URE#OMMUNITY2ATING0#2 %VERYMEMBEROFANINSURERSPOOLWITHINTHESAMEGEOGRAPHICAREAPAYSTHE SAMEPREMIUMRATE -ODIlED#OMMUNITY2ATING-#2 0REMIUMRATESMAYVARYBYAGEANDGENDERGENERALLY BUTNOTBYHEALTH STATUSORTHEEMPLOYERGROUPSCLAIMSEXPERIENCE 6ARIATIONSOFTHE)NITIAL.!)#2ATING-ODEL.!)# 2ATESMAYVARYBYAGEANDGENDERANDBYLIMITEDPER CENTAGESBASEDONHEALTHSTATUSANDCLAIMSEXPERIENCE4HESELIMITSAREFREQUENTLY PERCENTTO PERCENT OFTHEAVERAGERATE ALTHOUGHSOMESTATESMAYHAVEHIGHERORLOWERLIMITS4HEREMAYALSOBELIMITSONANNUAL RATEINCREASESATTRIBUTABLETOCHANGESINMORBIDITY WHICHISTHERELATIVEHEALTHSTATUSOFALLTHEMEMBERSOFA PARTICULAREMPLOYERGROUP %ACHOFTHEABOVETECHNIQUESHASTHEPOTENTIALTOPRODUCESTABLEPOOLEXPERIENCEOVERTIME ALTHOUGHTHEABILITY TOATTRACTABROADDISTRIBUTIONOFRISKSVARIES4HEPURECOMMUNITYRATINGTECHNIQUEISMOSTEFFECTIVEATIM PROVINGPREMIUMAFFORDABILITYFOROLDERANDLESSHEALTHYGROUPS%MPLOYERSWITHYOUNGANDHEALTHYMEMBERS HOWEVER ARELESSLIKELYTOPARTICIPATEBECAUSETHEIRPREMIUMSCOULDBEMUCHHIGHERTHANTHEEXPECTEDVALUEOF THECOVERAGE)NEFFECT THEDISTRIBUTIONOFENROLLEESWOULDSHIFTTOWARDTHOSEWITHHIGHERCLAIMSCOSTS RESULTING INANINCREASEINPREMIUMSASILLUSTRATEDIN4ABLESAND -ODIlEDCOMMUNITYRATINGREmECTSSIGNIlCANTDIFFERENCESBYGENDERANDAGESEE&IGURE# %MPLOYERSWITH YOUNGER EMPLOYEES ARE INDUCED TO JOIN AND REMAIN IN THE POOL BECAUSE THEIR PREMIUM COSTS ARE LOWER !N EMPLOYERWITHOLDEREMPLOYEES HOWEVER MAYBELESSLIKELYTOJOINTHEPOOL ANDMORELIKELYTOLEAVETHEPOOL BECAUSEOFHIGHERPREMIUMCOSTS &IGURE# 6ARIATIONIN#LAIM#OSTBY!GEAND'ENDER

 &%-!,%

#LAIMCOSTINDOLLARS



-!,%

   

9%!23

9%!23 !'%

3OURCE 4HE INFORMATION PROVIDED IN &IGURE # IS FOR ILLUSTRATIVE PURPOSES ONLY7HILE THE MAGNITUDE OF THE NUMBERSINDICATESREALEXPERIENCE THEACTUALNUMBERSWOULDVARY )335%"2)%&3%04%-"%2


4HE.!)#RATINGMETHODNORMALLYCOMBINESVARIATIONSWITHINLIMITEDPERCENTAGESBASEDONHEALTHSTATUSAND CLAIMS EXPERIENCE WITH AGE AND GENDER RATING 4HIS APPROACH PRODUCES A WIDE RANGE IN PREMIUM RATES OFTEN RESULTINGINAMORESTABLEPOOL9OUNGERANDHEALTHIERGROUPSWHOAREENCOURAGEDTOJOINANDSTAYINTHEPOOL SUBSIDIZETHEPREMIUMSFORTHEOLDERANDSICKERGROUPS7HILEOLDERANDSICKERGROUPSPAYHIGHERPREMIUMSUN DERTHE.!)#MODELTHANTHEYWOULDUNDEROTHERRATINGMETHODS THEYSTILLRECEIVESUBSIDIESFROMTHEYOUNGER ANDHEALTHIERGROUPSTHATHELPFUNDCLAIMEXPENSES,IMITATIONSONRATESANDRATEINCREASESMAYINDUCEhSICKERv GROUPSTOREMAININTHEPOOL

