2011, Issue 3 - Primates in Science
Chimpanzee Research & the Road to Retirement By Kathleen Conlee and Jennifer Ball 8 2011 PRIMATES & SCIENCE cannot meet the extremely complex psychological and social needs of chimpanzees and, furthermore, is detrimental to their well-being. Additionally, recent studies show that chimpanzees formerly used in invasive research experience symptoms similar to post-traumatic stress disorder and other mood and anxiety disorders in humans.4, 5, 6 SANCTUARY FOR SOME In the 1990s, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) requested that the National Research Council (NRC) examine chimpanzee research and long-term care. Among other suggestions, the NRC recommended that a sanctuary system be created for chimpanzees who were determined to no longer be needed for research. The committee also recommended against euthanasia of “surplus” chimpanzees, for ethical reasons. These recommendations spurred passage of the Chimpanzee Health Improvement, Maintenance, and Protection Act in 2000, which established a governmentsupported sanctuary system for federallyowned chimpanzees that is currently run by Chimp Haven in Shreveport, Louisiana. The first residents were retired in 2005, and the facility now houses approximately 120 chimpanzees. However, despite the creation of a national sanctuary, many chimpanzees are simply languishing in laboratories at a significant cost to taxpayers. A prime example of this is the number of federallyowned chimpanzees at the Alamogordo Primate Facility (APF) in New Mexico, all of whom have a heart-wrenching past. The APF chimpanzees were once in a facility called The Coulston Foundation (TCF)—a laboratory with a long record of serious violations of the Animal PHOTOS COURTESY OF THE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES I THE TRUTH BEHIND CLOSED DOORS Decades ago, chimpanzees were used in a variety of experiments, such as testing the effects of space flight, toxic substances, and disease. Over time, ethical concerns and scientific advancements have significantly reduced their use. Today, only 10-20 percent of chimpanzees in labs are involved in active research protocols. Some claim chimpanzees are vital to hepatitis C and monoclonal antibody therapy research. However, recent reviews have shown that alternatives—such as in vitro modeling and well-designed, human epidemiological studies—are more effective and should be the way forward.1, 2, 3 Nonetheless, a 2009 unprecedented undercover investigation by The Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) at the largest chimpanzee laboratory in the world, the University of Louisiana at Lafayette’s New Iberia Research Center (NIRC), revealed what life is like One of many baby chimps born at the New Iberia Research Center for chimpanzees behind despite a breeding moratorium. laboratory doors. An investigator documented chimpanzees isolated in small, steel cages for months at a time; screaming when pursued with dart guns; and baby chimpanzees taken away from their mothers. We were also introduced to Sterling—a chimpanzee who mutilates himself— and Karen, who was 53 years old at the time of the investigation. What everyone suspected was confirmed: the laboratory environment clearly f you ever meet a chimpanzee, you can’t help but feel an instant connection. But, beyond the undeniable feeling of connectedness, science is showing us more and more just how much alike we are. What we have learned about the mental and emotional capabilities of chimpanzees since Dr. Jane Goodall first began observing wild chimps 50 years ago is remarkable. Chimps have complex social and emotional lives; they express a range of emotions, including pleasure, sympathy, fear, and depression. Their incredible intelligence is evidenced by problem solving, tool use, numerical skills, and even the ability to communicate in American Sign Language. Unfortunately, their similarity to us has kept chimpanzees in laboratories for the past several decades, but the tide may finally be turning in favor of these majestic individuals.