Page 1

)SSUE"RIEF

*ULY 

! M E R I C A N ! C A D E M Y O F ! C T UA R I E S

4HE6ALUEOF$ElNED"ENElT0LANS $ElNED BENElT $" AND DElNED CONTRIBUTION $# PLANS ARE BOTH COMPONENTS OF A BROAD EXAMINATION OF RETIREMENT SECURITY (OWEVER THEREAREANUMBEROFDISTINCTDIFFERENCESBETWEENTHESETYPESOFRETIREMENTPLANS4HE!MERICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUARIES0ENSION #OMMITTEEHASCREATEDTHISISSUEBRIEFTODISCUSSTHESEDIFFERENCES WHATTHEYMEANTOLONG TERMRETIREMENTGOALS ANDWAYSTOACHIEVEPARITY BETWEEN$"AND$#PLANS

$ElNITIONS $ElNED BENElT PLANS $" SPECIFY THE BENElT EMPLOYEES WILL RECEIVE WHEN THEY RETIRE FROMEMPLOYMENT$"BENElTS CANBEOFANYAMOUNT CALCULATEDACCORDINGTOAFORMULAANDDElNEDINALEGALDOCUMENT&OREXAMPLE ATRADITIONAL$" FORMULAMIGHTBEPERCENTOFAVERAGECOMPENSATIONFOREVERYYEARWORKED4HUS ANINDIVIDUALWHOWORKEDFORYEARS WOULDGETPERCENTOFHISAVERAGECOMPENSATIONWHENHERETIRESONTOPOF3OCIAL3ECURITY "ECAUSETHEBENElTISDE lNED EMPLOYEESKNOWWHATBENElTPAYOUTTOEXPECTWHENTHEYRETIRE THUSENABLINGTHEMTOPLANAHEAD $ElNEDCONTRIBUTIONPLANS$# SPECIFYTHECONTRIBUTIONTHEEMPLOYERPAYSINTOTHEPLANEACHYEARFORTHEEMPLOYEE4HE AMOUNTTHATEMPLOYEESGETATRETIREMENTDEPENDSONINVESTMENTCHOICESANDMARKETTRENDS)N #ONGRESSENACTED SECTIONK OFTHE)NTERNAL2EVENUE#ODE)2# TOALLOWEMPLOYEESTOMAKEPRE TAXEMPLOYEECONTRIBUTIONSTOCER TAIN$#PLANSANDALLOWEMPLOYERSTOMATCHTHEM)NATYPICALPRIVATE SECTORK ARRANGEMENT ANEMPLOYEEMIGHT CONTRIBUTEPERCENTOFWAGESPRE TAX ANDTHEEMPLOYERMIGHTMATCHITCENTSONTHEDOLLAR FORATOTALEMPLOYER CONTRIBUTIONOFPERCENTOFTHATEMPLOYEESWAGES4HUS PRIVATESECTOREMPLOYEESSOMETIMESCONTRIBUTEMORETHANTHEIR EMPLOYER (YBRIDPLANS2ETIREMENTPLANSARECALLEDHYBRIDPLANSIFTHEYCOMBINEBOTH$"AND$#ELEMENTS&OREXAMPLE INAHY BRIDKNOWNASACASHBALANCEPLAN THEEMPLOYERPROMISESBOTHTHECONTRIBUTIONTOANACCOUNTEG PERCENTOFPAY AND 