Piya Tan
SD 2.17 Is There a Soul?
!
" # $
%
$
#
%& )"
( "
" '
"
' (
#
(
#
" % )
#
" "
-
* * "
" '
*
+
+
%,
*
+
#. /
+
#0
"
#
#
% &
#
' /
0
1 "
(
( 2 #
!
%& "
$
#
' )"
%
#
!
"#
$
%
* ,
$% #
"#
"" &
#
+ &
% " "
&
(
) "
(
#
" ""
,
#
%,
(
' %3
# &
#
"
'
#
""
#
" #
4
"
&
)
#
2
'
% ,
&
&
* "
" %5
1
;
.7869: (#
3
"
'
""
#
$
#
"%6
'
3% # .86<7) % ( 4
6
#
"" +#
) " >
= * .88 7.?
@
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
#
+#
*
+ %
% "
#
- .A%.. * '3+%
1
Living Word of the Buddha SD 2 no 17
Is There a Soul?
" B #
" "
C
" #
%!
" 4
4
"
( %
* ' ' ) E )"
1 #% > ' '
#
# "
" "
" )"
+# *5
A
?
+
'
D
=
+
"
*;- + 1 * +
D
4 " +% #" "
*
%. B " F
% " "
"
<
4
5
+
" %
"
# "
#
# ( " )" %
? 76+
%8
2 *5 4 "
% !4 *,
" "
" (
#
,
& "
# '
( %
" +#
*
""
*
4 "
%
)"
%.. 5
"
% '
*;- +
)" %
"
)" $
%
" "
)" "
"
)"
# F " *.8<6+# ; '
# #
"
" %. %.
)"
)" )" .6 *! ;- + .8<A%.3 ' )" '
;" ( ;- #
) B >
G ""
H4 !
(
"" )
'
%.6
;- %.? 5 %
?
#.< ""
# #
" (
2
"
#
% % I I &I I8I.8I % IJ "7II %" " % I IK K % J > #/ ' %0 H ; G .A6#6 G .88<7 <' 3% A "7II % % I I I8I.8I I 6 3AA% % 8 "7II % ' % I)" I <% % . "7II % % % (II I(K I 2 I3 <. .A% % .. "7II % ) % I" I " "' 8% . E # /; ')" # # 7 ; 5 B B ; ')" %0 ? #.' H ?7. 3'.6.% . , : # /; ' )" " " " 0 .7 8' 38% .3 "7II % % I% .6 H G #/ # %0 ! " " "# H .88 % .? "7II % (" % I (IB K K" K K K ' K )" .< "7II % (" % I (IB L K % <
"7II "7II
;"
"
" % )"
%
"
6#
" 'G
%
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
Piya Tan
SD 2.17 Is There a Soul?
%
#
, (#$
" $ ( #
" " # (
" #
.
! ! "
" (
#
#
) %!
" " =
D ( $
"
"
*.A 6'.A86+# #
"
'
# - , " F %
'
(
' # ' ""
4
%
" " (#
* " % "
"
#
4
4 #
+
%&
( #
*
, %
# "
"
#.8 -
B
2 " " #D # " " # " " 3
%
) " # # " *.A8 + %&
*.88<+%
3
(
"
"
"
) F
% %&
" F
#
/
0 )" 4 " % "
# F "
4 ' "
#
2
%
F
' " "
"
"
% ("
6
$ ?
" " # . *.8 3'.88?+# " "
4
"
%5
("
# %< '
# 7+ ' %
,
A
/ "
%& +
* (
*
F
.A
#
'
+
$ +
%
8
) '
# " 8# E 7G # .A8 % #* $ ! # @ J # .88 % ! ; '?3?' .'< % % I % % . , ( #) )$ . ( ) ) # (# = 7& " B # % ! ; .'6<.<3' 3 '. "7II % (" % I (I! K % "7II % (" % I (I K K K KB % 3 ! # " ) * -, " # 7 # .88<% 6 "7II % (" % I (I K ( % ? "7II % (" % I (I@ K % < "7II % (" % I (IB K % A - .A%..* %.' % +% 8 : ?.' ??9D 8 '83 M D 7G . ?'.3 9 4 " / " " - .8387 8#.3%
.8
;
"
$ (
+% *
*"
#
!(
B "7II
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
3
Living Word of the Buddha SD 2 no 17 7
Is There a Soul?
