A4
Thursday, November 15, 2012
Maple Ridge & Pitt Meadows Times
Maple Ridge council
13th Annual 10th Annual
Cat owners balk at bylaw READERS’ CHOICE Council dealt with its
animal control bylaw at Tuesday’s meeting. by Maria Rantanen
mrantanen@mrtimes.com
Maple Ridge council is looking at tweaking its animal control bylaw, which would allow for Savannah cats, but not undomesticated serval cats to be kept as pets. Serval cats are not listed as in the International Cat Association, but Savannah cats are, therefore the latter are allowed as part of the “domestic cat” category. Several people came to Maple Ridge’s Tuesday evening council meeting to speak about allowing Savannah and serval cats, and they were allowed to ask questions during ques-
Maria Rantanen/TIMES
Kelly Allen brought her serval cat Duma to the Maple Ridge council meeting on Tuesday. tion period. Kelly Allen brought her serval cat Duma to the meeting as well. Servals are allowed if owners can prove they are domesticated.
“[I’m] not sure what the test of that is,” said Maple Ridge Mayor Ernie Daykin. The animal control bylaw will come back for final reading at a future council meeting. Coun. Cheryl Ashlie said she wanted the bylaw to go through at this point, but questioned why dogs weren’t allowed in certain areas, for example, on playgrounds, pointing out that it’s a common sight to see a mother pushing a stroller and walking the family dog. Often the family dog is a part of the family. “I’m wondering if this is going too far,” she said, adding it might be “stomping on” something families are doing with their dog. Ashlie suggested that the bylaw be reviewed after a year to see if the dog restrictions are working.
You & The Law
MAXIMUM MONEY for “PAIN AND SUFFERING” from ACCIDENT
She was hit in three separate accidents. And – in probably the largest similar court award ever made in Canada – a Vancouver jury initially gave her over $12 million. Part of that was $6.5 million for “non-pecuniary compensation” (legal short-hand for pain, suffering and loss of enjoyment of life). Too much money? You’re right if you agree. In the attention-grabbing case, the BC Court of Appeal revisited when the maximum judgment can be awarded for pain and suffering. The plaintiff (let’s call her “Joan”) was hurt in three different accidents over a 15-month period, where she was not at fault. She suffered soft tissue injuries to her neck and, after the accidents, experienced continual upper body pain and depression and was unable to function effectively in the business she and her husband owned. Before the car accidents, Joan had been injured in an accident at the PNE, which caused a mild concussion, and she later had surgery after a disc herniation was found. This raised the question of how much of her situation was due to the car accidents rather than her pre-existing condition. But she testified that she felt her condition was improving before the car accidents (and compensation can still be given if a subsequent accident aggravates a pre-existing condition). At trial, the judge told the Vancouver jury that Canada has an upper limit or cap on the compensation that can be given for pain and suffering. Asked by the judge if they meant to award that top amount, the jury said yes and cut this part of its award to the maximum allowed. The trial judge determined this figure to be roughly $327,000. Adjusted for inflation, this is the equivalent of the $100,000 maximum amount for pain and suffering fixed by the Supreme Court of Canada in
1978. The defendants appealed what they viewed as a still-excessive court award totalling over $6 million, and asked for a new trial. The BC Court of Appeal agreed there should be a new trial for several reasons. One reason related to the amount for pain and suffering. The appeal court pointed out that the maximum award of some $327,000 is only for cases of “truly catastrophic injury,” which the plaintiff Joan admittedly hadn’t endured. When the Supreme Court of Canada fixed this cap in 1978, it dealt with three very serious injury cases – a 17-year old with a neck injury resulting in loss of use of all limbs, a 21-year old quadriplegic and a four-year old with serious brain damage and debilitating physical injuries. The court there, noting that no money can provide true compensation, explained that the pain and suffering award is meant to help make the victim’s life more endurable (rather than express sympathy). Also, a cap would help prevent runaway insurance premiums in Canada. If awards were too high, reasoned the court, no one but the very rich could own a car and pay the huge premiums that insurance companies would have to charge to pay out on claims. Of course, an innocent victim hurt in a car accident may be entitled to other types of compensation too, e.g., for medical expenses, income loss, future care and lost earning capacity. If you have the misfortune of being injured, consult a lawyer who can help you with recovering the fair compensation that may be your due. This column has been written with the assistance of DANIEL RICHARDSON. It provides information only and must not be relied on for legal advice. Please contact DANIEL RICHARDSON of BTM Lawyers LLP for legal advice concerning your particular case.
