opinion
the ellis act needs to be repealed, not just reformed.
Taken down for riding Muni By Tony Robles OPINION Violence against elders and people with disabilities is on the rise. Recently an Asian elder was beaten bloody by police in New York City for jaywalking, while in Oklahoma, an elder with a disability — deafness (stated on his driver’s license) — was severely beaten when he didn’t hear police commands after being pulled over. Perhaps you have seen what I have seen, San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency fare inspectors in droves patrolling buses whose riders are mostly people of color or low-income people. During a fare inspection sweep, I witnessed the abuse of an elder in downtown San Francisco. At about 8:50am, I came out of a coffee shop on Market Street heading towards Ninth Street on my way to work. I saw two Muni buses at a standstill. Nearby were two SFPD squad cars. A half-dozen Muni fare inspectors stood around and, from the commotion I saw on one of the buses, it looked like they were in pursuit of a passenger. The police boarded and pulled out an Asian man in his late 50s or early 60s. The police pulled him across the street to the sidewalk. The man appeared to have some kind of mental or emotional disability. The officers said something to him — what, I couldn’t make out. The man tried to pull away from the officers, making noises that sounded like grunts. As I looked on, this man didn’t seem to be cognizant of what was happening. After a few minutes, the officers let the man go. But after some words from the commanding officer in charge, to my amazement, the officers went after the man again as he walked towards Ninth Street. This time, the two officers tackled the man to the ground. I thought I was watching something out of a Deacon Jones NFL highlight reel. The officers took the man to the 6 SAN FRANCISCO BAY GUARDIAN
ground, and not gently. As this was happening, I saw a fare inspector laugh. As the man was being led to the sidewalk, I told the commanding officer that the man appeared to have a disability and that I didn’t want to see him hurt. The officer replied that some passengers are smart, that they are good actors and put up a front to avoid paying fare. It is not without irony that those fare inspectors are mostly people of color, many of whom are born and raised in SF and are likely having a difficult time just surviving here. Ironic that they are forced to occupy these enforcement type jobs — fare inspector, security guard, etc. — that enforce poor people laws against their own communities, on people who are faring worse than they are. With people with disabilities across the country being killed or maimed by law enforcement in incidents that were avoidable, it is irresponsible for law enforcement to have such an attitude. How is tackling an elder to the ground, one who appeared to need help and not a beat-down, over a $2 bus fare going to help the city or community? And while the cops tackle the disabled elder and the fare inspector laughs, the rich techies get a free ride on their buses stamped with Google or Apple or a half-dozen other tech logos. Perhaps if the tech millionaires and billionaires paid their fair share in taxes to contribute to the city’s transportation system, elders could ride the buses free and not be subjected to humiliation and violence. As those tech workers board their buses and stick their tongues out at the protestors and take our pictures, we do not see anything funny about this situation. It ain’t no joke. 2 Tony Robles is co-Editor at POOR Magazine and a housing advocate at Senior and Disability Action. opinion
news
Tech must support Ellis reforms EDITORIAL San Francisco is facing an eviction crisis, a reality that politicians of all ideological stripes have finally begun to address. It was good to see our two best representatives to the California Legislature introduce bills to reform the Ellis Act in the last week, but these will be empty gestures unless the political class and its allies in the technology industry and the larger business community step up and offer strong support for the effort. This is a small but difficult first step in addressing the displacement that is hurting the city’s diversity and driving out its working class. San Francisco is one of the few cities in the California that has rent control, which the Ellis Act was designed by landlords and the real estate industry to subvert. So the political dynamics of reforming the Ellis Act are difficult in Sacramento, and it will take business community support to get this done. Twitter and other SF-based tech companies have food + Drink
gotten big local tax breaks to stay here, while Google and other Silicon Valley companies use San Francisco to house their high-paid employees, both feeding the frenzy of real estate speculation behind the current eviction epidemic. This is their chance to show that they want to be a part of San Francisco’s community, rather than just seeing this city as a resource to exploit for their own ends. In introducing his Senate Bill 1439 outside a Chinatown apartment building on Feb. 24, Sen. Mark Leno cited city figures showing that more than 300 apartments were cleared of residents using the Ellis Act in 2013, more than half of those involving landlords who owned the building for less than a year, half of those for less than six months. “These are not the landlords the Ellis Act was designed to help,” Mayor Ed Lee said in support of SB 1439. Leno’s bill would require landlords to own a building for at least
the selector
music
five years before using the Ellis Act to evict tenants. Assemblymember Tom Ammiano also introduced a bill on Feb. 21, Assembly Bill 2405, which would allow San Francisco voters or the Board of Supervisors to declare a moratorium on Ellis Act evictions if city affordable housing goals aren’t met. Both are small, sensible reforms that would easily pass in a society less consumed by greed than ours is now. Tech leaders should welcome the opportunity to show they understand what’s happening in this city and have compassion for those being displaced, rather than tacitly supporting the real estate speculators. But it’s also just a first step. The Ellis Act needs to be repealed, not just reformed. More than 1,000 rent control units have been lost in San Francisco in the last two years, affordable housing converted into speculators’ profits. This must end, or the righteous populist anger that is consuming the city will only get worse. 2
arts + culture
film
classifieds