#
%! % 0
# / %.G
;
+% * 7/,
G $ N0
( :
$ (G *: +1 ( $
. /,
( (
0
( ! '> 7
; #;
)
"
" (( # G
*:
(
(
%
(
%! + %
(
#
/
N! #
#
F (
7 #
&
*
1& 2 +
#
1
#
# %0
*G
N0 A #&
4
+
"
7 %; ' # ( ' % # 1 ) G =F 1 " * ) < ( +% ! # ) 3 4 15 * 33%8I378A'3 +# 0 1 + *G A% ?' 8+ ' / %0 = 4 1+ # 3 ' (# * " (7 %. # . # 3 + ' %@ " " #! & 4 ) ( F *.886 ?+# %! % & # F "" " (# # : O# * + G #" P * +% " % ' # ( ! " " ( 7 4 5
"
"
"" "
Q
' 4 #* +
#"
*.+ F %
Q
4
R <%6 S
% (
"
" (
"
"# * +
7
#
"
' ' ""
4O O %0
* "
(
"
*
+ R6S +
)
)" %
6 3%.
G # %& ' ' '
#
(
(
:
*G A% ?I.7?6 + R ) " S ' ' '
4
"
0$
+ ( " 9
"
%!
M : 7B . % : # ( . 5 " G #" P # H ! # D7!. A . J G
#
*
# #
# ' ' '
7"889 .A
%
G G (4 ! *: 3# 6+% & # .88? U!!!%3% # .8A.7. 9 7 .3 ? 6 # .3.. <6%
T#"
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
Piya Tan
SD 2.17 Is There a Soul?
• • • 1
9 9 *
' ' '
+
" ' ' '
3%
%
*G A% ?I.7?6 +
*G 8 %.AI7.6? + R ) " S R $
$ " $ '
$
-
'
$
%1 " -
3
4
3
-4
"
$
' "
' '
$
2
5
$
"
7
-
6 $ 48
-
"
-
7
$ "3 "- "
$ 3
-
"%S
"
%
7 #!
/
"
-
# 7Q
#
# #
9
(9 #
"
"
#
9
#
#
#
%4 Q # ' Q; # Q #
# N4 %4 #
( (
4 '
Q; Q ' Q; Q
# #
(
N4
%4 #
( N4
# #
%4 #
(
4 '
Q; # Q # Q #
(
%4 # (
+ :
' ' '
:
9 "
* ' ' ' 9
.5 5
# #
#
3
' ' ' ' ' '
( ( N #0 *G 8 %.AI7.6<+ / %G
-
(0+ -
%!
6
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
%
6
#
#
0 %
4
%0
0
%! *- .6I7? +
$
3%
" $
# "
( " (
/
# */
#
9
' ' '
" (
4
5 % 7 ;<9 &
1
/
'
N4
7
N&
(
% "
( :
% %
%
5
Living Word of the Buddha SD 2 no 17 Q # ( %4 Q Q
3%
( # #
:
' ' ' # #
: V *
Is There a Soul?
' " Q
#
#
%4
* 33%8I3788 + " ( 0 R.6S%+
> ( # #"
/
1
#
"#
R 7
# " #"
#
"#
S
%
" # Q #
#
N4 (
# #
=/
#
(
"
%4 # "
"
"
#
#
# 7
% #
'(
1
%4 7Q&
#
#
%4 # N0
> " /! % = #! : * 7: / = #F
>
#
/= *
?
/@
:
*
-
%-
7:
. .9>
?1
?
*
. .9% # S#
>
# S% @ # = # # #: #!
#
#=
<
#!
R
S%0
# N0 #
# >
R
#! %0
S
#
. %@ #=
%0
# > : #
N0 #
/
/ 0 0+ ""
1
" * /
1 %0
/
. <37
9 9
: 9 9 % < 9" ; $ ;
"
$
D" % 9 9 ;- $ "
;
( " *G < %.8I.73A<+
1. %
-$ X
W
$
;$
<< 9 9
8
%0 & .. @
0
<
# # * . <3+# /H +#0 *; # .88 7. + A "" 9 $ ;$ ; <<9 8 = ; $ " > ?9 9 ;$ 9 > 9
A
#
%
6
#=
*
> /= R ; /
%&
#
R 6 /
#
*
; 9" ;
9 9 -
;
@
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
Piya Tan
SD 2.17 Is There a Soul?
3%3
(
' * 3?% I67 ?8 +3
"
(
#
( )"
# / * + 5 * + !
3.
' %,
" N
(
% (
#
(
% *.+ !
(
# #3
R
* +! # R * +! #
" - - 7 <S% ( -
" - - 7 <S% (
"
3 3.