Lawyer Janice Mucalov, author of this article, has written several popular law books and writes about legal affairs for a variety of publications. “You and the Law” is a registered trade-mark. © by Janice Mucalov
Daniel Richardson
OFFICIAL 2012 BALLOT
Limit one entry per person for the duration of the promotion. Original newspaper pages only, no facsimilies or photocopies or vote online at mrtimes.com, 1 entry per email address. Ballots become the property of the Maple Ridge Pitt Meadows Times, which reserves the right to publish contest results. Final decisions on ballots and winners is that of the Maple Ridge Pitt Meadows Times. All participants must be 19 years of age or older. Send ballots to: Readers’ Choice, c/o Maple Ridge Pitt Meadows Times, #2-22345 North Ave. Maple Ridge BC V2X 8TZ DEADLINE: December 17, 2012 _____________________________________________ Accounting / Tax Preparation _____________________________________________ Animal Boarding _____________________________________________ Appliance Store _____________________________________________ Auto Body / Collision Repair _____________________________________________ Auto Dealership _____________________________________________ Auto parts/ Accessories _____________________________________________ Auto service and tune up _____________________________________________ Bakery _____________________________________________ Bank / Credit Union – Location _____________________________________________ Bar or Restaurant Patio _____________________________________________ Bartender / Server - Establishment _____________________________________________ Barber Shop _____________________________________________ Bicycle Shop _____________________________________________ Book Store _____________________________________________ Breakfast _____________________________________________ Beer or Wine - Brew your own Store _____________________________________________ Building Supplies / Lumberyard _____________________________________________ Butcher _____________________________________________ Camera/photo store _____________________________________________ Carpet Cleaner _____________________________________________ Caterer _____________________________________________ Cellular/Wireless – Location _____________________________________________ Chinese Restaurant _____________________________________________ Clothing – Children’s _____________________________________________ Clothing – Men’s _____________________________________________ Clothing – Women’s _____________________________________________ Coach – Team/Sport _____________________________________________ Coffee Shop – Location _____________________________________________ Computer Store _____________________________________________ Dance Studio _____________________________________________ Day Spa _____________________________________________ Deli / Meat Store _____________________________________________ Dental Office – Dentist _____________________________________________ Doggy Daycare _____________________________________________ Dollar Store _____________________________________________ Dry Cleaner _____________________________________________ Electronics Retailer _____________________________________________ Family Restaurant _____________________________________________ Financial Planner _____________________________________________ Fine Dining _____________________________________________ Fireplace Store _____________________________________________ Fish ‘n’ Chips _____________________________________________ Fitness and Health Club _____________________________________________ Flooring Store _____________________________________________ Florist _____________________________________________ Furniture Store _____________________________________________ Gift Store _____________________________________________ Golf Course _____________________________________________ Greek restaurant
SERVICES ARE PROVIDED THROUGH LAW CORPORATIONS
Contact Daniel Richardson Telephone 604.937.1166 530 - 130 Brew Street, Port Moody - Suter Brook
Readers’ Choice, c/o Maple Ridge Pitt Meadows Times, #2-22345 North Ave. Maple Ridge BC V2X 8TZ
_____________________________________________ Grocery Store – Location _____________________________________________ Hair Salon _____________________________________________ Hair Stylist _____________________________________________ Hamburger _____________________________________________ Hardware Store _____________________________________________ Horse Stable / Riding Academy _____________________________________________ Indian Restaurant _____________________________________________ Insurance Agency _____________________________________________ Italian Restaurant _____________________________________________ Japanese Restaurant _____________________________________________ Jewellery Store _____________________________________________ Legal Firm _____________________________________________ Lighting Store _____________________________________________ Liquor / Beer / Wine Store _____________________________________________ Lunch Spot _____________________________________________ Martial Arts _____________________________________________ Mattress Store _____________________________________________ Meal under $10 _____________________________________________ Musical Lessons _____________________________________________ Nail Salon _____________________________________________ Neighbourhood Pub _____________________________________________ Nursery / garden Centre _____________________________________________ Office Supplies and Equipment _____________________________________________ Oil Change _____________________________________________ Optical Store _____________________________________________ Paint and Décor Store _____________________________________________ Pet Grooming _____________________________________________ Pet Store _____________________________________________ Pharmacy – Location _____________________________________________ Photo Studio / Portraits _____________________________________________ Pizzeria _____________________________________________ Produce Market _____________________________________________ Real Estate Agent _____________________________________________ Restaurant Server _____________________________________________ Sandwich / Sub – Location _____________________________________________ Shoe Store _____________________________________________ Sporting Goods (New and Used) _____________________________________________ Tanning Salon _____________________________________________ Thai Restaurant _____________________________________________ Thrift Store _____________________________________________ Tire Store _____________________________________________ Travel Agency _____________________________________________ Vehicle Sales Person _____________________________________________ Veterinarian Clinic _____________________________________________ Vitamins / Health Food Store _____________________________________________ Weight Loss / Diet Centre
All Ballots Eligible for Draw!
______________________________________________________ Name ______________________________________________________ Address ______________________________________________________ Phone ______________________________________________________ Email Address ______________________________________________________