4HE!MERICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUARIESISANATIONALORGANIZATIONFORMEDINTOBRINGTOGETHER INASINGLEENTITY ACTUARIESOFALLSPECIALIZATIONSWITHINTHE5NITED3TATES!MAJORPURPOSE OFTHE!CADEMYISTOACTASAPUBLICINFORMATIONORGANIZATIONFORTHEPROFESSION!CADEMYCOMMITTEES TASKFORCESANDWORKGROUPSREGULARLYPREPARETESTIMONYANDPROVIDEINFORMATION TO#ONGRESSANDSENIORFEDERALPOLICY MAKERS COMMENTONPROPOSEDFEDERALANDSTATEREGULATIONS ANDWORKCLOSELYWITHTHE.ATIONAL!SSOCIATIONOF)NSURANCE#OMMISSIONERSANDSTATE OFFICIALSONISSUESRELATEDTOINSURANCE PENSIONSANDOTHERFORMSOFRISKFINANCING4HE!CADEMYESTABLISHESQUALIFICATIONSTANDARDSFORTHEACTUARIALPROFESSIONINTHE5NITED3TATESANDSUP PORTSTWOINDEPENDENTBOARDS4HE!CTUARIAL3TANDARDS"OARDPROMULGATESSTANDARDSOFPRACTICEFORTHEPROFESSION ANDTHE!CTUARIAL"OARDFOR#OUNSELINGAND$ISCIPLINEHELPSTOENSURE HIGHSTANDARDSOFPROFESSIONALCONDUCTAREMET4HE!CADEMYALSOSUPPORTSTHE*OINT#OMMITTEEFORTHE#ODEOF0ROFESSIONAL#ONDUCT WHICHDEVELOPSSTANDARDSOFCONDUCTFORTHE53 ACTUARIALPROFESSION -EMBERSOFTHE!MERICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUARIES0ENSION#OMMITTEEINCLUDE*AMES&6ERLAUTZ CHAIRPERSON %! &#! &3! -!!!#HESTER$!NDRZEJEWSKI VICECHAIRPERSON %! &#! &3! -!!!$ONALD!"ARNES %! &30! -!!!%DWARD%"URROWS %! -!!! -30!2ON'EBHARDTSBAUER %! &#! &3! -!!! -30!*EREMY'OLD &#! &3! -!!!!LLEN'ORRELICK %! -!!! -30!$ENNIS*'RAF %! &#! &3! -!!!$AVID2+ASS %! &3! -!!!%MILY%+ESSLER &3! -!!!%THAN%+RA %! &#! &3! -!!! -30!,ISA!,ARSEN !3! %! -!!!#HRISTINE 4-AHONEY %! &3! -!!! -#!'ERARD#-INGIONE %! &3! -!!!*OHN(-OORE %! &#! &3! -!!!"RIAN./+ONSKI !3! %! -!!!.ADINE(/RLOFF %! &#! &3! -!!!*OHN0 0ARKS %! &#! -!!! -30!-ICHAEL&0OLLACK %! &#! &3! -!!!-ARK2ULOFF %! &#! &3! -!!!$ONALD*3EGAL %! &#! &3! -!!!,AWRENCE*3HER %! &#! &3! -!!!7ILLIAM* 3OHN %! &#! &3! -!!!*UDY+3TROMBACK %! &3! -!!!,AWRENCE&7ILSON !3! %! -!!!3ARAH77RIGHT %! &#! &3! -!!!#AROLYN%:IMMERMAN %! &#! &3! -!!!