/ # $
#
#
" - - 7 <S%3
(
"
# R -
"
( )
#
# (
(
' )"
%.6 '
36
R
-"
%
* 3?% I67?8 +
% ::
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
#0 & 7*.+ -
#
#
#
#
(
#
" - - 7 <S%33
-
#
(
# #
" 7 <S% A #
"
# R
) *6+ ! #
#
# )
*3+ ! #
# #
1
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
7
Living Word of the Buddha SD 2 no 17 ( "
#
Is There a Soul?
'
> 68 /D;(8A *?
7
*! += (# F 4 *! + * " + ( *D + (( *D + (( * + - (( ; - (( ; # * #" + * " + # " *# " +; * " + PP
F .
.
"
> 68 /D ;(8A *? *- %.%8I7 <+# 07 " ( / 0
%
*- %.%8*.A+I7 <+ * 3A%.6I67 .+ * 3A% 3I67 3 + * 3A%??I67 < + * 6.% ?I67A6+ * 63%6I67.3+ * 66% 6%AI67<A + * %A?% I.7 # * %A<% I.7 3+ * 3%. .I7. # * <%.?%3I37 . + * <%.<%3I37 .3+ * <%6 I 37< + * <%A I 37.3?+ * 8%. %?I37A + * ? % I 67. + * ?3% I 67. + * U3 '3?I.? +
.
J
( +
' /
"
"
(
"
' #
*
"
9
#
:
1 #
)
'" /" .<+%
*&
' 0
# .8867 . 9 "
9
+
'
, ! ' #0
(
.F 37<+% E
"
6(
;
* E .?9
*
*5 &
*
"
"
%
" 5 * '
#
+
" * <%6 I37< '<3+# / " (
# 1. .8867. +%
0 *&
/ '
R3S
'
7 , . . .
# # # # *
#
" "#
9 9
-
"A
# -
+9 *
-
"
+9
(#
#
9 3 6
"
(#
"
" (#
* <%6 I 37< '<39- .
8
M
% 76 9
9 ( 7..39
" 37<9G
# .8A?7..6+
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
Piya Tan
SD 2.17 Is There a Soul?
" B
*
$
+#
/
#
'"
$
' /" *G .7.< +% # E * 6+ %
/
.
0 0*
*
.?#
%@
F )"
* +
#
8
0
*. ' + /
#
0
'
*
* # . '
" .8867. .9G
/
.8A?7..?# .
0 ""
9 ,
.8<37 ?+
$ +
>
# .. ? 7
# *.+ * + * +
* 3%. .% '3I7.
G
*
+
(
'
* )
+* " : +9 " : +% * 3%. .% '3I7.
$ -
*
(
/
%
"
( -
"
"
"
9
" :
+9
G
.8A?7..3+
#0
' "
'
%
% " 0*
/ #
(
%
%0
%5
#
5 #
"
( # / )
(
!
0*
/
/ #
#0 R ) #
0
#S3?
'
/
"
'
#
H! 7
3?
* * $ +9 ' ) " 36# . <.+% ( #
#0
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
*&
+ *E " +* -
* #
#0 / ) ' / 0
#(
/
/ ) 0 *G ..3 M 6+#
8"
$ +9 ' ) +* $ < ' A I..<9G
'
' %
= FF #3< $
0
$ +%
"
" )
/ "
+
#
3<
" /
/
" 378+ 09
*
*
%0
/
' )
8 )
#
' "
% *&
37<+% & /
" - G .7 3?6+#
" +0 ' +0 % / " #0 / %
' 0
4
.8867 . +
G
F> $ +9 +*
?7 ' -
) $ +*
' ) * * #" (7 %. '. I736#
%
9
Living Word of the Buddha SD 2 no 17
@ @ , , , , ,
"
* "
+9
#
%
# $
$
*
#
+% *
#
* #
*
-
*
+%3A +%
+% % *G .33%..I7?? M
6%A<% I3768 M D A.9
(
*
+ /,
+*
#
"
8/
) +%38
"
"
1
6
Is There a Soul?
0 # G O ( O"
*
+ 1&
#
#
F
. %3 I7?<+ '
6%86+7 #
2
#
9 9 2 # G O ( O" # , # G O ( O" , # G O ( O" 4%06
<
3A
/! / 763M<3+# $ -
# #
Q Q
#4 #4
%46
Q Q
'
0
#0
/ #0 / 7/!