)NTRODUCING0OOLSWITH$IFFERENT2ATING-ECHANISMS 2ECENTPROPOSALSWOULDALLOWTHEINTRODUCTIONOFNEWPOOLSPOTENTIALLYUSINGRATINGTECHNIQUESDIFFERENTFROM THOSECURRENTLYREQUIREDINTHESTATES"ENElTSOFFEREDINTHENEWPOOLSMAYALSOBEDIFFERENTFROMTHOSECUR RENTLYREQUIRED4HEIMPACTOFANEWRATINGSYSTEMONASTATESINSURANCEMARKETWILLVARYBASEDONTHERATING RULERESTRICTIONSINCURRENTSTATEREGULATIONS0URECOMMUNITYRATINGISTYPICALLYTHEMOSTRESTRICTIVERATINGTECH NIQUE WHILETHE.!)#RATINGMETHODISTHELEASTRESTRICTIVE ANDMODIlEDCOMMUNITYRATINGLIESSOMEWHEREIN BETWEEN4HEIMPACTOFINTRODUCINGALTERNATIVEBENElTPACKAGESWILLALSOVARYBASEDONASTATESCURRENTBENElT PACKAGEREQUIREMENTS )NTRODUCINGAPOOLINTOASTATEWITHLESSRESTRICTIVERATINGREQUIREMENTSMAYINDUCEYOUNGERANDHEALTHIERGROUPS TOJOINTHENEWPOOLANDOLDERANDLESSHEALTHYGROUPSTOREMAININTHEEXISTINGPOOLBECAUSEOFTHESIGNIlCANT DIFFERENCESINPREMIUMSBYAGEANDORHEALTHSTATUS&ORINSTANCE INTRODUCINGANEWPOOLWITHMODIlEDCOM MUNITYRATINGINTOASTATEWITHPURECOMMUNITYRATINGCOULDRESULTINTHEPURECOMMUNITYRATINGPOOLHAVING ANEVENHIGHERAVERAGEAGEANDHIGHERCOSTSOVERTIME4HISCOULDCREATEAhRATESPIRAL vMAKINGINSURANCEVERY EXPENSIVEANDUNATTRACTIVEFORALLBUTTHESICKESTINDIVIDUALSINTHEPOOL)NTRODUCINGAPOOLREGULATEDUNDERTHE .!)#RATINGRULES WHICHALLOWSAGEANDGENDERRATING INTOANEXISTINGMODIlEDCOMMUNITYRATINGSTATEMAY HAVESIMILARRESULTS)TCOULDINDUCESOMEEMPLOYERSTOJOINTHENEWPOOLIFTHEAGEGENDERRATINGFACTORSARENOT COMPARABLEBETWEENTHETWOPOOLS%MPLOYERSWILLSEEKTHEPOOLTHATMAXIMIZESTHEIRECONOMICWELLBEING IE THELOWESTRATESFORSIMILARBENElTS %MPLOYERGROUPSTHATPREVIOUSLYWERESUBSIDIZINGOTHERGROUPSWILLHAVE ANECONOMICINTERESTTOJOINTHEPOOLTHATREQUIRESTHEMTOCONTRIBUTETHELEASTSUBSIDY3IMILARLY GROUPSTHATARE CURRENTLYENJOYINGAHIGHSUBSIDYFROMOTHERGROUPSWILLHAVEANECONOMICINTERESTTOREMAININTHEPOOLTHAT PROVIDESTHEMTHEGREATESTSUBSIDY %MPLOYERSMAYALSOBEINDUCEDTOJOINANEWPOOLIFBENElTSOFFEREDINTHENEWPOOLARESIGNIlCANTLYLESSTHAN THOSEREQUIREDINTHEEXISTINGPOOL&OREXAMPLE GROUPSWHOSEMEMBERSDONOTUSEMANDATEDBENElTSWOULDBE INDUCEDTOJOINAPOOLWITHOUTTHOSEBENElTSANDWITHCORRESPONDINGLYLOWERPREMIUMS4HEOLDPOOLWILLHAVE HIGHERPREMIUMSSINCEITWILLBEDISPROPORTIONATELYCOMPOSEDOFENROLLEESWHOWILLUSETHEMANDATEDBENElTS )NTRODUCINGAPOOLWITHMORERESTRICTIVERATINGREQUIREMENTSINTOASTATEUSINGTHE.!)#RATINGMETHODWILL SIMILARLYRESULTINMARKETSEGMENTATION'ROUPSWITHEXPECTEDCLAIMCOSTSANDPREMIUMSTHATAREHIGHERTHAN THEEXISTINGRATESWILLJOINTHENEWPOOLTOOBTAINLOWERRATES'ROUPSWITHLOWEREXPECTEDCLAIMCOSTSANDPRE MIUMSTHANTHENEWPOOLISALLOWEDTOCHARGE HOWEVER WILLHAVEANINCENTIVETOSTAYINTHEEXISTINGPOOL4HIS INTURN WILLRESULTINTHEEXISTINGPOOLBEINGCOMPOSEDOFALARGERTHANEXPECTEDSHAREOFHEALTHYGROUPS WHICH WILLDRIVETHEPREMIUMSFURTHERDOWN4HENEWPOOL HOWEVER WILLNOTHAVEENOUGHHEALTHYGROUPSTOSUBSIDIZE THEPREMIUMSFORTHEOLDERSICKERGROUPS4HEPREMIUMSFORTHISNEWPOOLWILLINCREASE ENCOURAGINGMORE GROUPSINTHENEWPOOLTOCONSIDERTHEEXISTINGPOOL WHICHWILLDRIVEEVENMOREHEALTHYGROUPSOUTOFTHENEW POOL4HEPROCESSOFDRIVINGHEALTHIERRISKSOUTOFAPOOLISOFTENCALLEDANASSESSMENTSPIRALORADEATHSPIRAL BECAUSEONCEITBEGINS ITISUSUALLYTHEPRECURSORTOTHEDEATHOFTHEPOOL4HISWILLBETRUEWHETHERTHEPREMIUM RATEDIFFERENTIALISDUETOLESSGENEROUSBENElTSORLOWERhEXPERIENCEADJUSTMENTSvBUILTINTOTHENEWPOOLRATES