!MER ICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUAR IES 3EVENTEENTH3TREET.73EVENTH&LOOR7ASHINGTON $# 4EL&AX WWWACTUARYORG +EVIN#RONIN %XECUTIVE$IRECTOR .OEL#ARD $IRECTOROF#OMMUNICATIONS #RAIG(ANNA $IRECTOROF0UBLIC0OLICY (EATHER*ERBI 3ENIOR0ENSION0OLICY!NALYST ยน4HE!MERICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUARIES!LL2IGHTS2ESERVED


THEINVESTMENTRETURNEG PERCENTORTHE YEAR4REASURYBONDYIELD )TISA$"PLANBECAUSETHEEMPLOYER GUARANTEESTHERETURNEVENIFTHEUNDERLYINGPLANASSETSDONTPERFORMWELL(YBRIDPLANSPROVIDEmEXIBILITYIN TERMSOFHOWMUCHISCONTRIBUTEDEACHYEARANDWHERETHEFUNDSAREINVESTED4HEYALSOHAVESOMEmEXIBILITY INDESIGNANDCANIMPROVEBENElTSQUICKLYWHENNEEDED7HILEITISOFTENARGUEDTHATTRADITIONAL$"PLANSARE NOTASVALUABLEFORANINCREASINGLYMOBILEWORKFORCE THEDESIGNOFACASHBALANCEPLANALLEVIATESTHOSECONCERNS WITHOUTSACRIlCINGTHEBENElTSOFATRADITIONAL$"PLAN/THEREXAMPLESOFHYBRIDSINCLUDEPENSIONEQUITYPLANS 0%0S WHICHINEFFECTOFTENPROVIDEANINVESTMENTRETURNEQUALTOTHEINCREASEINTHEEMPLOYEESPAY *USTAFTER%2)3!WASSIGNEDINTOLAWIN PERCENTOFTHELABORFORCEPARTICIPATEDINA$"PLAN ANDPERCENT PARTICIPATEDINA$#PLAN4ODAY HOWEVER THEREVERSEISTRUEˆONLYPERCENTPARTICIPATEINA$"PLAN WHILE PERCENTPARTICIPATEINA$#PLAN

