1866
John T. Alsap
1867
Edward Darling
1868
E. D. Baker
1869
George W. Curtiss
1870
George W. Curtiss
1871
George W. Curtiss
1872
Hezikiah Brooks
1873
George W. Curtiss
1874
Thomas Cordis
1875
George Lount
1876
George Kemdall
1877
A. S. Haskell
1878
George W. Curtiss
1879
J. T. Butler
1880
J. Rodenburg
1881
Morris Goldwater Grand Master 1888
1882
Morris Goldwater Grand Master 1888
1883
E. W. Wells
1884
W. G. Oliver
1885
W. G. Oliver
1886
J. E. Anderson
1887
R. N. Fredericks Grand Master 1894
1888
R. N. Fredericks Grand Master 1894
1889
Alexander G. Oliver Grand Master 1891
1890
C. F. Fisher
1891
D. F. Mitchell
1892
S. E. Bright
1893
S. E. Bright
1894
Nathan Levy
1895
J. C. Herndon
1896
Anthony A. Johns Grand Master 1898
1897
F. G. Brecht
1898
Morris Goldwater Grand Master 1888
1899
Morris Goldwater Grand Master 1888
1900
R. H. Heatherington
1901
Albert D. Barnhart
1902
Albert D. Barnhart
1903
Anthony A. Johns Grand Master 1898
1904
C. E. Peter
1905
W. M. Claypool
1906
Fred P. Cruice
1907
W. H. Martin
1908
Robert K. Porter
1909
Anthony A. Johns Grand Master 1898
1910
Charles M. Shaw
1911
Harry T. Southworth
1912
Frank G. Brown Grand Master 1921
1913
H. D. Aitken
1914
Frank G. Brown Grand Master 1921
1915
Arnold Cruickshank
1916
H. W. Heap
1917
Arnold Cruickshank
1918
James Whetstine
1919
James Whetstine
1920
Arnold Cruickshank
1921
D. W. Russell
1922
John H. Orthel
1923
Gary O. Vyne
1924
Gary O. Vyne
1925
Henry Brinkmeyer Jr.
1926
Henry Brinkmeyer Jr.
1927
Wilbert E. Scott
1928
R. E. Geimer
1929
C. R. K. Swetnam
1930
I. S. McCash
1931
Kenneth Aitken
1932
A. Kenyon. Trengrove
1933
Charles Elmer ‘C.E.’ Lawrence
1934
George Voller
1935
Harry F. Dise
1936
Arnold Cruickshank
1937
Arnold Cruickshank
1938
Kenneth C. Harrison
1939
Frank F. Bartlett
1940
C. D. Rhodes
1941
Adolph Charles Johnson
1942
Franklyn E. Brown Grand Master 1953
1943
Earl A. Swenson
1944
Henry C. Vardy
1945
Arthur A. Foster
1946
Harry W. Marshall
1947
John F. Sills
1948
E. H. Scott
1949
Wilmer J. Webb
1950
Harry K. Grove
1951
Al S. Potter
1952
Lee E. Jones
1953
C. Don Rhodes
1954
Gordon W. Boudreau
1955
Paulding P. Forry
1956
Louis F. Bombardieri
1957
Alfred E. Pehl Sr.
1958
James A. Meteer
1959
George D. Holcombe
1960
Edgar E. Lee
1961
Edgar E. Lee
1962
John F. Sills
1963
Segurd C. Jacobsen
1964
Byron R. Williams
1965
Samuel J. Hairston
1966
Norman W. ‘Bill’ Fain II
1967
Arthur Wimmer
1968
George Tope
1969
Leonard Sullivan
1970
Ray A. Berry
1971
Howard A. Cottle
1972
Clayton J. Starin
1973
Frederick O. Mey
1974
George Tope
1975
Ray A. Berry
1976
Bill D. Grayson
1977
Fred Disert
1978
Bill D. Grayson
1979
Ronald L. Wright
1980
Glenn M. Donaldson
1981
Eugene M. Hunt
1982
Sylvester H. Bufkin
1983
John M. Conahay Sr.
1984
Clifford L. Lindberg
1985
Elwood Harris Sr.
1986
Edward W. Cannon
1987
William B. McLaws
1988
Ralph E. Barkheimer
1989
Roger Gibson
1990
Walter Repp
1991
David W. Huber
1992
Roger Gibson
1993
Charles W. Mummaw
1994
David W. Huber
1995
Linwood Snyder
1996
Olen O'Connor
1997
John Miklochik
1998
James Cooley
1999
David H. Luebke Grand Master 2007
2000
William G. Wellendorf
2001
Robert A. Davis
2002
Thomas P. Brockett
2003
Bruce Lamb
2004
Glenn M. Steiner
2005
Howard 'Andy' Anderson
2006
Howard 'Andy' Anderson
2007
Ettore 'Ted' Damiani
2008
Jeffery D. Wasowicz
2009
Keith L. Rosewitz
2010
Boyd W. Robertson
2011
George E. Weil
2012
George E. Weil
2013
A. Martin Granville
2014
Paul Demuth
2015
George C. Hutchenson
2016
David Sahady