13
Yukon News
Wednesday, October 2, 2013
Environmentalists, loggers seek consensus as Boreal Forest Agreement hits reset Bruce Cheadle Canadian Press
OTTAWA We’re not out of the woods yet.” In her rush to explain the promise and the peril of the three-year-old Canadian Boreal Forest Agreement, Janet Sumner doesn’t even pause to consider her unintended pun. Sumner, a spokeswoman for the Canadian Parks and Wilderness Society, is among those heralding a “reset” in a groundbreaking co-operative experiment between environmental groups and the forestry industry. The agreement, known as the CBFA, could serve as a model for industry and environmental groups that shout past one another while polarizing their constituencies and solving nothing. But the agreement has to be shown to produce real results and so far those have been hard to come by. “We all share that frustration,” Aran O’Carroll, the group’s interim executive director, said Wednesday in an interview with The Canadian Press. “We set out a very ambitious and aggressive set of milestones.” The 2010 agreement, which currently includes 19 forestry companies and seven environmental organizations, was coming apart at the seams last spring after two major environmental groups quit and negotiations with Resolute Forest Products reached
“
a stalemate. “This summer all the signatories sat down, reaffirmed their commitment to the agreement and we’ve been working hard over the summer to recalibrate our work plans, identify priorities for our work and set new milestones,” said O’Carroll. A series of agreements will be announced this fall and winter, said O’Carroll. And the CBFA is still waiting on the province of Ontario to sign off on an agreement in northeastern Ontario that has been approved by local communities, First Nations and non-signatory forest companies. The proposal protects over 800,000 hectares of forest while increasing harvestable timber by 20 per cent, thus protecting local mills. However negotiators were simply unable to get a satisfactory agreement on the vast, top priority “phase one” forest areas in Quebec and Ontario, Sumner said in a phone interview. Talks had been “bubbling away” in other regions and the focus has shifted to those more productive discussions, she said. “For (Canadian Parks and Wilderness Society) very specifically, we’re working in Newfoundland, Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Alberta and seeing those conversations with those companies really starting to bear some fruit.” And that has advocates of the Canadian Boreal Forest Agree-
Canada has about a third of the world’s boreal forest; getting co-operation on its management between environmentalists and loggers is seen as a potential model for other resource sectors, including oil and gas. Lazar contrasts the “tug of war” over the oilsands – “I’ll get my billionaire to beat up on your billionaire,” he says – with the forest talks. “You have grown-up humans sitting in a room together with a map.” A hard-won agreement among the CBFA signatories on scientific methodology is “a small miracle of consensus ment back on a public relations building,” said Lazar. offensive this fall. The modelling shows how Bruce Lourie of the Ivey much habitat woodland caribou Foundation, which helps fund the require. Logging maps reveal how participation of a number of enmuch timber a community mill – vironmental groups in the agree- and the community itself – needs ment, says neither conservationto survive. ists nor industry want to go back The CBFA is designed to use to the days when they warred over that common methodology to forestry practices. map out agreements that environ“This is clearly the right way mentalists, forestry companies, to do things,” said Lourie, who First Nations and local communijoined O’Carroll and former ties all can live with. forestry executive Avrim Lazar in Sumner said in her talks in pitching CBFA’s merits WednesAlberta, Saskatchewan and Maniday. toba, “I feel like we’re just light “It’s just more complex than years away from where we were anyone imagined.”
MEMORIAL PLAQUES 207 Main St. 668-3447
FOOTWEAR SALE 20% ON NOW 10
with other industrial sectors.” But some key environmental groups have walked away from the agreement. Both Greenpeace and Canopy, an advocacy group for sustainable forestry that was involved in the CBFA’s creation, bowed out last spring, citing a lack of progress. “Our assessment coming up to the third anniversary, when there was not a single hectare protected on the ground, or even jointly recommended to governments for protection, was that it just wasn’t the most effective vehicle,” said Nicole Rycroft, Canopy’s executive director. “Success is ultimately measured by results on the ground.” Sumner argues that it’s better to have environmentalists “inside the tent” seeing industry and government data and understanding the trade-offs that can be made. But the environmental campaigner agrees the Canadian Boreal Forest Agreement was in serious trouble this summer. “Oh yeah,” Sumner said, emphatically. “We’re not out of the woods yet. We’ve got to produce some results. Otherwise, we’ve just agreed on a bunch of process.”
Bites Into Winter Not Your Wallet.
%
off
80
Save up to $ on select sets of
off
Huge selection of Running Shoes, Cross Trainers, Walking Shoes, Kids Shoes and more. While quantities last! Sale ends October 13.
The Hougen Centre, Whitehorse, Yukon
30
%
off
305 Main St, 668-6848 Mon-Thur 9-6, Fri 9-7, Sat 9-6, Sun noon-5 /SportslifeYukon
4
Canadian winters are known for a variety of cold weather conditions. From black ice to slush to deep snowfalls, each having its own unique challenges. TOYO Observe Winter Tires are designed and tested to bite into them all. For a limited time, get TOYO advanced technology and save a bundle on select sets of 4. Ask for details. TOYO TIRES … engineered for the real world. R E B AT E O F F E R E N D S D E C E M B E R 1 5 , 2 0 1 3
Integra Tire
667-6102 • 107 Industrial Rd.
www.yukontire.com Ser ving Whitehorse and Yukon Territory since 1946 integratire.com
Winter is almost here, and Integra Tire wants to get you and your vehicle ready for a safe season of snowy driving with the Fall Love Your Ride Tire Event. From now until December 15th you could get huge savings up to $80 on select sets of tires. And when you visit your local Integra Tire this fall, you could WIN one of SIX $500 gift certificates.