!DVANTAGESOF$"PLANSVERSUS$#PLANSTOEMPLOYEES 2ETIREMENTSECURITY$"PLANSPROVIDEEMPLOYEESWITHPREDICTABLEINCOMESFORLIFE NOMATTERHOWLONGTHEYLIVE 2ISK$"PLANSCANMOREEFFECTIVELYREDUCETHEDIFFERENTTYPESOFRISKFOREMPLOYEESTHAN$#PLANS s )NVESTMENTRISKn)NA$"PLAN THEEMPLOYERGENERALLYASSUMESTHEINVESTMENTRISK SOEMPLOYEESWILL NOTSUFFERIFTHEYRETIREINADOWNMARKET7HILEDECLINESINTHESTOCKMARKETANDLOWINTERESTRATESAF FECT$"PLANS ANDMAYPOTENTIALLYCAUSEUNDERFUNDING THOSEDECLINESAFFECT$#PLANSASWELL7ITH$" PLANS THEEMPLOYERHASSOMETIMETOBRINGTHEPLANUPTOAFULLY FUNDEDSTATUS)FTHEEMPLOYERISIN BANKRUPTCY THE0"'#PROVIDESAGUARANTEE WHICHDOESNOTCOVER$#PLANS)NAK ARRANGEMENT OLDEREMPLOYEESEXPERIENCINGADOWNMARKETMAYHAVETODELAYRETIREMENTnOREVENWORSE TIGHTENTHEIR BELTS IFMARKETSDECLINEAFTERTHEYVEMADEANIRREVOCABLEDECISIONTORETIRE s ,ONGEVITYRISKn4HE$"PLANASSUMESTHEEMPLOYEESLONGEVITYRISKBYPAYINGAPENSIONFORTHELIFEOF THEWORKER NOMATTERHOWLONGTHATMAYBE%MPLOYEESINAK CANDOTHISBYBUYINGANANNUITY AFTERTHEYRETIRE BUTFEWDO-OSTK SDONOTEVENOFFERANANNUITYPAYOUTOPTION ANDPEOPLEARE RELUCTANTTOBUYTHEIROWNANNUITIESINTHEMARKET s )NmATIONRISKn4HEEMPLOYEROFTENASSUMESTHEINmATIONRISKUNTILTHEEMPLOYEEQUITSORRETIRES)NADDI TION MOSTGOVERNMENT$"PLANSANDAHANDFULOFPRIVATE SECTOR$"PLANS PROVIDEINmATIONINDEXING AFTERRETIREMENT3OMEPEOPLEHAVESUGGESTEDTHATAK INVESTEDINSTOCKCANCOMPENSATEFORTHIS RISK BUTSTOCKRETURNSDONOTCORRELATEWELLWITHINmATIONOVERTHESHORTRUN s #ONTRIBUTIONRISKn$"PLANSGENERALLYCOVERALLEMPLOYEES EXCEPTTEMPORARYANDSOMEPART TIMEEM PLOYEES (OWEVER IN A K ARRANGEMENT EVEN WITH TAX ADVANTAGES AND EMPLOYER MATCHES MANY WORKERSWILLNOTORCANNOTCONTRIBUTE LEAVINGTHEMWITHOUTABENElTWHENTHEYRETIRE!NOTHERLARGE GROUPOFEMPLOYEESMAYCONTRIBUTE BUTNOTENOUGHTOPROVIDEANADEQUATERETIREMENTINCOME BECAUSE THEYDONTKNOWHOWMUCHISNEEDED s ,EAKAGERISKn-ANY$"PLANSSTILLPAYONLYANNUITIES)NALLK ARRANGEMENTS HOWEVER EMPLOYEES CANEASILYWITHDRAWTHEIRMONEYANDSPENDITBEFORERETIREMENT4HELOANOPTIONINAK ARRANGE MENTCANALSOSERVETODEPLETESAVINGS BECAUSELOANSAREUSUALLYDEDUCTEDFROMACCOUNTBALANCESWHEN ANEMPLOYEELEAVESACTIVESERVICE s $ISABILITYRISKn-ANY$"PLANSPAYPENSIONSUPONDISABLEMENT$#PLANSARENOTASGOODATPROVIDING DISABILITYBENElTSAS$"PLANS PARTICULARLYATYOUNGAGESWHENTHEACCOUNTBALANCEISSMALL3OMELARGE K ARRANGEMENTSALLOWPARTICIPANTSTOELECTAGROUPLONG TERMDISABILITYCOVERAGETHATWILLMAKEUP THEIROWNCONTRIBUTIONSANDMATCHINGCONTRIBUTIONSWHILEDISABLED BUTTHEPARTICIPANTSWILLHAVETOPAY FORTHECOVERAGE s 3URVIVORRISKn$"PLANSPAYSURVIVORPENSIONSTOSPOUSESUPONTHEDEATHOFTHEEMPLOYEEBOTHBEFORE ANDAFTERRETIREMENT ANDTHEEMPLOYERSELF INSURESTHISRISK)NK S RETIREESOFTENSPENDTHEIRMONEY TOOQUICKLYSOTHATTHEREISNOMONEYLEFTFORTHESURVIVOR s %ARLY RETIREMENT RISK n )N SOME $" PLANS EMPLOYEES WHO RETIRE EARLY CAN RECEIVE A SUBSIDIZED EARLY $EPARTMENTOF,ABOR%MPLOYEE"ENElTS3ECURITY!DMINISTRATION!BSTRACTOF&ORMDATATABLES!$&EBRUARY !LSOFROM7ORKERS FROM",3STATISTICSEMPLOYEDFULLANDPARTTIME ANDUNEMPLOYEDWAGEANDSALARYWORKERSTABLE% 