)335%"2)%&3%04%-"%2


#ONCLUSION 0OOLINGISESSENTIALFORAHEALTHYINSURANCEPROGRAM BUTITDOESNOTBYITSELF GUARANTEEVIABILITY0OLICYMAKERS NEEDTOUNDERSTANDTHEADVANTAGESOFPOOLING BUTALSOTHEDANGERSTHATCANOCCURIFPOOLSAREDISRUPTEDBY MARKETREFORMS)FALLPOOLSHAVETOABIDEBYTHESAMERULESTHATDONOTENCOURAGESELECTION THENANTI SELECTION COULDBEMINIMIZED!LLOWINGDIFFERENTRULESWITHINTHESAMEMARKETWILLDOOMAPOOLTHATHASTHEMORESTRIN GENTREQUIREMENTS ANDWILLRESULTINMARKETDISRUPTION-EDICALINSURANCEISABALANCEOFENCOURAGINGENOUGH HEALTHYRISKSTOENROLLTOSUBSIDIZETHEUNHEALTHYRISKSTHATWILLHAVETHEECONOMICINCENTIVETOPARTICIPATE#ARE MUSTBETAKENTODEVELOPPOLICIESTHATWILLRESULTINMAXIMIZINGTHEENROLLMENTOFTHESEHEALTHYRISKSWHILENOT PRICINGTHEUNHEALTHYRISKSOUTOFTHEMARKET 0OLICYMAKERSOFTENHAVETOBALANCECOMPETINGGOALSOFINCREASEDACCESSAVAILABILITYTOALLMEMBERS ANDIN CREASEDAFFORDABILITYLOWERPREMIUMS 4HESEGOALSCANPRODUCEDIFlCULTCHOICESTHATCOULDRESULTINUNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES0OLICYMAKERSSHOULDBEMINDFULOFBOTHTHEFAVORABLEANDUNFAVORABLEPOTENTIALCONSEQUENCESOF THESECHOICESASTHEYCONSIDERNEWAPPROACHESTOINCREASEACCESSANDAFFORDABILITYINHEALTHCOVERAGE

 )335% "2)%& 3%04%-"%2 


pools_sep06