1 + %! #
*G A+ "
" 4
7
#0 / 0 *G 7Y ...?+% * ) + *- .7.? 9G .7.6 # Aâ&#x2030; 8.<9 76 9 # ' %0 G .7 3M 6# G B C $ : ( 0 * -+ 6 O -O T * B # D .%. I A+% # # ' #/ #0 # ' # # : $ F ' " # % # # % / 2 0 F 2 ' * - $9 $ :: +% ! 2 #/ 2 0 + % # # # ! # # % ( " # " # " % ( %0 @ ' # " # % " * : $ # +# %5# # /G ' # 2 %, # # / 01 # # # # 2 %* 7 .3. <6+ 6. 6 # / 0 # % " % 6 6 # / #0 # % " % 6 / X #0 $ " % F ' ' D " E " * $ +% & # ) "" "" * # ) " #3 5 1B # 7/, #= # #! %0 * 373 9 G .7??# 7.6<+% 38
10
%46.
Q
(
<
*
9 2 #
-
-
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
Piya Tan
SD 2.17 Is There a Soul? (
&
#
# * B + N "
( ""
(
R 9
S#
$
9 %
.%AI.3< M :
+% ,
9 *G A%.6I.7?.+
%
*
0
*
63
$
#
#
8+7
97"89 9
;
G !
( Z
"" '
#( )
3. I7. +%66 <"0 * *G . +
#
(
!
&
0*
(
9
* + * + (
D
.3< M :
E $
*
(7 %3 ' 1
" & 0$
*
8+
#
4 9
+1 *
#
*.+ (
$
$
# *
+%6? "
:
*
(# " -
#
4 ( " (
)
C
#
+# *- A+
/ .C
*-
+
" +7 (
#
(
4
(
#
4
(
#
(
#
# ( (
# #
'
9
*3+
4 ( :
0*
:
$
+%6<
-
" (
( # : *- A%6I7 . M - %.%..* <+I7 .+ "
#
%6A #
" (
"
* '3+#
" #
)
/ %@
" "
63
F G H- 9 9 9 G 7Y ..A? . 66 5 $ 6? G . %.'?I7. % # 6< - A%6I7 . % " *- 37.<?+% 6A . ( $
0
#
G9 $
"
$9
0
&
"
('
'
$9-
" -
- <
.88 7AA'8 % *- .3%.%.<I7. + 4 / 3 *.+ * " ('
* 3%. <I7. *
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
"
%
+9
"9- $ <<9> ;
"
;
="
T#
%0 9* +
A
9* + +9*3+
'(
* A%< %.6'.<I37. +#
1 "
9
+
* A%< %.A+%
11
Living Word of the Buddha SD 2 no 17
Is There a Soul?
I *
I # %0 ! ' )"
' F
#
-
* " F #F .* '
" +# +
$ #
/
0* $ # *
" #
$
# ! .* . : * + #Q " " $
# &
$ +
' F " " # := ( + . ' R6S ( ? -< + *- .7A +% 22 1& ( # "
%* "
I"
G S*
$ -
/
/ #
+% &
# "
I/ *G 8%.8I.7<8+ " " / #0 # I6 "
$ *
"" X
0* 0
S0
: F
#
Q 4%0 *& #
.8867. + 0 #
#/
#
"
2
'
#
R )
0 *& "
.8867. #
#
#
68
( &
+
"
" /
#
& / 0 *G 8%.8I.7<8+%
S
+% 3
*
+
6% 3+#
7 #
%
/ /
R
# (
"
S% ( *- %8?I.7 A +
#
+ %
+ .
R #
0* (
E
" " +
S4
' #
R
R
+# /
'
7
" .* <
+ #: $
" )"
*- +1
(# ( '( " "
# $ X
X N0 &
%
" #
"
#
#
#
)
9
( "
" (
'( " # /, $
" # /&
#
# R
S% % !
"
#
(#
#
7E
F
# "
#
F
( " %E . 5+ & F
%E
%E
J
" -. %E 7:
%4 E
. *
12
/-
#0
F
* # F
.
% 7 A;9E F 9F* #
&
4
/
) :*
' . F
+ # %
;
!
68
#
*
1
#
#
X%
0 *$ <<
*
6%
: 3I37.83 +
+%
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
Piya Tan I;
SD 2.17 Is There a Soul? &
00
/
2
7
07
# ( #
/
"
9
07
( # 07
/
#
# ( (9 4 " 9
" 4 " $
# (
#
#
% 3 4
* 33%8I378A'3 # "
1
" (
+ R %. '.6S# %/ )
#
( "
" %0 *&
.8867. +%
AG A
$) ,
K ,
) "
$
0 %
# '" !
" +
4
' ( )
# "
R
S "
* # #
:
+# ( "
%
(
/
0
/
*:
# . 6+% =
* 3
*=
( +#
*= "
'
" "
/
0* ! " "
#
' #
" .7A'. # .