)335%"2)%&*5,9


RETIREMENTBENElTINORDERTOMANAGETHETRANSITIONINTORETIREMENT!K CANNOTPROVIDESUBSIDIZED BENElTS s #OMPANYSOLVENCYRISKn)FACOMPANYGOESBANKRUPT MOSTACCRUEDBENElTSWOULDBEGUARANTEEDBYTHE 0"'# WHEREASINA$#PLANANYASSETSINVESTEDINCOMPANYSTOCKWOULDLOSEALLVALUE (IGHERRETURNS$"PLANSHAVEBEENMOREEFlCIENTATINVESTINGONELARGEPOTOFFUNDS WHICHMEANSTHEYCAN FUNDLARGERBENElTSWITHTHESAMECONTRIBUTION ORTHESAMEBENElTWITHASMALLERCONTRIBUTION!CCORDINGTO THE$EPARTMENTOF,ABOR THEREISAMUCHHIGHERLEVELOFRISKFOREMPLOYEESINTHEIRK ARRANGEMENTS PAR TICULARLYTHOSEINVESTINGINTHEIREMPLOYERSSTOCK

!DVANTAGESOF$"PLANSVERSUS$#PLANSTOEMPLOYERS &LEXIBILITYOF$"PLANS4HE$"PLANISASmEXIBLEANDCREATIVEASTHEIDEASOFITSDESIGNER s #ONTRIBUTIONmEXIBILITYn%MPLOYERSHAVESOMEmEXIBILITYINTHEAMOUNTOFCONTRIBUTIONSTHEYMAKETO $"PLANSEACHYEARnINGOODYEARSTHEYCANPUTINMORE ANDINTOUGHYEARS THEYCANPUTINLESS!K DOESNOTHAVETHISmEXIBILITY)FANEMPLOYERCOMMITSTOAPERCENTMATCH THEEMPLOYERMUSTPAYIT WHATEVERTHEAMOUNTOFEMPLOYEECONTRIBUTIONS)FANEMPLOYERDESIRES HECANREDUCEORELIMINATETHE MATCH BUTHEMUSTANNOUNCEITBEFORETHEBEGINNINGOFTHEPLANYEAR)NA$"PLAN THEEMPLOYERCAN ADJUSTCONTRIBUTIONSWITHINTHEMINIMUMTOMAXIMUMRANGE WHICHWILLAFFECTTHEFUNDINGRATIOBUT NOTTHEPARTICIPANTSIMMEDIATEBENElTS)NA$#PLAN THOUGH ANYCHANGESTOCONTRIBUTIONSWILLHAVEA DIRECTANDIMMEDIATEIMPACTONPARTICIPANTBENElTS s )NVESTMENTmEXIBILITYn%MPLOYERSWITH$"PLANSCANINVESTMOREINEXPERIMENTALASSETCLASSES HARD TO VALUEASSETSANDNON LIQUIDASSETS"ECAUSEMANYOTHERINVESTORSINCLUDING$#PLANPARTICIPANTS WILL NOTORCANNOTDOTHIS $"PLANSMAYBETTERMANAGERISKOREARNAHIGHERPREMIUMFORTHEAMOUNTOFRISK TAKENUSINGTHESEINVESTMENTS s $ESIGNmEXIBILITYn$"BENElTFORMULASCANBEAMENDEDEASILY&OREXAMPLE ANEMPLOYERCANOPENA RETIREMENTWINDOWTOENCOURAGESOMEQUICKRETIREMENTSANDPAYFORITGRADUALLY INCREASEBENElTSWHEN THELABORMARKETISTIGHT ANDPROVIDEANADHOC#/,!TORETIREESIFINmATIONHASBEENHIGHANDORTHE PENSIONPLANSINVESTMENTSHAVEDONEWELL!K COULDNOTMAKETHESEDESIGNCHANGES 7ORKFORCEMANAGEMENT$"PLANSHELPEMPLOYERSBETTERMANAGETHEIRWORKFORCE s 2ETIREMENTWINDOWSn#OMPANIESCANUSEEARLYRETIREMENTWINDOWSIN$"PLANSTOMITIGATETHENEGA TIVElNANCIALEFFECTSOFWORKFORCEREDUCTIONSONEMPLOYEES!K ARRANGEMENTCANNOTPROVIDEEARLY RETIREMENTWINDOWS s 2ETIREOLDEREMPLOYEESWITHDIGNITYn2ETIRINGOLDEREMPLOYEESISEASIERWHENONECANGIVETHEMAPEN SIONFROMA$"PLAN)FTHEEMPLOYERHADONLYAK THEOLDEREMPLOYEEMAYNOTHAVEENOUGHFUNDS TORETIREBECAUSEOFANUMBEROFREASONS INCLUDINGDROPSINTHESTOCKMARKET JUMPSININmATION POOR INVESTMENTRETURNS LEAKAGE ETC s #REATEPROMOTIONPOTENTIALFORYOUNGEREMPLOYEESn%MPLOYEESIN$"PLANSCANRETIREWITHMOREREGULAR ITY ALLOWINGEMPLOYERSTOPROMOTEANDKEEPYOUNGEREMPLOYEES7ITHAK EMPLOYEESAREMORE LIKELYTORETIREINLARGENUMBERSWHENTHEMARKETSDOWELL ANDNOTRETIREWHENMARKETSDECLINE WHICH MAKESWORKFORCEMANAGEMENTMOREDIFlCULT s 2ETAINEMPLOYEESn$"PLANSPROVIDESTRONGERINCENTIVESTHANK SFOREMPLOYEESTOCONTINUEWITHTHE COMPANY s 2ECRUITEMPLOYEESn$"PLANS LIKEK S CANPROVIDEGOODBENElTSTOYOUNGEMPLOYEESIFTHEEMPLOYER DESIRESTOUSESUCHAPLANFORRECRUITINGPURPOSES s 3ATISFYCOLLECTIVEBARGAININGCONSIDERATIONSn5NIONSAREMORELIKELYTOBARGAINFOR$"PLANS )NCREASEDPRODUCTIVITY,IKEK SANDOTHER$#PLANS $"PLANSCANIMPROVEEMPLOYEEMORALEANDREDUCE

4HE0"'#INSURANCECANALLOWWEAKCOMPANIESTOAVOIDPAYINGFORALLTHEIRACCRUEDLIABILITIES)TISHOPED HOWEVER THATPENSIONREFORMLEGISLATIONWILL REDUCETHISPROBLEMINTHEFUTURE

)335%"2)%&*5,9


EMPLOYEE FEARS ABOUT RETIREMENT WHICH CAN INCREASE EMPLOYEE PRODUCTIVITY7HEN COMMUNICATED WELL $" PLANSAREMOREEFFECTIVEINREDUCINGRETIREMENTFEARSAMONGOLDEREMPLOYEESBECAUSE$"PENSIONBENElTSARE MOREPREDICTABLE

!DVANTAGESOF$"PLANSVERSUS$#PLANSTOTHENATION $"PENSIONPLANSAREBROADERBASED'ENERALLY AHIGHERPERCENTAGEOFANEMPLOYERSWORKFORCEISCOVEREDINA $"PLANTHANINAK WHERETHEEMPLOYEESCONTRIBUTIONISVOLUNTARY4HUS LOW INCOMEWORKERSAREMUCH MORELIKELYTOGETABENElTFROMA$"PLANANDTHUSLESSLIKELYTODEPENDONGOVERNMENTASSISTANCEPROGRAMS INRETIREMENT 4HETRILLIONSIN$"ASSETSPROMOTENATIONALSAVING ECONOMICEFlCIENCY ANDCERTAINMARKETSTHATK SCANNOT!S SHAREHOLDERS $"PLANSHAVEBEENLEADERSINPROMOTINGBETTERCORPORATEPERFORMANCE WHICHREDUCESTHECOSTOF PROVIDING$"PLANBENElTS WHILE$#PLANSHAVECONmICTSOFINTERESTTHATINHIBITTHISROLE)NADDITION $"PLANS CANPROVIDETHESEFUNDSTOTHEREALESTATESECTOR ANDOTHERLESSLIQUIDANDHARD TO VALUEASSETSK ANDOTHER $#PLANSGENERALLYDONOTORCANNOTINVESTINTHESEAREAS 2EDUCESTHENATIONSDEPENDENCEON3OCIAL3ECURITYANDGOVERNMENTASSISTANCEPROGRAMS"OTH$"AND$#PLANS REDUCETHENATIONSDEPENDENCEONGOVERNMENTPROGRAMS BUT$"PLANSAREMOREEFFECTIVEBECAUSEPARTICIPANTS AREMORELIKELYTORECEIVEASTABLE PREDICTABLEBENElTFORLIFE $"PLANSREDUCEPOVERTYRATESFORTHEELDERLY,IFETIMEPENSIONBENElTSFROM$"PLANSAREMORELIKELYTOHELP REDUCEPOVERTYRATESWHERETHEYARETHEHIGHESTEG AMONGSTVERYELDERLYWOMEN BECAUSEOFTHELEVELINCOME FORLIFEANDJOINTANDSURVIVORREQUIREMENTS