'
" S
*U?%.?+% *& .886 U?% .+ (
#
( 7
(7 U.3 I " 8 +% 5 (# %* )" *;- + %&
+#
),
#
+ G
+#
# (" #
R
*
),
( %5 "
0
* A" , *5 +
*
%
( 73A 9 (7 " 83+ ' ' )" *.886 . + * +
+%
(
I I */ )
"
(
-
0+
7
# $
# /!
B
#0
*@
#
J
" # .8<A7<+% )# *& .8867. 3+
G
% A/ # % F : : ) " # #
# $) L %
*-
%
$)
%.?I7
+#
" " "
?
)" " "
( ( '"
'" "
# #
"
&
J
:
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
#
#
" " F
"
)"
" ?
" "
% "
'" "
" / *& 7
#
# 0 .886 U?%<+%
9
" %
13
Living Word of the Buddha SD 2 no 17 *.+
"" * +
14
*-
# ( #
# # +#
@ "
I.6I7 0
Is There a Soul?
+ * '"
/ *&
.886 U?%8+
)" 8+
/
' ( /
%0 / /
4
0 * $ - "" '
0*
+0 -
0 0
" *= .7.6+%
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
Piya Tan
SD 2.17 Is There a Soul?
→=
#( 3'6
%
#> .8A
. &
!+1 .3#
4 6%
! →
( # .88?
.* #>
H% / %0 ;
#B " .883
#B .88
& &
# .8A<
Q %G
# .886 #5 ( .88?
S
( % # .8<
!
( [ 6.." 6
( %
# % .8A S J 6 # " ) # .8A87 .A<'.A8% R
" -%# .8A %
$
" 7 3 # .88?7? '
"
""%
&
% %0 !
# % B 4 +# % 2 ( " (JD # .8837 ..' 6%
""
N0 *
*
K
6 .88 7 .<8'.8.% 3# -
"7, # .88<#
.8A<76?' ?3 RB
6 $
! G
# 7D%
N4 6
J .! # .886%
%S ;
# .88 %
7 # .8A?S
+ G
G
"
/ B .88.'.88 * " ! # %E # 5 @% / 4 ( >
2 &
7#.8< 7H
( ! R R \ 2'B ] # H% .8A S% + (( ! .! 7= @
# .8A
>
% :R B
-%
.88
>
%
>
" # .88?% B " ;
B -
7
7
.%
# .8A?
$ )$ ! .8A<% # % %# .8AA% R ; ' ; # :B * + .88 ) & *% * ) + % ; ( .8<. " ' "" 0S% : # .8AA ( $ )$ 8 ". #& .8<. / #>
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com
E " "". 6'. %S ;"
7
JD
%
(
&
# %# "
+% 5)
R.8 AS 7
7
)
# .88 %
(
R/ # .8<.%
! A# .8AA7 %0 J
% RG
# %# .8A?S K
% <8# .8<.7 3' A%
15
Living Word of the Buddha SD 2 no 17 .888
/!
Is There a Soul?
) " 6# .8887 . .'.63% %
O ; (O %0 K
!
5
(# V â&#x2020;&#x2019; #! .8<3 ' "( $ ) %D = # .8<3% .8<6 ( ) " *.%L * D = # .8<6% .8<? ( ) " **.%L D = # .8<?% #@ .8< ( ) : 7 # .868# .8?3# .8< % F # F /, %0 ! # + 7 #. 7 3'8% "7 I I % % I I , ^ E ^ %" % #E .86< / ( %0 #. 5 .86<76'A% .8? / $ ( %0 6#3 " .8? 7. '.<% = 3
,
R
(S 1+ ; R (=S D% , # %E # % (# ( # % .# .8.A' .9 7*.+ " D% , A( # # ( # .8 ' ?9* + R= S J " # % E% = \ # 5.( -E # .8.3'.A9 .66A# & ? * G +7 % % = \ # .'8 7 +( #9*? +# E # .8 ' % B " G _=!# .8<.% # ?
/=
7 !"
?
/ ,
( # 5& .836 /= , # ) .8<3 / ! + -
2 #
?%
7
%
%0 ! * + -: ; E
".
%0 R! "7I I
(%
%
%
# 7B
# <; ?%S @ I ( I I ?I ..I<I
' # ;C J I%
,F
$
0( " '
E%
- " %-
3 ? 9
16
J
?
M $ %0 ! 7-% B
" ) $ ' #. " .836% + # .8<37 <' 8%
*
89 <...A9 A 6
http://dharmafarer.googlepages.com