!CHIEVINGPARITYBETWEEN$"AND$#PLANS !TONETIME $"PLANSCOVEREDPERCENTOFTHEWORKERSINTHE53.OW THEYCOVERLESSTHANHALFTHATPERCENT AGE4HEDISPARITYINTREATMENTOF$"VERSUS$#PLANSSETBYLAWHASCONTRIBUTEDTOTHISDECLINE"ELOWAREAFEW OFTHERULESTHATCREATEADISADVANTAGEFOR$"PLANS s $# PLANS CAN HAVE PRE RETIREMENT DISTRIBUTIONS TAX DEFERRED EMPLOYEE CONTRIBUTIONS AND EMPLOYER MATCHES WHILEPRIVATE SECTOR$"PLANSCANNOT s $"PLANSMUSTPROVIDEANNUITIESANDELECTIONSFORSPOUSALSURVIVORBENElTS BUT$#PLANSANDREGULAR SAVINGSARENOTSUBJECTTOTHISREQUIREMENTANDMOST$#PLANSDONOTPROVIDEANYANNUITYOPTIONSAT ALL"ECAUSETHISISAVALUABLEREQUIREMENT ONEOPTIONWOULDBETOREQUIRE$#PLANSTOOFFERANNUITIES s 0RIVATE SECTOR$"PLANSAREGENERALLYREQUIREDTOPAYFOR0"'#INSURANCE WHICHINCREASESBENElTSECU RITY BUT$#PLANSHAVENOREQUIREMENTTOINSUREBENElTS s $#PLANSANDREGULARSAVINGS CANPROVIDEPARTIALPHASED RETIREMENTBENElTSTOOLDEREMPLOYEEWHO ARESTILLWORKINGPARTTIME WHEREAS$"PLANSCANNOT s ,OW INCOMEEMPLOYEESCANGETTHE)2#3EC"TAXCREDITMATCHFROMTHEGOVERNMENTIN$#PLANSAND )2!S BUTNOTIN$"PLANS s 3MALLEMPLOYERSCANGETATAXCREDITFOR$#PLANSTART UPCOSTS BUTNOTFORNEW$"PLANS s $#PLANSCANEASILYPASSONHIGHERRATESOFINVESTMENTRETURNSTHAN4REASURYRATESTOEMPLOYEES BUTCASH BALANCE$"PLANSCANNOTDOTHISWITHOUTRUNNINGINTODIFlCULTYWITHOTHERPENSIONRULES s 2ULESFORDETERMININGLUMPSUMSIN$"PLANSTENDTODISCOURAGEPARTICIPANTSFROMCHOOSINGANNUITIES DILUTINGONEOFTHEKEYADVANTAGESOF$"PLANS s 3OMEPROPOSALSREQUIREA$"PLANTOBEMAINTAINEDFORlVEYEARSAFTERCONVERTINGTOACASHBALANCEFOR MULA$#PLANSWOULDNOTBESUBJECTEDTOASIMILARREQUIREMENT 3OMEOFTHEDISADVANTAGES$"PLANSENCOUNTERCANBEALLEVIATEDTHROUGHAMOREEQUALTREATMENTOF$"AND $#PLANS)NFACT AN!CADEMYISSUEBRIEFONTHECONCEPTOF$" + ARETIREMENTPLANTHATCOULDCOMBINE

)335%"2)%&*5,9


VALUABLEFEATURESOF$"AND$#PLANS DISCUSSESSEVERALAPPROACHESTOPROVIDINGMOREPARITYBETWEENTHESE TWOTYPESOFPLANS3OMEOFTHERESTRICTIONSIMPOSEDON$"PLANSAREQUITEIMPORTANT SOCONSIDERATIONOF WHETHERTOAPPLYTHEMTO$#PLANSISCRUCIALNOWTHATK SAREBECOMINGTHESOLEORPRIMARYRETIREMENT PLANSFORMILLIONSOFWORKERS $ElNEDBENElTPLANSPLAYAVALUABLEROLEINRETIREMENTSECURITY4HEYNOTONLYPROVIDEAGUARANTEEDBENElT FORLIFE THEYALSOMANAGERISKMOREEFFECTIVELYTHANDElNEDCONTRIBUTIONPLANS7HILEPERSONALSAVINGSTHROUGH K SOROTHERSAVINGSVEHICLESISANIMPORTANTCOMPONENTOFRETIREMENTPLANNING THEVALUEOFASTABLE SECURE INCOMESHOULDNOTGOUNRECOGNIZED

)335%"2)%&*5,9


!MER ICAN!CADEMYOF!CTUAR IES 3EVENTEENTH3TREET.7s3EVENTH&LOORs7ASHINGTON $# 4ELs&AX WWWACTUARYORG


db_july06.4  

Read more
Read more
Similar to
Popular now
Just for you